Is it common to see frost during some college commencements?
1 issue
Full Question
Is it common to see frost during some college commencements?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. College commencement ceremonies often happen during the months of December, May, and sometimes June. Frost isn't uncommon to see during the month of December, as it is the winter.
Generated Answer
Answer: College commencements typically occur in the late spring or early summer (May/June). Frost is a weather phenomenon associated with temperatures at or below freezing (0°C or 32°F). Late spring/early summer is generally well after the last frost in most regions, particularly those where colleges and universities are located. While unusual weather can occasionally happen, frost is not common during the typical commencement season.
{false}
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contradicts the reference explanation by omitting December as a month when college commencements occur. This omission leads to the incorrect conclusion that frost is not common during commencement season.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionmedium
Statement
College commencements typically occur in the late spring or early summer (May/June).
Explanation
The reference states that college commencement ceremonies often happen during the months of December, May, and sometimes June. The generated reasoning omits December.
Answer Span:
College commencements typically occur in the late spring or early summer (May/June).
Reference/Question Span:
College commencement ceremonies often happen during the months of December, May, and sometimes June.
Question #1
Hydrogen's atomic number squared exceeds number of Spice Girls?
Clean
Full Question
Hydrogen's atomic number squared exceeds number of Spice Girls?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Hydrogen is the first element and has an atomic number of one. To square a number, you multiply it by itself. The Spice Girls has five members.
Generated Answer
Hydrogen's atomic number is 1. 1 squared is 1. There were 5 Spice Girls. 1 is less than 5.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation and arrives at the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2
Would a pear sink in water?
1 issue
Full Question
Would a pear sink in water?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The density of a raw pear is about 0.59 g/cm^3. The density of water is about 1 g/cm^3. Objects only sink if they are denser than the surrounding fluid.
Generated Answer
Answer: The density of a pear is slightly higher than the density of water.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning states that the density of a pear is higher than water, which is a contradiction of the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The density of a pear is slightly higher than the density of water.
Explanation
The density of a pear is lower than the density of water, not higher.
Answer Span:
slightly higher than
Reference/Question Span:
0.59 g/cm^3
Question #3
Do hamsters provide food for any animals?
Clean
Full Question
Do hamsters provide food for any animals?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Hamsters are prey animals. Prey animals provide food for predators.
Generated Answer
Answer: Hamsters are prey animals. Several animals, including snakes, owls, hawks, and foxes, prey on hamsters.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that hamsters are prey animals and providing examples of predators that eat them.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #4
Are all limbs required for jujutsu?
Clean
Full Question
Are all limbs required for jujutsu?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Jujutsu is a Japanese martial art that uses unarmed combat to subdue opponents. Nick Newell, a congenital amputee, got his black belt after two straight submission wins. Fighter Aaron LaPointe has succeeded in martial arts with a fully paralyzed arm.
Generated Answer
Answer: Jujutsu is a Japanese martial art. Many Jujutsu techniques involve grappling and joint manipulation, which can involve the use of limbs. However, adaptive Jujutsu techniques exist for practitioners with disabilities affecting limb use. So, while limbs are typically involved, they are not strictly *required* for all forms of the art.
{false}
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning chain correctly infers that limbs are not strictly required for jujutsu, based on the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #5
Could a llama birth twice during War in Vietnam (1945-46)?
1 issue
Full Question
Could a llama birth twice during War in Vietnam (1945-46)?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The War in Vietnam (1945-46) lasted around 6 months. The gestation period for a llama is 11 months.
Generated Answer
Answer: Llamas have a gestation period of approximately 11 months. The Vietnam War lasted from 1955 to 1975, much longer than two llama gestation periods. Therefore, a llama could give birth twice during the Vietnam War.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning hallucinates the dates of the Vietnam War, leading to an incorrect conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The Vietnam War lasted from 1955 to 1975, much longer than two llama gestation periods.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that the Vietnam War lasted from 1955 to 1975, but the reference states that the War in Vietnam lasted from 1945-46.
Answer Span:
The Vietnam War lasted from 1955 to 1975
Reference/Question Span:
The War in Vietnam (1945-46)
Question #6
Does Linus Torvalds make money off of DirectX?
Clean
Full Question
Does Linus Torvalds make money off of DirectX?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. DirectX is a proprietary technology owned by Microsoft. Linus Torvalds is the creator and lead developer for the open-source Linux kernel. The Linux kernel is used in operating systems that are competitors of Microsoft Windows.
Generated Answer
Linus Torvalds created the Linux kernel. DirectX is a collection of application programming interfaces (APIs) developed by Microsoft for handling tasks related to multimedia, especially game programming and video, on Microsoft platforms. These are entirely separate entities.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately identifies that Linus Torvalds created the Linux kernel and that DirectX is a Microsoft product, correctly concluding that they are separate entities.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #7
Could Brooke Shields succeed at University of Pennsylvania?
Clean
Full Question
Could Brooke Shields succeed at University of Pennsylvania?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Brooke Shields graduated from Princeton University. Princeton is ranked as the number 1 national college by US news. University of Pennsylvania is ranked as number 6 national college by US news. Princeton only admits around 6 percent of applicants as of 2018. University of Pennsylvania accepts around 9% of applicants as of 2018.
Generated Answer
Brooke Shields attended Princeton University and graduated with a Bachelor of Arts in Romance Languages. Success at one Ivy League institution suggests a likelihood of success at another, assuming similar levels of effort and commitment. University of Pennsylvania is also an Ivy League university, so the academic rigor would be comparable.
Answer: {true}
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning chain correctly uses the information provided in the reference explanation to support the conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #8
Could a silverfish reach the top of the Empire State Building?
1 issue
Full Question
Could a silverfish reach the top of the Empire State Building?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Silverfish cannot fly. Animals that cannot fly can only access objects at or near ground level without mechanical assistance. The top of the Empire State Building is 1,454 ft high.
Generated Answer
Answer: Silverfish are insects. Insects are capable of climbing. The Empire State Building is a building. Buildings can be climbed.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning makes a generalization about insects being able to climb, which is irrelevant to the specific limitation of silverfish not being able to fly to reach the top of the building.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
Insects are capable of climbing.
Explanation
The reference states that silverfish cannot fly and therefore cannot reach the top of the Empire State Building without assistance. The generated reasoning makes a generalization about insects being capable of climbing, which is irrelevant to the specific limitation of silverfish not being able to fly to reach the top of the building.
Answer Span:
Insects are capable of climbing.
Reference/Question Span:
Silverfish cannot fly.
Question #9
Are the majority of Reddit users familiar with the Pledge of Allegiance?
Clean
Full Question
Are the majority of Reddit users familiar with the Pledge of Allegiance?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. 55% of the Reddit user base comes from the United States. Congressional sessions open with the recital of the Pledge, as do many government meetings at local levels, and meetings held by many private organizations. All states except California, Hawaii, Iowa, Vermont, and Wyoming require a regularly scheduled recitation of the pledge in public schools.
Generated Answer
Answer: Reddit is an American social news aggregation, content rating, and discussion website.
The Pledge of Allegiance is recited by Americans.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that Reddit is an American website and that the Pledge of Allegiance is recited by Americans. This supports the conclusion that the majority of Reddit users are familiar with the Pledge of Allegiance.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #10
Do the anchors on Rede Globo speak Chinese?
Clean
Full Question
Do the anchors on Rede Globo speak Chinese?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Rede Globo is a Brazilian television network. The official language of Brazil is Portuguese.
Generated Answer
Answer: Rede Globo is a Brazilian television network. The primary language of Brazil is Portuguese. Thus, the anchors on Rede Globo would speak Portuguese, not Chinese.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that Rede Globo is a Brazilian television network where the primary language is Portuguese, thus the anchors would speak Portuguese, not Chinese.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #11
Can Reiki be stored in a bottle?
Clean
Full Question
Can Reiki be stored in a bottle?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Reiki practitioners use a technique called palm healing or hands-on healing through which a "universal energy" is said to be transferred through the palms of the practitioner to the patient in order to encourage emotional or physical healing. Medications are typically stored in pill bottles.
Generated Answer
Reiki is a form of energy healing. Proponents of Reiki believe it is a universal life force energy that can be channeled by practitioners. However, the concept of "storing" Reiki, especially in a bottle, is not consistent with the core principles of Reiki practice. Reiki is considered an active, flowing energy that is channeled, not a substance that can be contained.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation and correctly concludes that Reiki cannot be stored in a bottle.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #12
While viewing "Scary Movie" is the viewer likely to experience an increase in adrenaline?
Clean
Full Question
While viewing "Scary Movie" is the viewer likely to experience an increase in adrenaline?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Scary Movie is a film that is a comedy take on horror, intended to make viewers laugh but not afraid. Adrenaline is produced when a human is frightened or excited.
Generated Answer
Answer: "Scary Movie" is a parody film designed to elicit laughter, not fear. While some scenes might contain startling elements, the overall tone is comedic, undermining genuine fear and the associated adrenaline rush. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that "Scary Movie" is a parody film designed to elicit laughter, not fear, and therefore would not cause an adrenaline rush.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #13
Would Marvel's Gateway be envious of the Doctor (Doctor Who)'s TARDIS machine?
1 issue
Full Question
Would Marvel's Gateway be envious of the Doctor (Doctor Who)'s TARDIS machine?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Doctor (Doctor Who) used the TARDIS, a largely unreliable time traveling machine, to travel through time and space. Gateway is a Marvel comic character linked to the X-Men comics. Gateway has the power to create wormholes that allow him to travel through time and space.
Generated Answer
Answer:
Gateway's mutant ability allows him to create portals for teleportation.
The Doctor's TARDIS is a time and space machine that is larger on the inside and can travel anywhere in time and space.
Gateway's powers are limited to teleportation within his current timeline, while the TARDIS can traverse both space and time. Thus, Gateway would likely be envious of the Doctor's superior technology.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning incorrectly states that Gateway's powers are limited to teleportation within his current timeline, contradicting the reference explanation that he can travel through time and space.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Gateway's powers are limited to teleportation within his current timeline, while the TARDIS can traverse both space and time.
Explanation
The reference states that Gateway can travel through time and space, which contradicts the statement that his powers are limited to teleportation within his current timeline.
Answer Span:
Gateway's powers are limited to teleportation within his current timeline
Reference/Question Span:
Gateway has the power to create wormholes that allow him to travel through time and space.
Question #14
Is material from an aloe plant sometimes enclosed in petroleum-derived products?
Clean
Full Question
Is material from an aloe plant sometimes enclosed in petroleum-derived products?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Aloe vera gel is sometimes kept in plastic packaging. Plastic packaging is derived from petroleum.
Generated Answer
Answer: Aloe vera is often sold in plastic bottles. Plastic is derived from petroleum.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that aloe vera is sold in plastic bottles, which are derived from petroleum. This aligns with the reference's point about aloe vera gel being kept in plastic packaging derived from petroleum.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #15
Could a bee hummingbird balance a scale with a single pea on it?
1 issue
Full Question
Could a bee hummingbird balance a scale with a single pea on it?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The average pea weighs between 0.1 and 0.36 grams. Female bee hummingbirds on average weigh 2.6 grams, while on average male bee hummingbirds weigh 1.95 grams.
Generated Answer
Answer: A bee hummingbird weighs about 1.7 grams, or 0.06 ounces. A pea weighs between 0.1 and 0.36 grams, averaging around 0.23 grams. This means a pea can weigh up to about 1/7th the weight of the bee hummingbird. It is highly unlikely a hummingbird could balance a scale with something so comparatively heavy.
{false}
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains a factual error about the weight of a bee hummingbird.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
A bee hummingbird weighs about 1.7 grams, or 0.06 ounces.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that a bee hummingbird weighs about 1.7 grams, but the reference states that female bee hummingbirds weigh 2.6 grams and male bee hummingbirds weigh 1.95 grams.
Answer Span:
A bee hummingbird weighs about 1.7 grams
Reference/Question Span:
Female bee hummingbirds on average weigh 2.6 grams, while on average male bee hummingbirds weigh 1.95 grams.
Question #16
Would a broadcast from Spirit make the news in 2020?
Clean
Full Question
Would a broadcast from Spirit make the news in 2020?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. In 2010, the Spirit rover sent what is recorded as its final transmission. In 2019, another rover made the news with its viral "final words".
Generated Answer
Answer: Spirit, the Mars rover, ceased communications in 2010. Any broadcast from it in 2020 would be highly unusual and newsworthy, likely making international headlines.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly infers that a broadcast from Spirit in 2020 would be newsworthy, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #17
Would characters in Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone be persecuted as pagans?
Clean
Full Question
Would characters in Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone be persecuted as pagans?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Pagans are defined as people that hold beliefs other than those of the major world religions (Christianity, Islam, and Judaism). The characters in Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone practice magic. Islam explicitly forbid the practice of magic and has harsh consequences for it. Jezebel in Hebrew scripture was a worshiper of pagan Baal and was thrown from a window for her beliefs. Women accused of being witches were burned alive by Christians during the Salem Witch Trials.
Generated Answer
Answer: The characters in Harry Potter practice witchcraft. Witchcraft is considered paganism. Historically, people accused of witchcraft have been persecuted. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that the characters in Harry Potter practice witchcraft, which is considered paganism, and that people accused of witchcraft have historically been persecuted. This aligns with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #18
Can music be used as a weapon?
Clean
Full Question
Can music be used as a weapon?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Music is an art form whose medium is sound. Music can help elevate or subdue emotions. People connect to music through the sound. The military uses loud music to cause psychological disorientation and confusion . The military calls the use of loud disorienting music part of psychological operations.
Generated Answer
Music can be used to incite violence, spread propaganda, and inflict psychological distress. Think of war chants, national anthems used to stir up nationalistic fervor, or even songs with hateful lyrics designed to dehumanize a group of people. Music has also been used as a form of torture, with loud, repetitive, or jarring music used to break down prisoners' resistance. While music often has positive effects, its power can be misused for harmful purposes.
Answer: {true}
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that music can be used as a weapon, citing examples such as inciting violence, spreading propaganda, and inflicting psychological distress, which aligns with the reference explanation that music can be used to cause psychological disorientation and confusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #19
Can Harry Potter book a flight on Asiana Airlines?
Clean
Full Question
Can Harry Potter book a flight on Asiana Airlines?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Asiana Airlines is the second largest airline in South Korea. Harry Potter is a fictional character.
Generated Answer
Answer: Asiana Airlines is a South Korean airline. Harry Potter is a fictional character. Fictional characters cannot book flights.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that Harry Potter is a fictional character and therefore cannot book a flight on Asiana Airlines, which aligns with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #20
Karachi was a part of Alexander the Great's success?
1 issue
Full Question
Karachi was a part of Alexander the Great's success?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Karachi is a city in modern day Pakistan. Krokola was an ancient port located in what is now Karachi. Alexander the Great stationed his fleet in Krokola on his way to Babylon. Alexander the Great defeated Darius and conquered Babylon before expanding his empire.
Generated Answer
Alexander the Great's empire stretched across parts of modern-day Greece, Egypt, Turkey, Iran, Afghanistan, and Pakistan. Karachi, however, is located in modern-day Pakistan. While Alexander's empire did reach the Indus Valley region (parts of modern-day Pakistan), Karachi wasn't specifically a significant city or part of his main conquests. His campaign focused on the areas further north and east of Karachi.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning contradicts the reference by stating that Karachi wasn't a significant city, while the reference indicates it was a location where Alexander stationed his fleet.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Karachi wasn't specifically a significant city or part of his main conquests.
Explanation
The reference states that Alexander the Great stationed his fleet in Krokola, which is now Karachi. This implies that Karachi (Krokola) was a significant location for his fleet, contradicting the statement that it wasn't a significant city or part of his main conquests.
Answer Span:
Karachi wasn't specifically a significant city or part of his main conquests.
Reference/Question Span:
Alexander the Great stationed his fleet in Krokola on his way to Babylon.
Question #21
Was Jackson Pollock trained by Leonardo da Vinci?
1 issue
Full Question
Was Jackson Pollock trained by Leonardo da Vinci?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Leonardo lived during the Italian Renaissance in the 17th century. Jackson Pollock lived during the 20th century.
Generated Answer
Answer: Jackson Pollock was an influential American painter of the 20th century and a major figure in the abstract expressionist movement. Leonardo da Vinci was an Italian polymath of the High Renaissance who died in 1519. Given the vastly different time periods, da Vinci could not have trained Pollock.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning is correct, but it contains a factual error about the time period in which Leonardo da Vinci lived.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Leonardo lived during the Italian Renaissance in the 17th century.
Explanation
The reference states that Leonardo lived in the 15th/16th century, not the 17th century.
Answer Span:
17th century
Reference/Question Span:
17th century
Question #22
Will The Exorcist stimulate limbic system?
Clean
Full Question
Will The Exorcist stimulate limbic system?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The limbic system of the brain contains regions that detect fear, control bodily functions and perceive sensory information. The Exorcist has been called one of the scariest movies of all time. The Exorcist ranked number 3 on the American Film Institute's 100 Years/100 Thrills list.
Generated Answer
Answer: The limbic system is responsible for emotions, motivation, and memory formation. Horror movies like The Exorcist are designed to evoke strong emotional responses, particularly fear and anxiety. These emotional responses are mediated by the limbic system. Therefore, watching The Exorcist would likely stimulate the limbic system.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately explains why The Exorcist would stimulate the limbic system, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #23
Would World War II have been the same without Alan Turing?
Clean
Full Question
Would World War II have been the same without Alan Turing?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. During WW2, the German Military used something called the Engima device to send messages secretly. Alan Turing broke the Enigma code, allowing German messages to be understood and intercepted.
Generated Answer
Answer: Alan Turing was a British mathematician and computer scientist. He is widely considered to be the father of theoretical computer science and artificial intelligence. During World War II, Turing worked for the Government Code and Cypher School (GC&CS) at Bletchley Park, Britain's codebreaking centre. He played a crucial role in cracking the German Enigma code, which significantly impacted the war's outcome. It is widely believed that Turing's work shortened the war by several years and saved countless lives. Without his contributions, the Allied efforts would have been severely hampered, and the war could have had a very different outcome.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, providing a clear and concise explanation of Alan Turing's role in World War II and the impact of his work on the war's outcome.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #24
Would a sophist use an épée?
1 issue
Full Question
Would a sophist use an épée?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. A sophist is a specific kind of teacher in ancient Greece, in the fifth and fourth centuries BC. Sophists specialized in using the tools of philosophy and rhetoric, though other sophists taught subjects such as music, athletics and mathematics. An épée is a sword used in fencing. The épée was not developed until the 19th century.
Generated Answer
Answer: A sophist is a person who reasons with clever but fallacious arguments. An épée is a fencing sword. The question is a play on words, since "sophism" and "épéeism" are very similar. While a sophist might *use* an épée, the question is about the more common usage of sophist related to rhetoric and logical fallacies. There is nothing in the definition of sophist that dictates they would or would not use an épée.
{false}
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning hallucinates a connection between "sophism" and "épéeism" that does not exist in the reference, leading to a flawed interpretation of the question.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorhigh
Statement
The question is a play on words, since "sophism" and "épéeism" are very similar.
Explanation
The reference does not mention any similarity between "sophism" and "épéeism". This is a misinterpretation of the question.
Answer Span:
The question is a play on words, since "sophism" and "épéeism" are very similar.
Reference/Question Span:
A sophist is a specific kind of teacher in ancient Greece, in the fifth and fourth centuries BC. ... An épée is a sword used in fencing.
Question #25
Did Dale Jr hug his dad after their last Daytona 500 together?
Clean
Full Question
Did Dale Jr hug his dad after their last Daytona 500 together?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Dale Jr. and his father Dale Sr. last raced together at the Daytona 500 in 2001. During the 2001 Daytona 500 Dale Sr. suffered a basilar skull fracture and died.
Generated Answer
Answer: Dale Earnhardt Jr. and Dale Earnhardt Sr. last raced together in the Daytona 500 in 2001. Dale Sr. tragically died in a crash on the last lap of that race. Therefore, there would have been no opportunity for a hug afterward.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that Dale Earnhardt Sr. died in the 2001 Daytona 500, making it impossible for Dale Jr. to hug him afterward.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #26
Can citrus grow in Ulaanbaatar?
Clean
Full Question
Can citrus grow in Ulaanbaatar?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Citrus can withstand short periods down to as cold as −10 °C (14 °F), but realistically temperatures not falling below −2 °C (28 °F) are required for successful cultivation. Ulaanbaatar has an average annual temperature of −0.4 °C or 31.3 °F.
Generated Answer
Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia has a very harsh continental climate with short, hot summers and long, frigid winters. Citrus fruits require a subtropical or tropical climate to thrive. Ulaanbaatar's extreme cold would kill citrus trees.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately explains why citrus cannot grow in Ulaanbaatar, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #27
Does New York Harbor sit on a craton without volcanic activity?
1 issue
Full Question
Does New York Harbor sit on a craton without volcanic activity?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. New York Harbor is located on Laurentia craton. The southwestern portion of Laurentia contains numerous large volcanic eruptions.
Generated Answer
Answer: New York Harbor is located on the eastern edge of the North American craton. Cratons are generally stable and lack volcanic activity.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning incorrectly claims that cratons generally lack volcanic activity, contradicting the reference explanation that the southwestern portion of Laurentia (a craton) contains numerous large volcanic eruptions.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Cratons are generally stable and lack volcanic activity.
Explanation
The reference states that the southwestern portion of Laurentia contains numerous large volcanic eruptions, contradicting the statement that cratons generally lack volcanic activity.
Answer Span:
Cratons are generally stable and lack volcanic activity.
Reference/Question Span:
The southwestern portion of Laurentia contains numerous large volcanic eruptions.
Question #28
Can the Palace of Westminster tell time in the dark?
1 issue
Full Question
Can the Palace of Westminster tell time in the dark?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The Palace of Westminster has Big Ben, a striking clock tower. Big Ben communicates the time via bells.
Generated Answer
Answer: The Palace of Westminster houses Big Ben, a famous clock with a large bell and illuminated clock faces. Therefore, the Palace of Westminster can tell time in the dark.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning contains a logical error by stating that Big Ben has illuminated clock faces, implying that it tells time visually in the dark, while the reference explanation states that Big Ben communicates the time via bells.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
The Palace of Westminster houses Big Ben, a famous clock with a large bell and illuminated clock faces.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that Big Ben has illuminated clock faces, implying that it can tell time visually in the dark. However, the reference explanation states that Big Ben communicates the time via bells, which is how it tells time, especially in the dark. The generated reasoning misinterprets how Big Ben tells time.
Answer Span:
illuminated clock faces
Reference/Question Span:
Big Ben communicates the time via bells.
Question #29
In teenagers and young adults with depression, are SSRI medications less safe than they are for adults?
Clean
Full Question
In teenagers and young adults with depression, are SSRI medications less safe than they are for adults?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. In teens, SSRI medications may increase the risk of suicidal thinking. In adults over 25, SSRI medications are regarded as generally safe.
Generated Answer
Answer: SSRIs carry a black box warning for increased risk of suicidality in children, adolescents, and young adults up to age 24. While they are still commonly prescribed and can be helpful, this population needs to be more closely monitored for worsening symptoms and suicidal thoughts/behaviors when starting or changing doses of SSRIs. Therefore, while not necessarily *less* *safe*, there is more to consider regarding risk/benefit compared to older adults.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that SSRI medications may increase the risk of suicidal thinking in teens and young adults, while they are generally considered safe for adults over 25.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #30
Does Marco Rubio have a close relationship with Allah?
Clean
Full Question
Does Marco Rubio have a close relationship with Allah?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Marco Rubio adheres to the religious sect of Christianity known as Catholicism. Catholics and other Christians worship God. Allah is worshiped by believers of Islam.
Generated Answer
Answer: Marco Rubio is a practicing Catholic. Catholicism is a Christian religion. Islam is a separate Abrahamic religion that reveres Allah. While both religions share some historical figures and narratives, they are distinct faiths with different central figures of worship. It is unlikely for a practicing Catholic to have a close, personal relationship with a central figure of another religion.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. It correctly identifies Marco Rubio's religious affiliation and contrasts it with the worship of Allah in Islam, leading to a logical conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #31
Would Persephone be a good consultant to a landscape architect?
Clean
Full Question
Would Persephone be a good consultant to a landscape architect?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Persephone is a vegetation goddess. A vegetation deity is a nature deity whose disappearance and reappearance, or life, death and rebirth, embodies the growth cycle of plants. Landscape architects deal with planning and laying out gardens and other plant life.
Generated Answer
Answer: Persephone is the Greek goddess of spring growth, so she would have extensive knowledge of plants and flowers. Landscape architects design outdoor spaces using plants. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, providing a sound justification for the answer.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #32
Is Argon near Neon on the periodic table of elements?
Clean
Full Question
Is Argon near Neon on the periodic table of elements?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Argon is a noble gas. Neon is a noble gas. The noble gases are all clumped together on the periodic table of elements.
Generated Answer
Argon (Ar) has atomic number 18. Neon (Ne) has atomic number 10. They are both noble gases and in the same column (group 18) of the periodic table. Elements in the same group are arranged vertically and share similar chemical properties. Therefore, Argon is in the same column and near Neon on the periodic table.
Answer: {true}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. It correctly identifies Argon and Neon as noble gases and their proximity on the periodic table.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #33
Did Thomas Greenhill's parents violate the concept of monogamy?
1 issue
Full Question
Did Thomas Greenhill's parents violate the concept of monogamy?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Thomas Greenhill was a surgeon born to William and Elizabeth Greenhill. William and Elizabeth Greenhill had 39 children. Monogamy is a committed relationship between two people where usually they remain together for life. Thomas Greenhill was the last of his parents 39 children and was born shortly after his father died.
Generated Answer
Answer: Thomas Greenhill was the illegitimate son of painter Joshua Reynolds and his mistress.
Monogamy is defined as the practice or custom of having only one wife or husband at a time.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning hallucinates that Thomas Greenhill was the son of Joshua Reynolds, which is incorrect. The reference states that he was the son of William and Elizabeth Greenhill.
Detected Issues (1)
entity_swaphigh
Statement
Thomas Greenhill was the illegitimate son of painter Joshua Reynolds and his mistress.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that Thomas Greenhill was the illegitimate son of Joshua Reynolds, but the reference states that Thomas Greenhill was the son of William and Elizabeth Greenhill.
Answer Span:
Thomas Greenhill was the illegitimate son of painter Joshua Reynolds and his mistress.
Reference/Question Span:
Thomas Greenhill was a surgeon born to William and Elizabeth Greenhill.
Question #34
Would it be uncommon for a high schooler to use the yellow pages?
Clean
Full Question
Would it be uncommon for a high schooler to use the yellow pages?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. High school students are between 14-19 years old. Teenagers now are considered 'digital natives'. 'Digital natives' are individuals who have grown up during the computer age, being exposed to technology from early childhood.
Generated Answer
Answer: High schoolers are generally members of Generation Z. Generation Z has grown up with ubiquitous internet access. The yellow pages are a print directory of businesses, largely supplanted by online search engines. It would be uncommon for a high schooler to use the yellow pages.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that high schoolers are digital natives who are unlikely to use the yellow pages, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #35
Could an escapee swim nonstop from Alcatraz island to Siberia?
Clean
Full Question
Could an escapee swim nonstop from Alcatraz island to Siberia?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Alcatraz Island was a San Francisco Bay prison. Siberia is over 5,217 miles away from San Francisco. The longest continuous swim record was 139 miles.
Generated Answer
Answer: Alcatraz is off the coast of San Francisco. Siberia is across the Pacific Ocean. No human could swim that distance. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that Alcatraz is off the coast of San Francisco and Siberia is across the Pacific Ocean, leading to the correct conclusion that no human could swim that distance. This aligns with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #36
Would the Titanic be well preserved at the bottom of the Gulf of Finland?
Clean
Full Question
Would the Titanic be well preserved at the bottom of the Gulf of Finland?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The bottom of the gulf is one of the world's largest ship cemeteries. Because of the low salinity and cold waters, and no shipworms, the ships are relatively well preserved. RMS Titanic was a British passenger ship.
Generated Answer
Answer: The Titanic sank in the Atlantic Ocean, not the Gulf of Finland. The preservation of a shipwreck depends heavily on the environment in which it rests. The Gulf of Finland, being part of the Baltic Sea, has brackish water (a mix of fresh and saltwater) which can be more corrosive to some materials than the deep ocean saltwater where the Titanic rests. The Titanic rests very deep in the Atlantic which also contributes to its preservation. So even if the Titanic had sunk in the Gulf of Finland, the conditions there are less conducive to preservation than its actual resting place.
{false}
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that the Titanic sank in the Atlantic Ocean and discusses the environmental factors affecting preservation, although it doesn't directly address whether the Titanic would be well-preserved in the Gulf of Finland based on the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #37
Could a snowy owl survive in the Sonoran?
Clean
Full Question
Could a snowy owl survive in the Sonoran?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Snowy owl is a bird native to the Arctic regions of North America. Temperatures in the North American Arctic range from -36.4F to 50F. The Sonoran is one of the hottest deserts in the world. The Sonoran Desert can get as hot as 118F.
Generated Answer
Answer: Snowy owls are adapted to cold, arctic climates. The Sonoran Desert is a hot, arid environment. These are incompatible environments for the snowy owl's survival needs. {false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that snowy owls are adapted to cold climates and the Sonoran Desert is a hot environment, making them incompatible.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #38
Would a rabbi worship martyrs Ranavalona I killed?
Clean
Full Question
Would a rabbi worship martyrs Ranavalona I killed?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Rabbis are teachers of Judaism. Ranavalona I, ruler of Madagascar, killed many Christians that were later determined by the church to be martyrs. Judaism does not have a group of saints and martyrs that are prayed to like Christianity..
Generated Answer
Answer: Ranavalona I was the queen of the Merina Kingdom, which is located in Madagascar, and ruled during the 19th century. She is known for her persecution of Christians and is estimated to have killed thousands of people during her reign, some of whom were considered martyrs by Christians. A rabbi is a Jewish religious leader and would adhere to the tenets of Judaism, not Christianity. Therefore, a rabbi would not worship the Christian martyrs killed by Ranavalona I.
{false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation and arrives at the correct conclusion without any hallucinations.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #39
Would an oil painter avoid reds from scale insects that live on a cactus?
1 issue
Full Question
Would an oil painter avoid reds from scale insects that live on a cactus?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Carmine is the product of an insect that lives on some cacti. Carmine is not stable in oil paints and its usage has been discontinued. Carmine is red.
Generated Answer
Answer: Cochineal insects, which live on prickly pear cacti, are the source of carmine, a natural red pigment. Oil painters frequently use carmine and other pigments derived from cochineal. Therefore, an oil painter would not necessarily avoid reds from scale insects that live on a cactus, as these can be a valuable source of pigment.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains a factual error regarding the use of carmine in oil paints, directly contradicting the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Oil painters frequently use carmine and other pigments derived from cochineal.
Explanation
The reference states that carmine is not stable in oil paints and its usage has been discontinued, which contradicts the statement that oil painters frequently use carmine.
Answer Span:
Oil painters frequently use carmine and other pigments derived from cochineal.
Reference/Question Span:
Carmine is not stable in oil paints and its usage has been discontinued.
Question #40
Was the Second Amendment to the United States Constitution written without consideration for black Americans?
Clean
Full Question
Was the Second Amendment to the United States Constitution written without consideration for black Americans?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The writers of the Constitutional Amendments did not view black people as legitimate human beings. The writers of the Constitutional Amendments believed that slavery benefited black slaves. The Constitutional Amendments were written for people that the writers considered human.
Generated Answer
The Second Amendment, ratified in 1791, was written during a time when slavery was legal in the United States. The Founding Fathers, who drafted the Constitution and the Bill of Rights, largely held racist views and did not consider enslaved people to have the same rights as white citizens. Therefore, while the Second Amendment speaks to the right to bear arms, this right was not intended for, nor extended to, Black Americans who were enslaved at the time. Even after the abolition of slavery, systemic racism continued to restrict Black Americans' access to firearms ownership and other rights.
Answer: {true}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that the Second Amendment was written without consideration for black Americans due to the racist views of the Founding Fathers and the prevalence of slavery at the time.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #41
Are all the elements plants need for photosynthesis present in atmosphere of Mars?
1 issue
Full Question
Are all the elements plants need for photosynthesis present in atmosphere of Mars?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Plants need three elements for photosynthesis: Hydrogen, Oxygen, and Carbon. The atmosphere of Mars is composed of carbon dioxide, nitrogen, argon, and trace levels of water vapor, oxygen, carbon monoxide, hydrogen and other noble gases.
Generated Answer
Answer: Photosynthesis requires carbon dioxide, water, and sunlight. While Mars has sunlight and some carbon dioxide in its atmosphere, the amount of water vapor present is minimal. Plants also require nutrients typically found in soil, which are not readily available in the Martian atmosphere. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning introduces irrelevant information about soil nutrients, which are not part of the photosynthesis process described in the reference. This leads to an incorrect conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
Plants also require nutrients typically found in soil, which are not readily available in the Martian atmosphere.
Explanation
The question asks about elements needed for photosynthesis, not general plant nutrients. The reference explanation only discusses the elements needed for photosynthesis, which are present in the Martian atmosphere.
Answer Span:
Plants also require nutrients typically found in soil, which are not readily available in the Martian atmosphere.
Reference/Question Span:
Plants need three elements for photosynthesis: Hydrogen, Oxygen, and Carbon.
Question #42
Can you find Bob Marley's face in most smoke shops?
Clean
Full Question
Can you find Bob Marley's face in most smoke shops?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Bob Marley's face is on the packaging of a popular brand of rolling papers. Bob Marley is a popular graphic to print on t-shirts for sale to smokers.
Generated Answer
Answer: Bob Marley is a cultural icon associated with cannabis use. Images of him are frequently displayed in smoke shops that cater to that culture.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly identifies Bob Marley's association with cannabis culture and the likelihood of his image being displayed in smoke shops, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #43
Did Pablo Escobar's nickname collection outshine Robert Moses Grove's?
1 issue
Full Question
Did Pablo Escobar's nickname collection outshine Robert Moses Grove's?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Robert Moses Grove was a baseball player nicknamed Lefty Grove. Pablo Escobar had several nicknames including: Don Pablo, El Padrino, and El Patrón.
Generated Answer
Answer:
Pablo Escobar's nicknames include "El Padrino" (The Godfather) and "El Patrón" (The Boss). Robert Moses Grove's nicknames include "Lefty," "Old Mose," and "Blackie." While Escobar's nicknames are more evocative of power and notoriety, Grove's are more descriptive or based on appearance. Whether Escobar's "outshine" Grove's is subjective, but it's fair to say they reflect different aspects of their respective personalities and public images. One could argue Escobar's nicknames are more widely recognized due to his notoriety, but "outshine" is a matter of opinion.
{false}
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain hallucinates nicknames for Robert Moses Grove that are not mentioned in the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Robert Moses Grove's nicknames include "Lefty," "Old Mose," and "Blackie."
Explanation
The reference explanation only mentions that Robert Moses Grove was nicknamed Lefty Grove. The other nicknames are not mentioned and therefore are a hallucination.
Answer Span:
Robert Moses Grove's nicknames include "Lefty," "Old Mose," and "Blackie."
Reference/Question Span:
Robert Moses Grove was a baseball player nicknamed Lefty Grove.
Question #44
Has the Subway restaurant franchise had any connections with child abusers?
Clean
Full Question
Has the Subway restaurant franchise had any connections with child abusers?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Subway hired Jared Fogle as a spokesman for their sandwich shops. Jared Fogle was convicted for having sex with minors and for possessing child pornography.
Generated Answer
Answer: Jared Fogle, Subway's longtime spokesperson, was convicted of child pornography charges and traveling to engage in illicit sexual conduct with a minor. He was sentenced to over 15 years in prison. This created a significant scandal for the company.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. It correctly identifies Jared Fogle's connection to Subway and his conviction for child pornography charges and illicit sexual conduct with a minor.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #45
Does autopilot rely on fossil fuels?
1 issue
Full Question
Does autopilot rely on fossil fuels?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Autopilot is used in vehicles. Vehicles are powered by engines. Engines rely on fossil fuels to operate.
Generated Answer
Answer: Autopilot, as a feature in vehicles like Tesla cars, relies on electricity to power the car's systems. While the electricity used to charge the car's batteries *might* be generated from fossil fuels, autopilot itself doesn't directly consume or rely on them. It relies on electricity, which can come from various sources, including renewable energy. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning introduces the idea that autopilot relies on electricity, which is not mentioned in the reference. This is a misinterpretation of the reference fact that vehicles rely on fossil fuels.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
Autopilot, as a feature in vehicles like Tesla cars, relies on electricity to power the car's systems.
Explanation
The reference states that autopilot is used in vehicles, which are powered by engines that rely on fossil fuels. The generated reasoning introduces the idea that autopilot relies on electricity, which is not mentioned in the reference. This is a misinterpretation of the reference fact that vehicles rely on fossil fuels.
Answer Span:
Autopilot, as a feature in vehicles like Tesla cars, relies on electricity to power the car's systems.
Reference/Question Span:
Vehicles are powered by engines. Engines rely on fossil fuels to operate.
Question #46
Are psychiatric patients welcome to join the United States Air Force?
Clean
Full Question
Are psychiatric patients welcome to join the United States Air Force?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Having a history of mental illness disqualifies most people from joining the Armed Forces. Psychiatric patients are being seen for management of mental illness.
Generated Answer
Answer: Individuals with a history of severe mental disorders, including most psychotic disorders, are generally disqualified from serving in the United States Air Force. This includes conditions like schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and major depressive disorder with psychotic features. While waivers are sometimes possible, they are rarely granted for these conditions due to the demanding and stressful nature of military service. The Air Force requires its members to maintain a high level of mental stability and resilience.
{false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that individuals with a history of mental illness are generally disqualified from serving in the United States Air Force.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #47
Does Nicole Kidman know any Scientologists?
Clean
Full Question
Does Nicole Kidman know any Scientologists?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Nicole Kidman was married to Tom Cruise. Tom Cruise is a Scientologist.
Generated Answer
Answer: Nicole Kidman was married to Tom Cruise, a prominent Scientologist, for over 10 years. It is highly likely she knows other Scientologists through him, even if she herself is not one.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that Nicole Kidman knows Scientologists because she was married to Tom Cruise, who is a Scientologist. The reasoning is sound and aligns with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #48
Was John Lennon known to be a good friend to Sasha Obama?
Clean
Full Question
Was John Lennon known to be a good friend to Sasha Obama?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. John Lennon died in 1980. Sasha Obama was born in 2001.
Generated Answer
Answer: John Lennon died in 1980. Sasha Obama was born in 2001. It is impossible for them to have been friends.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly states the facts and arrives at the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #49
Would the tunnels at CERN fit onto the High Speed 1 rails?
Clean
Full Question
Would the tunnels at CERN fit onto the High Speed 1 rails?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. High Speed 1 (HS1), legally the Channel Tunnel Rail Link (CTRL), is a 67-mile (108 km) high-speed railway. The CERN collider is contained in a circular tunnel, with a circumference of 26.7 kilometres (16.6 mi). The circumference of a circle is the length of the enclosing boundary.
Generated Answer
Answer: The Large Hadron Collider at CERN has a circumference of 27 kilometers. High Speed 1, also known as the Channel Tunnel Rail Link, has a total length of 108 kilometers. The tunnels at CERN are much shorter than the rails of High Speed 1. Thus, they could easily fit onto the rails.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning chain correctly compares the circumference of the CERN collider to the length of the High Speed 1 rails and concludes that the CERN tunnels could fit onto the rails. No hallucinations are present.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #50
Could an elephant easily defeat a male macaque?
1 issue
Full Question
Could an elephant easily defeat a male macaque?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Male macaques range from 16 to 28 inches tall with a weight between 12.13 to 39.7 pounds. Elephants are between 7 to 11 feet tall and weigh several thousand pounds. Elephants contain large, sharp tusks that can injure or kill other animals.
Generated Answer
Answer: Adult male macaques weigh between 10-15kg. Adult elephants can weigh between 2,700 - 6,000kg. An elephant is significantly larger and stronger than a macaque.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain contains a minor factual inaccuracy regarding the weight of male macaques.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionlow
Statement
Adult male macaques weigh between 10-15kg.
Explanation
The reference states that male macaques weigh between 12.13 to 39.7 pounds, which is approximately 5.5 to 18 kg. The generated reasoning states that they weigh between 10-15kg, which is not entirely wrong but not as accurate as the reference.
Answer Span:
Adult male macaques weigh between 10-15kg.
Reference/Question Span:
weight between 12.13 to 39.7 pounds
Question #51
Do the Ubuntu people speak Ubuntu?
1 issue
Full Question
Do the Ubuntu people speak Ubuntu?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Ubuntu is a of free and open-source software used on computers. The Ubuntu people are a tribe that lives in Africa. The Ubuntu people derive their language from Nguni Bantu. As of 2019 only 10% of households in Africa have a computer.
Generated Answer
Answer: Ubuntu is a Nguni Bantu term meaning "humanity". It is often translated as "I am because we are," or "humanity towards others". While the term originates with the Nguni Bantu language family, Ubuntu itself is a philosophy and worldview, not a distinct language. The Ubuntu people, if referring to those who adhere to the Ubuntu philosophy, would speak various languages, depending on their geographic and cultural background. Many Nguni Bantu languages are spoken in Southern Africa, including Zulu, Xhosa, Southern Ndebele, Swazi, and Northern Ndebele.
{false}
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain misinterprets the reference fact that the Ubuntu people derive their language from Nguni Bantu.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
Ubuntu is a Nguni Bantu term meaning "humanity".
Explanation
The reference states that the Ubuntu people derive their language from Nguni Bantu. The generated reasoning states that Ubuntu is a Nguni Bantu term meaning "humanity". This is a misinterpretation of the reference fact.
Answer Span:
Ubuntu is a Nguni Bantu term meaning "humanity".
Reference/Question Span:
The Ubuntu people derive their language from Nguni Bantu.
Question #52
Is cycling a high-risk activity for pelvis fractures?
1 issue
Full Question
Is cycling a high-risk activity for pelvis fractures?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Cycling is a low-impact activity . Stress fractures in a pelvic bone often develop as a result of repetitive, high-impact activity that puts stress on the pelvis, such as long-distance running or ballet.
Generated Answer
Answer: Cycling can involve falls, and in the event of a fall, the pelvis can be injured. High-impact falls can result in pelvic fractures. However, cycling is not generally considered a high-risk activity for pelvic fractures when compared to activities like contact sports or motorcycling. While fractures can occur, they are not common enough to classify cycling as inherently high-risk for this specific injury.
{false}
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning introduces the possibility of falls, which is not the focus of the reference explanation. The reference focuses on stress fractures from the activity itself, not from external events like falls.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
Cycling can involve falls, and in the event of a fall, the pelvis can be injured.
Explanation
The reference states that cycling is a low-impact activity and that stress fractures in the pelvic bone are a result of repetitive, high-impact activity. The generated reasoning introduces the possibility of falls, which is not the focus of the reference explanation. The reference focuses on stress fractures from the activity itself, not from external events like falls.
Answer Span:
Cycling can involve falls, and in the event of a fall, the pelvis can be injured.
Reference/Question Span:
Cycling is a low-impact activity
Question #53
Is a platypus immune from cholera?
1 issue
Full Question
Is a platypus immune from cholera?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Cholera is a bacteria that damages the small intestines in humans. The intestines are part of the stomach of humans. A platypus does not have a stomach.
Generated Answer
Answer: Cholera is a bacterial infection that affects the intestines. Platypuses are mammals, and mammals can be affected by bacterial infections. There's no reason to believe platypuses have a special immunity to cholera.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain fails to use the key fact from the reference explanation (platypuses lack a stomach) and instead makes a general statement about mammals and bacterial infections, leading to an incorrect conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorhigh
Statement
Platypuses are mammals, and mammals can be affected by bacterial infections.
Explanation
The reference explanation states that platypuses do not have a stomach, which is necessary for cholera to affect them. The generated reasoning makes a logical error by stating that platypuses are mammals and mammals can be affected by bacterial infections, which is irrelevant to the fact that platypuses lack a stomach.
Answer Span:
Platypuses are mammals, and mammals can be affected by bacterial infections.
Reference/Question Span:
A platypus does not have a stomach.
Question #54
Would a moose hypothetically be too much for a minotaur to devour whole?
1 issue
Full Question
Would a moose hypothetically be too much for a minotaur to devour whole?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. A minotaur was a mythological beast with the head of a bull and body of a human. Human stomachs process about three to four pounds of food a day. A moose can weigh up to 1500 pounds. Bulls can consume around 33 pounds of food a day.
Generated Answer
Answer: A moose can weigh up to 1,800 pounds. A minotaur is a mythical creature, half man and half bull. While bulls are large and strong, they don't typically swallow things whole, especially something the size of a large moose. Even allowing for the mythical strength of a minotaur, swallowing an entire moose seems improbable.
{true}
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning contains a factual error regarding the weight of a moose, but the overall reasoning is sound.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionmedium
Statement
A moose can weigh up to 1,800 pounds.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that a moose can weigh up to 1,800 pounds, but the reference states that a moose can weigh up to 1,500 pounds.
Answer Span:
1,800 pounds
Reference/Question Span:
1500 pounds
Question #55
Are there bones in an anchovy pizza?
Clean
Full Question
Are there bones in an anchovy pizza?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Anchovies used on pizza are typically packed whole in oil or water. Anchovies on pizza are not usually cut or filleted in any way.
Generated Answer
Answer: Anchovies are small, common forage fish in the herring family. While they do have bones, they are very small and often soften during the cooking process. Therefore, an anchovy pizza would contain bones.
{true}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that anchovies on pizza contain bones because they are typically used whole and not filleted.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #56
Can a Bengal cat survive eating only pancakes?
Clean
Full Question
Can a Bengal cat survive eating only pancakes?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Bengal cats are carnivores. Pancakes contain no meat. Carnivores eat only meat to survive.
Generated Answer
Answer: Bengal cats, like all cats, are obligate carnivores. This means their bodies are designed to primarily process and obtain nutrients from animal-based protein. Pancakes are made from grains and offer little to no nutritional value that a cat needs to survive. A diet lacking in animal protein will lead to severe health problems and eventual death for a Bengal cat. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately explains why a Bengal cat cannot survive on a pancake-only diet, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #57
Can the original name of the zucchini be typed on the top row of a QWERTY keyboard?
2 issues
Full Question
Can the original name of the zucchini be typed on the top row of a QWERTY keyboard?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The original name for the zucchini in Mexican language or Nahuatl is ayokonetl. The top row of a QWERTY keyboard contains the keys q, w, e, r, t, y, u, i , o, and p.
Generated Answer
The original name of the zucchini is "zucca." The letters Z, U, C, and C are all on the top row of a QWERTY keyboard. Therefore, the word "zucca" can be typed on the top row.
Answer: {true}
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains multiple hallucinations. It incorrectly states the original name of the zucchini and incorrectly identifies the letters on the top row of a QWERTY keyboard.
Detected Issues (2)
entity_swaphigh
Statement
The original name of the zucchini is "zucca."
Explanation
The original name of the zucchini is ayokonetl, not zucca.
Answer Span:
"zucca"
Reference/Question Span:
ayokonetl
contradictionhigh
Statement
The letters Z, U, C, and C are all on the top row of a QWERTY keyboard.
Explanation
The top row of a QWERTY keyboard contains the letters q, w, e, r, t, y, u, i , o, and p. The letters Z and C are not on the top row.
Answer Span:
Z, U, C, and C are all on the top row of a QWERTY keyboard
Reference/Question Span:
q, w, e, r, t, y, u, i , o, and p
Question #58
Does The Hague border multiple bodies of water?
Clean
Full Question
Does The Hague border multiple bodies of water?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Hague is in the Netherlands. The Hague is in the Western part of the Netherlands. The Netherlands borders the North Sea to its west.
Generated Answer
Answer: The Hague is a city on the western coast of the Netherlands bordering the North Sea. It doesn't border multiple bodies of water.
{false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. It correctly states that The Hague is on the western coast of the Netherlands bordering the North Sea and that it does not border multiple bodies of water.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #59
Do people in middle school usually get breast exams?
Clean
Full Question
Do people in middle school usually get breast exams?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Women should begin giving themselves breast exams at the age of 20. Middle school students are usually preteens or young teens.
Generated Answer
Middle school typically encompasses ages 11-14. Breast exams are not a routine part of healthcare for this age group. While some young girls may begin puberty during middle school, routine breast exams are typically recommended for adult women, starting later in life. Doctors may perform a breast exam if a specific concern arises, but it's not standard practice.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that breast exams are not a routine part of healthcare for middle schoolers, who are typically preteens or young teens.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #60
Did people in Korea under Japanese Rule watch a lot of Iron Chef?
Clean
Full Question
Did people in Korea under Japanese Rule watch a lot of Iron Chef?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The first televisions were sold in 1946. Iron Chef started airing in 1993.
Generated Answer
Answer: Iron Chef premiered in 1993. Japanese rule in Korea ended in 1945. Therefore, people in Korea under Japanese rule would not have been able to watch Iron Chef.
{false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly deduces that people in Korea under Japanese rule could not have watched Iron Chef, based on the timeline of Japanese rule ending in 1945 and Iron Chef premiering in 1993. This aligns with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #61
Would bald eagle deliver an urgent message before B-52?
1 issue
Full Question
Would bald eagle deliver an urgent message before B-52?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. A bald eagle can travel up to 99 MPH. The B-52 is a US air bomber that can travel up to 650 MPH.
Generated Answer
Answer: Bald eagles can fly at a maximum speed of 30-35 mph. The B-52 has a maximum speed of 650 mph.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning contains a factual error regarding the speed of bald eagles, which contradicts the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Bald eagles can fly at a maximum speed of 30-35 mph.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that bald eagles can fly at a maximum speed of 30-35 mph, which contradicts the reference explanation that states they can travel up to 99 mph.
Answer Span:
Bald eagles can fly at a maximum speed of 30-35 mph.
Reference/Question Span:
A bald eagle can travel up to 99 MPH.
Question #62
Does Snoopy look like Chance from Homeward Bound?
1 issue
Full Question
Does Snoopy look like Chance from Homeward Bound?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Chance from Homeward Bound is a golden retriever. Snoopy is black and white. Golden Retrievers are yellow in color.
Generated Answer
Answer: Snoopy is a beagle. Chance from Homeward Bound is an American Bulldog. They don't look alike.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning incorrectly identifies Chance from Homeward Bound as an American Bulldog, when he is a golden retriever. This is a significant factual error.
Detected Issues (1)
entity_swaphigh
Statement
Chance from Homeward Bound is an American Bulldog.
Explanation
Chance from Homeward Bound is a golden retriever, not an American Bulldog.
Answer Span:
Chance from Homeward Bound is an American Bulldog
Reference/Question Span:
Chance from Homeward Bound is a golden retriever
Question #63
Was Dioskourides a lapidary?
1 issue
Full Question
Was Dioskourides a lapidary?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. A lapidary is a person or machine who cuts gemstones; classically, it refers to a person who engraves gemstones. Dioskourides put his signature on a Roman amethyst ringstone with a portrait of Demosthenes circa late 1st century BC. Artists sign their work.
Generated Answer
Answer: Dioskourides was a physician, pharmacologist, and botanist. A lapidary is someone who cuts, polishes, or engraves gems. While Dioskourides studied minerals for their medicinal properties as described in *De materia medica*, this does not qualify him as a lapidary.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning incorrectly claims that Dioskourides's study of minerals does not qualify him as a lapidary, contradicting the reference which states he signed a ringstone, thus qualifying him as a lapidary.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
While Dioskourides studied minerals for their medicinal properties as described in *De materia medica*, this does not qualify him as a lapidary.
Explanation
The reference states that Dioskourides signed a Roman amethyst ringstone, which qualifies him as a lapidary. The generated reasoning contradicts this by stating that studying minerals for medicinal properties does not qualify him as a lapidary.
Answer Span:
this does not qualify him as a lapidary
Reference/Question Span:
Dioskourides put his signature on a Roman amethyst ringstone with a portrait of Demosthenes circa late 1st century BC.
Question #64
Do most middle class families have butlers?
Clean
Full Question
Do most middle class families have butlers?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Butlers make about $60,000 per year on average for their work. Middle class income is between $48,000 and $145,000.
Generated Answer
A butler is a live-in domestic worker, usually male, responsible for managing a household's staff and serving the needs of the family and guests. Butlers are traditionally associated with wealthy families who can afford to employ a large household staff. Middle-class families typically do not have the resources to employ live-in domestic help, including butlers.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning chain correctly explains why middle-class families typically do not have butlers, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #65
Was Hillary Clinton's deputy chief of staff in 2009 baptised?
Clean
Full Question
Was Hillary Clinton's deputy chief of staff in 2009 baptised?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Huma Abedin was Hillary Clinton's deputy chief of staff in 2009. Huma Abedin is an American Muslim. Baptism is a Christian tradition.
Generated Answer
Answer: Huma Abedin was Hillary Clinton's deputy chief of staff in 2009. Huma Abedin is Muslim. Muslim individuals are not typically baptized. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation and arrives at the correct conclusion without any hallucinations.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #66
Does the New York Public Library sell Alpo products?
Clean
Full Question
Does the New York Public Library sell Alpo products?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The New York Public Library is a public lending library system in New York City. Alpo produces pet food and related products.
Generated Answer
Answer: The New York Public Library is a library system. Libraries lend books and other media. They do not typically sell pet food. Alpo is a brand of pet food.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that the New York Public Library is a library system that lends books and other media, and that libraries do not typically sell pet food. It also correctly identifies Alpo as a brand of pet food. Therefore, the New York Public Library does not sell Alpo products.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #67
Did Solomon make up bigger percentage of Islamic prophets than Kings of Judah?
1 issue
Full Question
Did Solomon make up bigger percentage of Islamic prophets than Kings of Judah?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. According to The Quran, Solomon was one of 25 prophets. According to some Islamic hadiths, there have been as many as 124,000 prophets. Solomon was one of 20 Kings of Judah.
Generated Answer
Solomon was both a King of Judah and an Islamic prophet. Since he's a member of both sets, he represents a larger percentage of the smaller set (Kings of Judah). There have been many more Islamic prophets than Kings of Judah.
Answer: {true}
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains a factual error, stating that Solomon was both a King of Judah and an Islamic prophet, which contradicts the reference explanation. This error leads to incorrect reasoning and a wrong conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Solomon was both a King of Judah and an Islamic prophet.
Explanation
The reference states that Solomon was one of 20 Kings of Judah and one of 25 prophets according to The Quran. The generated reasoning incorrectly states that he was both.
Answer Span:
Solomon was both a King of Judah and an Islamic prophet
Reference/Question Span:
Solomon was one of 20 Kings of Judah. According to The Quran, Solomon was one of 25 prophets.
Question #68
Would Taylor Swift refer to Snoopy as oppa?
1 issue
Full Question
Would Taylor Swift refer to Snoopy as oppa?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Oppa is a Korean word used by women to address a man who is 10 or more years older than her. Snoopy is 47 years old. Taylor Swift is 30 years old.
Generated Answer
Answer: Taylor Swift is American. "Oppa" is a Korean honorific used by females to refer to older males with whom they are close. It is unlikely Taylor Swift would use this term, especially for a cartoon dog.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain makes a logical error by stating that it is unlikely Taylor Swift would use the term oppa for Snoopy, when the reference explanation states that Snoopy is more than 10 years older than Taylor Swift, making it likely that she would use the term.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorhigh
Statement
It is unlikely Taylor Swift would use this term, especially for a cartoon dog.
Explanation
The reference explanation states that Taylor Swift is 30 and Snoopy is 47, meaning that Snoopy is more than 10 years older than Taylor Swift. Therefore, it is likely that Taylor Swift would refer to Snoopy as oppa.
Answer Span:
It is unlikely Taylor Swift would use this term, especially for a cartoon dog.
Reference/Question Span:
Oppa is a Korean word used by women to address a man who is 10 or more years older than her. Snoopy is 47 years old. Taylor Swift is 30 years old.
Question #69
Did Confederate States Army influence West Point fashion?
1 issue
Full Question
Did Confederate States Army influence West Point fashion?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The Confederate States Army was clad in cadet gray uniforms. West Point uniforms are cadet gray and white. Confederate States Army uniforms contained Generally, the uniform jacket of the Confederate soldier was single breasted, made of gray or brown fabric, with a six to nine button front and hat. West Point uniforms contain a standing collar, white trousers, and black shakos (known as a "tarbucket hat" in U.S. Army nomenclature).
Generated Answer
Answer: West Point, the United States Military Academy, maintains a distinct military fashion tradition. The Confederate States Army, having seceded from the United States, would have had no influence over West Point's traditions or fashion after the secession. {false}
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain directly contradicts the reference explanation by stating that the Confederate States Army had no influence on West Point fashion, while the reference states that it did, specifically regarding the cadet gray uniforms.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The Confederate States Army, having seceded from the United States, would have had no influence over West Point's traditions or fashion after the secession.
Explanation
The reference states that the Confederate States Army influenced West Point fashion, specifically the cadet gray uniforms.
Answer Span:
would have had no influence over West Point's traditions or fashion after the secession
Reference/Question Span:
Yes. The Confederate States Army was clad in cadet gray uniforms. West Point uniforms are cadet gray and white.
Question #70
Does conservatism repulse Blaire White?
Clean
Full Question
Does conservatism repulse Blaire White?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Blaire White is a Youtuber. Blaire White posts content that leans towards conservative politics.
Generated Answer
Answer: Blaire White is an American YouTuber who describes herself as a conservative. Therefore, conservatism would not repulse her.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly infers that conservatism would not repulse Blaire White, based on the information that she identifies as a conservative. The reasoning aligns with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #71
Do all parts of the aloe vera plant taste good?
Clean
Full Question
Do all parts of the aloe vera plant taste good?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. There is a layer of yellow latex liquid between the outside of an aloe leaf and the gel inside. The latex inside aloe tastes very bitter.
Generated Answer
Answer: Aloe vera is a succulent plant. The inner gel of the aloe vera plant is commonly used for topical purposes due to its soothing properties. While generally considered safe for topical use, ingesting large amounts of aloe vera latex (the yellow sap) can be harmful. Different parts of the plant have different properties and tastes. The gel is generally bitter.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that not all parts of the aloe vera plant taste good, specifically mentioning the bitter taste of the gel and the potential harm of ingesting large amounts of aloe vera latex, which aligns with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #72
Does an individual oceanographer study many sciences?
Clean
Full Question
Does an individual oceanographer study many sciences?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Study of the oceans involve many fields or science. To properly study their specific topic of research, an oceanographer must understand how their science interacts with the other involved sciences.
Generated Answer
Answer: Oceanography is an interdisciplinary science that draws on aspects of geology, chemistry, physics, biology, and meteorology. Individual oceanographers therefore study many sciences.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that oceanography is an interdisciplinary science and that oceanographers study many sciences.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #73
Did Kurt Cobain's music genre survive after his death?
Clean
Full Question
Did Kurt Cobain's music genre survive after his death?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Kurt Cobain was the lead singer of Nirvana. Nirvana's music is classified as Grunge rock. Kurt Cobain died on April 5, 1994. Some of the major Grunge rock bands included Alice in Chains, Pearl Jam, and Soundgarden. Alice in Chains and Pearl Jam released their latest albums in 2018 and 2020 respectively.
Generated Answer
Answer: Kurt Cobain was the lead singer, guitarist, and primary songwriter of the band Nirvana. Nirvana's music is widely considered grunge, a subgenre of alternative rock. Grunge music continued to be made and appreciated after Kurt Cobain's death in 1994. Many other grunge artists and bands continued to perform and record. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that grunge music continued after Kurt Cobain's death, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #74
Did Immanuel Kant ever meet the 14th president of the United States?
1 issue
Full Question
Did Immanuel Kant ever meet the 14th president of the United States?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Immanuel Kant died on Feb 12, 1804. Franklin Pierce was the 14th president of the United States. Franklin PIerce was born Nov 23, 1804.
Generated Answer
Answer: Immanuel Kant died in 1804.
Franklin Pierce, the 14th president of the United States, was born in 1804.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning contains a factual error regarding the birthdate of Franklin Pierce, leading to a flawed conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Franklin Pierce, the 14th president of the United States, was born in 1804.
Explanation
The reference states that Franklin Pierce was born on Nov 23, 1804, after Immanuel Kant died on Feb 12, 1804. The generated reasoning incorrectly states that Franklin Pierce was born in 1804, implying he could have met Kant.
Answer Span:
was born in 1804
Reference/Question Span:
was born Nov 23, 1804
Question #75
Would eliminating competition in the Japanese bulk carrier market be profitable for a steel company?
1 issue
Full Question
Would eliminating competition in the Japanese bulk carrier market be profitable for a steel company?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. 62% of bulk carriers are built in Japan. Bulk carrier hulls are made of steel.
Generated Answer
Answer: Eliminating competition would give the steel company a monopoly in the Japanese bulk carrier market. This would allow them to set prices and potentially increase profits significantly. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning makes a logical leap that is not supported by the reference. The reference only provides facts about the construction of bulk carriers and the location of their construction, not about market monopolies.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorhigh
Statement
Eliminating competition would give the steel company a monopoly in the Japanese bulk carrier market.
Explanation
The reference states that 62% of bulk carriers are built in Japan and that bulk carrier hulls are made of steel. It does not imply that a steel company would gain a monopoly in the Japanese bulk carrier market by eliminating competition.
Answer Span:
Eliminating competition would give the steel company a monopoly in the Japanese bulk carrier market.
Reference/Question Span:
62% of bulk carriers are built in Japan.
Question #76
Would a geographer use biochemistry in their work?
Clean
Full Question
Would a geographer use biochemistry in their work?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. A geographer is a scientist whose area of study is geography, the study of Earth's natural environment and human society. Biochemistry is the study of chemical processes within and relating to living organisms.
Generated Answer
Answer: Geography is the study of the physical features of the earth and its atmosphere, and of human activity as it affects and is affected by these, including the distribution of populations and resources, land use, and industries. Biochemistry is the branch of science concerned with the chemical and physicochemical processes and substances that occur within living organisms. A geographer would not use biochemistry in their work.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately defines geography and biochemistry and correctly concludes that a geographer would not use biochemistry in their work, aligning perfectly with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #77
Is most coffee produced South of the Equator?
1 issue
Full Question
Is most coffee produced South of the Equator?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The countries with the highest coffee production are in South America. Almost all of South America is in the Southern Hemisphere.
Generated Answer
Answer: Coffee plants grow best in a band around the equator called the "Bean Belt," which lies between the tropics of Capricorn and Cancer. Major coffee producers like Brazil, Colombia, Vietnam, Indonesia, and Ethiopia are located within this band. The majority of these countries are south of the Equator.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain contains a factual error regarding the location of major coffee-producing countries relative to the Equator. While it correctly identifies the "Bean Belt" and some major producers, it incorrectly claims that the majority of the listed countries are south of the Equator.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The majority of these countries are south of the Equator.
Explanation
The generated reasoning includes Vietnam and Ethiopia in the list of major coffee producers. Vietnam is in the Northern Hemisphere, and Ethiopia is very close to the Equator, but still in the Northern Hemisphere. Therefore, it is not true that the majority of the listed countries are south of the Equator.
Answer Span:
The majority of these countries are south of the Equator.
Reference/Question Span:
Almost all of South America is in the Southern Hemisphere.
Question #78
Is it hard to get a BLT in Casablanca?
Clean
Full Question
Is it hard to get a BLT in Casablanca?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. A BLT is a sandwich consisting of bacon, lettuce and tomato. Casablanca is predominantly Muslim. Islam forbids the consumption of pork and pork products.
Generated Answer
Answer: A BLT sandwich contains bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Casablanca is a predominantly Muslim city in Morocco. Pork products, including bacon, are not commonly consumed due to religious restrictions. Therefore, it would likely be difficult to find a traditional BLT in Casablanca.
Answer: {true}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, providing a clear and logical argument for why it would be difficult to find a BLT in Casablanca.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #79
Could largest ship from Voyages of Christopher Columbus haul Statue of Liberty?
Clean
Full Question
Could largest ship from Voyages of Christopher Columbus haul Statue of Liberty?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The largest ship Christopher Columbus used was the Santa Maria. The Santa Maria has a cargo capacity of 108 tons. The Statue of Liberty weighs 225 tons.
Generated Answer
Answer: The largest ship on Columbus' first voyage was the Santa María. Its cargo capacity was estimated at about 100 tons. The Statue of Liberty, including its pedestal and foundation, weighs over 225 tons. So, no, the Santa María could not haul the Statue of Liberty.
{false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation and arrives at the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #80
Would Jolly Green Giant's largest monument look impressive next to Pyrenees?
Clean
Full Question
Would Jolly Green Giant's largest monument look impressive next to Pyrenees?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Jolly Green Giant monument in Blue Earth, Minnesota is 55.5 feet tall. The Pyrenees mountains are 11,168 feet high. The Pyrenees mountains are 305 miles wide.
Generated Answer
Answer: The Jolly Green Giant statue in Blue Earth Minnesota is 55 feet tall. The Pyrenees mountains have peaks that are close to 11,000 feet. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation and arrives at the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #81
Did Karl Marx influence the communist party of China?
Clean
Full Question
Did Karl Marx influence the communist party of China?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Communist ideology is the foundation of communist party of China. Marx produced a political pamphlet that has since come to be commonly known as the communist manifesto.
Generated Answer
Karl Marx is the author of the Communist Manifesto, a foundational text for communist ideology. The Communist Party of China is explicitly a communist party. Their ideology is rooted in Marxism-Leninism, a development of Marxist thought. Therefore, Karl Marx's ideas were a major influence on the CCP.
Answer: {true}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, providing a clear and logical argument for Karl Marx's influence on the Communist Party of China. There are no hallucinations or errors in the reasoning.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #82
Does Soylent use Pea for their source of protein?
Clean
Full Question
Does Soylent use Pea for their source of protein?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Soylent is a meal replacement drink that offers 20mg protein. The protein in Soylent is derived from Soy.
Generated Answer
Answer: Soylent uses soy protein, not pea protein.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that Soylent uses soy protein, not pea protein, which aligns with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #83
Do most religious people in Quebec refer to the Quran?
Clean
Full Question
Do most religious people in Quebec refer to the Quran?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Christianity is the major religion in Quebec. Christians refer to the Bible as their book of reference.
Generated Answer
Answer: Quebec is a province in Canada. The dominant religion in Quebec is Catholicism, a branch of Christianity. The central religious text of Christianity is the Bible. The Quran is the central religious text of Islam.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. It correctly identifies Christianity as the major religion in Quebec and the Bible as its central text, contrasting it with the Quran, which is the central text of Islam. There are no hallucinations or logical errors.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #84
Does Family Guy take place on the American West Coast?
Clean
Full Question
Does Family Guy take place on the American West Coast?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Family Guy takes place in the fictional town of Quahog, Rhode Island. Rhode Island is a state on the American East Coast.
Generated Answer
Answer: Family Guy takes place in Quahog, Rhode Island. Rhode Island is a state on the East Coast of the United States.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that Family Guy takes place in Quahog, Rhode Island, which is on the East Coast of the United States.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #85
Are lengths measured in metres in the UK?
Clean
Full Question
Are lengths measured in metres in the UK?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Metres are part of the metric system. The UK uses the metric system for measurements.
Generated Answer
Answer: The UK uses the metric system, which includes metres for length.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #86
Did the first Duke of Valentinois play a key role in the Hundred Years' War?
Clean
Full Question
Did the first Duke of Valentinois play a key role in the Hundred Years' War?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Hundred Years' War was a conflict between England and France from 1337-1453. Cesare Borgia, the son of Pope Alexander VI, was the first Duke of Valentinois. Cesare Borgia was born in 1475.
Generated Answer
Answer: The Hundred Years' War took place from 1337 to 1453. Cesare Borgia, the first Duke of Valentinois, was born in 1475. Therefore, he could not have played a role in the Hundred Years' War.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly uses the dates of the Hundred Years' War and Cesare Borgia's birth to conclude that he could not have played a role in the war.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #87
Do gorillas fight with panda bears?
Clean
Full Question
Do gorillas fight with panda bears?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Gorilla distribution is limited to areas of the continent of Africa. Panda bears are found in the wild only in China.
Generated Answer
Answer: Gorillas live in the forests of central Africa. Giant pandas live in a few mountain ranges in central China. Their natural habitats do not overlap, so they would not encounter each other in the wild.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that gorillas and pandas live in different regions and therefore would not encounter each other.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #88
Was Christina Aguilera born in the forgotten borough?
Clean
Full Question
Was Christina Aguilera born in the forgotten borough?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Christina Maria Aguilera was born on December 18, 1980, in Staten Island, New York. Staten Island has sometimes been called "the forgotten borough" by inhabitants who feel neglected by the city government.
Generated Answer
Answer: Christina Aguilera was born in Staten Island, New York. Staten Island is one of the five boroughs of New York City. While it's sometimes referred to as the "forgotten borough," it is not forgotten in the sense that it's not officially recognized. So, she was born in NYC, in a borough sometimes jokingly called "forgotten."
{false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. There are no contradictions, entity swaps, or logical errors.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #89
Is H's most common two letter pair partner a freebie in Wheel of Fortune bonus round?
1 issue
Full Question
Is H's most common two letter pair partner a freebie in Wheel of Fortune bonus round?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. H forms the most common two letter pair in the English language along with the letter T. The Wheel of Fortune bonus round gives the player six free letters: R, S, T, L, N, E.
Generated Answer
H's most common two-letter pair partner is E, forming HE.
The free letters in the bonus round of Wheel of Fortune are R, S, T, L, N, and E.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning incorrectly identifies the most common two-letter pair partner of H, which is a critical factual error.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
H's most common two-letter pair partner is E, forming HE.
Explanation
The reference states that H's most common two-letter pair partner is T, not E.
Answer Span:
H's most common two-letter pair partner is E, forming HE
Reference/Question Span:
H forms the most common two letter pair in the English language along with the letter T
Question #90
Can a quarter fit inside of a human kidney?
1 issue
Full Question
Can a quarter fit inside of a human kidney?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Kidney stones are hard mineral deposits that can form in the kidneys. The largest kidney stone ever recorded was 13 cm wide. The diameter of a quarter is 2.4 cm.
Generated Answer
Answer:
A quarter has a diameter of 0.955 inches. Human kidneys are roughly 4-5 inches long, 2-3 inches wide, and 1 inch thick. Thus a quarter can easily fit inside of a human kidney.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning is mostly correct, but contains a minor factual inaccuracy regarding the diameter of a quarter.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionlow
Statement
A quarter has a diameter of 0.955 inches.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that a quarter has a diameter of 0.955 inches, but the reference explanation states that the diameter of a quarter is 2.4 cm, which is approximately 0.94 inches. While close, it is not exact and could lead to incorrect reasoning.
Answer Span:
A quarter has a diameter of 0.955 inches.
Reference/Question Span:
The diameter of a quarter is 2.4 cm.
Question #91
Does James Webb Space Telescope fail astronomer in locating planet Krypton?
Clean
Full Question
Does James Webb Space Telescope fail astronomer in locating planet Krypton?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The James Webb Space Telescope is the most powerful telescope created. Krypton is a planet in the fictional Superman comic book series.
Generated Answer
Answer: The James Webb Space Telescope is a telescope that observes space. Krypton is a fictional planet from DC Comics, the home world of Superman. It was destroyed before the events of most Superman stories. Fictional planets cannot be located by telescopes.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that Krypton is a fictional planet and therefore cannot be located by telescopes like the James Webb Space Telescope. This aligns with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #92
Was P. G. Wodehouse's favorite book The Hunger Games?
Clean
Full Question
Was P. G. Wodehouse's favorite book The Hunger Games?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. P. G. Wodehouse died in 1975. The Hunger Games was published in 2008.
Generated Answer
Answer: P.G. Wodehouse died in 1975. The Hunger Games was published in 2008. Therefore, The Hunger Games could not have been P.G. Wodehouse's favorite book.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly uses the information provided in the reference explanation to answer the question.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #93
Should a finished website have lorem ipsum paragraphs?
Clean
Full Question
Should a finished website have lorem ipsum paragraphs?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Lorem Ipsum paragraphs are meant to be temporary. Web designers always remove lorem ipsum paragraphs before launch.
Generated Answer
Lorem ipsum is placeholder text used in design and publishing to occupy space where real content will eventually be. It's used so designers can focus on the visual layout and aesthetics without being distracted by actual content. A finished website, by definition, is ready for public viewing and should have final, polished content. Using lorem ipsum indicates the site isn't complete.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately explains why a finished website should not have lorem ipsum paragraphs, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #94
Did William Shaespeare read the Daily Mirror?
Clean
Full Question
Did William Shaespeare read the Daily Mirror?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Daily Mirror is a British tabloid founded in 1903. William Shakespeare died in 1616.
Generated Answer
William Shakespeare died in 1616. The Daily Mirror was founded in 1903. Therefore, Shakespeare could not have read The Daily Mirror.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating the relevant dates and concluding that Shakespeare could not have read the Daily Mirror.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #95
Will more people go in and out of Taco Bell than a Roy Rogers each year?
1 issue
Full Question
Will more people go in and out of Taco Bell than a Roy Rogers each year?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Taco Bell has over 7,072 restaurants as of 2018. Roy Rogers had over 600 restaurants at its peak. Roy Rogers has 48 locations as of 2019.
Generated Answer
Answer: Roy Rogers Restaurants was a chain with 220 locations in 2023.
Taco Bell is a chain with over 7000 locations in the USA.
More people would realistically visit a restaurant with 7000 locations each year.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains a factual error regarding the number of Roy Rogers locations, which contradicts the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Roy Rogers Restaurants was a chain with 220 locations in 2023.
Explanation
The reference states that Roy Rogers has 48 locations as of 2019. The generated reasoning states that Roy Rogers has 220 locations in 2023, which contradicts the reference.
Answer Span:
Roy Rogers Restaurants was a chain with 220 locations in 2023.
Reference/Question Span:
Roy Rogers has 48 locations as of 2019.
Question #96
Is it safe to wear sandals in snow?
Clean
Full Question
Is it safe to wear sandals in snow?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Sandals have open toes and don't completely cover the feet. Snow is very cold and direct exposure to skin can cause hypothermia. The feet need to be completely covered to walk through snow safely.
Generated Answer
Answer: Sandals offer very little protection from the cold and snow. They also provide no traction on icy surfaces. Wearing sandals in the snow would be uncomfortable and possibly dangerous. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that sandals offer little protection from the cold and snow and provide no traction on icy surfaces, making them unsafe to wear in the snow.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #97
Was Nikola Tesla's home country involved in the American Civil War?
1 issue
Full Question
Was Nikola Tesla's home country involved in the American Civil War?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Nikola Tesla was born in the Austrian Empire. The American Civil War was a domestic American conflict.
Generated Answer
Answer: Nikola Tesla was Serbian-American. Serbia was not involved in the American Civil War.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning incorrectly states that Nikola Tesla was Serbian-American, contradicting the reference explanation that he was born in the Austrian Empire. The rest of the reasoning is based on this incorrect premise.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Nikola Tesla was Serbian-American.
Explanation
The reference states that Nikola Tesla was born in the Austrian Empire, not that he was Serbian-American.
Answer Span:
Serbian-American
Reference/Question Span:
Austrian Empire
Question #98
Did Ada Lovelace die tragically young for her era?
1 issue
Full Question
Did Ada Lovelace die tragically young for her era?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Ada Lovelace died at the age of 36 in 1852. The life expectancy in the 1800s was between 35 and 39 years old. Tuberculosis was one of the leading causes of death in the 1800s and a vaccine was not made until the 1900s.
Generated Answer
Ada Lovelace died at the age of 36 in 1852. The average life expectancy for women in England at that time was around 40-42 years. While dying at 36 is certainly younger than the average, it's not dramatically so, especially considering she died of uterine cancer, a disease that was difficult to treat effectively at the time. Therefore, while her death was undoubtedly a loss, it wasn't drastically outside the norm for her era.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning contains a factual error regarding the life expectancy in the 1800s, which contradicts the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The average life expectancy for women in England at that time was around 40-42 years.
Explanation
The reference states that the life expectancy in the 1800s was between 35 and 39 years old. The generated reasoning states that the average life expectancy for women in England at that time was around 40-42 years, which contradicts the reference.
Answer Span:
The average life expectancy for women in England at that time was around 40-42 years.
Reference/Question Span:
The life expectancy in the 1800s was between 35 and 39 years old.
Question #99
Can an Asian black bear use chopsticks?
Clean
Full Question
Can an Asian black bear use chopsticks?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Asian black bear are a species of bear found in asia. Asian black bear don't have opposable thumbs. Chopsticks are eating utensils use requires opposable thumbs.
Generated Answer
Answer: Asian black bears, also known as moon bears, are native to Asia and have paws, not hands. Chopsticks require the dexterity and opposable thumbs that bears lack. So they cannot use chopsticks.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that Asian black bears lack the dexterity and opposable thumbs required to use chopsticks.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #100
Can someone sell their time through the Toronto Star?
1 issue
Full Question
Can someone sell their time through the Toronto Star?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The Toronto Star has a classifieds section. Readers can advertise their own labor or services and thus their time .
Generated Answer
The Toronto Star is a newspaper, primarily focused on news and advertising. While they might have classified ads for services, selling one's time in a general sense isn't something typically done through a newspaper. One might advertise specific services (tutoring, handyman work, etc.) but not time as a commodity itself.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning contradicts the reference by stating that selling one's time isn't typically done through a newspaper, while the reference explicitly states that readers can advertise their labor or services, thus their time, in the classifieds section.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
While they might have classified ads for services, selling one's time in a general sense isn't something typically done through a newspaper.
Explanation
This contradicts the reference, which states that readers can advertise their own labor or services and thus their time.
Answer Span:
selling one's time in a general sense isn't something typically done through a newspaper.
Reference/Question Span:
Readers can advertise their own labor or services and thus their time
Question #101
Were deaths from Apollo 13 mission eclipsed by other space missions?
1 issue
Full Question
Were deaths from Apollo 13 mission eclipsed by other space missions?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Apollo 13 was a failed Moon landing in which the crew had faulty oxygen resources. All of the Apollo 13 crew returned safely to earth. The Challenger was a space shuttle that malfunctioned, killing all seven passengers. The Space Shuttle Columbia disaster had seven casualties.
Generated Answer
Answer: Apollo 13 did not have any deaths. The Apollo 1 mission resulted in the deaths of three astronauts. The Space Shuttle Challenger disaster resulted in the deaths of seven astronauts. The Space Shuttle Columbia disaster also resulted in the death of seven astronauts.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain introduces a new entity (Apollo 1) that is not mentioned in the reference explanation. This is used to justify the answer.
Detected Issues (1)
entity_swapmedium
Statement
The Apollo 1 mission resulted in the deaths of three astronauts.
Explanation
The reasoning chain introduces the Apollo 1 mission, which is not mentioned in the reference explanation. This is used to justify the answer.
Answer Span:
Apollo 1 mission
Reference/Question Span:
Apollo 13
Question #102
Can you purchase a dish with injera at Taco Bell?
Clean
Full Question
Can you purchase a dish with injera at Taco Bell?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Taco Bell serves a variety of Mexican and Tex-Mex foods that include tacos, burritos, quesadillas, and nachos. Injera is a sour fermented flatbread with a slightly spongy texture, traditionally made out of teff flour. Injera is part of Ethiopian cuisine.
Generated Answer
Answer: Injera is a spongy flatbread made from teff flour and is a staple in Eritrean and Ethiopian cuisine. Taco Bell is a fast food chain that specializes in Tex-Mex style cuisine. Their menu items are typically made with tortillas, not injera.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately explains why you cannot purchase a dish with injera at Taco Bell, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #103
Is xenophobia hypothetically unimportant between Saladin and Ali Askari?
2 issues
Full Question
Is xenophobia hypothetically unimportant between Saladin and Ali Askari?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Xenophobia is the dislike of someone that is foreign or from a different background. Saladin was a Kurdish leader that became sultan of Egypt. Ali Askari was a Kurdish politician.
Generated Answer
Answer: Saladin was a Sunni Muslim.
Ali Askari is a Shia Muslim.
Xenophobia is the fear and hatred of strangers or foreigners or of anything that is strange or foreign.
While Sunni and Shia Islam are both branches of Islam, they have historical disagreements.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning introduces details not present in the reference to justify a false conclusion. The reference states that both individuals are Kurdish, implying a shared background that would make xenophobia unimportant. The generated reasoning introduces religious differences to argue the opposite.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Saladin was a Sunni Muslim.
Explanation
The reference does not mention Saladin's religious affiliation. The generated reasoning introduces a detail not present in the reference, and uses it to justify a false conclusion.
Answer Span:
Saladin was a Sunni Muslim.
Reference/Question Span:
Saladin was a Kurdish leader that became sultan of Egypt.
contradictionmedium
Statement
Ali Askari is a Shia Muslim.
Explanation
The reference does not mention Ali Askari's religious affiliation. The generated reasoning introduces a detail not present in the reference, and uses it to justify a false conclusion.
Answer Span:
Ali Askari is a Shia Muslim.
Reference/Question Span:
Ali Askari was a Kurdish politician.
Question #104
Does Sockington enjoy onions?
Clean
Full Question
Does Sockington enjoy onions?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Sockington is a domestic cat. Onions can cause toxicity in cats by breaking down their red blood cells.
Generated Answer
Answer: Sockington is a cat. Cats generally dislike onions. Onions are toxic to cats.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. It correctly identifies Sockington as a cat and states that onions are toxic to cats, leading to the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #105
Was Raphael's paintings influenced by the country of Guam?
Clean
Full Question
Was Raphael's paintings influenced by the country of Guam?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Raphael was a European painter that died in 1520. Magellan's 1521 voyage was Europe's first trip to Guam.
Generated Answer
Answer: Raphael lived from 1483 to 1520.
Guam was claimed by Spain in 1565.
Raphael died before Guam was claimed by Spain.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly deduces that Raphael's paintings were not influenced by Guam, as Raphael died before Guam was claimed by Spain, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #106
Could Oscar Wilde have operated a motor vehicle?
1 issue
Full Question
Could Oscar Wilde have operated a motor vehicle?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Motor vehicles were in use by the 1890s. Oscar Wilde lived until 1900.
Generated Answer
Answer: Oscar Wilde died in 1900.
The first gasoline-powered automobile in the US was in 1893.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain contains an irrelevant fact about the first gasoline-powered automobile in the US, which is not necessary to answer the question.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorlow
Statement
The first gasoline-powered automobile in the US was in 1893.
Explanation
The location of the first gasoline-powered automobile is irrelevant to whether Oscar Wilde could have operated a motor vehicle. The reference explanation only states that motor vehicles were in use by the 1890s and that Oscar Wilde lived until 1900.
Answer Span:
The first gasoline-powered automobile in the US was in 1893.
Reference/Question Span:
Motor vehicles were in use by the 1890s.
Question #107
Does ontology require a scalpel?
Clean
Full Question
Does ontology require a scalpel?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. A scalpel is used during surgery. Ontology is a philosophical domain, not a medical one.
Generated Answer
Answer: Ontology is the branch of metaphysics dealing with the nature of being. A scalpel is a surgical instrument. Surgery and metaphysics are unrelated fields.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that ontology is a philosophical domain and a scalpel is a surgical instrument, thus concluding they are unrelated.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #108
Was King Arthur at the beheading of Anne Boleyn?
Clean
Full Question
Was King Arthur at the beheading of Anne Boleyn?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. King Arthur was a legendary British leader who, according to medieval histories and romances, led the defence of Britain against Saxon invaders in the late 5th and early 6th centuries. Anne Boleyn was beheaded May 19, 1536.
Generated Answer
Answer: Anne Boleyn was beheaded in 1536. King Arthur is a legendary figure who is believed to have lived between the late 5th and early 6th centuries. Thus, King Arthur could not have been present at Anne Boleyn's beheading.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that King Arthur could not have been at Anne Boleyn's beheading because they lived in different time periods. The reasoning is sound and consistent with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #109
Would Alexander Graham Bell hypothetically support Nazi eugenics?
Clean
Full Question
Would Alexander Graham Bell hypothetically support Nazi eugenics?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Eugenics was the idea of selective breeding or sterilization to rid the human populace of certain traits. Nazis used eugenics to justify mass sterilization and mass murder. Alexander Graham Bell Alexander Graham Bell advocated against the use of sign language and hoped to eradicate deafness through selective breeding.
Generated Answer
Answer: Alexander Graham Bell was a prominent advocate of eugenics. Nazi eugenics, while sharing some surface similarities with other eugenics movements, was particularly focused on racial purity and involved horrific human rights abuses. While Bell's eugenics work was problematic, it's impossible to know with certainty what his reaction would have been to the specific practices of Nazi Germany. However, given his known views, it is plausible to suggest he might have been sympathetic to some of the underlying ideas, though hopefully not the methods employed.
{true}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, acknowledging Bell's advocacy for eugenics and drawing a plausible connection to the underlying ideas of Nazi eugenics, while also acknowledging the differences in methods.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #110
Was Harry Truman's presidency unaffected by the twenty-third Amendment to the US Constitution?
Clean
Full Question
Was Harry Truman's presidency unaffected by the twenty-third Amendment to the US Constitution?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The 23rd Amendment to the US Constitution was passed in 1961. Harry Truman was the President from 1945-1953.
Generated Answer
Answer: The Twenty-third Amendment grants the District of Columbia electors in the Electoral College. This amendment was ratified in 1961. Harry Truman's presidency was from 1945-1953. Therefore, his presidency predates the amendment and would not have been affected by it.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation and arrives at the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #111
Would the trees in Auburn, New York be changing colors in September?
Clean
Full Question
Would the trees in Auburn, New York be changing colors in September?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. In New York, fall begins during the month of September. When the weather gets cooler in the fall, leaves begin to change colors.
Generated Answer
Answer: Auburn, New York experiences a temperate climate with four distinct seasons. Leaf color change, or "fall foliage," begins in September in New York state. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that leaf color change begins in September in New York state, which aligns with the reference.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #112
Is Black Lives Matter connected with capsaicin?
1 issue
Full Question
Is Black Lives Matter connected with capsaicin?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Black Lives Matter has held numerous protests. Protesters at Black Lives Matter events have had pepper spray used against them by police. Capsaicin is the main ingredient of pepper spray.
Generated Answer
Answer: The Black Lives Matter movement is primarily focused on addressing systemic racism and police brutality against Black people. Capsaicin is the active component of chili peppers, causing a burning sensation. While some protesters might carry pepper spray for self-defense, which contains capsaicin, there isn't a direct or inherent connection between the Black Lives Matter movement and capsaicin itself. {false}
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning contradicts the reference explanation by denying a connection between Black Lives Matter and capsaicin, despite the reference stating that pepper spray (containing capsaicin) has been used against protesters at Black Lives Matter events.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
While some protesters might carry pepper spray for self-defense, which contains capsaicin, there isn't a direct or inherent connection between the Black Lives Matter movement and capsaicin itself.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states there isn't a direct connection between Black Lives Matter and capsaicin, but the reference explanation states that protesters at Black Lives Matter events have had pepper spray used against them by police, and capsaicin is the main ingredient of pepper spray, thus establishing a connection.
Answer Span:
there isn't a direct or inherent connection between the Black Lives Matter movement and capsaicin itself.
Reference/Question Span:
Protesters at Black Lives Matter events have had pepper spray used against them by police. Capsaicin is the main ingredient of pepper spray.
Question #113
Was Achilles a direct descendent of Gaia?
1 issue
Full Question
Was Achilles a direct descendent of Gaia?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Achilles was the son of a Nereid. The Nereids were the 50 daughters of Nereus. Nereus was the eldest son of the union between Gaia and Pontus.
Generated Answer
Answer: Achilles was the son of Peleus and Thetis. Peleus was the son of Aeacus, who was the son of Zeus and Aegina. Aegina was the daughter of the river god Asopus and the river nymph Metope. Asopus was the son of Oceanus and Tethys. Oceanus and Tethys were the children of Uranus and Gaia. Therefore, Achilles was a descendant of Gaia.
{true}
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains a significant factual error regarding Achilles' parents, contradicting the reference explanation. The rest of the reasoning is based on this initial error.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Achilles was the son of Peleus and Thetis.
Explanation
The reference states that Achilles was the son of a Nereid, not Peleus and Thetis.
Answer Span:
Achilles was the son of Peleus and Thetis
Reference/Question Span:
Achilles was the son of a Nereid
Question #114
Does Jerry Seinfeld hang out at the Budweiser Party Deck?
1 issue
Full Question
Does Jerry Seinfeld hang out at the Budweiser Party Deck?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Budweiser Party Deck is a social gathering spot in Yankee Stadium. Yankee Stadium is home to the New York Yankees baseball team. Jerry Seinfeld is a fan of the New York Mets.
Generated Answer
Answer: Jerry Seinfeld is a comedian. The Budweiser Party Deck is at Busch Stadium, the home of the St. Louis Cardinals baseball team. There's no readily available information connecting Seinfeld to the Budweiser Party Deck or even a particular fondness for baseball, so it would be unlikely to find him hanging out there.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains a significant factual error regarding the location of the Budweiser Party Deck, which is a critical element in determining the answer.
Detected Issues (1)
entity_swaphigh
Statement
The Budweiser Party Deck is at Busch Stadium, the home of the St. Louis Cardinals baseball team.
Explanation
The Budweiser Party Deck is located in Yankee Stadium, not Busch Stadium. Yankee Stadium is the home of the New York Yankees, not the St. Louis Cardinals.
Answer Span:
Busch Stadium, the home of the St. Louis Cardinals baseball team
Reference/Question Span:
Yankee Stadium. Yankee Stadium is home to the New York Yankees baseball team
Question #115
Can you hide a basketball in a sand cat's ear?
Clean
Full Question
Can you hide a basketball in a sand cat's ear?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The diameter of a standard NBA basketball is around 9.5 inches. A sand cat's ear grows to 2.8 inches tall.
Generated Answer
A sand cat is a small wild cat, about the size of a large house cat. While their ears are proportionately large, they are still nowhere near the size of a basketball. A basketball is simply too large to fit inside a sand cat's ear.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately explains why a basketball cannot fit in a sand cat's ear, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #116
Could the Spice Girls compete against ŽRK Kumanovo?
Clean
Full Question
Could the Spice Girls compete against ŽRK Kumanovo?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Spice Girls had 5 members. ŽRK Kumanovo is a women's handball club from Kumanovo in the Republic of Macedonia. Handball is a sport played by two teams of seven players each.
Generated Answer
Answer: The Spice Girls are a British pop group. ŽRK Kumanovo is a women's handball club. These two entities are not comparable in a competitive setting.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that the Spice Girls and ŽRK Kumanovo are not comparable in a competitive setting, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #117
Does the swastika have positive uses?
Clean
Full Question
Does the swastika have positive uses?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The swastika is used in the Hindu religion to represent the sun. People practicing Hindu believe the swastika represents prosperity and good luck.
Generated Answer
Answer: The swastika has ancient origins and was used as a symbol of good fortune and well-being in various cultures, including Hinduism, Buddhism, and Jainism, long before its association with Nazism. While its original meaning is positive, the swastika has become irrevocably tied to the horrors of the Holocaust and Nazi ideology in the West. This makes its use extremely controversial and often interpreted as a symbol of hate, regardless of intent.
{true}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation, without introducing any hallucinations or contradictions.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #118
Was Black fly upstaged by another insect in Jeff Goldblum's 1986 film?
1 issue
Full Question
Was Black fly upstaged by another insect in Jeff Goldblum's 1986 film?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Jeff Goldnlum starred in the 1986 movie The Fly. The fly used in the movie The Fly was a common Housefly. The Black fly is most closely related to Chironomidae since they both feed on mammals.
Generated Answer
Answer: Jeff Goldblum starred in the 1986 film "The Fly". The antagonist/monster in the film *is* a fly. There is no other insect that upstages the fly.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning fails to recognize the Black fly as another insect in the context of the question, leading to a logical error.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
There is no other insect that upstages the fly.
Explanation
The reference states that the fly used in the movie was a common Housefly and that the Black fly is most closely related to Chironomidae since they both feed on mammals. This implies that the Black fly is another insect in the context of the question.
Answer Span:
There is no other insect that upstages the fly.
Reference/Question Span:
The fly used in the movie The Fly was a common Housefly. The Black fly is most closely related to Chironomidae since they both feed on mammals.
Question #119
Did Linnaeus edit Darwin's draft of Origin of Species?
Clean
Full Question
Did Linnaeus edit Darwin's draft of Origin of Species?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Linnaeus died in 1778. Origin of Species was published in 1859.
Generated Answer
Answer: Carl Linnaeus died in 1778.
Charles Darwin published On the Origin of Species in 1859.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation, stating the death year of Carl Linnaeus and the publication year of Darwin's Origin of Species, which correctly implies that Linnaeus could not have edited Darwin's work.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #120
Do all cancer patients get disability?
Clean
Full Question
Do all cancer patients get disability?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. All forms of cancer qualify as diagnoses that can result in disability. Disability is not determined by diagnosis, but by degree of impairment. Some cancer patients do not experience major impairment.
Generated Answer
Answer: Disability benefits are determined based on the impact of the illness on the individual's ability to work, not solely on the diagnosis. Not all cancers have the same impact, and some people with cancer are able to continue working. One must apply for disability and demonstrate their inability to work due to their illness. Therefore, simply having cancer does not guarantee disability benefits.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that disability benefits are determined by the impact of the illness on the individual's ability to work, not solely on the diagnosis. It correctly points out that not all cancers have the same impact and that some people with cancer are able to continue working. The reasoning concludes that simply having cancer does not guarantee disability benefits, which aligns with the reference.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #121
Did the death of Helen Palmer have a significant effect on Dr. Seuss?
Clean
Full Question
Did the death of Helen Palmer have a significant effect on Dr. Seuss?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Dr. Seuss's real name was Theodor Geisel. Theodor Geisel was married to Helen Palmer at the time of her suicide. Theodor Geisel is quoted having said he considered suicide after the death of his wife.
Generated Answer
Answer: Helen Palmer Geisel was the first wife of Theodor Seuss Geisel, better known as Dr. Seuss. She suffered from multiple health problems and took her own life in 1967. Dr. Seuss was deeply affected by her death and subsequently remarried. His second wife, Audrey Stone Dimond, is often credited with revitalizing his work. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. It correctly identifies Helen Palmer as Dr. Seuss's first wife and acknowledges the impact of her death on him.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #122
Can fish get Tonsillitis?
Clean
Full Question
Can fish get Tonsillitis?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Tonsils are a pair of soft tissue masses located at the rear of the throat. Tonsillitis is the inflammation of tonsils. Fish do not have tonsils. Tonsils are only found in mammals.
Generated Answer
Tonsillitis is the inflammation of the tonsils, which are part of the lymphatic system in mammals. Fish have a different immune system than mammals and lack tonsils. Therefore, they cannot get tonsillitis.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that fish cannot get tonsillitis because they lack tonsils, which are only found in mammals.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #123
Would it be impossible to get to Burning Man on the Mayflower?
Clean
Full Question
Would it be impossible to get to Burning Man on the Mayflower?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The Mayflower was a seafaring vessel. Burning Man is held in Black Rock Desert. There are no bodies of water flowing into the Black Rock Desert.
Generated Answer
Answer: Burning Man is an annual event held in the Black Rock Desert of Nevada. The Mayflower was a 17th-century ship that transported the Pilgrims to North America. The Mayflower could not traverse land, and therefore could not reach a desert in Nevada. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately explains why it would be impossible to get to Burning Man on the Mayflower, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #124
Does Lupita Nyongo have citizenship in paternal Family of Barack Obama's origin country?
Clean
Full Question
Does Lupita Nyongo have citizenship in paternal Family of Barack Obama's origin country?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Actress Lupita Nyongo has dual citizenship in Kenya and Mexico. Barack Obama's father was born in Nyang’oma Kogelo, Rachuonyo District, Kenya Colony. Barack Obama's father was a Kenyan of the Luo tribe.
Generated Answer
Lupita Nyong'o's parents are Kenyan. Barack Obama's paternal family is from Kenya. Therefore, Lupita Nyong'o has citizenship in the same country as Barack Obama's paternal family.
Answer: {true}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly infers that Lupita Nyong'o has citizenship in the same country as Barack Obama's paternal family based on the provided information.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #125
Are there enough Jonny Cash records in the world to give one to each French citizen?
1 issue
Full Question
Are there enough Jonny Cash records in the world to give one to each French citizen?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Johnny Cash has sold about 90 million albums. The population of France is around 66 million .
Generated Answer
Answer:
The population of France is about 65 million. It's highly unlikely that 65 million Johnny Cash records exist across all formats (vinyl, CD, etc.) throughout the world. While he was popular, that number is extremely high for physical record production, especially considering many people consume music digitally now.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning contradicts the reference explanation by stating that it's unlikely that 65 million Johnny Cash records exist, while the reference states that he has sold about 90 million albums.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
It's highly unlikely that 65 million Johnny Cash records exist across all formats (vinyl, CD, etc.) throughout the world.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that it's unlikely that 65 million Johnny Cash records exist, but the reference states that Johnny Cash has sold about 90 million albums, which is more than the population of France.
Answer Span:
It's highly unlikely that 65 million Johnny Cash records exist across all formats (vinyl, CD, etc.) throughout the world.
Reference/Question Span:
Johnny Cash has sold about 90 million albums.
Question #126
Could someone mistake the smell of your brussels sprouts for a fart?
Clean
Full Question
Could someone mistake the smell of your brussels sprouts for a fart?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Brussels Sprouts are cruciferous vegetables. Cruciferous vegetables have a sulfur containing chemical called glucosinolate in them. When you cook brussels sprouts, their smell intensifies.
Generated Answer
Answer: Brussels sprouts contain sulfur-containing compounds, which break down during cooking to produce hydrogen sulfide gas. This gas is also a component of flatulence and has a characteristic "rotten egg" smell. Therefore, it's possible that the smell of cooking Brussels sprouts could be mistaken for a fart.
{true}
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies the presence of sulfur-containing compounds in Brussels sprouts and explains how cooking them can produce a smell similar to flatulence, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #127
Can Stone Cold Steve Austin apply his finisher to a mule deer?
1 issue
Full Question
Can Stone Cold Steve Austin apply his finisher to a mule deer?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Steve Austin's finisher, The Stone Cold Stunner, involves lifting the opponent and then pulling their head down. The largest male mule deer's are around 330 pounds. Steve Austin has applied his finisher to the wrestler The Big Show. The Big Show weighs 383 pounds.
Generated Answer
Answer: Stone Cold Steve Austin's finisher is the Stone Cold Stunner.
A mule deer is a four-legged animal.
The Stone Cold Stunner requires an opponent to be in a standing position to be performed correctly.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains a logical error that misinterprets the reference facts. The reference implies that the finisher can be applied to a large opponent, and the standing position is not a requirement.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorhigh
Statement
The Stone Cold Stunner requires an opponent to be in a standing position to be performed correctly.
Explanation
The reference explanation states that Steve Austin has applied his finisher to the wrestler The Big Show. The Big Show weighs 383 pounds. This implies that the finisher can be applied to a large opponent, and the standing position is not a requirement.
Answer Span:
The Stone Cold Stunner requires an opponent to be in a standing position to be performed correctly.
Reference/Question Span:
Steve Austin has applied his finisher to the wrestler The Big Show. The Big Show weighs 383 pounds.
Question #128
Is the Joker in a healthy romantic relationship?
Clean
Full Question
Is the Joker in a healthy romantic relationship?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Healthy relationships are characterized by mutual trust and respect. The Joker is dating Harley Quinn. The Joker frequently abuses and talks down to Harley.
Generated Answer
Answer: The Joker, as portrayed in most iterations, is a highly unstable, chaotic, and often violent character. He is defined by his criminal insanity and lack of empathy. Healthy romantic relationships are built on trust, respect, and mutual care, none of which are compatible with the Joker's personality and actions. He frequently manipulates and abuses those around him, including Harley Quinn, who is often portrayed as being in a relationship with him. This relationship is typically depicted as toxic and co-dependent, rather than healthy.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that the Joker is not in a healthy romantic relationship due to his abusive and manipulative behavior towards Harley Quinn, which contradicts the principles of trust, respect, and mutual care in healthy relationships.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #129
Is the kayak a traditional boat in New Zealand?
Clean
Full Question
Is the kayak a traditional boat in New Zealand?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Kayaks were developed by native peoples to hunt in northern waters of the Arctic Ocean, North Atlantic, Bering Sea and North Pacific. New Zealand is in the Southern Hemisphere. The native Maori people of New Zealand arrived there in canoes.
Generated Answer
Answer: The traditional boat of the Māori people of New Zealand is the waka. Kayaks are not traditionally associated with New Zealand.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation, stating that kayaks are not traditionally associated with New Zealand and that the traditional boat of the Māori people is the waka.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #130
Did Boris Yeltsin watch the 2008 Summer Olympics?
Clean
Full Question
Did Boris Yeltsin watch the 2008 Summer Olympics?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The 2008 Summer Olympics were held Aug 08 - 24, 2008. Boris Yeltsin died on Apr 23, 2007.
Generated Answer
Answer: Boris Yeltsin died in 2007. The 2008 Summer Olympics were held in 2008. Therefore, he could not have watched them.
{false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation, leading to a correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #131
Did the swallow play a role in a famous film about King Arthur?
Clean
Full Question
Did the swallow play a role in a famous film about King Arthur?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Monty Python and the Holy Grail was a famous film about King Arthur. In Monty Python and the Holy Grail, swallows are mentioned several times.
Generated Answer
Answer: The question refers to the film *Monty Python and the Holy Grail*. In one scene, King Arthur and his knights are confronted by a French soldier who mocks them. One of the insults is a challenge to their supposed knowledge of swallows, specifically regarding coconut migration and their airspeed velocity. The argument is silly and nonsensical, but iconic to the film. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately describes the role of swallows in Monty Python and the Holy Grail, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #132
Was Michael Crichton ever in danger of flunking out of Harvard as an undergraduate?
2 issues
Full Question
Was Michael Crichton ever in danger of flunking out of Harvard as an undergraduate?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Scholastic probation or academic dismissal, sometimes known as flunking out, is the termination of students at a higher educational institution as the result of poor academic achievement. Michael Crichton obtained his bachelor's degree in biological anthropology summa cum laude in 1964. Summa cum laude is the highest distinction a person can achieve in college for academic success. Someone who achieves summa cum laude cannot have even a single semester of poor grades.
Generated Answer
Answer: Michael Crichton felt that his professors were trying to fail him due to his writing career taking off. He then decided to submit an English paper written by George Orwell as his own.
He received a B- for the plagiarized work and graduated Harvard in 1964
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains significant factual inaccuracies and contradicts the reference explanation. It invents a scenario about Crichton plagiarizing a paper and receiving a B-, which is inconsistent with his summa cum laude graduation.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Michael Crichton felt that his professors were trying to fail him due to his writing career taking off. He then decided to submit an English paper written by George Orwell as his own.
Explanation
This statement contradicts the reference explanation, which states that Michael Crichton graduated summa cum laude, the highest distinction for academic success. There is no mention of professors trying to fail him or him submitting a paper written by George Orwell.
Answer Span:
Michael Crichton felt that his professors were trying to fail him due to his writing career taking off. He then decided to submit an English paper written by George Orwell as his own.
Reference/Question Span:
Michael Crichton obtained his bachelor's degree in biological anthropology summa cum laude in 1964.
contradictionhigh
Statement
He received a B- for the plagiarized work and graduated Harvard in 1964
Explanation
This statement contradicts the reference explanation, which states that Michael Crichton graduated summa cum laude. Receiving a B- on a plagiarized paper is not consistent with graduating summa cum laude.
Answer Span:
He received a B- for the plagiarized work and graduated Harvard in 1964
Reference/Question Span:
Michael Crichton obtained his bachelor's degree in biological anthropology summa cum laude in 1964.
Question #133
Was Surfing popular when pogs came out?
Clean
Full Question
Was Surfing popular when pogs came out?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Pogs came out in the 1990's. The 90's saw a rise in 'Big Wave Culture', a practice involving finding the largest possible waves to surf on.
Generated Answer
Answer: Pogs were popular in the mid-1990s. Surfing has been popular since the early to mid 20th century. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that pogs were popular in the mid-1990s and that surfing has been popular since the early to mid 20th century. This aligns with the reference explanation, which states that pogs came out in the 1990s and that the 90s saw a rise in 'Big Wave Culture', a practice involving finding the largest possible waves to surf on.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #134
Could a student at the University of Houston see a caracal on campus?
Clean
Full Question
Could a student at the University of Houston see a caracal on campus?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The caracal is native to Africa, the Middle East, Central Asia, and India. The University of Houston is located in the United States. The United States is located in North America.
Generated Answer
Answer: The University of Houston is in Texas. Caracals are native to Africa, the Middle East, Central Asia, and India. While a caracal might be kept as an exotic pet, it is extremely unlikely to be found roaming free on the University of Houston campus. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that caracals are not native to the University of Houston's location and are unlikely to be found there, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #135
Did the Coen brothers ever collaborate with the Brothers Grimm?
Clean
Full Question
Did the Coen brothers ever collaborate with the Brothers Grimm?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Coen brothers were born in 1954 and 1957. The Brothers Grimm died in 1859 and 1863.
Generated Answer
Answer: The Coen brothers are contemporary filmmakers. The Brothers Grimm lived from 1785-1863. Therefore, they could not have collaborated.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that the Coen brothers and the Brothers Grimm lived in different time periods, making collaboration impossible. The reasoning aligns with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #136
Could a hundred thousand lolcats fit on a first generation iPhone?
2 issues
Full Question
Could a hundred thousand lolcats fit on a first generation iPhone?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Lolcat memes are often in jpeg form. The average size of a jpeg is 10 to 30 kb. One gigabyte is 1000000 kb. The first iPhone had 4GB to 16GB of storage .
Generated Answer
Answer: A first-generation iPhone had 4GB of storage. Let's assume an average lolcat image is 1MB (a reasonable estimate, given older image compression and resolutions). 1GB is equal to 1024MB. So, 4GB is equal to 4096MB. Therefore, a first-generation iPhone could theoretically store about 4096 lolcats. 100,000 is significantly more than 4096.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains a significant factual error regarding the size of a lolcat image, which leads to an incorrect conclusion. The reasoning is flawed due to this initial incorrect assumption.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Let's assume an average lolcat image is 1MB (a reasonable estimate, given older image compression and resolutions).
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that an average lolcat image is 1MB, but the reference states that the average size of a jpeg is 10 to 30 kb. 1MB is equal to 1024 kb, so this is a contradiction.
Answer Span:
1MB
Reference/Question Span:
10 to 30 kb
logical_errorhigh
Statement
Therefore, a first-generation iPhone could theoretically store about 4096 lolcats.
Explanation
Given that the average lolcat image is assumed to be 1MB, and the iPhone has 4096MB of storage, the calculation is correct. However, since the initial assumption of 1MB is wrong, the conclusion is also wrong. The reference states that the average size of a jpeg is 10 to 30 kb, which means the iPhone could store significantly more lolcats.
Answer Span:
4096 lolcats
Reference/Question Span:
10 to 30 kb
Question #137
Are monks forbidden from engaging in warfare?
1 issue
Full Question
Are monks forbidden from engaging in warfare?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Monks are members of religious orders that usually take vows of poverty, chastity, and obedience. The Knights Templar were a religious order that fought during the Crusades and captured Jerusalem in 1099. Buddhist Shaolin monks developed very powerful martial arts skills, have defended temples during conquests.
Generated Answer
Answer: Buddhist monks are expected to adhere to the principle of non-violence. Many monastic orders have explicit prohibitions against participating in warfare. The concept of a "warrior monk" is more common in pop culture than in actual Buddhist practice. While there have been historical examples of monks taking up arms (e.g., the Sohei of feudal Japan), this is generally considered an exception, not the rule. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contradicts the reference explanation by claiming that warrior monks are more common in pop culture than in reality, while the reference provides historical examples of such monks.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The concept of a "warrior monk" is more common in pop culture than in actual Buddhist practice.
Explanation
This statement contradicts the reference explanation, which provides examples of warrior monks such as the Knights Templar and Buddhist Shaolin monks who developed martial arts skills and defended temples during conquests.
Answer Span:
The concept of a "warrior monk" is more common in pop culture than in actual Buddhist practice.
Reference/Question Span:
Buddhist Shaolin monks developed very powerful martial arts skills, have defended temples during conquests.
Question #138
Is the BBC World Service hosted in Europe?
Clean
Full Question
Is the BBC World Service hosted in Europe?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The BBC World Service is part of the BBC network. The BBC operates in England. England is part of Europe.
Generated Answer
Answer: The BBC World Service is a division of the BBC. The BBC is the British Broadcasting Corporation, and is headquartered in London, England. London is a city in Europe.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, providing a clear and concise justification for the answer. There are no hallucinations or logical errors present.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #139
Would 1996 leap year baby technically be 1 year old in 2000?
Clean
Full Question
Would 1996 leap year baby technically be 1 year old in 2000?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. A leap year happens once every 4 years and has 29 days in February. The years 1996, 2000, 2004, 2008, 2012, 2016, and 2020 are the last 7 leap years that have happened. 1996 to 2000 is one leap year.
Generated Answer
Answer: A leap year baby born in 1996 would have their first birthday in 1997. They would turn 2 in 1998, 3 in 1999, and 4 in 2000.
{false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly explains why a leap year baby born in 1996 would be 4 years old in 2000.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #140
Did Clark Gable marry more women once than Richard Burton?
1 issue
Full Question
Did Clark Gable marry more women once than Richard Burton?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Richard Burton was married to Elizabeth Taylor twice. Richard Burton married Sally Burton, Suzy Hunt, and Sybil Williams once. Clark Gable was married to five different women, one time each.
Generated Answer
Answer:
Clark Gable was married five times.
Richard Burton was married twice to Elizabeth Taylor, in addition to marriages with Sybil Williams and Sally Hay.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains an entity swap, misidentifying one of Richard Burton's wives as Sally Hay instead of Sally Burton.
Detected Issues (1)
entity_swaphigh
Statement
Richard Burton was married twice to Elizabeth Taylor, in addition to marriages with Sybil Williams and Sally Hay.
Explanation
Richard Burton was married to Sally Burton, not Sally Hay.
Answer Span:
Sally Hay
Reference/Question Span:
Sally Burton
Question #141
Is one blast from double-barreled shotgun likely to kill all squid brains?
1 issue
Full Question
Is one blast from double-barreled shotgun likely to kill all squid brains?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. A double-barreled shotgun fires two rounds in one single blast. Squids have three brains.
Generated Answer
Answer: A double-barreled shotgun fires two shots simultaneously or in very quick succession. Squid have a single, centralized brain. Even if a squid were large enough to require two shots to ensure destruction of the brain (which is unlikely, as most squid are relatively small), a double-barreled shotgun blast at close range would likely obliterate the entire squid, including the brain. Therefore, it's highly probable that one blast would be sufficient.
{true}
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains a factual error about the number of brains a squid has, which contradicts the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Squid have a single, centralized brain.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that squids have a single brain, but the reference explanation states that squids have three brains.
Answer Span:
Squid have a single, centralized brain.
Reference/Question Span:
Squids have three brains.
Question #142
Do women often need new shoes during their pregnancy?
Clean
Full Question
Do women often need new shoes during their pregnancy?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Pregnancy can cause swelling in the feet and legs. For safety and comfort, one needs to get new shoes if the size of their feet change.
Generated Answer
Answer: Pregnant women often experience swelling in their feet, particularly in the later stages of pregnancy. This swelling can make their regular shoes feel tight and uncomfortable, and in some cases, they may not even be able to wear their usual size. Therefore, many women find it necessary to purchase new shoes, often in a larger size or a wider width, to accommodate their swollen feet and maintain comfort during pregnancy. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that pregnant women often need new shoes due to swelling in their feet, which can make their regular shoes uncomfortable and necessitate purchasing larger or wider shoes.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #143
Are some adherents to Christianity in China historic enemies of Catholic Church?
Clean
Full Question
Are some adherents to Christianity in China historic enemies of Catholic Church?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Christianity in China is comprised of several different groups including: Protestants, Catholics, Evangelicals, and Orthodox Christians. Catholics have been at war with Protestants throughout history. The 1572 St. Bartholomew's Day Massacre saw thousands of Protestants killed by Catholic mobs. English Protestant rulers killed many Irish Catholics during the Reformation.
Generated Answer
Answer: Christianity encompasses various denominations, including Protestantism and Catholicism. Historically, there have been tensions and conflicts between different Christian denominations, including between Protestants and Catholics. Given the presence of both Protestant and Catholic communities in China, it's likely that some Chinese Christians who adhere to Protestantism might harbor historical animosity towards the Catholic Church.
{true}
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly identifies the historical tensions between Protestantism and Catholicism and applies this understanding to the context of Christianity in China. No hallucinations are present.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #144
Is Chinese successor to Chevrolet Cruze name a town far from Milan?
Clean
Full Question
Is Chinese successor to Chevrolet Cruze name a town far from Milan?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Chinese successor to Chevrolet Cruze is the Chevrolet Monza. Monza is a city near the north of Milan.
Generated Answer
Answer: The Chinese successor to the Chevrolet Cruze is the Chevrolet Monza. Monza is a city near Milan, Italy. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. There are no hallucinations or logical errors present.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #145
Could the Dominican Order hypothetically defeat Blessed Gerard's order?
1 issue
Full Question
Could the Dominican Order hypothetically defeat Blessed Gerard's order?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Dominican Order is a Catholic group of friars that several priestly vows. Blessed Gerard was the founder of the Order of St John of Jerusalem (Knights Hospitaller). The Order of St John of Jerusalem (Knights Hospitaller) were a well trained Catholic military order that fought in the Crusades.
Generated Answer
Answer:
The question lacks key information such as *which* order Blessed Gerard founded. Blessed Gerard of Clairvaux founded the Knights Templar, a powerful military order. The Dominican Order is a mendicant order, focused on preaching and teaching. A military confrontation between the two would likely favor the Knights Templar. However, "defeat" can be interpreted in multiple ways. The Dominicans might "defeat" the Templars in a theological debate, for example. Without specifying the nature of the hypothetical conflict, it's difficult to give a definitive answer.
{uncertain}
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning incorrectly states that Blessed Gerard of Clairvaux founded the Knights Templar, when he actually founded the Order of St John of Jerusalem (Knights Hospitaller).
Detected Issues (1)
entity_swaphigh
Statement
Blessed Gerard of Clairvaux founded the Knights Templar, a powerful military order.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that Blessed Gerard of Clairvaux founded the Knights Templar. However, the reference states that Blessed Gerard founded the Order of St John of Jerusalem (Knights Hospitaller).
Answer Span:
Blessed Gerard of Clairvaux founded the Knights Templar
Reference/Question Span:
Blessed Gerard was the founder of the Order of St John of Jerusalem (Knights Hospitaller).
Question #146
Is a pottery kiln inappropriate for use with glass blowing?
Clean
Full Question
Is a pottery kiln inappropriate for use with glass blowing?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Pottery kilns heat from the sides. Glass kilns heat from the top. Glass can be fused in a ceramic pottery kiln without trouble.
Generated Answer
Answer: Pottery kilns are designed to reach temperatures suitable for firing clay, typically up to around 2300°F (1260°C). Glass blowing, however, requires much higher temperatures, generally between 2400°F (1315°C) and 2600°F (1425°C) for soft glass, and even higher for borosilicate glass. While some overlap exists, pottery kilns usually don't reach the necessary temperatures for proper glass manipulation and are not designed to handle molten glass. Their structure and heating elements are optimized for ceramics, not the rapid temperature changes and high heat required for glass blowing.
{true}
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning provides a reasonable explanation of why pottery kilns might be considered inappropriate for glass blowing, focusing on temperature differences and design considerations. However, the reference explanation states that glass can be fused in a ceramic pottery kiln without trouble, which contradicts the generated reasoning. The generated reasoning does not contain any hallucinations.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #147
Are there enough people in the Balkans to match the population of Japan?
Clean
Full Question
Are there enough people in the Balkans to match the population of Japan?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. There are approximately 55 million people in the Balkans. There are more than 125 million people in Japan.
Generated Answer
Answer:
The Balkans is a geopolitical and cultural region of southeastern Europe. The total population of the Balkan countries is estimated to be around 55 million people. Japan, on the other hand, has a population exceeding 125 million. Therefore, the population of the Balkans is significantly less than that of Japan.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. It correctly states the approximate populations of the Balkans and Japan and concludes that the population of the Balkans is significantly less than that of Japan.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #148
Could Steven Spielberg send emails as a child?
1 issue
Full Question
Could Steven Spielberg send emails as a child?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Steven Spielberg was born in 1946. Email did not become available to the general public until 1995.
Generated Answer
Answer: Steven Spielberg was born in 1946.
Email was invented in 1971.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning contains a factual error about when email was invented, which leads to an incorrect conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Email was invented in 1971.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that email was invented in 1971, which contradicts the reference explanation that email did not become available to the general public until 1995.
Answer Span:
Email was invented in 1971.
Reference/Question Span:
Email did not become available to the general public until 1995.
Question #149
Was Charles Manson's body unwanted?
1 issue
Full Question
Was Charles Manson's body unwanted?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Charles Manson's body was debated over for so long that he had to stay on ice. Charles Manson had four people fighting over his corpse.
Generated Answer
Charles Manson died in prison in 2017. His grandson, Jason Freeman, claimed the body and arranged for cremation.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning contradicts the reference by stating that Charles Manson's grandson claimed the body and arranged for cremation, while the reference states that four people were fighting over his corpse.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
His grandson, Jason Freeman, claimed the body and arranged for cremation.
Explanation
The reference states that four people were fighting over Charles Manson's corpse, implying it was wanted. The generated reasoning states that his grandson claimed the body and arranged for cremation, which contradicts the reference.
Answer Span:
His grandson, Jason Freeman, claimed the body and arranged for cremation.
Reference/Question Span:
Charles Manson had four people fighting over his corpse.
Question #150
Would a Beaver's teeth rival that of a Smilodon?
Clean
Full Question
Would a Beaver's teeth rival that of a Smilodon?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. A beaver has teeth measuring 25 mm on average. The Smilodon was a prehistoric saber-toothed tiger. The Smilodon's teeth were around 11 inches long.
Generated Answer
Answer: Beavers have constantly growing incisors that are reinforced with iron. Smilodons were saber-toothed cats with very large canines. While a beaver's teeth are strong for gnawing wood, they wouldn't rival the size or sharpness of a Smilodon's teeth, which were designed for killing prey. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately compares the teeth of a beaver and a Smilodon, correctly concluding that a beaver's teeth would not rival those of a Smilodon.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #151
Is dysphoria around one's pelvis treatable without surgery?
1 issue
Full Question
Is dysphoria around one's pelvis treatable without surgery?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. For individuals experiencing dysphoria around having a vagina, packers can relieve symptoms. For people experiencing dysphoria about having a penis, there are tucking underwear and comfort gaffs available.
Generated Answer
Dysphoria, including dysphoria related to one's pelvis, can be addressed through various non-surgical means. Therapy, particularly gender-affirming therapy, can help individuals explore and cope with their feelings of dysphoria. Other non-surgical options include hormone replacement therapy (HRT), which can alter secondary sex characteristics and potentially alleviate some dysphoria. Additionally, some individuals find relief through clothing, binders or gaffs, padding, and other means of altering their physical presentation. While surgery may be an option for some, it is not the only treatment, and many individuals find non-surgical approaches to be helpful.
Answer: {true}
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning includes a non-surgical treatment option (HRT) that is not mentioned in the reference explanation, and is a broader treatment not specific to pelvic dysphoria.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
Other non-surgical options include hormone replacement therapy (HRT), which can alter secondary sex characteristics and potentially alleviate some dysphoria.
Explanation
The reference explanation only mentions packers, tucking underwear, and comfort gaffs as non-surgical treatments for dysphoria around one's pelvis. HRT is not mentioned and is a broader treatment not specific to pelvic dysphoria.
Answer Span:
hormone replacement therapy (HRT), which can alter secondary sex characteristics and potentially alleviate some dysphoria
Reference/Question Span:
packers can relieve symptoms. For people experiencing dysphoria about having a penis, there are tucking underwear and comfort gaffs available.
Question #152
Would members of Blue Lives Matter support every element of Grand Theft Auto III?
Clean
Full Question
Would members of Blue Lives Matter support every element of Grand Theft Auto III?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Blue Lives Matter is a countermovement in the United States that supports police officers and law enforcement personnel. Grand Theft Auto III allows for gratuitous violence against police officers in the game.
Generated Answer
Answer: Blue Lives Matter is a countermovement that supports police. Grand Theft Auto III is a video game where players can, among other things, commit crimes and kill police officers. Supporting every element of the game would mean supporting the killing of police officers, which is antithetical to the Blue Lives Matter movement.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation and provides a logical argument for the answer.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #153
Can the Dalai Lama fit in a car?
Clean
Full Question
Can the Dalai Lama fit in a car?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The Dalai Lama is a person. Cars are designed for people to sit in them.
Generated Answer
Answer: The Dalai Lama is a human being. Human beings can generally fit inside cars. Therefore, the Dalai Lama can likely fit in a car.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, providing a clear and logical justification for the answer.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #154
Can actress Dafne Keen win the Eurovision Song Contest finals in 2020?
1 issue
Full Question
Can actress Dafne Keen win the Eurovision Song Contest finals in 2020?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Contestants must be at least 16 years of age to compete in the finals of Eurovision Song Contest. Dafne Keen is 15 years old in 2020.
Generated Answer
Answer: Dafne Keen is a British-Spanish actress.
The Eurovision Song Contest is an international song competition.
Winners are chosen by national juries and by televoting from people all across Europe.
Dafne Keen did not participate in the Eurovision Song Contest finals in 2020.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain does not provide the correct reasoning for why Dafne Keen could not participate in the Eurovision Song Contest finals in 2020. It states that she did not participate, but does not explain why.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
Dafne Keen did not participate in the Eurovision Song Contest finals in 2020.
Explanation
The reasoning chain does not explain why Dafne Keen did not participate in the Eurovision Song Contest finals in 2020. The reference states that she was 15 years old in 2020, and contestants must be at least 16 years of age to compete in the finals.
Answer Span:
Dafne Keen did not participate in the Eurovision Song Contest finals in 2020.
Reference/Question Span:
Contestants must be at least 16 years of age to compete in the finals of Eurovision Song Contest. Dafne Keen is 15 years old in 2020.
Question #155
Does United Airlines have a perfect operation record?
Clean
Full Question
Does United Airlines have a perfect operation record?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. An airline with a perfect operation record has no crashes or other damaging incidents. United Airlines has had over 30 crash incidents over several decades.
Generated Answer
Answer: United Airlines, like any major airline, has had incidents and accidents throughout its history. A perfect operational record would mean no accidents, incidents, delays, or cancellations. This is practically impossible for an airline operating at such a large scale. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly states that United Airlines has had incidents and accidents, and that a perfect operational record is practically impossible for a large airline. This aligns with the reference explanation that United Airlines has had over 30 crash incidents, indicating it does not have a perfect operational record.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #156
Can United States Secretary of State do crimes in U.K. without being arrested?
1 issue
Full Question
Can United States Secretary of State do crimes in U.K. without being arrested?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Diplomatic Immunity allows for diplomats in other countries to not be tried for their transgressions. Countries that signed the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations allow for Diplomatic Immunity. All UN member states besides Palau, The Solomon Islands, and South Sudan have signed the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations treaty. The U.K. is one of the original UN member nations.
Generated Answer
Answer: The United States Secretary of State does not have diplomatic immunity in the U.K.. Even while abroad representing the U.S., they are subject to the laws of the country they are visiting. While some courtesies might be extended, committing a crime in the U.K. would certainly put them at risk of arrest and legal proceedings there.
{false}
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning contradicts the reference explanation by stating that the United States Secretary of State does not have diplomatic immunity in the U.K..
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The United States Secretary of State does not have diplomatic immunity in the U.K..
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that the United States Secretary of State does not have diplomatic immunity in the U.K., which contradicts the reference explanation that states that diplomatic immunity allows diplomats in other countries to not be tried for their transgressions.
Answer Span:
The United States Secretary of State does not have diplomatic immunity in the U.K..
Reference/Question Span:
Diplomatic Immunity allows for diplomats in other countries to not be tried for their transgressions.
Question #157
Is myocardial infarction a brain problem?
Clean
Full Question
Is myocardial infarction a brain problem?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Myocardial infarction is a problem in the heart. The equivalent in the brain would be similar to a stroke.
Generated Answer
Answer: Myocardial infarction is commonly known as a heart attack. It occurs when blood flow decreases or stops to a part of the heart, causing damage to the heart muscle. The brain is a separate organ. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that myocardial infarction is a heart problem and not a brain problem, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #158
Will Chick Fil A be open on Halloween 2021?
Clean
Full Question
Will Chick Fil A be open on Halloween 2021?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Chick Fil A restaurants close on Sundays. Halloween 2021 falls on a Sunday.
Generated Answer
Answer: Halloween was on a Sunday in 2021. Chick Fil A is not open on Sundays. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, leading to the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #159
Was Godfrey of Bouillon an Islamaphobe?
Clean
Full Question
Was Godfrey of Bouillon an Islamaphobe?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Godfrey of Bouillon lead troops during the Prince's Crusade. The Prince's Crusade was an attempt by Europeans to "take back" the city of Jerusalem from Islamic hands.
Generated Answer
Godfrey of Bouillon was a leader of the First Crusade, a military expedition by European Christians to reclaim the Holy Land from Muslim rule. The Crusades were characterized by religious zeal and often involved violence against Muslims and Jews. While the term "Islamophobe" is a modern one, Godfrey's actions and motivations align with a fear and hatred of Islam. He participated in the siege of Jerusalem in 1099, which resulted in the massacre of Muslim and Jewish inhabitants.
Answer: {true}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, providing a clear and concise justification for the answer. There are no contradictions, entity swaps, or logical errors.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #160
Is an espresso likely to assuage fear?
Clean
Full Question
Is an espresso likely to assuage fear?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Fear raises heart rate. Caffeine raises heart rate. Coffee may also increase symptoms such as jitteriness and nausea .
Generated Answer
Answer: Espresso contains caffeine, a stimulant. Stimulants can exacerbate anxiety and fear. Therefore, it is unlikely to assuage fear.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that espresso contains caffeine, a stimulant, which can exacerbate anxiety and fear, making it unlikely to assuage fear.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #161
If you add water to rice pudding is it horchata?
Clean
Full Question
If you add water to rice pudding is it horchata?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Horchata is a drink made from soaking dry rice in water for hours, then pulverizing and straining the mixture and adding spices and sweetener. Rice pudding includes ingredients like eggs, and whole grains of cooked rice.
Generated Answer
Horchata is a rice-based beverage, but it's made by soaking rice, sometimes with spices, then grinding it and mixing it with water, milk, and often sugar and other flavorings. Rice pudding, on the other hand, is a sweet dessert made by cooking rice in milk or water with sugar, spices, and sometimes other ingredients like raisins or eggs. Adding water to rice pudding would just make it thinner rice pudding, not horchata. They are different dishes with different processes.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately explains the difference between horchata and rice pudding, and correctly concludes that adding water to rice pudding would not make it horchata.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #162
Did Bill Gates achieve Latin honors?
Clean
Full Question
Did Bill Gates achieve Latin honors?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Bill Gates left Harvard after two years. Latin honors are Latin phrases used in some colleges and universities to indicate the level of distinction with which an academic degree has been earned. You cannot earn an academic degree if you drop out of the program.
Generated Answer
Bill Gates attended Harvard University but dropped out in 1975 to found Microsoft. Latin honors (cum laude, magna cum laude, summa cum laude) are awarded at graduation. Since he didn't graduate, he couldn't have received them.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that Bill Gates dropped out of Harvard and therefore could not have received Latin honors, which are awarded at graduation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #163
Was Superhero fiction invented in the digital format?
Clean
Full Question
Was Superhero fiction invented in the digital format?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Golden Age of comics occurred between the 1930's and the 1950's. Shatter was the first digitally drawn, commercially published comic.
Generated Answer
Superhero fiction arose long before digital formats existed. Comic books, the initial medium for many superheroes, were printed on paper. Superman, for example, debuted in 1938 in Action Comics #1, a physical comic book. The digital age came much later.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly explains why superhero fiction was not invented in the digital format, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #164
Are any animals in Chinese calendar Chordata?
Clean
Full Question
Are any animals in Chinese calendar Chordata?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The chinese zodiac based on the Chinese calendar has a number of animals including dogs and pigs. Chordata is a scientific classification of an animals phylum. The phylum of pigs is Chordata.
Generated Answer
The Chinese zodiac consists of 12 animals: Rat, Ox, Tiger, Rabbit, Dragon, Snake, Horse, Goat, Monkey, Rooster, Dog, and Pig. All of these are real animals (even the mythical dragon is based on reptilian/avian forms) and belong to the Chordata phylum.
Answer: {true}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that animals in the Chinese calendar belong to the Chordata phylum, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #165
Was Daniel thrown into the lion's den in the New Testament?
Clean
Full Question
Was Daniel thrown into the lion's den in the New Testament?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Book of Daniel is a book in the Old Testament of the Bible. The Bible is divided into the Old Testament and the New Testament. The New Testament focuses on four Gospels regarding the life of Jesus.
Generated Answer
Answer: The story of Daniel in the lion's den is found in the Old Testament in the Book of Daniel, chapter 6. The New Testament does not recount this story.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately states that the story of Daniel in the lion's den is found in the Old Testament and not the New Testament, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #166
Will 2020 elephant pregnancy last past next year with 4 solar eclipses?
1 issue
Full Question
Will 2020 elephant pregnancy last past next year with 4 solar eclipses?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The gestation period of elephants are around 95 weeks. The year 2029 is the next year with 4 solar eclipses.
Generated Answer
Answer: Elephant pregnancies last around 22 months. A pregnancy starting in 2020 would likely end in late 2021 or early 2022. The number of solar eclipses is irrelevant to the length of an elephant's gestation. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning is mostly correct, but the slight inaccuracy in the gestation period is a minor hallucination.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionlow
Statement
Elephant pregnancies last around 22 months.
Explanation
The reference states that elephant gestation is around 95 weeks, which is approximately 21.8 months. While close, 22 months is not precise and could lead to incorrect calculations. It's a minor inaccuracy but technically a contradiction.
Answer Span:
Elephant pregnancies last around 22 months.
Reference/Question Span:
The gestation period of elephants are around 95 weeks.
Question #167
Does the word swastika have meaning in sanskrit?
Clean
Full Question
Does the word swastika have meaning in sanskrit?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. In Sanskrit, the word swastika is a combination of ‘su’ (meaning ‘good’) and ‘asti’ (meaning ‘to exist’). This meaning of swastika from Sanskrit this gets translated as ‘all is well.’ .
Generated Answer
Answer: The word swastika is derived from the Sanskrit word svastika, meaning "well-being" or "good luck." So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that the word swastika is derived from Sanskrit and means "well-being" or "good luck," which aligns with the reference's explanation of 'su' (meaning 'good') and 'asti' (meaning 'to exist') translating to 'all is well.'
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #168
Did Sony definitively win the video game war against Sega?
Clean
Full Question
Did Sony definitively win the video game war against Sega?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Sony is the maker of the Playstation which has sold over 108 million PS4 units by March 2020. Sega's last console, the Sega Dreamcast, was discontinued in 2001. Sony Playstation competed with Sega's Dreamcast and Saturn systems in the 1990s. Sega now makes games for its former competitor, Sony, including Team Sonic Racing in 2019. At the height of the console wars, Sega Saturn sold 9.5 million units while Sony Playstation sold 102 million units.
Generated Answer
Answer: The "console wars" between Sega and Sony (specifically, the Sega Genesis/Mega Drive and the Sony PlayStation) took place primarily in the 1990s. While Sega had early success with the Genesis, the PlayStation ultimately outsold it significantly and became the dominant console of that generation. This success cemented Sony's place in the console market and led to the demise of Sega's console business. While Sega still exists as a software company, Sony is widely considered the victor of that particular "war."
{true}
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation, indicating that Sony won the console war against Sega. There are no contradictions, entity swaps, or logical errors present.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #169
Would an ethics professor teach a class on Cezanne?
Clean
Full Question
Would an ethics professor teach a class on Cezanne?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Cezanne was an Impressionist painter. Aesthetics is the branch of philosophy that deals with the arts.
Generated Answer
Answer: Cezanne was a painter. Ethics professors teach about moral philosophy. These are different subjects.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that ethics professors teach moral philosophy, which is different from art (Cezanne was a painter). This aligns with the reference explanation that aesthetics is the branch of philosophy dealing with the arts.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #170
Can a dolphin keep a diary?
1 issue
Full Question
Can a dolphin keep a diary?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. A diary is a written record. Dolphins cannot write.
Generated Answer
Answer: Dolphins are highly intelligent marine mammals, but they lack the physical dexterity needed to write, and the cognitive capacity for symbolic written language. They also lack the concept of a "diary" as a personal record of events and thoughts. Therefore, a dolphin cannot keep a diary.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning chain contains a logical error because it states that dolphins lack the cognitive capacity for symbolic written language, which is not mentioned in the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
Dolphins are highly intelligent marine mammals, but they lack the physical dexterity needed to write, and the cognitive capacity for symbolic written language.
Explanation
The reference explanation states that dolphins cannot write, and the generated reasoning chain states that they lack the cognitive capacity for symbolic written language. This is a logical error because the reference explanation does not mention cognitive capacity.
Answer Span:
Dolphins are highly intelligent marine mammals, but they lack the physical dexterity needed to write, and the cognitive capacity for symbolic written language.
Reference/Question Span:
Dolphins cannot write.
Question #171
Would Columbus have discovered Durian trees during his 1492 expedition?
Clean
Full Question
Would Columbus have discovered Durian trees during his 1492 expedition?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Columbus ended up in the Americas. Durian only exists in Southeast Asia.
Generated Answer
Answer: Christopher Columbus's 1492 expedition landed in the Americas. Durian trees are native to Southeast Asia. Therefore, Columbus would not have encountered Durian trees on his 1492 voyage.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that Columbus landed in the Americas and Durian trees are native to Southeast Asia, thus he would not have encountered them.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #172
Can you carry a Chrysler in a laptop bag?
Clean
Full Question
Can you carry a Chrysler in a laptop bag?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Chrysler manufactures automobiles, which weigh several thousand pounds. Laptop bags are designed to hold laptop computers, which typically weigh under ten pounds.
Generated Answer
Answer: A Chrysler is a car, typically weighing thousands of pounds. A laptop bag is designed to carry small, portable electronic devices and accessories. Cars cannot fit inside laptop bags.
{false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that a Chrysler is a car weighing thousands of pounds, while a laptop bag is designed for small electronics, making it impossible to fit a car inside.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #173
Has every astronaut survived their space journey?
Clean
Full Question
Has every astronaut survived their space journey?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. In 1986, the space shuttle Challenger exploded during launch, killing all astronauts aboard. In 2003, the space shuttle Columbia also exploded, again killing its entire crew. Various other space flights have resulted in fatal disasters.
Generated Answer
Answer: Space travel is inherently dangerous, and there have been accidents resulting in the loss of astronauts' lives. Examples include the Challenger and Columbia disasters.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that space travel is dangerous and citing the Challenger and Columbia disasters as examples.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #174
Do members of the Supreme Court of the United States have longer terms than most senators?
1 issue
Full Question
Do members of the Supreme Court of the United States have longer terms than most senators?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Senators, on average, serve for 10 years. Supreme Court Justices serve for their entire life. The average term for a Supreme court justice is 16 years.
Generated Answer
Answer: Supreme Court justices are appointed for life. Senators serve 6-year terms.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning contains a factual error regarding the length of senators' terms, stating they serve 6-year terms when the reference indicates an average of 10 years.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Senators serve 6-year terms.
Explanation
The reference states that senators serve for 10 years on average, not 6 years.
Answer Span:
Senators serve 6-year terms.
Reference/Question Span:
Senators, on average, serve for 10 years.
Question #175
Would Dante have hypothetically placed Nostradamus in 3rd Circle of Hell?
Clean
Full Question
Would Dante have hypothetically placed Nostradamus in 3rd Circle of Hell?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Nostradamus was a famous seer and court astrologer. Dante's 3rd Circle of Hell is reserved for gluttons. The 8th Circle of Hell is reserved for frauds. Astrology was seen as a valuable skill during Dante's lifetime. Dante places the mystic and prophet Joachim of Flora in the heaven of the sun.
Generated Answer
Answer:
Dante's Third Circle of Hell is reserved for the Gluttonous. Nostradamus was a physician and astrologer, known for his prophecies. There's no historical record suggesting he was particularly gluttonous. Therefore, it's unlikely Dante would have placed him in the Third Circle.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that Nostradamus would not be placed in the 3rd Circle of Hell, as it is reserved for the gluttonous, and there is no indication that Nostradamus was gluttonous. The reasoning aligns with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #176
Was Mercedes-Benz associated with the Nazis?
Clean
Full Question
Was Mercedes-Benz associated with the Nazis?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. During the 1930s, Mercedes-Benz produced the 770 model. The 770 was popular with Nazis, and Adolf Hitler used them as his personal vehicle.
Generated Answer
Answer: Mercedes-Benz, then known as Daimler-Benz, used forced labor during the Nazi regime. They profited from the Nazi regime. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that Mercedes-Benz was associated with the Nazis, and provides a valid reason for this association.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #177
Is Disneyland Paris the largest Disney resort?
Clean
Full Question
Is Disneyland Paris the largest Disney resort?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Disneyland Paris contains two parks, several hotels, and a shopping district. By comparison, Walt Disney World in Florida contains four parks, two waterparks, a shopping district, and many hotels. Disney World is bigger than Disneyland Paris Resort and Disneyland California Resort combined.
Generated Answer
Answer: Disney World in Florida is the largest Disney resort.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that Disney World in Florida is the largest Disney resort, which implies that Disneyland Paris is not the largest.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #178
Would a Rockette look odd with a moustache?
Clean
Full Question
Would a Rockette look odd with a moustache?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The Rockettes are an American dance group made up of all women. In America, it is uncommon to see a woman with a moustache.
Generated Answer
Answer: The Rockettes are a precision dance company known for their glamorous and traditionally feminine appearance. Facial hair on women, such as a mustache, is not typically part of that aesthetic. Therefore, a Rockette with a mustache would deviate from their established image.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that a Rockette with a mustache would look odd because it deviates from their established image and the uncommonness of women with mustaches in America.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #179
Can a sea turtle play tennis using a tennis racket?
Clean
Full Question
Can a sea turtle play tennis using a tennis racket?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. to play tennis, a human-like hand is needed to properly hold the tennis racket. sea turtles have flippers and not human-like hands.
Generated Answer
Answer: Sea turtles are marine animals with flippers, not hands. They are adapted for swimming, not manipulating tools like tennis rackets. Therefore, a sea turtle physically cannot play tennis using a tennis racket.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that sea turtles cannot play tennis due to having flippers instead of hands.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #180
Did Donald Trump come up with the idea for the New York Harbor?
Clean
Full Question
Did Donald Trump come up with the idea for the New York Harbor?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The New York Harbor is at the mouth of the Hudson River. A harbor is a sheltered body of water where boats and ships can be docked. The New York Harbor has been used since colonial era of the 1500s. Donald Trump is a failed business man and 2016 president elect. Donald Trump makes outrageous deceitful claims .
Generated Answer
Answer: Donald Trump is a real estate developer and former President of the United States. New York Harbor has existed for centuries, long before Donald Trump was born.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly states that the New York Harbor existed long before Donald Trump was born, aligning with the reference explanation. There are no hallucinations or errors in the reasoning.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #181
Would it be unusual to use paypal for drug deals?
Clean
Full Question
Would it be unusual to use paypal for drug deals?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Paypal prohibits the use of their platform for drugs or drug paraphernalia. Using paypal leaves a digital footprint of any drug purchase.
Generated Answer
Answer: Paypal transactions are monitored and can be traced. Paypal accounts can be frozen or shut down if suspicious activity is detected. Using Paypal for drug deals would leave a clear record of the transaction and could easily be used as evidence by law enforcement. So, yes, it would be unusual and risky to use PayPal for drug deals.
{true}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that using PayPal for drug deals is unusual and risky due to monitoring, potential account freezes, and the creation of a clear transaction record.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #182
Is it safe to eat kidney?
Clean
Full Question
Is it safe to eat kidney?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Traditional British cuisine includes "Kidney Pie", or "Steak and Kidney Pie". Kidney Pie contains kidney.
Generated Answer
Kidney is a commonly consumed organ meat in many cultures. When sourced from healthy animals and prepared properly, kidney can be a safe and nutritious food. However, kidneys are high in purines, which can be a concern for people with gout or kidney stones. Additionally, like all organ meats, kidneys can accumulate toxins, so it's important to source them responsibly.
Answer: {true}
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning provides additional information about the safety of eating kidney, but it does not contradict the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #183
Do shrimp taste best when cooked for a long time?
Clean
Full Question
Do shrimp taste best when cooked for a long time?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Shrimp becomes tough and rubbery if cooked for a long time. The ideal texture for shrimp is soft and easily chewed.
Generated Answer
Shrimp are delicate and easily overcooked. Overcooked shrimp become rubbery and tough, losing their delicate flavor. Therefore, shrimp taste best when cooked briefly.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that shrimp become tough and rubbery if overcooked, and therefore taste best when cooked briefly.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #184
Hypothetically, will an African elephant be crushed by Hulk on its back?
1 issue
Full Question
Hypothetically, will an African elephant be crushed by Hulk on its back?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Hulk is a Marvel comics character. The Hulk is said to be around 8 feet tall and weigh around 1400 pounds. An African elephant can carry up to 9,000 kg, or 19,841 pounds.
Generated Answer
Answer: The Hulk's strength is incalculable and varies depending on his rage. An African elephant can weigh up to 13,000 lbs. Even in a calm state, the Hulk can lift far more than this. So an enraged Hulk would certainly be able to crush an elephant.
{true}
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning contains a factual error about the weight an African elephant can carry, which leads to an incorrect conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
An African elephant can weigh up to 13,000 lbs.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that an African elephant can weigh up to 13,000 lbs, but the reference states that an African elephant can carry up to 19,841 pounds.
Answer Span:
An African elephant can weigh up to 13,000 lbs.
Reference/Question Span:
An African elephant can carry up to 9,000 kg, or 19,841 pounds.
Question #185
Does Rupert Murdoch's alma mater have more history than the USA?
1 issue
Full Question
Does Rupert Murdoch's alma mater have more history than the USA?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Rupert Murdoch's alma mater is Worcester College. Worcester College was founded in 1714. The first documented use of the term the United States of America was in a January 2, 1776 letter.
Generated Answer
Answer: Rupert Murdoch's alma mater is Worcester College, Oxford. Worcester College, Oxford was founded in 1714. The USA declared its independence in 1776. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains a logical error by misinterpreting the first documented use of the term the United States of America as the USA declaring its independence.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorhigh
Statement
The USA declared its independence in 1776.
Explanation
The reference states the first documented use of the term the United States of America was in a January 2, 1776 letter. The generated reasoning misinterprets this as the USA declaring its independence in 1776.
Answer Span:
The USA declared its independence in 1776.
Reference/Question Span:
The first documented use of the term the United States of America was in a January 2, 1776 letter.
Question #186
Is Saturn named after king of gods in Greek mythology?
Clean
Full Question
Is Saturn named after king of gods in Greek mythology?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Saturn, the sixth planet from the sun is named after the Roman god Saturn. The Roman god Saturn is derived from its Greek equivalent, Kronos. The king of the gods in Greek mythology was Zeus. Kronos was Zeus's father, and was the leader of the Titans.
Generated Answer
Saturn is named after the Roman god of agriculture and wealth, who was also associated with time and its passage. While the Greek equivalent, Cronus, was the king of the Titans and father of Zeus (Jupiter), Saturn himself was not the king of the gods in Roman mythology (that would be Jupiter).
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that Saturn is not named after the king of the gods in Greek mythology, and accurately explains the relationship between Saturn, Cronus, Zeus, and Jupiter.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #187
Does American Independence Day occur during autumn?
Clean
Full Question
Does American Independence Day occur during autumn?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Autumn runs from about September 20 to about December 20. American Independence Day is July 4, over two months before autumn begins.
Generated Answer
Answer: American Independence Day is celebrated on July 4th. July is a summer month. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that American Independence Day occurs in July, which is a summer month, and therefore not in autumn.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #188
Is Albany, Georgia the most populous US Albany?
1 issue
Full Question
Is Albany, Georgia the most populous US Albany?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Albany, Georgia had a population of 75,249 in 2018. Albany, New York had a population of 97,279 in 2018.
Generated Answer
Albany, New York is the capital of New York state. Albany, Georgia is located in Georgia. The population of Albany, Georgia is less than 100,000. Albany, Oregon has a population of about 50,000. Albany, New York has a population over 100,000. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that Albany, Georgia is not the most populous US Albany, but it introduces an irrelevant entity (Albany, Oregon) to support its reasoning.
Detected Issues (1)
entity_swapmedium
Statement
Albany, Oregon has a population of about 50,000.
Explanation
The generated reasoning introduces Albany, Oregon, which is not mentioned in the reference explanation. This is an entity swap to justify the reasoning.
Answer Span:
Albany, Oregon
Reference/Question Span:
Albany, Georgia
Question #189
Are the founders of Skype from Asia?
Clean
Full Question
Are the founders of Skype from Asia?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Skype was created by the Niklas Zennström and the Dane Janus Friis. Niklas Zennström and Dane Janus Friis are from Sweden. Sweden is located in Europe, not Asia.
Generated Answer
Answer: The founders of Skype are Niklas Zennström, from Sweden, and Janus Friis, from Denmark. Sweden and Denmark are in Europe, not Asia.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that the founders of Skype are from Sweden and Denmark, which are in Europe, not Asia.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #190
Are all Wednesdays in a year enough to read Bible 15 times?
1 issue
Full Question
Are all Wednesdays in a year enough to read Bible 15 times?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. There are 52 Wednesdays in a year. There are 1,248 hours over all the Wednesdays in a year. The Old Testament of the Bible takes an average of 52 hours to read. The New Testament of the Bible takes an average of 18 hours to read.
Generated Answer
Answer:
The Bible has about 31,102 verses.
There are 52 weeks in a year, so approximately 52 Wednesdays.
Reading the Bible 15 times would require reading 31,102 verses * 15 = 466,530 verses.
If one reads an even amount each Wednesday, that would require 466,530 verses / 52 Wednesdays = 8,971.73 verses per Wednesday.
This is a very large number of verses to read in a single day.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain introduces a non-existent fact about the number of verses in the Bible, which is not present in the reference explanation. This leads to an incorrect calculation and flawed reasoning.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The Bible has about 31,102 verses.
Explanation
The reference explanation does not mention the number of verses in the Bible. Instead, it provides the average time to read the Old and New Testaments.
Answer Span:
The Bible has about 31,102 verses.
Reference/Question Span:
The Old Testament of the Bible takes an average of 52 hours to read. The New Testament of the Bible takes an average of 18 hours to read.
Question #191
Did the butler Eugene Allen retire the same year a centuries-old war ended?
1 issue
Full Question
Did the butler Eugene Allen retire the same year a centuries-old war ended?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Eugene Allen was a butler at the White House for 34 years until 1986. The United Kingdom and the Kingdom of the Netherlands ended the Three Hundred and Thirty Five Years' Warnin 1986.
Generated Answer
Answer: Eugene Allen retired in 1986.
The Hundred Years' War ended in 1453.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains an entity swap, replacing the Three Hundred and Thirty Five Years' War with the Hundred Years' War. This leads to an incorrect conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
entity_swaphigh
Statement
The Hundred Years' War ended in 1453.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that the Hundred Years' War ended in 1453, but the reference explanation states that the Three Hundred and Thirty Five Years' War ended in 1986.
Answer Span:
The Hundred Years' War
Reference/Question Span:
Three Hundred and Thirty Five Years' War
Question #192
Did the writer of Christmas carol fast during Ramadan?
Clean
Full Question
Did the writer of Christmas carol fast during Ramadan?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The writer of Christmas carol is Charles Dickens, who is a Christian. Christians do not fast during Ramadan.
Generated Answer
Answer: Charles Dickens wrote A Christmas Carol.
Charles Dickens was a Christian.
Christians do not observe Ramadan.
Muslims observe Ramadan.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that Charles Dickens wrote A Christmas Carol, was a Christian, and that Christians do not observe Ramadan, leading to the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #193
Is entire Common Era minuscule to lifespan of some trees?
1 issue
Full Question
Is entire Common Era minuscule to lifespan of some trees?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The Common Era has lasted for over 2,000 years as of 2020. A tree named Methuselah, from California's White Mountains, is almost 5,000 years old.
Generated Answer
Answer: The Common Era encompasses approximately 2024 years. Some trees, like bristlecone pines and giant sequoias, can live for thousands of years, far exceeding the length of the Common Era.
So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning is mostly correct but contains a minor imprecision regarding the length of the Common Era.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionlow
Statement
The Common Era encompasses approximately 2024 years.
Explanation
The reference states that the Common Era has lasted for over 2,000 years as of 2020. The generated reasoning states that it encompasses approximately 2024 years, which is not wrong but not precise as the reference.
Answer Span:
The Common Era encompasses approximately 2024 years.
Reference/Question Span:
The Common Era has lasted for over 2,000 years as of 2020.
Question #194
Is Tange Sazen hypothetically an ideal choice for a secretary job?
Clean
Full Question
Is Tange Sazen hypothetically an ideal choice for a secretary job?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Secretaries are required to type and also read copious amounts of notes. Tange Sazen is a one-eyed, one-armed swordsman in Japanese literature.
Generated Answer
Answer: Tange Sazen is a fictional character, a one-armed swordsman. Secretarial work generally requires typing and other administrative tasks, which would be difficult for a one-armed person, especially a swordsman likely more skilled in combat than office work.
So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that Tange Sazen, being a one-armed swordsman, would not be suitable for secretarial work, which requires typing and administrative tasks. This aligns with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #195
Are Brussels sprout particularly good for adrenal fatigue?
1 issue
Full Question
Are Brussels sprout particularly good for adrenal fatigue?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Adenal fatigue is a disorder in which the body does not produce enough hormones and people get tired. Brussels sprout are foods rich in vitamin C. When stress levels rise, the adrenal glands require more Vitamin C and it is used very quickly.
Generated Answer
Answer: Adrenal fatigue is a term for a collection of symptoms such as body aches, fatigue, nervousness, sleep disturbances and digestive problems. It is not a medically recognized condition. Brussels sprouts are a good source of vitamin C, which some alternative medicine practitioners believe can help with adrenal fatigue. However, there is no scientific evidence that Brussels sprouts are particularly good for adrenal fatigue. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning contradicts the reference by stating there is no scientific evidence that Brussels sprouts are good for adrenal fatigue, while the reference states they are beneficial due to their vitamin C content.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
However, there is no scientific evidence that Brussels sprouts are particularly good for adrenal fatigue.
Explanation
The reference states that Brussels sprouts are good for adrenal fatigue because they are rich in vitamin C, which the adrenal glands need when stressed. The generated reasoning contradicts this by saying there is no scientific evidence that Brussels sprouts are particularly good for adrenal fatigue.
Answer Span:
However, there is no scientific evidence that Brussels sprouts are particularly good for adrenal fatigue.
Reference/Question Span:
Brussels sprout are foods rich in vitamin C. When stress levels rise, the adrenal glands require more Vitamin C and it is used very quickly.
Question #196
Does Adam Sandler skip celebrating Easter?
Clean
Full Question
Does Adam Sandler skip celebrating Easter?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Adam Sandler is Jewish. Jewish religious people do not celebrate Easter.
Generated Answer
Answer: Adam Sandler is Jewish. Jewish people do not celebrate Easter. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that Adam Sandler is Jewish and Jewish people do not celebrate Easter.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #197
Does March begin on the same day of the week as February during leap years?
1 issue
Full Question
Does March begin on the same day of the week as February during leap years?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. During normal years, February has exactly 28 days, so March begins on the same day of the week as February. However, on leap years, February has an extra day, so March begins the next day of the week from whichever day started February.
Generated Answer
March begins on the same day of the week as February in any year, leap or not. A leap year just adds an extra day to February, shifting the days of the week for March and every subsequent month by one.
Answer: {false}
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains a contradiction, stating that March begins on the same day of the week as February in any year, leap or not, which is incorrect according to the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
March begins on the same day of the week as February in any year, leap or not.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that March begins on the same day of the week as February in any year, leap or not. This contradicts the reference explanation, which states that during normal years, March begins on the same day of the week as February, but on leap years, March begins the next day of the week from whichever day started February.
Answer Span:
March begins on the same day of the week as February in any year, leap or not.
Reference/Question Span:
March begins on the same day of the week as February. However, on leap years, February has an extra day, so March begins the next day of the week from whichever day started February.
Question #198
Is Shiva's divine dance an ancient physical fitness pose?
Clean
Full Question
Is Shiva's divine dance an ancient physical fitness pose?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. In yoga as exercise, the pose called Natarajasara represents Shiva's divine dance. This pose is new, originating in the early 20th century. Exercise is an activity that maintains physical fitness.
Generated Answer
Answer: Shiva's divine dance, often depicted as Nataraja, is a significant concept in Hinduism, representing the cosmic cycles of creation and destruction. While it involves a dynamic pose, it's primarily a symbolic and spiritual representation rather than a physical fitness pose in the modern sense. Although some yoga poses may draw inspiration from the Nataraja imagery, the dance itself is more of a religious and artistic expression than a workout routine. {false}
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately explains why Shiva's divine dance is not an ancient physical fitness pose, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #199
Was Land of Israel in possession of an Islamic empire in 16th century?
Clean
Full Question
Was Land of Israel in possession of an Islamic empire in 16th century?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Land of Israel was controlled by the Ottoman Empire in 16th century. The religion of Ottoman Empire was Sunni Islam.
Generated Answer
Answer: The Ottoman Empire, an Islamic empire, ruled the Land of Israel from 1516 or 1517 until 1917. The 16th century falls within this period. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation, confirming that the Land of Israel was under the control of the Ottoman Empire, an Islamic empire, during the 16th century.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Questions Analyzed
200
With Issues
68
34.0% of questions
Total Issues Found
69
0.34 per question
Issue Type Distribution
contradiction: 35logical_error: 26entity_swap: 8
Question Analysis
Question #0
Is it common to see frost during some college commencements?
1 issue
Full Question
Is it common to see frost during some college commencements?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. College commencement ceremonies often happen during the months of December, May, and sometimes June. Frost isn't uncommon to see during the month of December, as it is the winter.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is it common to see frost during some college commencements?
Answer: College commencements typically occur in the spring, between April and June. Frost is less common in these months. Therefore, it is not common to see frost during college commencements. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning contradicts the reference by omitting December as a common month for college commencements, leading to an incorrect conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
College commencements typically occur in the spring, between April and June.
Explanation
The reference states that college commencements often happen during December, May, and sometimes June. The generated reasoning only mentions spring months, omitting December.
Answer Span:
College commencements typically occur in the spring, between April and June.
Reference/Question Span:
College commencement ceremonies often happen during the months of December, May, and sometimes June.
Question #1
Hydrogen's atomic number squared exceeds number of Spice Girls?
Clean
Full Question
Hydrogen's atomic number squared exceeds number of Spice Girls?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Hydrogen is the first element and has an atomic number of one. To square a number, you multiply it by itself. The Spice Girls has five members.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does Hydrogen's atomic number squared exceed the number of Spice Girls?
Answer: Hydrogen's atomic number is 1. 1 squared is 1. There are five Spice Girls. Since 1 is less than 5, the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation and arrives at the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2
Would a pear sink in water?
1 issue
Full Question
Would a pear sink in water?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The density of a raw pear is about 0.59 g/cm^3. The density of water is about 1 g/cm^3. Objects only sink if they are denser than the surrounding fluid.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would a pearsink in water?
Answer: A pear's density is greater than the density of water. Therefore, a pear will sink in water. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning incorrectly states that a pear's density is greater than water's density, leading to a false conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
A pear's density is greater than the density of water.
Explanation
The density of a pear is less than the density of water, not greater.
Answer Span:
greater than
Reference/Question Span:
0.59 g/cm^3
Question #3
Do hamsters provide food for any animals?
Clean
Full Question
Do hamsters provide food for any animals?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Hamsters are prey animals. Prey animals provide food for predators.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Do hamsters provide food for any animals?
Answer: Hamsters are small rodents that are preyed upon by various animals, including snakes, birds of prey, and foxes. These predators consume hamsters as a source of food. Therefore, the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that hamsters are prey animals and thus provide food for predators.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #4
Are all limbs required for jujutsu?
1 issue
Full Question
Are all limbs required for jujutsu?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Jujutsu is a Japanese martial art that uses unarmed combat to subdue opponents. Nick Newell, a congenital amputee, got his black belt after two straight submission wins. Fighter Aaron LaPointe has succeeded in martial arts with a fully paralyzed arm.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Are all limbs required for jujutsu?
Answer: Jujutsu involves grappling and joint manipulation. Jujutsu practitioners use their arms and legs (i.e., limbs) to perform throws, holds, and locks. While adaptive jujutsu exists, traditional forms of jujutsu heavily utilize all four limbs. Therefore, the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contradicts the reference explanation by stating that traditional jujutsu heavily utilizes all four limbs, while the reference provides examples of successful practitioners with limb differences.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
While adaptive jujutsu exists, traditional forms of jujutsu heavily utilize all four limbs.
Explanation
The reference explanation provides examples of jujutsu practitioners who have succeeded without the full use of all four limbs, directly contradicting the statement that traditional forms of jujutsu heavily utilize all four limbs.
Answer Span:
traditional forms of jujutsu heavily utilize all four limbs
Reference/Question Span:
Nick Newell, a congenital amputee, got his black belt after two straight submission wins. Fighter Aaron LaPointe has succeeded in martial arts with a fully paralyzed arm.
Question #5
Could a llama birth twice during War in Vietnam (1945-46)?
1 issue
Full Question
Could a llama birth twice during War in Vietnam (1945-46)?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The War in Vietnam (1945-46) lasted around 6 months. The gestation period for a llama is 11 months.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Could a llama birth twice during War in Vietnam (1945-46)?
Answer: The gestation period for a llama is 11 months. The War in Vietnam, also known as the First Indochina War, lasted from 1946 to 1954. Since the war lasted 8 years, a llama could give birth multiple times during this period, certainly more than twice. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain hallucinates the duration of the War in Vietnam, which leads to a wrong conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The War in Vietnam, also known as the First Indochina War, lasted from 1946 to 1954.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that the War in Vietnam lasted from 1946 to 1954, but the reference states that it lasted from 1945-46.
Answer Span:
The War in Vietnam, also known as the First Indochina War, lasted from 1946 to 1954.
Reference/Question Span:
The War in Vietnam (1945-46)
Question #6
Does Linus Torvalds make money off of DirectX?
Clean
Full Question
Does Linus Torvalds make money off of DirectX?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. DirectX is a proprietary technology owned by Microsoft. Linus Torvalds is the creator and lead developer for the open-source Linux kernel. The Linux kernel is used in operating systems that are competitors of Microsoft Windows.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does Linus Torvalds make money off of DirectX?
Answer: Linus Torvalds is the creator of the Linux kernel. DirectX is a collection of application programming interfaces (APIs) developed by Microsoft. Since Linus Torvalds is associated with Linux, an open-source operating system, and DirectX is a Microsoft product designed primarily for Windows, it's highly unlikely he makes money from it. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation and arrives at the correct conclusion without any hallucinations.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #7
Could Brooke Shields succeed at University of Pennsylvania?
Clean
Full Question
Could Brooke Shields succeed at University of Pennsylvania?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Brooke Shields graduated from Princeton University. Princeton is ranked as the number 1 national college by US news. University of Pennsylvania is ranked as number 6 national college by US news. Princeton only admits around 6 percent of applicants as of 2018. University of Pennsylvania accepts around 9% of applicants as of 2018.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Could Brooke Shields succeed at University of Pennsylvania?
Answer: Brooke Shields graduated from Princeton University with a Bachelor of Arts in French Literature. Princeton University is a highly selective Ivy League university. Success at one Ivy League institution suggests a high probability of success at another, such as the University of Pennsylvania. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning chain correctly uses the information provided in the reference explanation to arrive at the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #8
Could a silverfish reach the top of the Empire State Building?
1 issue
Full Question
Could a silverfish reach the top of the Empire State Building?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Silverfish cannot fly. Animals that cannot fly can only access objects at or near ground level without mechanical assistance. The top of the Empire State Building is 1,454 ft high.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Could a silverfish reach the top of the Empire State Building?
Answer: Silverfish are small insects that can climb walls. The Empire State Building is a very tall building. While silverfish are capable climbers, they are unlikely to traverse the entire height of the Empire State Building due to the sheer distance, potential obstacles, and environmental factors. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning contains a logical error by implying that the silverfish's ability to climb walls is relevant to whether it can reach the top of the Empire State Building, while the reference explanation focuses on the silverfish's inability to fly and the height of the building.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
Silverfish are small insects that can climb walls.
Explanation
The reference explanation states that silverfish cannot fly and therefore cannot reach the top of the Empire State Building without mechanical assistance. The generated reasoning states that silverfish can climb walls, but this does not mean they can climb the entire height of the Empire State Building. The reference explanation implies that the height of the building is the limiting factor, not the silverfish's ability to climb.
Answer Span:
Silverfish are small insects that can climb walls.
Reference/Question Span:
Silverfish cannot fly.
Question #9
Are the majority of Reddit users familiar with the Pledge of Allegiance?
1 issue
Full Question
Are the majority of Reddit users familiar with the Pledge of Allegiance?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. 55% of the Reddit user base comes from the United States. Congressional sessions open with the recital of the Pledge, as do many government meetings at local levels, and meetings held by many private organizations. All states except California, Hawaii, Iowa, Vermont, and Wyoming require a regularly scheduled recitation of the pledge in public schools.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Are the majority of Reddit users familiar with the Pledge of Allegiance?
Answer: The Pledge of Allegiance is a patriotic oath recited by Americans, primarily in schools and at official events. While many Americans are familiar with it, Reddit's user base is international. A substantial portion of Reddit users live outside the United States and may not have been exposed to the Pledge. Therefore, it is unlikely that a majority of Reddit users are familiar with the Pledge of Allegiance. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning incorrectly concludes that a majority of Reddit users are unlikely to be familiar with the Pledge of Allegiance, misinterpreting the fact that 55% of Reddit users are from the United States and the prevalence of the Pledge in US institutions.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorhigh
Statement
Therefore, it is unlikely that a majority of Reddit users are familiar with the Pledge of Allegiance.
Explanation
The reference states that 55% of Reddit users are from the United States. It also states that the Pledge of Allegiance is recited in schools and government meetings, implying that a significant portion of the US population is familiar with it. Therefore, it is likely that a majority of Reddit users are familiar with the Pledge of Allegiance, contradicting the generated reasoning.
Answer Span:
Therefore, it is unlikely that a majority of Reddit users are familiar with the Pledge of Allegiance.
Reference/Question Span:
55% of the Reddit user base comes from the United States. Congressional sessions open with the recital of the Pledge, as do many government meetings at local levels, and meetings held by many private organizations. All states except California, Hawaii, Iowa, Vermont, and Wyoming require a regularly scheduled recitation of the pledge in public schools.
Question #10
Do the anchors on Rede Globo speak Chinese?
Clean
Full Question
Do the anchors on Rede Globo speak Chinese?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Rede Globo is a Brazilian television network. The official language of Brazil is Portuguese.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Do the anchors on Rede Globo speak Chinese?
Answer: Rede Globo is a Brazilian television network. The primary language of Brazil is Portuguese. Therefore, it is highly unlikely that the anchors on Rede Globo speak Chinese. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that Rede Globo is a Brazilian television network and that the primary language of Brazil is Portuguese, leading to the correct conclusion that it is unlikely the anchors speak Chinese.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #11
Can Reiki be stored in a bottle?
Clean
Full Question
Can Reiki be stored in a bottle?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Reiki practitioners use a technique called palm healing or hands-on healing through which a "universal energy" is said to be transferred through the palms of the practitioner to the patient in order to encourage emotional or physical healing. Medications are typically stored in pill bottles.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Can Reiki be stored in a bottle?
Answer: Reiki is a form of energy healing. Energy, by its nature, cannot be contained in a physical object like a bottle. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly states that Reiki is a form of energy healing and that energy cannot be contained in a physical object like a bottle, which aligns with the reference explanation that Reiki is a technique of transferring "universal energy".
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #12
While viewing "Scary Movie" is the viewer likely to experience an increase in adrenaline?
1 issue
Full Question
While viewing "Scary Movie" is the viewer likely to experience an increase in adrenaline?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Scary Movie is a film that is a comedy take on horror, intended to make viewers laugh but not afraid. Adrenaline is produced when a human is frightened or excited.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: While viewing "Scary Movie" is the viewer likely to experience an increase in adrenaline?
Answer: "Scary Movie" is a parody film designed to elicit laughter. While some viewers may experience a slight increase in adrenaline due to the comedic suspense or jump scares, the primary physiological response would likely be related to amusement rather than fear. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning introduces the possibility of adrenaline increase due to comedic suspense or jump scares, which contradicts the reference's statement that the movie is intended to make viewers laugh but not afraid.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
While some viewers may experience a slight increase in adrenaline due to the comedic suspense or jump scares, the primary physiological response would likely be related to amusement rather than fear.
Explanation
The reference states that adrenaline is produced when a human is frightened or excited, and that Scary Movie is intended to make viewers laugh but not afraid. The generated reasoning suggests that viewers may experience a slight increase in adrenaline due to comedic suspense or jump scares, which contradicts the reference's intention that the movie is not intended to frighten viewers.
Answer Span:
While some viewers may experience a slight increase in adrenaline due to the comedic suspense or jump scares, the primary physiological response would likely be related to amusement rather than fear.
Reference/Question Span:
intended to make viewers laugh but not afraid. Adrenaline is produced when a human is frightened or excited.
Question #13
Would Marvel's Gateway be envious of the Doctor (Doctor Who)'s TARDIS machine?
1 issue
Full Question
Would Marvel's Gateway be envious of the Doctor (Doctor Who)'s TARDIS machine?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Doctor (Doctor Who) used the TARDIS, a largely unreliable time traveling machine, to travel through time and space. Gateway is a Marvel comic character linked to the X-Men comics. Gateway has the power to create wormholes that allow him to travel through time and space.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would Marvel's Gateway be envious of the Doctor (Doctor Who)'s TARDIS machine?
Answer: Gateway is a Marvel character who can create portals to teleport himself and others across vast distances. The TARDIS is a time machine and spacecraft that is much larger on the inside than it appears on the outside, and can travel through time and space. Since Gateway's powers are limited to teleportation, it is plausible that he would be envious of the TARDIS's time travel and significantly more advanced technology. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning incorrectly limits Gateway's powers, leading to a flawed conclusion. It misinterprets the reference information about Gateway's ability to travel through time and space.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorhigh
Statement
Since Gateway's powers are limited to teleportation, it is plausible that he would be envious of the TARDIS's time travel and significantly more advanced technology.
Explanation
The reference states that Gateway can travel through time and space using wormholes, not just teleportation. The generated reasoning incorrectly limits Gateway's powers to teleportation only, leading to the flawed conclusion that he would be envious of the TARDIS's time travel capabilities.
Answer Span:
Since Gateway's powers are limited to teleportation
Reference/Question Span:
Gateway has the power to create wormholes that allow him to travel through time and space.
Question #14
Is material from an aloe plant sometimes enclosed in petroleum-derived products?
Clean
Full Question
Is material from an aloe plant sometimes enclosed in petroleum-derived products?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Aloe vera gel is sometimes kept in plastic packaging. Plastic packaging is derived from petroleum.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is material from an aloe plant sometimes enclosed in petroleum-derived products?
Answer: Aloe vera gel is often sold in plastic bottles. Plastic is a petroleum-derived product. Therefore, aloe vera gel, a material from an aloe plant, is sometimes enclosed in petroleum-derived products. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, providing a clear and logical justification for the answer.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #15
Could a bee hummingbird balance a scale with a single pea on it?
1 issue
Full Question
Could a bee hummingbird balance a scale with a single pea on it?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The average pea weighs between 0.1 and 0.36 grams. Female bee hummingbirds on average weigh 2.6 grams, while on average male bee hummingbirds weigh 1.95 grams.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Could a bee hummingbird balance a scale with a single pea on it?
Answer: A bee hummingbird weighs less than a single pea. Therefore, it could not balance a scale with a pea on the other side. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains a factual error that contradicts the reference explanation. The reasoning is based on the incorrect premise that a bee hummingbird weighs less than a pea.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
A bee hummingbird weighs less than a single pea.
Explanation
The reference states that bee hummingbirds weigh between 1.95 and 2.6 grams, while a pea weighs between 0.1 and 0.36 grams. Therefore, a bee hummingbird weighs more than a pea, not less.
Answer Span:
A bee hummingbird weighs less than a single pea.
Reference/Question Span:
Female bee hummingbirds on average weigh 2.6 grams, while on average male bee hummingbirds weigh 1.95 grams. The average pea weighs between 0.1 and 0.36 grams.
Question #16
Would a broadcast from Spirit make the news in 2020?
1 issue
Full Question
Would a broadcast from Spirit make the news in 2020?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. In 2010, the Spirit rover sent what is recorded as its final transmission. In 2019, another rover made the news with its viral "final words".
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would a broadcast from Spirit make the news in 2020?
Answer: Spirit is the Mars Exploration Rover that landed on Mars in 2004. Communication with Spirit ceased in 2009. If there was a broadcast from Spirit in 2020, it would definitely make the news. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain contains a factual error regarding the year of Spirit's final transmission. The reference states 2010, while the generated reasoning states 2009.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Communication with Spirit ceased in 2009.
Explanation
The reference states that the final transmission from Spirit was in 2010, not 2009.
Answer Span:
Communication with Spirit ceased in 2009.
Reference/Question Span:
In 2010, the Spirit rover sent what is recorded as its final transmission.
Question #17
Would characters in Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone be persecuted as pagans?
1 issue
Full Question
Would characters in Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone be persecuted as pagans?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Pagans are defined as people that hold beliefs other than those of the major world religions (Christianity, Islam, and Judaism). The characters in Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone practice magic. Islam explicitly forbid the practice of magic and has harsh consequences for it. Jezebel in Hebrew scripture was a worshiper of pagan Baal and was thrown from a window for her beliefs. Women accused of being witches were burned alive by Christians during the Salem Witch Trials.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would characters in Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone be persecuted as pagans?
Answer: Paganism often involves magic and nature worship. The magic practiced in Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone is a core element of the world. Characters interact with magical creatures and perform spells. Some might consider this similar to pagan practices. However, the characters are not explicitly identified as pagans, and the wizarding world exists alongside the "Muggle" world, which is largely Christian. While the magical elements might be seen as "pagan" by some, there isn't a clear persecution of wizards *because* they're pagan within the context of the book. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning fails to recognize that the practice of magic is considered pagan and that throughout history, pagans have been persecuted for their beliefs. It incorrectly concludes that there is no clear persecution of wizards in the context of the book.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorhigh
Statement
However, the characters are not explicitly identified as pagans, and the wizarding world exists alongside the "Muggle" world, which is largely Christian. While the magical elements might be seen as "pagan" by some, there isn't a clear persecution of wizards *because* they're pagan within the context of the book.
Explanation
The reference explains that practicing magic is explicitly forbidden in Islam and that throughout history, people who practiced magic or were accused of witchcraft were persecuted. The generated reasoning states that there isn't a clear persecution of wizards because they're pagan within the context of the book, which is a misinterpretation of the reference.
Answer Span:
there isn't a clear persecution of wizards *because* they're pagan within the context of the book
Reference/Question Span:
Islam explicitly forbid the practice of magic and has harsh consequences for it. Jezebel in Hebrew scripture was a worshiper of pagan Baal and was thrown from a window for her beliefs. Women accused of being witches were burned alive by Christians during the Salem Witch Trials.
Question #18
Can music be used as a weapon?
Clean
Full Question
Can music be used as a weapon?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Music is an art form whose medium is sound. Music can help elevate or subdue emotions. People connect to music through the sound. The military uses loud music to cause psychological disorientation and confusion . The military calls the use of loud disorienting music part of psychological operations.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Can music be used as a weapon?
Answer: Music can be used as a form of psychological torture. Loud, jarring, or repetitive music has been used in interrogations and as a means of crowd dispersal. Therefore, since music can be used to inflict harm or achieve a strategic advantage, it can be considered a weapon in certain contexts. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that music can be used as a weapon, aligning with the reference explanation. The reasoning provided is consistent with the reference.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #19
Can Harry Potter book a flight on Asiana Airlines?
Clean
Full Question
Can Harry Potter book a flight on Asiana Airlines?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Asiana Airlines is the second largest airline in South Korea. Harry Potter is a fictional character.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Can Harry Potter book a flight on Asiana Airlines?
Answer: Harry Potter is a fictional character. Asiana Airlines is a real airline. Fictional characters cannot book real flights. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that Harry Potter is fictional and Asiana Airlines is real, leading to the correct conclusion that Harry Potter cannot book a flight on Asiana Airlines. The reasoning aligns perfectly with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #20
Karachi was a part of Alexander the Great's success?
1 issue
Full Question
Karachi was a part of Alexander the Great's success?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Karachi is a city in modern day Pakistan. Krokola was an ancient port located in what is now Karachi. Alexander the Great stationed his fleet in Krokola on his way to Babylon. Alexander the Great defeated Darius and conquered Babylon before expanding his empire.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was Karachi a part of Alexander the Great's success?
Answer: Karachi was founded in 1729. Alexander the Great died in 323 BCE. Since 1729 CE is after 323 BCE, Karachi could not have been a part of Alexander the Great's success. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains a factual error about the founding date of Karachi, which contradicts the reference explanation. This error leads to an incorrect conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Karachi was founded in 1729.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that Karachi was founded in 1729. However, the reference states that Krokola, an ancient port located in what is now Karachi, existed during the time of Alexander the Great.
Answer Span:
Karachi was founded in 1729
Reference/Question Span:
Krokola was an ancient port located in what is now Karachi
Question #21
Was Jackson Pollock trained by Leonardo da Vinci?
1 issue
Full Question
Was Jackson Pollock trained by Leonardo da Vinci?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Leonardo lived during the Italian Renaissance in the 17th century. Jackson Pollock lived during the 20th century.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was Jackson Pollock trained by Leonardo da Vinci?
Answer: Jackson Pollock (1912–1956) was an American painter. Leonardo da Vinci (1452–1519) was an Italian Renaissance artist. Given the gap in their lifespans, Jackson Pollock could not have been trained by Leonardo da Vinci. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning contains a factual error regarding the time period in which Leonardo da Vinci lived, misattributing him to the 17th century instead of the 15th/16th century.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Leonardo lived during the Italian Renaissance in the 17th century.
Explanation
The reference states that Leonardo lived in the 15th/16th century, not the 17th century.
Answer Span:
17th century
Reference/Question Span:
17th century
Question #22
Will The Exorcist stimulate limbic system?
Clean
Full Question
Will The Exorcist stimulate limbic system?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The limbic system of the brain contains regions that detect fear, control bodily functions and perceive sensory information. The Exorcist has been called one of the scariest movies of all time. The Exorcist ranked number 3 on the American Film Institute's 100 Years/100 Thrills list.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Will The Exorcist stimulate the limbic system?
Answer: The Exorcist is a horror film. Horror films are designed to evoke strong emotional responses, including fear and disgust. The limbic system is involved in processing emotions. Therefore, watching The Exorcist is likely to stimulate the limbic system. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly infers that The Exorcist will stimulate the limbic system based on its nature as a horror film designed to evoke strong emotional responses, which aligns with the reference explanation that the limbic system is involved in processing emotions and detecting fear.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #23
Would World War II have been the same without Alan Turing?
Clean
Full Question
Would World War II have been the same without Alan Turing?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. During WW2, the German Military used something called the Engima device to send messages secretly. Alan Turing broke the Enigma code, allowing German messages to be understood and intercepted.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would World War II have been the same without Alan Turing?
Answer: Alan Turing was a British mathematician and computer scientist who played a crucial role in breaking the German Enigma code during World War II. This breakthrough significantly impacted the Allied war effort, allowing them to anticipate German movements and strategies. Therefore, it's highly unlikely that World War II would have been the same without Alan Turing's contributions. His code-breaking work is widely credited with shortening the war and saving countless lives. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, highlighting Alan Turing's crucial role in breaking the Enigma code during World War II and its impact on the Allied war effort. There are no contradictions, entity swaps, or logical errors.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #24
Would a sophist use an épée?
Clean
Full Question
Would a sophist use an épée?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. A sophist is a specific kind of teacher in ancient Greece, in the fifth and fourth centuries BC. Sophists specialized in using the tools of philosophy and rhetoric, though other sophists taught subjects such as music, athletics and mathematics. An épée is a sword used in fencing. The épée was not developed until the 19th century.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would a sophist use an épée?
Answer: Sophists were ancient Greek teachers of rhetoric and philosophy. An épée is a fencing sword. Sophists existed centuries before the invention of the épée. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation and arrives at the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #25
Did Dale Jr hug his dad after their last Daytona 500 together?
Clean
Full Question
Did Dale Jr hug his dad after their last Daytona 500 together?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Dale Jr. and his father Dale Sr. last raced together at the Daytona 500 in 2001. During the 2001 Daytona 500 Dale Sr. suffered a basilar skull fracture and died.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did Dale Jr. hug his dad after their last Daytona 500 together?
Answer: Dale Earnhardt Jr.'s father, Dale Earnhardt Sr., died in a crash on the last lap of the 2001 Daytona 500. This was their last Daytona 500 together. Since Dale Jr.'s dad died during the race, they could not have hugged after. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that Dale Earnhardt Sr. died in a crash during the 2001 Daytona 500, which was their last race together, thus they could not have hugged after the race.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #26
Can citrus grow in Ulaanbaatar?
Clean
Full Question
Can citrus grow in Ulaanbaatar?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Citrus can withstand short periods down to as cold as −10 °C (14 °F), but realistically temperatures not falling below −2 °C (28 °F) are required for successful cultivation. Ulaanbaatar has an average annual temperature of −0.4 °C or 31.3 °F.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Can citrus grow in Ulaanbaatar?
Answer: Citrus trees require a warm climate. Ulaanbaatar has a subarctic climate with very cold winters, making it unsuitable for citrus cultivation. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that citrus trees require a warm climate and that Ulaanbaatar's subarctic climate is unsuitable for citrus cultivation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #27
Does New York Harbor sit on a craton without volcanic activity?
1 issue
Full Question
Does New York Harbor sit on a craton without volcanic activity?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. New York Harbor is located on Laurentia craton. The southwestern portion of Laurentia contains numerous large volcanic eruptions.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does New York Harbor sit on a cratonwithout volcanic activity?
Answer: New York Harbor is located on the North American craton. Cratons are generally stable and lack volcanic activity. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning incorrectly claims that cratons generally lack volcanic activity, contradicting the reference explanation which states that the southwestern portion of Laurentia contains numerous large volcanic eruptions.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Cratons are generally stable and lack volcanic activity.
Explanation
The reference states that the southwestern portion of Laurentia contains numerous large volcanic eruptions, contradicting the statement that cratons lack volcanic activity.
Answer Span:
Cratons are generally stable and lack volcanic activity.
Reference/Question Span:
The southwestern portion of Laurentia contains numerous large volcanic eruptions.
Question #28
Can the Palace of Westminster tell time in the dark?
1 issue
Full Question
Can the Palace of Westminster tell time in the dark?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The Palace of Westminster has Big Ben, a striking clock tower. Big Ben communicates the time via bells.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Can the Palace of Westminster tell time in the dark?
Answer: The Palace of Westminster houses the iconic clock tower, Big Ben. Big Ben, and the clock within it, are illuminated at night. Therefore, the Palace of Westminster *can* tell time in the dark. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning introduces the concept of illumination, which is not mentioned in the reference. The reference states that Big Ben communicates the time via bells.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorhigh
Statement
Big Ben, and the clock within it, are illuminated at night.
Explanation
The reference states that Big Ben communicates the time via bells, not by illumination. The generated reasoning introduces the concept of illumination, which is not mentioned in the reference.
Answer Span:
Big Ben, and the clock within it, are illuminated at night.
Reference/Question Span:
Big Ben communicates the time via bells.
Question #29
In teenagers and young adults with depression, are SSRI medications less safe than they are for adults?
Clean
Full Question
In teenagers and young adults with depression, are SSRI medications less safe than they are for adults?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. In teens, SSRI medications may increase the risk of suicidal thinking. In adults over 25, SSRI medications are regarded as generally safe.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: In teenagers and young adults with depression, are SSRI medications less safe than they are for adults?
Answer: SSRIs carry a black box warning for children, adolescents, and young adults due to an increased risk of suicidal thoughts and behaviors. While SSRIs can be effective in treating depression in these age groups, they require careful monitoring. The increased risk does not necessarily make them categorically "less safe" for younger individuals compared to older adults, but it does highlight the need for increased vigilance and a different risk/benefit assessment than when prescribing to adults. So, while they are not strictly less safe in terms of other side effects, the increased risk of suicidality in younger patients requires considering them differently in terms of safety. The answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, highlighting the increased risk of suicidal thoughts and behaviors in younger individuals taking SSRIs compared to adults. It correctly emphasizes the need for careful monitoring and a different risk/benefit assessment.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #30
Does Marco Rubio have a close relationship with Allah?
Clean
Full Question
Does Marco Rubio have a close relationship with Allah?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Marco Rubio adheres to the religious sect of Christianity known as Catholicism. Catholics and other Christians worship God. Allah is worshiped by believers of Islam.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does Marco Rubio have a close relationship with Allah?
Answer: Allah is the Arabic word for God. Marco Rubio is a practicing Catholic. Catholicism is a Christian religion. While both Christianity and Islam are Abrahamic religions that believe in one God, they have different theological interpretations. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly explains why Marco Rubio does not have a close relationship with Allah, based on his Catholic faith and the distinct theological differences between Christianity and Islam.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #31
Would Persephone be a good consultant to a landscape architect?
Clean
Full Question
Would Persephone be a good consultant to a landscape architect?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Persephone is a vegetation goddess. A vegetation deity is a nature deity whose disappearance and reappearance, or life, death and rebirth, embodies the growth cycle of plants. Landscape architects deal with planning and laying out gardens and other plant life.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would Persephone be a good consultant to a landscape architect?
Answer: In Greek mythology, Persephone is the goddess of spring growth. A landscape architect designs outdoor spaces, often incorporating plants. Given Persephone's association with vegetation and the cycle of seasons, she would likely have significant knowledge about plants and their growth, making her a potentially valuable consultant to a landscape architect. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, providing a logical justification for why Persephone would be a good consultant to a landscape architect.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #32
Is Argon near Neon on the periodic table of elements?
Clean
Full Question
Is Argon near Neon on the periodic table of elements?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Argon is a noble gas. Neon is a noble gas. The noble gases are all clumped together on the periodic table of elements.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is Argon near Neon on the periodic table of elements?
Answer: Argon (Ar) and Neon (Ne) are both in Group 18 (noble gases) of the periodic table. Neon is in period 2, while Argon is in period 3, placing them adjacent to one another in the same column. Therefore, the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately explains why Argon and Neon are near each other on the periodic table, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #33
Did Thomas Greenhill's parents violate the concept of monogamy?
1 issue
Full Question
Did Thomas Greenhill's parents violate the concept of monogamy?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Thomas Greenhill was a surgeon born to William and Elizabeth Greenhill. William and Elizabeth Greenhill had 39 children. Monogamy is a committed relationship between two people where usually they remain together for life. Thomas Greenhill was the last of his parents 39 children and was born shortly after his father died.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did Thomas Greenhill's parents violate the concept of monogamy?
Answer: Monogamy is defined as the state of being married to one person at a time. Thomas Greenhill was an illegitimate child, therefore his parents were not married. Since his parents were not married, the concept of monogamy does not apply. Therefore, the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain incorrectly states that Thomas Greenhill was an illegitimate child, contradicting the reference explanation. This leads to a flawed conclusion about monogamy not applying to his parents.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Thomas Greenhill was an illegitimate child, therefore his parents were not married.
Explanation
The reference states that Thomas Greenhill was born to William and Elizabeth Greenhill, implying they were married and that he was not illegitimate.
Answer Span:
Thomas Greenhill was an illegitimate child, therefore his parents were not married.
Reference/Question Span:
Thomas Greenhill was a surgeon born to William and Elizabeth Greenhill.
Question #34
Would it be uncommon for a high schooler to use the yellow pages?
Clean
Full Question
Would it be uncommon for a high schooler to use the yellow pages?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. High school students are between 14-19 years old. Teenagers now are considered 'digital natives'. 'Digital natives' are individuals who have grown up during the computer age, being exposed to technology from early childhood.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would it be uncommon for a high schooler to use the yellow pages?
Answer: Yellow pages are primarily used to find business contact information. High schoolers today primarily use the internet for information searches. Therefore, it would be uncommon for a high schooler to use the yellow pages. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that high schoolers primarily use the internet for information searches, making it uncommon for them to use the yellow pages. This aligns with the reference explanation that teenagers are 'digital natives' and exposed to technology from early childhood.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #35
Could an escapee swim nonstop from Alcatraz island to Siberia?
Clean
Full Question
Could an escapee swim nonstop from Alcatraz island to Siberia?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Alcatraz Island was a San Francisco Bay prison. Siberia is over 5,217 miles away from San Francisco. The longest continuous swim record was 139 miles.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Could an escapee swim nonstop from Alcatraz island to Siberia?
Answer: Alcatraz Island is located in the San Francisco Bay, off the coast of California. Siberia is located in Northeast Asia, separated from Alaska by the Bering Strait. The Pacific Ocean lies between Alcatraz and Siberia. It is physically impossible for a human to swim nonstop across the Pacific Ocean, even for a hypothetical escapee. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately explains why it is impossible to swim from Alcatraz to Siberia, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #36
Would the Titanic be well preserved at the bottom of the Gulf of Finland?
Clean
Full Question
Would the Titanic be well preserved at the bottom of the Gulf of Finland?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The bottom of the gulf is one of the world's largest ship cemeteries. Because of the low salinity and cold waters, and no shipworms, the ships are relatively well preserved. RMS Titanic was a British passenger ship.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would the Titanic be well preserved at the bottom of the Gulf of Finland?
Answer: The Titanic sank in the Atlantic Ocean. The Gulf of Finland is part of the Baltic Sea. Since the Titanic is not in the Gulf of Finland, it cannot be well preserved there. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that the Titanic is not in the Gulf of Finland, and therefore cannot be well-preserved there. This aligns with the reference explanation, which provides context about ship preservation in the Gulf of Finland but does not imply the Titanic is located there.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #37
Could a snowy owl survive in the Sonoran?
Clean
Full Question
Could a snowy owl survive in the Sonoran?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Snowy owl is a bird native to the Arctic regions of North America. Temperatures in the North American Arctic range from -36.4F to 50F. The Sonoran is one of the hottest deserts in the world. The Sonoran Desert can get as hot as 118F.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Could a snowy owl survive in the Sonoran Desert?
Answer: Snowy owls are adapted to cold, arctic climates. The Sonoran Desert is a hot, arid environment. The extreme heat of the Sonoran Desert would likely be fatal to a snowy owl, which lacks the adaptations to cope with such temperatures. Therefore, a snowy owl could not survive in the Sonoran Desert. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that a snowy owl could not survive in the Sonoran Desert due to the owl's adaptation to cold climates and the desert's extreme heat.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #38
Would a rabbi worship martyrs Ranavalona I killed?
Clean
Full Question
Would a rabbi worship martyrs Ranavalona I killed?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Rabbis are teachers of Judaism. Ranavalona I, ruler of Madagascar, killed many Christians that were later determined by the church to be martyrs. Judaism does not have a group of saints and martyrs that are prayed to like Christianity..
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would a rabbi worship martyrs Ranavalona I killed?
Answer: Rabbis are Jewish religious leaders. Ranavalona I persecuted Christians in Madagascar. A rabbi would not worship Christian martyrs. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation and arrives at the correct conclusion without any hallucinations.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #39
Would an oil painter avoid reds from scale insects that live on a cactus?
Clean
Full Question
Would an oil painter avoid reds from scale insects that live on a cactus?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Carmine is the product of an insect that lives on some cacti. Carmine is not stable in oil paints and its usage has been discontinued. Carmine is red.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would an oil painter avoid reds from scale insects that live on a cactus?
Answer: Reds made from scale insects, like carmine, are known to be fugitive, meaning they fade over time. Oil painters, particularly those creating works meant to last, would likely avoid such pigments due to their instability. While the cactus habitat of the insects is interesting, it doesn't directly affect the pigment's lightfastness, which is the primary concern for an oil painter. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that oil painters would avoid reds from scale insects due to their instability (fugitive nature) in oil paints.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #40
Was the Second Amendment to the United States Constitution written without consideration for black Americans?
Clean
Full Question
Was the Second Amendment to the United States Constitution written without consideration for black Americans?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The writers of the Constitutional Amendments did not view black people as legitimate human beings. The writers of the Constitutional Amendments believed that slavery benefited black slaves. The Constitutional Amendments were written for people that the writers considered human.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was the Second Amendment to the United States Constitution written without consideration for black Americans?
Answer: The United States Constitution, including the Second Amendment, was written at a time when slavery was legal and Black Americans were not considered full citizens. The framers of the Constitution largely viewed Black Americans as property, not as individuals with the same rights as white Americans. Therefore, it is accurate to say that the Second Amendment was written without consideration for the rights of Black Americans.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that the Second Amendment was written without consideration for Black Americans due to the prevailing views of the time.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #41
Are all the elements plants need for photosynthesis present in atmosphere of Mars?
1 issue
Full Question
Are all the elements plants need for photosynthesis present in atmosphere of Mars?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Plants need three elements for photosynthesis: Hydrogen, Oxygen, and Carbon. The atmosphere of Mars is composed of carbon dioxide, nitrogen, argon, and trace levels of water vapor, oxygen, carbon monoxide, hydrogen and other noble gases.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Are all the elements plants need for photosynthesis present in atmosphere of Mars?
Answer: Plants need light, water, and carbon dioxide for photosynthesis. While Mars's atmosphere contains carbon dioxide, it lacks sufficient liquid water and receives less sunlight than Earth. Therefore, not all elements necessary for photosynthesis are present in the atmosphere of Mars. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning introduces irrelevant factors (liquid water and sunlight) and incorrectly concludes that not all necessary elements are present in the atmosphere of Mars, contradicting the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorhigh
Statement
While Mars's atmosphere contains carbon dioxide, it lacks sufficient liquid water and receives less sunlight than Earth. Therefore, not all elements necessary for photosynthesis are present in the atmosphere of Mars.
Explanation
The reference states that plants need Hydrogen, Oxygen, and Carbon for photosynthesis, all of which are present in the atmosphere of Mars. The generated reasoning introduces the need for liquid water and sunlight, which are not elements and are not relevant to the question of whether the necessary elements are present in the atmosphere.
Answer Span:
While Mars's atmosphere contains carbon dioxide, it lacks sufficient liquid water and receives less sunlight than Earth. Therefore, not all elements necessary for photosynthesis are present in the atmosphere of Mars.
Reference/Question Span:
Plants need three elements for photosynthesis: Hydrogen, Oxygen, and Carbon. The atmosphere of Mars is composed of carbon dioxide, nitrogen, argon, and trace levels of water vapor, oxygen, carbon monoxide, hydrogen and other noble gases.
Question #42
Can you find Bob Marley's face in most smoke shops?
Clean
Full Question
Can you find Bob Marley's face in most smoke shops?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Bob Marley's face is on the packaging of a popular brand of rolling papers. Bob Marley is a popular graphic to print on t-shirts for sale to smokers.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Can you find Bob Marley's face in most smoke shops?
Answer: Bob Marley is a cultural icon associated with cannabis use. Smoke shops often sell paraphernalia related to cannabis consumption. Therefore, it is likely that images of Bob Marley's face would be found in many smoke shops. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly infers that Bob Marley's image is likely found in smoke shops due to his association with cannabis culture, which aligns with the reference explanation that his face is on rolling papers and t-shirts sold in such shops.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #43
Did Pablo Escobar's nickname collection outshine Robert Moses Grove's?
1 issue
Full Question
Did Pablo Escobar's nickname collection outshine Robert Moses Grove's?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Robert Moses Grove was a baseball player nicknamed Lefty Grove. Pablo Escobar had several nicknames including: Don Pablo, El Padrino, and El Patrón.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did Pablo Escobar's nickname collection outshine Robert Moses Grove's?
Answer: Pablo Escobar had nicknames such as "The King of Cocaine" and "Don Pablo." Robert Moses Grove, a baseball player, was nicknamed "Lefty" and "Old Mose." Escobar's nicknames reflect his notorious criminal enterprise, while Grove's are related to his athletic career. So, while subjective, it's likely Escobar's nicknames are more widely recognized and associated with a more impactful (though negative) figure, thus "outshining" Grove's in terms of notoriety. The answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning chain contains a factual error by including a nickname for Robert Moses Grove that is not mentioned in the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Robert Moses Grove, a baseball player, was nicknamed "Lefty" and "Old Mose."
Explanation
The reference explanation only mentions that Robert Moses Grove was nicknamed "Lefty Grove". The nickname "Old Mose" is not mentioned in the reference.
Answer Span:
"Lefty" and "Old Mose"
Reference/Question Span:
Lefty Grove
Question #44
Has the Subway restaurant franchise had any connections with child abusers?
Clean
Full Question
Has the Subway restaurant franchise had any connections with child abusers?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Subway hired Jared Fogle as a spokesman for their sandwich shops. Jared Fogle was convicted for having sex with minors and for possessing child pornography.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Has the Subway restaurant franchise had any connections with child abusers?
Answer: Subway was formerly represented by Jared Fogle. Fogle was convicted of child sex offenses and possession of child pornography. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. It correctly identifies Jared Fogle's association with Subway and his conviction for child sex offenses and possession of child pornography.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #45
Does autopilot rely on fossil fuels?
Clean
Full Question
Does autopilot rely on fossil fuels?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Autopilot is used in vehicles. Vehicles are powered by engines. Engines rely on fossil fuels to operate.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does autopilot rely on fossil fuels?
Answer: Autopilot systems are primarily used in aircraft and increasingly in cars. Most aircraft and the vast majority of cars currently run on fossil fuels. Thus, in its most common applications, autopilot relies on vehicles powered by fossil fuels. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that autopilot systems rely on fossil fuels because they are used in vehicles, which are powered by engines that rely on fossil fuels.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #46
Are psychiatric patients welcome to join the United States Air Force?
Clean
Full Question
Are psychiatric patients welcome to join the United States Air Force?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Having a history of mental illness disqualifies most people from joining the Armed Forces. Psychiatric patients are being seen for management of mental illness.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Are psychiatric patients welcome to join the United States Air Force?
Answer: Individuals with a history of psychiatric conditions, particularly those requiring ongoing treatment or medication, generally face significant challenges in joining the United States Air Force. The Air Force has stringent medical standards to ensure personnel can handle the demanding physical and psychological rigors of military service. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that individuals with a history of psychiatric conditions generally face significant challenges in joining the United States Air Force due to stringent medical standards.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #47
Does Nicole Kidman know any Scientologists?
Clean
Full Question
Does Nicole Kidman know any Scientologists?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Nicole Kidman was married to Tom Cruise. Tom Cruise is a Scientologist.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does Nicole Kidman know any Scientologists?
Answer: Nicole Kidman's ex-husband, Tom Cruise, is a prominent Scientologist. Therefore, it is highly likely that Nicole Kidman knows Scientologists. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation and provides a logical deduction.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #48
Was John Lennon known to be a good friend to Sasha Obama?
Clean
Full Question
Was John Lennon known to be a good friend to Sasha Obama?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. John Lennon died in 1980. Sasha Obama was born in 2001.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was John Lennon known to be a good friend to Sasha Obama?
Answer: John Lennon died in 1980. Sasha Obama was born in 2001. Since John Lennon died before Sasha Obama was born, they could not have been friends. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly uses the dates of John Lennon's death and Sasha Obama's birth to conclude that they could not have been friends.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #49
Would the tunnels at CERN fit onto the High Speed 1 rails?
Clean
Full Question
Would the tunnels at CERN fit onto the High Speed 1 rails?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. High Speed 1 (HS1), legally the Channel Tunnel Rail Link (CTRL), is a 67-mile (108 km) high-speed railway. The CERN collider is contained in a circular tunnel, with a circumference of 26.7 kilometres (16.6 mi). The circumference of a circle is the length of the enclosing boundary.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would the tunnels at CERN fit onto the High Speed 1 rails?
Answer: The Large Hadron Collider at CERN has a circumference of 27 kilometers. High Speed 1 is 108 kilometers long. The tunnel is much shorter than the length of the rails, so it could theoretically fit lengthwise. However, the question doesn't specify *how* the tunnel would be placed on the rails. The LHC tunnel's cross-section is much larger than the space between the rails, so it physically wouldn't fit. Therefore, the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly uses the lengths of the CERN collider and High Speed 1 to determine if the collider could fit on the rails. It also considers the cross-section of the tunnel, which is a valid point.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #50
Could an elephant easily defeat a male macaque?
Clean
Full Question
Could an elephant easily defeat a male macaque?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Male macaques range from 16 to 28 inches tall with a weight between 12.13 to 39.7 pounds. Elephants are between 7 to 11 feet tall and weigh several thousand pounds. Elephants contain large, sharp tusks that can injure or kill other animals.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Could an elephant easily defeat a male macaque?
Answer: Elephants are significantly larger and stronger than macaques. An elephant could easily crush a macaque. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that elephants are significantly larger and stronger than macaques and could easily crush them.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #51
Do the Ubuntu people speak Ubuntu?
Clean
Full Question
Do the Ubuntu people speak Ubuntu?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Ubuntu is a of free and open-source software used on computers. The Ubuntu people are a tribe that lives in Africa. The Ubuntu people derive their language from Nguni Bantu. As of 2019 only 10% of households in Africa have a computer.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Do the Ubuntu people speak Ubuntu?
Answer: Ubuntu is not a spoken language, it's the name of an operating system and a Nguni Bantu term. The Ubuntu people are a Nguni ethnolinguistic group, primarily in South Africa, and speak Nguni Bantu languages, not Ubuntu. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately explains why the Ubuntu people do not speak Ubuntu, aligning with the reference explanation. It correctly identifies Ubuntu as an operating system and the language of the Ubuntu people as Nguni Bantu.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #52
Is cycling a high-risk activity for pelvis fractures?
Clean
Full Question
Is cycling a high-risk activity for pelvis fractures?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Cycling is a low-impact activity . Stress fractures in a pelvic bone often develop as a result of repetitive, high-impact activity that puts stress on the pelvis, such as long-distance running or ballet.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is cycling a high-risk activity for pelvis fractures?
Answer: While cycling can result in falls, and falls can cause pelvis fractures, cycling is not generally considered a high-risk activity for this type of injury. Activities like contact sports, high-impact falls from heights, or motor vehicle accidents are more commonly associated with pelvic fractures. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that cycling is not generally considered a high-risk activity for pelvis fractures and providing examples of activities that are more commonly associated with such injuries.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #53
Is a platypus immune from cholera?
1 issue
Full Question
Is a platypus immune from cholera?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Cholera is a bacteria that damages the small intestines in humans. The intestines are part of the stomach of humans. A platypus does not have a stomach.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is a platypus immune from cholera?
Answer: Cholera is caused by bacteria. Platypuses are mammals and are susceptible to bacterial infections. Thus, a platypus is not immune from cholera. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning fails to connect the fact that platypuses lack a stomach to the fact that cholera affects the stomach, leading to an incorrect conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorhigh
Statement
Thus, a platypus is not immune from cholera.
Explanation
The reference states that cholera affects the small intestines, which are part of the stomach in humans. Platypuses do not have stomachs, therefore they are immune. The generated reasoning fails to make this connection and incorrectly concludes that platypuses are not immune.
Answer Span:
Thus, a platypus is not immune from cholera.
Reference/Question Span:
A platypus does not have a stomach.
Question #54
Would a moose hypothetically be too much for a minotaur to devour whole?
1 issue
Full Question
Would a moose hypothetically be too much for a minotaur to devour whole?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. A minotaur was a mythological beast with the head of a bull and body of a human. Human stomachs process about three to four pounds of food a day. A moose can weigh up to 1500 pounds. Bulls can consume around 33 pounds of food a day.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would a moose hypothetically be too much for a minotaur to devour whole?
Answer: A moose can weigh up to 1,800 lbs. A minotaur is a mythical creature, half man and half bull. While bulls are large and powerful, they are herbivores. Even assuming a carnivorous minotaur with enhanced eating capacity compared to a bull, 1,800 lbs of moose is a tremendous amount for any creature to consume in one sitting. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning contains a factual error regarding the weight of a moose, but the overall logic is sound.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionmedium
Statement
A moose can weigh up to 1,800 lbs.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that a moose can weigh up to 1,800 lbs, but the reference states that a moose can weigh up to 1500 pounds.
Answer Span:
1,800 lbs
Reference/Question Span:
1500 pounds
Question #55
Are there bones in an anchovy pizza?
Clean
Full Question
Are there bones in an anchovy pizza?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Anchovies used on pizza are typically packed whole in oil or water. Anchovies on pizza are not usually cut or filleted in any way.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Are there bones in an anchovy pizza?
Answer: Anchovies are small fish. Fish have bones. While some pizza makers may use anchovy fillets where larger bones have been removed, anchovies still contain smaller, more delicate bones. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that anchovies are small fish with bones and that they are typically used whole on pizzas, thus containing bones.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #56
Can a Bengal cat survive eating only pancakes?
Clean
Full Question
Can a Bengal cat survive eating only pancakes?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Bengal cats are carnivores. Pancakes contain no meat. Carnivores eat only meat to survive.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Can a Bengal cat survive eating only pancakes?
Answer: Pancakes do not contain the necessary nutrients for a cat to survive. Cats are obligate carnivores. This means their survival depends on nutrients found in meat. Because pancakes are not meat, a Bengal cat cannot survive eating only pancakes. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that Bengal cats are carnivores and cannot survive on a diet of pancakes, which lack the necessary nutrients found in meat.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #57
Can the original name of the zucchini be typed on the top row of a QWERTY keyboard?
1 issue
Full Question
Can the original name of the zucchini be typed on the top row of a QWERTY keyboard?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The original name for the zucchini in Mexican language or Nahuatl is ayokonetl. The top row of a QWERTY keyboard contains the keys q, w, e, r, t, y, u, i , o, and p.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Can the original name of the zucchini be typed on the top row of a QWERTY keyboard?
Answer: The original name of the zucchini is "zucchino." The letters in "zucchino" are z, u, c, c, h, i, n, o. The letters on the top row of a QWERTY keyboard are q, w, e, r, t, y, u, i, o, p. While u, i, and o appear in both "zucchino" and the top row, the letters z, c, h, and n do not. Therefore, "zucchino" cannot be typed using only the top row of a QWERTY keyboard. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain hallucinates the original name of the zucchini, which leads to an incorrect conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
entity_swaphigh
Statement
The original name of the zucchini is "zucchino."
Explanation
The original name of the zucchini is ayokonetl, not zucchino.
Answer Span:
"zucchino."
Reference/Question Span:
ayokonetl
Question #58
Does The Hague border multiple bodies of water?
1 issue
Full Question
Does The Hague border multiple bodies of water?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Hague is in the Netherlands. The Hague is in the Western part of the Netherlands. The Netherlands borders the North Sea to its west.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does The Hague border multiple bodies of water?
Answer: The Hague is on the coast of the North Sea. The Hague also borders multiple lakes and canals. Thus, The Hague borders multiple bodies of water. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain hallucinates that The Hague borders multiple lakes and canals, which is not mentioned in the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The Hague also borders multiple lakes and canals.
Explanation
The reference explanation only mentions that the Netherlands borders the North Sea to its west. It does not mention that The Hague borders multiple lakes and canals.
Answer Span:
The Hague also borders multiple lakes and canals.
Reference/Question Span:
The Netherlands borders the North Sea to its west.
Question #59
Do people in middle school usually get breast exams?
Clean
Full Question
Do people in middle school usually get breast exams?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Women should begin giving themselves breast exams at the age of 20. Middle school students are usually preteens or young teens.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Do people in middle school usually get breast exams?
Answer: Breast exams are typically recommended for adult women as a screening tool for breast cancer. People in middle school are children and adolescents, not yet adults. Therefore, routine breast exams are not typically part of healthcare for middle school students. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation and provides a logical justification for the answer.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #60
Did people in Korea under Japanese Rule watch a lot of Iron Chef?
Clean
Full Question
Did people in Korea under Japanese Rule watch a lot of Iron Chef?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The first televisions were sold in 1946. Iron Chef started airing in 1993.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did people in Korea under Japanese Rule watch a lot of Iron Chef?
Answer: Iron Chef premiered in 1993. Japanese rule in Korea ended in 1945. Therefore, people in Korea under Japanese rule could not have watched Iron Chef. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly uses the dates of Iron Chef's premiere and the end of Japanese rule in Korea to conclude that people in Korea under Japanese rule could not have watched Iron Chef.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #61
Would bald eagle deliver an urgent message before B-52?
1 issue
Full Question
Would bald eagle deliver an urgent message before B-52?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. A bald eagle can travel up to 99 MPH. The B-52 is a US air bomber that can travel up to 650 MPH.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would a bald eagle deliver an urgent message before a B-52?
Answer: A bald eagle is a bird. A B-52 is a strategic bomber. A bird is much faster than a strategic bomber. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains a factual error, stating that a bird is faster than a strategic bomber, which contradicts the reference explanation. This leads to an incorrect conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
A bird is much faster than a strategic bomber.
Explanation
This statement contradicts the reference explanation, which states that a B-52 can travel up to 650 MPH, while a bald eagle can travel up to 99 MPH. Therefore, the bomber is much faster than the bird.
Answer Span:
A bird is much faster than a strategic bomber.
Reference/Question Span:
A bald eagle can travel up to 99 MPH. The B-52 is a US air bomber that can travel up to 650 MPH.
Question #62
Does Snoopy look like Chance from Homeward Bound?
1 issue
Full Question
Does Snoopy look like Chance from Homeward Bound?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Chance from Homeward Bound is a golden retriever. Snoopy is black and white. Golden Retrievers are yellow in color.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does Snoopy look like Chance from Homeward Bound?
Answer: Snoopy is a beagle from the comic strip Peanuts. Chance from Homeward Bound is an American Bulldog. Since beagles and American Bulldogs are different breeds with distinct appearances, Snoopy does not look like Chance. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning incorrectly identifies Chance from Homeward Bound as an American Bulldog instead of a golden retriever, leading to a flawed comparison and conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
entity_swaphigh
Statement
Chance from Homeward Bound is an American Bulldog.
Explanation
Chance from Homeward Bound is a golden retriever, not an American Bulldog.
Answer Span:
Chance from Homeward Bound is an American Bulldog
Reference/Question Span:
Chance from Homeward Bound is a golden retriever
Question #63
Was Dioskourides a lapidary?
1 issue
Full Question
Was Dioskourides a lapidary?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. A lapidary is a person or machine who cuts gemstones; classically, it refers to a person who engraves gemstones. Dioskourides put his signature on a Roman amethyst ringstone with a portrait of Demosthenes circa late 1st century BC. Artists sign their work.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was Dioskourides a lapidary?
Answer: Dioskourides was a physician, pharmacologist and botanist. A lapidary is someone who cuts, polishes, or engraves gems. Therefore, Dioskourides was not a lapidary. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning incorrectly concludes that Dioskourides was not a lapidary based on his other professions, contradicting the reference which states he signed a ringstone, indicating he was also a lapidary.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorhigh
Statement
Dioskourides was a physician, pharmacologist and botanist.
Explanation
The generated reasoning uses Dioskourides's profession as a physician, pharmacologist, and botanist to incorrectly conclude that he was not a lapidary. The reference states that Dioskourides signed a Roman amethyst ringstone, indicating he was also a lapidary.
Answer Span:
Dioskourides was a physician, pharmacologist and botanist.
Reference/Question Span:
Dioskourides put his signature on a Roman amethyst ringstone with a portrait of Demosthenes circa late 1st century BC.
Question #64
Do most middle class families have butlers?
Clean
Full Question
Do most middle class families have butlers?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Butlers make about $60,000 per year on average for their work. Middle class income is between $48,000 and $145,000.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Do mostmiddle class families have butlers?
Answer: Butlers are typically employed by the wealthy. Middle class families generally do not have the financial resources to employ a butler. Therefore, mostmiddle class families do not have butlers. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation and arrives at the correct conclusion without any hallucinations.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #65
Was Hillary Clinton's deputy chief of staff in 2009 baptised?
Clean
Full Question
Was Hillary Clinton's deputy chief of staff in 2009 baptised?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Huma Abedin was Hillary Clinton's deputy chief of staff in 2009. Huma Abedin is an American Muslim. Baptism is a Christian tradition.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was Hillary Clinton's deputy chief of staff in 2009baptised?
Answer: Hillary Clinton's deputy chief of staff in 2009 was Huma Abedin. Huma Abedin is Muslim. Muslims are not typically baptised. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation and arrives at the correct conclusion without any hallucinations.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #66
Does the New York Public Library sell Alpo products?
Clean
Full Question
Does the New York Public Library sell Alpo products?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The New York Public Library is a public lending library system in New York City. Alpo produces pet food and related products.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does the New York Public Library sell Alpo products?
Answer: Alpo is a brand of dog food. The New York Public Library is a library system. Libraries lend books and other media. They do not typically sell pet food. Therefore, the New York Public Library does not sell Alpo products. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that the New York Public Library does not sell Alpo products, based on the fact that the library is a lending system and Alpo is a brand of dog food.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #67
Did Solomon make up bigger percentage of Islamic prophets than Kings of Judah?
1 issue
Full Question
Did Solomon make up bigger percentage of Islamic prophets than Kings of Judah?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. According to The Quran, Solomon was one of 25 prophets. According to some Islamic hadiths, there have been as many as 124,000 prophets. Solomon was one of 20 Kings of Judah.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did Solomon make up bigger percentage of Islamic prophets than Kings of Judah?
Answer: Solomon is considered a prophet in Islam. There are many Islamic prophets, including figures like Moses, Jesus, and Muhammad. Solomon is only one of them, so he represents a small percentage of the total number of Islamic prophets. Solomon was also a King of Judah. The number of Kings of Judah is far fewer than the number of Islamic prophets. Therefore, Solomon makes up a larger percentage of the Kings of Judah than the Islamic prophets. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning contains a logical error, leading to an incorrect conclusion. The generated reasoning incorrectly concludes that Solomon represents a larger percentage of Islamic prophets than Kings of Judah, contradicting the reference.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorhigh
Statement
Therefore, Solomon makes up a larger percentage of the Kings of Judah than the Islamic prophets.
Explanation
The reasoning is flawed. The reference states that Solomon was one of 25 prophets (or even one of 124,000 according to some hadiths) and one of 20 Kings of Judah. Therefore, Solomon represents a larger percentage of the Kings of Judah than the Islamic prophets.
Answer Span:
Therefore, Solomon makes up a larger percentage of the Kings of Judah than the Islamic prophets.
Reference/Question Span:
Solomon was one of 25 prophets. Solomon was one of 20 Kings of Judah.
Question #68
Would Taylor Swift refer to Snoopy as oppa?
1 issue
Full Question
Would Taylor Swift refer to Snoopy as oppa?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Oppa is a Korean word used by women to address a man who is 10 or more years older than her. Snoopy is 47 years old. Taylor Swift is 30 years old.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would Taylor Swift refer to Snoopy as oppa?
Answer: Oppa is a Korean honorific used by females to refer to older males. Taylor Swift is American. Snoopy is a cartoon dog. It's highly unlikely Taylor Swift would use a Korean honorific to refer to Snoopy. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning makes an incorrect assumption that Taylor Swift would not use a Korean honorific to refer to Snoopy, contradicting the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorhigh
Statement
It's highly unlikely Taylor Swift would use a Korean honorific to refer to Snoopy.
Explanation
The reference explanation states that Taylor Swift is 30 and Snoopy is 47, so she could refer to him as oppa. The generated reasoning incorrectly assumes that she would not use a Korean honorific to refer to Snoopy.
Answer Span:
It's highly unlikely Taylor Swift would use a Korean honorific to refer to Snoopy.
Reference/Question Span:
Oppa is a Korean word used by women to address a man who is 10 or more years older than her. Snoopy is 47 years old. Taylor Swift is 30 years old.
Question #69
Did Confederate States Army influence West Point fashion?
1 issue
Full Question
Did Confederate States Army influence West Point fashion?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The Confederate States Army was clad in cadet gray uniforms. West Point uniforms are cadet gray and white. Confederate States Army uniforms contained Generally, the uniform jacket of the Confederate soldier was single breasted, made of gray or brown fabric, with a six to nine button front and hat. West Point uniforms contain a standing collar, white trousers, and black shakos (known as a "tarbucket hat" in U.S. Army nomenclature).
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did Confederate States Army influence West Point fashion?
Answer: Many Confederate officers were graduates of West Point. After the Civil War, some aspects of Confederate uniforms and styles, such as the kepi and certain gray shades, were adopted into military fashion more broadly, sometimes influencing later West Point styles. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning contains a logical error by suggesting that West Point styles were influenced *after* the Civil War, while the reference implies that the influence was already present due to the Confederate army being clad in cadet gray uniforms, which is the same color as West Point uniforms.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
After the Civil War, some aspects of Confederate uniforms and styles, such as the kepi and certain gray shades, were adopted into military fashion more broadly, sometimes influencing later West Point styles.
Explanation
The reference states that West Point uniforms are cadet gray and white, and that Confederate uniforms were clad in cadet gray uniforms. The generated reasoning suggests that West Point styles were influenced *after* the Civil War, implying a later adoption. However, the reference implies that the influence was already present due to the Confederate army being clad in cadet gray uniforms, which is the same color as West Point uniforms.
Answer Span:
After the Civil War, some aspects of Confederate uniforms and styles, such as the kepi and certain gray shades, were adopted into military fashion more broadly, sometimes influencing later West Point styles.
Reference/Question Span:
The Confederate States Army was clad in cadet gray uniforms. West Point uniforms are cadet gray and white.
Question #70
Does conservatism repulse Blaire White?
Clean
Full Question
Does conservatism repulse Blaire White?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Blaire White is a Youtuber. Blaire White posts content that leans towards conservative politics.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does conservatism repulse Blaire White?
Answer: Blaire White is a transgender YouTube commentator who is politically conservative. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that Blaire White is politically conservative, aligning with the reference explanation. There are no hallucinations or errors in the reasoning.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #71
Do all parts of the aloe vera plant taste good?
1 issue
Full Question
Do all parts of the aloe vera plant taste good?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. There is a layer of yellow latex liquid between the outside of an aloe leaf and the gel inside. The latex inside aloe tastes very bitter.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Do all parts of the aloe vera planttaste good?
Answer: While the aloe vera plant's inner gel is known for its medicinal properties and is sometimes added to drinks, the outer parts, including the rind and latex, contain compounds that can be toxic and taste bitter or unpleasant. Therefore, not all parts of the aloe vera planttaste good. The answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that not all parts of the aloe vera plant taste good, but it incorrectly states that the outer parts are toxic, which is not mentioned in the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionmedium
Statement
the outer parts, including the rind and latex, contain compounds that can be toxic
Explanation
The reference explanation only mentions that the latex tastes bitter, not that the outer parts are toxic.
Answer Span:
contain compounds that can be toxic
Reference/Question Span:
The latex inside aloe tastes very bitter.
Question #72
Does an individual oceanographer study many sciences?
Clean
Full Question
Does an individual oceanographer study many sciences?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Study of the oceans involve many fields or science. To properly study their specific topic of research, an oceanographer must understand how their science interacts with the other involved sciences.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does an individual oceanographer study many sciences?
Answer: An oceanographer studies the ocean. The ocean encompasses many disciplines, including physics, chemistry, geology, and biology. Because an oceanographer's work can involve these different aspects of the ocean, they often draw upon multiple scientific fields. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that oceanographers study the ocean, which encompasses many disciplines, and therefore they often draw upon multiple scientific fields.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #73
Did Kurt Cobain's music genre survive after his death?
Clean
Full Question
Did Kurt Cobain's music genre survive after his death?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Kurt Cobain was the lead singer of Nirvana. Nirvana's music is classified as Grunge rock. Kurt Cobain died on April 5, 1994. Some of the major Grunge rock bands included Alice in Chains, Pearl Jam, and Soundgarden. Alice in Chains and Pearl Jam released their latest albums in 2018 and 2020 respectively.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did Kurt Cobain'smusic genre survive after his death?
Answer: Kurt Cobain was the lead singer and guitarist of the band Nirvana. Nirvana's music genre was grunge, a subgenre of alternative rock. Grunge music continued to be made and enjoyed by fans after Kurt Cobain's death in 1994. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. There are no contradictions or logical errors.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #74
Did Immanuel Kant ever meet the 14th president of the United States?
Clean
Full Question
Did Immanuel Kant ever meet the 14th president of the United States?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Immanuel Kant died on Feb 12, 1804. Franklin Pierce was the 14th president of the United States. Franklin PIerce was born Nov 23, 1804.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did Immanuel Kant ever meet the 14th president of the United States?
Answer: Immanuel Kant died in 1804. Franklin Pierce, the 14th president of the United States, was born in 1804. Therefore, Kant could not have met Pierce. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly states that Immanuel Kant died in 1804 and Franklin Pierce was born in 1804, leading to the correct conclusion that they could not have met.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #75
Would eliminating competition in the Japanese bulk carrier market be profitable for a steel company?
1 issue
Full Question
Would eliminating competition in the Japanese bulk carrier market be profitable for a steel company?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. 62% of bulk carriers are built in Japan. Bulk carrier hulls are made of steel.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would eliminating competition in the Japanese bulk carrier market be profitable for a steel company?
Answer: Bulk carriers are ships used to transport large quantities of unpackaged goods, like steel. Steel companies would likely supply steel to companies building bulk carriers. Eliminating competition in the Japanese bulk carrier market would likely decrease the demand for new bulk carriers, which would reduce the need for steel. This would likely decrease profits for a steel company. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning incorrectly assumes that eliminating competition would decrease demand for bulk carriers and steel, contradicting the likely outcome of increased profits and steel demand.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorhigh
Statement
Eliminating competition in the Japanese bulk carrier market would likely decrease the demand for new bulk carriers, which would reduce the need for steel.
Explanation
The reference states that 62% of bulk carriers are built in Japan and that bulk carrier hulls are made of steel. Eliminating competition would allow Japanese companies to charge more, increasing profits, and thus increasing steel demand.
Answer Span:
Eliminating competition in the Japanese bulk carrier market would likely decrease the demand for new bulk carriers, which would reduce the need for steel.
Reference/Question Span:
62% of bulk carriers are built in Japan. Bulk carrier hulls are made of steel.
Question #76
Would a geographer use biochemistry in their work?
Clean
Full Question
Would a geographer use biochemistry in their work?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. A geographer is a scientist whose area of study is geography, the study of Earth's natural environment and human society. Biochemistry is the study of chemical processes within and relating to living organisms.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would a geographer use biochemistry in their work?
Answer: Geographers study the earth and its features, inhabitants, and phenomena. Biochemistry is the study of chemical processes within and relating to living organisms. A geographer would be unlikely to employ biochemistry directly in their studies. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that geographers study the earth and its features, while biochemistry focuses on chemical processes in living organisms, making it unlikely for a geographer to directly use biochemistry in their studies.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #77
Is most coffee produced South of the Equator?
1 issue
Full Question
Is most coffee produced South of the Equator?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The countries with the highest coffee production are in South America. Almost all of South America is in the Southern Hemisphere.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is most coffee produced South of the Equator?
Answer: Most coffee production occurs in a region known as the Bean Belt. The Bean Belt spans the globe along the equator, with the vast majority of producing countries lying south of the equator. Thus, most coffee *is* produced south of the Equator. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning introduces the concept of the 'Bean Belt' which is not mentioned in the reference explanation, and incorrectly states that the vast majority of producing countries lie south of the equator. The reference explanation states that the countries with the highest coffee production are in South America, which is almost entirely in the Southern Hemisphere.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The Bean Belt spans the globe along the equator, with the vast majority of producing countries lying south of the equator.
Explanation
The reference states that the countries with the highest coffee production are in South America, which is almost entirely in the Southern Hemisphere. The generated reasoning states that the Bean Belt spans the globe along the equator, with the vast majority of producing countries lying south of the equator. This is a contradiction because the reference does not mention the Bean Belt.
Answer Span:
The Bean Belt spans the globe along the equator, with the vast majority of producing countries lying south of the equator.
Reference/Question Span:
The countries with the highest coffee production are in South America. Almost all of South America is in the Southern Hemisphere.
Question #78
Is it hard to get a BLT in Casablanca?
Clean
Full Question
Is it hard to get a BLT in Casablanca?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. A BLT is a sandwich consisting of bacon, lettuce and tomato. Casablanca is predominantly Muslim. Islam forbids the consumption of pork and pork products.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is it hard to get a BLT in Casablanca?
Answer: A BLT is a sandwich containing bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Casablanca is a predominantly Muslim city in Morocco. Pork products, like bacon, are not commonly consumed in Muslim cultures. Therefore, it is likely difficult to find the ingredients for a BLT in Casablanca, making it hard to get one. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation and provides a logical justification for the answer.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #79
Could largest ship from Voyages of Christopher Columbus haul Statue of Liberty?
2 issues
Full Question
Could largest ship from Voyages of Christopher Columbus haul Statue of Liberty?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The largest ship Christopher Columbus used was the Santa Maria. The Santa Maria has a cargo capacity of 108 tons. The Statue of Liberty weighs 225 tons.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Could the largest ship from the Voyages of Christopher Columbus haul the Statue of Liberty?
Answer: The Statue of Liberty weighs 450,000 lbs. The largest ship on Columbus's first voyage was the Santa María, which had a cargo capacity estimated between 200 and 250 toneladas. A tonelada is roughly equivalent to 2,000 lbs. This means the Santa María could carry between 400,000 and 500,000 lbs. Since this is greater than the weight of the Statue of Liberty, the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains factual errors regarding the cargo capacity of the Santa Maria and misrepresents the units of measurement for the Statue of Liberty's weight, leading to an incorrect conclusion.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
The Statue of Liberty weighs 450,000 lbs.
Explanation
The Statue of Liberty weighs 225 tons, which is equivalent to 450,000 lbs. However, the reference states the weight in tons (225 tons), not pounds.
Answer Span:
The Statue of Liberty weighs 450,000 lbs.
Reference/Question Span:
The Statue of Liberty weighs 225 tons.
contradictionhigh
Statement
which had a cargo capacity estimated between 200 and 250 toneladas
Explanation
The Santa Maria had a cargo capacity of 108 tons, not 200-250 toneladas.
Answer Span:
which had a cargo capacity estimated between 200 and 250 toneladas
Reference/Question Span:
The Santa Maria has a cargo capacity of 108 tons.
Question #80
Would Jolly Green Giant's largest monument look impressive next to Pyrenees?
Clean
Full Question
Would Jolly Green Giant's largest monument look impressive next to Pyrenees?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Jolly Green Giant monument in Blue Earth, Minnesota is 55.5 feet tall. The Pyrenees mountains are 11,168 feet high. The Pyrenees mountains are 305 miles wide.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would Jolly Green Giant's largest monument look impressive next to Pyrenees?
Answer: The Jolly Green Giant statue in Blue Earth, Minnesota is 55 feet tall. The Pyrenees mountain range has peaks that reach over 11,000 feet. Therefore, the Jolly Green Giant statue would be dwarfed by the Pyrenees and would not look impressive next to them. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation and arrives at the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #81
Did Karl Marx influence the communist party of China?
1 issue
Full Question
Did Karl Marx influence the communist party of China?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Communist ideology is the foundation of communist party of China. Marx produced a political pamphlet that has since come to be commonly known as the communist manifesto.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did Karl Marx influence the communist party of China?
Answer: The Communist Party of China’s ideology is officially Marxism-Leninism, a synthesis of Karl Marx’s ideas and those of Vladimir Lenin. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning chain contains a logical error by stating that the ideology is Marxism-Leninism, which is a synthesis of Karl Marx's ideas and those of Vladimir Lenin. This implies that Marx's ideas were not directly used, but rather a synthesis of his and Lenin's ideas were used, which is not stated in the reference.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
The Communist Party of China’s ideology is officially Marxism-Leninism, a synthesis of Karl Marx’s ideas and those of Vladimir Lenin.
Explanation
The reference states that communist ideology is the foundation of the communist party of China and that Marx produced the communist manifesto. The generated reasoning states that the ideology is Marxism-Leninism, which is a synthesis of Karl Marx's ideas and those of Vladimir Lenin. While this may be true, it is not stated in the reference and implies that Marx's ideas were not directly used, but rather a synthesis of his and Lenin's ideas were used.
Answer Span:
The Communist Party of China’s ideology is officially Marxism-Leninism, a synthesis of Karl Marx’s ideas and those of Vladimir Lenin.
Reference/Question Span:
Communist ideology is the foundation of communist party of China. Marx produced a political pamphlet that has since come to be commonly known as the communist manifesto.
Question #82
Does Soylent use Pea for their source of protein?
Clean
Full Question
Does Soylent use Pea for their source of protein?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Soylent is a meal replacement drink that offers 20mg protein. The protein in Soylent is derived from Soy.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does Soylent use Pea for their source of protein?
Answer: Soylent uses soy protein, not pea protein, as its primary source of protein. Therefore, the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that Soylent uses soy protein, not pea protein, as its primary source of protein, which aligns with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #83
Do most religious people in Quebec refer to the Quran?
Clean
Full Question
Do most religious people in Quebec refer to the Quran?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Christianity is the major religion in Quebec. Christians refer to the Bible as their book of reference.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Do most religious people in Quebec refer to the Quran?
Answer: The Quran is the central religious text of Islam. Quebec's population is largely Christian, with Catholicism being the most prevalent religion. Most religious people in Quebec would therefore refer to the Bible, not the Quran. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. It correctly identifies Christianity as the major religion in Quebec and the Bible as the primary religious text for Christians, leading to the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #84
Does Family Guy take place on the American West Coast?
Clean
Full Question
Does Family Guy take place on the American West Coast?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Family Guy takes place in the fictional town of Quahog, Rhode Island. Rhode Island is a state on the American East Coast.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does Family Guy take place on the American West Coast?
Answer: Family Guy takes place in Quahog, Rhode Island. Rhode Island is on the East Coast of the United States, not the West Coast. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that Family Guy takes place in Quahog, Rhode Island, which is on the East Coast, not the West Coast.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #85
Are lengths measured in metres in the UK?
Clean
Full Question
Are lengths measured in metres in the UK?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Metres are part of the metric system. The UK uses the metric system for measurements.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Are lengths measured in metres in the UK?
Answer: The UK uses the metric system, so lengths are measured in metres. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that the UK uses the metric system, which includes metres for measuring lengths.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #86
Did the first Duke of Valentinois play a key role in the Hundred Years' War?
Clean
Full Question
Did the first Duke of Valentinois play a key role in the Hundred Years' War?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Hundred Years' War was a conflict between England and France from 1337-1453. Cesare Borgia, the son of Pope Alexander VI, was the first Duke of Valentinois. Cesare Borgia was born in 1475.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did the first Duke of Valentinois play a key role in the Hundred Years' War?
Answer: The Hundred Years' War took place between 1337 and 1453. The first Duke of Valentinois was Cesare Borgia, who lived from 1475 to 1507. Since Cesare Borgia was born after the Hundred Years' War ended, he could not have played a key role in it. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that Cesare Borgia could not have played a role in the Hundred Years' War because he was born after it ended. The reasoning is sound and consistent with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #87
Do gorillas fight with panda bears?
Clean
Full Question
Do gorillas fight with panda bears?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Gorilla distribution is limited to areas of the continent of Africa. Panda bears are found in the wild only in China.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Do gorillas fight with panda bears?
Answer: Gorillas live in the forests of central Africa. Panda bears live in the mountains of central China. Since gorillas and panda bears live on different continents, they do not interact and therefore do not fight. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating the geographical locations of gorillas and panda bears and concluding that they do not interact or fight due to their different habitats.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #88
Was Christina Aguilera born in the forgotten borough?
Clean
Full Question
Was Christina Aguilera born in the forgotten borough?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Christina Maria Aguilera was born on December 18, 1980, in Staten Island, New York. Staten Island has sometimes been called "the forgotten borough" by inhabitants who feel neglected by the city government.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was Christina Aguilera born in the forgotten borough?
Answer: Christina Aguilera was born in Staten Island, New York. Staten Island is known as the forgotten borough. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. It correctly identifies that Christina Aguilera was born in Staten Island, which is known as the forgotten borough.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #89
Is H's most common two letter pair partner a freebie in Wheel of Fortune bonus round?
Clean
Full Question
Is H's most common two letter pair partner a freebie in Wheel of Fortune bonus round?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. H forms the most common two letter pair in the English language along with the letter T. The Wheel of Fortune bonus round gives the player six free letters: R, S, T, L, N, E.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is H's most common two letter pair partner a freebie in Wheel of Fortune bonus round?
Answer: The most common two letter pair partner for H is T. T is given as a free letter in the bonus round of Wheel of Fortune. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that the most common two-letter pair with H is T, and that T is a free letter in the Wheel of Fortune bonus round, thus accurately answering the question.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #90
Can a quarter fit inside of a human kidney?
1 issue
Full Question
Can a quarter fit inside of a human kidney?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Kidney stones are hard mineral deposits that can form in the kidneys. The largest kidney stone ever recorded was 13 cm wide. The diameter of a quarter is 2.4 cm.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Can a quarter fit inside of a human kidney?
Answer: A quarter has a diameter of 0.955 inches. A human kidney is about 4 inches long, 2 inches wide, and 1 inch thick. Since the smallest dimension of a kidney is larger than the diameter of a quarter, a quarter can fit inside a human kidney. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning chain contains a factual error regarding the diameter of a quarter. However, the overall logic is sound.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionmedium
Statement
A quarter has a diameter of 0.955 inches.
Explanation
The reference explanation states that the diameter of a quarter is 2.4 cm, which is approximately 0.94 inches. While close, the generated reasoning states the diameter is 0.955 inches, which is incorrect.
Answer Span:
0.955 inches
Reference/Question Span:
2.4 cm
Question #91
Does James Webb Space Telescope fail astronomer in locating planet Krypton?
Clean
Full Question
Does James Webb Space Telescope fail astronomer in locating planet Krypton?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The James Webb Space Telescope is the most powerful telescope created. Krypton is a planet in the fictional Superman comic book series.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does James Webb Space Telescope fail astronomer in locating planet Krypton?
Answer: Krypton is a fictional planet from DC Comics, the home world of Superman. The James Webb Space Telescope observes real celestial objects. Therefore, the James Webb Space Telescope would not be used to search for a fictional planet like Krypton. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that Krypton is a fictional planet and the James Webb Space Telescope observes real celestial objects, leading to the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #92
Was P. G. Wodehouse's favorite book The Hunger Games?
Clean
Full Question
Was P. G. Wodehouse's favorite book The Hunger Games?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. P. G. Wodehouse died in 1975. The Hunger Games was published in 2008.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was P. G. Wodehouse's favorite book The Hunger Games?
Answer: The Hunger Games was written by Suzanne Collins and published in 2008. P.G. Wodehouse died in 1975. Therefore, The Hunger Games could not have been P. G. Wodehouse's favorite book. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that P.G. Wodehouse could not have liked The Hunger Games because he died before it was published. The reasoning is sound and consistent with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #93
Should a finished website have lorem ipsum paragraphs?
Clean
Full Question
Should a finished website have lorem ipsum paragraphs?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Lorem Ipsum paragraphs are meant to be temporary. Web designers always remove lorem ipsum paragraphs before launch.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Should a finished website have lorem ipsum paragraphs?
Answer: A finished website is ready to be viewed by the public. Lorem ipsum is placeholder text. Placeholder text is used as a stand-in for actual content. A website that is finished should not contain placeholder text. Therefore, a finished website should not have lorem ipsum paragraphs. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly explains why a finished website should not have lorem ipsum paragraphs, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #94
Did William Shaespeare read the Daily Mirror?
Clean
Full Question
Did William Shaespeare read the Daily Mirror?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Daily Mirror is a British tabloid founded in 1903. William Shakespeare died in 1616.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did William Shakespeare read the Daily Mirror?
Answer: William Shakespeare died in 1616. The Daily Mirror was founded in 1903. Therefore, Shakespeare could not have read the Daily Mirror. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation, and it correctly concludes that William Shakespeare could not have read the Daily Mirror.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #95
Will more people go in and out of Taco Bell than a Roy Rogers each year?
Clean
Full Question
Will more people go in and out of Taco Bell than a Roy Rogers each year?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Taco Bell has over 7,072 restaurants as of 2018. Roy Rogers had over 600 restaurants at its peak. Roy Rogers has 48 locations as of 2019.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Will more people go in and out of Taco Bell than a Roy Rogers each year?
Answer: Taco Bell is a large, international fast-food chain. Roy Rogers is a much smaller regional chain. Therefore, it is highly likely that more people visit Taco Bell annually than Roy Rogers. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly infers that Taco Bell likely has more annual visitors than Roy Rogers based on the relative sizes of the chains, which aligns with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #96
Is it safe to wear sandals in snow?
Clean
Full Question
Is it safe to wear sandals in snow?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Sandals have open toes and don't completely cover the feet. Snow is very cold and direct exposure to skin can cause hypothermia. The feet need to be completely covered to walk through snow safely.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is it safe to wear sandals in snow?
Answer: Sandals offer minimal protection from the elements. Snow is cold and often wet. Wearing sandals in snow would expose one's feet to the cold and wet, potentially leading to frostbite or hypothermia. Therefore, it is not safe. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that wearing sandals in the snow is unsafe due to the exposure to cold and wet conditions, which can lead to frostbite or hypothermia.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #97
Was Nikola Tesla's home country involved in the American Civil War?
1 issue
Full Question
Was Nikola Tesla's home country involved in the American Civil War?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Nikola Tesla was born in the Austrian Empire. The American Civil War was a domestic American conflict.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was Nikola Tesla's home country involved in the American Civil War?
Answer: Nikola Tesla was born in Smiljan, Croatia. Croatia was part of the Austro-Hungarian Empire at the time. The American Civil War was an internal conflict within the United States. The Austro-Hungarian Empire was not involved in the American Civil War. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain contains an entity swap, stating Tesla was born in Croatia instead of the Austrian Empire. The rest of the reasoning is correct.
Detected Issues (1)
entity_swaphigh
Statement
Nikola Tesla was born in Smiljan, Croatia.
Explanation
The reference states that Nikola Tesla was born in the Austrian Empire, not Croatia.
Answer Span:
Smiljan, Croatia
Reference/Question Span:
Austrian Empire
Question #98
Did Ada Lovelace die tragically young for her era?
Clean
Full Question
Did Ada Lovelace die tragically young for her era?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Ada Lovelace died at the age of 36 in 1852. The life expectancy in the 1800s was between 35 and 39 years old. Tuberculosis was one of the leading causes of death in the 1800s and a vaccine was not made until the 1900s.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did Ada Lovelace die tragically young for her era?
Answer: Ada Lovelace died at age 36. The average life expectancy for women in the Victorian era (Lovelace's time) was about 40 years. While dying at 36 is certainly young, it wasn't drastically shorter than the average life expectancy for her time. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. It correctly states Ada Lovelace's age at death and compares it to the average life expectancy of the time, concluding that her death, while young, was not drastically shorter than average.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #99
Can an Asian black bear use chopsticks?
1 issue
Full Question
Can an Asian black bear use chopsticks?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Asian black bear are a species of bear found in asia. Asian black bear don't have opposable thumbs. Chopsticks are eating utensils use requires opposable thumbs.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Can an Asian black bear use chopsticks?
Answer: Chopsticks require a certain level of dexterity and fine motor control to use effectively. Bears, while intelligent, have paws designed for powerful actions like digging, climbing, and swatting, not delicate manipulation. Therefore, it is highly unlikely that an Asian black bear could use chopsticks. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning provides a plausible but ultimately incorrect explanation for why an Asian black bear cannot use chopsticks. It focuses on dexterity rather than the lack of opposable thumbs, which is the key factor mentioned in the reference.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
Bears, while intelligent, have paws designed for powerful actions like digging, climbing, and swatting, not delicate manipulation.
Explanation
The reference states that Asian black bears don't have opposable thumbs, which is the reason they cannot use chopsticks. The generated reasoning focuses on dexterity and fine motor control, which is a misinterpretation of the core reason.
Answer Span:
Bears, while intelligent, have paws designed for powerful actions like digging, climbing, and swatting, not delicate manipulation.
Reference/Question Span:
Asian black bear don't have opposable thumbs.
Question #100
Can someone sell their time through the Toronto Star?
Clean
Full Question
Can someone sell their time through the Toronto Star?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The Toronto Star has a classifieds section. Readers can advertise their own labor or services and thus their time .
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Can someone sell their time through the Toronto Star?
Answer: The Toronto Star is a newspaper. Newspapers sell advertising space. People selling time are offering services. Therefore, someone could buy advertising space in the Toronto Star to sell their time/services. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, providing a logical and correct justification for the answer.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #101
Were deaths from Apollo 13 mission eclipsed by other space missions?
1 issue
Full Question
Were deaths from Apollo 13 mission eclipsed by other space missions?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Apollo 13 was a failed Moon landing in which the crew had faulty oxygen resources. All of the Apollo 13 crew returned safely to earth. The Challenger was a space shuttle that malfunctioned, killing all seven passengers. The Space Shuttle Columbia disaster had seven casualties.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Were deaths from Apollo 13 mission eclipsed by other space missions?
Answer: The Apollo 13 mission, while experiencing a significant malfunction, resulted in no deaths. Other space missions, such as the Challenger and Columbia shuttle disasters, resulted in the deaths of all crew members. Therefore, the Apollo 13 mission had zero deaths, a number not eclipsed by the death tolls of these other missions. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains a logical error in interpreting the question, leading to an incorrect conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorhigh
Statement
Therefore, the Apollo 13 mission had zero deaths, a number not eclipsed by the death tolls of these other missions.
Explanation
The question asks if the deaths from Apollo 13 were eclipsed by other missions. Since there were zero deaths in Apollo 13, any mission with deaths would eclipse it. The reasoning here misinterprets the question.
Answer Span:
Therefore, the Apollo 13 mission had zero deaths, a number not eclipsed by the death tolls of these other missions.
Reference/Question Span:
All of the Apollo 13 crew returned safely to earth. The Challenger was a space shuttle that malfunctioned, killing all seven passengers. The Space Shuttle Columbia disaster had seven casualties.
Question #102
Can you purchase a dish with injera at Taco Bell?
Clean
Full Question
Can you purchase a dish with injera at Taco Bell?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Taco Bell serves a variety of Mexican and Tex-Mex foods that include tacos, burritos, quesadillas, and nachos. Injera is a sour fermented flatbread with a slightly spongy texture, traditionally made out of teff flour. Injera is part of Ethiopian cuisine.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Can you purchase a dish with injera at Taco Bell?
Answer: Injera is a spongy flatbread made from teff flour and is a staple in Eritrean and Ethiopian cuisine. Taco Bell is a fast-food restaurant chain that specializes in Tex-Mex cuisine. Since Taco Bell's menu does not include dishes featuring ingredients from East African cuisine, such as injera, the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. It correctly identifies injera as part of Eritrean and Ethiopian cuisine and Taco Bell as a Tex-Mex restaurant, concluding that Taco Bell would not serve injera.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #103
Is xenophobia hypothetically unimportant between Saladin and Ali Askari?
1 issue
Full Question
Is xenophobia hypothetically unimportant between Saladin and Ali Askari?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Xenophobia is the dislike of someone that is foreign or from a different background. Saladin was a Kurdish leader that became sultan of Egypt. Ali Askari was a Kurdish politician.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is xenophobia hypothetically unimportant between Saladin and Ali Askari?
Answer: Xenophobia is the fear and hatred of strangers or foreigners or of anything that is strange or foreign. Saladin was a Kurdish Muslim and Ali Askari was an Iraqi Shia Muslim. Since they shared similar cultural and religious backgrounds, xenophobia would likely be unimportant between them. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains a significant factual error by misidentifying Ali Askari as an Iraqi Shia Muslim instead of a Kurdish politician, which is a critical detail for assessing the potential for xenophobia between him and Saladin.
Detected Issues (1)
entity_swaphigh
Statement
Ali Askari was an Iraqi Shia Muslim.
Explanation
The reference states that Ali Askari was a Kurdish politician, not an Iraqi Shia Muslim.
Answer Span:
Ali Askari was an Iraqi Shia Muslim
Reference/Question Span:
Ali Askari was a Kurdish politician
Question #104
Does Sockington enjoy onions?
Clean
Full Question
Does Sockington enjoy onions?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Sockington is a domestic cat. Onions can cause toxicity in cats by breaking down their red blood cells.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does Sockington enjoy onions?
Answer: Sockington is a cat. Cats generally do not enjoy onions. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that Sockington is a cat and that cats generally do not enjoy onions, which aligns with the reference explanation that onions can be toxic to cats.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #105
Was Raphael's paintings influenced by the country of Guam?
Clean
Full Question
Was Raphael's paintings influenced by the country of Guam?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Raphael was a European painter that died in 1520. Magellan's 1521 voyage was Europe's first trip to Guam.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was Raphael's paintings influenced by the country of Guam?
Answer: Raphael lived from 1483 to 1520. Guam was discovered by Europeans in 1521. Since Raphael died the year before Guam's European discovery, his paintings could not have been influenced by it. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, providing a clear and logical argument to support the answer. There are no hallucinations or errors in the reasoning.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #106
Could Oscar Wilde have operated a motor vehicle?
Clean
Full Question
Could Oscar Wilde have operated a motor vehicle?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Motor vehicles were in use by the 1890s. Oscar Wilde lived until 1900.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Could Oscar Wilde have operated a motor vehicle?
Answer: Oscar Wilde died in 1900. The first commercially available motor vehicle was the 1886 Benz Patent-Motorwagen. Since 1886 is before 1900, it is possible that Oscar Wilde could have operated a motor vehicle. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that Oscar Wilde could have operated a motor vehicle because he lived until 1900, which is after the invention of the first commercially available motor vehicle in 1886. The reasoning is sound and aligns with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #107
Does ontology require a scalpel?
Clean
Full Question
Does ontology require a scalpel?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. A scalpel is used during surgery. Ontology is a philosophical domain, not a medical one.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does ontology require a scalpel?
Answer: Ontology is the branch of metaphysics dealing with the nature of being. A scalpel is a small and extremely sharp bladed instrument used for surgery, anatomical dissection, and various arts and crafts. Since ontology is a philosophical pursuit and a scalpel is a physical tool used in medical and other practical applications, the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately explains why ontology does not require a scalpel, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #108
Was King Arthur at the beheading of Anne Boleyn?
Clean
Full Question
Was King Arthur at the beheading of Anne Boleyn?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. King Arthur was a legendary British leader who, according to medieval histories and romances, led the defence of Britain against Saxon invaders in the late 5th and early 6th centuries. Anne Boleyn was beheaded May 19, 1536.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was King Arthur at the beheading of Anne Boleyn?
Answer: Anne Boleyn was beheaded in 1536. King Arthur is a legendary figure who, if he existed, would have lived centuries earlier. Therefore, King Arthur could not have been present at Anne Boleyn's beheading. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that King Arthur could not have been at Anne Boleyn's beheading because they lived in different time periods, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #109
Would Alexander Graham Bell hypothetically support Nazi eugenics?
Clean
Full Question
Would Alexander Graham Bell hypothetically support Nazi eugenics?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Eugenics was the idea of selective breeding or sterilization to rid the human populace of certain traits. Nazis used eugenics to justify mass sterilization and mass murder. Alexander Graham Bell Alexander Graham Bell advocated against the use of sign language and hoped to eradicate deafness through selective breeding.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would Alexander Graham Bell hypothetically support Nazi eugenics?
Answer: Alexander Graham Bell was a proponent of eugenics. Nazi eugenics was based upon the same principles as Bell's beliefs. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. It correctly identifies Alexander Graham Bell as a proponent of eugenics and draws a parallel between his beliefs and the principles underlying Nazi eugenics.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #110
Was Harry Truman's presidency unaffected by the twenty-third Amendment to the US Constitution?
Clean
Full Question
Was Harry Truman's presidency unaffected by the twenty-third Amendment to the US Constitution?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The 23rd Amendment to the US Constitution was passed in 1961. Harry Truman was the President from 1945-1953.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was Harry Truman's presidency unaffected by the twenty-third Amendment to the US Constitution?
Answer: The Twenty-third Amendment grants the District of Columbia electors in the Electoral College. The Twenty-third Amendment was ratified in 1961. Harry Truman's presidency ended in 1953. Therefore, his presidency was unaffected by the Twenty-third Amendment. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that Harry Truman's presidency was unaffected by the Twenty-third Amendment because the amendment was ratified after his presidency ended. The reasoning is clear, concise, and accurate.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #111
Would the trees in Auburn, New York be changing colors in September?
Clean
Full Question
Would the trees in Auburn, New York be changing colors in September?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. In New York, fall begins during the month of September. When the weather gets cooler in the fall, leaves begin to change colors.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would the trees in Auburn, New York be changing colors in September?
Answer: Auburn, New York is located in the northeastern United States. September marks the beginning of fall in the northeast. Trees in the northeast are known for their vibrant fall foliage. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, providing a logical and factually correct justification for the answer. There are no hallucinations or errors present.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #112
Is Black Lives Matter connected with capsaicin?
1 issue
Full Question
Is Black Lives Matter connected with capsaicin?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Black Lives Matter has held numerous protests. Protesters at Black Lives Matter events have had pepper spray used against them by police. Capsaicin is the main ingredient of pepper spray.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is Black Lives Matter connected with capsaicin?
Answer: Black Lives Matter is a social movement advocating for racial equality. Capsaicin is a chemical compound found in chili peppers. There is no known connection between Black Lives Matter and capsaicin. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain incorrectly states that there is no connection between Black Lives Matter and capsaicin, contradicting the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
There is no known connection between Black Lives Matter and capsaicin.
Explanation
The reference states that Black Lives Matter protesters have had pepper spray (whose main ingredient is capsaicin) used against them by police, which establishes a connection.
Answer Span:
There is no known connection between Black Lives Matter and capsaicin.
Reference/Question Span:
Protesters at Black Lives Matter events have had pepper spray used against them by police. Capsaicin is the main ingredient of pepper spray.
Question #113
Was Achilles a direct descendent of Gaia?
1 issue
Full Question
Was Achilles a direct descendent of Gaia?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Achilles was the son of a Nereid. The Nereids were the 50 daughters of Nereus. Nereus was the eldest son of the union between Gaia and Pontus.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was Achilles a direct descendant of Gaia?
Answer: Achilles's mother was Thetis, a sea nymph. Thetis's parents were Nereus and Doris, who were children of Oceanus and Tethys. Oceanus and Tethys were Titans, children of Gaia and Uranus. Since Achilles's maternal great-grandparents were children of Gaia, Achilles was a descendant, though not a *direct* descendant, of Gaia. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain incorrectly identifies Achilles's mother as Thetis instead of a Nereid, leading to a flawed lineage tracing and ultimately a wrong conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
entity_swaphigh
Statement
Achilles's mother was Thetis, a sea nymph.
Explanation
The reference states that Achilles was the son of a Nereid, not Thetis.
Answer Span:
Achilles's mother was Thetis
Reference/Question Span:
Achilles was the son of a Nereid
Question #114
Does Jerry Seinfeld hang out at the Budweiser Party Deck?
1 issue
Full Question
Does Jerry Seinfeld hang out at the Budweiser Party Deck?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Budweiser Party Deck is a social gathering spot in Yankee Stadium. Yankee Stadium is home to the New York Yankees baseball team. Jerry Seinfeld is a fan of the New York Mets.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does Jerry Seinfeld hang out at the Budweiser Party Deck?
Answer: Jerry Seinfeld is a comedian and actor. The Budweiser Party Deck is located at Busch Stadium in St. Louis. There's no publicly available information connecting Jerry Seinfeld to the Budweiser Party Deck. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning incorrectly states the location of the Budweiser Party Deck, claiming it's in Busch Stadium instead of Yankee Stadium.
Detected Issues (1)
entity_swaphigh
Statement
The Budweiser Party Deck is located at Busch Stadium in St. Louis.
Explanation
The Budweiser Party Deck is located in Yankee Stadium, not Busch Stadium.
Answer Span:
Busch Stadium in St. Louis
Reference/Question Span:
Yankee Stadium
Question #115
Can you hide a basketball in a sand cat's ear?
Clean
Full Question
Can you hide a basketball in a sand cat's ear?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The diameter of a standard NBA basketball is around 9.5 inches. A sand cat's ear grows to 2.8 inches tall.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Can you hide a basketball in a sand cat's ear?
Answer: A basketball is significantly larger than a sand cat's ear. Therefore, you cannot hide a basketball in a sand cat's ear. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that a basketball is significantly larger than a sand cat's ear, thus it cannot be hidden inside.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #116
Could the Spice Girls compete against ŽRK Kumanovo?
Clean
Full Question
Could the Spice Girls compete against ŽRK Kumanovo?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Spice Girls had 5 members. ŽRK Kumanovo is a women's handball club from Kumanovo in the Republic of Macedonia. Handball is a sport played by two teams of seven players each.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Could the Spice Girls compete against ŽRK Kumanovo?
Answer: The Spice Girls are a British pop group. ŽRK Kumanovo is a professional handball team. Since the Spice Girls are singers and ŽRK Kumanovo are athletes in a completely different field, they could not compete against each other. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that the Spice Girls and ŽRK Kumanovo are in completely different fields (music vs. professional handball) and therefore could not compete against each other. This aligns with the reference explanation, which states that ŽRK Kumanovo is a women's handball club and the Spice Girls had 5 members, implying they are not a handball team.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #117
Does the swastika have positive uses?
1 issue
Full Question
Does the swastika have positive uses?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The swastika is used in the Hindu religion to represent the sun. People practicing Hindu believe the swastika represents prosperity and good luck.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does the swastika have positive uses?
Answer: The swastika symbol has been used for over 3,000 years and in many cultures represents good fortune and well-being. In Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, and other Eastern religions, the swastika continues to be a sacred symbol associated with positive meanings. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning chain includes information not present in the reference explanation, specifically mentioning Buddhism, Jainism, and other Eastern religions, which constitutes a logical error.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
In Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, and other Eastern religions, the swastika continues to be a sacred symbol associated with positive meanings.
Explanation
The reference only mentions Hinduism. The inclusion of Buddhism, Jainism, and other Eastern religions is not supported by the reference and implies a broader scope than what is provided.
Answer Span:
In Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, and other Eastern religions, the swastika continues to be a sacred symbol associated with positive meanings.
Reference/Question Span:
the swastika is used in the Hindu religion to represent the sun.
Question #118
Was Black fly upstaged by another insect in Jeff Goldblum's 1986 film?
1 issue
Full Question
Was Black fly upstaged by another insect in Jeff Goldblum's 1986 film?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Jeff Goldnlum starred in the 1986 movie The Fly. The fly used in the movie The Fly was a common Housefly. The Black fly is most closely related to Chironomidae since they both feed on mammals.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was Black fly upstaged by another insect in Jeff Goldblum's1986 film?
Answer: Jeff Goldblum starred in "The Fly" in 1986. In the film, he transforms into a fly-like creature. While referred to as "Brundlefly," the creature is not specifically a black fly, and the transformation focuses on a hybrid human-fly creature. Therefore, there isn't another insect upstaging a black fly, making the answer {false}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning contains a logical error by misinterpreting the type of fly used in the movie, as specified in the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
In the film, he transforms into a fly-like creature. While referred to as "Brundlefly," the creature is not specifically a black fly, and the transformation focuses on a hybrid human-fly creature.
Explanation
The reference states that the fly used in the movie was a common Housefly. The generated reasoning misinterprets this fact by stating that the creature is not specifically a black fly, implying that it could be some other type of fly, when the reference specifies it was a common Housefly.
Answer Span:
the creature is not specifically a black fly
Reference/Question Span:
The fly used in the movie The Fly was a common Housefly.
Question #119
Did Linnaeus edit Darwin's draft of Origin of Species?
Clean
Full Question
Did Linnaeus edit Darwin's draft of Origin of Species?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Linnaeus died in 1778. Origin of Species was published in 1859.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did Linnaeus edit Darwin's draft of Origin of Species?
Answer: Carl Linnaeus died in 1778. Darwin's On the Origin of Species was published in 1859. Therefore, Linnaeus could not have edited Darwin's work. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that Linnaeus could not have edited Darwin's work because Linnaeus died before Darwin's work was published. The reasoning is sound and consistent with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #120
Do all cancer patients get disability?
Clean
Full Question
Do all cancer patients get disability?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. All forms of cancer qualify as diagnoses that can result in disability. Disability is not determined by diagnosis, but by degree of impairment. Some cancer patients do not experience major impairment.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Do allcancer patients get disability?
Answer: Not allcancer patients qualify for disability. Disability benefits are typically awarded based on the severity of the illness and its impact on the individual's ability to work. Some cancer patients may have less aggressive forms of cancer or respond well to treatment, allowing them to continue working. Therefore, while some cancer patients may qualify for disability, it is not a guarantee for all patients.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that not all cancer patients qualify for disability because disability is determined by the degree of impairment, not just the diagnosis.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #121
Did the death of Helen Palmer have a significant effect on Dr. Seuss?
Clean
Full Question
Did the death of Helen Palmer have a significant effect on Dr. Seuss?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Dr. Seuss's real name was Theodor Geisel. Theodor Geisel was married to Helen Palmer at the time of her suicide. Theodor Geisel is quoted having said he considered suicide after the death of his wife.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did the death of Helen Palmer have a significant effect on Dr. Seuss?
Answer: Helen Palmer Geisel was Dr. Seuss' first wife. She suffered from illnesses for many years, and after being diagnosed with a brain tumor, she took her own life in 1967. Dr. Seuss blamed himself for her suffering and her death, and it had a profound impact on him. He remarried the following year, but many believe his later works reflect the sadness and guilt he carried after Helen's death. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. It correctly identifies Helen Palmer as Dr. Seuss' first wife, mentions her suicide, and highlights the profound impact it had on Dr. Seuss. There are no contradictions, entity swaps, or logical errors present.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #122
Can fish get Tonsillitis?
Clean
Full Question
Can fish get Tonsillitis?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Tonsils are a pair of soft tissue masses located at the rear of the throat. Tonsillitis is the inflammation of tonsils. Fish do not have tonsils. Tonsils are only found in mammals.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Can fish get Tonsillitis?
Answer: Tonsillitis is the inflammation of the tonsils. Fish do not have tonsils. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation, stating that fish do not have tonsils and therefore cannot get tonsillitis.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #123
Would it be impossible to get to Burning Man on the Mayflower?
Clean
Full Question
Would it be impossible to get to Burning Man on the Mayflower?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The Mayflower was a seafaring vessel. Burning Man is held in Black Rock Desert. There are no bodies of water flowing into the Black Rock Desert.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would it be impossible to get to Burning Man on the Mayflower?
Answer: Burning Man is an annual event held in the Black Rock Desert of Nevada. The Mayflower was a 17th-century ship that transported the Pilgrims to North America. Given the vastly different time periods and locations of Burning Man and the voyage of the Mayflower, it would be impossible to travel to the event on that ship. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies the impossibility of traveling to Burning Man on the Mayflower, citing the different time periods and locations. The reasoning aligns with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #124
Does Lupita Nyongo have citizenship in paternal Family of Barack Obama's origin country?
Clean
Full Question
Does Lupita Nyongo have citizenship in paternal Family of Barack Obama's origin country?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Actress Lupita Nyongo has dual citizenship in Kenya and Mexico. Barack Obama's father was born in Nyang’oma Kogelo, Rachuonyo District, Kenya Colony. Barack Obama's father was a Kenyan of the Luo tribe.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does Lupita Nyong'o have citizenship in Barack Obama's paternal Family's origin country?
Answer: Lupita Nyong'o was born in Mexico City, but both of her parents are Kenyan. Lupita Nyong'o holds dual citizenship in Kenya and Mexico. Barack Obama's paternal family originates from Kenya. Therefore, Lupita Nyong'o holds citizenship in Kenya, Barack Obama's paternal family's origin country. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that Lupita Nyong'o holds citizenship in Kenya, which is the origin country of Barack Obama's paternal family, as stated in the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #125
Are there enough Jonny Cash records in the world to give one to each French citizen?
1 issue
Full Question
Are there enough Jonny Cash records in the world to give one to each French citizen?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Johnny Cash has sold about 90 million albums. The population of France is around 66 million .
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Are there enough Jonny Cash records in the world to give one to each French citizen?
Answer: There are an estimated 150 million Johnny Cash records sold worldwide. The population of France is about 67 million. Since 150 million is greater than 67 million, there are enough Johnny Cash records to give one to each French citizen. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning chain contains a factual error regarding the number of Johnny Cash records sold. The rest of the reasoning is sound.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
There are an estimated 150 million Johnny Cash records sold worldwide.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that there are 150 million Johnny Cash records sold worldwide, but the reference explanation states that Johnny Cash has sold about 90 million albums.
Answer Span:
150 million Johnny Cash records sold worldwide
Reference/Question Span:
90 million albums
Question #126
Could someone mistake the smell of your brussels sprouts for a fart?
Clean
Full Question
Could someone mistake the smell of your brussels sprouts for a fart?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Brussels Sprouts are cruciferous vegetables. Cruciferous vegetables have a sulfur containing chemical called glucosinolate in them. When you cook brussels sprouts, their smell intensifies.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Could someone mistake the smell of your brussels sprouts for a fart?
Answer: Brussels sprouts contain sulfur-containing compounds. Flatulence also often contains sulfur-containing compounds. The sulfur compounds are what create the unpleasant odor associated with both brussels sprouts and farts. Therefore, it is possible that someone could mistake the smell of cooking brussels sprouts for flatulence. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. It correctly identifies the presence of sulfur-containing compounds in both brussels sprouts and flatulence, leading to the conclusion that the smells could be mistaken for each other.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #127
Can Stone Cold Steve Austin apply his finisher to a mule deer?
1 issue
Full Question
Can Stone Cold Steve Austin apply his finisher to a mule deer?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Steve Austin's finisher, The Stone Cold Stunner, involves lifting the opponent and then pulling their head down. The largest male mule deer's are around 330 pounds. Steve Austin has applied his finisher to the wrestler The Big Show. The Big Show weighs 383 pounds.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Could Stone Cold Steve Austin apply his finisher (the Stone Cold Stunner) to a mule deer?
Answer: Stone Cold Steve Austin's finisher, the Stone Cold Stunner, requires a willing participant to jump into the air and allow the wrestler to bring them down onto their back. A mule deer would neither jump into the air nor take part in wrestling, thus Stone Cold could not apply his finisher. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain hallucinates that the Stone Cold Stunner requires a willing participant to jump, which is false. The reference states that it involves lifting the opponent and pulling their head down.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Stone Cold Steve Austin's finisher, the Stone Cold Stunner, requires a willing participant to jump into the air and allow the wrestler to bring them down onto their back.
Explanation
The Stone Cold Stunner does not require a willing participant to jump into the air. It involves lifting the opponent and then pulling their head down.
Answer Span:
Stone Cold Steve Austin's finisher, the Stone Cold Stunner, requires a willing participant to jump into the air and allow the wrestler to bring them down onto their back.
Reference/Question Span:
Steve Austin's finisher, The Stone Cold Stunner, involves lifting the opponent and then pulling their head down.
Question #128
Is the Joker in a healthy romantic relationship?
Clean
Full Question
Is the Joker in a healthy romantic relationship?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Healthy relationships are characterized by mutual trust and respect. The Joker is dating Harley Quinn. The Joker frequently abuses and talks down to Harley.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is the Joker in a healthy romantic relationship?
Answer: The Joker is a fictional character known for his chaotic and abusive behavior. A healthy romantic relationship involves mutual respect, trust, and support, which are qualities absent in the Joker's interactions, particularly with Harley Quinn, who is often portrayed as a victim of his manipulation and abuse. Therefore, the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that the Joker is not in a healthy romantic relationship due to his abusive behavior towards Harley Quinn.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #129
Is the kayak a traditional boat in New Zealand?
Clean
Full Question
Is the kayak a traditional boat in New Zealand?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Kayaks were developed by native peoples to hunt in northern waters of the Arctic Ocean, North Atlantic, Bering Sea and North Pacific. New Zealand is in the Southern Hemisphere. The native Maori people of New Zealand arrived there in canoes.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is the kayak a traditional boat in New Zealand?
Answer: The kayak originated with the Inuit, Yup'ik, and Aleut peoples in the Arctic regions. New Zealand's traditional boat is the waka, a large outrigger canoe. Therefore, the kayak is not a traditional boat of New Zealand. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that kayaks are not traditional boats in New Zealand, and accurately states that New Zealand's traditional boat is the waka.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #130
Did Boris Yeltsin watch the 2008 Summer Olympics?
Clean
Full Question
Did Boris Yeltsin watch the 2008 Summer Olympics?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The 2008 Summer Olympics were held Aug 08 - 24, 2008. Boris Yeltsin died on Apr 23, 2007.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did Boris Yeltsin watch the 2008 Summer Olympics?
Answer: Boris Yeltsin died in 2007. The 2008 Summer Olympics occurred in 2008. Therefore, he could not have watched the 2008 Summer Olympics. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly states that Boris Yeltsin died in 2007 and the 2008 Summer Olympics occurred in 2008. It then correctly concludes that he could not have watched the Olympics.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #131
Did the swallow play a role in a famous film about King Arthur?
Clean
Full Question
Did the swallow play a role in a famous film about King Arthur?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Monty Python and the Holy Grail was a famous film about King Arthur. In Monty Python and the Holy Grail, swallows are mentioned several times.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did the swallow play a role in a famous film about King Arthur?
Answer: In *Monty Python and the Holy Grail,* a famous comedic film about King Arthur, there is a scene where a swallow is discussed as a potential means of carrying a coconut. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, confirming the role of swallows in the film about King Arthur.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #132
Was Michael Crichton ever in danger of flunking out of Harvard as an undergraduate?
Clean
Full Question
Was Michael Crichton ever in danger of flunking out of Harvard as an undergraduate?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Scholastic probation or academic dismissal, sometimes known as flunking out, is the termination of students at a higher educational institution as the result of poor academic achievement. Michael Crichton obtained his bachelor's degree in biological anthropology summa cum laude in 1964. Summa cum laude is the highest distinction a person can achieve in college for academic success. Someone who achieves summa cum laude cannot have even a single semester of poor grades.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was Michael Crichton ever in danger of flunking out of Harvard as an undergraduate?
Answer: Michael Crichtongraduated summa cum laude from Harvard. Therefore, he was not in danger of flunking out. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. It correctly infers that someone who graduated summa cum laude could not have been in danger of flunking out.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #133
Was Surfing popular when pogs came out?
Clean
Full Question
Was Surfing popular when pogs came out?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Pogs came out in the 1990's. The 90's saw a rise in 'Big Wave Culture', a practice involving finding the largest possible waves to surf on.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was Surfing popular when pogs came out?
Answer: Pogs were popular in the mid-1990s. Surfing was already a popular sport by the mid-1990s. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly infers that surfing was popular when pogs came out, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #134
Could a student at the University of Houston see a caracal on campus?
Clean
Full Question
Could a student at the University of Houston see a caracal on campus?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The caracal is native to Africa, the Middle East, Central Asia, and India. The University of Houston is located in the United States. The United States is located in North America.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Could a student at the University of Houston see a caracal on campus?
Answer: Caracals are wild cats native to Africa, the Middle East, Central Asia, and India. They are not native to Texas, where the University of Houston is located. While it's *possible* a caracal could escape from a zoo or private owner and end up near the University of Houston campus, it is extremely unlikely. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that caracals are not native to Texas, where the University of Houston is located. It also acknowledges the remote possibility of a caracal escaping from captivity but deems it extremely unlikely.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #135
Did the Coen brothers ever collaborate with the Brothers Grimm?
Clean
Full Question
Did the Coen brothers ever collaborate with the Brothers Grimm?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Coen brothers were born in 1954 and 1957. The Brothers Grimm died in 1859 and 1863.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did the Coen brothers ever collaborate with the Brothers Grimm?
Answer: The Coen brothers are contemporary filmmakers. The Brothers Grimm are famous for their fairy tales, and died in the 19th century. Therefore, collaboration between the Coen brothers and the Brothers Grimm would be impossible. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately explains why the Coen brothers could not have collaborated with the Brothers Grimm, based on their respective lifespans.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #136
Could a hundred thousand lolcats fit on a first generation iPhone?
1 issue
Full Question
Could a hundred thousand lolcats fit on a first generation iPhone?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Lolcat memes are often in jpeg form. The average size of a jpeg is 10 to 30 kb. One gigabyte is 1000000 kb. The first iPhone had 4GB to 16GB of storage .
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Could a hundred thousand lolcats fit on a first generation iPhone?
Answer: A first-generation iPhone had storage options of 4GB or 8GB. One hundred thousand lolcats, assuming an average image size (which could vary wildly), would likely take up far more space than even 8GB. Therefore, the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning makes a logical error in calculating the storage space required for 100,000 lolcats, leading to an incorrect conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorhigh
Statement
One hundred thousand lolcats, assuming an average image size (which could vary wildly), would likely take up far more space than even 8GB.
Explanation
The generated reasoning makes a logical error. The reference states that the average size of a jpeg is 10 to 30 kb. 100,000 lolcats at 30kb each would take up 3,000,000 kb, which is 3GB. This would fit on a first generation iPhone.
Answer Span:
would likely take up far more space than even 8GB
Reference/Question Span:
The average size of a jpeg is 10 to 30 kb. One gigabyte is 1000000 kb. The first iPhone had 4GB to 16GB of storage
Question #137
Are monks forbidden from engaging in warfare?
1 issue
Full Question
Are monks forbidden from engaging in warfare?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Monks are members of religious orders that usually take vows of poverty, chastity, and obedience. The Knights Templar were a religious order that fought during the Crusades and captured Jerusalem in 1099. Buddhist Shaolin monks developed very powerful martial arts skills, have defended temples during conquests.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Are monks forbidden from engaging in warfare?
Answer: The monastic code generally emphasizes non-violence and pacifism. Therefore, most monks are forbidden from participating in warfare. There are some historical exceptions such as warrior monks, but these are not representative of the vast majority of monastic traditions. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain makes a generalization about monks being forbidden from warfare, which is contradicted by the reference explanation that provides examples of monks participating in warfare.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Therefore, most monks are forbidden from participating in warfare.
Explanation
The reference explanation provides examples of monks engaging in warfare, such as the Knights Templar and Buddhist Shaolin monks. This directly contradicts the statement that most monks are forbidden from participating in warfare.
Answer Span:
Therefore, most monks are forbidden from participating in warfare.
Reference/Question Span:
The Knights Templar were a religious order that fought during the Crusades and captured Jerusalem in 1099. Buddhist Shaolin monks developed very powerful martial arts skills, have defended temples during conquests.
Question #138
Is the BBC World Service hosted in Europe?
Clean
Full Question
Is the BBC World Service hosted in Europe?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The BBC World Service is part of the BBC network. The BBC operates in England. England is part of Europe.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is the BBC World Service hosted in Europe?
Answer: The BBC World Service is headquartered in London, which is located in the United Kingdom, a European country. Thus, the BBC World Service is hosted in Europe. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, providing a clear and concise justification for the answer.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #139
Would 1996 leap year baby technically be 1 year old in 2000?
Clean
Full Question
Would 1996 leap year baby technically be 1 year old in 2000?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. A leap year happens once every 4 years and has 29 days in February. The years 1996, 2000, 2004, 2008, 2012, 2016, and 2020 are the last 7 leap years that have happened. 1996 to 2000 is one leap year.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would a 1996 leap year baby technically be 1 year old in 2000?
Answer: A baby born in 1996 would experience the year 1997, 1998, 1999, and 2000. This means the baby would have lived through 4 years. Therefore, in 2000, the baby would be 4 years old, not 1 year old. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly calculates the age of the baby.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #140
Did Clark Gable marry more women once than Richard Burton?
1 issue
Full Question
Did Clark Gable marry more women once than Richard Burton?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Richard Burton was married to Elizabeth Taylor twice. Richard Burton married Sally Burton, Suzy Hunt, and Sybil Williams once. Clark Gable was married to five different women, one time each.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did Clark Gable marry more women once than Richard Burton?
Answer: Clark Gable married five times. Richard Burton married twice, but to the same woman, Elizabeth Taylor, meaning he married her once and then remarried her again. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains a significant logical error in calculating the number of times Richard Burton was married, leading to an incorrect conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorhigh
Statement
Richard Burton married twice, but to the same woman, Elizabeth Taylor, meaning he married her once and then remarried her again.
Explanation
The generated reasoning misinterprets the number of times Richard Burton was married. The reference states that Richard Burton was married to Elizabeth Taylor twice, and also married Sally Burton, Suzy Hunt, and Sybil Williams once each. This means he was married a total of 5 times, not twice.
Answer Span:
Richard Burton married twice, but to the same woman, Elizabeth Taylor, meaning he married her once and then remarried her again.
Reference/Question Span:
Richard Burton was married to Elizabeth Taylor twice. Richard Burton married Sally Burton, Suzy Hunt, and Sybil Williams once.
Question #141
Is one blast from double-barreled shotgun likely to kill all squid brains?
1 issue
Full Question
Is one blast from double-barreled shotgun likely to kill all squid brains?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. A double-barreled shotgun fires two rounds in one single blast. Squids have three brains.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is one blast from a double-barreled shotgun likely to kill all squid brains?
Answer: A double-barreled shotgun fires two shotshells at once, meaning one blast will deliver a wide spread of pellets. Squid have a complex nervous system and multiple ganglia, not just one centralized brain. While a shotgun blast would certainly be lethal to a squid hit directly, it's unlikely to destroy *all* neural tissue with a single blast if the squid is large enough or the range is great enough to spread the pellets widely. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning contradicts the reference by stating that squids have a complex nervous system and multiple ganglia, not just one centralized brain, while the reference states that squids have three brains.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Squid have a complex nervous system and multiple ganglia, not just one centralized brain.
Explanation
The reference states that squids have three brains. The generated reasoning states that squids have a complex nervous system and multiple ganglia, not just one centralized brain. This contradicts the reference.
Answer Span:
Squid have a complex nervous system and multiple ganglia, not just one centralized brain.
Reference/Question Span:
Squids have three brains.
Question #142
Do women often need new shoes during their pregnancy?
Clean
Full Question
Do women often need new shoes during their pregnancy?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Pregnancy can cause swelling in the feet and legs. For safety and comfort, one needs to get new shoes if the size of their feet change.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Do women often need new shoes during their pregnancy?
Answer: During pregnancy, women's feet often swell due to water retention and hormonal changes. This swelling can make their current shoes too tight and uncomfortable. Therefore, many women find they need new shoes in a larger size or with a wider fit to accommodate their swollen feet during pregnancy. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, providing a clear and logical explanation for why women often need new shoes during pregnancy.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #143
Are some adherents to Christianity in China historic enemies of Catholic Church?
1 issue
Full Question
Are some adherents to Christianity in China historic enemies of Catholic Church?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Christianity in China is comprised of several different groups including: Protestants, Catholics, Evangelicals, and Orthodox Christians. Catholics have been at war with Protestants throughout history. The 1572 St. Bartholomew's Day Massacre saw thousands of Protestants killed by Catholic mobs. English Protestant rulers killed many Irish Catholics during the Reformation.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Are some adherents to Christianity in China historic enemies of the Catholic Church?
Answer: Christianity encompasses various denominations, including Protestantism and Catholicism. The Catholic Church, specifically, has had a complex relationship with China. Historically, there have been tensions and conflicts between the Catholic Church and other Christian groups, as well as between the Catholic Church and the Chinese government. Therefore, it's true that some adherents to Christianity in China have historically been at odds with the Catholic Church. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning makes a logical error by broadening the scope of conflict beyond what is stated in the reference explanation. It introduces the idea of tensions between the Catholic Church and the Chinese government, which is not mentioned in the reference.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
Historically, there have been tensions and conflicts between the Catholic Church and other Christian groups, as well as between the Catholic Church and the Chinese government.
Explanation
The reference states that Catholics have been at war with Protestants throughout history. The generated reasoning broadens this to tensions between the Catholic Church and other Christian groups, as well as the Chinese government. The reference does not mention tensions with the Chinese government.
Answer Span:
Historically, there have been tensions and conflicts between the Catholic Church and other Christian groups, as well as between the Catholic Church and the Chinese government.
Reference/Question Span:
Catholics have been at war with Protestants throughout history.
Question #144
Is Chinese successor to Chevrolet Cruze name a town far from Milan?
Clean
Full Question
Is Chinese successor to Chevrolet Cruze name a town far from Milan?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Chinese successor to Chevrolet Cruze is the Chevrolet Monza. Monza is a city near the north of Milan.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is the Chinese successor to the Chevrolet Cruze named after a town far from Milan?
Answer: The Chinese successor to the Chevrolet Cruze is the Chevrolet Monza. Monza is a city near Milan. Therefore, the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies the Chinese successor to the Chevrolet Cruze as the Chevrolet Monza and accurately states that Monza is a city near Milan, aligning perfectly with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #145
Could the Dominican Order hypothetically defeat Blessed Gerard's order?
Clean
Full Question
Could the Dominican Order hypothetically defeat Blessed Gerard's order?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Dominican Order is a Catholic group of friars that several priestly vows. Blessed Gerard was the founder of the Order of St John of Jerusalem (Knights Hospitaller). The Order of St John of Jerusalem (Knights Hospitaller) were a well trained Catholic military order that fought in the Crusades.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Could the Dominican Order hypothetically defeat Blessed Gerard's order?
Answer: Blessed Gerard founded the Order of the Knights of St. John of Jerusalem, also known as the Knights Hospitaller. The Knights Hospitaller were a military order. The Dominican Order, while influential, was a mendicant order focused on preaching and teaching, not military pursuits. In a hypothetical military conflict, the Knights Hospitaller, with their military training and experience, would likely defeat the Dominican Order. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, correctly identifying the Dominican Order as a mendicant order focused on preaching and teaching, and the Knights Hospitaller as a military order. It logically concludes that the Knights Hospitaller would likely defeat the Dominican Order in a hypothetical military conflict.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #146
Is a pottery kiln inappropriate for use with glass blowing?
1 issue
Full Question
Is a pottery kiln inappropriate for use with glass blowing?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Pottery kilns heat from the sides. Glass kilns heat from the top. Glass can be fused in a ceramic pottery kiln without trouble.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is a pottery kiln inappropriate for use with glass blowing?
Answer: Pottery kilns typically reach maximum temperatures of around 2,400°F (1,315°C). Glass blowing requires temperatures much higher, often exceeding 2,800°F (1,538°C). Because pottery kilns don't typically reach the required temperature for glass blowing, they are generally inappropriate. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain incorrectly claims that pottery kilns are inappropriate for glass blowing due to temperature limitations, contradicting the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Glass blowing requires temperatures much higher, often exceeding 2,800°F (1,538°C). Because pottery kilns don't typically reach the required temperature for glass blowing, they are generally inappropriate.
Explanation
The reference states that glass can be fused in a ceramic pottery kiln without trouble, contradicting the statement that pottery kilns are generally inappropriate for glass blowing due to temperature limitations.
Answer Span:
Glass blowing requires temperatures much higher, often exceeding 2,800°F (1,538°C). Because pottery kilns don't typically reach the required temperature for glass blowing, they are generally inappropriate.
Reference/Question Span:
Glass can be fused in a ceramic pottery kiln without trouble.
Question #147
Are there enough people in the Balkans to match the population of Japan?
Clean
Full Question
Are there enough people in the Balkans to match the population of Japan?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. There are approximately 55 million people in the Balkans. There are more than 125 million people in Japan.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Are there enough people in the Balkans to match the population of Japan?
Answer: The population of Japan is about 125 million. The population of the Balkans is about 55 million. Since 55 million is less than 125 million, the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation and arrives at the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #148
Could Steven Spielberg send emails as a child?
Clean
Full Question
Could Steven Spielberg send emails as a child?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Steven Spielberg was born in 1946. Email did not become available to the general public until 1995.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Could Steven Spielberg send emails as a child?
Answer: Steven Spielberg was born in 1946. Email wasn't widely used until the 1990s. A child in the 1950s and 60s would not have had access to email. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation and arrives at the correct conclusion without any hallucinations.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #149
Was Charles Manson's body unwanted?
1 issue
Full Question
Was Charles Manson's body unwanted?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Charles Manson's body was debated over for so long that he had to stay on ice. Charles Manson had four people fighting over his corpse.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was Charles Manson's bodyunwanted?
Answer: Charles Manson's body was initially unclaimed after his death. His grandson eventually sought and won the right to claim his remains. Therefore, although initially unclaimed, his body was not ultimately unwanted. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains a factual error that contradicts the reference explanation. The claim that Charles Manson's body was initially unclaimed is false, as the reference states that four people were fighting over his corpse.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Charles Manson's body was initially unclaimed after his death.
Explanation
The reference states that Charles Manson's body was debated over for so long that he had to stay on ice and that four people were fighting over his corpse. This contradicts the statement that his body was initially unclaimed.
Answer Span:
Charles Manson's body was initially unclaimed after his death.
Reference/Question Span:
Charles Manson had four people fighting over his corpse.
Question #150
Would a Beaver's teeth rival that of a Smilodon?
Clean
Full Question
Would a Beaver's teeth rival that of a Smilodon?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. A beaver has teeth measuring 25 mm on average. The Smilodon was a prehistoric saber-toothed tiger. The Smilodon's teeth were around 11 inches long.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would a Beaver'steeth rival that of a Smilodon?
Answer: Beavers have large, strong teeth adapted for gnawing wood. Smilodons, also known as saber-toothed cats, had long, sharp canine teeth for hunting and killing large prey. While a beaver'steeth are impressive for their specific purpose, they would not rival the size, sharpness, or killing power of a smilodon'steeth. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately compares the teeth of a beaver and a smilodon, correctly concluding that a beaver's teeth would not rival those of a smilodon.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #151
Is dysphoria around one's pelvis treatable without surgery?
1 issue
Full Question
Is dysphoria around one's pelvis treatable without surgery?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. For individuals experiencing dysphoria around having a vagina, packers can relieve symptoms. For people experiencing dysphoria about having a penis, there are tucking underwear and comfort gaffs available.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is dysphoria around one's pelvis treatable without surgery?
Answer: Dysphoria related to the pelvis can sometimes be treated without surgery. Therapy, particularly gender-affirming therapy, can address the emotional distress associated with dysphoria. Other non-surgical options might include hormone replacement therapy (HRT), which can alter secondary sex characteristics and potentially alleviate some dysphoria related to the pelvic region. However, for some individuals, surgery may be the most effective treatment to alleviate dysphoria and achieve bodily congruence.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning introduces hormone replacement therapy (HRT) as a potential non-surgical option, which is not mentioned in the reference explanation as a treatment for dysphoria specifically related to the pelvic region. The reference focuses on packers, tucking underwear, and comfort gaffs.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
Other non-surgical options might include hormone replacement therapy (HRT), which can alter secondary sex characteristics and potentially alleviate some dysphoria related to the pelvic region.
Explanation
The reference explanation focuses on packers, tucking underwear, and comfort gaffs as non-surgical treatments for dysphoria around the pelvis. Hormone replacement therapy is not mentioned as a treatment for dysphoria specifically related to the pelvic region.
Answer Span:
hormone replacement therapy (HRT), which can alter secondary sex characteristics and potentially alleviate some dysphoria related to the pelvic region
Reference/Question Span:
packers can relieve symptoms. For people experiencing dysphoria about having a penis, there are tucking underwear and comfort gaffs available.
Question #152
Would members of Blue Lives Matter support every element of Grand Theft Auto III?
Clean
Full Question
Would members of Blue Lives Matter support every element of Grand Theft Auto III?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Blue Lives Matter is a countermovement in the United States that supports police officers and law enforcement personnel. Grand Theft Auto III allows for gratuitous violence against police officers in the game.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would members of Blue Lives Matter support every element of Grand Theft Auto III?
Answer: Blue Lives Matter is a pro-police movement. Grand Theft Auto III is a video game where players can commit crimes, including violence against police officers. It is highly unlikely members of Blue Lives Matter, a group supporting law enforcement, would endorse every element of a game like Grand Theft Auto III that allows players to engage in criminal activity, especially violence against police. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation and arrives at the correct conclusion without any hallucinations.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #153
Can the Dalai Lama fit in a car?
Clean
Full Question
Can the Dalai Lama fit in a car?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The Dalai Lama is a person. Cars are designed for people to sit in them.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Can the Dalai Lama fit in a car?
Answer: The Dalai Lama is a human being. Most cars are designed to fit human beings. Therefore, the Dalai Lama can likely fit in a car. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, providing a logical and correct answer.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #154
Can actress Dafne Keen win the Eurovision Song Contest finals in 2020?
1 issue
Full Question
Can actress Dafne Keen win the Eurovision Song Contest finals in 2020?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Contestants must be at least 16 years of age to compete in the finals of Eurovision Song Contest. Dafne Keen is 15 years old in 2020.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Could Dafne Keen win the Eurovision Song Contest finals in 2020?
Answer: The Eurovision Song Contest did not take place in 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Therefore, Dafne Keen could not have won. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain hallucinates that the Eurovision Song Contest did not take place in 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The reference explanation states that Dafne Keen was 15 years old in 2020 and contestants must be at least 16 years of age to compete in the finals of Eurovision Song Contest.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The Eurovision Song Contest did not take place in 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Explanation
The Eurovision Song Contest did take place in 2020, although it was cancelled. The reference explanation states that Dafne Keen was 15 years old in 2020 and contestants must be at least 16 years of age to compete in the finals of Eurovision Song Contest.
Answer Span:
The Eurovision Song Contest did not take place in 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Reference/Question Span:
Dafne Keen is 15 years old in 2020.
Question #155
Does United Airlines have a perfect operation record?
Clean
Full Question
Does United Airlines have a perfect operation record?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. An airline with a perfect operation record has no crashes or other damaging incidents. United Airlines has had over 30 crash incidents over several decades.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does United Airlines have a perfect operation record?
Answer: United Airlines has had several incidents and accidents throughout its operational history. A perfect operation record would imply no incidents or accidents. Therefore, the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that United Airlines has had incidents and accidents, thus not having a perfect operation record.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #156
Can United States Secretary of State do crimes in U.K. without being arrested?
1 issue
Full Question
Can United States Secretary of State do crimes in U.K. without being arrested?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Diplomatic Immunity allows for diplomats in other countries to not be tried for their transgressions. Countries that signed the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations allow for Diplomatic Immunity. All UN member states besides Palau, The Solomon Islands, and South Sudan have signed the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations treaty. The U.K. is one of the original UN member nations.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Can United States Secretary of State do crimes in U.K. without being arrested?
Answer: A United States Secretary of State is not above the law in the U.K.. If they commit crimes in the U.K. they can be arrested and prosecuted. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning directly contradicts the reference explanation by stating that a U.S. Secretary of State is not above the law in the U.K. and can be arrested, while the reference states that diplomatic immunity would prevent this.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
A United States Secretary of State is not above the law in the U.K.. If they commit crimes in the U.K. they can be arrested and prosecuted.
Explanation
The generated reasoning contradicts the reference explanation, which states that diplomatic immunity would prevent the Secretary of State from being arrested and prosecuted.
Answer Span:
A United States Secretary of State is not above the law in the U.K.. If they commit crimes in the U.K. they can be arrested and prosecuted.
Reference/Question Span:
Diplomatic Immunity allows for diplomats in other countries to not be tried for their transgressions.
Question #157
Is myocardial infarction a brain problem?
Clean
Full Question
Is myocardial infarction a brain problem?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Myocardial infarction is a problem in the heart. The equivalent in the brain would be similar to a stroke.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is myocardial infarction a brain problem?
Answer: Myocardial infarction is commonly known as a heart attack. A heart attack occurs due to blockage of blood flow to the heart muscle. The brain is a separate organ from the heart. Therefore, myocardial infarction is not a brain problem. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately explains why myocardial infarction is not a brain problem, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #158
Will Chick Fil A be open on Halloween 2021?
1 issue
Full Question
Will Chick Fil A be open on Halloween 2021?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Chick Fil A restaurants close on Sundays. Halloween 2021 falls on a Sunday.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Will Chick Fil A be open on Halloween 2021?
Answer: Chick Fil A is generally open on most holidays, but it is closed on Sundays. Halloween 2021 fell on a Sunday. Therefore, Chick Fil A was closed on Halloween 2021. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain contains a factual error about Chick Fil A's holiday hours, but correctly identifies that it is closed on Sundays and that Halloween 2021 was on a Sunday.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Chick Fil A is generally open on most holidays, but it is closed on Sundays.
Explanation
This statement contradicts the reference explanation. The reference explanation only states that Chick Fil A is closed on Sundays, and does not mention anything about holidays.
Answer Span:
Chick Fil A is generally open on most holidays
Reference/Question Span:
Chick Fil A restaurants close on Sundays.
Question #159
Was Godfrey of Bouillon an Islamaphobe?
Clean
Full Question
Was Godfrey of Bouillon an Islamaphobe?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Godfrey of Bouillon lead troops during the Prince's Crusade. The Prince's Crusade was an attempt by Europeans to "take back" the city of Jerusalem from Islamic hands.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was Godfrey of Bouillon an Islamaphobe?
Answer: Godfrey of Bouillon was a leader of the First Crusade. The First Crusade was a military expedition by European Christians to reclaim the Holy Land from Muslim control. Historians generally agree that the Crusades were fueled, at least in part, by religious zeal and prejudice against Muslims. While the modern term "Islamaphobe" didn't exist then, Godfrey of Bouillon's actions and role in the Crusades strongly suggest hostility and intolerance towards Islam and Muslims, fitting the modern definition of the term. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, providing a clear and logical argument to support the conclusion. There are no contradictions, entity swaps, or logical errors.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #160
Is an espresso likely to assuage fear?
Clean
Full Question
Is an espresso likely to assuage fear?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Fear raises heart rate. Caffeine raises heart rate. Coffee may also increase symptoms such as jitteriness and nausea .
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is an espresso likely to assuage fear?
Answer: An espresso contains caffeine. Caffeine is a stimulant. Stimulants can increase anxiety, which is the opposite of assuaging fear. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that caffeine, a stimulant in espresso, can increase anxiety, which is the opposite of assuaging fear, aligning with the reference explanation that caffeine raises heart rate and may increase symptoms such as jitteriness.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #161
If you add water to rice pudding is it horchata?
Clean
Full Question
If you add water to rice pudding is it horchata?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Horchata is a drink made from soaking dry rice in water for hours, then pulverizing and straining the mixture and adding spices and sweetener. Rice pudding includes ingredients like eggs, and whole grains of cooked rice.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: If you add water to rice pudding is it horchata?
Answer: Rice pudding is a dish made from water or milk, rice, sugar, and sometimes spices. Horchata is a beverage made from soaked rice, nuts, seeds, or tigernuts blended with water with added sugar and spices. While both contain rice and water, horchata uses uncooked rice whereas rice pudding uses cooked rice. Simply adding water to rice pudding will not turn it into horchata due to this key difference in the preparation of the rice. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately explains why adding water to rice pudding does not make it horchata, highlighting the key difference in the preparation of the rice (uncooked for horchata, cooked for rice pudding).
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #162
Did Bill Gates achieve Latin honors?
Clean
Full Question
Did Bill Gates achieve Latin honors?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Bill Gates left Harvard after two years. Latin honors are Latin phrases used in some colleges and universities to indicate the level of distinction with which an academic degree has been earned. You cannot earn an academic degree if you drop out of the program.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did Bill Gates achieve Latin honors?
Answer: Bill Gates dropped out of Harvard University. Latin honors are awarded upon graduation. Since Bill Gates did not graduate, he did not achieve Latin honors. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that Bill Gates dropped out of Harvard and therefore did not receive Latin honors, which are awarded upon graduation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #163
Was Superhero fiction invented in the digital format?
Clean
Full Question
Was Superhero fiction invented in the digital format?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Golden Age of comics occurred between the 1930's and the 1950's. Shatter was the first digitally drawn, commercially published comic.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was Superhero fiction invented in the digital format?
Answer: Superhero fiction predates digital formats. Superhero comics, a quintessential form of superhero fiction, originated in the 1930s, long before digital technologies existed. Therefore, superhero fiction was not invented in the digital format. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly deduces that superhero fiction was not invented in the digital format, accurately referencing the origin of superhero comics in the 1930s, which predates digital technologies. The reasoning aligns perfectly with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #164
Are any animals in Chinese calendar Chordata?
1 issue
Full Question
Are any animals in Chinese calendar Chordata?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The chinese zodiac based on the Chinese calendar has a number of animals including dogs and pigs. Chordata is a scientific classification of an animals phylum. The phylum of pigs is Chordata.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Are any animals in the Chinese calendarChordata?
Answer: The animals in the Chinese zodiac are the Rat, Ox, Tiger, Rabbit, Dragon, Snake, Horse, Goat, Monkey, Rooster, Dog, and Pig. All of these animals except for the mythical Dragon are chordates (vertebrates, to be more precise). So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning correctly identifies some animals in the Chinese zodiac as chordates but makes an unsupported claim about dragons not being chordates, which is a logical error.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
All of these animals except for the mythical Dragon are chordates (vertebrates, to be more precise).
Explanation
The statement implies that the mythical Dragon is not a chordate. However, the reference explanation only states that pigs are chordates, without making any claims about dragons or other animals in the Chinese zodiac. The generated reasoning makes an unsupported assumption about dragons not being chordates.
Answer Span:
All of these animals except for the mythical Dragon are chordates (vertebrates, to be more precise).
Reference/Question Span:
The phylum of pigs is Chordata.
Question #165
Was Daniel thrown into the lion's den in the New Testament?
Clean
Full Question
Was Daniel thrown into the lion's den in the New Testament?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Book of Daniel is a book in the Old Testament of the Bible. The Bible is divided into the Old Testament and the New Testament. The New Testament focuses on four Gospels regarding the life of Jesus.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was Daniel thrown into the lion's den in the New Testament?
Answer: The story of Daniel being thrown into the lion's den is found in the Book of Daniel, which is part of the Old Testament, not the New Testament. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that the story of Daniel and the lion's den is in the Old Testament, not the New Testament, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #166
Will 2020 elephant pregnancy last past next year with 4 solar eclipses?
1 issue
Full Question
Will 2020 elephant pregnancy last past next year with 4 solar eclipses?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The gestation period of elephants are around 95 weeks. The year 2029 is the next year with 4 solar eclipses.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Will a 2020 elephant pregnancy last past next year with 4 solar eclipses?
Answer: Elephant pregnancies last around 22 months. A pregnancy beginning in 2020 would likely end in late 2021 or early 2022. Next year, in reference to 2020, is 2021. The number of solar eclipses has no bearing on the length of an elephant pregnancy. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning is mostly correct, but the slight inaccuracy in the gestation period of elephants is a minor hallucination.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionlow
Statement
Elephant pregnancies last around 22 months.
Explanation
The reference states that elephant pregnancies last around 95 weeks, which is approximately 21.8 months. While close, 22 months is not precise and could lead to incorrect calculations. It is close enough to be considered a low severity error.
Answer Span:
Elephant pregnancies last around 22 months
Reference/Question Span:
The gestation period of elephants are around 95 weeks
Question #167
Does the word swastika have meaning in sanskrit?
Clean
Full Question
Does the word swastika have meaning in sanskrit?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. In Sanskrit, the word swastika is a combination of ‘su’ (meaning ‘good’) and ‘asti’ (meaning ‘to exist’). This meaning of swastika from Sanskrit this gets translated as ‘all is well.’ .
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does the word swastika have meaning in Sanskrit?
Answer: The word swastika is derived from the Sanskrit word svastika, meaning "well-being." So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that the word swastika is derived from Sanskrit and means "well-being" or "all is well."
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #168
Did Sony definitively win the video game war against Sega?
Clean
Full Question
Did Sony definitively win the video game war against Sega?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Sony is the maker of the Playstation which has sold over 108 million PS4 units by March 2020. Sega's last console, the Sega Dreamcast, was discontinued in 2001. Sony Playstation competed with Sega's Dreamcast and Saturn systems in the 1990s. Sega now makes games for its former competitor, Sony, including Team Sonic Racing in 2019. At the height of the console wars, Sega Saturn sold 9.5 million units while Sony Playstation sold 102 million units.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did Sony definitively win the video game war against Sega?
Answer: While Sony's PlayStation significantly outsold Sega's Saturn and Dreamcast, leading to Sega exiting the console hardware market, "definitively win" is subjective. Sega remains a successful software publisher and maintains a dedicated fanbase. Therefore, while Sony dominated the console market share of that era, whether they *definitively* won the overall video game war is debatable. The answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly acknowledges Sony's dominance in the console market while also pointing out that Sega still exists as a software publisher, making the idea of a 'definitive win' debatable. No hallucinations were detected.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #169
Would an ethics professor teach a class on Cezanne?
1 issue
Full Question
Would an ethics professor teach a class on Cezanne?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Cezanne was an Impressionist painter. Aesthetics is the branch of philosophy that deals with the arts.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would an ethics professor teach a class on Cezanne?
Answer: Cezanne was a French artist. Ethics professors teach about moral principles and conduct. It is unlikely an ethics professor would teach about Cezanne unless there was a specific ethical dimension to his work or life being explored, such as art forgery or the ethics of art ownership. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning chain contains a logical error by suggesting that an ethics professor might teach about Cezanne if there were ethical dimensions to his work, which is not supported by the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
It is unlikely an ethics professor would teach about Cezanne unless there was a specific ethical dimension to his work or life being explored, such as art forgery or the ethics of art ownership.
Explanation
The reference explanation states that Cezanne was an Impressionist painter and that aesthetics is the branch of philosophy that deals with the arts. It does not mention any ethical dimensions of Cezanne's work or life, so this is a misinterpretation of the reference facts.
Answer Span:
It is unlikely an ethics professor would teach about Cezanne unless there was a specific ethical dimension to his work or life being explored, such as art forgery or the ethics of art ownership.
Reference/Question Span:
Cezanne was an Impressionist painter. Aesthetics is the branch of philosophy that deals with the arts.
Question #170
Can a dolphin keep a diary?
1 issue
Full Question
Can a dolphin keep a diary?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. A diary is a written record. Dolphins cannot write.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Can a dolphin keep a diary?
Answer: A diary requires the ability to write and record personal experiences. Dolphins lack the physical dexterity to write and do not possess the cognitive capacity for the complex, reflective thought required for diary keeping. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning chain contains a logical error by adding information not present in the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errorlow
Statement
Dolphins lack the physical dexterity to write and do not possess the cognitive capacity for the complex, reflective thought required for diary keeping.
Explanation
The reference explanation only states that dolphins cannot write. The generated reasoning adds that dolphins do not possess the cognitive capacity for complex thought, which is not mentioned in the reference explanation.
Answer Span:
Dolphins lack the physical dexterity to write and do not possess the cognitive capacity for the complex, reflective thought required for diary keeping.
Reference/Question Span:
Dolphins cannot write.
Question #171
Would Columbus have discovered Durian trees during his 1492 expedition?
Clean
Full Question
Would Columbus have discovered Durian trees during his 1492 expedition?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Columbus ended up in the Americas. Durian only exists in Southeast Asia.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would Columbus have discovered Durian trees during his 1492 expedition?
Answer: Columbus sailed to the Americas in 1492. Durian trees are native to Southeast Asia. Therefore, Columbus would not have encountered Durian trees in the Americas during his 1492 expedition. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that Columbus sailed to the Americas and Durian trees are native to Southeast Asia, thus he would not have encountered them during his expedition.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #172
Can you carry a Chrysler in a laptop bag?
Clean
Full Question
Can you carry a Chrysler in a laptop bag?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Chrysler manufactures automobiles, which weigh several thousand pounds. Laptop bags are designed to hold laptop computers, which typically weigh under ten pounds.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Can you carry a Chrysler in a laptop bag?
Answer: A Chrysler is a car, which is a large and heavy object. A laptop bag is designed to carry a laptop, which is a relatively small and lightweight electronic device. A Chrysler would not fit in a laptop bag. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that a Chrysler is a car, which is large and heavy, while a laptop bag is designed for small, lightweight laptops. Therefore, a Chrysler would not fit in a laptop bag.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #173
Has every astronaut survived their space journey?
1 issue
Full Question
Has every astronaut survived their space journey?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. In 1986, the space shuttle Challenger exploded during launch, killing all astronauts aboard. In 2003, the space shuttle Columbia also exploded, again killing its entire crew. Various other space flights have resulted in fatal disasters.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Has every astronautsurvived their space journey?
Answer: Sadly, not every astronaut has survived their space journey. There have been several fatal accidents in the history of space exploration, including the Apollo 1 fire, the Challenger explosion, and the Columbia disaster, where astronauts lost their lives. Therefore, the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that not all astronauts have survived their space journeys but includes an event (Apollo 1 fire) that, while tragic, did not occur during a space journey, which is a misinterpretation of the prompt.
Detected Issues (1)
logical_errormedium
Statement
including the Apollo 1 fire, the Challenger explosion, and the Columbia disaster, where astronauts lost their lives.
Explanation
The reference explanation only mentions the Challenger and Columbia disasters. While the Apollo 1 fire was a tragedy, it did not occur during a space journey.
Answer Span:
including the Apollo 1 fire
Reference/Question Span:
In 1986, the space shuttle Challenger exploded during launch, killing all astronauts aboard. In 2003, the space shuttle Columbia also exploded, again killing its entire crew.
Question #174
Do members of the Supreme Court of the United States have longer terms than most senators?
1 issue
Full Question
Do members of the Supreme Court of the United States have longer terms than most senators?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Senators, on average, serve for 10 years. Supreme Court Justices serve for their entire life. The average term for a Supreme court justice is 16 years.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Do members of the Supreme Court of the United States have longer terms than most senators?
Answer: Members of the Supreme Court are appointed for life. Senators serve 6-year terms. Therefore, members of the Supreme Court serve longer terms than senators. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain contains a factual error about the average length of a senator's term.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Senators serve 6-year terms.
Explanation
Senators serve 6-year terms, but on average serve for 10 years due to re-election.
Answer Span:
Senators serve 6-year terms.
Reference/Question Span:
Senators, on average, serve for 10 years.
Question #175
Would Dante have hypothetically placed Nostradamus in 3rd Circle of Hell?
Clean
Full Question
Would Dante have hypothetically placed Nostradamus in 3rd Circle of Hell?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Nostradamus was a famous seer and court astrologer. Dante's 3rd Circle of Hell is reserved for gluttons. The 8th Circle of Hell is reserved for frauds. Astrology was seen as a valuable skill during Dante's lifetime. Dante places the mystic and prophet Joachim of Flora in the heaven of the sun.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would Dante have hypothetically placed Nostradamus in the 3rd Circle of Hell?
Answer: Dante's *Inferno* places the gluttonous in the Third Circle of Hell. Nostradamus was a physician and astrologer, not known for gluttony. Therefore, it's unlikely Dante would have placed him there. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that Nostradamus was not known for gluttony and therefore would not be placed in the Third Circle of Hell, which is reserved for the gluttonous, according to Dante's *Inferno*.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #176
Was Mercedes-Benz associated with the Nazis?
Clean
Full Question
Was Mercedes-Benz associated with the Nazis?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. During the 1930s, Mercedes-Benz produced the 770 model. The 770 was popular with Nazis, and Adolf Hitler used them as his personal vehicle.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was Mercedes-Benz associated with the Nazis?
Answer: Mercedes-Benz, then known as Daimler-Benz, used forced labor during World War II under the Nazi regime. Therefore, the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly identifies Mercedes-Benz's association with the Nazi regime, although it focuses on forced labor during World War II, which is a valid but different aspect than the reference explanation's focus on the 770 model and Hitler's personal use.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #177
Is Disneyland Paris the largest Disney resort?
Clean
Full Question
Is Disneyland Paris the largest Disney resort?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Disneyland Paris contains two parks, several hotels, and a shopping district. By comparison, Walt Disney World in Florida contains four parks, two waterparks, a shopping district, and many hotels. Disney World is bigger than Disneyland Paris Resort and Disneyland California Resort combined.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is Disneyland Paris the largest Disney resort?
Answer: Walt Disney World Resort in Florida is the largest Disney resort. Therefore, Disneyland Paris is not the largest Disney resort. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly identifies that Walt Disney World Resort in Florida is the largest Disney resort, and therefore Disneyland Paris is not the largest.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #178
Would a Rockette look odd with a moustache?
Clean
Full Question
Would a Rockette look odd with a moustache?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The Rockettes are an American dance group made up of all women. In America, it is uncommon to see a woman with a moustache.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would a Rockette look odd with a moustache?
Answer: Rockettes are known for their glamorous and traditionally feminine appearance. A moustache is generally considered a masculine facial feature. Therefore, a moustache would clash with the typical Rockette image, making it look odd. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning correctly explains why a Rockette would look odd with a moustache, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #179
Can a sea turtle play tennis using a tennis racket?
Clean
Full Question
Can a sea turtle play tennis using a tennis racket?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. to play tennis, a human-like hand is needed to properly hold the tennis racket. sea turtles have flippers and not human-like hands.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Can a sea turtle play tennis using a tennis racket?
Answer: Tennis requires the player to hold a tennis racket and hit a ball over a net. Sea turtles have flippers, not hands, so they cannot grip a tennis racket. Therefore, a sea turtle cannot play tennis. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that sea turtles cannot play tennis because they have flippers instead of hands, which are needed to grip a tennis racket.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #180
Did Donald Trump come up with the idea for the New York Harbor?
Clean
Full Question
Did Donald Trump come up with the idea for the New York Harbor?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The New York Harbor is at the mouth of the Hudson River. A harbor is a sheltered body of water where boats and ships can be docked. The New York Harbor has been used since colonial era of the 1500s. Donald Trump is a failed business man and 2016 president elect. Donald Trump makes outrageous deceitful claims .
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did Donald Trump come up with the idea for the New York Harbor?
Answer: New York Harbor has existed for centuries, long before Donald Trump was born. Therefore, he could not have conceived of the idea for the New York Harbor. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly deduces that Donald Trump could not have come up with the idea for the New York Harbor, as it existed long before he was born. The reasoning aligns with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #181
Would it be unusual to use paypal for drug deals?
Clean
Full Question
Would it be unusual to use paypal for drug deals?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Paypal prohibits the use of their platform for drugs or drug paraphernalia. Using paypal leaves a digital footprint of any drug purchase.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Would it be unusual to use paypal for drug deals?
Answer: Paypal keeps records of transactions and user information. Because drug deals are illegal, using a service like Paypal that creates a clear record of the transaction would be risky and unusual. Therefore, the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that using PayPal for drug deals would be risky and unusual due to the platform's record-keeping practices and the illegal nature of drug transactions.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #182
Is it safe to eat kidney?
Clean
Full Question
Is it safe to eat kidney?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Traditional British cuisine includes "Kidney Pie", or "Steak and Kidney Pie". Kidney Pie contains kidney.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is it safe to eat kidney?
Answer: Kidney is a nutrient-rich organ meat that is safe to eat when properly prepared. It's important to source kidneys from healthy animals and to cook them thoroughly to eliminate any potential health risks.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning provides a reasonable explanation that kidney is safe to eat when properly prepared. It does not contradict the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #183
Do shrimp taste best when cooked for a long time?
Clean
Full Question
Do shrimp taste best when cooked for a long time?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Shrimp becomes tough and rubbery if cooked for a long time. The ideal texture for shrimp is soft and easily chewed.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Do shrimp taste best when cooked for a long time?
Answer: Shrimp cook quickly. If shrimp are cooked for a long time, they become tough and rubbery. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that shrimp becomes tough and rubbery if cooked for a long time.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #184
Hypothetically, will an African elephant be crushed by Hulk on its back?
1 issue
Full Question
Hypothetically, will an African elephant be crushed by Hulk on its back?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The Hulk is a Marvel comics character. The Hulk is said to be around 8 feet tall and weigh around 1400 pounds. An African elephant can carry up to 9,000 kg, or 19,841 pounds.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Hypothetically, will an African elephant be crushed by Hulk on its back?
Answer: An African elephant can weigh up to 13,000 pounds. The Hulk is immensely strong and can lift far more than 13,000 pounds. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning chain contains a factual error about the weight an African elephant can carry, which leads to a flawed comparison with the Hulk's lifting capacity.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
An African elephant can weigh up to 13,000 pounds.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that an African elephant can weigh up to 13,000 pounds, which contradicts the reference explanation that states that an African elephant can carry up to 19,841 pounds.
Answer Span:
An African elephant can weigh up to 13,000 pounds.
Reference/Question Span:
An African elephant can carry up to 9,000 kg, or 19,841 pounds.
Question #185
Does Rupert Murdoch's alma mater have more history than the USA?
Clean
Full Question
Does Rupert Murdoch's alma mater have more history than the USA?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Rupert Murdoch's alma mater is Worcester College. Worcester College was founded in 1714. The first documented use of the term the United States of America was in a January 2, 1776 letter.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does Rupert Murdoch's alma mater have more history than the USA?
Answer: Rupert Murdoch's alma mater is Worcester College, Oxford. Worcester College, Oxford was founded in 1714. The USA declared its independence in 1776. Since 1714 is earlier than 1776, Worcester College has more history than the USA. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation and arrives at the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #186
Is Saturn named after king of gods in Greek mythology?
Clean
Full Question
Is Saturn named after king of gods in Greek mythology?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Saturn, the sixth planet from the sun is named after the Roman god Saturn. The Roman god Saturn is derived from its Greek equivalent, Kronos. The king of the gods in Greek mythology was Zeus. Kronos was Zeus's father, and was the leader of the Titans.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is Saturn named after king of gods in Greek mythology?
Answer: In Greek mythology, the king of the gods is Zeus. Saturn is the Roman equivalent of the Greek god Cronus, who is Zeus's father and the former king of the Titans. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that Saturn is not named after the king of the gods in Greek mythology, and accurately explains the relationship between Saturn, Cronus, and Zeus.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #187
Does American Independence Day occur during autumn?
Clean
Full Question
Does American Independence Day occur during autumn?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Autumn runs from about September 20 to about December 20. American Independence Day is July 4, over two months before autumn begins.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does American Independence Day occur during autumn?
Answer: American Independence Day is celebrated on July 4th. Autumn is typically considered to be the months of September, October, and November in the Northern Hemisphere. Since July is not in autumn, the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately explains why American Independence Day does not occur during autumn, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #188
Is Albany, Georgia the most populous US Albany?
1 issue
Full Question
Is Albany, Georgia the most populous US Albany?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Albany, Georgia had a population of 75,249 in 2018. Albany, New York had a population of 97,279 in 2018.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is Albany, Georgia the most populous US Albany?
Answer: Albany, New York has a population of about 99,000, whereas Albany, Georgia has about 70,000. Since 99,000 is greater than 70,000, Albany, Georgia is not the most populous Albany in the US. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning chain contains a factual error regarding the population of Albany, New York and Albany, Georgia.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Albany, New York has a population of about 99,000, whereas Albany, Georgia has about 70,000.
Explanation
The generated reasoning states that Albany, New York has a population of about 99,000 and Albany, Georgia has about 70,000. However, the reference explanation states that Albany, New York has a population of 97,279 and Albany, Georgia has a population of 75,249.
Answer Span:
Albany, New York has a population of about 99,000, whereas Albany, Georgia has about 70,000
Reference/Question Span:
Albany, New York had a population of 97,279 in 2018. Albany, Georgia had a population of 75,249 in 2018.
Question #189
Are the founders of Skype from Asia?
Clean
Full Question
Are the founders of Skype from Asia?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Skype was created by the Niklas Zennström and the Dane Janus Friis. Niklas Zennström and Dane Janus Friis are from Sweden. Sweden is located in Europe, not Asia.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Are the founders of Skype from Asia?
Answer: The founders of Skype are Janus Friis and Niklas Zennström, both from Europe. Friis is from Denmark and Zennström is from Sweden. Since neither Denmark nor Sweden are in Asia, the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the reference explanation, stating that the founders of Skype are from Europe (Denmark and Sweden), not Asia.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #190
Are all Wednesdays in a year enough to read Bible 15 times?
1 issue
Full Question
Are all Wednesdays in a year enough to read Bible 15 times?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. There are 52 Wednesdays in a year. There are 1,248 hours over all the Wednesdays in a year. The Old Testament of the Bible takes an average of 52 hours to read. The New Testament of the Bible takes an average of 18 hours to read.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Are all Wednesdays in a year enough to read the Bible15 times?
Answer: There are 52 or 53 Wednesdays in a year. The Bible has approximately 783,137 words. A fast reader can read about 300 words per minute. This means it would take about 2610 minutes or 43.5 hours to read the Bible once. To read it 15 times, it would take 652.5 hours. Even if there were 53 Wednesdays, that would only provide 1274 hours if someone spent all 24 hours of each Wednesday reading. Since it only takes 652.5 hours to read the Bible15 times, all the Wednesdays in a year would be enough. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: fair
The generated reasoning chain introduces an irrelevant and incorrect fact about the number of words in the Bible, which is not mentioned in the reference explanation. The rest of the reasoning is based on this hallucinated fact, but the final conclusion is still correct.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The Bible has approximately 783,137 words.
Explanation
The reference explanation does not mention the number of words in the Bible. Instead, it provides the average time it takes to read the Old and New Testaments.
Answer Span:
The Bible has approximately 783,137 words.
Reference/Question Span:
The Old Testament of the Bible takes an average of 52 hours to read. The New Testament of the Bible takes an average of 18 hours to read.
Question #191
Did the butler Eugene Allen retire the same year a centuries-old war ended?
1 issue
Full Question
Did the butler Eugene Allen retire the same year a centuries-old war ended?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Eugene Allen was a butler at the White House for 34 years until 1986. The United Kingdom and the Kingdom of the Netherlands ended the Three Hundred and Thirty Five Years' Warnin 1986.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did the butler Eugene Allen retire the same year a centuries-old war ended?
Answer: Eugene Allen retired in 1986. The Cold War, which some historians date back to 1917, ended in 1991. Since 1986 is not the same as 1991, the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning introduces an irrelevant entity (Cold War) and uses it to incorrectly answer the question.
Detected Issues (1)
entity_swaphigh
Statement
The Cold War, which some historians date back to 1917, ended in 1991.
Explanation
The generated reasoning introduces the Cold War, which is not mentioned in the reference explanation. The reference mentions the Three Hundred and Thirty Five Years' War.
Answer Span:
The Cold War
Reference/Question Span:
Three Hundred and Thirty Five Years' War
Question #192
Did the writer of Christmas carol fast during Ramadan?
Clean
Full Question
Did the writer of Christmas carol fast during Ramadan?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. The writer of Christmas carol is Charles Dickens, who is a Christian. Christians do not fast during Ramadan.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Did the writer of Christmas carol fast during Ramadan?
Answer: The writer of A Christmas Carol was Charles Dickens. Ramadan is a Muslim holiday. Charles Dickens was Christian. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning correctly identifies Charles Dickens as the writer of A Christmas Carol, notes that Ramadan is a Muslim holiday, and states that Charles Dickens was Christian. This aligns with the reference explanation and leads to the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #193
Is entire Common Era minuscule to lifespan of some trees?
1 issue
Full Question
Is entire Common Era minuscule to lifespan of some trees?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. The Common Era has lasted for over 2,000 years as of 2020. A tree named Methuselah, from California's White Mountains, is almost 5,000 years old.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is the entire Common Era minuscule to the lifespan of some trees?
Answer: The Common Era spans approximately 2023 years. Some tree species, such as the Great Basin Bristlecone Pine, can live for thousands of years, exceeding the length of the Common Era. Therefore, the Common Era could be considered minuscule compared to the lifespan of some trees. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning is mostly correct and aligns with the reference explanation. However, it includes a slightly different number for the length of the Common Era, which is not directly from the reference.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionlow
Statement
The Common Era spans approximately 2023 years.
Explanation
The reference states that the Common Era has lasted for over 2,000 years as of 2020. The generated reasoning states that the Common Era spans approximately 2023 years. While technically not incorrect, it is not the information provided in the reference explanation.
Answer Span:
The Common Era spans approximately 2023 years.
Reference/Question Span:
The Common Era has lasted for over 2,000 years as of 2020.
Question #194
Is Tange Sazen hypothetically an ideal choice for a secretary job?
Clean
Full Question
Is Tange Sazen hypothetically an ideal choice for a secretary job?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. Secretaries are required to type and also read copious amounts of notes. Tange Sazen is a one-eyed, one-armed swordsman in Japanese literature.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is Tange Sazen hypothetically an ideal choice for a secretary job?
Answer: Tange Sazen is a fictional one-armed swordsman. A secretary performs administrative tasks, often involving typing and writing. Since Sazen only has one arm, he would likely have difficulty performing these tasks. Therefore, he is not an ideal choice for a secretary job. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that Tange Sazen would not be a good secretary due to his physical limitations, which aligns with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #195
Are Brussels sprout particularly good for adrenal fatigue?
Clean
Full Question
Are Brussels sprout particularly good for adrenal fatigue?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Adenal fatigue is a disorder in which the body does not produce enough hormones and people get tired. Brussels sprout are foods rich in vitamin C. When stress levels rise, the adrenal glands require more Vitamin C and it is used very quickly.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Are Brussels sprouts particularly good for adrenal fatigue?
Answer: Adrenal fatigue is a term applied to a collection of symptoms such as body aches, fatigue, nervousness, sleep disturbances and digestive problems. Brussels sprouts are a good source of vitamin C, and some proponents of the idea of adrenal fatigue believe vitamin C can be helpful for this condition. However, adrenal fatigue is not a medically recognized condition. Mainstream medicine recognizes adrenal insufficiency, which has different causes and treatments. While there is limited scientific evidence to support the claim that Brussels sprouts are particularly good for adrenal fatigue, they are a nutritious vegetable that can contribute to overall health. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: good
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that Brussels sprouts are a good source of vitamin C and that vitamin C can be helpful for adrenal fatigue. It also correctly states that adrenal fatigue is not a medically recognized condition, but that Brussels sprouts are a nutritious vegetable that can contribute to overall health.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #196
Does Adam Sandler skip celebrating Easter?
Clean
Full Question
Does Adam Sandler skip celebrating Easter?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Adam Sandler is Jewish. Jewish religious people do not celebrate Easter.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does Adam Sandler skip celebrating Easter?
Answer: Adam Sandler is Jewish. Easter is a Christian holiday. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain correctly identifies that Adam Sandler is Jewish and Easter is a Christian holiday, which leads to the correct conclusion that he does not celebrate Easter.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #197
Does March begin on the same day of the week as February during leap years?
Clean
Full Question
Does March begin on the same day of the week as February during leap years?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. During normal years, February has exactly 28 days, so March begins on the same day of the week as February. However, on leap years, February has an extra day, so March begins the next day of the week from whichever day started February.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Does March begin on the same day of the week as February during leap years?
Answer: February has 29 days during leap years. Since there are 7 days in a week, adding 29 days shifts the day of the week by one (29 mod 7 = 1). Therefore, March will begin one day later in the week than February during leap years. So the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning chain accurately explains why March does not begin on the same day of the week as February during leap years, aligning with the reference explanation.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #198
Is Shiva's divine dance an ancient physical fitness pose?
1 issue
Full Question
Is Shiva's divine dance an ancient physical fitness pose?
Ground Truth Explanation
No. In yoga as exercise, the pose called Natarajasara represents Shiva's divine dance. This pose is new, originating in the early 20th century. Exercise is an activity that maintains physical fitness.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Is Shiva's divine dance an ancient physical fitness pose?
Answer: Shiva's divine dance, Tandava, is an ancient Hindu tradition. While some modern interpretations may incorporate elements of it into physical fitness poses, its primary purpose historically wasn't fitness. It represents cosmic cycles of creation and destruction, not a workout. Therefore, the answer is {false}.
Overall Quality: poor
The generated reasoning introduces an entity swap by mentioning 'Tandava' instead of 'Natarajasara' as the pose representing Shiva's divine dance, which is a significant deviation from the reference explanation.
Detected Issues (1)
entity_swaphigh
Statement
Shiva's divine dance, Tandava, is an ancient Hindu tradition.
Explanation
The reference mentions Natarajasara as the pose representing Shiva's divine dance, not Tandava.
Answer Span:
Tandava
Reference/Question Span:
Natarajasara
Question #199
Was Land of Israel in possession of an Islamic empire in 16th century?
Clean
Full Question
Was Land of Israel in possession of an Islamic empire in 16th century?
Ground Truth Explanation
Yes. Land of Israel was controlled by the Ottoman Empire in 16th century. The religion of Ottoman Empire was Sunni Islam.
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: Was Land of Israel in possession of an Islamic empire in the 16th century?
Answer: The Ottoman Empire, an Islamic empire, controlled the Land of Israel starting in 1517. The 16th century covers the years 1501-1600. So the answer is {true}.
Overall Quality: excellent
The generated reasoning accurately reflects the information provided in the reference explanation. It correctly identifies the Ottoman Empire as an Islamic empire that controlled the Land of Israel in the 16th century.