We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains one medium black square and a medium blue square. It also contains one big blue triangle and one small blue square. Below the small blue...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains one medium black square and a medium blue square. It also contains one big blue triangle and one small blue square. Below the small blue square there is the medium blue square. Above, to the left of and near to the medium black square which is to the right of and below the small blue square is the big blue triangle. Then, we have block B with a small yellow square, a big blue circle and a medium black triangle in it. This block also contains a small yellow triangle. To the right of the small yellow square which is above the big blue circle and the medium black triangle there is the small yellow triangle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the medium black triangle there is a medium black circle. Block C is to the right of block B and below block A. It has two small yellow circles and two other medium yellow circles. Small yellow circle number one is above small yellow circle number two. Medium yellow circle number one is to the left of, above and near to medium yellow circle number two. It is to the right of small yellow circle number two. Below and to the left of medium yellow circle number one is small yellow circle number one. What is to the right of the medium black circle? a small yellow circle number two or a small yellow circle number one?
(a) small yellow circle number two
(b) small yellow circle number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block B contains a medium black triangle touching the bottom edge, and to its right is a medium black circle. Block C, to the right of Block B, contains two small yellow circles (number one above number two) and two medium yellow circles. Since Block C is directly to the right of Block B, the objects to the right of the medium black circle are the contents of Block C, which include both small yellow circle number one and small yellow circle number two.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in Block C but makes an unsupported assumption about the spatial relationship between the medium black circle (in B) and the contents of Block C, leading to a conclusion that might be factually unsupported by the strict spatial constraints given.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block C is directly to the right of Block B, the objects to the right of the medium black circle are the contents of Block C, which include both small yellow circle number one and small yellow circle number two.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes that the medium black circle (which is to the right of the medium black triangle in Block B) is immediately adjacent to Block C such that Block C's contents are 'to the right' of it. The context only states that Block C is to the right of Block B. It does not specify the exact horizontal position of the medium black circle relative to the boundary between B and C, nor does it state that the contents of C are immediately to the right of the medium black circle.
Answer Span:
Since Block C is directly to the right of Block B, the objects to the right of the medium black circle are the contents of Block C, which include both small yellow circle number one and small yellow circle number two.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C is to the right of block B
Question #2792
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains one medium black square and a medium blue square. It also contains one big blue triangle and one small blue square. Below the small blue...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains one medium black square and a medium blue square. It also contains one big blue triangle and one small blue square. Below the small blue square there is the medium blue square. Above, to the left of and near to the medium black square which is to the right of and below the small blue square is the big blue triangle. Then, we have block B with a small yellow square, a big blue circle and a medium black triangle in it. This block also contains a small yellow triangle. To the right of the small yellow square which is above the big blue circle and the medium black triangle there is the small yellow triangle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the medium black triangle there is a medium black circle. Block C is to the right of block B and below block A. It has two small yellow circles and two other medium yellow circles. Small yellow circle number one is above small yellow circle number two. Medium yellow circle number one is to the left of, above and near to medium yellow circle number two. It is to the right of small yellow circle number two. Below and to the left of medium yellow circle number one is small yellow circle number one. Which object is above a small yellow circle? the medium black circle or the big blue triangle?
(a) the medium black circle
(b) the big blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a big blue triangle, and Block C (below Block A) contains two small yellow circles. Since Block C is below Block A, the big blue triangle is above the small yellow circles. The medium black circle is in Block B, which is separate from Blocks A and C.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies that the big blue triangle in Block A is above the small yellow circles in Block C, which is below Block A. It correctly notes the medium black circle is in Block B, separate from the relevant objects in A and C. The conclusion follows logically from the context provided.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #3270
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of A and block A is to the left of B. Block A contains a big blue square, one big black circle and one big yellow circle. To t...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of A and block A is to the left of B. Block A contains a big blue square, one big black circle and one big yellow circle. To the left of, above and near to the big black circle which is far from and below a medium yellow circle is the big blue square. The big black circle is touching the right edge of this block. Block B contains two medium blue squares. Above medium blue square number two is medium blue square number one. Medium blue square number two is to the right of a small yellow square and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the left edge of this block. Medium blue square number two is touching the right edge of this block. This block also has a medium black square. And block C has a big blue triangle, one medium black square and one small black triangle. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of and below the small black triangle. The big blue triangle is to the right of the small black triangle. It is above the black shape which is to the right of the small black triangle. Which object is to the right of a small black triangle? the square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the triangle which is touching the left edge of a block?
(a) the square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the triangle which is touching the left edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block C contains a small black triangle. The medium black square is to the right of and below the small black triangle, touching the bottom edge of Block C. The big blue triangle is also to the right of the small black triangle, above the medium black square. The medium yellow triangle is in Block B and is not related to the objects in Block C. Therefore, only the square touching the bottom edge of a block (the medium black square) is to the right of the small black triangle.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects to the right of the small black triangle based on the context provided for Block C.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #3269
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of A and block A is to the left of B. Block A contains a big blue square, one big black circle and one big yellow circle. To t...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of A and block A is to the left of B. Block A contains a big blue square, one big black circle and one big yellow circle. To the left of, above and near to the big black circle which is far from and below a medium yellow circle is the big blue square. The big black circle is touching the right edge of this block. Block B contains two medium blue squares. Above medium blue square number two is medium blue square number one. Medium blue square number two is to the right of a small yellow square and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the left edge of this block. Medium blue square number two is touching the right edge of this block. This block also has a medium black square. And block C has a big blue triangle, one medium black square and one small black triangle. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of and below the small black triangle. The big blue triangle is to the right of the small black triangle. It is above the black shape which is to the right of the small black triangle. What is to the right of the small black triangle? a object which is touching the bottom edge of a block or a triangle that is touching the left edge of a block?
(a) object which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) triangle that is touching the left edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block C contains the small black triangle. In the same block, the medium black square is to the right of and below the small black triangle, and the big blue triangle is to the right of the small black triangle and above the medium black square. Block B contains a medium yellow triangle touching the left edge. Neither the medium black square (which is in Block C) nor the medium yellow triangle (which is in Block B) is to the right of the small black triangle in Block C. The big blue triangle, which is in Block C, is to the right of the small black triangle.
Answer: {D}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains a direct contradiction regarding the position of the medium black square relative to the small black triangle, stating it is NOT to the right when the context explicitly says it IS to the right. This error fundamentally undermines the subsequent steps needed to answer the question.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionlow
Statement
Block B contains a medium yellow triangle touching the left edge.
Explanation
The context states that the medium yellow triangle is in Block B, but it is described as being to the left of medium blue square number two, not explicitly stated as touching the left edge of Block B. The context states: 'Medium blue square number two is to the right of a small yellow square and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the left edge of this block.' The 'this block' refers to Block B, as the preceding sentence discusses Block B's contents (medium blue squares). However, the reasoning chain implies the medium yellow triangle is *in* Block B, which is true, but the specific claim about it touching the left edge is only mentioned in relation to Block B's contents, and the reasoning chain uses this to compare it against an object in Block C.
Answer Span:
Block B contains a medium yellow triangle touching the left edge.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium blue square number two is to the right of a small yellow square and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the left edge of this block.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Neither the medium black square (which is in Block C) nor the medium yellow triangle (which is in Block B) is to the right of the small black triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly concludes that the medium black square is not to the right of the small black triangle. The context explicitly states: 'It [the medium black square] is to the right of and below the small black triangle.' The reasoning chain contradicts this fact.
Answer Span:
Neither the medium black square (which is in Block C) nor the medium yellow triangle (which is in Block B) is to the right of the small black triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
It [the medium black square] is to the right of and below the small black triangle.
Question #129
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block C is to the left of B. Block A has one small yellow circle, one small blue square and one big yellow circle. One small...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block C is to the left of B. Block A has one small yellow circle, one small blue square and one big yellow circle. One small black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. The big yellow circle is above and to the left of the small black square.. Below and near to the small blue square which is above the small black square there is the small yellow circle. It is to the right of the circle which is above the small black square. Block B has a medium yellow triangle and one small yellow circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of and below the small yellow circle. Block C has two big yellow triangles. One medium blue triangle is also in this block. There is also a big black square touching the right edge of this block. The medium blue triangle is to the left of, above and near to the big black square. Big yellow triangle number one is to the left of, far from and above the big black square. This block also has a small black square. Big yellow triangle number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. Which object is to the left of a big yellow triangle? the small yellow circle that is in block A or the small yellow circle that is in block B?
(a) the small yellow circle that is in block A
(b) the small yellow circle that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A has a small yellow circle. Block B has a small yellow circle and a medium yellow triangle. Block C has two big yellow triangles and a big black square. Block A is to the left of Block C, and Block C is to the left of Block B. Therefore, the small yellow circle in Block A is to the left of the big yellow triangles in Block C. The small yellow circle in Block B is to the right of the big yellow triangles in Block C.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly establishes the left-to-right order of the blocks (A < C < B). It correctly deduces that the object in A is to the left of the objects in C. However, it incorrectly concludes the final answer based on the relative position of the object in B, which is not explicitly established as being to the right of the objects in C in a way that resolves the question, leading to an incomplete or potentially flawed final step, although the final choice (A) is correct based on the first part of the deduction.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The small yellow circle in Block B is to the right of the big yellow triangles in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning chain concludes that the small yellow circle in Block B is to the right of the big yellow triangles in Block C. While Block C is to the left of Block B, the question asks which object is to the *left* of a big yellow triangle. The reasoning chain fails to establish the relative position of the small yellow circle in Block B with respect to the big yellow triangles in Block C in a way that answers the question, and instead makes an assertion about its position relative to Block C that doesn't directly address the core comparison needed for the final choice.
Answer Span:
The small yellow circle in Block B is to the right of the big yellow triangles in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the left of a big yellow triangle? the small yellow circle that is in block A or the small yellow circle that is in block B?
Question #1505
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One small black square, a medium black circle and a small yellow circle are in block A. Above the medium black circle and the small yellow circle there is the small...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One small black square, a medium black circle and a small yellow circle are in block A. Above the medium black circle and the small yellow circle there is the small black square. The medium black circle is below the small yellow circle. The small yellow circle is touching the right edge of this block. Then, there is block B which contains one big blue square and one small blue square. A big yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big yellow square is to the right of and above the big blue square. Above the small blue square and the big blue square is a medium black square. It is to the left of the square which is to the right of the big blue square. Finally, to the left of block B we have block C. It is to the left of block A. It contains a medium black triangle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a big blue circle. A small blue circle is to the left of and above the medium black triangle. To the left of the big blue circle is the medium black triangle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. Which object is to the right of a big blue circle? the small blue circle or the medium black circle?
(a) the small blue circle
(b) the medium black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block C contains the big blue circle. Block A, to the right of Block C, contains the medium black circle. Since Block A is directly to the right of Block C, the medium black circle is to the right of the big blue circle. The small blue circle is to the left of the big blue circle, within Block C.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the blocks containing the objects but fails to establish the correct spatial relationship needed to answer the final question ('Which object is to the right of a big blue circle?'). It incorrectly concludes the medium black circle is to the right of the big blue circle based on block adjacency without confirming the specific object placement relative to the big blue circle, and it ignores the fact that the small blue circle is to the left of the big blue circle.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block A, to the right of Block C, contains the medium black circle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain claims Block A contains the medium black circle, but the context states the medium black circle is in Block A along with a small black square and a small yellow circle. More importantly, the reasoning chain uses the location of the medium black circle to answer the final question, but the question asks about the medium black circle OR the small blue circle relative to the big blue circle. The context states the medium black circle is in Block A, while the big blue circle is in Block C. The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes the medium black circle is the object being referenced in the final question, which is a possibility, but it fails to establish the relative positions correctly based on block placement.
Answer Span:
Block A, to the right of Block C, contains the medium black circle.
Reference/Question Span:
One small black square, a medium black circle and a small yellow circle are in block A.
missing_contextlow
Statement
The small blue circle is to the left of the big blue circle, within Block C.
Explanation
The context states: 'A small blue circle is to the left of and above the medium black triangle.' and 'To the left of the big blue circle is the medium black triangle.' This implies the small blue circle is to the left of the medium black triangle, which is to the left of the big blue circle. Therefore, the small blue circle is to the left of the big blue circle. However, the reasoning chain asserts the small blue circle is *within* Block C, which is true, but it fails to use the established spatial relationship to answer the final question about what is to the *right* of the big blue circle.
Answer Span:
The small blue circle is to the left of the big blue circle, within Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
A small blue circle is to the left of and above the medium black triangle.
Question #1506
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One small black square, a medium black circle and a small yellow circle are in block A. Above the medium black circle and the small yellow circle there is the small...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One small black square, a medium black circle and a small yellow circle are in block A. Above the medium black circle and the small yellow circle there is the small black square. The medium black circle is below the small yellow circle. The small yellow circle is touching the right edge of this block. Then, there is block B which contains one big blue square and one small blue square. A big yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big yellow square is to the right of and above the big blue square. Above the small blue square and the big blue square is a medium black square. It is to the left of the square which is to the right of the big blue square. Finally, to the left of block B we have block C. It is to the left of block A. It contains a medium black triangle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a big blue circle. A small blue circle is to the left of and above the medium black triangle. To the left of the big blue circle is the medium black triangle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. What is to the right of the small blue circle? a small black square or a medium black circle?
(a) small black square
(b) medium black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block C contains the small blue circle, and Block A (to the right of Block C) contains the small black square and the medium black circle. Since both the small black square and the medium black circle are in Block A, which is to the right of Block C where the small blue circle is located, both of these shapes are to the right of the small blue circle.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes a factual error by stating the small blue circle is in Block C, and then uses this flawed premise to incorrectly conclude that both options are to the right of the small blue circle, ignoring the actual spatial relationship required by the question.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block C contains the small blue circle
Explanation
The context states Block C contains a medium black triangle and a big blue circle. It does not state it contains the small blue circle.
Answer Span:
Block C contains the small blue circle
Reference/Question Span:
Finally, to the left of block B we have block C. It is to the left of block A. It contains a medium black triangle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a big blue circle.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since both the small black square and the medium black circle are in Block A, which is to the right of Block C where the small blue circle is located, both of these shapes are to the right of the small blue circle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes the small blue circle is in Block C. The question states the small blue circle is to the left of and above the medium black triangle (which is in C), but it never explicitly states the small blue circle is *in* Block C. More importantly, the reasoning relies on the location of the small blue circle to determine the answer, but the relationship between the small blue circle and the objects in Block A (small black square or medium black circle) is not established in the text.
Answer Span:
Since both the small black square and the medium black circle are in Block A, which is to the right of Block C where the small blue circle is located, both of these shapes are to the right of the small blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the right of the small blue circle? a small black square or a medium black circle?
Question #3097
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one big yellow triangle, one medium yellow square and a small blue circle. The big yellow triangle is above and to the right of a medium ye...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one big yellow triangle, one medium yellow square and a small blue circle. The big yellow triangle is above and to the right of a medium yellow triangle. Above the medium yellow triangle there is the small blue circle. The medium yellow square is touching the top edge of this block. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and above the medium yellow triangle is the medium yellow square. Above block A we have block B with two medium yellow squares in it. This block also has a medium yellow circle. The medium yellow circle is to the left of and above medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Finally, we have block C to the right of block B. It has two medium yellow triangles and two small yellow circles. Below small yellow circle number one and medium yellow triangle number two there is medium yellow triangle number one. Small yellow circle number one is above and to the left of small yellow circle number two. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow circle or the medium yellow square that is touching the top edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow circle
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the top edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium yellow square touching the top edge, and Block B (above Block A) contains medium yellow squares and a medium yellow circle. The medium yellow circle is above medium yellow square number two, which is above medium yellow square number one. Since Block B is directly above Block A, the objects below the medium yellow square (touching the top edge of Block A) are the medium yellow squares and circle in Block B.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain completely fails to analyze the spatial relationships required to answer the question based on the options provided. It incorrectly relates objects in Block B (above) to objects in Block A, and ignores the actual question structure.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B is directly above Block A, the objects below the medium yellow square (touching the top edge of Block A) are the medium yellow squares and circle in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly assumes that the objects *below* the medium yellow square touching the top edge of Block A are the objects *in* Block B. Block B is *above* Block A. The question asks which object is *below* a medium yellow square (referring to the options provided). The reasoning chain seems to confuse the spatial relationship or misinterprets what is being asked relative to the options.
Answer Span:
the objects below the medium yellow square (touching the top edge of Block A) are the medium yellow squares and circle in Block B
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow circle or the medium yellow square that is touching the top edge of a block?
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B is directly above Block A, the objects below the medium yellow square (touching the top edge of Block A) are the medium yellow squares and circle in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning chain attempts to answer the question by looking at objects *above* Block A (in Block B) relative to an object *in* Block A. The question asks which of the two *options* (medium yellow circle OR medium yellow square touching the top edge of a block) is *below* *a* medium yellow square. The reasoning ignores the options entirely and tries to establish a relationship between Block A and Block B objects.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is directly above Block A, the objects below the medium yellow square (touching the top edge of Block A) are the medium yellow squares and circle in Block B
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow circle or the medium yellow square that is touching the top edge of a block?
Question #1952
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are two medium blue squares in block A. This block also contains a small blue square. This block also contains a medium black triangle. One big...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are two medium blue squares in block A. This block also contains a small blue square. This block also contains a medium black triangle. One big black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium blue square number one is to the left of and above medium blue square number two. Below the medium black triangle there is the small blue square. A small yellow circle is far from and above the big black square. Block B is above block A. It has one big yellow circle, one small blue circle and one medium blue triangle. This block also contains one small yellow square. The big yellow circle is to the left of and above the medium blue triangle. This object is near to the small blue circle which is to the left of, above and near to the medium blue triangle. To the right of block B there is block C. It contains two small black circles. It also contains one medium black square. Small black circle number one is below small black circle number two. The medium black square is below and to the right of small black circle number two. What is to the right of the small yellow square? a small black circle or a big black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) small black circle
(b) big black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block B contains the small yellow square, and Block C, to the right of Block B, contains the small black circles. Therefore, a small black circle is to the right of the small yellow square. The big black square is in Block A, which is below Block B, so it's not to the right of the small yellow square.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the blocks containing the relevant objects (small yellow square in B, small black circles in C, big black square in A). However, it fails to incorporate the specific positional constraint of the big black square (touching the bottom edge) into its evaluation of the options, and it makes an unsubstantiated leap regarding the relative position of the small black circle to the small yellow square, ignoring the need to check the spatial relationship between objects in adjacent blocks.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The big black square is in Block A, which is below Block B, so it's not to the right of the small yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning correctly identifies the big black square is in Block A, but it ignores the crucial positional information that the big black square is *touching the bottom edge of this block* (Block A). This detail is part of the options provided in the question and should have been retained if the reasoning was to correctly evaluate the options.
Answer Span:
The big black square is in Block A, which is below Block B, so it's not to the right of the small yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
One big black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Therefore, a small black circle is to the right of the small yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning concludes that a small black circle is to the right of the small yellow square based on Block B being to the left of Block C. However, it fails to establish the relative position of the *small yellow square* within Block B relative to the *small black circles* in Block C. The question asks what is to the right of the small yellow square. The reasoning only establishes that Block C (containing small black circles) is to the right of Block B (containing the small yellow square), but it doesn't confirm if the small black circle is *immediately* or *generally* to the right of the small yellow square, which is necessary to evaluate option (a) against the specific spatial relationship implied by the question structure.
Answer Span:
Therefore, a small black circle is to the right of the small yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the right of the small yellow square? a small black circle or a big black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #2215
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are one medium black square, one medium black triangle and one small yellow triangle in block A. To the left of a small yellow square is the medi...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are one medium black square, one medium black triangle and one small yellow triangle in block A. To the left of a small yellow square is the medium black square. The small yellow triangle is to the left of and below the small yellow square. The medium black triangle is to the right of and above the yellow object which is to the left of the small yellow square. Block B is below block A. It contains a big black square, a medium blue square and a small yellow square. Above a small black triangle there is the small yellow square. This block also has a small yellow triangle. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. The big black square is below the small yellow square and the small black triangle.. It is to the right of the small yellow triangle. Finally, there is block C which is to the right of block A. It has one small blue triangle and one medium yellow square. Near to and to the left of the medium yellow square there is the small blue triangle. What is below the medium black triangle? a small blue triangle or a small yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) small blue triangle
(b) small yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains the medium black triangle. Block B, below Block A, contains a small yellow square touching the right edge. Since Block B is directly below Block A, the object below the medium black triangle is the small yellow square touching the right edge of Block B. The small blue triangle is in Block C, which is to the right of Block A, not below it.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsubstantiated assumption about vertical alignment between objects in Block A and Block B, leading to a conclusion based on faulty spatial reasoning relative to the provided context. It fails to establish the actual object below the medium black triangle.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B is directly below Block A, the object below the medium black triangle is the small yellow square touching the right edge of Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes the medium black triangle in Block A is directly above the small yellow square in Block B. The context only establishes the relative positions of the blocks (B is below A) and the objects within them, but does not state that the medium black triangle is vertically aligned with the small yellow square.
Answer Span:
the object below the medium black triangle is the small yellow square touching the right edge of Block B
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is below block A.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The small blue triangle is in Block C, which is to the right of block A, not below it.
Explanation
The reasoning correctly identifies the location of the small blue triangle (Block C, right of A), but this information is irrelevant to answering the question: 'What is below the medium black triangle?'. The reasoning uses this fact to dismiss option (a) without establishing the actual vertical relationship between the medium black triangle and the small blue triangle.
Answer Span:
The small blue triangle is in Block C, which is to the right of block A, not below it.
Reference/Question Span:
What is below the medium black triangle?
Question #3098
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one big yellow triangle, one medium yellow square and a small blue circle. The big yellow triangle is above and to the right of a medium ye...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one big yellow triangle, one medium yellow square and a small blue circle. The big yellow triangle is above and to the right of a medium yellow triangle. Above the medium yellow triangle there is the small blue circle. The medium yellow square is touching the top edge of this block. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and above the medium yellow triangle is the medium yellow square. Above block A we have block B with two medium yellow squares in it. This block also has a medium yellow circle. The medium yellow circle is to the left of and above medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Finally, we have block C to the right of block B. It has two medium yellow triangles and two small yellow circles. Below small yellow circle number one and medium yellow triangle number two there is medium yellow triangle number one. Small yellow circle number one is above and to the left of small yellow circle number two. What is to the right of the object which is touching the bottom edge of a block? a big object or a medium thing which is touching the top edge of a block?
(a) big object
(b) medium thing which is touching the top edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium yellow triangle touching the bottom edge. The medium yellow square is touching the top edge of Block A and is also to the right of the medium yellow triangle. The big yellow triangle is also to the right of the medium yellow triangle. Thus, both a big object (the big yellow triangle) and a medium thing touching the top edge of a block (the medium yellow square) are to the right of the object touching the bottom edge of Block A.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the object touching the bottom edge of Block A (medium yellow triangle) and then checks the relative positions of the two candidate objects (big yellow triangle and medium yellow square) based on the context. The conclusion derived from the reasoning matches the final answer choice.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #11
There are three blocks, A, B and C. A medium yellow triangle, one big black square and a big blue square are in block A. This block also contains one medium black circle. The medium black circle is to...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. A medium yellow triangle, one big black square and a big blue square are in block A. This block also contains one medium black circle. The medium black circle is to the right of the big black square and the big blue square. The medium yellow triangle is far from the big blue square. This block also has a big blue triangle. It is touching the right edge of this block. Near to the big blue triangle is the medium black circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the big black square there is the medium yellow triangle. To the left of block A we have block B with a medium yellow circle and a medium yellow triangle in it. It also has one big yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is above and to the left of the big yellow triangle. The medium yellow circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the big yellow triangle. Above block A there is block C which contains one small black square and one medium blue circle. To the left of the medium blue circle is the small black square. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow triangle? the big blue triangle or the medium yellow circle?
(a) the big blue triangle
(b) the medium yellow circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium yellow triangle and a big blue triangle. The medium yellow triangle is stated to be touching the right edge of this block, and the big blue triangle is also touching the right edge of this block. This implies they are likely overlapping or at least sharing the same edge. Block B, to the left of A, contains a medium yellow circle. Since Block B is to the left of Block A, the medium yellow circle is not to the right of the medium yellow triangle. Therefore, only the big blue triangle is to the right of the medium yellow triangle.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an incomplete list of objects in Block A and then draws a conclusion about the relative positions of objects based on block location (B left of A) without checking the specific positional constraints given in the context for the medium yellow triangle (in A or B) and the medium yellow circle (in B).
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block A contains a medium yellow triangle and a big blue triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly states that Block A contains a big blue triangle. The context states: 'This block also has a big blue triangle.' referring to Block A, but the reasoning chain omits other objects in Block A when listing them, and then incorrectly uses the location of the big blue triangle relative to the medium yellow triangle in Block A.
Answer Span:
Block A contains a medium yellow triangle and a big blue triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
a medium yellow triangle, one big black square and a big blue square are in block A. This block also contains one medium black circle. . . This block also has a big blue triangle.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B is to the left of Block A, the medium yellow circle is not to the right of the medium yellow triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning ignores the relative positions *within* the blocks or the specific question asked. The question asks which object is to the right of the medium yellow triangle (which is in Block A or B). The reasoning incorrectly dismisses the medium yellow circle (in Block B) based only on Block B being to the left of Block A, ignoring that the medium yellow triangle is also in Block B, and the question asks about the object to the right of *a* medium yellow triangle.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is to the left of Block A, the medium yellow circle is not to the right of the medium yellow triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium yellow triangle? the big blue triangle or the medium yellow circle?
Question #128
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block C is to the left of B. Block A has one small yellow circle, one small blue square and one big yellow circle. One small...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block C is to the left of B. Block A has one small yellow circle, one small blue square and one big yellow circle. One small black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. The big yellow circle is above and to the left of the small black square.. Below and near to the small blue square which is above the small black square there is the small yellow circle. It is to the right of the circle which is above the small black square. Block B has a medium yellow triangle and one small yellow circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of and below the small yellow circle. Block C has two big yellow triangles. One medium blue triangle is also in this block. There is also a big black square touching the right edge of this block. The medium blue triangle is to the left of, above and near to the big black square. Big yellow triangle number one is to the left of, far from and above the big black square. This block also has a small black square. Big yellow triangle number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow triangle? the big yellow circle or the small blue square?
(a) the big yellow circle
(b) the small blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains the big yellow circle and the small blue square. Block B contains the medium yellow triangle. Since Block A is to the left of Block C, and Block C is to the left of Block B, both the big yellow circle and the small blue square are to the left of the medium yellow triangle.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in Block A (which contains the big yellow circle and small blue square) and Block B (which contains the medium yellow triangle). It correctly uses the positional information (A is left of C, C is left of B) to conclude that objects in A are to the left of objects in B, thus answering the question.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1559
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block C and it is below block A. Block A contains two medium blue circles. To the left of medium blue circle number two the...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block C and it is below block A. Block A contains two medium blue circles. To the left of medium blue circle number two there is medium blue circle number one. Block B contains one medium black square and one big blue triangle. The medium black square is above a medium blue circle. The medium blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below and to the left of the big blue triangle. Block C contains two medium yellow squares and two other big black circles. Medium yellow square number one is above big black circle number one. Medium yellow square number two is touching the right edge of this block. Big black circle number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is below big black circle number two. It is near to and to the left of medium yellow square number two. Which object is to the right of a big blue object? the medium blue circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block B contains a big blue triangle. Block C, to the right of Block B, contains a medium yellow square touching the right edge (medium yellow square number two). The medium blue circle touching the bottom edge of a block is also in Block B, so it is not to the right of the big blue triangle. Since medium yellow square number two is in Block C which is to the right of the big blue triangle in Block B.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly frames the comparison and misses crucial positional information needed to answer the question correctly. It focuses only on Block B objects relative to the triangle in Block B, ignoring the possibility of the objects being to the right of the big blue circles in Block C.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The medium blue circle touching the bottom edge of a block is also in Block B, so it is not to the right of the big blue triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes the comparison is relative to the big blue triangle, but the question asks which object is to the right of *a* big blue object. The reasoning chain fails to check if the medium blue circle is to the right of the big blue circles in Block C, or if the medium yellow square is to the right of the big blue triangle in Block B. More critically, it ignores the fact that the medium blue circle is *below and to the left* of the big blue triangle in Block B, making the conclusion about its position relative to the triangle irrelevant to the final comparison required by the question.
Answer Span:
The medium blue circle touching the bottom edge of a block is also in Block B, so it is not to the right of the big blue triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a big blue object? the medium blue circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block?
Question #1887
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C and block C is below B. Block A has one big blue circle, one big black square and one big yellow triangle. Above, to the right of and near...
3 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C and block C is below B. Block A has one big blue circle, one big black square and one big yellow triangle. Above, to the right of and near to a medium black square which is to the left of and below the big yellow triangle there is the big blue circle. This block also has a big black circle. The big black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of the medium object which is to the left of the big yellow triangle. Block B contains one big yellow circle, a big blue square and one big yellow triangle. The big yellow circle is to the right of and above the big yellow triangle. This shape is touching the right edge of this block. Above the big yellow triangle is the big blue square. And block C has one small yellow circle, a small yellow square and a big yellow circle. To the left of the small yellow square and the big yellow circle there is the small yellow circle. The big yellow circle is touching the right edge of this block. The small yellow square is below the big yellow circle. What is to the right of the big blue circle? a big yellow circle which is in block B or a big yellow circle which is in block C?
(a) big yellow circle which is in block B
(b) big yellow circle which is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains the big blue circle. Block B, which is above Block C and to the right of Block A, contains a big yellow circle. Block C also contains a big yellow circle. Since Block B is to the right of Block A, the big yellow circle in Block B is to the right of the big blue circle in Block A. The big yellow circle in Block C is not to the right of the big blue circle, as Block C is below Block A.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsupported assumption about the relative horizontal position of Block B to Block A ('Block B... to the right of Block A') and uses the vertical relationship ('Block C is below Block A') to incorrectly dismiss the possibility of the object in C being to the right of the object in A, ignoring that the question asks about the location of the big blue circle in A relative to objects in B and C.
Detected Issues (3)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block B, which is above Block C and to the right of Block A, contains a big yellow circle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain asserts Block B is to the right of Block A, but the context only states 'Block A is to the left of C and block C is below B'. This implies A is to the left of C, and B is above C. The relative position of A and B is not explicitly defined as 'B is to the right of A'.
Answer Span:
Block B, which is above Block C and to the right of Block A
Reference/Question Span:
Block A is to the left of C and block C is below B
contradictionlow
Statement
Block C also contains a big yellow circle.
Explanation
The context states Block C has 'one small yellow circle, a small yellow square and a big yellow circle'. The reasoning chain incorrectly states Block C contains 'a big yellow circle' when the context explicitly lists the contents of Block C as 'one small yellow circle, a small yellow square and a big yellow circle'. Wait, re-reading the context: 'And block C has one small yellow circle, a small yellow square and a big yellow circle.' The reasoning chain states 'Block C also contains a big yellow circle.' This is factually correct based on the context. However, the reasoning chain later uses this fact to conclude C is below A, which is not directly supported by the context for the purpose of answering the question about relative position to the blue circle in A.
Answer Span:
Block C also contains a big yellow circle.
Reference/Question Span:
And block C has one small yellow circle, a small yellow square and a big yellow circle.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The big yellow circle in Block C is not to the right of the big blue circle, as Block C is below Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning chain uses the spatial relationship 'Block C is below Block A' to conclude that the object in C cannot be to the right of the object in A. While the context establishes C is below B, and A is to the left of C, it does not explicitly define the relationship between A and C in the horizontal plane necessary to dismiss the object in C as being to the right of the object in A. The reasoning relies on an assumption about the 2D layout not fully specified.
Answer Span:
The big yellow circle in Block C is not to the right of the big blue circle, as Block C is below Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A is to the left of C and block C is below B
Question #3493
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the right of A. Block B is above C. Block A contains one small yellow triangle, one small blue circle and a big black square. A big blue triangle is t...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the right of A. Block B is above C. Block A contains one small yellow triangle, one small blue circle and a big black square. A big blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. It is to the right of the small yellow triangle , the big black square and the small blue circle. The small yellow triangle is below the small blue circle. This block also has a big yellow triangle. Block B has a medium yellow circle, one small black square and a big black square. Above the big black square there is the small black square. The medium yellow circle is near to and above the big black square. Block C contains one big black circle, a medium black triangle and a medium blue triangle. To the left of a small yellow square which is to the right of and near to the medium blue triangle there is the big black circle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of the medium blue triangle. This shape is below the small yellow square. Which object is to the right of a big black square? the small yellow square or the medium black triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small yellow square
(b) the medium black triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains a big black square, and Block C contains a medium black triangle touching the bottom edge and a small yellow square. Block C is to the right of Block A. Therefore, both the small yellow square and the medium black triangle are to the right of the big black square.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes unsupported assumptions about the contents of Block C and fails to establish the necessary spatial relationship (Block A vs Block C) required to answer the question about what is to the right of the big black square (in A).
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C contains a medium black triangle touching the bottom edge and a small yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly places the small yellow square in Block C. The context states the small yellow square is to the right of and near to the medium blue triangle within Block C, but it does not explicitly state the small yellow square is *in* Block C, only that the medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge *of this block* (Block C). More critically, the reasoning chain implies the small yellow square is an object *in* Block C, which is not explicitly stated, whereas the context only places the medium black triangle touching the bottom edge of Block C.
Answer Span:
Block C contains a medium black triangle touching the bottom edge and a small yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C contains one big black circle, a medium black triangle and a medium blue triangle. To the left of a small yellow square which is to the right of and near to the medium blue triangle there is the big black circle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Therefore, both the small yellow square and the medium black triangle are to the right of the big black square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain fails to establish the spatial relationship between the big black square (located in Block A) and the objects it claims are to its right (the small yellow square and medium black triangle, which are associated with Block C). The question asks which object is to the right of the big black square, which requires comparing the location of the big black square (in A) with the location of the small yellow square and medium black triangle (in C). The reasoning chain skips this crucial step of relating Block A's contents/location to Block C's contents/location, relying instead on an unsupported assertion about the objects' relative positions.
Answer Span:
Therefore, both the small yellow square and the medium black triangle are to the right of the big black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C is to the right of A. Block B is above C. Block A contains one small yellow triangle, one small blue circle and a big black square. . . Block C contains one big black circle, a medium black triangle and a medium blue triangle. To the left of a small yellow square which is to the right of and near to the medium blue triangle there is the big black circle.
Question #12
There are three blocks, A, B and C. A medium yellow triangle, one big black square and a big blue square are in block A. This block also contains one medium black circle. The medium black circle is to...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. A medium yellow triangle, one big black square and a big blue square are in block A. This block also contains one medium black circle. The medium black circle is to the right of the big black square and the big blue square. The medium yellow triangle is far from the big blue square. This block also has a big blue triangle. It is touching the right edge of this block. Near to the big blue triangle is the medium black circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the big black square there is the medium yellow triangle. To the left of block A we have block B with a medium yellow circle and a medium yellow triangle in it. It also has one big yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is above and to the left of the big yellow triangle. The medium yellow circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the big yellow triangle. Above block A there is block C which contains one small black square and one medium blue circle. To the left of the medium blue circle is the small black square. What is below the small shape? a medium black circle or a big blue square?
(a) medium black circle
(b) big blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block C contains a small black square, and Block A (below C) contains a medium black circle and a big blue square. Since the small black square is in Block C and is above the medium black circle and big blue square, both shapes are below it in Block A.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsupported assumption about the vertical alignment between objects in Block C and Block A, leading to a conclusion based on missing spatial context.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since the small black square is in Block C and is above the medium black circle and big blue square, both shapes are below it in Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes the small black square in Block C is directly above the medium black circle and big blue square in Block A, which is not explicitly stated or derivable from the context. The context only states Block C is 'Above block A'.
Answer Span:
Since the small black square is in Block C and is above the medium black circle and big blue square, both shapes are below it in Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Above block A there is block C which contains one small black square and one medium blue circle.
Question #1953
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are two medium blue squares in block A. This block also contains a small blue square. This block also contains a medium black triangle. One big...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are two medium blue squares in block A. This block also contains a small blue square. This block also contains a medium black triangle. One big black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium blue square number one is to the left of and above medium blue square number two. Below the medium black triangle there is the small blue square. A small yellow circle is far from and above the big black square. Block B is above block A. It has one big yellow circle, one small blue circle and one medium blue triangle. This block also contains one small yellow square. The big yellow circle is to the left of and above the medium blue triangle. This object is near to the small blue circle which is to the left of, above and near to the medium blue triangle. To the right of block B there is block C. It contains two small black circles. It also contains one medium black square. Small black circle number one is below small black circle number two. The medium black square is below and to the right of small black circle number two. Which object is to the left of a small black circle? the small blue circle or the medium blue triangle?
(a) the small blue circle
(b) the medium blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block B contains a small blue circle and a medium blue triangle. Block C, to the right of Block B, contains two small black circles. The small blue circle is to the left of the medium blue triangle, and both are in Block B. Since Block B is to the left of Block C, the small blue circle is to the left of the small black circles. The medium blue triangle is also to the left of the small black circles, as it is in the same block (B) as the small blue circle and to its left.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly deduces the relative positions of the small blue circle and the medium blue triangle, leading to an incorrect justification for why the medium blue triangle is to the left of the small black circles. The source states the small blue circle is to the left of the medium blue triangle, but the reasoning chain implies the opposite relationship when concluding the medium blue triangle is to the left of the small black circles based on its position relative to the small blue circle.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The small blue circle is to the left of the medium blue triangle, and both are in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning chain claims the small blue circle is to the left of the medium blue triangle. The context states: 'This object [big yellow circle] is near to the small blue circle which is to the left of, above and near to the medium blue triangle.' This means the small blue circle is to the left of the medium blue triangle, but the reasoning chain incorrectly implies the relationship is established directly between the two objects without referencing the complex positional description given in the source text, although the resulting positional relationship stated here ('small blue circle is to the left of the medium blue triangle') is actually consistent with the source text. However, the reasoning chain then states: 'The medium blue triangle is also to the left of the small black circles, as it is in the same block (B) as the small blue circle and to its left.' This implies the medium blue triangle is to the left of the small blue circle, which contradicts the source text: 'the small blue circle which is to the left of... the medium blue triangle.'
Answer Span:
The small blue circle is to the left of the medium blue triangle, and both are in Block B. Since Block B is to the left of Block C, the small blue circle is to the left of the small black circles. The medium blue triangle is also to the left of the small black circles, as it is in the same block (B) as the small blue circle and to its left.
Reference/Question Span:
This object is near to the small blue circle which is to the left of, above and near to the medium blue triangle.
Question #3314
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains one big yellow square, one small yellow circle and one medium black square. Below the medium black square is the big yellow square. ...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains one big yellow square, one small yellow circle and one medium black square. Below the medium black square is the big yellow square. The small yellow circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of the medium black square. The big yellow square is above the small yellow circle. Block B is to the left of block A. It contains two medium blue triangles. It also contains one small blue circle. Above a medium black triangle there is the small blue circle. Medium blue triangle number one is to the right of medium blue triangle number two. To the left of and touching medium blue triangle number two there is the medium black triangle. The small blue circle is above the triangle which is to the right of medium blue triangle number two. Medium blue triangle number one is touching the right edge of this block. Finally, we have block C. It is below block A. It has one big black square. A big blue square is to the right of the big black square. What is to the left of the big yellow square? a big blue square or a medium blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) big blue square
(b) medium blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains the big yellow square. Block B, to the left of Block A, contains the medium blue triangles and the small blue circle. The big blue square is in Block C, which is below Block A, not to its left. So, the medium blue triangle touching the right edge of Block B (medium blue triangle number one) is to the left of the big yellow square. The big blue square is not to the left of the big yellow square.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes unsupported spatial claims about the relative positions of objects in Block B and Block C relative to the object in Block A, leading to a conclusion that cannot be verified or derived solely from the context provided.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
So, the medium blue triangle touching the right edge of Block B (medium blue triangle number one) is to the left of the big yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain claims that medium blue triangle number one is to the left of the big yellow square. The question only establishes the relative positions of Block B (left of A) and the contents of Block A (which contains the big yellow square). It does not state that any object in Block B is to the left of the big yellow square, which is in Block A. This conclusion relies on an unstated spatial relationship.
Answer Span:
So, the medium blue triangle touching the right edge of Block B (medium blue triangle number one) is to the left of the big yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains one big yellow square, one small yellow circle and one medium black square. . . Block B is to the left of block A.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The big blue square is not to the left of the big yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain asserts that the big blue square is not to the left of the big yellow square. The question establishes the big blue square is in Block C, which is below Block A (where the big yellow square is). The question asks what *is* to the left of the big yellow square, and the reasoning chain fails to establish the actual spatial relationship between the big blue square (Block C) and the big yellow square (Block A) based on the provided context, instead making an unsupported negative assertion.
Answer Span:
The big blue square is not to the left of the big yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the left of the big yellow square? a big blue square or a medium blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block?
Question #2085
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is above A. Block A contains one small black circle. It also contains a medium yellow square. It also contains one medium ye...
3 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is above A. Block A contains one small black circle. It also contains a medium yellow square. It also contains one medium yellow circle. The small black circle is above the medium yellow square. To the left of and above the medium yellow square there is the medium yellow circle. Block B has a medium blue circle. There are also one small blue triangle and one small black circle in this block. To the left of the small black circle is the small blue triangle. To the right of and below the small black circle is the medium blue circle. And block C contains two small blue triangles. Small blue triangle number one is touching the top edge of this block. Small blue triangle number two is touching the right edge of this block. Near to and above a big yellow square there is small blue triangle number one. This object is to the left of small blue triangle number two. Which object is above a small black circle? the small blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block or the square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
3
Generated Answer
Block A contains a small black circle, a medium yellow square, and a medium yellow circle. Block B, which is above Block A, contains a medium blue circle, a small blue triangle, and a small black circle. Block C, to the left of Block B, contains two small blue triangles and a big yellow square. The question asks what is above the small black circle in Block A. Since Block B is above Block A, and the small black circle in Block B is not specified as being directly above the small black circle in Block A, neither the small blue triangle (number two) touching the right edge of Block C nor the big yellow square in Block C is directly above the small black circle in Block A.
Answer: {D}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes several factual errors regarding the location of the big yellow square and incorrectly focuses the analysis only on the small black circle in Block A, ignoring the positional constraints provided for the objects listed in the options relative to *a* small black circle.
Detected Issues (3)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block C, to the left of Block B, contains two small blue triangles and a big yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly states that Block C contains a big yellow square. The context states that near to and above a big yellow square there is small blue triangle number one (which is in Block C), but it never states the big yellow square is *in* Block C.
Answer Span:
Block C, to the left of Block B, contains two small blue triangles and a big yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Near to and above a big yellow square there is small blue triangle number one.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B is above Block A, and the small black circle in Block B is not specified as being directly above the small black circle in Block A, neither the small blue triangle (number two) touching the right edge of Block C nor the big yellow square in Block C is directly above the small black circle in Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly assumes the question is asking about the small black circle in Block A. The question asks: 'Which object is above a small black circle? the small blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block or the square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?'. The context describes two small black circles: one in A and one in B. The reasoning fails to check the relative positions of the candidate objects against *both* small black circles mentioned in the context, or correctly identify which small black circle the options refer to (if any). Crucially, it ignores the positional information given for the objects mentioned in the options.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is above Block A, and the small black circle in Block B is not specified as being directly above the small black circle in Block A, neither the small blue triangle (number two) touching the right edge of Block C nor the big yellow square in Block C is directly above the small black circle in Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is above a small black circle? the small blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block or the square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
missing_contexthigh
Statement
neither the small blue triangle (number two) touching the right edge of Block C nor the big yellow square in Block C is directly above the small black circle in Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly identifies the location of the objects mentioned in the options. Option (a) refers to 'the small blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block'. The context states: 'Small blue triangle number two is touching the right edge of this block [Block C]'. The reasoning incorrectly places this object relative to Block C, and then incorrectly dismisses it based on the location of the small black circle in Block A, ignoring the positional data provided for the objects in the options.
Answer Span:
neither the small blue triangle (number two) touching the right edge of Block C nor the big yellow square in Block C is directly above the small black circle in Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Small blue triangle number two is touching the right edge of this block.
Question #2583
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is to the right of A and block C is above B. Block A contains a medium black circle. It also has a medium yellow triangle. This block also contains one medi...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is to the right of A and block C is above B. Block A contains a medium black circle. It also has a medium yellow triangle. This block also contains one medium black square. It is to the left of and above the medium black circle. The medium black circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium yellow triangle is below the medium black circle. It is to the right of the medium black square. Block B has one big yellow square and a small black square. There is also a big black square touching the right edge of this block. This shape is below and to the right of the small black square. The big yellow square is below the square which is below the small black square. And block C contains a big yellow triangle, one big blue square and one small black square. The big blue square is below and near to the small black square. The big yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. This shape is above the big blue square. It is to the right of the small black square. Which object is above a big black square? the circle which is touching the right edge of a block or the big blue square?
(a) the circle which is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the big blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium black circle touching its right edge. Block B, to the right of A, contains a big black square. Block C, above B, contains a big blue square. Thus, the big blue square in Block C is above the big black square in Block B. The medium black circle is in Block A, not above the big black square.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an assumption about the vertical relationship between objects in Block C and Block B based only on the block arrangement, ignoring the need for specific positional data. It also incorrectly implies the big blue square is the only object in C relevant to the comparison, although it correctly identifies the block contents.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block C, above B, contains a big blue square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly states that the big blue square is in Block C. The context states Block C contains a big yellow triangle, one big blue square and one small black square. The reasoning chain then uses the location of the big blue square in Block C to determine its vertical relationship with the big black square in Block B, which is a crucial step in the final answer derivation that relies on an incorrect premise about the location of the big blue square relative to the big black square.
Answer Span:
Block C, above B, contains a big blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has one big yellow square and a small black square. There is also a big black square touching the right edge of this block. . . And block C contains a big yellow triangle, one big blue square and one small black square.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Thus, the big blue square in Block C is above the big black square in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning chain asserts that the big blue square (in C) is above the big black square (in B) based on the block arrangement (C is above B). However, the question asks which object is above the big black square, which is located in Block B. The reasoning chain correctly identifies the block arrangement (C is above B), but it fails to use the specific positional information given for the big blue square within Block C relative to the big black square in Block B, which is necessary to confirm the vertical relationship required by the question. The context states: 'The big blue square is below and near to the small black square' (in C). The relationship between objects in C and objects in B is not explicitly defined as 'above' just because C is above B, unless specified. The reasoning chain skips checking the specific positional relationship.
Answer Span:
Thus, the big blue square in Block C is above the big black square in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is above a big black square?
Question #1826
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Me...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below the medium blue square.. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and the medium blue square. Below block A there is block B with a medium blue square and one medium yellow square in it. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square and a medium black square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Below block B there is block C. It has two medium blue squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium blue square number two. It is below the yellow object which is below medium blue square number two. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block B?
(a) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium black square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains two medium black squares and a medium blue square. Medium black square number one is at the bottom of Block A. Block B, below Block A, contains a medium blue square and a medium yellow square, with the medium blue square below the medium yellow square and a medium black square. Block C is below Block B. The question asks what is below the medium yellow square in Block B. That would be the medium black square also in Block B. The medium black square touching the bottom edge of a block is in Block A, not below the medium yellow square in question.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the object below the yellow square in Block B, but it incorrectly dismisses the first option by assuming the black square touching the bottom edge of a block must be in Block A and therefore irrelevant to the comparison, failing to check if that specific black square is below *any* yellow square mentioned in the context, which is what the question asks.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The medium black square touching the bottom edge of a block is in Block A, not below the medium yellow square in question.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes the medium black square touching the bottom edge of a block is in Block A, when the question asks to compare two specific black squares: one touching the bottom edge of *a* block (which could be A or C, as C has no black squares mentioned, it must be A) and the one in Block B. The reasoning chain fails to check if the black square touching the bottom edge of a block (which is in Block A) is below *any* medium yellow square mentioned in the context, instead focusing only on the yellow square in Block B.
Answer Span:
The medium black square touching the bottom edge of a block is in Block A, not below the medium yellow square in question.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block B?
Question #1888
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C and block C is below B. Block A has one big blue circle, one big black square and one big yellow triangle. Above, to the right of and near...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C and block C is below B. Block A has one big blue circle, one big black square and one big yellow triangle. Above, to the right of and near to a medium black square which is to the left of and below the big yellow triangle there is the big blue circle. This block also has a big black circle. The big black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of the medium object which is to the left of the big yellow triangle. Block B contains one big yellow circle, a big blue square and one big yellow triangle. The big yellow circle is to the right of and above the big yellow triangle. This shape is touching the right edge of this block. Above the big yellow triangle is the big blue square. And block C has one small yellow circle, a small yellow square and a big yellow circle. To the left of the small yellow square and the big yellow circle there is the small yellow circle. The big yellow circle is touching the right edge of this block. The small yellow square is below the big yellow circle. Which object is to the left of a big yellow circle? the small yellow circle or the big blue square?
(a) the small yellow circle
(b) the big blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains a big blue circle, a big black square, and a big yellow triangle. Block B contains a big yellow circle, a big blue square, and a big yellow triangle. Block C contains a small yellow circle, a small yellow square, and a big yellow circle. The question asks what is to the left of a big yellow circle. In Block C, the small yellow circle is to the left of the big yellow circle. The big blue square is in Block B, which is above Block C, so it's not to the left of the big yellow circle in Block C. Block B also has a big yellow circle, but nothing is described as being to its left.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the small yellow circle as being to the left of the big yellow circle in Block C. However, it fails to fully evaluate the big blue square against the big yellow circle in Block B, incorrectly dismissing it based on block location rather than checking the positional constraints provided in the text for Block B.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The big blue square is in Block B, which is above Block C, so it's not to the left of the big yellow circle in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning correctly identifies that the small yellow circle is to the left of the big yellow circle in Block C. However, it incorrectly dismisses the big blue square based on spatial relationships (Block B is above Block C) without checking if the big blue square is *also* described as being to the left of *any* big yellow circle mentioned in the context. The question asks which object is to the left of *a* big yellow circle, implying we must check all big yellow circles mentioned. The reasoning chain only checks the one in Block C and makes an assumption about the relative positions of the blocks (A left of C, C below B) to dismiss the object in Block B, rather than checking the specific relationships described for the objects within Block B.
Answer Span:
The big blue square is in Block B, which is above Block C, so it's not to the left of the big yellow circle in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the left of a big yellow circle? the small yellow circle or the big blue square?
Question #1825
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Me...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below the medium blue square.. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and the medium blue square. Below block A there is block B with a medium blue square and one medium yellow square in it. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square and a medium black square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Below block B there is block C. It has two medium blue squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium blue square number two. It is below the yellow object which is below medium blue square number two. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Here's the breakdown:
* **Block A:** Contains two medium black squares and one medium blue square. Medium black square one is at the bottom, below medium black square two and the medium blue square. Essentially, the blue square is at the top of Block A.
* **Block B:** Contains a medium blue square and a medium yellow square. The blue square is below the yellow square.
* **Block C:** Contains two medium blue squares and a medium yellow square. Medium blue square one is at the bottom, below the yellow square, which in turn is below medium blue square two.
The question asks what is above a medium yellow square. There are two medium yellow squares:
1. **In Block B:** The medium blue square is below it.
2. **In Block C:** Medium blue square two is above it.
Neither of the options given is "medium blue square two". The medium blue square in Block A is above the contents of Block B, but not directly above the yellow square in Block B. The medium blue square touching the bottom edge of a block (medium blue square one in Block C) is below, not above, the yellow square in Block C.
Answer: {D}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the yellow squares in B and C. However, it makes an unsubstantiated claim about the blue square in Block A being at the top, and it incorrectly dismisses the relevance of the blue square in Block A without fully checking if it satisfies the condition 'above a medium yellow square' based on the block hierarchy, which is crucial for option (a).
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextlow
Statement
Essentially, the blue square is at the top of Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes the blue square is at the top of Block A, but the context only states that medium black square number one is below the medium blue square, and medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and the medium blue square. It does not explicitly state the blue square is at the very top.
Answer Span:
Essentially, the blue square is at the top of Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and the medium blue square.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The medium blue square in Block A is above the contents of Block B, but not directly above the yellow square in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning makes an assertion about the relative vertical position of Block A's contents relative to Block B's contents, which is not directly relevant to answering the question about what is *above* a yellow square, and it ignores the fact that the question asks about the *medium blue square that is in block A* specifically.
Answer Span:
The medium blue square in Block A is above the contents of Block B, but not directly above the yellow square in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #2086
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is above A. Block A contains one small black circle. It also contains a medium yellow square. It also contains one medium ye...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is above A. Block A contains one small black circle. It also contains a medium yellow square. It also contains one medium yellow circle. The small black circle is above the medium yellow square. To the left of and above the medium yellow square there is the medium yellow circle. Block B has a medium blue circle. There are also one small blue triangle and one small black circle in this block. To the left of the small black circle is the small blue triangle. To the right of and below the small black circle is the medium blue circle. And block C contains two small blue triangles. Small blue triangle number one is touching the top edge of this block. Small blue triangle number two is touching the right edge of this block. Near to and above a big yellow square there is small blue triangle number one. This object is to the left of small blue triangle number two. Which object is to the right of a thing that is touching the right edge of a block? the small blue triangle which is in block B or the object that is touching the top edge of a block?
(a) the small blue triangle which is in block B
(b) the object that is touching the top edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block C contains two small blue triangles. Small blue triangle number two is touching the right edge of block C. Block B is to the right of block C and contains a small blue triangle and a small black circle. Since Block B is to the right of Block C, the small blue triangle in Block B is to the right of small blue triangle number two (which is touching the right edge of Block C). Small blue triangle number one is also in Block C and is described as touching the top edge. So, the small blue triangle in Block B is to the right of small blue triangle number two, which is the thing touching the right edge of a block.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the object touching the right edge of a block (SBT #2 in C) and correctly identifies the object touching the top edge of a block (SBT #1 in C). It then attempts to compare the location of the small blue triangle in B relative to SBT #2. The assumption that 'Block B is to the right of block C' is derived from 'Block C is to the left of B', but the reasoning chain uses this derived spatial relationship to answer the final question without fully establishing the necessary positional logic based on the constraints provided for the final comparison.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block B is to the right of block C
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes Block B is to the right of Block C, but the context only states the relative vertical and horizontal positions of A, B, and C: 'Block C is to the left of B and block B is above A.' This does not explicitly state B is to the right of C, only that C is to the left of B (which implies B is to the right of C in the horizontal dimension, but the reasoning chain uses this as a definitive spatial relationship without grounding it fully in the provided constraints, especially since the question asks about objects to the right of something touching the right edge of a block). More critically, the reasoning chain uses this spatial relationship to determine which object is to the right of another, which is the core of the final question, but the initial setup only gives C left of B, and B above A. The reasoning chain needs to establish the location of the object touching the right edge of the block (SBT #2 in C) relative to the object in B.
Answer Span:
Block B is to the right of block C
Reference/Question Span:
Block C is to the left of B and block B is above A.
Question #2216
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are one medium black square, one medium black triangle and one small yellow triangle in block A. To the left of a small yellow square is the medi...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are one medium black square, one medium black triangle and one small yellow triangle in block A. To the left of a small yellow square is the medium black square. The small yellow triangle is to the left of and below the small yellow square. The medium black triangle is to the right of and above the yellow object which is to the left of the small yellow square. Block B is below block A. It contains a big black square, a medium blue square and a small yellow square. Above a small black triangle there is the small yellow square. This block also has a small yellow triangle. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. The big black square is below the small yellow square and the small black triangle.. It is to the right of the small yellow triangle. Finally, there is block C which is to the right of block A. It has one small blue triangle and one medium yellow square. Near to and to the left of the medium yellow square there is the small blue triangle. What is above the big thing? a medium black square or a small yellow square?
(a) medium black square
(b) small yellow square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block B contains a big black square. Block A, which is above Block B, contains a medium black square. Thus, the medium black square is above the big black square. The small yellow square is in Block B, below the small black triangle. Block A is above B, therefore the small yellow square isn't above the big black square.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly states the relative vertical position of the small yellow square and the small black triangle in Block B, leading to a flawed deduction about the small yellow square's position relative to the big black square.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The small yellow square is in Block B, below the small black triangle.
Explanation
The context states that 'Above a small black triangle there is the small yellow square,' meaning the small yellow square is *above* the small black triangle, not below it.
Answer Span:
The small yellow square is in Block B, below the small black triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
Above a small black triangle there is the small yellow square.
Question #1069
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of blocks C and B. Block A has one medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this bloc...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of blocks C and B. Block A has one medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. There is also one small blue triangle touching the right edge of this block. Near to and above the medium yellow triangle is the small blue triangle. Block B has one medium yellow square, a big yellow circle and a big blue circle. The medium yellow square is below a big blue triangle. To the right of the big blue circle is the big yellow circle. This object is near to and to the left of the big blue triangle. The medium yellow square is to the right of the big blue circle. The big blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. And block C has one medium blue triangle, one big yellow circle and a small blue triangle. To the right of and near to the big yellow circle which is to the right of and below the small blue triangle is the medium blue triangle. What is to the right of the medium blue triangle? a medium yellow triangle that is touching the right edge of a block or a small blue triangle?
(a) medium yellow triangle that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) small blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block C contains the medium blue triangle, and Block A, which is to the right of Block C, contains both the medium yellow triangle and the small blue triangle. Since Block A is directly to the right of Block C, and both the medium yellow triangle and small blue triangle are in Block A, they are both to the right of the medium blue triangle in Block C.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain fails to correctly interpret the positional constraints given in the context. It makes unsupported assumptions about the relative positions of the blocks and ignores the complex spatial relationship defining the location of the medium blue triangle within Block C, leading to a flawed conclusion.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block C contains the medium blue triangle, and Block A, which is to the right of Block C, contains both the medium yellow triangle and the small blue triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes the relative positions of Block A and Block C based on the description of objects within them, rather than using the explicit positional information given: 'Block A is to the right of blocks C and B.' The chain also fails to account for the complex positional description linking the medium blue triangle to the big yellow circle in Block C.
Answer Span:
Block C contains the medium blue triangle, and Block A, which is to the right of Block C, contains both the medium yellow triangle and the small blue triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A is to the right of blocks C and B.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block A is directly to the right of Block C, and both the medium yellow triangle and small blue triangle are in Block A, they are both to the right of the medium blue triangle in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning chain makes a massive leap in logic by concluding that because the objects are in different blocks (A and C), and A is generally to the right of C, the objects in A are to the right of the object in C. This ignores the specific positional constraints given for the medium blue triangle in Block C: 'To the right of and near to the big yellow circle which is to the right of and below the small blue triangle is the medium blue triangle.' This complex relationship must be resolved before determining what is to the right of the medium blue triangle.
Answer Span:
Since Block A is directly to the right of Block C, and both the medium yellow triangle and small blue triangle are in Block A, they are both to the right of the medium blue triangle in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
To the right of and near to the big yellow circle which is to the right of and below the small blue triangle is the medium blue triangle.
Question #2376
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One big black circle is in block A. There is also a big yellow square touching the right edge of this block. The big yellow square is far from and to the right of t...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One big black circle is in block A. There is also a big yellow square touching the right edge of this block. The big yellow square is far from and to the right of the big black circle. Then, there is block B. It contains one big yellow circle, one big black triangle and a big blue square. To the left of, below and near to the big blue square there is the big yellow circle. Below the big blue square there is the big black triangle. Finally, we have block C which is to the right of block A. Block B is to the right of it. It contains one small blue circle, one big blue triangle and a small black square. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It also has a small yellow square. This object is to the right of the small black square. The small blue circle is above the small black square and the big blue triangle. To the right of and below the small object which is to the right of the small black square is the big blue triangle. What is to the right of the small blue circle? a big blue square or a yellow thing that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) big blue square
(b) yellow thing that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A has a big black circle and a big yellow square touching the right edge. Block C, to the right of Block A, contains a small blue circle, a big blue triangle, and a small black square. It also has a small yellow square. The big yellow square in Block A is touching the right edge. The question asks what is to the right of the small blue circle (which is in Block C). Since the big yellow square is in Block A and the small blue circle is in Block C (to the right of Block A), the big yellow square is not to the right of the small blue circle. The big blue square is in Block B, which is to the right of Block C. Therefore, neither the big blue square nor the big yellow square is to the right of the small blue circle.
Answer: {D}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the location of the small blue circle (Block C) but fails to correctly evaluate the spatial relationship required by the question. It makes an unsupported leap in logic regarding the big blue square's position relative to the small blue circle, and it ignores the necessary spatial analysis of the options provided in the question.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The big yellow square is touching the right edge.
Explanation
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that the big yellow square is touching the right edge of Block A, but it fails to use the crucial positional information that Block C is to the right of Block A, and Block B is to the right of Block C. This spatial relationship is necessary to determine if objects in A or B are to the right of an object in C.
Answer Span:
The big yellow square is touching the right edge.
Reference/Question Span:
Finally, we have block C which is to the right of block A. Block B is to the right of it.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The big blue square is in Block B, which is to the right of Block C. Therefore, neither the big blue square nor the big yellow square is to the right of the small blue circle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain correctly states the relative positions of the blocks (A -> C -> B). However, it incorrectly concludes that because the big blue square is in Block B (to the right of C), it cannot be to the right of the small blue circle (in C). The reasoning chain fails to check if the big blue square is *actually* to the right of the small blue circle within Block B's contents or relative to Block C's position, and it ignores the possibility that the 'yellow thing that is touching the right edge of a block' (which is the big yellow square in Block A) might still be spatially to the right of the small blue circle in C, even though they are in different blocks.
Answer Span:
Therefore, neither the big blue square nor the big yellow square is to the right of the small blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the right of the small blue circle? a big blue square or a yellow thing that is touching the right edge of a block?
Question #784
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is above block A and below block C. Block A contains a medium yellow triangle, one medium black square and a medium black circle. The medium ...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is above block A and below block C. Block A contains a medium yellow triangle, one medium black square and a medium black circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium yellow triangle is below the medium black circle. This shape is below and to the right of the medium black square. Block B has a big blue triangle, one medium blue square and one small black square. One small yellow triangle is also touching the right edge of this block. It is touching and above the medium blue square. The big blue triangle is to the left of the triangle which is touching the medium blue square. It is far from and above the medium blue square. Block C contains a big blue square. To the right of a small black square there is a medium blue circle.. Near to and below the small black square there is the big blue square. This shape is above the circle which is to the right of the small black square. Which object is below a small black square? the medium blue square or the big blue square?
(a) the medium blue square
(b) the big blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block B contains the small black square, and Block C (which is above Block B) contains the big blue square. Block A (below Block B) contains the medium black square. The big blue square is near to and below the small black square, meaning it is directly below the small black square in Block B. Therefore, the object below the small black square is the big blue square.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly places the big blue square (from Block C) into Block B and makes an unsupported leap that 'near to and below' means 'directly below' within the same block, contradicting the block structure provided in the context.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The big blue square is near to and below the small black square, meaning it is directly below the small black square in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning claims the big blue square is directly below the small black square in Block B. The context states the big blue square is in Block C, and the small black square is in Block B. Furthermore, the context states the big blue square is 'Near to and below the small black square' and 'This shape [big blue square] is above the circle which is to the right of the small black square.' This does not imply the big blue square is *in* Block B or *directly* below the small black square.
Answer Span:
The big blue square is near to and below the small black square, meaning it is directly below the small black square in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has a big blue triangle, one medium blue square and one small black square. . . Block C contains a big blue square. . . Near to and below the small black square there is the big blue square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The big blue square is near to and below the small black square, meaning it is directly below the small black square in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly places the big blue square (which is in Block C) as being 'in Block B'. The context explicitly separates the contents of Block B and Block C.
Answer Span:
The big blue square is near to and below the small black square, meaning it is directly below the small black square in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has a big blue triangle, one medium blue square and one small black square. . . Block C contains a big blue square.
Question #1747
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. A small yellow circle is in block A. Block B is to the right of block A. It has two medium yellow triangles. Above and near to a medium yellow square i...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. A small yellow circle is in block A. Block B is to the right of block A. It has two medium yellow triangles. Above and near to a medium yellow square is medium yellow triangle number two. There is also one medium black circle in this block. It also contains a small blue circle. The small blue circle is below and touching medium yellow triangle number two. Below and to the right of medium yellow triangle number two is the medium black circle. To the right of block A there is block C which has two medium yellow squares. It also contains one medium yellow triangle. It also contains a medium yellow circle. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of and below the medium yellow circle there is the medium yellow triangle. Near to, to the left of and below the medium yellow circle is medium yellow square number two. What is to the right of the small yellow circle? a medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a medium yellow square which is in block B?
(a) medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium yellow square which is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains a small yellow circle. Block B, to the right of Block A, contains medium yellow triangles, a medium black circle, and a small blue circle, but no medium yellow squares. Block C, also to the right of Block A, contains two medium yellow squares, one of which (number one) is touching the bottom edge. Since Block C is to the right of Block A, the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge (in Block C) is to the right of the small yellow circle. There are no medium yellow squares in Block B.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the contents and relative positions of the blocks and uses this information to answer the question about what is to the right of the small yellow circle.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2592
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. This object is below medium black square number two. Medium bla...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. This object is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below medium black square number two. This shape is below the medium blue square. Then, we have block B. It contains two medium blue squares. It also has one medium black square. Below medium blue square number two there is the medium black square. Below medium blue square number two is medium blue square number one. Below medium blue square number one there is the medium black square. Block C is to the right of block A. Block B is to the left of it. It contains a medium blue square and a medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium black square. Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains two medium black squares and a medium blue square. Block C is to the right of Block A, and contains a medium blue square and a medium black square. Since Block C is directly to the right of Block A, and the medium blue square is in Block A. The medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of block C is also to the right of the medium black squares in block A.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes unsupported assumptions about the relative horizontal positions of objects within the blocks and incorrectly identifies which blue square is being referenced in the final comparison, leading to a flawed conclusion based on speculation rather than deduction from the provided positional constraints.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C is to the right of Block A, and contains a medium blue square and a medium black square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain states Block C contains a medium blue square and a medium black square, but it ignores the specific positional information given for Block C's contents: 'The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium black square.'
Answer Span:
Block C is to the right of Block A, and contains a medium blue square and a medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C is to the right of block A. Block B is to the left of it. It contains a medium blue square and a medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium black square.
contradictionhigh
Statement
The medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of block C is also to the right of the medium black squares in block A.
Explanation
The reasoning chain refers to 'the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of block C'. The context states that Block C contains 'a medium blue square' which is touching the bottom edge of *that block* (Block C). The reasoning chain incorrectly implies this square is the one being asked about in option (b), which is 'the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of *a* block' (which could be C, but the reasoning chain makes an assertion about its position relative to A's contents that isn't supported or necessary for the final comparison). More critically, the reasoning chain assumes the relative positions of objects *within* the blocks are known or can be inferred to answer the question, which asks about the relative positions *between* blocks/objects.
Answer Span:
The medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of block C is also to the right of the medium black squares in block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #3492
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the right of A. Block B is above C. Block A contains one small yellow triangle, one small blue circle and a big black square. A big blue triangle is t...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the right of A. Block B is above C. Block A contains one small yellow triangle, one small blue circle and a big black square. A big blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. It is to the right of the small yellow triangle , the big black square and the small blue circle. The small yellow triangle is below the small blue circle. This block also has a big yellow triangle. Block B has a medium yellow circle, one small black square and a big black square. Above the big black square there is the small black square. The medium yellow circle is near to and above the big black square. Block C contains one big black circle, a medium black triangle and a medium blue triangle. To the left of a small yellow square which is to the right of and near to the medium blue triangle there is the big black circle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of the medium blue triangle. This shape is below the small yellow square. What is above the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block? a big black square or a small yellow triangle?
(a) big black square
(b) small yellow triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
The question describes three blocks A, B, and C. Block C contains a medium black triangle touching the bottom edge. Block B is above Block C, and it contains a big black square. Therefore, the big black square in Block B is directly above the medium black triangle that's touching the bottom edge of Block C. The small yellow triangle is in Block A and is not related to the position of Block C or its contents.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the shape touching the bottom edge of Block C (medium black triangle) but makes an unsupported assumption about the vertical relationship between Block B's contents and Block C's contents to answer the final positional question. It fails to check the position of the small yellow triangle relative to the shape touching the bottom edge.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block C contains a medium black triangle touching the bottom edge.
Explanation
The context states that the medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of Block C, but it does not state that this is the *only* shape touching the bottom edge, nor does it explicitly state the medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge (it says 'The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block'). However, the reasoning chain implies this is the key shape for the final question, which is about 'the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block'. The crucial error is assuming the medium black triangle is the *only* shape touching the bottom edge, which is not supported, but the reasoning chain uses this fact to link to Block B.
Answer Span:
Block C contains a medium black triangle touching the bottom edge.
Reference/Question Span:
The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Therefore, the big black square in Block B is directly above the medium black triangle that's touching the bottom edge of Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes a direct vertical relationship between the big black square in Block B and the medium black triangle in Block C based only on the relative positions of the blocks (B is above C) and the location of the shapes within their respective blocks. The question asks what is above 'the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block'. The shape touching the bottom edge of Block C is the medium black triangle. The question asks what is above *that* shape. The reasoning chain correctly identifies the shape touching the bottom edge (medium black triangle in C) but then jumps to checking if the big black square in B is above it, without establishing the necessary vertical alignment or proximity required by the final question, which is a positional query.
Answer Span:
Therefore, the big black square in Block B is directly above the medium black triangle that's touching the bottom edge of Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
What is above the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block? a big black square or a small yellow triangle?
Question #1073
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is above A and block A is to the right of C. Block A has a big yellow triangle. There is also a big blue square touching the right edge of this...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is above A and block A is to the right of C. Block A has a big yellow triangle. There is also a big blue square touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is above the big yellow triangle. Block B has one medium black square and one small yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of and below the small yellow square. Block C contains two big yellow circles. This block also has a big black circle. There is also a medium blue square in this block. It also has one small blue triangle. Big yellow circle number two is touching the top edge of this block. To the right of, near to and below big yellow circle number one there is a big black square. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of and near to the big black circle is the medium blue square. This object is below big yellow circle number two. Which object is to the left of a big blue square? the medium black square or the big black circle that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the medium black square
(b) the big black circle that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a big blue square and Block B contains a medium black square. Since Block B is above Block A, the medium black square is not to the left of the big blue square. The big black circle is in Block C and Block A is to the right of Block C. Therefore, the big black circle is to the left of the big blue square.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an inaccurate statement about the contents of Block A and draws a conclusion about the relative positions of the big black circle and the big blue square based on incomplete spatial reasoning, ignoring crucial positional details provided in the context.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block A contains a big blue square
Explanation
The context states that Block A has a big yellow triangle and there is a big blue square touching the right edge of this block (Block A). It does not state the block *contains* the square, but rather that the square is *touching* the edge of the block.
Answer Span:
Block A contains a big blue square
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has a big yellow triangle. There is also a big blue square touching the right edge of this block.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The big black circle is in Block C and Block A is to the right of Block C. Therefore, the big black circle is to the left of the big blue square.
Explanation
The reasoning concludes the big black circle is to the left of the big blue square based only on the relative positions of Block C and Block A. It completely ignores the spatial relationship between the big blue square (which is touching the right edge of Block A) and the big black circle (which is in Block C). The context states 'Block A is to the right of C', which means C is to the left of A. The big blue square is on A. The big black circle is in C. This spatial relationship is insufficient to determine if the circle is to the left of the square without knowing the exact placement of the square relative to the block edges and the circle's position within C.
Answer Span:
The big black circle is in Block C and Block A is to the right of Block C. Therefore, the big black circle is to the left of the big blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A is to the right of C. . . Block C contains two big yellow circles. This block also has a big black circle. . . There is also a big blue square touching the right edge of this block.
Question #783
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is above block A and below block C. Block A contains a medium yellow triangle, one medium black square and a medium black circle. The medium ...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is above block A and below block C. Block A contains a medium yellow triangle, one medium black square and a medium black circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium yellow triangle is below the medium black circle. This shape is below and to the right of the medium black square. Block B has a big blue triangle, one medium blue square and one small black square. One small yellow triangle is also touching the right edge of this block. It is touching and above the medium blue square. The big blue triangle is to the left of the triangle which is touching the medium blue square. It is far from and above the medium blue square. Block C contains a big blue square. To the right of a small black square there is a medium blue circle.. Near to and below the small black square there is the big blue square. This shape is above the circle which is to the right of the small black square. What is above the medium yellow triangle? a big blue square or a medium blue circle?
(a) big blue square
(b) medium blue circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains the medium yellow triangle. Block B, which is above Block A, contains the small yellow triangle, medium blue square, and big blue triangle. Block C, which is above Block B, contains the big blue square, small black square, and medium blue circle. Since Block B is directly above Block A, the objects above the medium yellow triangle are the contents of Block B. Neither the big blue square (in Block C) nor the medium blue circle (in Block C) is directly above the medium yellow triangle.
Answer: {D}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that objects in Block B are above Block A, but it incorrectly lists the contents of Block C, leading to an incorrect final conclusion based on flawed premises about where the objects are located.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block C, which is above Block B, contains the big blue square, small black square, and medium blue circle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly states that the small black square and medium blue circle are in Block C. The context states Block C contains a big blue square, and that 'To the right of a small black square there is a medium blue circle.' It does not explicitly state the small black square and medium blue circle are *contained* in Block C, only that the big blue square is. Furthermore, the reasoning chain incorrectly lists the contents of Block C based on the description of Block B and C's contents.
Answer Span:
Block C, which is above Block B, contains the big blue square, small black square, and medium blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has a big blue triangle, one medium blue square and one small black square. . . Block C contains a big blue square. To the right of a small black square there is a medium blue circle.. Near to and below the small black square there is the big blue square.
Question #2593
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. This object is below medium black square number two. Medium bla...
3 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. This object is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below medium black square number two. This shape is below the medium blue square. Then, we have block B. It contains two medium blue squares. It also has one medium black square. Below medium blue square number two there is the medium black square. Below medium blue square number two is medium blue square number one. Below medium blue square number one there is the medium black square. Block C is to the right of block A. Block B is to the left of it. It contains a medium blue square and a medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium black square. Which object is below a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has two medium black squares and a medium blue square below the second black square. The first black square is below the second black square and the blue square. Block B has two medium blue squares and a medium black square below them. Block C has a medium black square and a medium blue square below it. The question asks what is below a medium black square. In Block A, a medium blue square is below a medium black square (number two). In Block C, a medium blue square is also below a medium black square. Therefore, both the medium blue square in Block A and the medium blue square touching the bottom edge of Block C are below a medium black square.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains multiple factual contradictions regarding the relative positions of objects within Block A and Block C, leading to an incorrect final assessment of which blue square meets the criteria.
Detected Issues (3)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block A has two medium black squares and a medium blue square below the second black square.
Explanation
The context states the medium blue square in Block A is below medium black square number two, but it also states 'This shape is below the medium blue square,' implying the blue square is not the lowest object described in relation to the black squares.
Answer Span:
a medium blue square below the second black square
Reference/Question Span:
This object is below medium black square number two. . . This shape is below the medium blue square.
contradictionhigh
Statement
The first black square is below the second black square and the blue square.
Explanation
The context only states that medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of the block, and the blue square is below medium black square number two. It never states that black square one is below black square two or the blue square.
Answer Span:
The first black square is below the second black square and the blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below medium black square number two. This shape is below the medium blue square.
contradictionhigh
Statement
In Block C, a medium blue square is also below a medium black square.
Explanation
The context for Block C states: 'The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium black square.' This means the object below the medium black square in Block C is *not* the medium blue square (which is touching the bottom edge), but some other unspecified object.
Answer Span:
In Block C, a medium blue square is also below a medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
It contains a medium blue square and a medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium black square.
Question #1546
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium blue squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. Th...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium blue squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. The medium yellow square is below the medium black square. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. The medium yellow square is below medium blue square number one which is below the medium black square. It is below medium blue square number two. Then, there is block B with one medium yellow square in it. There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square. Below block A and to the left of block B there is block C. It contains one medium black square and one medium blue square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is in block B?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium black square and a medium yellow square touching the bottom edge. Block B, to the right of Block C and below Block A, contains a medium yellow square. Block C contains a medium black square. Since Block B is to the right of Block C, and the medium yellow square is in Block B, the medium yellow square in Block B is to the right of the medium black square in Block C. The medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of Block A is not to the right of the medium black square in Block C.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly establishes the spatial relationship between Block B and Block C, leading to an unsupported conclusion about the position of the yellow square touching the bottom edge of Block A relative to the black square in Block C.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block B, to the right of Block C and below Block A, contains a medium yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly states the relative position of Block B to Block C. The context states Block C is below Block A and to the left of Block B, not that Block B is to the right of Block C and below Block A.
Answer Span:
Block B, to the right of Block C and below Block A, contains a medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Below block A and to the left of block B there is block C.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of Block A is not to the right of the medium black square in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning chain makes a definitive statement about the relative position of the yellow square touching the bottom edge of Block A and the black square in Block C, but the context does not provide enough spatial information (left/right relationships between objects *within* or *across* blocks A and C) to support this conclusion. The question asks which object *is* to the right, implying one must be.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of Block A is not to the right of the medium black square in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is in block B?
Question #2582
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is to the right of A and block C is above B. Block A contains a medium black circle. It also has a medium yellow triangle. This block also contains one medi...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is to the right of A and block C is above B. Block A contains a medium black circle. It also has a medium yellow triangle. This block also contains one medium black square. It is to the left of and above the medium black circle. The medium black circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium yellow triangle is below the medium black circle. It is to the right of the medium black square. Block B has one big yellow square and a small black square. There is also a big black square touching the right edge of this block. This shape is below and to the right of the small black square. The big yellow square is below the square which is below the small black square. And block C contains a big yellow triangle, one big blue square and one small black square. The big blue square is below and near to the small black square. The big yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. This shape is above the big blue square. It is to the right of the small black square. What is to the right of the medium black square? a medium yellow triangle or a big black square?
(a) medium yellow triangle
(b) big black square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains the medium black square, medium black circle, and medium yellow triangle. The medium black square is to the left of and above the medium black circle, and the medium yellow triangle is below the medium black circle and to the right of the medium black square. Therefore, the medium yellow triangle is to the right of the medium black square. The big black square is in Block B, which is to the right of Block A, not directly to the right of the medium black square within Block A.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the shapes within Block A based on the context to determine what is to the right of the medium black square.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #3047
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is above and C is to the right of A. Block A has a small black square and one medium black triangle. To the left of and near to the medium bl...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is above and C is to the right of A. Block A has a small black square and one medium black triangle. To the left of and near to the medium black triangle there is the small black square. Block B has one medium yellow circle and one big yellow triangle. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of, above and near to the big yellow triangle is the medium yellow circle. Block C contains one small blue square and one small yellow triangle. There is also a small yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also contains a small yellow circle. To the right of the small blue square which is near to and to the right of the small yellow triangle is the small yellow circle. Below the small yellow triangle there is the small yellow square. The small yellow circle is to the right of and below the small yellow triangle. Which object is above a small black square? the small yellow square or the big yellow triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small yellow square
(b) the big yellow triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains the small black square, and Block B, which is above Block A, contains the big yellow triangle. Thus, the big yellow triangle is above the small black square. The small yellow square is in Block C, which is to the right of Block A, so it is not above the small black square.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the location of the objects mentioned in the question based on the provided context and arrives at the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1074
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is above A and block A is to the right of C. Block A has a big yellow triangle. There is also a big blue square touching the right edge of this...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is above A and block A is to the right of C. Block A has a big yellow triangle. There is also a big blue square touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is above the big yellow triangle. Block B has one medium black square and one small yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of and below the small yellow square. Block C contains two big yellow circles. This block also has a big black circle. There is also a medium blue square in this block. It also has one small blue triangle. Big yellow circle number two is touching the top edge of this block. To the right of, near to and below big yellow circle number one there is a big black square. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of and near to the big black circle is the medium blue square. This object is below big yellow circle number two. What is above the big yellow triangle? a medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a medium blue square?
(a) medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains the big yellow triangle, and Block B (above A) contains the medium black square and the small yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of Block B. Since Block B is directly above Block A, the medium black square is above the big yellow triangle. The medium blue square is in Block C.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the locations of the objects but makes an unsupported leap in spatial reasoning regarding the medium black square being above the big yellow triangle based only on the block positions, ignoring the need for specific object-to-object vertical alignment checks.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block B is directly above Block A, the medium black square is above the big yellow triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes that because Block B is above Block A, everything in Block B is above everything in Block A. The question only establishes the relative position of the blocks (B is above A), not the relative position of the objects *within* those blocks to each other, except where explicitly stated. The medium black square is in Block B, and the big yellow triangle is in Block A. While B is above A, the reasoning chain fails to check if the medium black square is *actually* above the big yellow triangle based on the provided spatial relationships, which are complex. The reasoning chain makes a leap based only on block position.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is directly above Block A, the medium black square is above the big yellow triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is above A
Question #1560
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block C and it is below block A. Block A contains two medium blue circles. To the left of medium blue circle number two the...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block C and it is below block A. Block A contains two medium blue circles. To the left of medium blue circle number two there is medium blue circle number one. Block B contains one medium black square and one big blue triangle. The medium black square is above a medium blue circle. The medium blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below and to the left of the big blue triangle. Block C contains two medium yellow squares and two other big black circles. Medium yellow square number one is above big black circle number one. Medium yellow square number two is touching the right edge of this block. Big black circle number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is below big black circle number two. It is near to and to the left of medium yellow square number two. What is above the triangle? a medium blue circle or a medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) medium blue circle
(b) medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block B contains the big blue triangle. The medium black square is above the triangle in Block B. Block A is above Block B, and contains medium blue circles. Block C is to the right of Block B and contains medium yellow squares and big black circles. Neither the medium blue circle nor the medium yellow square touching the right edge of a block is directly above the big blue triangle in Block B.
Answer: {D}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains a direct contradiction regarding the position of the medium black square relative to the triangle and fails to correctly use the positional information (Block A is above Block B) to determine what is above the triangle.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The medium black square is above the triangle in Block B.
Explanation
The context states the medium black square is above a medium blue circle, not the big blue triangle.
Answer Span:
The medium black square is above the triangle in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
The medium black square is above a medium blue circle.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Neither the medium blue circle nor the medium yellow square touching the right edge of a block is directly above the big blue triangle in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning chain fails to establish the vertical relationship between the items in Block A (where the medium blue circles are) and the item in Block B (the triangle) to answer the question 'What is above the triangle?'. The context states Block B is below Block A, implying Block A is above Block B, but the reasoning chain doesn't use this to check if the medium blue circles are above the triangle.
Answer Span:
Neither the medium blue circle nor the medium yellow square touching the right edge of a block is directly above the big blue triangle in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the left of block C and it is below block A.
Question #187
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block B is to the right of A. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black squa...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block B is to the right of A. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue square is medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two and the medium blue square is medium black square number one. Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two is a medium black square. Below the medium black square is medium yellow square number one. It is below medium yellow square number two. Block C has one medium yellow square and one medium blue square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is in block B or the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium black square that is in block B
(b) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A has two medium black squares and a medium blue square. Block B has two medium yellow squares and a medium black square. Block C has a medium yellow square and a medium blue square. The question asks what is below *a* medium yellow square. In Block B, the medium black square is below medium yellow square number two. In Block C, nothing is described as being below the medium yellow square. Therefore, only the medium black square in Block B fits the description.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the relevant information for Block B but incorrectly states the contents of Block C by adding a medium black square, which is not mentioned in the context for Block C. This error affects the subsequent analysis of Block C.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block C has a medium yellow square and a medium blue square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain claims Block C has a medium black square, but the context only states Block C has one medium yellow square and one medium blue square. The reasoning chain incorrectly adds a medium black square to Block C.
Answer Span:
Block C has a medium yellow square and a medium blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C has one medium yellow square and one medium blue square.
Question #3313
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains one big yellow square, one small yellow circle and one medium black square. Below the medium black square is the big yellow square. ...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains one big yellow square, one small yellow circle and one medium black square. Below the medium black square is the big yellow square. The small yellow circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of the medium black square. The big yellow square is above the small yellow circle. Block B is to the left of block A. It contains two medium blue triangles. It also contains one small blue circle. Above a medium black triangle there is the small blue circle. Medium blue triangle number one is to the right of medium blue triangle number two. To the left of and touching medium blue triangle number two there is the medium black triangle. The small blue circle is above the triangle which is to the right of medium blue triangle number two. Medium blue triangle number one is touching the right edge of this block. Finally, we have block C. It is below block A. It has one big black square. A big blue square is to the right of the big black square. What is above the big blue square? a medium black square or a big black square?
(a) medium black square
(b) big black square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium black square. Block C, which is below Block A, contains a big blue square. Since Block C is directly below Block A, the object above the big blue square is the medium black square in Block A.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes incorrect assumptions about the spatial relationship between objects in Block A and Block C, specifically ignoring the horizontal placement of the big blue square within Block C and incorrectly concluding that an object from Block A must be directly above it.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C, which is below Block A, contains a big blue square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain states Block C contains a big blue square, but the context states Block C has 'one big black square. A big blue square is to the right of the big black square.' This implies the big blue square is in Block C, but the reasoning simplifies the contents incorrectly.
Answer Span:
Block C, which is below Block A, contains a big blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
Finally, we have block C. It is below block A. It has one big black square. A big blue square is to the right of the big black square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block C is directly below Block A, the object above the big blue square is the medium black square in Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes that because C is below A, the object directly above the big blue square (in C) must be an object in A. However, the big blue square is *to the right* of the big black square in C. The reasoning ignores the horizontal placement within C and incorrectly assumes vertical alignment between A and the object in C.
Answer Span:
Since Block C is directly below Block A, the object above the big blue square is the medium black square in Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the left of block A. . . Finally, we have block C. It is below block A. It has one big black square. A big blue square is to the right of the big black square. What is above the big blue square?
Question #3226
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains one big blue triangle and a big blue square. The big blue triangle is to the right of the big blue square. Block B is below block A. It has one big y...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains one big blue triangle and a big blue square. The big blue triangle is to the right of the big blue square. Block B is below block A. It has one big yellow circle. To the right of block A there is block C with a medium yellow circle, a small yellow circle and one medium yellow square in it. The medium yellow circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a small black square. Above the medium yellow square is the small yellow circle. The medium yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. A big yellow square is touching the left edge of this block. Far from and to the right of the big yellow square there is the medium yellow square.. The small yellow circle is to the right of the big yellow square. Below the big yellow square there is the medium yellow circle. Which object is below a big yellow square? the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block or the circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block C contains a big yellow square, a medium yellow square touching the right edge, a small yellow circle above the medium yellow square, and a medium yellow circle touching the bottom edge. The question asks what is below the big yellow square. Since the medium yellow circle is described as being below the big yellow square, that is the correct answer.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the relationship needed to answer the question (medium yellow circle is below the big yellow square) but inaccurately summarizes the contents of Block C by omitting the small black square and slightly misrepresenting the inclusion of the big yellow square.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C contains a big yellow square, a medium yellow square touching the right edge, a small yellow circle above the medium yellow square, and a medium yellow circle touching the bottom edge.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly states that Block C contains a big yellow square. The context states: 'To the right of block A there is block C with a medium yellow circle, a small yellow circle and one medium yellow square in it. [...] A big yellow square is touching the left edge of this block.' This implies the big yellow square is *in* block C, but the reasoning chain lists it as one of the objects *contained* in C alongside the others, which is slightly misleading, but the main issue is that it omits the small black square which is also explicitly listed as being in Block C.
Answer Span:
Block C contains a big yellow square, a medium yellow square touching the right edge, a small yellow circle above the medium yellow square, and a medium yellow circle touching the bottom edge.
Reference/Question Span:
To the right of block A there is block C with a medium yellow circle, a small yellow circle and one medium yellow square in it. [...] A big yellow square is touching the left edge of this block. [...] This block also has a small black square.
Question #708
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains one big black circle and a medium blue triangle. To the right of, far from and above the medium blue triangle there is the big black...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains one big black circle and a medium blue triangle. To the right of, far from and above the medium blue triangle there is the big black circle. The medium blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of block A we have block B with one medium blue square and a medium black circle in it. Above a big black triangle there is the medium blue square. It is near to, below and to the right of the medium black circle. To the right of block A there is block C. It contains one medium yellow square and one medium yellow circle. This block also has a big yellow triangle. Above and to the right of a small black square there is the medium yellow square. Above a big yellow square is the medium yellow circle. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Near to and to the right of the medium yellow circle is the medium yellow square. The small black square is to the left of the medium yellow circle. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow circle? the medium yellow square or the small thing?
(a) the medium yellow square
(b) the small thing
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block C contains a medium yellow square, a medium yellow circle, and a small black square. The small black square is to the left of the medium yellow circle. The medium yellow square is also described as being to the right of the medium yellow circle. Thus, only the small black square (the "small thing") is to the left of the medium yellow circle.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning correctly identifies that the small black square is to the left of the medium yellow circle. However, it incorrectly interprets the relationship between the medium yellow square and the medium yellow circle, stating the square is to the right of the circle, and then uses this (partially correct but misleadingly applied) fact to conclude the square is *not* to the left, which is not what the question asks. The question asks which object *is* to the left. The context explicitly states the small black square is to the left. The reasoning chain incorrectly uses the 'to the right' relationship to dismiss the medium yellow square as a candidate for being 'to the left' without checking if the context supports it being to the left as well, or if the premise used to dismiss it is relevant to the question asked.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The medium yellow square is also described as being to the right of the medium yellow circle.
Explanation
The reasoning claims the medium yellow square is to the right of the medium yellow circle, but the context states: 'Near to and to the right of the medium yellow circle is the medium yellow square.' This means the medium yellow square is to the right of the medium yellow circle, which contradicts the question asking what is to the *left* of the medium yellow circle. More critically, the reasoning uses this statement to exclude the medium yellow square from being to the left, when the context actually states the small black square is to the left.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow square is also described as being to the right of the medium yellow circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Near to and to the right of the medium yellow circle is the medium yellow square.
Question #300
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. It also has one medium blue square. This shape is below medium black square number two. Medium black square numbe...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. It also has one medium blue square. This shape is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square and medium black square number two. Below block A is block B which has two medium yellow squares. There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium blue square is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. Finally, we have block C. It is to the left of block B. It contains a medium yellow square. This block also has a medium black square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue square that is in block A?
(a) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium blue square and two medium black squares. Block B, below Block A, contains two medium yellow squares and a medium blue square touching the bottom edge. Block C, to the left of Block B, contains a medium yellow square and a medium black square. The question asks what is below *a* medium yellow square. There are three medium yellow squares. The one in Block C has nothing below it. In Block B, the medium blue square touching the bottom edge is below both medium yellow squares. Therefore, the medium blue square touching the bottom edge of a block is below a medium yellow square (specifically, the ones in Block B). The medium blue square in Block A is above the medium yellow squares, not below them.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies that the blue square touching the bottom edge of a block (in B) is below the yellow squares in B. However, it makes an unsupported claim about the position of the blue square in A relative to yellow squares, and incorrectly concludes that the blue square in A is above them, which is not stated in the context.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
There are three medium yellow squares.
Explanation
The context explicitly states Block B has two medium yellow squares and Block C has one medium yellow square, totaling three. However, the reasoning chain later incorrectly states the location of the medium blue square in Block A relative to the yellow squares, which is not supported by the text.
Answer Span:
There are three medium yellow squares.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B which has two medium yellow squares. . . Block C. It contains a medium yellow square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The medium blue square in Block A is above the medium yellow squares, not below them.
Explanation
The reasoning chain claims the medium blue square in Block A is above the medium yellow squares. The context does not mention the relative vertical position of the medium blue square in Block A to *any* medium yellow square, only that the blue square in A is below the second black square and above the first black square. The reasoning introduces an unsupported relationship.
Answer Span:
The medium blue square in Block A is above the medium yellow squares, not below them.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has two medium black squares. It also has one medium blue square. This shape is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square and medium black square number two.
Question #709
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains one big black circle and a medium blue triangle. To the right of, far from and above the medium blue triangle there is the big black...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains one big black circle and a medium blue triangle. To the right of, far from and above the medium blue triangle there is the big black circle. The medium blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of block A we have block B with one medium blue square and a medium black circle in it. Above a big black triangle there is the medium blue square. It is near to, below and to the right of the medium black circle. To the right of block A there is block C. It contains one medium yellow square and one medium yellow circle. This block also has a big yellow triangle. Above and to the right of a small black square there is the medium yellow square. Above a big yellow square is the medium yellow circle. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Near to and to the right of the medium yellow circle is the medium yellow square. The small black square is to the left of the medium yellow circle. Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium yellow square or the small thing?
(a) the medium yellow square
(b) the small thing
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block B contains the medium blue square, and Block A contains a medium blue triangle. Block C, to the right of Block A, contains a medium yellow square and a small black square. Since Block C is to the right of Block A, the objects within Block C (the medium yellow square and small black square) are to the right of the objects in Block A (including the medium blue triangle) but not necessarily the medium blue square which is in Block B and is not next to Block C. The medium blue square is not above or below the medium yellow square.
Answer: {D}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly identifies the contents of Block C by including the small black square, which is only described relative to objects in Block C, not contained within it. It also introduces an irrelevant spatial comparison that is not supported by the context.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block C, to the right of Block A, contains a medium yellow square and a small black square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly states that Block C contains a small black square. The context states Block C contains 'one medium yellow square and one medium yellow circle. This block also has a big yellow triangle.' The small black square is located relative to objects *within* Block C, but is not listed as *contained* in Block C.
Answer Span:
Block C, to the right of Block A, contains a medium yellow square and a small black square.
Reference/Question Span:
To the right of block A there is block C. It contains one medium yellow square and one medium yellow circle. This block also has a big yellow triangle.
missing_contextlow
Statement
The medium blue square is not above or below the medium yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain makes an assertion about the relative vertical position of the medium blue square and the medium yellow square, which is not established or necessary for answering the question based on block locations. The question asks what is to the right of the medium blue square, which is in Block B. Block C (containing the medium yellow square) is to the right of Block A. The relationship between Block B and Block C is not fully defined spatially, making this specific assertion irrelevant and potentially misleading.
Answer Span:
The medium blue square is not above or below the medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium yellow square or the small thing?
Question #3126
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is below B. Block C is to the right of A. Block A has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the right edge of this block. M...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is below B. Block C is to the right of A. Block A has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the right edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. Above medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. Block B has one big black square and a big black circle. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. This block also has a small black circle. The big black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big black square is to the right of the big black circle and the small black circle. And block C has one big black triangle. There is also a small yellow circle in this block. Near to and to the left of the big black triangle is the small yellow circle. The big black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the big black triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the small black circle?
(a) the big black triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the small black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains two medium yellow squares. Block C, to the right of Block A, contains a big black triangle and a small yellow circle. The big black triangle is touching the bottom edge of Block C. Block B, above Block A, contains a big black square, a big black circle, and a small black circle. Since Block C is to the right of Block A, the big black triangle (which is in Block C) is to the right of the medium yellow squares (which are in Block A). The small black circle is in Block B, which is above Block A, not to the right of it.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies that Block C is to the right of Block A, thus the object in C (big black triangle) is to the right of objects in A (medium yellow squares). It incorrectly dismisses the small black circle based on its vertical location in Block B relative to A, rather than checking its horizontal relationship to the medium yellow squares in A. However, the final conclusion aligns with the correct answer based on the explicit spatial relationship established between C and A.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block B, above Block A, contains a big black square, a big black circle, and a small black circle.
Explanation
The context states Block A is below B, meaning B is above A. However, the reasoning chain incorrectly states that Block B is above Block A, which is a restatement of the positional relationship, but the critical error is that the reasoning chain implies the small black circle is not to the right of a medium yellow square based on its location in Block B (above A), while the question asks which object *is* to the right of a medium yellow square. The reasoning chain incorrectly dismisses the small black circle based on its vertical relationship to A, rather than checking its horizontal relationship to the medium yellow squares.
Answer Span:
The small black circle is in Block B, which is above Block A, not to the right of it.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A is below B.
Question #2375
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One big black circle is in block A. There is also a big yellow square touching the right edge of this block. The big yellow square is far from and to the right of t...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One big black circle is in block A. There is also a big yellow square touching the right edge of this block. The big yellow square is far from and to the right of the big black circle. Then, there is block B. It contains one big yellow circle, one big black triangle and a big blue square. To the left of, below and near to the big blue square there is the big yellow circle. Below the big blue square there is the big black triangle. Finally, we have block C which is to the right of block A. Block B is to the right of it. It contains one small blue circle, one big blue triangle and a small black square. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It also has a small yellow square. This object is to the right of the small black square. The small blue circle is above the small black square and the big blue triangle. To the right of and below the small object which is to the right of the small black square is the big blue triangle. Which object is to the left of a small blue circle? the big black circle or the big black triangle?
(a) the big black circle
(b) the big black triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains a big black circle. Block B contains a big black triangle. Block C contains a small blue circle. Block C is to the right of Block A, and Block B is to the right of Block C. Therefore, the order of the blocks from left to right is A, C, B. The small blue circle is in Block C, so the big black circle (in Block A) is to its left. The big black triangle is in Block B, which is to the right of the small blue circle, not to its left.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the contents of the blocks and establishes the relative order of the blocks (A, C, B). However, the final step relies on spatial reasoning (left/right) between objects in different blocks without explicitly checking the positional constraints given in the text for the specific objects asked about (big black circle and big black triangle relative to the small blue circle). The reasoning chain incorrectly concludes the big black triangle is to the right of the small blue circle without sufficient textual evidence for that specific relative placement, although the final answer choice selection seems to follow from the derived block order.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionlow
Statement
Block C is to the right of Block A, and Block B is to the right of Block C. Therefore, the order of the blocks from left to right is A, C, B.
Explanation
The context states: 'Block C which is to the right of block A. Block B is to the right of it [Block C]'. This implies the order A -> C -> B. However, the reasoning chain incorrectly states the order is A, C, B based on the premise that B is to the right of C, which is consistent, but the reasoning chain then uses this derived order to answer the question, which is fine, but the subsequent step about the big black triangle's location relative to the small blue circle is based on an assumption about relative positions that isn't fully supported by the text for the final comparison.
Answer Span:
Block B is to the right of it.
Reference/Question Span:
Finally, we have block C which is to the right of block A. Block B is to the right of it.
Question #2544
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There is a medium yellow square in block A. Above block A there is block B which contains one medium blue triangle and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow t...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There is a medium yellow square in block A. Above block A there is block B which contains one medium blue triangle and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium blue triangle is near to a medium yellow circle. It is above the medium yellow triangle. Below the medium yellow circle is the medium yellow triangle. To the right of block A there is block C with one medium yellow square and a big yellow square in it. A small blue triangle is above the medium yellow square. The medium yellow square is above the big yellow square. The big yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. This object is near to and far from a big blue square. The small blue triangle is to the right of the big blue square. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium yellow triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the big yellow square which is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the big yellow square which is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium yellow square, and Block B (above Block A) contains a medium yellow triangle touching the bottom edge. Block C (to the right of Block A) contains a medium yellow square above a big yellow square touching the right edge. The question asks what is above *a* medium yellow square, not specifically the one in Block A. In Block C, the small blue triangle is above the medium yellow square. So, the medium yellow triangle is above the medium yellow square in Block A, and the small blue triangle is above the medium yellow square in Block C. Neither of the options given is above the medium yellow square in Block C. Only the medium yellow triangle is above a medium yellow square (the one in Block A).
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly identifies the spatial relationship between the medium yellow triangle and the medium yellow square in Block A, leading to an incorrect intermediate conclusion about which object is above which medium yellow square. It correctly identifies the object above the medium yellow square in Block C (small blue triangle) but then incorrectly evaluates the options based on its flawed premise regarding Block A.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
So, the medium yellow triangle is above the medium yellow square in Block A, and the small blue triangle is above the medium yellow square in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning claims the medium yellow triangle is above the medium yellow square in Block A. The context states the medium yellow square is *in* block A, and block B (above A) contains the medium yellow triangle. Therefore, the medium yellow triangle is not above the medium yellow square in Block A.
Answer Span:
the medium yellow triangle is above the medium yellow square in Block A
Reference/Question Span:
There is a medium yellow square in block A. Above block A there is block B which contains one medium blue triangle and a medium yellow triangle.
Question #3048
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is above and C is to the right of A. Block A has a small black square and one medium black triangle. To the left of and near to the medium bl...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is above and C is to the right of A. Block A has a small black square and one medium black triangle. To the left of and near to the medium black triangle there is the small black square. Block B has one medium yellow circle and one big yellow triangle. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of, above and near to the big yellow triangle is the medium yellow circle. Block C contains one small blue square and one small yellow triangle. There is also a small yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also contains a small yellow circle. To the right of the small blue square which is near to and to the right of the small yellow triangle is the small yellow circle. Below the small yellow triangle there is the small yellow square. The small yellow circle is to the right of and below the small yellow triangle. What is to the left of the small yellow circle? a small blue square or a big object that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) small blue square
(b) big object that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block C contains a small yellow circle, a small blue square, a small yellow triangle, and a small yellow square. The small blue square is to the left of the small yellow circle, and the small yellow triangle is above both. The small yellow square is below the small yellow triangle. Since the question asks for what is *to the left* of the small yellow circle, and the small blue square fits this description. The big yellow triangle is in Block B, not Block C, so it's not to the left of the small yellow circle.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that the small blue square is to the left of the small yellow circle (Option A). However, it completely ignores the second possibility presented in the question ('a big object that is touching the bottom edge of a block?'), which is necessary to evaluate options (c) and (d). This constitutes a critical missing context error.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionlow
Statement
The small blue square is to the left of the small yellow circle
Explanation
The context states: 'To the right of the small blue square which is near to and to the right of the small yellow triangle is the small yellow circle.' This implies the small yellow circle is to the right of the small blue square, meaning the small blue square is to the left of the small yellow circle. However, the context also states: 'The small yellow circle is to the right of and below the small yellow triangle.' The relationship between the small blue square and the small yellow circle is defined by the complex sentence: 'To the right of the small blue square which is near to and to the right of the small yellow triangle is the small yellow circle.' This structure means: (Small yellow circle) is to the right of (Small blue square). Therefore, the small blue square is to the left of the small yellow circle. The reasoning chain's statement is actually consistent with the complex positional description, but the description in the reasoning chain is an oversimplification that might be interpreted as a direct restatement rather than derived fact. Let's re-examine the context for a clearer contradiction or missing context.
Answer Span:
The small blue square is to the left of the small yellow circle
Reference/Question Span:
To the right of the small blue square which is near to and to the right of the small yellow triangle is the small yellow circle.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The small blue square is to the left of the small yellow circle
Explanation
The reasoning chain fails to incorporate the second part of the question: 'a big object that is touching the bottom edge of a block?' which is option (b). The reasoning only confirms option (a) without checking if option (b) is also true, which is necessary to determine if (c) is the correct answer.
Answer Span:
The small blue square is to the left of the small yellow circle
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the left of the small yellow circle? a small blue square or a big object that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #301
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. It also has one medium blue square. This shape is below medium black square number two. Medium black square numbe...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. It also has one medium blue square. This shape is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square and medium black square number two. Below block A is block B which has two medium yellow squares. There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium blue square is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. Finally, we have block C. It is to the left of block B. It contains a medium yellow square. This block also has a medium black square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square. Which object is below a medium black square? the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium yellow square number one?
(a) the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium yellow square number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has two medium black squares and a medium blue square. Below Block A is Block B, which contains two medium yellow squares and a medium blue square. Block C, to the left of Block B, contains a medium black square and a medium yellow square. The question asks what is below *a* medium black square. There are three medium black squares: two in Block A and one in Block C. The one in Block C has a medium yellow square below it. One of the ones in Block A (number one) has medium yellow square number one below it. The other black square in Block A (number 2) is above the blue square, which in turn is above medium yellow square number two. Therefore, medium yellow square number one is below a medium black square, and the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of a block (in Block C) is also below a medium black square.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly identifies the number of black squares and incorrectly assigns relationships between black squares in Block A and medium yellow square number one, leading to an inaccurate justification for the conclusion.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
There are three medium black squares: two in Block A and one in Block C.
Explanation
The context states Block A has two medium black squares, and Block C has one medium black square. It does not mention a third medium black square in Block C, only one.
Answer Span:
There are three medium black squares: two in Block A and one in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has two medium black squares. . . Finally, we have block C. It is to the left of block B. It contains a medium yellow square. This block also has a medium black square.
contradictionhigh
Statement
The one in Block A (number one) has medium yellow square number one below it.
Explanation
The context states medium black square number one (in Block A) is below the medium blue square and medium black square number two. It does not state that medium yellow square number one is below it.
Answer Span:
The one in Block A (number one) has medium yellow square number one below it.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square and medium black square number two.
Question #1154
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium black squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. T...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium black squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium yellow square and medium black square number two. Below the medium yellow square there is medium black square number two. Then, we have block B. It has one medium black square and one medium blue square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. Finally, we have block C which is above block A. Block B is to the right of it. It contains a medium yellow square. This block also has one medium black square. This block also contains a medium blue square. Below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square there is the medium black square. Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square. Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block C or the medium blue square which is in block B?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block C
(b) the medium blue square which is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains two medium black squares and one medium yellow square. Block B, to the right of Block C, contains one medium black square and one medium blue square. Block C, above Block A, contains one medium yellow square, one medium black square, and one medium blue square. The question asks what is to the right of *a* medium black square. Since Block B is to the right of Block C (and Block A), the medium blue square in Block B is to the right of the medium black squares in Block A and C. However, Block B is to the right of block C. The medium black square from C is not to the right of the medium black square. The medium blue square from block C is in the same block C.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsupported leap regarding the horizontal positioning of objects across blocks (A, B, C) to conclude that the blue square in B is to the right of black squares in A and C. It also incorrectly summarizes the initial block descriptions. Crucially, it fails to use the specific vertical/horizontal constraints given for objects within Block C to determine the answer.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionlow
Statement
Block B, to the right of Block C, contains one medium black square and one medium blue square.
Explanation
The context states that Block B is to the right of Block C, but it does not specify the relative position of Block B to Block C in the initial description of the blocks' contents. The context later states: 'Block B is to the right of it [Block C]'. The reasoning chain presents this as a definitive placement established early on, which is slightly misleading, but the main contradiction is in the next point.
Answer Span:
Block B, to the right of Block C, contains one medium black square and one medium blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the right of it.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B is to the right of Block C (and Block A), the medium blue square in Block B is to the right of the medium black squares in Block A and C.
Explanation
The reasoning claims the medium blue square in Block B is to the right of the medium black squares in Block A and C based on Block B being to the right of Block C and A. However, the spatial relationship between objects *within* different blocks (A, B, C) is not fully defined by just stating which block is to the right of another. The question asks which object is to the right of *a* medium black square. The reasoning jumps to a conclusion about relative horizontal position between objects in different blocks without establishing the necessary horizontal alignment facts from the context.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is to the right of Block C (and Block A), the medium blue square in Block B is to the right of the medium black squares in Block A and C.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block C or the medium blue square which is in block B?
Question #1545
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium blue squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. Th...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium blue squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. The medium yellow square is below the medium black square. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. The medium yellow square is below medium blue square number one which is below the medium black square. It is below medium blue square number two. Then, there is block B with one medium yellow square in it. There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square. Below block A and to the left of block B there is block C. It contains one medium black square and one medium blue square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. Which object is above a medium blue square? medium blue square number one or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium blue square number one
(b) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains two medium blue squares (number one and number two), a medium yellow square, and a medium black square. The order from top to bottom in Block A is: medium black square, medium blue square number two, medium blue square number one, and medium yellow square. Block B contains a medium yellow square and a medium blue square (touching the bottom edge). The medium yellow square is above the medium blue square. Block C contains a medium blue square and a medium black square (touching the bottom edge). The medium blue square is above the medium black square. The question asks what is above *a* medium blue square. In Block B, the medium yellow square is above the medium blue square. In Block C, the medium blue square is above the medium black square. So a medium yellow square and a medium blue square are above a medium blue square somewhere. The question offers medium blue square number one and the medium blue square touching the bottom edge of a block. Medium blue square number one has a medium black square and medium blue square number two above it (in Block A), so this isn't correct. The medium blue square touching the bottom edge of a block (in Block B) has a medium yellow square above it. Therefore, only the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block has a relevant shape above it.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain fabricates a specific vertical order for Block A that contradicts the complex relative positioning provided in the context. It also makes an unsubstantiated claim about the objects above medium blue square number one, leading to an incorrect dismissal of option (a) based on flawed internal logic derived from the initial ordering error.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The order from top to bottom in Block A is: medium black square, medium blue square number two, medium blue square number one, and medium yellow square.
Explanation
The context provides specific relative positions for the objects in Block A, which are contradicted by this stated order. The context states: 'The medium yellow square is below the medium black square. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. The medium yellow square is below medium blue square number one which is below the medium black square. It is below medium blue square number two.' This implies the black square is highest, but the exact sequence derived here is not supported and contradicts the complex relative positioning given.
Answer Span:
The order from top to bottom in Block A is: medium black square, medium blue square number two, medium blue square number one, and medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Two medium blue squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. The medium yellow square is below the medium black square. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. The medium yellow square is below medium blue square number one which is below the medium black square. It is below medium blue square number two.
contradictionmedium
Statement
Medium blue square number one has a medium black square and medium blue square number two above it (in Block A), so this isn't correct.
Explanation
The reasoning claims that medium blue square number one has both the medium black square AND medium blue square number two above it. The context states that medium blue square number two is below the medium black square, and medium blue square number one is below the medium black square. Crucially, the context states: 'The medium yellow square is below medium blue square number one which is below the medium black square. It [medium yellow square] is below medium blue square number two.' This implies that medium blue square number two is *above* medium blue square number one, but the reasoning incorrectly asserts that both the black square AND blue square number two are above blue square number one, and then uses this flawed premise to dismiss option (a). The context does not explicitly state the relationship between blue square 1 and blue square 2, only that both are below the black square, and blue square 1 is above yellow, and yellow is below blue square 2.
Answer Span:
Medium blue square number one has a medium black square and medium blue square number two above it (in Block A), so this isn't correct.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. The medium yellow square is below medium blue square number one which is below the medium black square. It is below medium blue square number two.
Question #1153
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium black squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. T...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium black squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium yellow square and medium black square number two. Below the medium yellow square there is medium black square number two. Then, we have block B. It has one medium black square and one medium blue square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. Finally, we have block C which is above block A. Block B is to the right of it. It contains a medium yellow square. This block also has one medium black square. This block also contains a medium blue square. Below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square there is the medium black square. Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square. Which object is above a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is in block A or the medium yellow square which is in block C?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(b) the medium yellow square which is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains two medium black squares and a medium yellow square. The medium yellow square is above medium black square number one. Block C, which is above Block A, contains a medium yellow square and a medium black square. The medium yellow square in Block C is above the medium black square in the same block. Therefore, the medium yellow square in Block C is above a medium black square. The medium yellow square in Block A is also above a medium black square (number one).
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies that both yellow squares mentioned in the options are above a medium black square based on the provided context, leading to the correct choice (c).
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2513
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of C and block C is below A. Block A has one big yellow triangle and one small yellow square. The big yellow triangle is far fro...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of C and block C is below A. Block A has one big yellow triangle and one small yellow square. The big yellow triangle is far from and to the right of a big blue triangle which is to the right of and above the small yellow square. Block B has two big blue squares. This block also contains one big blue circle. This block also has a small yellow triangle. It also has one small black circle. Big blue square number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big blue circle is to the right of big blue square number two and big blue square number one. And block C has two big black squares. Big black square number one is touching the right edge of this block. This object is to the right of a big yellow triangle and big black square number two. Which object is to the right of a small yellow triangle? the big blue circle that is touching the right edge of a block or the object that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the big blue circle that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the object that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
3
Generated Answer
Block B contains the small yellow triangle. Also in Block B are two big blue squares (number two touching the bottom edge) and a big blue circle. The big blue circle is to the right of both big blue squares. Therefore, the big blue circle is to the right of the small yellow triangle, and big blue square number two (touching the bottom edge) is also to the right of the small yellow triangle. However, only the big blue circle is touching the right edge of the block.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsupported assertion about the relative horizontal positions of objects within Block B (specifically that big blue square number two is to the right of the small yellow triangle), which is not explicitly stated in the context. The context only states the position of the big blue circle relative to big blue square number two.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Therefore, the big blue circle is to the right of the small yellow triangle, and big blue square number two (touching the bottom edge) is also to the right of the small yellow triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain asserts that the big blue circle and big blue square number two are to the right of the small yellow triangle based only on their relative positions within Block B, but the question asks which object is to the right of the small yellow triangle *overall*, and the context does not establish the relative horizontal positions of the small yellow triangle and big blue square number two within Block B, only that the big blue circle is to the right of big blue square number two.
Answer Span:
Therefore, the big blue circle is to the right of the small yellow triangle, and big blue square number two (touching the bottom edge) is also to the right of the small yellow triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a small yellow triangle? the big blue circle that is touching the right edge of a block or the object that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #1294
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A is below B. Block A contains one small black circle, one medium black triangle and one small blue triangle. The small black circle is touching the...
Clean
Full Question
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A is below B. Block A contains one small black circle, one medium black triangle and one small blue triangle. The small black circle is touching the right edge of this block. Below and to the right of a medium black square is the small blue triangle. A medium yellow square is also in this block. Above and to the right of the small blue triangle is the small black circle. The small blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and below the medium black triangle is the small black circle. Block B has two medium black circles. Medium black circle number one is below medium black circle number two. Medium black circle number one is touching the right edge of this block. A small blue square is to the left of and above medium black circle number two. Medium black circle number two is touching the right edge of this block. What is below the small blue square? a small black circle which is touching the right edge of a block or a medium yellow object?
(a) small black circle which is touching the right edge of a block
(b) medium yellow object
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A (below Block B) contains a small black circle touching the right edge. The small blue square is in Block B, above medium black circle number two. Since Block A is directly below Block B, the objects below the small blue square would be those in Block A. The small black circle touching the right edge is in Block A, making it below the small blue square. The medium yellow square is also in block A.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in Block A and Block B and uses the spatial relationship (A is below B) to determine what is below the object in Block B. No contradictions or missing context were found.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #3112
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and below block C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge o...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and below block C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium black square number two. Block B contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below a medium black square and medium yellow square number two. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black square is below medium yellow square number two. Block C contains two medium black squares. Below medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. This block also has one medium yellow square. Below the medium object which is below medium black square number two there is the medium yellow square. It is below medium black square number two. Which object is to the left of a medium black square? the medium black square that is in block B or the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium black square that is in block B
(b) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A has two medium black squares. Block B, to the left of Block A, has two medium yellow squares and a medium black square. Block C has two medium black squares and a medium yellow square. The question asks what is to the left of *a* medium black square. Since Block B is to the left of Block A, and Block B contains a medium black square, the medium black square in Block B is to the left of the medium black squares in Block A. Therefore, the medium black square that is in Block B is to the left of a medium black square (specifically, the ones in Block A). The medium black square touching the bottom edge of a block is in Block A, so it cannot be to the left of a medium black square in Block A.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains a major factual error regarding the contents of Block B (claiming it has a medium black square when the context only assigns black squares to A and C) and makes a flawed logical deduction about the second option based on its location.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block B, to the left of Block A, has two medium yellow squares and a medium black square.
Explanation
The context explicitly states Block B contains two medium yellow squares, but it does not mention Block B containing any medium black squares. Block A contains the two medium black squares.
Answer Span:
Block B, to the left of Block A, has two medium yellow squares and a medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has two medium black squares. . . Block B contains two medium yellow squares.
contradictionmedium
Statement
The medium black square touching the bottom edge of a block is in Block A, so it cannot be to the left of a medium black square in Block A.
Explanation
The context states that the medium black square touching the bottom edge of a block (MB square #1) is in Block A. The reasoning then incorrectly concludes that because it is in Block A, it cannot be to the left of a medium black square in Block A. The question asks if *the object* (the medium black square touching the bottom edge) is to the left of *a* medium black square (any one). Furthermore, the reasoning chain incorrectly assumes the object in question is only compared against squares in Block A.
Answer Span:
The medium black square touching the bottom edge of a block is in Block A, so it cannot be to the left of a medium black square in Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the left of a medium black square? the medium black square that is in block B or the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #97
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. There are a small black circle, one medium black square and a big yellow square in block A. It also contains a medium black triangle. The big yellow square ...
2 issues
Full Question
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. There are a small black circle, one medium black square and a big yellow square in block A. It also contains a medium black triangle. The big yellow square is to the left of the medium black triangle. The small black circle is to the left of the medium black triangle. Above the big yellow square is the medium black square. It is touching the right edge of this block. It is above the medium black triangle. To the right of the square which is to the left of the medium black triangle is the small black circle. Below block A we have block B which contains one big blue triangle, a big yellow square and one small yellow triangle. The big blue triangle is above and to the left of the small yellow triangle. It is above the big yellow square. To the left of the small yellow triangle is the big yellow square. Which object is to the left of a shape which is touching the bottom edge of a block? the big yellow square that is in block A or the big yellow square that is in block B?
(a) the big yellow square that is in block A
(b) the big yellow square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains a big yellow square and Block B (below A) contains a big yellow square. The question asks what is to the left of a shape touching the bottom edge of a block. The big yellow square in Block B is touching the bottom edge of Block B. The big yellow square in Block A is above the big yellow triangle, which is touching the bottom edge of Block A. Since Block B is below Block A, nothing in Block A can be to the left of anything in Block B. Thus, the big yellow square in Block A is not to the left of the big yellow square in block B.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain introduces several unsubstantiated claims about which objects are touching the bottom edges of the blocks and misidentifies an object in Block A ('big yellow triangle' instead of 'medium black triangle'), leading to flawed logic regarding the premise of the question.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The big yellow square in Block B is touching the bottom edge of Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes the big yellow square in Block B is touching the bottom edge of Block B, but the context only states the contents of Block B and their relative positions, not which object is touching the bottom edge.
Answer Span:
The big yellow square in Block B is touching the bottom edge of Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Below block A we have block B which contains one big blue triangle, a big yellow square and one small yellow triangle.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The big yellow square in Block A is above the big yellow triangle, which is touching the bottom edge of Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning claims the big yellow square in Block A is above a big yellow triangle, but the context states Block A contains a 'big yellow square' and a 'medium black triangle', not a 'big yellow triangle'. Furthermore, it assumes the triangle is touching the bottom edge of Block A, which is not stated.
Answer Span:
The big yellow square in Block A is above the big yellow triangle, which is touching the bottom edge of Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. There are a small black circle, one medium black square and a big yellow square in block A. It also contains a medium black triangle.
Question #1070
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of blocks C and B. Block A has one medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this bloc...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of blocks C and B. Block A has one medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. There is also one small blue triangle touching the right edge of this block. Near to and above the medium yellow triangle is the small blue triangle. Block B has one medium yellow square, a big yellow circle and a big blue circle. The medium yellow square is below a big blue triangle. To the right of the big blue circle is the big yellow circle. This object is near to and to the left of the big blue triangle. The medium yellow square is to the right of the big blue circle. The big blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. And block C has one medium blue triangle, one big yellow circle and a small blue triangle. To the right of and near to the big yellow circle which is to the right of and below the small blue triangle is the medium blue triangle. What is near to the big blue triangle? a big yellow circle or a medium yellow triangle?
(a) big yellow circle
(b) medium yellow triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium yellow triangle and a small blue triangle. Block B contains a big blue triangle, a big yellow circle, and a medium yellow square. The big yellow circle is to the left of the big blue triangle. Block C has a medium blue triangle, a big yellow circle, and a small blue triangle. Since the question asks what is *near* the big blue triangle, and the big yellow circle is stated to be near and to the left of the big blue triangle within Block B, the big yellow circle is near the big blue triangle. The medium yellow triangle is in a different block (Block A).
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects near the big blue triangle based on the provided context, specifically noting the big yellow circle's proximity and correctly excluding the medium yellow triangle which is in a different block.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #3419
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of B and block B is above C. Block A has one small yellow triangle, a small blue circle and a big blue circle. To the left of...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of B and block B is above C. Block A has one small yellow triangle, a small blue circle and a big blue circle. To the left of the small blue circle which is to the right of the big blue circle is the small yellow triangle. The big blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Above the big blue circle there is the small yellow triangle. Block B has a big yellow circle. And block C contains one small black square, a big yellow triangle and a big yellow circle. The big yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. This block also has a small black triangle. The small black square is to the left of and above the big yellow triangle which is to the right of the big yellow circle.. One small blue square is also in this block. It is near to and above the big yellow circle. Which object is below a big yellow circle? the big blue circle which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the small black triangle?
(a) the big blue circle which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the small black triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A, which contains the big blue circle touching the bottom edge, is to the right of Block B, which contains a big yellow circle. Block C, which is below Block B, also contains a big yellow circle, a big yellow triangle, a small black square, and a small blue square. The small black triangle is not mentioned in the description. Since Block A is to the right of Block B, the big blue circle is not below the big yellow circle in Block B. The text states that Block C is below Block B. Thus, the objects in block C are below the objects in block B.
Answer: {D}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains a direct factual contradiction regarding the presence of the small black triangle and ignores the necessary steps to determine the vertical relationship between the specified objects (big blue circle and big yellow circle) based on block location.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The small black triangle is not mentioned in the description.
Explanation
The reasoning claims the small black triangle is not mentioned, but the context explicitly states Block C has a small black triangle.
Answer Span:
The small black triangle is not mentioned in the description.
Reference/Question Span:
This block also has a small black triangle.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block A, which contains the big blue circle touching the bottom edge, is to the right of Block B, which contains a big yellow circle.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly associates the big yellow circle (which is in Block B and C) with Block B in this specific sentence structure, but more importantly, it fails to use the positional information (A is right of B, B is above C) to determine which object is *below* which, which is the core of the question. The reasoning jumps to conclusions about relative positions without establishing the necessary vertical relationships for the objects in question.
Answer Span:
Block A, which contains the big blue circle touching the bottom edge, is to the right of Block B, which contains a big yellow circle. Block C, which is below Block B, also contains a big yellow circle, a big yellow triangle, a small black square, and a small blue square. The small black triangle is not mentioned in the description. Since Block A is to the right of Block B, the big blue circle is not below the big yellow circle in Block B. The text states that Block C is below Block B. Thus, the objects in block C are below the objects in block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A is to the right of B and block B is above C. Block A has one small yellow triangle, a small blue circle and a big blue circle. . . Block B has a big yellow circle. And block C contains one small black square, a big yellow triangle and a big yellow circle. . . Which object is below a big yellow circle?
Question #968
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is above block C and it is to the left of block A. Block A contains two small yellow circles. There is also one big black circle in this block. Small yellow c...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is above block C and it is to the left of block A. Block A contains two small yellow circles. There is also one big black circle in this block. Small yellow circle number one is above the big black circle and small yellow circle number two. Block B has two big yellow circles. It also contains one medium yellow triangle. Below big yellow circle number two is big yellow circle number one. It is to the left of and near to the medium yellow triangle. Block C contains a small black square, a big yellow triangle and a small yellow circle. A medium blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a big black square. Above the big black square and the small yellow circle there is the small black square. To the right of and touching the big black square is the medium blue triangle. This object is below the big yellow triangle. What is above the big black square? a blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block or a big yellow circle?
(a) blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) big yellow circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block C contains a big black square. Above the big black square is a small black square. Block B, which is above Block C, contains big yellow circles. Therefore, the object above the big black square is a small black square, not a blue triangle or a big yellow circle.
Answer: {D}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that the small black square is above the big black square. However, it fails to address the specific forced-choice question asked, which requires selecting between option (a) and option (b). It also includes an irrelevant statement about Block B's contents being above Block C as part of its justification.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block B, which is above Block C, contains big yellow circles.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly states that Block B is above Block C. The context states Block B is above Block C, but the reasoning uses this relationship to justify the location of an object, which is irrelevant to the question asked (what is above the big black square in Block C). More critically, the reasoning chain uses the relationship 'Block B, which is above Block C' as part of its justification, but the question is only about objects *within* Block C or objects *touching* Block C.
Answer Span:
Block B, which is above Block C, contains big yellow circles.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is above block C
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Therefore, the object above the big black square is a small black square, not a blue triangle or a big yellow circle.
Explanation
The reasoning correctly identifies that the small black square is above the big black square based on the context. However, the question asks to choose between two specific options: 'a blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block' or 'a big yellow circle'. By concluding the answer is 'none of them' based on the small black square being the answer, it ignores the forced choice presented in the question.
Answer Span:
Therefore, the object above the big black square is a small black square, not a blue triangle or a big yellow circle.
Reference/Question Span:
What is above the big black square? a blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block or a big yellow circle?
Question #1188
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is above A and block B is above C. Block A contains a medium black triangle. Block B contains a big blue triangle and one medium blue circle. The...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is above A and block B is above C. Block A contains a medium black triangle. Block B contains a big blue triangle and one medium blue circle. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has one medium black triangle. To the left of the big blue triangle is the medium black triangle. It is touching and below the medium blue circle. And block C contains one small yellow square, a medium yellow circle and one medium blue triangle. It also contains a medium black square. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. Near to and to the left of the medium black square is the medium blue triangle. The small yellow square is below the medium black square and the medium yellow circle. To the left of the medium black square is the medium yellow circle. Which object is above a medium black triangle? the medium blue triangle or the big blue triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue triangle
(b) the big blue triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium black triangle. Block B (above Block C, which is above A) contains a big blue triangle, a medium blue circle, and a medium black triangle. The big blue triangle is to the right of the medium black triangle in Block B. Block C contains a small yellow square, medium yellow circle, medium blue triangle, and medium black square. Since the medium black triangle is in Block B, and the big blue triangle is also in Block B and directly to the right of the medium black triangle, the object above the medium black triangle is something in Block C. In Block C, the medium blue triangle is present.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly identifies which medium black triangle it is analyzing (ignoring the one in A) and makes a flawed logical leap regarding vertical positioning based on horizontal positioning within Block B, leading to an incorrect conclusion about which block contains the object above it.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
The big blue triangle is to the right of the medium black triangle in Block B.
Explanation
The context states the medium black triangle is to the left of the big blue triangle in Block B, which means the big blue triangle is to the right of the medium black triangle. However, the context also states: 'To the left of the big blue triangle is the medium black triangle. It is touching and below the medium blue circle.' This implies a spatial relationship within the block, but the reasoning chain asserts a specific directional relationship ('to the right of') that is not explicitly stated as the primary relationship for the question, and more importantly, the reasoning chain incorrectly concludes that the object *above* the medium black triangle must be in Block C based on this relationship.
Answer Span:
The big blue triangle is to the right of the medium black triangle in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
To the left of the big blue triangle is the medium black triangle.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since the medium black triangle is in Block B, and the big blue triangle is also in Block B and directly to the right of the medium black triangle, the object above the medium black triangle is something in Block C.
Explanation
The question asks which object is *above* a medium black triangle. There are two medium black triangles mentioned: one in A and one in B. The reasoning chain focuses only on the one in Block B and incorrectly assumes that because the big blue triangle is in the same block (B), the object above it must be in the block above B (which is C). The question asks which object is *above* the medium black triangle, implying a vertical stacking relationship, not just which block is above the block containing the triangle. The reasoning ignores the vertical stacking information (C above A, B above C) when determining what is *above* the triangle in B.
Answer Span:
Since the medium black triangle is in Block B, and the big blue triangle is also in Block B and directly to the right of the medium black triangle, the object above the medium black triangle is something in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C is above A and block B is above C.
Question #3113
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and below block C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge o...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and below block C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium black square number two. Block B contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below a medium black square and medium yellow square number two. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black square is below medium yellow square number two. Block C contains two medium black squares. Below medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. This block also has one medium yellow square. Below the medium object which is below medium black square number two there is the medium yellow square. It is below medium black square number two. Which object is to the left of a medium black square? medium yellow square number two or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium yellow square number two
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has two medium black squares. Block B, to the left of Block A, contains two medium yellow squares and a medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium black square, and medium yellow square number two is above it. Block C is above Block B. The question asks what is to the left of *a* medium black square, meaning any medium black square. Since medium yellow square number two is to the left of the medium black square in Block B, and medium yellow square number one (touching the bottom edge of Block B) is also to the left of the same medium black square.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain introduces a medium black square into Block B, which contradicts the source text, leading to incorrect assumptions about the relative positions of the yellow squares in Block B.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block B, to the left of Block A, contains two medium yellow squares and a medium black square.
Explanation
The context states Block B contains two medium yellow squares, but it does not mention Block B containing any medium black squares. Block A contains the medium black squares.
Answer Span:
Block B, to the left of Block A, contains two medium yellow squares and a medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has two medium black squares.
contradictionhigh
Statement
Since medium yellow square number two is to the left of the medium black square in Block B, and medium yellow square number one (touching the bottom edge of Block B) is also to the left of the same medium black square.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes there is a medium black square in Block B, which is contradicted by the source text. Furthermore, the relative positions (left/right) between squares within blocks are not explicitly defined in a way that supports this conclusion for Block B.
Answer Span:
Since medium yellow square number two is to the left of the medium black square in Block B, and medium yellow square number one (touching the bottom edge of Block B) is also to the left of the same medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has two medium black squares.
Question #188
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block B is to the right of A. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black squa...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block B is to the right of A. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue square is medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two and the medium blue square is medium black square number one. Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two is a medium black square. Below the medium black square is medium yellow square number one. It is below medium yellow square number two. Block C has one medium yellow square and one medium blue square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? medium black square number two or the medium black square which is in block B?
(a) medium black square number two
(b) the medium black square which is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains medium black squares number one and two, and a medium blue square. Block B, to the right of A, contains medium yellow squares number one and two and a medium black square. Block C, to the right of B, contains a medium yellow square and a medium blue square. The question asks what is to the *left* of a medium yellow square. Since Block A is to the left of Block B, and Block B contains medium yellow squares, the objects in Block A (including medium black square number two) are to the left of the medium yellow squares. The medium black square in Block B is not to the left of the medium yellow squares in the same block, but rather below them.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes several unsubstantiated assumptions about the exact contents and numbering of squares within Blocks A and B, leading to potential factual inaccuracies regarding the location of specific squares, even though the final conclusion about relative positioning (A is left of B) is correct for answering the question.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block A contains medium black squares number one and two, and a medium blue square.
Explanation
The context states Block A has two medium black squares and one medium blue square, but it does not specify that medium black square number two is in Block A. The context places medium black square number two below the medium blue square *within* Block A, but it doesn't explicitly state that both black squares are in A, only that A has two medium black squares total. More critically, the reasoning chain incorrectly assumes the identity/location of the squares based on the description order.
Answer Span:
Block A contains medium black squares number one and two, and a medium blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue square is medium black square number two.
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block B, to the right of A, contains medium yellow squares number one and two and a medium black square.
Explanation
The context states Block B has two medium yellow squares and one medium black square, but it does not specify that medium yellow square number two is in Block B. The context only mentions medium yellow square number one and a medium black square in Block B, and then describes the relationship between them and medium yellow square number two, which is described in relation to the medium black square, but the location of medium yellow square number two relative to Block B is not explicitly confirmed as being *in* Block B, only that the medium black square in B is below medium yellow square number two.
Answer Span:
Block B, to the right of A, contains medium yellow squares number one and two and a medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two is a medium black square. Below the medium black square is medium yellow square number one. It is below medium yellow square number two.
Question #1869
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has one medium black triangle, a big black square and one medium yellow square. There is also one big blue circle touching the right edge of th...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has one medium black triangle, a big black square and one medium yellow square. There is also one big blue circle touching the right edge of this block. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of, near to and below the big blue circle. The medium black triangle is touching the top edge of this block. This shape is to the right of, far from and above the big black square. Then, there is block B with a small yellow circle and a big yellow triangle in it. Touching, to the left of and above the big yellow triangle there is the small yellow circle. Block C is above block A and to the left of block B. It contains one medium yellow circle. Which object is to the left of a big circle? the object which is touching the bottom edge of a block that is in block A or the object that is touching the bottom edge of a block that is in block A?
(a) the object which is touching the bottom edge of a block that is in block A
(b) the object that is touching the bottom edge of a block that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains a big blue circle touching the right edge, a medium yellow square touching the bottom edge, a medium black triangle touching the top edge, and a big black square. The medium yellow square is to the left of the big blue circle. The question asks what is to the left of a big circle (the big blue circle). The object touching the bottom edge of Block A is the medium yellow square, which is indeed to the left of the big blue circle. Since both options (a) and (b) refer to the same object (the medium yellow square), and this object is to the left of the big blue circle, both options are correct.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the object in question (medium yellow square) and its location relative to the big blue circle. However, it incorrectly states the big blue circle is contained within Block A, and it omits crucial spatial context ('near to and below') when describing the relationship between the square and the circle.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block A contains a big blue circle touching the right edge
Explanation
The context states the big blue circle is *touching* the right edge of Block A, but it is *not* listed as an object *contained within* Block A, unlike the triangle and squares.
Answer Span:
Block A contains a big blue circle touching the right edge
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has one medium black triangle, a big black square and one medium yellow square. There is also one big blue circle touching the right edge of this block.
missing_contextlow
Statement
The medium yellow square is to the left of the big blue circle.
Explanation
The context states the medium yellow square is 'to the left of, near to and below the big blue circle.' The reasoning chain only mentions 'to the left of', ignoring the other spatial relationships provided in the source text.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow square is to the left of the big blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
It is to the left of, near to and below the big blue circle.
Question #3586
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is above C and block C is below B. Block A contains two small yellow triangles. Small yellow triangle number one is to the left of small yellow triangle numbe...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is above C and block C is below B. Block A contains two small yellow triangles. Small yellow triangle number one is to the left of small yellow triangle number two and a big black triangle. Above and near to small yellow triangle number two is the big black triangle. Block B contains a medium black square. And block C contains two small blue triangles. This block also contains a big black triangle. It is far from, below and to the right of small blue triangle number one. This block also has a small black square. A medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Small blue triangle number two is touching the left edge of this block. There is also one medium blue square in this block. The medium black triangle is to the left of the medium blue square. It is below small blue triangle number one. Which object is below a medium black square? the small black square or the small blue triangle that is touching the left edge of a block?
(a) the small black square
(b) the small blue triangle that is touching the left edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block B contains a medium black square. Block C, which is below Block B, contains two small blue triangles, a small black square, a big black triangle, and a medium blue square. Since Block C is below Block B, the objects below the medium black square are the contents of Block C. The small black square and the small blue triangle touching the left edge are both in Block C, therefore both are below the medium black square.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies that Block B contains the medium black square and Block C is below Block B. It then correctly deduces that the contents of Block C are below the medium black square, leading to the correct conclusion based on the provided context.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #856
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the right of block B and above block A. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the right of block B and above block A. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium blue square number one which is below medium blue square number two. This object is below medium blue square number two. Below medium yellow square number two and medium blue square number one is medium yellow square number one. And block C contains two medium yellow squares. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one.. A medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium blue square number one?
(a) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium blue square number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block B contains two medium blue squares (number one and number two) and two medium yellow squares. Block C, to the right of Block B, contains two medium yellow squares and a medium blue square touching the bottom edge. Since Block C is to the right of Block B, and the medium blue square touching the bottom edge of Block C is in Block C, it is to the right of the other medium blue squares in Block B. Medium blue square number one is in Block B, not to the right of the other medium blue squares.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes significant unsubstantiated assumptions about the contents and location of squares within Block C, leading to a flawed comparison based on incorrect premises about which blue squares exist and where they are located.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block C, to the right of Block B, contains two medium yellow squares and a medium blue square touching the bottom edge.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly assumes Block C contains a medium blue square touching the bottom edge. The context only specifies the contents of Block B and that Block C contains two medium yellow squares. The description of the blue square touching the bottom edge is associated with the object below medium yellow square number two, which is not explicitly stated to be in Block C.
Answer Span:
Block C, to the right of Block B, contains two medium yellow squares and a medium blue square touching the bottom edge.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C contains two medium yellow squares.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Medium blue square number one is in Block B, not to the right of the other medium blue squares.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly assumes the identity and location of 'medium blue square number one' relative to the blocks. The context describes the arrangement of squares *within* Block B, but does not explicitly state that 'medium blue square number one' is in Block B, nor does it define the location of the blue squares in Block C relative to the blue squares in Block B.
Answer Span:
Medium blue square number one is in Block B, not to the right of the other medium blue squares.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium blue square number one which is below medium blue square number two. This object is below medium blue square number two. Below medium yellow square number two and medium blue square number one is medium yellow square number one. And block C contains two medium yellow squares. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one.. A medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two.
Question #2502
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the right of block A and to the left of block C. Block A has one small blue circle. This block also has a medium yellow square. The med...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the right of block A and to the left of block C. Block A has one small blue circle. This block also has a medium yellow square. The medium yellow square is to the right of the small blue circle. Block B contains one small yellow triangle, a medium yellow square and a medium blue triangle. To the left of and above the medium yellow square is the small yellow triangle. Near to the medium blue triangle is a small black triangle. The medium blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. Above and to the right of the small yellow triangle is the small black triangle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. And block C contains a small blue circle. Which object is to the right of a small blue circle? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains a small blue circle and a medium yellow square, with the square to the right of the circle. Block B contains a medium yellow square touching the bottom edge and a medium blue triangle touching the right edge. Block C contains a small blue circle. The question asks what is to the right of *a* small blue circle. This could refer to the one in Block A or Block C. The medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of a block is in Block B, to the right of the small blue circle in Block A. The medium yellow square is not touching the right edge of any block. The small blue circle in Block C has nothing to its right.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the contents of the blocks and the ambiguity of 'a small blue circle'. However, it incorrectly assigns the location of the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge to Block B when the context explicitly links it to Block A.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of a block is in Block B, to the right of the small blue circle in Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning claims the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge is in Block B. The context states Block A has a medium yellow square, and the medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of *this block* (Block A). Block B contains a medium yellow square, but the context does not specify its edge contact.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of a block is in Block B
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has one small blue circle. This block also has a medium yellow square. ... The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block.
Question #1189
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is above A and block B is above C. Block A contains a medium black triangle. Block B contains a big blue triangle and one medium blue circle. The...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is above A and block B is above C. Block A contains a medium black triangle. Block B contains a big blue triangle and one medium blue circle. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has one medium black triangle. To the left of the big blue triangle is the medium black triangle. It is touching and below the medium blue circle. And block C contains one small yellow square, a medium yellow circle and one medium blue triangle. It also contains a medium black square. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. Near to and to the left of the medium black square is the medium blue triangle. The small yellow square is below the medium black square and the medium yellow circle. To the left of the medium black square is the medium yellow circle. Which object is above a medium black triangle? the big object that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow circle?
(a) the big object that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Here's how to break down the locations of the shapes:
* **Block A:** Contains a medium black triangle.
* **Block B:** Contains a big blue triangle (touching the bottom edge), a medium blue circle, and a medium black triangle (to the left of the big blue triangle and below the medium blue circle).
* **Block C:** Contains a small yellow square (touching the right edge), a medium yellow circle, a medium blue triangle, and a medium black square. The relationships are: small yellow square below medium black square and medium yellow circle; medium yellow circle to the left of medium black square; medium blue triangle near and to the left of the medium black square. Block C is above A, and B is above C, so B is the highest block.
The question asks what is above the medium black triangle. The medium black triangle is in Block B. Since Block B is above Block C and Block C is above Block A, nothing is directly above the medium black triangle except other shapes within the same Block B. The big blue triangle is in the same block as the medium black triangle and it is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium yellow circle is in Block C, but this is below Block B, hence it cannot be above the medium black triangle. Hence only the big object that is touching the bottom edge of a block is above the medium black triangle.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the location of the medium black triangle (Block B) and correctly eliminates the medium yellow circle (Block C) as being above it due to block stacking. However, it fails to properly analyze the first candidate, 'the big object that is touching the bottom edge of a block' (the big blue triangle, also in Block B). The reasoning concludes that nothing in Block B is above the medium black triangle except other shapes in Block B, and then incorrectly selects option (a) based on this vague premise, without establishing the relative vertical position of the big blue triangle vs. the medium black triangle within Block B. The logic used to dismiss candidate (b) is sound based on block stacking, but the overall derivation is incomplete and relies on an assumption about the relative positions within Block B.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C is above A, and B is above C, so B is the highest block.
Explanation
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the stacking order (C above A, B above C), but it fails to use this information to determine what is *above* the medium black triangle, which is located in Block B. The conclusion drawn later that 'nothing is directly above the medium black triangle except other shapes within the same Block B' is based on an incorrect interpretation of the question's requirement ('Which object is above a medium black triangle?'). The question asks which *object* is above it, which could be an object in Block B or an object in a block stacked higher than B (if one existed). More critically, the reasoning chain incorrectly concludes that the medium yellow circle (in C) cannot be above the medium black triangle (in B) because C is below B, which is true, but the reasoning chain fails to consider that the question might be asking about objects in Block B itself, or objects in blocks above B (which don't exist). The primary error here is the flawed logic applied to the stacking order when evaluating the candidates.
Answer Span:
Block C is above A, and B is above C, so B is the highest block.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C is above A and block B is above C.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The medium yellow circle is in Block C, but this is below Block B, hence it cannot be above the medium black triangle.
Explanation
The medium black triangle is in Block B. The medium yellow circle is in Block C. Since Block C is below Block B, the medium yellow circle cannot be physically above the medium black triangle. However, the reasoning chain incorrectly dismisses option (b) based on this spatial relationship without fully analyzing the options provided in the question against the actual location of the medium black triangle. The question asks which object is above the medium black triangle. The medium black triangle is in Block B. The candidates are: (a) the big object that is touching the bottom edge of a block (which is the big blue triangle, also in Block B) or (b) the medium yellow circle (in Block C). Since the medium yellow circle is in a lower block (C) than the medium black triangle (B), it cannot be above it. The reasoning chain correctly identifies this spatial impossibility, but the overall conclusion derived from this step is flawed because it ignores the possibility that the big blue triangle (candidate a) *is* above the medium black triangle (if it's located higher within Block B, which is not specified, or if the question implies 'in a higher block'). Crucially, the reasoning chain fails to check if the big blue triangle (candidate a) is actually above the medium black triangle *within* Block B, or if it's simply in the same block. Since the relative vertical positions within Block B are not fully defined for all objects, dismissing candidate (b) based on block stacking is sound, but the subsequent conclusion about candidate (a) is unsupported.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow circle is in Block C, but this is below Block B, hence it cannot be above the medium black triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is above a medium black triangle? the big object that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow circle?
Question #305
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has one big yellow circle. To the left of a medium yellow triangle is the big yellow circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom ...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has one big yellow circle. To the left of a medium yellow triangle is the big yellow circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Block B is above block A. It contains a big black circle. Finally, we have block C. It is to the right of block A. It has one big black circle, one small black circle and one small blue square. It also has a big black square. Near to the big black square is the big black circle. Above the big black square there is the small black circle. The small blue square is to the left of the big black square. This shape is touching the left edge of this block. Far from the blue shape which is to the left of the big black square is the small black circle.. The big black circle is below the black shape which is far from the small blue square. Which object is to the right of a medium thing? the big yellow circle or the small blue square that is touching the left edge of a block?
(a) the big yellow circle
(b) the small blue square that is touching the left edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a big yellow circle and a medium yellow triangle. Block C, to the right of Block A, contains a small blue square touching the left edge. The question asks what is to the right of a "medium thing," which refers to the medium yellow triangle in Block A. Since Block C is to the right of Block A, and the small blue square is in Block C, the small blue square is to the right of the medium yellow triangle. The big yellow circle is to the *left* of the medium yellow triangle, not to the right.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the 'medium thing' as the medium yellow triangle and correctly places the small blue square relative to it based on block positions. However, it incorrectly states that the medium yellow triangle is contained within Block A, which contradicts the explicit description of Block A's contents.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block A contains a big yellow circle and a medium yellow triangle.
Explanation
The context states Block A has one big yellow circle. The medium yellow triangle is *to the left of* the big yellow circle, but it is not stated to be *in* Block A.
Answer Span:
Block A contains a big yellow circle and a medium yellow triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has one big yellow circle. To the left of a medium yellow triangle is the big yellow circle.
Question #855
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the right of block B and above block A. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the right of block B and above block A. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium blue square number one which is below medium blue square number two. This object is below medium blue square number two. Below medium yellow square number two and medium blue square number one is medium yellow square number one. And block C contains two medium yellow squares. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one.. A medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium blue square number two?
(a) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium blue square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares and two medium blue squares, with medium blue square number two at the top, followed by medium blue square number one, medium yellow square number two, and medium yellow square number one at the bottom. Block C has two medium yellow squares and a medium blue square at the bottom. The question asks what is above a medium yellow square. In Block B, medium blue square number two and medium blue square number one are above medium yellow squares. In Block C, medium yellow square number two is above medium yellow square number one, and both of those are above the medium blue square. Only medium blue square number two is above a medium yellow square.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain fabricates a specific vertical arrangement of squares within Block B and incorrectly asserts the presence and location of a blue square in Block C, leading to flawed intermediate steps, even though the final conclusion might coincidentally align with one possible interpretation of the ambiguous source text.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block B has two medium yellow squares and two medium blue squares, with medium blue square number two at the top, followed by medium blue square number one, medium yellow square number two, and medium yellow square number one at the bottom.
Explanation
The reasoning chain invents a specific vertical stacking order for the squares within Block B that is not supported by the text. The text only describes relative positions, not a complete stack from top to bottom.
Answer Span:
medium blue square number two at the top, followed by medium blue square number one, medium yellow square number two, and medium yellow square number one at the bottom
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium blue square number one which is below medium blue square number two. This object is below medium blue square number two. Below medium yellow square number two and medium blue square number one is medium yellow square number one. And block C contains two medium yellow squares. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one.. A medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two.
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block C has two medium yellow squares and a medium blue square at the bottom.
Explanation
The text states Block C contains two medium yellow squares, but it does not specify the location or existence of a medium blue square in Block C. It only mentions a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of 'this block' (referring to the block described immediately before, which is Block B, or perhaps Block A, but the context is ambiguous/incomplete for C). The reasoning chain asserts a specific blue square exists at the bottom of C.
Answer Span:
Block C has two medium yellow squares and a medium blue square at the bottom
Reference/Question Span:
And block C contains two medium yellow squares.
Question #2092
There are three blocks, A, B and C. A big black square, a medium black circle and one medium yellow triangle are in block A. Below the medium yellow triangle and the medium black circle is the big bla...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. A big black square, a medium black circle and one medium yellow triangle are in block A. Below the medium yellow triangle and the medium black circle is the big black square. It is touching the right edge of this block. Near to the medium yellow triangle is the medium black circle. Then, there is block B which has one big black triangle. This block also contains a small yellow triangle. Above a medium black circle which is touching and below the big black triangle there is the small yellow triangle. Above blocks A and B there is block C. It contains one medium yellow square, one small yellow square and one small blue triangle. This block also has a medium blue circle. Below the small blue triangle which is to the right of and above the medium blue circle there is the small yellow square. It is to the right of the medium blue circle. The medium yellow square is to the left of the small yellow square. What is below the medium blue circle? a medium yellow triangle or a small blue triangle?
(a) medium yellow triangle
(b) small blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block C contains the medium blue circle, and the small blue triangle is above it. Block A and Block B are below Block C. Block A contains a medium yellow triangle, but it's below the medium black circle, not the medium blue circle. The small blue triangle is directly above the medium blue circle.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies that the medium blue circle is in Block C and that the medium yellow triangle is in Block A, which is below C. However, it makes an unsupported assumption about the direct vertical relationship between the small blue triangle and the medium blue circle, which is crucial for determining what is *below* the medium blue circle.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The small blue triangle is directly above the medium blue circle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain states the small blue triangle is *directly* above the medium blue circle. The context only states: 'Below the small blue triangle which is to the right of and above the medium blue circle there is the small yellow square.' This implies a spatial relationship, but does not confirm the small blue triangle is *directly* above the medium blue circle, as other objects might intervene vertically between them, or the relationship might be complex due to the 'to the right of' clause.
Answer Span:
The small blue triangle is directly above the medium blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Below the small blue triangle which is to the right of and above the medium blue circle there is the small yellow square.
Question #2091
There are three blocks, A, B and C. A big black square, a medium black circle and one medium yellow triangle are in block A. Below the medium yellow triangle and the medium black circle is the big bla...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. A big black square, a medium black circle and one medium yellow triangle are in block A. Below the medium yellow triangle and the medium black circle is the big black square. It is touching the right edge of this block. Near to the medium yellow triangle is the medium black circle. Then, there is block B which has one big black triangle. This block also contains a small yellow triangle. Above a medium black circle which is touching and below the big black triangle there is the small yellow triangle. Above blocks A and B there is block C. It contains one medium yellow square, one small yellow square and one small blue triangle. This block also has a medium blue circle. Below the small blue triangle which is to the right of and above the medium blue circle there is the small yellow square. It is to the right of the medium blue circle. The medium yellow square is to the left of the small yellow square. What is below the big black triangle? a medium black circle or a medium yellow square?
(a) medium black circle
(b) medium yellow square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium black circle. Block B contains a big black triangle. Block C is above both A and B and contains the medium yellow square. Since Block B (with the big black triangle) is directly above Block A, the object directly below the big black triangle is the medium black circle.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes a critical, unsupported assumption that Block B is directly above Block A, leading to an unsubstantiated conclusion about what is below the big black triangle.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B (with the big black triangle) is directly above Block A, the object directly below the big black triangle is the medium black circle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes Block B is directly above Block A, but the context only states: "Above blocks A and B there is block C." It does not specify the relative vertical position of A and B to each other, which is crucial for determining what is directly below the object in Block B.
Answer Span:
Since Block B (with the big black triangle) is directly above Block A, the object directly below the big black triangle is the medium black circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Above blocks A and B there is block C.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B (with the big black triangle) is directly above Block A, the object directly below the big black triangle is the medium black circle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain concludes the object below the big black triangle is the medium black circle based on the faulty assumption that B is above A. The context states the medium black circle is in Block A, but it does not state that the medium black circle is *directly* below the big black triangle, nor does it state that Block A is directly below Block B.
Answer Span:
the object directly below the big black triangle is the medium black circle.
Reference/Question Span:
What is below the big black triangle? a medium black circle or a medium yellow square?
Question #2256
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this b...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. Below medium blue square number one , medium blue square number two and medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. Block B is to the right of block A. It has a medium black square. A medium yellow square is below the medium black square. Finally, there is block C. It is to the right of block B. It has a medium black square and a medium yellow square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Which object is to the left of a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block C
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains two medium yellow squares and two medium blue squares. Block B, to the right of A, has a medium black square. Block C, to the right of B, also has a medium black square. The question asks what is to the left of a medium black square. The medium yellow square in Block C is above the medium black square in the same block, so it's not to the left. The medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of Block A is to the left of the medium black square in Block B.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes unsupported assumptions about the horizontal positioning of specific squares across block boundaries, leading to a conclusion that relies on spatial inference not explicitly supported by the text (e.g., assuming the yellow square in A is directly left of the black square in B). It also incorrectly dismisses the first option based on a vertical relationship.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
The medium yellow square in Block C is above the medium black square in the same block, so it's not to the left.
Explanation
The context states that in Block C, 'The medium black square is below the medium yellow square,' which means the medium yellow square is above the medium black square. The reasoning correctly infers this relationship but then uses it to conclude it's 'not to the left,' which is an inference about spatial arrangement not explicitly stated as a fact to be checked against the source. However, the critical error is the next statement which assumes a vertical relationship implies it cannot be to the left, which is an unsupported leap. More importantly, the reasoning chain does not check if the medium yellow square in Block C *is* to the left of *any* medium black square, it only checks the one in Block C.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow square in Block C is above the medium black square in the same block, so it's not to the left.
Reference/Question Span:
It has a medium black square and a medium yellow square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of Block A is to the left of the medium black square in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning claims this yellow square is to the left of the black square in Block B. Block A is to the left of Block B, so anything entirely within Block A is to the left of anything entirely within Block B. However, the context only describes the relative positions of the blocks (A is left of B, B is left of C) and the internal arrangement of squares within A, B, and C. It never explicitly states that the specific square 'medium yellow square number one' (which is touching the bottom edge of A) is positioned horizontally relative to the medium black square in Block B, only that Block A is to the left of Block B. This is an assumption based on block placement, not a confirmed spatial relationship between the specific objects.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of Block A is to the left of the medium black square in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. . . Block B is to the right of block A.
Question #2897
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of C and block C is above B. Block A contains three medium yellow squares. It also contains a medium black square. It is below me...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of C and block C is above B. Block A contains three medium yellow squares. It also contains a medium black square. It is below medium yellow square number three. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium yellow square number three and the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium black square and medium yellow square number three. Block B contains two medium yellow squares. One medium blue square is also in this block. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium blue square and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square. Block C contains one medium yellow square. Which object is to the left of a medium square? medium yellow square number three or the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium yellow square number three
(b) the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
3
Generated Answer
Block A contains medium yellow squares 1, 2, and 3, along with a medium black square. Block C, which is to the left of Block A, contains one medium yellow square. Since Block C is directly to the left of Block A, the medium yellow square in Block C is to the left of all the shapes in Block A, including medium yellow square number three and the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge (number one).
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain introduces a false spatial relationship ('Block C, which is to the left of Block A') and incorrectly assigns the numbering of the yellow squares within Block A, leading to a flawed justification for the conclusion.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block A contains medium yellow squares 1, 2, and 3, along with a medium black square.
Explanation
The context states Block A contains three medium yellow squares and one medium black square, but it does not number the yellow squares 1, 2, and 3 within Block A. Yellow square number one is explicitly located relative to Block A, but the reasoning incorrectly assigns all three yellow squares in A as 1, 2, and 3.
Answer Span:
Block A contains medium yellow squares 1, 2, and 3, along with a medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains three medium yellow squares. It also contains a medium black square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block C, which is to the left of Block A, contains one medium yellow square.
Explanation
The context establishes the relative vertical/horizontal positions of the blocks (A is to the right of C, C is above B), but it never states that Block C is *to the left of* Block A. This spatial relationship is assumed/invented by the reasoning chain.
Answer Span:
Block C, which is to the left of Block A, contains one medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A is to the right of C and block C is above B.
Question #2907
We have two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A has a big black circle, one small black triangle and a small black square. This block also has a small yellow triangle. This block also has a big bl...
1 issue
Full Question
We have two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A has a big black circle, one small black triangle and a small black square. This block also has a small yellow triangle. This block also has a big black square. The big black circle is above the small black triangle which is below and to the right of the small black square. The small black square is below the big black square. To the right of the big black square is the big black circle. Block B is to the right of block A. It has a medium black triangle, one small black circle and one small blue triangle. To the right of the small blue triangle is the medium black triangle. This object is below the small black circle. This block also has one big black triangle. This block also has a big yellow triangle. It is near to and below the big black triangle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the big black triangle there is the small blue triangle. What is to the right of the big black circle? a small black circle or a big yellow triangle?
(a) small black circle
(b) big yellow triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains the big black circle. Block B, to the right of Block A, contains the small black circle and the big yellow triangle. Neither of these is directly to the right of the big black circle. The small black triangle is to the right and below the big black circle within block A.
Answer: {D}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in Block B that are candidates for the answer (small black circle and big yellow triangle) and correctly notes that Block B is to the right of Block A. However, it introduces an unsupported positional relationship between the big black circle and the small black triangle within Block A, which is irrelevant to the final question about what is to the right of the big black circle.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The small black triangle is to the right and below the big black circle within block A.
Explanation
The reasoning chain claims the small black triangle is to the right and below the big black circle. The context only states: 'The big black circle is above the small black triangle which is below and to the right of the small black square.' It does not establish the relative position between the big black circle and the small black triangle in terms of 'to the right and below' the circle.
Answer Span:
The small black triangle is to the right and below the big black circle within block A.
Reference/Question Span:
The big black circle is above the small black triangle which is below and to the right of the small black square.
Question #2906
We have two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A has a big black circle, one small black triangle and a small black square. This block also has a small yellow triangle. This block also has a big bl...
1 issue
Full Question
We have two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A has a big black circle, one small black triangle and a small black square. This block also has a small yellow triangle. This block also has a big black square. The big black circle is above the small black triangle which is below and to the right of the small black square. The small black square is below the big black square. To the right of the big black square is the big black circle. Block B is to the right of block A. It has a medium black triangle, one small black circle and one small blue triangle. To the right of the small blue triangle is the medium black triangle. This object is below the small black circle. This block also has one big black triangle. This block also has a big yellow triangle. It is near to and below the big black triangle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the big black triangle there is the small blue triangle. What is to the right of the big black circle? a big black triangle or a small black circle?
(a) big black triangle
(b) small black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains the big black circle. Block B, to the right of Block A, contains the small black circle. Thus, the small black circle is to the right of the big black circle. The big black triangle is also in Block B, but its position relative to the big black circle is not specified as directly to the right.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning incorrectly assumes that because Block B is to the right of Block A, any object in B is automatically to the right of any object in A, which ignores the lack of specific positional data linking the big black circle (in A) to the small black circle (in B).
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Thus, the small black circle is to the right of the big black circle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes that because Block B is to the right of Block A, and the small black circle is in Block B, it must be to the right of the big black circle (which is in Block A). However, the context only states Block B is to the right of Block A; it does not specify the relative horizontal position between specific objects in Block A and specific objects in Block B.
Answer Span:
Thus, the small black circle is to the right of the big black circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the right of block A.
Question #2390
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is below blocks A and C. Block A has two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of ...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is below blocks A and C. Block A has two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium blue square number two is below medium black square number two and medium black square number one. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two. Below medium black square number one and medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Block B has a medium yellow square. And block C contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. A medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. This object is below medium yellow square number one. Which object is above a medium blue square? the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium black square number one?
(a) the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium black square number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains two medium blue squares and two medium black squares. Medium black square number two is above medium black square number one, which is above medium blue square number two, which is above medium blue square number one. Block C contains a medium black square touching the bottom edge, below two medium yellow squares. Since Block B is below Block A, and contains a medium yellow square, the medium black squares in Block A (including medium black square number one) are above the medium blue squares also in Block A. The medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block C is not above a medium blue square.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains a significant factual error regarding the vertical stacking order of squares within Block A, which directly impacts the evaluation of 'medium black square number one'. It also fails to fully address the status of 'the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block' in relation to the blue squares, as it only discusses the one in Block C.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Medium black square number two is above medium black square number one, which is above medium blue square number two, which is above medium blue square number one.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly asserts a vertical relationship between medium black square number one and medium blue square number two. The context states: 'Below medium black square number one and medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one.' This implies medium blue square number one is below both, but it does not establish the direct relationship between medium black square number one and medium blue square number two.
Answer Span:
which is above medium blue square number two, which is above medium blue square number one
Reference/Question Span:
Below medium black square number one and medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block C is not above a medium blue square.
Explanation
The question asks about objects above a medium blue square. The reasoning chain correctly identifies that the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block C is not above a medium blue square (since medium blue squares are only mentioned in Block A). However, the reasoning chain fails to explicitly check the status of the *other* object in question: 'the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block'. The context states that Block A has two medium black squares, one of which is 'Medium black square number one' and the other is not explicitly numbered but is involved in a relationship with medium blue squares. The reasoning chain only discusses the black square touching the bottom edge of Block C, ignoring the status of the black square touching the bottom edge of Block A (if one exists, or if the question implies the black square touching the bottom edge of *a* block refers to one in A). Crucially, the reasoning chain does not establish the vertical position of the black square touching the bottom edge of Block A relative to any blue square in Block A, which is necessary to answer the question.
Answer Span:
The medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block C is not above a medium blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is above a medium blue square? the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium black square number one?
Question #304
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has one big yellow circle. To the left of a medium yellow triangle is the big yellow circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom ...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has one big yellow circle. To the left of a medium yellow triangle is the big yellow circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Block B is above block A. It contains a big black circle. Finally, we have block C. It is to the right of block A. It has one big black circle, one small black circle and one small blue square. It also has a big black square. Near to the big black square is the big black circle. Above the big black square there is the small black circle. The small blue square is to the left of the big black square. This shape is touching the left edge of this block. Far from the blue shape which is to the left of the big black square is the small black circle.. The big black circle is below the black shape which is far from the small blue square. What is to the left of the big black square? a small black circle or a small blue square that is touching the left edge of a block?
(a) small black circle
(b) small blue square that is touching the left edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block C contains a big black square, a small black circle, and a small blue square. The small blue square is to the left of the big black square and touching the left edge of Block C. The small black circle is above the big black square. Since the question asks what is *to the left* of the big black square, and the small blue square is stated to be to its left, that is the correct answer.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relevant facts within Block C regarding the relative positions of the big black square, the small blue square, and the small black circle, leading to the correct conclusion based on the provided context.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #722
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of and C is below A. Block A contains a big blue circle. Block B has one medium blue circle and a big blue triangle. This block ...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of and C is below A. Block A contains a big blue circle. Block B has one medium blue circle and a big blue triangle. This block also contains one small black square. To the left of the big blue triangle and the medium blue circle there is the small black square. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. And block C has one medium black square, a medium blue circle and one small black square. There is also a small black triangle in this block. Above the small black square and the small black triangle there is the medium black square. The medium blue circle is touching the top edge of this block. The small black square is to the left of the small black triangle. The medium blue circle is to the right of and above the small black square. Which object is to the left of a small black triangle? the big blue circle or the medium blue circle which is touching the top edge of a block?
(a) the big blue circle
(b) the medium blue circle which is touching the top edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
3
Generated Answer
Block A contains a big blue circle, Block B contains a medium blue circle and a big blue triangle, and Block C contains a medium blue circle, a medium black square, a small black square, and a small black triangle. The small black triangle is in Block C, and the small black square is to its left. The medium blue circle in Block C is above and to the right of the small black square. The big blue circle is in Block A. Since Block C is below Block A, and the small black triangle is in Block C, the big blue circle isn't to its left. The medium blue circle that is touching the top edge of Block C is to the right of the small black square, which is to the left of the small black triangle.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the location of the small black triangle (Block C) and uses the spatial relationship ('the small black square is to the left of the small black triangle') to determine that the small black square is to the left of the small black triangle. It then correctly deduces that the big blue circle (in A) is not to the left of the small black triangle (in C) because C is below A. The reasoning correctly identifies that the medium blue circle touching the top edge of its block (Block C) is to the right of the small black square, which is to the left of the small black triangle. However, there is a minor issue in describing the contents of Block C in the initial summary, although the final conclusion relies on the correct facts.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionlow
Statement
The medium blue circle in Block C is above and to the right of the small black square.
Explanation
The context states the medium blue circle in Block C is touching the top edge of the block, and it is to the right of and above the small black square. The reasoning chain incorrectly states the medium blue circle in Block C is above and to the right of the small black square, which is true, but it omits the crucial detail that the medium blue circle in Block C is touching the top edge of the block, which is relevant for identifying the object in option (b). More critically, the reasoning chain later identifies the object in option (b) as 'The medium blue circle that is touching the top edge of Block C', which is a correct identification based on the context, but the initial statement about the medium blue circle in Block C is slightly incomplete/misleading in isolation.
Answer Span:
The medium blue circle in Block C is above and to the right of the small black square.
Reference/Question Span:
The medium blue circle is to the right of and above the small black square.
Question #762
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one medium blue circle. One medium blue square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue circle is the medium blu...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one medium blue circle. One medium blue square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue circle is the medium blue square. Block B is below block A. It contains a small blue triangle, a medium yellow square and a medium blue circle. The small blue triangle is to the left of the medium yellow square and a big black square. The medium yellow square is to the left of the big black square. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. To the left of block B there is block C with two medium black circles in it. Medium black circle number one is below and touching a small yellow square. Medium black circle number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of and near to medium black circle number two is medium black circle number one. Which object is below a medium blue circle? the medium blue square or the big shape which is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square
(b) the big shape which is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium blue circle above a medium blue square. Block B, below Block A, has a big black square touching its right edge. Since the medium blue circle is in Block A and the medium blue square is directly below it (also in Block A), the object below the medium blue circle is the medium blue square. The big black square is in Block B, which is below Block A as a whole, but not directly below the medium blue circle.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the object below the medium blue circle based on the context provided for Block A and correctly dismisses the other option based on location.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #3225
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains one big blue triangle and a big blue square. The big blue triangle is to the right of the big blue square. Block B is below block A. It has one big y...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains one big blue triangle and a big blue square. The big blue triangle is to the right of the big blue square. Block B is below block A. It has one big yellow circle. To the right of block A there is block C with a medium yellow circle, a small yellow circle and one medium yellow square in it. The medium yellow circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a small black square. Above the medium yellow square is the small yellow circle. The medium yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. A big yellow square is touching the left edge of this block. Far from and to the right of the big yellow square there is the medium yellow square.. The small yellow circle is to the right of the big yellow square. Below the big yellow square there is the medium yellow circle. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? the square that is touching the left edge of a block or the small yellow circle?
(a) the square that is touching the left edge of a block
(b) the small yellow circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block C contains a medium yellow square touching the right edge, a small yellow circle above it, and a big yellow square touching the left edge. The small yellow circle is to the right of the big yellow square, which means the big yellow square (the one touching the left edge) is to the left of the small yellow circle, which is itself to the left of the medium yellow square. Therefore, both the big yellow square and the small yellow circle are to the left of the medium yellow square.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in Block C but makes an unsupported inference about the relative horizontal positions of the small yellow circle and the medium yellow square, leading to an incorrect intermediate conclusion about what is to the left of the medium yellow square.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionmedium
Statement
The small yellow circle is to the right of the big yellow square, which means the big yellow square (the one touching the left edge) is to the left of the small yellow circle, which is itself to the left of the medium yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly concludes the order is Big Yellow Square -> Small Yellow Circle -> Medium Yellow Square based on the premise that the small yellow circle is to the right of the big yellow square. The context states the small yellow circle is to the right of the big yellow square, but it does not state the medium yellow square is to the right of the small yellow circle. In fact, the context states the small yellow circle is *above* the medium yellow square, which implies they are vertically aligned or that the circle is not necessarily to the right of the square.
Answer Span:
which is itself to the left of the medium yellow square
Reference/Question Span:
Above the medium yellow square is the small yellow circle.
Question #2389
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is below blocks A and C. Block A has two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of ...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is below blocks A and C. Block A has two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium blue square number two is below medium black square number two and medium black square number one. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two. Below medium black square number one and medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Block B has a medium yellow square. And block C contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. A medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. This object is below medium yellow square number one. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium blue square number two?
(a) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium blue square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains two medium blue squares and two medium black squares. Medium blue square number one is at the bottom. Above it are medium blue square number two and the two black squares. Block B, below A, has a medium yellow square. Block C, also positioned below A (so both B and C are below A), has two medium yellow squares and a medium black square at the bottom. The question asks what is above the medium yellow square (singular). Since Block B has *a* medium yellow square and Block A is above it, we need to consider the contents of Block A. In Block A, both medium blue square number one (touching the bottom edge) and medium blue square number two are above the location of the medium yellow square in Block B.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly establishes the relative positions of blocks B and C, and then focuses only on the yellow square in Block B, ignoring the structure related to Block C, which is crucial for evaluating the options provided in the question.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block C, also positioned below A (so both B and C are below A)
Explanation
The context states Block B is below A and C, not that C is below A.
Answer Span:
Block C, also positioned below A (so both B and C are below A)
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is below blocks A and C.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
In Block A, both medium blue square number one (touching the bottom edge) and medium blue square number two are above the location of the medium yellow square in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly assumes that the question is asking about the medium yellow square in Block B. The question asks which object is above *a* medium yellow square, and there are yellow squares in Block B and Block C. The reasoning ignores the structure of Block C entirely when evaluating the options.
Answer Span:
In Block A, both medium blue square number one (touching the bottom edge) and medium blue square number two are above the location of the medium yellow square in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium blue square number two?
Question #2694
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the left of A. Block A is above B. Block A has two medium black squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium black squ...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the left of A. Block A is above B. Block A has two medium black squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square. It is below medium black square number two. Block B has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium black square number two. Block C has two medium yellow squares. A medium blue square is below medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block A or the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(b) the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block C contains two medium yellow squares, one of which is touching the bottom edge. Block A, which is to the right of Block C, contains a medium yellow square. Thus, the medium yellow square in Block A is to the right of both medium yellow squares in Block C.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly interprets the spatial relationships provided and fails to address the actual question asked, which requires identifying an object to the right of a specific yellow square. It incorrectly assumes the left/right relationship between blocks (C left of A) directly answers the question about what is to the right of a yellow square.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionlow
Statement
Block C contains two medium yellow squares, one of which is touching the bottom edge.
Explanation
The context states Block C has two medium yellow squares, but it does not specify that one is touching the bottom edge. It specifies that for Block C's yellow squares, 'Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block.' The reasoning chain incorrectly generalizes this specific fact about one square to imply that one of the two squares *is* touching the bottom edge, which is true, but the reasoning chain then uses this structure to justify the next step, which is flawed.
Answer Span:
Block C contains two medium yellow squares, one of which is touching the bottom edge.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C has two medium yellow squares. . . Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Thus, the medium yellow square in Block A is to the right of both medium yellow squares in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning chain concludes that the yellow square in A is to the right of the yellow squares in C based on the spatial relationship 'Block C is to the left of A'. However, the question asks which object is to the *right* of a medium yellow square, not which yellow square is to the right of another object. The reasoning chain fails to establish the necessary spatial relationship (right/left) between the yellow squares themselves or between the yellow squares and any other object that would answer the question.
Answer Span:
Thus, the medium yellow square in Block A is to the right of both medium yellow squares in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block A or the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #98
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. There are a small black circle, one medium black square and a big yellow square in block A. It also contains a medium black triangle. The big yellow square ...
Clean
Full Question
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. There are a small black circle, one medium black square and a big yellow square in block A. It also contains a medium black triangle. The big yellow square is to the left of the medium black triangle. The small black circle is to the left of the medium black triangle. Above the big yellow square is the medium black square. It is touching the right edge of this block. It is above the medium black triangle. To the right of the square which is to the left of the medium black triangle is the small black circle. Below block A we have block B which contains one big blue triangle, a big yellow square and one small yellow triangle. The big blue triangle is above and to the left of the small yellow triangle. It is above the big yellow square. To the left of the small yellow triangle is the big yellow square. What is to the left of the small yellow triangle? a big yellow square or a medium shape that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) big yellow square
(b) medium shape that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium black square touching the right edge. Block B contains a big yellow square and a small yellow triangle, with the big yellow square to the left of the small yellow triangle. Since the question asks what is to the left of the small yellow triangle, and the big yellow square is directly to its left, the answer is the big yellow square. The medium black square is in a different block (A) and is not to the left of the small yellow triangle.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relevant objects and their relative positions in Block B to answer the final question, without contradicting or ignoring key constraints.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2620
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the left of B and block B is to the left of C. Block A contains two medium yellow squares. One medium blue square is also touching the bo...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the left of B and block B is to the left of C. Block A contains two medium yellow squares. One medium blue square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two is medium yellow square number one. Below the square which is below medium yellow square number two there is the medium blue square. It is below medium yellow square number two. Block B contains one medium blue square. Block C has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below a medium black square is medium blue square number two. It also contains one medium yellow square. It is below the medium black square. It is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is below the medium yellow square and the medium black square. What is to the left of the black shape? a medium yellow square number one or a medium yellow square that is in block C?
(a) medium yellow square number one
(b) medium yellow square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains two medium yellow squares (number one below number two) and a medium blue square at the bottom. Block B contains a medium blue square. Block C contains two medium blue squares (number two above number one), a medium black square, and a medium yellow square at the bottom. The blocks are arranged A to the left of B, and B to the left of C. The medium black square is in Block C. Since Block B is to the left of Block C, and Block B contains nothing but a medium blue square, the shape to the left of the black shape in Block C is the medium blue square in Block B. Neither of the yellow squares mentioned are to the left of the black shape.
Answer: {D}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes several unsupported assumptions about the contents and internal structure of Block C, specifically inventing the vertical order of its blue squares and incorrectly stating it contains a yellow square. This leads to an incorrect final conclusion based on flawed premises.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block C contains two medium blue squares (number two above number one)
Explanation
The context describes the vertical arrangement of squares within Block A, but it does not specify the vertical arrangement of the two medium blue squares in Block C, nor does it label them as number one and number two in a specific vertical order. The reasoning invents an ordering for Block C's blue squares.
Answer Span:
Block C contains two medium blue squares (number two above number one)
Reference/Question Span:
Block C has two medium blue squares.
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block C contains two medium blue squares (number two above number one), a medium black square, and a medium yellow square at the bottom.
Explanation
The context states Block C has two medium blue squares and mentions a medium black square and a medium yellow square in relation to other elements, but it never explicitly states that Block C contains a medium yellow square. The context only mentions Block A contains two medium yellow squares and Block B contains one medium yellow square (implied by the final sentence relating MB1 to MY). The reasoning incorrectly assigns a yellow square to Block C.
Answer Span:
Block C contains two medium blue squares (number two above number one), a medium black square, and a medium yellow square at the bottom.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains two medium yellow squares.
Question #1748
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. A small yellow circle is in block A. Block B is to the right of block A. It has two medium yellow triangles. Above and near to a medium yellow square i...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. A small yellow circle is in block A. Block B is to the right of block A. It has two medium yellow triangles. Above and near to a medium yellow square is medium yellow triangle number two. There is also one medium black circle in this block. It also contains a small blue circle. The small blue circle is below and touching medium yellow triangle number two. Below and to the right of medium yellow triangle number two is the medium black circle. To the right of block A there is block C which has two medium yellow squares. It also contains one medium yellow triangle. It also contains a medium yellow circle. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of and below the medium yellow circle there is the medium yellow triangle. Near to, to the left of and below the medium yellow circle is medium yellow square number two. What is to the right of the small yellow circle? a medium black circle or a medium yellow triangle?
(a) medium black circle
(b) medium yellow triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has a small yellow circle. Block B, to the right of Block A, contains two medium yellow triangles, a medium black circle, and a small blue circle. Block C is also to the right of Block A but contains medium yellow squares, a medium yellow triangle, and a medium yellow circle. Since Block B is to the right of Block A, and Block B contains both medium yellow triangles and a medium black circle, both are to the right of the small yellow circle in Block A.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the contents of Block A (small yellow circle) and notes that Block B, which is to the right of A, contains both a medium black circle and medium yellow triangles. The conclusion that both are to the right of the small yellow circle is logically derived from the spatial arrangement described, even though the final answer choice selection might be debatable based on the exact phrasing of the question ('What is to the right of the small yellow circle?'). However, the reasoning chain itself does not contain factual contradictions or ignore crucial context.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2543
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There is a medium yellow square in block A. Above block A there is block B which contains one medium blue triangle and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow t...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There is a medium yellow square in block A. Above block A there is block B which contains one medium blue triangle and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium blue triangle is near to a medium yellow circle. It is above the medium yellow triangle. Below the medium yellow circle is the medium yellow triangle. To the right of block A there is block C with one medium yellow square and a big yellow square in it. A small blue triangle is above the medium yellow square. The medium yellow square is above the big yellow square. The big yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. This object is near to and far from a big blue square. The small blue triangle is to the right of the big blue square. Which object is near to a medium yellow object? the medium yellow triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue triangle?
(a) the medium yellow triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block B contains a medium yellow triangle and a medium blue triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge. The medium blue triangle is near a medium yellow circle, which is above the medium yellow triangle. Therefore, the medium blue triangle is near the medium yellow circle and the medium yellow triangle. This means both shapes are near a medium yellow object.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies that the medium blue triangle is near a medium yellow circle, and the medium yellow triangle is below that circle, implying the medium blue triangle is near the medium yellow triangle (which is a medium yellow object). The conclusion that both are near a medium yellow object is supported by the text, although the reasoning focuses only on the blue triangle's proximity to the yellow circle/triangle.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1610
We have two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A has a small yellow triangle, one small blue circle and a small black circle. There is also one big blue circle touching the bottom edge of this bloc...
1 issue
Full Question
We have two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A has a small yellow triangle, one small blue circle and a small black circle. There is also one big blue circle touching the bottom edge of this block. The small black circle is to the left of the big blue circle. The small yellow triangle is above the big blue circle. It is to the left of the small blue circle which is to the right of the small black circle. Above the big blue circle is the small blue circle. Block B is above block A. It has one big yellow circle, one small black square and one small yellow triangle. A big blue circle is to the left of the big yellow circle , the small yellow triangle and the small black square. The big yellow circle is above the small yellow triangle. The small black square is touching the right edge of this block. What is to the left of the big yellow circle? a big blue circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a big blue circle that is in block B?
(a) big blue circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) big blue circle that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a big blue circle touching the bottom edge. Block B, above Block A, contains a big yellow circle and a big blue circle to its left. The question asks what is to the left of the big yellow circle, and the big blue circle in Block B fits that description. The big blue circle touching the bottom edge of Block A is not to the left of the big yellow circle in Block B.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly asserts that Block B contains a big blue circle, which contradicts the explicit listing of Block B's contents and ignores the ambiguity of the location of the big blue circle mentioned relative to Block B.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block B, above Block A, contains a big yellow circle and a big blue circle to its left.
Explanation
The reasoning chain claims Block B contains a big blue circle, but the context only lists the contents of Block B as: one big yellow circle, one small black square and one small yellow triangle. The big blue circle mentioned here is described as being to the left of the big yellow circle, but the context does not state this big blue circle is *in* Block B; it only states that 'A big blue circle is to the left of the big yellow circle...'. The context does not specify the location of this big blue circle relative to Block B, only that it is to the left of the big yellow circle (which is in B). The reasoning incorrectly asserts the big blue circle is *in* Block B.
Answer Span:
Block B, above Block A, contains a big yellow circle and a big blue circle to its left.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is above block A. It has one big yellow circle, one small black square and one small yellow triangle. A big blue circle is to the left of the big yellow circle , the small yellow triangle and the small black square.
Question #516
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There is one big yellow square in block A. It also contains one medium black square. The medium black square is near to, above and to the right of the big yellow sq...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There is one big yellow square in block A. It also contains one medium black square. The medium black square is near to, above and to the right of the big yellow square. The big yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below block A is block B. It contains a big blue circle and a small black circle. The small black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is near to and to the right of the small black circle. Above block A there is block C which has a big blue triangle and one big yellow triangle. The big blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. This object is above and to the right of the big yellow triangle. What is below the big yellow square? a big blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block or a small black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) big blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) small black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains the big yellow square. Block B, below Block A, contains the small black circle. Since Block B is directly below Block A, the object below the big yellow square is the small black circle.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relationship between Block A and Block B (B is below A) and correctly concludes that the object below the big yellow square (which is in A) must be an object in B. The reasoning chain is sound based on the provided context.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2693
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the left of A. Block A is above B. Block A has two medium black squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium black squ...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the left of A. Block A is above B. Block A has two medium black squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square. It is below medium black square number two. Block B has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium black square number two. Block C has two medium yellow squares. A medium blue square is below medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block A or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium yellow square and two medium black squares. Block B, below A, has two medium black squares. Block C, to the left of A, has two medium yellow squares and a medium blue square. The question asks what is below *a* medium yellow square. This could refer to either of the medium yellow squares in Block C, or the one in Block A. The medium yellow square in Block A has a medium black square below it. Medium yellow square number two in Block C has a medium blue square below it, while medium yellow square number one (touching the bottom edge of Block C) has nothing below it. Thus, only the medium yellow square in Block A has another object (medium black square number one) directly below it.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes two significant factual errors regarding what is below specific medium yellow squares, directly contradicting or misinterpreting the positional information provided in the context.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The medium yellow square in Block A has a medium black square below it.
Explanation
The context states that Block A is above B, and Block A has one medium yellow square. It does not state what is below the medium yellow square in Block A. The reasoning incorrectly asserts a medium black square is below it.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow square in Block A has a medium black square below it.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has two medium black squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square.
contradictionhigh
Statement
Medium yellow square number two in Block C has a medium blue square below it, while medium yellow square number one (touching the bottom edge of Block C) has nothing below it.
Explanation
The context states: 'A medium blue square is below medium yellow square number two.' This part is correct. However, the context states: 'Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square.' This implies that medium yellow square number one is *above* the medium blue square, not that it has *nothing* below it. Furthermore, the question asks what is below *a* medium yellow square, and the reasoning incorrectly concludes that medium yellow square number one has nothing below it based on the provided text.
Answer Span:
while medium yellow square number one (touching the bottom edge of Block C) has nothing below it.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square.
Question #1345
We have two blocks, A and B. Block A contains one small yellow circle, a big blue circle and a small black circle. The small yellow circle is below the big blue circle. The big blue circle is to the l...
Clean
Full Question
We have two blocks, A and B. Block A contains one small yellow circle, a big blue circle and a small black circle. The small yellow circle is below the big blue circle. The big blue circle is to the left of and above the small black circle. The small black circle is touching the right edge of this block. To the right of block A we have block B. It contains a medium yellow square, one big blue triangle and one small black triangle. This block also has a medium yellow circle. Above the small black triangle and the big blue triangle is a medium black triangle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The small black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the medium yellow circle and the small black triangle is the big blue triangle. Which object is to the right of a object that is touching the right edge of a block? the big blue circle or the medium square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the big blue circle
(b) the medium square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a small black circle touching its right edge. Block B, to the right of Block A, contains a medium yellow square touching the bottom edge, a small black triangle also touching the bottom edge, and a big blue triangle. Since Block B is to the right of Block A, the medium yellow square and the small black triangle, which are both in Block B, are to the right of the small black circle (which touches the right edge of Block A).
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the object touching the right edge of a block (the small black circle in Block A) and then correctly identifies objects in Block B that are to the right of it, which is the core of the question. The conclusion is based on sound application of the spatial relationships provided.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1295
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A is below B. Block A contains one small black circle, one medium black triangle and one small blue triangle. The small black circle is touching the...
2 issues
Full Question
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A is below B. Block A contains one small black circle, one medium black triangle and one small blue triangle. The small black circle is touching the right edge of this block. Below and to the right of a medium black square is the small blue triangle. A medium yellow square is also in this block. Above and to the right of the small blue triangle is the small black circle. The small blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and below the medium black triangle is the small black circle. Block B has two medium black circles. Medium black circle number one is below medium black circle number two. Medium black circle number one is touching the right edge of this block. A small blue square is to the left of and above medium black circle number two. Medium black circle number two is touching the right edge of this block. Which object is below a medium black circle? the small blue square or the medium black square?
(a) the small blue square
(b) the medium black square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium black square, and Block B contains two medium black circles, with circle number two above circle number one. Block A is below Block B. Since Block A is directly below Block B, and the medium black square is in Block A, the medium black square is below the medium black circles. The small blue square is to the left of medium black circle number two, not below it.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly asserts the presence of a 'medium black square' in Block A, which contradicts the provided context. It also makes an unsupported assumption about Block A being *directly* below Block B.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block A contains a medium black square
Explanation
The context states Block A contains 'one small black circle, one medium black triangle and one small blue triangle' and 'A medium yellow square is also in this block.' It never mentions a medium black square in Block A.
Answer Span:
Block A contains a medium black square
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains one small black circle, one medium black triangle and one small blue triangle. . . A medium yellow square is also in this block.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block A is directly below Block B
Explanation
The context states 'Block A is below B,' but it does not specify that it is *directly* below B. This assumption is used to justify the next step.
Answer Span:
Since Block A is directly below Block B
Reference/Question Span:
Block A is below B.
Question #464
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Blocks B and A are below C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium bl...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Blocks B and A are below C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square. A medium blue square is also in this block. It is below medium black square number two. Below the medium blue square , the medium yellow square and medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. Block B has one medium blue square and one medium yellow square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It also contains one medium black square. This object is below the medium yellow square. Below the medium black square and the medium yellow square is the medium blue square. Block C contains one medium black square. Which object is below a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is in block B or the medium yellow square that is in block A?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block B
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium yellow square above medium black square number two. Block B contains a medium yellow square above a medium black square. Block C contains only a medium black square. Since both Block A and Block B have a medium yellow square below a medium black square, both medium yellow squares are below a medium black square.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly describes the vertical relationship between the yellow and black squares in Block A, leading to an incorrect final deduction about which yellow square is below a black square.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block A contains a medium yellow square above medium black square number two.
Explanation
The context states that medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square in Block A, meaning the yellow square is above the black square, but the reasoning chain reverses this relationship for Block A.
Answer Span:
Block A contains a medium yellow square above medium black square number two.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square.
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block B contains a medium yellow square above a medium black square.
Explanation
The context states that in Block B, the medium black square is below the medium yellow square, meaning the yellow square is above the black square. The reasoning chain states the yellow square is above the black square, which is consistent with the context. However, the final conclusion relies on both yellow squares being below a black square, which contradicts the established vertical order in Block B.
Answer Span:
Block B contains a medium yellow square above a medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
It also contains one medium black square. This object is below the medium yellow square.
Question #782
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is to the right of A. Block A has a big black circle. It also contains a small yellow triangle. The small yellow ...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is to the right of A. Block A has a big black circle. It also contains a small yellow triangle. The small yellow triangle is above and to the left of the big black circle. Block B has two big yellow triangles. It also contains a medium yellow circle. This block also has a big yellow circle. Big yellow triangle number one is touching the right edge of this block. Below a small black square there is big yellow triangle number two.. The medium yellow circle is to the right of and below the small black square. Far from and above the big yellow circle is big yellow triangle number one. It is to the right of big yellow triangle number two. And block C contains a medium blue triangle and a medium black circle. Below and to the left of the medium black circle there is the medium blue triangle. What is to the left of the thing which is touching the right edge of a block? a small yellow triangle or a big black circle?
(a) small yellow triangle
(b) big black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has a small yellow triangle and a big black circle. Block B has two big yellow triangles, a medium yellow circle, a big yellow circle, and a small black square. Big yellow triangle number one is touching the right edge of Block B. Block C has a medium blue triangle and a medium black circle. The question asks what is to the left of the object touching the right edge of a block. The object touching the right edge is big yellow triangle number one in Block B. To the left of big yellow triangle number one is big yellow triangle number two. Neither the small yellow triangle (in Block A) nor the big black circle (in Block A) are in Block B, so they are not to the left of big yellow triangle number one.
Answer: {D}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the object touching the right edge of a block (Big yellow triangle number one in Block B) and correctly deduces that the objects in question (small yellow triangle and big black circle) are in Block A, not Block B. However, it incorrectly lists the contents of Block B by including a 'small black square' as an item *in* Block B, which is not explicitly stated in the context.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block B has two big yellow triangles, a medium yellow circle, a big yellow circle, and a small black square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly lists the contents of Block B by including a 'small black square'. The context states Block B has 'two big yellow triangles. It also contains a medium yellow circle. This block also has a big yellow circle.' The small black square is mentioned in relation to Block B ('Below a small black square there is big yellow triangle number two'), but it is not stated to be *in* Block B.
Answer Span:
Block B has two big yellow triangles, a medium yellow circle, a big yellow circle, and a small black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has two big yellow triangles. It also contains a medium yellow circle. This block also has a big yellow circle.
Question #1601
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There are one small black square, one small black circle and one big black square in block A. The small black square is below and near to the small black circle. Th...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There are one small black square, one small black circle and one big black square in block A. The small black square is below and near to the small black circle. This object is to the left of the big black square. Below block A we have block B with one big blue circle, one small blue circle and a medium blue triangle in it. The big blue circle is above the medium blue triangle which is near to a big yellow triangle. The small blue circle is above the big yellow triangle. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Near to and to the left of the medium blue triangle there is the small blue circle. To the left of block A there is block C. It contains one small yellow circle and a big black square. To the right of the big black square there is the small yellow circle. What is below the small black circle? a small black square or a big yellow triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) small black square
(b) big yellow triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains a small black circle above a small black square. Block B, below Block A, contains a big yellow triangle touching the bottom edge. Since the small black circle is in Block A and the big yellow triangle is in Block B (directly below A), the object below the small black circle is the small black square.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly reverses the vertical relationship between the small black circle and the small black square in Block A, leading to a flawed intermediate step, although the final conclusion based on the flawed step happens to align with one of the options.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block A contains a small black circle above a small black square.
Explanation
The context states the small black square is *below* and near to the small black circle, not above it.
Answer Span:
Block A contains a small black circle above a small black square.
Reference/Question Span:
The small black square is below and near to the small black circle.
Question #3127
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is below B. Block C is to the right of A. Block A has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the right edge of this block. M...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is below B. Block C is to the right of A. Block A has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the right edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. Above medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. Block B has one big black square and a big black circle. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. This block also has a small black circle. The big black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big black square is to the right of the big black circle and the small black circle. And block C has one big black triangle. There is also a small yellow circle in this block. Near to and to the left of the big black triangle is the small yellow circle. The big black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the small yellow circle or the small black circle?
(a) the small yellow circle
(b) the small black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains two medium yellow squares. Block B, which is above Block A, contains a small black circle. Block C contains a small yellow circle. Since Block B is directly above Block A, the object above the medium yellow squares is the small black circle in Block B. The small yellow circle is in Block C, which is to the right of Block A, not above it.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the contents of the blocks but makes an unsupported assumption about the vertical relationship between B and A ('directly above') which isn't explicitly stated, although B being above A is true. Crucially, the reasoning fails to establish *which* medium yellow square is being referenced (there are two) and doesn't check if anything is *above* them based on the positional data provided (e.g., C is to the right of A, not above it).
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block B, which is above Block A
Explanation
The context states 'Block A is below B', which means B is above A, but the reasoning chain implies a direct vertical stacking relationship that isn't fully established for all blocks, and more importantly, it incorrectly assumes B is *directly* above A based only on the relative position given.
Answer Span:
Block B, which is above Block A
Reference/Question Span:
Block A is below B
Question #463
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Blocks B and A are below C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium bl...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Blocks B and A are below C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square. A medium blue square is also in this block. It is below medium black square number two. Below the medium blue square , the medium yellow square and medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. Block B has one medium blue square and one medium yellow square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It also contains one medium black square. This object is below the medium yellow square. Below the medium black square and the medium yellow square is the medium blue square. Block C contains one medium black square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is in block B or the medium black square which is in block C?
(a) the medium black square that is in block B
(b) the medium black square which is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block B has a medium yellow square with a medium black square below it. Block C has a medium black square. Since Blocks A and B are below C, the medium black square in Block C is above the medium yellow square in Block B. Therefore, the medium black square in Block B is below the medium yellow square, but the medium black square in block C is not.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relationship between the yellow square and the black square in Block B based on the context, and correctly concludes that the black square in Block C is not below a yellow square (as Block C only contains one black square and no yellow square is mentioned for C). The reasoning chain is sound based on the provided facts.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #730
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. One medium yellow triangle, one medium blue triangle and one small blue square are in block A. Below a small black triangle is the medium yellow triang...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. One medium yellow triangle, one medium blue triangle and one small blue square are in block A. Below a small black triangle is the medium yellow triangle. Below the small black triangle is a big yellow square. This object is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of the medium blue triangle which is near to the small blue square is the medium yellow triangle. Above and to the right of the small black triangle is the small blue square. Then, we have block B. It has a small yellow square and a medium yellow square. A medium blue circle is to the right of the medium yellow square and the small yellow square. Below the medium yellow square there is the small yellow square. Below both blocks A and B there is block C which contains one small black circle. Which object is above a small black circle? the small blue square or the big yellow object that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small blue square
(b) the big yellow object that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains a big yellow square touching the bottom edge. Block C, which is below both Block A and Block B, contains a small black circle. Since Block C is *below* Block A, the big yellow square (in Block A) is above the small black circle (in Block C). The small blue square is also in Block A, but it's above the small black triangle and the big yellow square. Therefore, only the big yellow square is directly above the small black circle.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes incorrect assumptions about the location of the big yellow square relative to Block A, leading to a flawed intermediate step regarding its position above the object in Block C.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block A contains a big yellow square touching the bottom edge.
Explanation
The context states the big yellow square is *below* the small black triangle, and *this object* (the big yellow square) is touching the bottom edge of *this block* (Block A). The reasoning chain incorrectly implies the big yellow square is *in* Block A, when the context implies it is below Block A, or at least positioned relative to objects in A.
Answer Span:
Block A contains a big yellow square touching the bottom edge.
Reference/Question Span:
Below the small black triangle is a big yellow square. This object is touching the bottom edge of this block.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block C is *below* Block A, the big yellow square (in Block A) is above the small black circle (in Block C).
Explanation
The reasoning assumes the big yellow square is in Block A, but the context only states it is below the small black triangle, and *that object* (the big yellow square) is touching the bottom edge of *this block* (Block A). Crucially, the reasoning chain fails to establish the location of the big yellow square relative to Block A or Block C, only that Block C is below A and B. The context implies the big yellow square is *below* Block A, not *in* it, which is critical for determining if it is above the object in C.
Answer Span:
Since Block C is *below* Block A, the big yellow square (in Block A) is above the small black circle (in Block C).
Reference/Question Span:
Below both blocks A and B there is block C which contains one small black circle.
Question #2973
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square and one medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium ...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square and one medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square. Block B is to the left of block A. It has a medium black square. Below block B there is block C with two medium black squares and two other medium yellow squares in it. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two is medium black square number two. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. It is below medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two and medium yellow square number one is medium black square number one. Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block A?
(a) the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium black square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block B has a medium black square, and Block A (to the right of Block B) has a medium black square and a medium blue square. Block C, below Block B, has two medium black squares and two medium yellow squares. The question asks what is to the right of *a* medium black square (specifically, the one in Block B). The medium black square in Block A is to the right of the one in Block B. The medium black square touching the bottom edge of a block (medium black square number one in Block C) is below the medium black square in Block B, not to its right.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain misinterprets the question by assuming it only asks what is to the right of the black square in Block B, ignoring the two specific candidates provided in the question for the reference object.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The question asks what is to the right of *a* medium black square (specifically, the one in Block B).
Explanation
The question asks which object is to the right of *either* 'the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block' OR 'the medium black square that is in block A'. The reasoning incorrectly narrows the scope to only considering what is to the right of the black square in Block B.
Answer Span:
The question asks what is to the right of *a* medium black square (specifically, the one in Block B).
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block A?
Question #2206
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is below A. Block C is to the right of B. Block A has one medium black square and one medium yellow square. The medium black square is below th...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is below A. Block C is to the right of B. Block A has one medium black square and one medium yellow square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Block B contains two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below a medium yellow square. A medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium blue square number two there is the medium yellow square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square , medium blue square number one and medium blue square number two. And block C contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block B or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block B
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium yellow square. Block B, which is below Block A, also contains a medium yellow square. Block C contains two medium yellow squares, one of which is touching the bottom edge. Since Block A is to the left of Block B, the medium yellow square in Block A is to the left of the medium yellow square in Block B. Block C is to the right of Block B, so the medium yellow squares in Block C are not to the left of the medium yellow square in Block B.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsupported assumption about the relative horizontal positioning of Block A and Block B, leading to a potentially incorrect conclusion based on flawed premises derived from missing context.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block A is to the left of Block B, the medium yellow square in Block A is to the left of the medium yellow square in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes a spatial relationship between Block A and Block B (A is to the left of B) which is not established in the context. The context only states 'Block B is below A' and 'Block C is to the right of B'. The relative left/right position of A and B is missing context.
Answer Span:
Since Block A is to the left of Block B, the medium yellow square in Block A is to the left of the medium yellow square in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is below A. Block C is to the right of B.
Question #565
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One big black circle is in block A. Below block A there is block B with a big blue triangle, a big black triangle and one big blue square in it. Above and to the ri...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One big black circle is in block A. Below block A there is block B with a big blue triangle, a big black triangle and one big blue square in it. Above and to the right of a medium black triangle there is the big blue triangle. The big black triangle is above the medium black triangle. It is to the left of and below the big blue square. Above block A there is block C with one small yellow square and a small black square in it. A big blue square is below the small yellow square. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. A big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and near to the small black square is the big blue square. The small black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and below the small yellow square is the big blue triangle. What is below the circle? a big blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a medium black triangle?
(a) big blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium black triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A has a big black circle. Block B, below Block A, has a big blue triangle, a big black triangle, and a big blue square. The big black triangle is below the big blue square and above a medium black triangle (not mentioned as being in any block, but implied to be in B). Block C, above Block A, has a small yellow square and a small black square. We're interested in what's below the circle in Block A. That's Block B, containing the big black triangle, big blue triangle and big blue square, and the implied medium black triangle. Of the options provided, the medium black triangle is below the big black circle.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the contents of Blocks A, B, and C based on the text. However, it introduces an unsupported assumption that the medium black triangle is in Block B, which leads to an incorrect final conclusion based on the provided options, as the context does not confirm the medium black triangle is below Block A (where the circle is).
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The big black triangle is below the big blue square and above a medium black triangle (not mentioned as being in any block, but implied to be in B).
Explanation
The reasoning chain makes an unsupported assumption about the location of the medium black triangle. The context only states the relative positions of the shapes, not that the medium black triangle is in Block B, or even in any block.
Answer Span:
The big black triangle is below the big blue square and above a medium black triangle (not mentioned as being in any block, but implied to be in B).
Reference/Question Span:
Below block A there is block B with a big blue triangle, a big black triangle and one big blue square in it.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Of the options provided, the medium black triangle is below the big black circle.
Explanation
The question asks what is below the circle (which is in Block A). The context states Block B is below Block A. The reasoning chain concludes the medium black triangle is below the circle, but the context only places the medium black triangle relative to other shapes, not explicitly stating it is in Block B or directly below the circle/Block A.
Answer Span:
Of the options provided, the medium black triangle is below the big black circle.
Reference/Question Span:
What is below the circle? a big blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a medium black triangle?
Question #1602
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There are one small black square, one small black circle and one big black square in block A. The small black square is below and near to the small black circle. Th...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There are one small black square, one small black circle and one big black square in block A. The small black square is below and near to the small black circle. This object is to the left of the big black square. Below block A we have block B with one big blue circle, one small blue circle and a medium blue triangle in it. The big blue circle is above the medium blue triangle which is near to a big yellow triangle. The small blue circle is above the big yellow triangle. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Near to and to the left of the medium blue triangle there is the small blue circle. To the left of block A there is block C. It contains one small yellow circle and a big black square. To the right of the big black square there is the small yellow circle. Which object is below a big black square? the small black square or the big shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small black square
(b) the big shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a big black square, a small black square (below the small black circle), and a small black circle. Block B (below Block A) contains a big yellow triangle touching the bottom edge. Since Block B is directly below Block A, the object below the big black square in Block A is the big yellow triangle in Block B. The small black square is below the small black circle, not the big black square.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsupported assumption about the vertical alignment of objects between Block A and Block B, leading to an incorrect intermediate conclusion about what is below the big black square in A. It also fails to fully account for all objects in Block A and ignores the existence of a second big black square in Block C, which is crucial for answering the question about which object is below *a* big black square.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextlow
Statement
Block A contains a big black square, a small black square (below the small black circle), and a small black circle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain omits the third object in Block A, which is 'one big black square'. The context states Block A has 'one small black square, one small black circle and one big black square'. The reasoning lists the big black square but omits the fact that Block A also contains a big black square, which is relevant for determining what is below it.
Answer Span:
Block A contains a big black square, a small black square (below the small black circle), and a small black circle.
Reference/Question Span:
There are one small black square, one small black circle and one big black square in block A.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B is directly below Block A, the object below the big black square in Block A is the big yellow triangle in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes that because Block B is below Block A, the object directly below the big black square in A must be the big yellow triangle in B. This ignores the fact that Block C is to the left of A, and Block B is below A, but it doesn't specify the exact horizontal alignment of the big black square in A relative to the objects in B. More importantly, it ignores the contents of Block C, which is adjacent to A, and the question asks which object is below *a* big black square (there is one in A and one in C). The reasoning only considers the big black square in A and ignores the possibility of the big black square in C being relevant, or the spatial relationship between the objects in A and B.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is directly below Block A, the object below the big black square in Block A is the big yellow triangle in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Below block A we have block B with one big blue circle, one small blue circle and a medium blue triangle in it. . . To the left of block A there is block C. It contains one small yellow circle and a big black square.
Question #2095
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and a medium black square. This shape ...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and a medium black square. This shape is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black square is below medium blue square number two. Above block A there is block B which has three medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium yellow square number three. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number three and medium yellow square number two. To the right of block B there is block C. It has two medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Which object is above a medium blue square? medium yellow square number two or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium yellow square number two
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains two medium blue squares and a medium black square. Block B, which is above Block A, has three medium yellow squares with medium yellow square number one touching the bottom edge. Since Block B is directly above Block A, which contains the medium blue squares, the objects directly above the medium blue squares are the medium yellow squares in Block B, including medium yellow square number one (touching the bottom edge). Medium yellow square number two is also in Block B, so it's also above the medium blue squares.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the blocks (B above A, C to the right of B) and attempts to answer the question about what is above a medium blue square. However, it incorrectly asserts that Block A contains the medium black square, which is only described as being below one of the blue squares and touching the bottom edge of the block.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block A contains two medium blue squares and a medium black square.
Explanation
The context states Block A contains two medium blue squares AND a medium black square, but it does not explicitly state that the black square is *in* Block A, only that it is below medium blue square number two and touching the bottom edge of the block.
Answer Span:
Block A contains two medium blue squares and a medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and a medium black square. This shape is touching the bottom edge of this block.
Question #2514
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of C and block C is below A. Block A has one big yellow triangle and one small yellow square. The big yellow triangle is far fro...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of C and block C is below A. Block A has one big yellow triangle and one small yellow square. The big yellow triangle is far from and to the right of a big blue triangle which is to the right of and above the small yellow square. Block B has two big blue squares. This block also contains one big blue circle. This block also has a small yellow triangle. It also has one small black circle. Big blue square number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big blue circle is to the right of big blue square number two and big blue square number one. And block C has two big black squares. Big black square number one is touching the right edge of this block. This object is to the right of a big yellow triangle and big black square number two. Which object is to the right of a small yellow triangle? the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the small black circle?
(a) the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the small black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
3
Generated Answer
Block B contains the small yellow triangle, a small black circle, and two big blue squares (one of which is touching the bottom edge). The big blue circle is to the right of the two big blue squares. Thus, both the small black circle and the big blue square touching the bottom edge are to the right of the small yellow triangle.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly asserts a spatial relationship (to the right of) between the small yellow triangle and the shape touching the bottom edge of Block B, which is not supported by the provided context. The context only places both items within Block B.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Thus, both the small black circle and the big blue square touching the bottom edge are to the right of the small yellow triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain concludes that the big blue square touching the bottom edge is to the right of the small yellow triangle. However, the context only states the location of the small yellow triangle (in Block B) and the location of the big blue square touching the bottom edge (Big blue square number two is touching the bottom edge of this block [Block B]). It never establishes a relative position (left/right) between the small yellow triangle and the big blue square touching the bottom edge.
Answer Span:
the big blue square touching the bottom edge are to the right of the small yellow triangle
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a small yellow triangle? the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the small black circle?
Question #775
We have three blocks, A, B and C. There are a big yellow square, a big blue circle and one medium black circle in block A. The big yellow square is near to a small yellow square. Near to the medium bl...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. There are a big yellow square, a big blue circle and one medium black circle in block A. The big yellow square is near to a small yellow square. Near to the medium black circle there is the big blue circle. The small yellow square is above the medium black circle. The medium black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the medium black circle is the big yellow square.. The big blue circle is to the left of the small yellow square. Above block A we have block B which contains one medium yellow triangle. Below block A there is block C with a small blue square and one big blue triangle in it. One big blue circle is also in this block. To the right of and below the big blue triangle there is the small blue square. It is near to the big blue circle. Which object is below a medium yellow triangle? the small yellow square or the black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small yellow square
(b) the black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains the small yellow square and the medium black circle touching the bottom edge. Block B, which is above Block A, contains a medium yellow triangle. Therefore, the objects below the medium yellow triangle are the small yellow square and the medium black circle.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly places the small yellow square in Block A, which contradicts the context that only lists the big yellow square, big blue circle, and medium black circle as being in Block A. This error affects the subsequent conclusion about what is below the medium yellow triangle.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block A contains the small yellow square and the medium black circle touching the bottom edge.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly states that the small yellow square is in Block A. The context states that Block A contains 'a big yellow square, a big blue circle and one medium black circle'. The small yellow square is only mentioned in relation to the medium black circle's position, not its location within a specific block.
Answer Span:
Block A contains the small yellow square and the medium black circle touching the bottom edge.
Reference/Question Span:
There are a big yellow square, a big blue circle and one medium black circle in block A.
Question #2844
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square. To the left of block A is block B which contains a medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also contains a medium...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square. To the left of block A is block B which contains a medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also contains a medium yellow square. It is below the medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square. To the right of block A there is block C. It has two medium yellow squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. It is below the medium blue square. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square and the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square. Which object is above a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block C or the medium blue square which is in block B?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block C
(b) the medium blue square which is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium blue square. Block B (to the left of A) has a medium black square below a medium blue square and a medium yellow square. Block C (to the right of A) has a medium black square below a medium blue square and two medium yellow squares. The question asks what is above a medium black square. In Block B, the medium blue square and the medium yellow square are above the medium black square. In Block C, the medium blue square is above the medium black square. The question specifically asks about the medium blue squares. Since the medium blue square in Block C is above a medium black square, and the medium blue square in Block B is also above a medium black square, both are correct.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the squares in Block B and Block C based on the context and accurately concludes that both specified blue squares are above a black square.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1657
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains one medium yellow square. A medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square. Then, t...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains one medium yellow square. A medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square. Then, there is block B. It has one medium black square. Finally, we have block C. It is to the left of block A and to the right of block B. It contains two medium blue squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. This block also has a medium black square. This shape is below the medium yellow square and medium blue square number two.. Below the medium yellow square there is medium blue square number one. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium blue square number two which is below the medium yellow square. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block C?
(a) the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium black square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium yellow square and a medium black square touching the bottom edge. Block B has a medium black square. Block C has two medium blue squares, a medium yellow square, and a medium black square. The medium black square in Block A is below the medium yellow square and touching the bottom edge. The medium black square in Block C is below the medium yellow square and medium blue square number two. Block C is to the left of Block A. Therefore, the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block A is to the right of the medium yellow square (and all other shapes) in Block C.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an incorrect assumption about the contents of Block A and fails to correctly evaluate the spatial relationship required by the question, leading to an unsupported conclusion about the relative positions.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block A has a medium yellow square and a medium black square touching the bottom edge.
Explanation
The context states Block A contains one medium yellow square, and a medium black square is touching the bottom edge *of this block* (Block A), but it does not state the black square is *in* Block A, only that it is touching the bottom edge of Block A.
Answer Span:
Block A has a medium yellow square and a medium black square touching the bottom edge.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains one medium yellow square. A medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Therefore, the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block A is to the right of the medium yellow square (and all other shapes) in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning concludes that the black square touching the bottom edge of Block A is to the right of shapes in Block C. However, the question asks which object is to the right of *a* medium yellow square, implying we need to check the relative positions of the two candidate objects (the black square touching the bottom edge, and the black square in C) relative to *any* medium yellow square. The reasoning incorrectly assumes the relative position based only on the left/right placement of Block C relative to Block A, ignoring the specific spatial relationships required by the question.
Answer Span:
Therefore, the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block A is to the right of the medium yellow square (and all other shapes) in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block C?
Question #2578
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A contains a small black square, one big blue circle and one medium black square. The small black square is above and near to the medium black square ...
2 issues
Full Question
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A contains a small black square, one big blue circle and one medium black square. The small black square is above and near to the medium black square which is above, to the left of and near to a medium yellow square. The big blue circle is to the left of the medium yellow square. To the left of block A is block B. It has two small black circles. A big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a small yellow square. It also has one small black triangle and a medium blue circle. To the left of the medium blue circle is the small black triangle. Below the small yellow square there is the big yellow triangle. To the left of and below the small yellow square there is the small black triangle.. The medium blue circle is above small black circle number two. What is to the right of the small yellow square? a big blue circle or a thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) big blue circle
(b) thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains a big blue circle and a medium yellow square. Block B contains a small yellow square. Since Block B is to the left of Block A, the objects in Block A (big blue circle and medium yellow square) are to the right of the small yellow square in Block B. The big yellow triangle touching the bottom edge of Block B is not to the right of the small yellow square, but below it.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain suffers from significant missing context by omitting most of the objects listed in both Block A and Block B, leading to an incomplete basis for determining the spatial relationship required by the question.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block A contains a big blue circle and a medium yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain omits several other objects explicitly stated to be in Block A: a small black square and one medium black square.
Answer Span:
Block A contains a big blue circle and a medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains a small black square, one big blue circle and one medium black square.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block B contains a small yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain only mentions the small yellow square in Block B, ignoring the other four objects explicitly stated to be in Block B: two small black circles, a big yellow triangle, one small black triangle, and a medium blue circle.
Answer Span:
Block B contains a small yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
It has two small black circles. A big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a small yellow square. It also has one small black triangle and a medium blue circle.
Question #3576
We have three blocks, A, B and C. There are three medium yellow squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below m...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. There are three medium yellow squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below medium yellow square number three. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number three. Above block A is block B with a medium black square in it. To the left of block A there is block C with a medium black square, one medium blue square and a medium yellow square in it. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square is the medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square. Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is in block C?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block C contains a medium black square, a medium blue square, and a medium yellow square. Block A, to the right of Block C, contains three medium yellow squares. Since Block A is to the right of Block C, and the medium yellow squares are in Block A, they are to the right of the medium black square in Block C. Specifically, the medium yellow square in Block C is directly to the right of the medium black square at the bottom of Block C, as it is described as being above the medium black square. The question asks which object is to the right of *a* medium black square. Since the medium yellow square in block C is directly to the right of the medium black square, and the medium yellow squares are in Block A, which is to the right of the medium black square in Block C, both are valid answers.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an incorrect spatial assumption about the yellow square in Block C relative to the black square in Block C (stating it is to the right when the context implies it is above). It also fails to correctly analyze the positional relationships required to answer the question, which asks which object is to the right of *a* medium black square (implying a comparison between objects in different blocks or relative positions). The reasoning incorrectly concludes both options are valid based on flawed spatial logic.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block A is to the right of Block C, and the medium yellow squares are in Block A, they are to the right of the medium black square in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes Block A is to the right of Block C. The context states: 'To the left of block A there is block C'. This means Block A is to the right of Block C, but the reasoning chain does not explicitly use the positional information given in the context to establish this relationship, relying on an assertion that isn't directly derived from the stated facts about the relative positions of A and C.
Answer Span:
Since Block A is to the right of Block C
Reference/Question Span:
To the left of block A there is block C
contradictionhigh
Statement
Specifically, the medium yellow square in Block C is directly to the right of the medium black square at the bottom of Block C, as it is described as being above the medium black square.
Explanation
The context states the medium yellow square in Block C is *above* the medium blue square, and the medium black square is *below* the medium yellow square and the medium blue square. This means the medium yellow square is *above* the medium black square in Block C, not *to the right* of it. Furthermore, the question asks which object is to the right of *a* medium black square, implying a spatial relationship between objects, not just vertical stacking within the same block.
Answer Span:
the medium yellow square in Block C is directly to the right of the medium black square at the bottom of Block C
Reference/Question Span:
Below the medium yellow square is the medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square.
Question #2099
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block C and below block A. Block A contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below a medium blue square and med...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block C and below block A. Block A contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below a medium blue square and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square. Block B has two medium blue squares. This block also contains a medium black square. Below the medium black square there is medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the square which is below the medium black square. This shape is below the medium black square. And block C has one medium black square. It also has one medium yellow square. Below the medium black square is the medium yellow square. Which object is above a medium blue square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue square that is in block A?
(a) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block B contains two medium blue squares and a medium black square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block, and medium blue square number two is above it, below the medium black square. Block A contains a medium blue square, which is above medium yellow square number two. The question asks which object is above *a* medium blue square, meaning any medium blue square. Medium blue square number two is above medium blue square number one (the one touching the bottom edge of Block B). The medium blue square in Block A is above medium yellow squares. Since medium blue square number two is above another medium blue square, and the medium blue square in Block A is above a medium yellow square, the answer is the medium blue square that is in Block A.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains factual contradictions regarding the relative positions of the blue squares in Block B and ignores the actual question being asked, which is 'Which object is above a medium blue square?' The reasoning incorrectly concludes based on flawed premises about what is above what.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block, and medium blue square number two is above it, below the medium black square.
Explanation
The context states that medium blue square number one is below the square which is below the medium black square, and that medium blue square number two is *not* mentioned in relation to medium blue square number one's position relative to the medium black square. The context explicitly states: 'Below the medium black square there is medium blue square number two.' and 'Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the square which is below the medium black square.' The reasoning incorrectly asserts that medium blue square number two is above medium blue square number one and below the medium black square, which is not explicitly stated in this sequence.
Answer Span:
Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block, and medium blue square number two is above it, below the medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Below the medium black square there is medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the square which is below the medium black square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block A contains a medium blue square, which is above medium yellow squares.
Explanation
The reasoning claims the medium blue square in Block A is above medium yellow squares. The context states Block A contains two medium yellow squares, and that 'Medium yellow square number one is below a medium blue square and medium yellow square number two.' This implies the medium blue square is above medium yellow square number one, but the reasoning generalizes this relationship without specifying which yellow square(s) it is above, and more importantly, it fails to address the core question: what is *above* the medium blue square in Block A, or what is *above* the medium blue square touching the bottom edge of Block B.
Answer Span:
The medium blue square in Block A is above medium yellow squares.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below a medium blue square and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square.
Question #2974
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square and one medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium ...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square and one medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square. Block B is to the left of block A. It has a medium black square. Below block B there is block C with two medium black squares and two other medium yellow squares in it. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two is medium black square number two. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. It is below medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two and medium yellow square number one is medium black square number one. Which object is below a medium black square? the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block A?
(a) the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium black square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium black square and a medium blue square below it. Block B, to the left of A, also has a medium black square. Block C, below B, has two medium black squares and two medium yellow squares. Medium black square number one in Block C is touching the bottom edge. The medium blue square in Block A is below the medium black square in Block A. The medium black square number one in Block C is below the medium black square in Block B. Only the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block C is directly below another medium black square (the one in Block B). The medium black square in Block A has a medium blue square below it, not another medium black square.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes a significant factual error by claiming a square in Block C is below a square in Block B, which is not supported by the context. This error leads to an incorrect intermediate conclusion about which black square is below another black square.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The medium black square number one in Block C is below the medium black square in Block B.
Explanation
The context states Block B is to the left of Block A, and Block C is below Block B. It does not state that any square in C is below a square in B. The context only describes the internal arrangement of squares within Block C.
Answer Span:
The medium black square number one in Block C is below the medium black square in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the left of block A. It has a medium black square. Below block B there is block C with two medium black squares and two other medium yellow squares in it.
Question #969
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is above block C and it is to the left of block A. Block A contains two small yellow circles. There is also one big black circle in this block. Small yellow c...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is above block C and it is to the left of block A. Block A contains two small yellow circles. There is also one big black circle in this block. Small yellow circle number one is above the big black circle and small yellow circle number two. Block B has two big yellow circles. It also contains one medium yellow triangle. Below big yellow circle number two is big yellow circle number one. It is to the left of and near to the medium yellow triangle. Block C contains a small black square, a big yellow triangle and a small yellow circle. A medium blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a big black square. Above the big black square and the small yellow circle there is the small black square. To the right of and touching the big black square is the medium blue triangle. This object is below the big yellow triangle. Which object is below a big yellow circle? the small black square or the big black circle?
(a) the small black square
(b) the big black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains a big black circle and two small yellow circles, and Block B (above Block C) contains two big yellow circles. Since Block A is to the right of Block B, the objects below the big yellow circles are the small yellow circles and the big black circle in Block A. Block C contains the small black square.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsupported leap by assuming objects below the big yellow circles (in Block B) are located in Block A, and it incorrectly infers a positional relationship ('A is to the right of B') which is not explicitly stated.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block A is to the right of Block B, the objects below the big yellow circles are the small yellow circles and the big black circle in Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly assumes the objects below the big yellow circles (which are in Block B) are located in Block A. The context only states where the objects are located within their respective blocks, not that objects in Block B are above objects in Block A.
Answer Span:
the objects below the big yellow circles are the small yellow circles and the big black circle in Block A
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has two big yellow circles.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block A is to the right of Block B, the objects below the big yellow circles are the small yellow circles and the big black circle in Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning uses the positional relationship 'Block A is to the right of Block B' to infer vertical relationships ('objects below'), which is not supported by the context. The context only states B is above C and B is to the left of A. It does not state A is to the right of B, nor does it establish a vertical relationship between objects in A and objects in B.
Answer Span:
Since Block A is to the right of Block B
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is above block C and it is to the left of block A.
Question #1254
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains a big black circle and one small blue circle. The big black circle is below a medium black triangle. Below the medium black triangle t...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains a big black circle and one small blue circle. The big black circle is below a medium black triangle. Below the medium black triangle there is the small blue circle. The big black circle is above and near to the small blue circle. Then, there is block B with one medium yellow circle, a big black square and one small blue square in it. A medium black circle is to the right of the medium yellow circle and the small blue square. Above the big black square and the small blue square is the medium yellow circle. The medium black circle is above the big black square. To the right of block A and to the left of block B there is block C. It has one medium blue circle and a small blue circle. The medium blue circle is near to and to the left of a medium black square which is to the right of and below the small blue circle. Which object is to the right of a big black circle? the medium blue circle or the small blue square?
(a) the medium blue circle
(b) the small blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains the big black circle. Block B, to the right of Block A, contains the small blue square. Block C, which is also to the right of Block A (and to the left of Block B), contains the medium blue circle. Since both Block B and C are to the right of Block A, both the small blue square (in B) and the medium blue circle (in C) are to the right of the big black circle in Block A.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in blocks B and C relative to block A, but it fails to use the specific positional information given in the context to determine which object is *immediately* to the right of the big black circle, which is the core of the question. However, based strictly on the hallucination definitions (contradiction or missing crucial context that *changes* the reasoning path), no explicit hallucination is present, as the reasoning chain establishes that both objects are generally to the right of the block containing the target object.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1453
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There is one medium yellow square in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium blue squares. It also contains a medium yellow square. M...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There is one medium yellow square in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium blue squares. It also contains a medium yellow square. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and the medium yellow square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square is medium blue square number two. Above block A there is block C which contains two medium yellow squares. This block also contains one medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium black square and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium black square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium black square or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium black square
(b) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium yellow square. Block B, below A, contains two medium blue squares and a medium yellow square. Medium blue square number one is at the bottom. Block C, above A, contains two medium yellow squares and a medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is at the bottom. The question asks what is below *a* medium yellow square. There are three medium yellow squares. The one in Block A has medium blue squares below it (in Block B). The two medium yellow squares in Block C have nothing below them since Block C is the top block. Therefore, only the medium blue square touching the bottom edge of a block (medium blue square number one) is below a medium yellow square (the one in Block A).
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes a critical error by assuming that objects in the top block (C) have nothing below them, ignoring the vertical stacking structure (C above A above B). This leads to an incomplete evaluation of which objects are below *a* medium yellow square.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The two medium yellow squares in Block C have nothing below them since Block C is the top block.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly assumes that because Block C is the top block, the yellow squares within it have nothing below them. The context specifies relationships *within* blocks and *between* blocks. The yellow squares in Block C are above Block A, which contains objects. The reasoning ignores the structure that Block C is above A, and A is above B, meaning objects in A and B are below objects in C.
Answer Span:
The two medium yellow squares in Block C have nothing below them since Block C is the top block.
Reference/Question Span:
Below block A there is block C which contains two medium yellow squares.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Therefore, only the medium blue square touching the bottom edge of a block (medium blue square number one) is below a medium yellow square (the one in Block A).
Explanation
This conclusion is based on the faulty premise that the yellow squares in Block C have nothing below them. The reasoning fails to check if the yellow squares in Block C have anything below them (like Block A's contents, or Block B's contents, depending on the interpretation of 'below'). Crucially, it ignores the possibility that the yellow squares in Block C might have the medium black square below them (which is false based on the text, but the reasoning doesn't check the relationship between the yellow squares and the black square in C, nor does it check if the yellow squares in C are above the objects in A). The reasoning only checks the yellow square in A.
Answer Span:
Therefore, only the medium blue square touching the bottom edge of a block (medium blue square number one) is below a medium yellow square (the one in Block A).
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium black square or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #1454
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There is one medium yellow square in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium blue squares. It also contains a medium yellow square. M...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There is one medium yellow square in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium blue squares. It also contains a medium yellow square. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and the medium yellow square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square is medium blue square number two. Above block A there is block C which contains two medium yellow squares. This block also contains one medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium black square and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium black square. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square?
(a) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium black square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium yellow square. Block B, below A, contains two medium blue squares and a medium yellow square. Block C, above A, contains two medium yellow squares and a medium black square. The question asks what is above "a medium yellow square". There are three medium yellow squares: one in Block A, and two in Block C. Block C is above Block A which contains a medium yellow square, and Block C also contains the medium black square. Therefore, the medium black square is above a medium yellow square (specifically, the one in Block A and the one touching the bottom edge of Block C). Additionally, the medium yellow square in Block B is below the medium yellow square in Block A. The bottom most medium blue square (number one) in block B is also below the medium yellow square in Block B, so it is also below the medium yellow square in block A. Thus, the medium black square is above a medium yellow square.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains significant factual errors regarding the count and relative vertical positions of the medium yellow squares, leading to an incomplete and flawed analysis of the question's constraints.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
There are three medium yellow squares: one in Block A, and two in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly counts the total number of medium yellow squares by omitting the one in Block B. The context states Block A has one, Block B has one, and Block C has two, totaling four.
Answer Span:
There are three medium yellow squares: one in Block A, and two in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
There is one medium yellow square in block A. . . Block B. . . It also contains a medium yellow square. . . Block C which contains two medium yellow squares.
contradictionhigh
Statement
Additionally, the medium yellow square in Block B is below the medium yellow square in Block A.
Explanation
The context states Block B is below Block A, meaning any object in B is below any object in A. This statement reverses the vertical relationship between the yellow squares in A and B.
Answer Span:
Additionally, the medium yellow square in Block B is below the medium yellow square in Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
There is one medium yellow square in block A. . . Block B is below block A.
Question #806
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and above block C. Block A contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below medium black sq...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and above block C. Block A contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. There is also a medium blue square in this block. It is below medium black square number two. Below the blue shape which is below medium black square number two is medium black square number one. Block B has a medium black square and a medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium blue square. It also contains one medium yellow square.. Below the medium blue square and the medium black square is the medium yellow square. And block C contains one medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium blue square? the thing which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block B?
(a) the thing which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium black square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium blue square and two medium black squares, with medium black square number one touching the bottom edge. Block B, which is to the left of Block A, contains a medium black square and a medium blue square, with the medium black square below the medium blue square. Block C is below Block B. Since Block B is to the left of Block A, which contains a medium blue square, the medium black square in Block B is to the left of the medium blue square in Block A. Additionally, since the medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of Block A, and Block B (which contains the medium black square) is to the left of Block A, the medium black square in Block B is also to the left of the object touching the bottom edge of Block A (medium black square number one).
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the objects in Block A and Block B, but it incorrectly states the positional relationship between Block B and Block C, although this error does not directly impact the final comparison required by the question. The final conclusion is incorrect based on the required comparison.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block C is below Block B.
Explanation
The context states Block B is above block C, not that Block C is below Block B (though this is logically equivalent, the reasoning chain incorrectly states the relationship as derived from the context, which only established B is above C). More critically, the reasoning chain incorrectly states the relative positions of B and C based on the initial setup, which only says B is above C, not B is to the left of A AND above C.
Answer Span:
Block C is below Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the left of block A and above block C.
Question #999
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and it is below block C. Block A has one small blue circle. Above and to the left of a medium black square there is t...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and it is below block C. Block A has one small blue circle. Above and to the left of a medium black square there is the small blue circle. The medium black square is touching the right edge of this block. Block B has a small yellow triangle, one big blue circle and a big black circle. The small yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. The small yellow triangle is above the big blue circle. It is below and to the right of the big black circle. And block C contains two medium yellow circles. Medium yellow circle number one is above, to the left of and near to medium yellow circle number two. This block also has a small yellow circle. What is to the left of the small blue circle? a medium yellow circle or a small yellow triangle which is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) medium yellow circle
(b) small yellow triangle which is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains the small blue circle. Block B, to the left of Block A, contains the small yellow triangle. Since Block B is directly to the left of Block A, the small yellow triangle (which is in Block B) is to the left of the small blue circle (in Block A). The medium yellow circles are in Block C, which is above Block B, so they are not directly to the left of the small blue circle.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes unsupported assumptions about direct adjacency ('directly to the left') and completely ignores the explicit positional relationship given for the small blue circle relative to the medium black square, which is necessary to answer the question about what is to its left.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B is directly to the left of Block A, the small yellow triangle (which is in Block B) is to the left of the small blue circle (in Block A).
Explanation
The reasoning assumes Block B is *directly* to the left of Block A, which is not stated. The context only says 'Block B is to the left of block A'. Furthermore, the question asks what is to the left of the *small blue circle*, which is located relative to a *medium black square*, not relative to Block A itself.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is directly to the left of Block A, the small yellow triangle (which is in Block B) is to the left of the small blue circle (in Block A).
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the left of block A
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The medium yellow circles are in Block C, which is above Block B, so they are not directly to the left of the small blue circle.
Explanation
The reasoning ignores the crucial positional information given for the small blue circle: 'Above and to the left of a medium black square there is the small blue circle.' The question asks what is to the left of the small blue circle, which requires knowing the relative position of the medium yellow circle (in C) to the small blue circle, not just that C is above B.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow circles are in Block C, which is above Block B, so they are not directly to the left of the small blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the left of the small blue circle?
Question #3501
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block C is above block A and to the right of block B. Block A has a big black circle. One medium yellow circle is also in this block. The medium yellow...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block C is above block A and to the right of block B. Block A has a big black circle. One medium yellow circle is also in this block. The medium yellow circle is above and to the right of the big black circle. Block B contains a big black circle. A medium yellow triangle and one small black square are also in this block. The medium yellow triangle is to the left of, above and near to the small black square. The big black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Block C contains one small yellow triangle, a medium blue triangle and one medium black triangle. Below and to the left of the medium blue triangle which is near to the medium black triangle there is the small yellow triangle. This shape is below the medium black triangle. Which object is near to a medium black triangle? the medium blue triangle or the big black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue triangle
(b) the big black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block C contains a medium black triangle and a medium blue triangle described as being near to it. The big black circle touching the bottom edge is in Block B, which is not near Block C. Therefore, only the medium blue triangle is near the medium black triangle.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects involved but makes an assumption about the proximity relationship being sufficient to answer the question without considering the spatial relationship between the blocks, which is crucial for comparing the two options presented in the question.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C contains a medium black triangle and a medium blue triangle described as being near to it.
Explanation
The reasoning claims the medium blue triangle is described as being near the medium black triangle in Block C. The context only states the medium blue triangle is near the medium black triangle, but it does not explicitly state this relationship is the basis for answering the final question about which object is *near* the medium black triangle, which is the core of the question. More importantly, the reasoning uses this proximity to eliminate the other option, but the context only establishes the relationship between the two triangles within Block C, not their proximity relative to the block containing the big black circle.
Answer Span:
Block C contains a medium black triangle and a medium blue triangle described as being near to it.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C contains one small yellow triangle, a medium blue triangle and one medium black triangle. Below and to the left of the medium blue triangle which is near to the medium black triangle there is the small yellow triangle.
Question #2843
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square. To the left of block A is block B which contains a medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also contains a medium...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square. To the left of block A is block B which contains a medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also contains a medium yellow square. It is below the medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square. To the right of block A there is block C. It has two medium yellow squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. It is below the medium blue square. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square and the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square. Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium yellow square that is in block B or medium yellow square number two?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block B
(b) medium yellow square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium blue square. Block B, to the left of Block A, contains a medium yellow square and a medium blue square. Block C, to the right of Block A, contains two medium yellow squares (number one and two). Since Block C is to the right of Block A (which contains a medium blue square), the objects in Block C (including medium yellow square number two) are to the right of the medium blue square in Block A. The medium yellow square in Block B is to the left, not the right, of the medium blue square in Block A.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the blocks (B left of A, C right of A) and uses this to evaluate the options relative to the blue square in A. However, it makes an unsupported assumption/misstatement about which block contains 'medium yellow square number two', although this error does not ultimately change the final selection based on the logic applied.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C, to the right of Block A, contains two medium yellow squares (number one and two).
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly assigns 'number two' to Block C. The context states Block C has two medium yellow squares, and then later defines 'Medium yellow square number one' and 'Medium yellow square number two' based on their relative positions, not explicitly stating both are in Block C.
Answer Span:
Block C, to the right of Block A, contains two medium yellow squares (number one and two)
Reference/Question Span:
It has two medium yellow squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. It is below the medium blue square. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square and the medium black square.
Question #3577
We have three blocks, A, B and C. There are three medium yellow squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below m...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. There are three medium yellow squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below medium yellow square number three. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number three. Above block A is block B with a medium black square in it. To the left of block A there is block C with a medium black square, one medium blue square and a medium yellow square in it. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square is the medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square which is in block C or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square which is in block C
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains three medium yellow squares, numbered one through three from bottom to top. Block C contains a medium yellow square, a medium blue square below it, and a medium black square below both of those. The question asks what is below *a* medium yellow square. This could refer to any of the medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number two in Block A is above medium yellow square number one. Medium yellow square number three in Block A is above medium yellow square number two. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square in Block C. Therefore, only the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block (medium yellow square number one in Block A) has nothing below it. So, the medium blue square in block C is below a medium yellow square and is below the medium yellow square which is in block C.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that the blue square in Block C is below the yellow square in Block C. However, it incorrectly reasons about the yellow squares in Block A, concluding that the lowest one (which is touching the bottom edge) has nothing below it, directly contradicting the source text which states it is below square number two.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block A contains three medium yellow squares, numbered one through three from bottom to top.
Explanation
The context states that square 1 is below square 2, and square 2 is below square 3. This implies the order from bottom to top is 1, 2, 3. The reasoning chain states this order, but then later incorrectly concludes that square 1 has nothing below it, which contradicts the established stacking order (1 is below 2, 2 is below 3). More critically, the reasoning chain later states: "Therefore, only the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block (medium yellow square number one in Block A) has nothing below it." This directly contradicts the context: "Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two."
Answer Span:
only the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block (medium yellow square number one in Block A) has nothing below it
Reference/Question Span:
Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two
contradictionhigh
Statement
Therefore, only the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block (medium yellow square number one in Block A) has nothing below it.
Explanation
This statement contradicts the context which explicitly states that medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two.
Answer Span:
only the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block (medium yellow square number one in Block A) has nothing below it
Reference/Question Span:
Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two
Question #3067
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks A and B. Block A contains one small yellow square. Block B contains a big blue triangle, one medium black circle and one medium y...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks A and B. Block A contains one small yellow square. Block B contains a big blue triangle, one medium black circle and one medium yellow square. The medium black circle is to the right of a small black square and the medium yellow square. It is touching the right edge of this block. The small black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below and to the left of the medium yellow square. And block C contains one medium yellow triangle, a medium black circle and a small yellow square. To the left of and above the small yellow square is the medium black circle. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. Below the medium black circle is the medium yellow triangle. Which object is above a medium black circle? the medium yellow triangle or the small black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow triangle
(b) the small black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block B contains a medium black circle and a small black square touching the bottom edge. The small black square is below and to the left of a medium yellow square, and the medium black circle is to the right of both of these shapes. Block C contains a medium black circle, a medium yellow triangle below it, and a small yellow square to the right of and below the medium black circle. Since Block C is below Blocks A and B, the medium black circle in Block B has the small black square below it, and not the medium yellow triangle.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain introduces objects into Block B that are not present there (small black square) and misrepresents the spatial relationships within Block C, leading to an incorrect conclusion based on faulty premises.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block B contains a medium black circle and a small black square touching the bottom edge.
Explanation
The context states Block B contains 'one big blue triangle, one medium black circle and one medium yellow square.' It does not mention a small black square in Block B.
Answer Span:
Block B contains a medium black circle and a small black square touching the bottom edge.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B contains one big blue triangle, one medium black circle and one medium yellow square.
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block C contains a medium black circle, a medium yellow triangle below it, and a small yellow square to the right of and below the medium black circle.
Explanation
The context states Block C contains 'one medium yellow triangle, a medium black circle and a small yellow square.' It specifies the relative positions: 'To the left of and above the small yellow square is the medium black circle.' and 'Below the medium black circle is the medium yellow triangle.' The reasoning incorrectly places the small yellow square relative to the medium black circle.
Answer Span:
Block C contains a medium black circle, a medium yellow triangle below it, and a small yellow square to the right of and below the medium black circle.
Reference/Question Span:
And block C contains one medium yellow triangle, a medium black circle and a small yellow square. To the left of and above the small yellow square is the medium black circle. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. Below the medium black circle is the medium yellow triangle.
Question #3096
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A contains one medium blue triangle and a small yellow square. There is also a small black circle in this block. Above an...
Clean
Full Question
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A contains one medium blue triangle and a small yellow square. There is also a small black circle in this block. Above and to the left of the small yellow square is the medium blue triangle. A medium black circle is far from, above and to the left of the small yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is to the left of and below medium yellow square number two. It also has one medium black circle. This object is below medium yellow square number two. It also contains a big blue square. Below and near to the big blue square is the medium black circle. To the left of the black object which is below the big blue square there is medium yellow square number one. Which object is below a big object? the medium black circle which is in block A or the thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium black circle which is in block A
(b) the thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium blue triangle, a small yellow square, and a small black circle. Block B contains two medium yellow squares, a medium black circle, and a big blue square. The question asks what is below a "big object." The only big object mentioned is the big blue square in Block B. The medium black circle in Block B is described as being below the big blue square. The "thing touching the bottom edge of a block" is not explicitly mentioned in relation to Block B.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in each block and focuses on the 'big object' (the big blue square) to determine what is below it, which is necessary to answer the final question.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #3420
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of B and block B is above C. Block A has one small yellow triangle, a small blue circle and a big blue circle. To the left of...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of B and block B is above C. Block A has one small yellow triangle, a small blue circle and a big blue circle. To the left of the small blue circle which is to the right of the big blue circle is the small yellow triangle. The big blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Above the big blue circle there is the small yellow triangle. Block B has a big yellow circle. And block C contains one small black square, a big yellow triangle and a big yellow circle. The big yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. This block also has a small black triangle. The small black square is to the left of and above the big yellow triangle which is to the right of the big yellow circle.. One small blue square is also in this block. It is near to and above the big yellow circle. Which object is to the left of a big blue circle? the small yellow triangle or the small blue square?
(a) the small yellow triangle
(b) the small blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
3
Generated Answer
Block A contains a big blue circle, a small yellow triangle, and a small blue circle. The small yellow triangle is to the left of the small blue circle, which is to the right of the big blue circle. Therefore, the small yellow triangle is to the left of the big blue circle. The small blue square is in Block C, which is below and to the left of Block A where the big blue circle is.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the contents of Block A but misinterprets the complex spatial relationship given for the objects within Block A, leading to an unsupported conclusion about the small yellow triangle's position relative to the big blue circle. It also includes an unnecessary and potentially flawed positional statement about Block C relative to Block A.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The small yellow triangle is to the left of the small blue circle, which is to the right of the big blue circle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly interprets the spatial relationship described in the context. The context states: 'To the left of the small blue circle which is to the right of the big blue circle is the small yellow triangle.' This means the order from left to right is: small yellow triangle, small blue circle, big blue circle (or some configuration where the small yellow triangle is left of the small blue circle, and the small blue circle is right of the big blue circle). The chain concludes the small yellow triangle is to the left of the big blue circle based on this interpretation, but the actual relationship derived from the context is that the small yellow triangle is to the left of the small blue circle, and the small blue circle is to the right of the big blue circle. The critical piece of information ignored is the relative position of the small yellow triangle *to* the big blue circle based on the complex sentence structure.
Answer Span:
The small yellow triangle is to the left of the small blue circle, which is to the right of the big blue circle. Therefore, the small yellow triangle is to the left of the big blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
To the left of the small blue circle which is to the right of the big blue circle is the small yellow triangle.
missing_contextlow
Statement
The small blue square is in Block C, which is below and to the left of Block A where the big blue circle is.
Explanation
The reasoning attempts to place the small blue square relative to Block A, but the context only establishes the relative positions of A, B, and C ('Block A is to the right of B and block B is above C'). It does not explicitly state that Block C is 'below and to the left' of Block A, which is an inference based on the A/B/C relationship that is not strictly necessary or fully supported by the provided positional facts for answering the specific question about objects relative to the big blue circle (which is in A). More importantly, the reasoning uses this placement to dismiss the small blue square, whereas the question only asks about the relative position *to* the big blue circle, which is an object within Block A.
Answer Span:
The small blue square is in Block C, which is below and to the left of Block A where the big blue circle is.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A is to the right of B and block B is above C.
Question #1335
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Blocks B and C are below A. Block A contains a medium blue square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Blocks B and C are below A. Block A contains a medium blue square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below a medium black square. Block B contains two medium blue squares. It also contains a medium black square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium black square there is medium blue square number two. Below medium blue square number two and the medium black square there is medium blue square number one. And block C has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square. Below the medium yellow square is medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is below the medium black square number two. Which object is above a medium black square? the medium black square that is in block A or the medium black square that is in block B?
(a) the medium black square that is in block A
(b) the medium black square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium blue square below a medium black square. Block B, below A, contains two medium blue squares and a medium black square. Block C, also below A, contains two medium black squares and a medium yellow square. The question asks what is above *a* medium black square. The medium blue square in Block A is below the medium black square in Block A. In Block B, the medium black square is above medium blue square number two. Therefore, the medium black square in Block A is above the medium blue square, and the medium black square in Block B is also above a medium blue square.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains factual contradictions regarding the contents and relative positions of objects in Block A, and misrepresents the contents of Block C by stating it contains a yellow square when the context only places a yellow square above one of its black squares.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block A contains a medium blue square below a medium black square.
Explanation
The context states that Block A contains a medium blue square, and this object is *below* a medium black square. The reasoning reverses this relationship.
Answer Span:
Block A contains a medium blue square below a medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains a medium blue square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below a medium black square.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C, also below A, contains two medium black squares and a medium yellow square.
Explanation
The context states Block C has two medium black squares, but it does not mention that Block C contains a medium yellow square. The medium yellow square is described as being *above* one of the black squares in C, not *contained* within C.
Answer Span:
Block C, also below A, contains two medium black squares and a medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
And block C has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square.
Question #1386
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are three medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square nu...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are three medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number two. A medium yellow square is also in this block. This object is below medium black square number three. It is below the black object which is below medium black square number three. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number one. It is below medium black square number two. Above block A there is block B which has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. To the right of block A there is block C which has one medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium blue square? medium black square number two or the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium black square number two
(b) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains three medium black squares and a medium yellow square. Medium black square number one is at the bottom, followed by number two, then number three, and finally the yellow square. Block B (above A) has two medium blue squares, and Block C (to the right of A) has one medium blue square. Since Block A is to the left of Block C, and both medium black squares number one (touching the bottom edge) and number two are in Block A, they are both to the left of the medium blue square in Block C.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains a significant hallucination regarding the vertical arrangement of objects within Block A, inventing an order not supported by the text. It also simplifies the spatial relationships by only considering Block C's blue square, potentially ignoring the blue squares in Block B, which affects the final determination of which object is to the left of *a* medium blue square.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Medium black square number one is at the bottom, followed by number two, then number three, and finally the yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly orders the objects within Block A. The context specifies the relationship between 1, 2, and 3, and the position of the yellow square relative to 3, but does not support this specific linear stacking order (1, 2, 3, Yellow). Specifically, the context states: 'Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number two.' and 'Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number one. It is below medium black square number two.' This implies 2 is below 3, and 1 is below 3 AND below 2. The chain invents a specific vertical order that is not supported.
Answer Span:
Medium black square number one is at the bottom, followed by number two, then number three, and finally the yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number two. A medium yellow square is also in this block. This object is below medium black square number three. It is below the black object which is below medium black square number three. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number one. It is below medium black square number two.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block A is to the left of Block C, and both medium black squares number one (touching the bottom edge) and number two are in Block A, they are both to the left of the medium blue square in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning correctly identifies that objects in Block A are to the left of objects in Block C, but it fails to consider the relationship between the two candidate objects (medium black square number two and the medium black square touching the bottom edge) and the medium blue square in Block C. The question asks which object is to the left of *a* medium blue square. The reasoning chain only checks the blue square in C, ignoring the blue squares in B, which are positioned above A, not to the right of A. The crucial context is that Block B is *above* A, not to the right, meaning objects in A are *below* objects in B, not necessarily to the left of them.
Answer Span:
Since Block A is to the left of Block C, and both medium black squares number one (touching the bottom edge) and number two are in Block A, they are both to the left of the medium blue square in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Above block A there is block B which has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. To the right of block A there is block C which has one medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium blue square?
Question #627
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium blue squares are in block A. There is also one medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium yellow square is below medium blue s...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium blue squares are in block A. There is also one medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium yellow square is below medium blue square number two. It is below medium blue square number one which is below medium blue square number two. Block B is below block A. It has one medium yellow square. Finally, we have block C which is above block A. It has a medium blue square and a medium black square. There is also one medium yellow square in this block. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. Below the medium black square is the medium blue square. It is below the medium yellow square. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block C
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has two medium blue squares and a medium yellow square touching the bottom edge. Block B, below A, has a medium yellow square. Block C, above A, has a medium yellow square, a medium black square, and a medium blue square. The medium yellow square in Block C is above the medium black square, which is above the medium blue square. Since Block C is above Block A, the medium yellow square in Block C is above the objects in Block A, including the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge. The other medium yellow square is in Block B, below Block A, so it is not above any medium yellow square.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the locations of the yellow squares but fails to correctly interpret the question, which asks which *object* is above *a* medium yellow square, presenting two candidate yellow squares as the potential objects. The reasoning chain incorrectly analyzes the second candidate (the yellow square in A) by concluding it is not above any yellow square, and then incorrectly concludes the yellow square in C is the answer based on its position relative to the yellow square in A, rather than analyzing if the yellow square in A is above *any* yellow square as required by option (b).
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionlow
Statement
The medium yellow square in Block C is above the medium black square, which is above the medium blue square.
Explanation
The context states the vertical relationship in Block C is: Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. Below the medium black square is the medium blue square. It is below the medium yellow square. This means the order from top to bottom is Yellow -> Black -> Blue. The reasoning states Yellow is above Black, which is above Blue, which is consistent with the first part, but then it incorrectly states the relationship between Blue and Yellow: 'It [the medium blue square] is below the medium yellow square.' The reasoning chain states the order is Y > B > Blue, which is consistent with the first two sentences, but the final sentence in the context ('It is below the medium yellow square') is redundant or confusingly phrased, but the established order is Y > Black > Blue. The reasoning chain's description of the order (Y above Black above Blue) is actually consistent with the first two sentences of the context describing Block C's internal vertical arrangement: 'Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. Below the medium black square is the medium blue square.' However, the reasoning chain then makes a leap about the final answer based on this structure that ignores the actual question.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow square in Block C is above the medium black square, which is above the medium blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. Below the medium black square is the medium blue square. It is below the medium yellow square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block C is above Block A, the medium yellow square in Block C is above the objects in Block A, including the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge.
Explanation
The question asks which object is above *a* medium yellow square: the one in C, or the one touching the bottom edge of *a* block (which is in A). The reasoning incorrectly assumes the yellow square in C must be above the yellow square in A, which is true because C is above A. However, the question asks which object is above *a* medium yellow square. The reasoning chain fails to analyze the second option: Is the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of a block (the one in A) above any medium yellow square? The yellow square in A is below the two blue squares in A. It is not stated to be above any other yellow square. The reasoning chain concludes the yellow square in C is the answer because it's above the yellow square in A, but it doesn't properly evaluate if the yellow square in A is above *any* yellow square, which is necessary to determine if (b) could be correct.
Answer Span:
Since Block C is above Block A, the medium yellow square in Block C is above the objects in Block A, including the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #1344
We have two blocks, A and B. Block A contains one small yellow circle, a big blue circle and a small black circle. The small yellow circle is below the big blue circle. The big blue circle is to the l...
Clean
Full Question
We have two blocks, A and B. Block A contains one small yellow circle, a big blue circle and a small black circle. The small yellow circle is below the big blue circle. The big blue circle is to the left of and above the small black circle. The small black circle is touching the right edge of this block. To the right of block A we have block B. It contains a medium yellow square, one big blue triangle and one small black triangle. This block also has a medium yellow circle. Above the small black triangle and the big blue triangle is a medium black triangle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The small black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the medium yellow circle and the small black triangle is the big blue triangle. What is to the right of the small yellow circle? a small black triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a big blue triangle?
(a) small black triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) big blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains the small yellow circle, and Block B (to the right of A) contains the small black triangle and the big blue triangle. The small black triangle is touching the bottom edge of Block B. Since both are in Block B, which is to the right of Block A where the small yellow circle is located, both the small black triangle and the big blue triangle are to the right of the small yellow circle.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the location of the small yellow circle (Block A) and the two candidate objects (small black triangle and big blue triangle, both in Block B, which is to the right of A). It concludes that both are to the right of the small yellow circle, which is a reasonable inference based on the block placement, although the specific relative positioning within Block B is not fully detailed, the conclusion that both are to the right of the object in Block A is sound given the setup.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #316
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of A. Block A is below C. Block A has one medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also has one medium yellow sq...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of A. Block A is below C. Block A has one medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also has one medium yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square and the medium yellow square. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square. Block B has two medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Block C has two medium yellow squares. Below a medium blue square there is medium yellow square number one. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square number two. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? medium blue square number one or the medium blue square which is in block C?
(a) medium blue square number one
(b) the medium blue square which is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block B contains two medium blue squares, and Block C contains two medium yellow squares and a medium blue square. Since Block B is to the left of Block A and Block C is above Block A, only Block B can contain objects that are to the left of the medium yellow squares in Block C. The medium blue squares are in Block B and are thus to the left of the objects in Block C. Therefore, both medium blue square number one and the medium blue square in Block C are to the left of a medium yellow square.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains a factual contradiction regarding the contents of Block C and ignores the crucial positional information needed to determine which object is to the left of a medium yellow square, relying instead on block-level positioning.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block C contains two medium yellow squares and a medium blue square.
Explanation
The context states Block C has two medium yellow squares, but it does not state it has a medium blue square. Block A has the medium blue square mentioned in relation to Block C's yellow squares.
Answer Span:
Block C contains two medium yellow squares and a medium blue square
Reference/Question Span:
Block C has two medium yellow squares.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The medium blue squares are in Block B and are thus to the left of the objects in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning concludes that the medium blue squares in Block B are to the left of the medium yellow squares in Block C based only on the block positions (B left of A, C above A). It fails to check the relative vertical/horizontal positions of the specific medium yellow squares in C versus the specific medium blue squares in B, which is necessary to answer the question about which object is *to the left of a medium yellow square*.
Answer Span:
The medium blue squares are in Block B and are thus to the left of the objects in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? medium blue square number one or the medium blue square which is in block C?
Question #2495
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains one medium yellow square. To the right of block A we have block B. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one ...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains one medium yellow square. To the right of block A we have block B. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a medium blue square. Medium black square number two is below the medium blue square. Below the medium blue square and medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. Finally, there is block C which is below block A. It has three medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and medium blue square number three. Medium blue square number two is below medium blue square number three. A medium yellow square is below medium blue square number two and medium blue square number one. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium blue square which is in block B or medium blue square number one?
(a) the medium blue square which is in block B
(b) medium blue square number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B, to the right of A, contains a medium blue square and two medium black squares. Block C, below Block A, contains three medium blue squares and a medium yellow square. Since Block B is to the right of Block A (which contains a medium yellow square), the medium blue square in Block B is to the right of the medium yellow square in Block A. The medium blue squares in Block C are below, not to the right of, the medium yellow square in Block A.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the relative positions of A and B to answer the question about the medium yellow square in A, but it incorrectly adds a medium yellow square to Block C, which contradicts the source text.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block C, below Block A, contains three medium blue squares and a medium yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly states that Block C contains a medium yellow square. The context only states Block A contains the medium yellow square.
Answer Span:
Block C, below Block A, contains three medium blue squares and a medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains one medium yellow square.
Question #349
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the right of A. Block B is to the left of C. Block A contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bo...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the right of A. Block B is to the left of C. Block A contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Block B has three medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square number three is medium black square number two. Below medium black square number three is medium black square number one. It is below the medium black square number two. And block C contains a medium yellow square and one medium blue square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square. Which object is below a medium black square? medium black square number three or the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium black square number three
(b) the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block B contains three medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge. Medium black square number two is above number one, and medium black square number three is above number two. Therefore, medium black square number one is below medium black square number two, and medium black square number two is below medium black square number three. The question asks what is below *a* medium black square, implying any of them. Only medium black square number three and two have something below them. Medium black square number one, which is also the medium black square touching the bottom edge, has nothing below it.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly interprets the vertical stacking order of the medium black squares in Block B, leading to an incorrect analysis of which squares have objects below them, even though the final answer choice selection might coincidentally align with the flawed logic.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Medium black square number two is above number one, and medium black square number three is above number two.
Explanation
The source states the vertical relationship for B's squares as: 'Below medium black square number three is medium black square number one. It is below the medium black square number two.' This implies the order from bottom to top is: 1, 3, 2. The reasoning chain incorrectly states the order is 1, 2, 3 (or 3 is above 2, which is above 1).
Answer Span:
Medium black square number two is above number one, and medium black square number three is above number two.
Reference/Question Span:
Below medium black square number three is medium black square number one. It is below the medium black square number two.
Question #1845
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are two medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are two medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square. Medium black square number one is below the medium yellow square. This object is below medium black square number two. Above block A we have block B with two medium blue squares in it. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium blue square number two. It also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is below the yellow object which is below medium blue square number two. Below block A there is block C with one medium yellow square in it. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or the medium yellow square that is in block A?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block C
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains two medium black squares and a medium yellow square. Block B, above A, contains two medium blue squares and a medium yellow square. Block C, below A, contains one medium yellow square. The question asks what is below the medium yellow square. Since Block C is below Block A, and the medium yellow square in Block C is the only object directly below anything in Block A, the medium yellow square in Block C is below the objects in Block A, including the medium yellow square. The medium yellow square in block A is above the medium black squares in block A.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain incorrectly asserts the contents of Block A by adding a medium yellow square, which is not explicitly stated to be *in* Block A, although relationships involving a yellow square are described relative to objects in A. The reasoning then proceeds to answer the question based on this flawed premise.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionlow
Statement
Block A contains two medium black squares and a medium yellow square.
Explanation
The context states Block A has two medium black squares, but it does not explicitly state it contains a medium yellow square. It only describes relationships involving a medium yellow square relative to the black squares within A.
Answer Span:
Block A contains two medium black squares and a medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
There are two medium black squares in block A.
Question #1846
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are two medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are two medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square. Medium black square number one is below the medium yellow square. This object is below medium black square number two. Above block A we have block B with two medium blue squares in it. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium blue square number two. It also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is below the yellow object which is below medium blue square number two. Below block A there is block C with one medium yellow square in it. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block B or the medium yellow square that is in block A?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block B
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium yellow square and two medium black squares. Block B, above Block A, contains two medium blue squares and a medium yellow square. Block C, below Block A, contains a medium yellow square. The question asks what is above the medium yellow square in Block C. Since Block A is directly above Block C, and Block A contains a medium yellow square, the medium yellow square in Block A is above the medium yellow square in Block C. The medium yellow square in Block B is not directly above the one in Block C.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain fundamentally misinterprets the final question, leading it to analyze the wrong relationship (what is above the yellow square in C) instead of comparing the objects above the yellow squares in A and B.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The question asks what is above the medium yellow square in Block C.
Explanation
The final question asks: "Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block B or the medium yellow square that is in block A?" The reasoning chain incorrectly reframes the question to only ask about what is above the yellow square in Block C.
Answer Span:
The question asks what is above the medium yellow square in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block B or the medium yellow square that is in block A?
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block A is directly above Block C, and Block A contains a medium yellow square, the medium yellow square in Block A is above the medium yellow square in Block C.
Explanation
While Block A is above Block C, the reasoning focuses only on the relationship between the yellow square in A and the yellow square in C, ignoring the primary comparison requested in the actual question (comparing what is above the yellow square in B vs. what is above the yellow square in A).
Answer Span:
Since Block A is directly above Block C, and Block A contains a medium yellow square, the medium yellow square in Block A is above the medium yellow square in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block B or the medium yellow square that is in block A?
Question #317
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of A. Block A is below C. Block A has one medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also has one medium yellow sq...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of A. Block A is below C. Block A has one medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also has one medium yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square and the medium yellow square. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square. Block B has two medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Block C has two medium yellow squares. Below a medium blue square there is medium yellow square number one. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square number two. Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium blue square that is in block A or medium blue square number one?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) medium blue square number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block B contains two medium blue squares, numbered one and two. Block A, to the right of Block B, contains a medium blue square. Therefore, the medium blue square in Block A is to the right of both medium blue squares in Block B. Medium blue square number one is in Block B, so it cannot be to the right of itself.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly assigns numbers to the blue squares in Block B and makes an unsupported leap regarding the relative positions of the blue squares based only on block positions, ignoring the specific constraints needed to answer the final question.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block B contains two medium blue squares, numbered one and two.
Explanation
The context states Block B has two medium blue squares, but it does not assign them numbers 'one' and 'two'. The numbering (medium blue square number one) is introduced later in relation to Block C's contents, not Block B's.
Answer Span:
Block B contains two medium blue squares, numbered one and two.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has two medium blue squares.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Therefore, the medium blue square in Block A is to the right of both medium blue squares in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes Block A is to the right of Block B based on the initial spatial relationship ('Block B is to the left of A'). However, the question asks which object is to the right of a *medium blue square*. The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes the spatial relationship between the blocks dictates the answer without checking the specific locations of the blue squares relative to each other, which is the core of the question.
Answer Span:
Therefore, the medium blue square in Block A is to the right of both medium blue squares in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the left of A.
Question #1789
We have two blocks, A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A contains one small blue triangle, a big blue circle and one medium blue triangle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of th...
2 issues
Full Question
We have two blocks, A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A contains one small blue triangle, a big blue circle and one medium blue triangle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. This object is near to, above and to the right of the medium blue triangle. Block B contains two medium blue triangles. Medium blue triangle number one is touching the right edge of this block. A big yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of medium blue triangle number two is a small yellow circle. Below medium blue triangle number two is a big blue triangle.. To the left of medium blue triangle number one and the big blue triangle there is the big yellow square. It is to the right of the yellow shape which is to the left of medium blue triangle number two. What is to the right of the small blue triangle? a big blue triangle or a yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) big blue triangle
(b) yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains a small blue triangle, and Block B contains a big blue triangle and a big yellow square touching the bottom edge. Since Block B is to the right of Block A, and both the big blue triangle and the big yellow square are in Block B, they are both to the right of the small blue triangle in Block A.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes incorrect assumptions about object placement (specifically regarding the big blue triangle and the big yellow square's relationship to Block B vs. being to the right of the small blue triangle) and completely ignores the necessary step of checking relative positions within Block A, where the small blue triangle resides.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block A contains a small blue triangle, and Block B contains a big blue triangle and a big yellow square touching the bottom edge.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly places the big blue triangle in Block B. The context states the big blue triangle is below medium blue triangle number two, which is in Block B, but it does not explicitly state the big blue triangle is *in* Block B, only that it is below MBT2. More critically, the reasoning claims Block B contains a big yellow square touching the bottom edge, but the context states the big yellow square touching the bottom edge is in Block B, but it is *not* stated that the big blue triangle is in Block B.
Answer Span:
Block B contains a big blue triangle and a big yellow square touching the bottom edge.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B contains two medium blue triangles. Medium blue triangle number one is touching the right edge of this block. A big yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of medium blue triangle number two is a small yellow circle. Below medium blue triangle number two is a big blue triangle.. To the left of medium blue triangle number one and the big blue triangle there is the big yellow square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B is to the right of Block A, and both the big blue triangle and the big yellow square are in Block B, they are both to the right of the small blue triangle in Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes that because the objects are in Block B (which is to the right of Block A), they are necessarily to the right of the small blue triangle in Block A. The question asks what is to the right of the small blue triangle, which is an object *within* Block A. The reasoning fails to check the relative positions of objects *within* Block A.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is to the right of Block A, and both the big blue triangle and the big yellow square are in Block B, they are both to the right of the small blue triangle in Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the right of the small blue triangle? a big blue triangle or a yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #3160
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of and C is to the right of B. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B contains two medium blue squares. This block also has a medium black...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of and C is to the right of B. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B contains two medium blue squares. This block also has a medium black square. This block also contains one medium yellow square. This object is below medium blue square number two. It is below the medium black square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium blue square number two , the medium yellow square and the medium black square. Block C has two medium yellow squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square is medium yellow square number one. Which object is below a black shape? the medium blue square that is in block C or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block C
(b) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block B contains a medium black square and two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of Block B, below the black square. Block C contains a medium blue square, but this is not directly below the black square in Block B. Only the medium blue square touching the bottom edge of Block B is below the black shape.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relevant information about the black square in Block B and the location of the blue squares relative to it, leading to the correct conclusion based on the provided context.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2896
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of C and block C is above B. Block A contains three medium yellow squares. It also contains a medium black square. It is below me...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of C and block C is above B. Block A contains three medium yellow squares. It also contains a medium black square. It is below medium yellow square number three. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium yellow square number three and the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium black square and medium yellow square number three. Block B contains two medium yellow squares. One medium blue square is also in this block. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium blue square and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square. Block C contains one medium yellow square. Which object is below a medium square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or medium yellow square number three?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block C
(b) medium yellow square number three
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
3
Generated Answer
Block C contains a medium yellow square, and Block B (below C) contains two medium yellow squares and a medium blue square. Block A (to the right of C) contains three medium yellow squares and a medium black square. The question asks what is below *a* medium square, meaning *any* medium square. The medium yellow square in Block C is above other shapes in Block B. Medium yellow square number three in Block A is above medium yellow square number two and the medium black square. Therefore, both of the specified medium squares are above other shapes.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain fails to correctly establish the vertical relationships required to answer the question. It makes unsupported claims about what is above/below specific objects (MYQ3 and the MYQ in C) based only on block positions, leading to a flawed conclusion about which object is below a medium square.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The medium yellow square in Block C is above other shapes in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning claims the medium yellow square in Block C is *above* other shapes in Block B. The context only states the relative positions of the blocks (C is above B), but it does not specify the vertical relationship between the *contents* of C and the *contents* of B, which is necessary to answer the final question. The reasoning jumps to a conclusion about the contents' relative positions without supporting facts.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow square in Block C is above other shapes in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C contains one medium yellow square. Which object is below a medium square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or medium yellow square number three?
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Medium yellow square number three in Block A is above medium yellow square number two and the medium black square.
Explanation
The reasoning claims MYQ3 is above MYQ2 and the medium black square. The context states MYQ3 is *above* MYQ2, but it also states MYQ3 is *below* MYQ1. The reasoning incorrectly asserts MYQ3 is above the medium black square when the context states MYQ1 is below the medium black square and MYQ3. The reasoning needs to establish what is *below* MYQ3 to answer the question, and this statement misrepresents the known relationships.
Answer Span:
Medium yellow square number three in Block A is above medium yellow square number two and the medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium yellow square number one is below the medium black square and medium yellow square number three.
Question #2032
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one medium blue square. Block B is above block A. It contains one medium blue triangle, one big yellow square and one small yellow square. ...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one medium blue square. Block B is above block A. It contains one medium blue triangle, one big yellow square and one small yellow square. A big blue circle is also in this block. The small yellow square is above the big blue circle. The medium blue triangle is below the small yellow square. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is near to the big blue circle. The big yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. It is below the small shape which is above the big blue circle. It is above the big blue circle. To the left of block B there is block C which has one big black circle. There is also one medium black circle in this block. The big black circle is to the left of and near to the medium black circle. Which object is below a medium blue object? the medium black circle or the square that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the medium black circle
(b) the square that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
3
Generated Answer
Block B contains a medium blue triangle, and Block A (below Block B) contains a medium blue square. The big yellow square in Block B is touching the right edge. Since the medium blue triangle is in Block B and Block A (with the medium blue square) is directly below Block B, the big yellow square (touching the right edge of Block B) is directly above the medium blue square. The medium black circle is in Block C, which is to the left of Block B, so it is not below the medium blue triangle.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes unsupported assumptions about vertical positioning (big yellow square above medium blue square) and incorrectly dismisses the medium black circle based on horizontal positioning relative to the medium blue triangle, failing to properly evaluate the required vertical relationships for both candidate objects against both medium blue objects mentioned in the context.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since the medium blue triangle is in Block B and Block A (with the medium blue square) is directly below Block B, the big yellow square (touching the right edge of Block B) is directly above the medium blue square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes the big yellow square is directly above the medium blue square based only on their block locations (both in B or A, respectively) and the big yellow square touching the right edge of B. The context does not establish a vertical relationship between the big yellow square (in B) and the medium blue square (in A), only that A is below B.
Answer Span:
the big yellow square (touching the right edge of Block B) is directly above the medium blue square
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has one medium blue square. Block B is above block A.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The medium black circle is in Block C, which is to the left of Block B, so it is not below the medium blue triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly concludes that the medium black circle cannot be below the medium blue triangle simply because C is to the left of B. The question asks which object is below *a* medium blue object. The medium blue triangle is in B. The medium black circle is in C. The spatial relationship 'below' must be determined absolutely, not just by horizontal separation. Furthermore, the reasoning chain fails to check if the medium black circle is below the *other* medium blue object (the square in A).
Answer Span:
The medium black circle is in Block C, which is to the left of Block B, so it is not below the medium blue triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is below a medium blue object? the medium black circle or the square that is touching the right edge of a block?
Question #1516
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of C and block C is to the right of A. Block A contains a medium blue square, one big blue circle and a big black circle. This...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of C and block C is to the right of A. Block A contains a medium blue square, one big blue circle and a big black circle. This block also has a small black square. There is also one small blue square in this block. The big blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the small blue square. The medium blue square is below and to the right of the small black square. This shape is above and to the left of the big black circle. Block B contains a medium black square. Block C contains one small black square, one small yellow triangle and one small blue triangle. Below the small blue triangle and the small yellow triangle there is the small black square. The small yellow triangle is near to the small blue triangle. What is to the right of the small blue square? a object that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a small black square?
(a) object that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) small black square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a small blue square, a big blue circle (touching the bottom edge), a medium blue square, a small black square, and a big black circle. The small blue square is above the big blue circle. The medium blue square is below and to the right of the small black square, which is above and to the left of the big black circle. This means the small black square is to the right of the small blue square. The big blue circle is the object touching the bottom edge and is below the small blue square, not to its right.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly lists the contents of Block A but makes an unsupported positional claim about the small black square relative to the small blue square. Crucially, the reasoning chain fails to address the actual question, which asks what is to the right of the small blue square based on the positional constraints given for Block A.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
This means the small black square is to the right of the small blue square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain makes an assertion about the relative position of the small black square and the small blue square ('This means the small black square is to the right of the small blue square') based on the preceding description, but the context only specifies the relative position of the medium blue square to the small black square, and the big blue circle's position relative to the small blue square. It does not explicitly state the horizontal relationship between the small black square and the small blue square, making this deduction an unsupported assumption or inference that isn't directly verifiable from the text.
Answer Span:
This means the small black square is to the right of the small blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains a medium blue square, one big blue circle and a big black circle. This block also has a small black square. There is also one small blue square in this block. The big blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the small blue square. The medium blue square is below and to the right of the small black square. This shape is above and to the left of the big black circle.
Question #2821
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. One medium blue square, a medium black square and a medium yellow square are in block A. Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. The me...
1 issue
Full Question
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. One medium blue square, a medium black square and a medium yellow square are in block A. Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square and the medium black square. Below block A is block B. It has three medium black squares. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number one. Below medium black square number three is medium black square number two. There is also one medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium black square number one is the medium yellow square. This object is below medium black square number two and medium black square number three. Which object is below a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is in block A or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium yellow square, a medium black square, and a medium blue square. Block B, below Block A, contains three medium black squares and a medium yellow square touching the bottom edge. The medium yellow square in Block B is below the medium black squares in Block B. Since the question asks what is below *a* medium black square (implying any medium black square), the medium yellow square in Block B fits the description. The medium yellow square in Block A is above the medium black square in Block A, not below it.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that the yellow square in Block B is below a medium black square. However, it incorrectly concludes that the yellow square in Block A is *above* the black square in Block A, when the context explicitly states the black square is below the yellow square in Block A, meaning the yellow square in A is *above* the black square in A. The reasoning chain seems to have misinterpreted the relationship in Block A when trying to eliminate option (a).
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The medium yellow square in Block B is below the medium black squares in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning chain claims the medium yellow square in Block B is below the medium black squares in Block B, but the context only specifies the relationship between black squares (1, 2, 3) and the yellow square relative to black square 1. It states: 'Below medium black square number one is the medium yellow square. This object is below medium black square number two and medium black square number three.' This confirms the yellow square in B is below black squares 1, 2, and 3. However, the reasoning chain then incorrectly concludes that the yellow square in A is *above* the medium black square in A, which contradicts the context.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow square in Block A is above the medium black square in Block A, not below it.
Reference/Question Span:
Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square and the medium black square.
Question #1425
There are two blocks, A and B. Block A has a big black square, a small black square and one medium black square. The small black square is above the medium black square. Near to and to the right of th...
Clean
Full Question
There are two blocks, A and B. Block A has a big black square, a small black square and one medium black square. The small black square is above the medium black square. Near to and to the right of the small black square there is the big black square. Block B is to the right of block A. It contains one medium black triangle, one small black square and one big yellow square. A medium yellow triangle is also in this block. The big yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. Near to the big yellow square and the small black square there is the medium black triangle. The small black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black triangle is to the right of the medium yellow triangle. Which object is to the left of a medium black triangle? the thing that is touching the right edge of a block or the black thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the thing that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the black thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
3
Generated Answer
Block B contains a medium black triangle, a small black square touching the bottom edge, and a big yellow square touching the right edge. The medium black triangle is near both the big yellow square and the small black square. The small black square is to the left of the medium black triangle, but the big yellow square is to its right. Therefore, the object to the left of the medium black triangle is the small black square which is also the black thing touching the bottom edge of block B.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in Block B and their relative positions based on the context to answer the final question.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2635
We have two blocks. We call them A and B. There are one small yellow triangle, a big black square and a medium black triangle in block A. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block....
1 issue
Full Question
We have two blocks. We call them A and B. There are one small yellow triangle, a big black square and a medium black triangle in block A. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. It is above the medium black triangle. The small yellow triangle is touching the top edge of this block. The medium black triangle is touching the right edge of this block. The small yellow triangle is above and to the left of the big black square. Block B is above block A. It contains one small black square, one medium yellow circle and one big black triangle. This block also has a small blue square. Above the big black triangle is the medium yellow circle. A small blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Above the small blue circle and the big black triangle there is the small black square. What is below the small blue square? a big black square or a small object that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) big black square
(b) small object that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains a big black square and Block B (above A) contains the small blue square. Since Block B is directly above Block A, the big black square is below the small blue square. The small blue circle is touching the bottom edge of Block B, but it is not below the small blue square.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning correctly identifies that the big black square (in A) is below the small blue square (in B), but it fails to properly evaluate the second option presented in the question ('a small object that is touching the bottom edge of a block') against the small blue square's position, leading to an incomplete evaluation necessary to select the correct option (c).
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The small blue circle is touching the bottom edge of Block B, but it is not below the small blue square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain fails to consider the second part of the question: 'a big black square or a small object that is touching the bottom edge of a block?'. The small object touching the bottom edge of Block B is the small blue circle. The reasoning chain mentions this object but then dismisses it without evaluating if it is below the small blue square, which is necessary to answer the question.
Answer Span:
The small blue circle is touching the bottom edge of Block B, but it is not below the small blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
What is below the small blue square? a big black square or a small object that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #3095
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A contains one medium blue triangle and a small yellow square. There is also a small black circle in this block. Above an...
1 issue
Full Question
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A contains one medium blue triangle and a small yellow square. There is also a small black circle in this block. Above and to the left of the small yellow square is the medium blue triangle. A medium black circle is far from, above and to the left of the small yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is to the left of and below medium yellow square number two. It also has one medium black circle. This object is below medium yellow square number two. It also contains a big blue square. Below and near to the big blue square is the medium black circle. To the left of the black object which is below the big blue square there is medium yellow square number one. What is to the left of the blue square? a medium blue triangle or a medium black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium blue triangle
(b) medium black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium blue triangle, a small yellow square, and a small black circle. Block B contains two medium yellow squares, a medium black circle, and a big blue square. Block A is to the left of Block B. Since the medium blue triangle is in Block A and Block A is to the left of Block B (which contains the big blue square), the medium blue triangle is to the left of the big blue square. The medium black circle is in Block B and is below medium yellow square number two, so it is not to the left of the big blue square.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the location of the medium blue triangle relative to the big blue square (which is in Block B). However, it fails to properly evaluate the condition for the medium black circle option (b) by ignoring the required positional constraint ('touching the bottom edge of a block').
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The medium black circle is in Block B and is below medium yellow square number two, so it is not to the left of the big blue square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain concludes the medium black circle is not to the left of the big blue square based on its location relative to medium yellow square number two. However, the question asks what is to the left of the blue square, and the options involve a medium black circle *touching the bottom edge of a block*. The reasoning ignores the specific condition required for option (b).
Answer Span:
The medium black circle is in Block B and is below medium yellow square number two, so it is not to the left of the big blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the left of the blue square? a medium blue triangle or a medium black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #1253
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains a big black circle and one small blue circle. The big black circle is below a medium black triangle. Below the medium black triangle t...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains a big black circle and one small blue circle. The big black circle is below a medium black triangle. Below the medium black triangle there is the small blue circle. The big black circle is above and near to the small blue circle. Then, there is block B with one medium yellow circle, a big black square and one small blue square in it. A medium black circle is to the right of the medium yellow circle and the small blue square. Above the big black square and the small blue square is the medium yellow circle. The medium black circle is above the big black square. To the right of block A and to the left of block B there is block C. It has one medium blue circle and a small blue circle. The medium blue circle is near to and to the left of a medium black square which is to the right of and below the small blue circle. What is to the left of the big black square? a medium blue circle or a yellow object?
(a) medium blue circle
(b) yellow object
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A has a big black circle and a small blue circle. Block B has a medium yellow circle, a big black square, and a small blue square. Block C has a medium blue circle and a small blue circle. The question asks what is to the left of the big black square. Since Block B contains the big black square and Block A (containing the big black circle and small blue circle) is to the left of Block B, and Block C (containing a medium blue circle) is to the *right* of Block A and to the *left* of Block B, the objects to the left of the big black square could be from either Block A or Block C. The medium blue circle is in Block C, and the medium yellow circle (the yellow object) is in Block B. Thus, only the medium blue circle is to the left of the big black square.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly interprets the spatial relationships between the blocks and fails to correctly evaluate which objects are spatially to the left of the big black square based on the provided context, leading to an unsupported conclusion.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block C (containing a medium blue circle) is to the *right* of Block A and to the *left* of Block B
Explanation
The context states Block C is 'To the right of block A and to the left of block B', but the reasoning incorrectly states Block C is to the *right* of Block A and to the *left* of Block B, which is a restatement, but the subsequent deduction about what is to the left of the big black square relies on an incorrect spatial relationship derived from this.
Answer Span:
Block C (containing a medium blue circle) is to the *right* of Block A and to the *left* of Block B
Reference/Question Span:
To the right of block A and to the left of block B there is block C
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Thus, only the medium blue circle is to the left of the big black square.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly concludes that only the medium blue circle is to the left of the big black square. The question asks what is to the left of the big black square: 'a medium blue circle or a yellow object?'. The medium blue circle is in Block C. The yellow object mentioned in the options is the medium yellow circle, which is in Block B. The reasoning fails to check if any object in Block A (which is to the left of Block B) is to the left of the big black square, or if the medium blue circle in Block C is actually to the left of the big black square based on the positional data provided for Block C relative to Block B.
Answer Span:
Thus, only the medium blue circle is to the left of the big black square.
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the left of the big black square? a medium blue circle or a yellow object?
Question #1296
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is above blocks C and A. Block A has a small yellow square and one big yellow triangle. The small yellow square is below the big yellow triangle. Block B ha...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is above blocks C and A. Block A has a small yellow square and one big yellow triangle. The small yellow square is below the big yellow triangle. Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the right edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is above a big blue triangle. It also contains a big blue square. It is above and to the right of the big blue triangle. Above and to the right of the big blue triangle there is medium yellow square number one. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. And block C has one medium yellow square and a big yellow circle. This block also has a medium black triangle. The medium yellow square is near to, to the right of and below the big yellow circle. Which object is above a yellow square? the triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the big blue square?
(a) the triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the big blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains a small yellow square, and Block B (above A) contains a big blue triangle touching the bottom edge and a big blue square above and to the right of the triangle. Thus, directly above the small yellow square is the big blue triangle. Block C also contains a medium yellow square, but nothing is described as being directly above it. Since Block B is above both A and C, only the objects in B can be directly above objects in either A or C. Thus the blue triangle in B is above the small yellow square in A. The big blue square in B is above and to the right of the big blue triangle, not directly above the yellow square in A. The medium yellow square in C has the big yellow circle near, to the right and above it, not the blue triangle.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes several unsupported assumptions about the vertical alignment of objects and incorrectly places the big blue triangle as a primary object in Block B, leading to a false conclusion about what is above the small yellow square in Block A.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block A contains a small yellow square, and Block B (above A) contains a big blue triangle touching the bottom edge and a big blue square above and to the right of the triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes the big blue triangle is in Block B. The context states Block B has two medium yellow squares and a big blue square. The big blue triangle is only mentioned in relation to Block B's contents in the context of where medium yellow square number two is located relative to it, but the context does not explicitly state the big blue triangle is *in* Block B. More critically, the context states the big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of *this block* (referring to the block containing medium yellow square number two, which is Block B). However, the reasoning chain then states the big blue triangle is *in* Block B, which is plausible but not explicitly stated as a direct inventory item of B like the squares are. The major error is the next sentence.
Answer Span:
Block B (above A) contains a big blue triangle touching the bottom edge
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the right edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is above a big blue triangle. It also contains a big blue square. It is above and to the right of the big blue triangle. Above and to the right of the big blue triangle there is medium yellow square number one. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block.
contradictionhigh
Statement
Thus, directly above the small yellow square is the big blue triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain concludes the big blue triangle is directly above the small yellow square in Block A. The context only states Block B is above Block A. It does not specify the vertical alignment between the small yellow square in A and any specific object in B (like the big blue triangle, which is only mentioned in relation to medium yellow square #2). The reasoning chain invents a direct vertical relationship that is not supported by the text.
Answer Span:
Thus, directly above the small yellow square is the big blue triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is above blocks C and A.
Question #350
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. One medium yellow square is in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below a medium ...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. One medium yellow square is in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square and medium black square number two. This block also contains one medium blue square. The medium blue square is below medium black square number one and medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two is the medium yellow square. To the left of block B there is block C with two medium yellow squares in it. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. One medium blue square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two there is the medium blue square. It is below medium yellow square number one. Which object is above a medium blue square? medium yellow square number one or the medium yellow square which is in block A?
(a) medium yellow square number one
(b) the medium yellow square which is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium yellow square, and Block B (below A) contains two medium black squares and a medium blue square. Block C, to the left of Block B, contains two medium yellow squares (number two above number one) and a medium blue square below them. The question asks what is above the medium blue square. In Block C, medium yellow square number one is directly above the medium blue square. The medium yellow square in Block A is above the medium black squares in Block B, not the medium blue square in Block C.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in each block but makes an incorrect assumption about the vertical relationship of the objects in Block C, specifically stating Y1 is 'directly above' the blue square when the context describes a sequence (Y2 above Y1, Blue below Y2 and Y1).
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionmedium
Statement
In Block C, medium yellow square number one is directly above the medium blue square.
Explanation
The context states that in Block C, medium yellow square number one is *below* medium yellow square number two, and the medium blue square is below medium yellow square number two, and it is below medium yellow square number one. This implies medium yellow square number one is *above* the blue square, but the reasoning chain implies a specific vertical relationship (directly above) that contradicts the complex layering described, specifically by ignoring the relationship between Y1 and Y2.
Answer Span:
medium yellow square number one is directly above the medium blue square
Reference/Question Span:
Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. . . Below medium yellow square number two there is the medium blue square. It is below medium yellow square number one.
Question #2115
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is below block B and it is above block C. Block A has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and a medi...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is below block B and it is above block C. Block A has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and a medium black square. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. Block B contains two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium blue square number two is below medium black square number two and medium black square number one. Below medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. Medium blue square number one is below the black object which is below medium black square number two. It is below the medium blue square number two. Block C contains one medium black square. Which object is below a medium black square? medium black square number one or the medium black square that is in block C?
(a) medium black square number one
(b) the medium black square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A, which is below Block B, has two medium blue squares and a medium black square. Block B has two medium blue squares and two medium black squares. Block C, below Block A, has one medium black square. The question asks what is below *a* medium black square. Since Block A is below Block B, and contains a medium black square, the medium black square in Block C is below a medium black square (the one in Block A). Also, medium blue square number one in Block B is described as being below the black object (medium black square number one) which is below medium black square number two. Thus, medium black square number one is below another medium black square (number two). So both options are below a medium black square.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes several factual errors regarding the contents of Block A and the relative positions used to justify the conclusion. Specifically, it incorrectly places a medium black square inside Block A and misinterprets the positional relationships to conclude that the medium black square in C is below the medium black square in A.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block A, which is below Block B, has two medium blue squares and a medium black square.
Explanation
The context states Block A has two medium blue squares, but it does not state it has a medium black square. The context describes the squares *within* Block A: 'Block A has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and a medium black square. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square.' This implies the black square is *below* Block A, not *in* Block A.
Answer Span:
Block A, which is below Block B, has two medium blue squares and a medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has two medium blue squares.
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block C, below Block A, has one medium black square.
Explanation
The context states Block A is below Block B and above Block C (meaning C is below A), but the reasoning chain incorrectly states Block C is below Block A and then claims Block C has a medium black square, which is true, but the reasoning chain uses this to justify that the medium black square in C is below the medium black square in A, which is not supported by the positional information given.
Answer Span:
Block C, below Block A, has one medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A is below block B and it is above block C.
Question #2822
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. One medium blue square, a medium black square and a medium yellow square are in block A. Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. The me...
2 issues
Full Question
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. One medium blue square, a medium black square and a medium yellow square are in block A. Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square and the medium black square. Below block A is block B. It has three medium black squares. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number one. Below medium black square number three is medium black square number two. There is also one medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium black square number one is the medium yellow square. This object is below medium black square number two and medium black square number three. Which object is below a blue object? the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is in block A?
(a) the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium blue square, a medium black square, and a medium yellow square. The blue square is at the bottom, the black square is in the middle, and the yellow square is at the top. Below Block A is Block B, which contains three black squares and a yellow square at the bottom. Since Block B is directly below Block A, and the blue square is at the bottom of Block A, the objects directly below the blue square are in Block B. The yellow square in Block B is touching the bottom edge of the block. Therefore, the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of Block B is below the medium blue square in Block A.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly determines the vertical arrangement of objects within Block A, leading to an incorrect assumption about what is below the blue square. It also ignores the specific positional constraints within Block B.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The blue square is at the bottom, the black square is in the middle, and the yellow square is at the top.
Explanation
The context specifies the relative vertical positions of the squares in Block A, which the reasoning chain reverses.
Answer Span:
The blue square is at the bottom, the black square is in the middle, and the yellow square is at the top.
Reference/Question Span:
Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square and the medium black square.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block B is directly below Block A, and the blue square is at the bottom of Block A, the objects directly below the blue square are in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes the object directly below the blue square in Block A is the object immediately below Block A (i.e., in Block B). However, the question asks which object *is below* a blue object, which could be any object lower down, and the reasoning chain fails to check the specific positional constraints given for Block B objects relative to Block A objects.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is directly below Block A, and the blue square is at the bottom of Block A, the objects directly below the blue square are in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Below block A is block B.
Question #2116
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is below block B and it is above block C. Block A has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and a medi...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is below block B and it is above block C. Block A has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and a medium black square. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. Block B contains two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium blue square number two is below medium black square number two and medium black square number one. Below medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. Medium blue square number one is below the black object which is below medium black square number two. It is below the medium blue square number two. Block C contains one medium black square. Which object is below a medium blue square? medium black square number one or the medium black square that is in block C?
(a) medium black square number one
(b) the medium black square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A has two medium blue squares and a medium black square, with medium blue square number two below the medium black square and medium blue square number one below medium blue square number two. Block B has two medium blue squares and two medium black squares, with medium blue square number one at the bottom, below medium blue square number two, which is below both medium black squares. Block C has one medium black square, and is below Block A. The question asks what is below *a* medium blue square. Medium black square number one is below a medium blue square (number two, specifically) in Block B. The medium black square in Block C is below Block A, which contains medium blue squares.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain introduces factual claims about the contents of Block A (adding a black square) and the relative position of Block C that are not explicitly supported or are misinterpretations of the positional data provided in the context.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block A has two medium blue squares and a medium black square
Explanation
The context states Block A has two medium blue squares, but it does not mention any black squares in Block A. It only mentions the relationship between the blue squares and a medium black square outside of the block description.
Answer Span:
Block A has two medium blue squares and a medium black square
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has two medium blue squares
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C has one medium black square, and is below Block A.
Explanation
The context states the relative vertical positions of A, B, and C (A is below B, A is above C), but it does not explicitly state that Block C is below Block A. The reasoning chain introduces this specific relationship as a fact when the context only establishes A is above C.
Answer Span:
Block C has one medium black square, and is below Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A is below block B and it is above block C.
Question #631
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks B and A. Block A has two medium blue squares. A medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium blue square number one is touc...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks B and A. Block A has two medium blue squares. A medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square there is medium blue square number two. Below the medium yellow square and medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Block B contains two medium blue squares. It also has a medium black square. This object is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the square which is below medium blue square number two. This shape is below medium blue square number two. Block C has one medium black square. Which object is below a medium blue square? the medium black square which is in block B or the medium black square that is in block C?
(a) the medium black square which is in block B
(b) the medium black square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has medium blue squares and a medium yellow square. Block B also has medium blue squares and a medium black square below medium blue square number two. Block C has a medium black square. Since Block C is below both A and B, the medium black square in Block C is below the medium blue squares in both Block A and Block B.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the contents of the blocks but fails to fully utilize the positional constraints provided for the black square in Block C, which is necessary to determine if it is below a medium blue square, leading to an incomplete justification for the final choice.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C has a medium black square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain states Block C has a medium black square, but it fails to incorporate the crucial positional information given for the black square in Block C, which is necessary to answer the final question.
Answer Span:
Block C has a medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C has one medium black square.
Question #2255
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this b...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. Below medium blue square number one , medium blue square number two and medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. Block B is to the right of block A. It has a medium black square. A medium yellow square is below the medium black square. Finally, there is block C. It is to the right of block B. It has a medium black square and a medium yellow square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Which object is to the left of a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or medium yellow square number two?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block C
(b) medium yellow square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains two medium yellow squares and two medium blue squares. Block B, to the right of A, has a medium black square. Block C, to the right of B, also has a medium black square. Since Block A is to the left of Block B, and Block B contains a medium black square, the objects in Block A (including medium yellow square number two) are to the left of the medium black square in Block B. The medium yellow square in Block C is to the right of the medium black square in block B, not to its left. Only medium yellow square number two is to the left of a medium black square.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the blocks and the objects within them based on the context to answer the question about which object is to the left of a medium black square.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #630
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks B and A. Block A has two medium blue squares. A medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium blue square number one is touc...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks B and A. Block A has two medium blue squares. A medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square there is medium blue square number two. Below the medium yellow square and medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Block B contains two medium blue squares. It also has a medium black square. This object is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the square which is below medium blue square number two. This shape is below medium blue square number two. Block C has one medium black square. Which object is below a medium blue square? the medium black square that is in block B or the medium black square that is in block C?
(a) the medium black square that is in block B
(b) the medium black square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has medium blue squares and a medium yellow square. Block B also has medium blue squares and a medium black square below medium blue square number two. Block C has a medium black square. Since Block C is below both A and B, the medium black square in Block C is below the medium blue squares in both Block A and Block B. The medium black square in Block B is below a medium blue square (number two), but not below all medium blue squares.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the contents of the blocks but makes an unsupported leap regarding the vertical relationship between the contents of Block C and the contents of Blocks A and B, which is not necessary to answer the specific question about which black square is below *a* medium blue square.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block C is below both A and B, the medium black square in Block C is below the medium blue squares in both Block A and Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning claims Block C is below A and B, which is true based on the context ('Block C is below blocks B and A'). However, the conclusion drawn that the black square in C is below the blue squares in A and B is an inference that relies on the vertical stacking of the blocks, which is not explicitly detailed enough to confirm the relative vertical position of the *contents* of C versus the contents of A and B, especially since the question asks about what is *below* a medium blue square *within* its own block or relative to other objects mentioned.
Answer Span:
Since Block C is below both A and B, the medium black square in Block C is below the medium blue squares in both Block A and Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C is below blocks B and A.
Question #1490
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are two medium yellow squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two which is below a medium blue squ...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are two medium yellow squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two which is below a medium blue square. It also contains one medium black square. Below the medium blue square and medium yellow square number one there is the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium blue square. Then, there is block B with one medium yellow square in it. Finally, we have block C to the right of block A and to the left of block B. It contains a medium yellow square and a medium black square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is in block C or the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium black square that is in block C
(b) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains two medium yellow squares and a medium black square. Block C, which is to the right of Block A, contains a medium yellow square and a medium black square. The medium black square in Block C is above the medium yellow square. Since Block C is to the right of Block A, which contains medium yellow squares, the medium black square in Block C is to the right of a medium yellow square. The prompt specifies that the medium yellow square in Block C is touching the bottom edge, and the medium black square is above it, meaning it is not touching the bottom edge.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the components of Block A and C. However, it makes an unsupported inference about the vertical relationship in C and fails to properly analyze the spatial relationship required by the question (i.e., which yellow square the black square in C might be to the right of, given Block C is to the right of Block A). The reasoning focuses too narrowly on the vertical relationship within Block C.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionlow
Statement
The medium black square in Block C is above the medium yellow square.
Explanation
The context states that in Block C, the medium yellow square is below the medium black square, which means the medium black square is above the medium yellow square. However, the reasoning chain incorrectly claims the medium yellow square in Block C is touching the bottom edge, and then uses this to deduce the black square is not touching the bottom edge, which is an inference based on a potentially misread or incomplete description of the spatial relationship within C, but the primary contradiction is in the subsequent sentence.
Answer Span:
The medium black square in Block C is above the medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
It contains a medium yellow square and a medium black square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block C is to the right of Block A, which contains medium yellow squares, the medium black square in Block C is to the right of a medium yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning concludes that the medium black square in Block C is to the right of *a* medium yellow square, but it fails to specify *which* medium yellow square it is to the right of. The question asks which object is to the right of *a* medium yellow square, implying we need to check if the black square in C is to the right of any yellow square mentioned in the context (either in A or C). The reasoning only checks if it's to the right of a yellow square *in Block C* (which is true by vertical stacking), but ignores the possibility of it being to the right of yellow squares in Block A, which is crucial for evaluating option (a).
Answer Span:
Since Block C is to the right of Block A, which contains medium yellow squares, the medium black square in Block C is to the right of a medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is in block C or the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #3068
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks A and B. Block A contains one small yellow square. Block B contains a big blue triangle, one medium black circle and one medium y...
3 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks A and B. Block A contains one small yellow square. Block B contains a big blue triangle, one medium black circle and one medium yellow square. The medium black circle is to the right of a small black square and the medium yellow square. It is touching the right edge of this block. The small black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below and to the left of the medium yellow square. And block C contains one medium yellow triangle, a medium black circle and a small yellow square. To the left of and above the small yellow square is the medium black circle. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. Below the medium black circle is the medium yellow triangle. Which object is above a medium black circle? the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow triangle?
(a) the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block B contains a medium black circle, and Block C (below Block A and B) contains a medium yellow triangle and a medium black circle. The small black square is below the medium yellow square in Block B. The medium black circle in Block C is above the medium yellow triangle. Since Block C is below Block B, the medium black circle in Block B is above the medium black circle in Block C, which in turn is above the medium yellow triangle. The small black square is below, not above, the medium black circle in Block B. Therefore, only the medium yellow triangle is below a medium black circle.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains multiple factual inaccuracies and ignores the core requirement of the question (identifying what is *above* a medium black circle) by focusing on what is *below* it. It also misinterprets positional data from the context.
Detected Issues (3)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block B contains a medium black circle
Explanation
The context states Block B contains 'a big blue triangle, one medium black circle and one medium yellow square'. It does not state Block B contains a medium black circle, it contains *one* medium black circle, but the reasoning implies this is the only object of that type, and more importantly, the question asks about objects *above* a medium black circle, and the reasoning chain incorrectly identifies which block contains which object relevant to the final question.
Answer Span:
Block B contains a medium black circle
Reference/Question Span:
Block B contains a big blue triangle, one medium black circle and one medium yellow square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The small black square is below the medium yellow square in Block B.
Explanation
The context describes the location of the medium black circle relative to the small black square and the medium yellow square in Block B, but it does not state that the small black square is *below* the medium yellow square. It states: 'The small black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object [the small black square] is below and to the left of the medium yellow square.' The reasoning incorrectly summarizes this positional relationship.
Answer Span:
The small black square is below the medium yellow square in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
This object is below and to the left of the medium yellow square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The small black square is below, not above, the medium black circle in Block B.
Explanation
The question asks which object is *above* a medium black circle. The reasoning chain focuses on what is *below* a medium black circle, which is irrelevant to answering the question posed. Furthermore, the context does not specify the vertical relationship between the small black square and the medium black circle in Block B.
Answer Span:
The small black square is below, not above, the medium black circle in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is above a medium black circle? the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow triangle?
Question #299
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are a medium blue circle, one big yellow square and one medium black square in block A. Below the medium black square which is to the right of a bi...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are a medium blue circle, one big yellow square and one medium black square in block A. Below the medium black square which is to the right of a big blue square is the big yellow square. It is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is touching the left edge of this block.. The medium blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. It is above the big yellow square. It is below and to the right of the medium black square. Block B is below block A. It has a small black triangle and one small black square. To the right of the small black square there is the small black triangle. Finally, there is block C above block B. It has one small yellow square. It also has one medium blue triangle. The medium blue triangle is to the right of and below the small yellow square. Which object is below a small yellow square? the small black square or the medium blue triangle?
(a) the small black square
(b) the medium blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block C contains the small yellow square, and Block B (below C) contains the small black square and the medium blue triangle. Since the small black square is in Block B, which is directly below Block C, the small black square is below the small yellow square. The medium blue triangle is also in Block B, but it is to the right of and below the small yellow square, not directly below it.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly states that Block B contains a medium blue triangle, which contradicts the provided context. The context states Block B has a small black triangle and a small black square, while Block C has the small yellow square and the medium blue triangle.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block B (below C) contains the small black square and the medium blue triangle.
Explanation
The context states Block B has a small black triangle and one small black square. It does not mention a medium blue triangle in Block B.
Answer Span:
Block B (below C) contains the small black square and the medium blue triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is below block A. It has a small black triangle and one small black square.
Question #807
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and above block C. Block A contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below medium black sq...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and above block C. Block A contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. There is also a medium blue square in this block. It is below medium black square number two. Below the blue shape which is below medium black square number two is medium black square number one. Block B has a medium black square and a medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium blue square. It also contains one medium yellow square.. Below the medium blue square and the medium black square is the medium yellow square. And block C contains one medium blue square. Which object is below a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square that is in block C?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) the medium blue square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has two medium black squares, with number two above number one, and a medium blue square below number two. Block B, to the left of A and above C, has a medium black square above a medium yellow square, and a medium blue square above the medium black square. Block C contains a medium blue square. The question asks what is below *a* medium black square, not specifically the one in Block A or B. Block C is below Block B, and Block B contains a medium black square. The medium blue square in Block C is below the medium black square in Block B. So, the medium blue square in Block C is below a medium black square. The medium blue square in Block A is also below a medium black square (number two in Block A).
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning chain accurately synthesizes the spatial relationships described in the context for blocks A, B, and C, and correctly identifies that both blue squares mentioned in the options are below some medium black square.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1627
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. There is also a medium blue square touching the bo...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two and medium yellow square number one is the medium blue square. Then, we have block B. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and a medium blue square. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square number two there is the medium blue square. To the right of both blocks A and B there is block C. It contains one medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium blue square? the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue square that is in block B?
(a) the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium blue square touching the bottom edge. Block B has a medium blue square above a medium black square which is touching the bottom edge. Block C has a medium blue square and is to the right of both A and B. The question asks what is to the left of *a* medium blue square. This is ambiguous, as there are three medium blue squares. If the question refers to the medium blue square in block C, then both the medium blue square touching the bottom edge of block A and the medium blue square in block B are to its left.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes two factual assertions about the relative positions of blue squares in blocks A and B that contradict or misinterpret the spatial relationships described in the source text, leading to an incorrect analysis of the final question.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionlow
Statement
Block A has a medium blue square touching the bottom edge.
Explanation
The context states the medium blue square in block A is touching the bottom edge, but it does not specify *which* medium blue square is touching the bottom edge. The context says: 'There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block [A].' This is a specific detail that the reasoning chain asserts as fact without full qualification, but the main issue is the next contradiction.
Answer Span:
Block A has a medium blue square touching the bottom edge.
Reference/Question Span:
There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block.
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block B has a medium blue square above a medium black square which is touching the bottom edge.
Explanation
The context states that medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge, and medium black square number one is below medium black square number two AND a medium blue square. This implies the blue square is *not* necessarily above the black square touching the bottom edge; it is just positioned relative to the black squares. The context states: 'Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and a medium blue square.' This does not mean the blue square is above MB1.
Answer Span:
Block B has a medium blue square above a medium black square which is touching the bottom edge.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and a medium blue square.
Question #2579
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A contains a small black square, one big blue circle and one medium black square. The small black square is above and near to the medium black square ...
Clean
Full Question
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A contains a small black square, one big blue circle and one medium black square. The small black square is above and near to the medium black square which is above, to the left of and near to a medium yellow square. The big blue circle is to the left of the medium yellow square. To the left of block A is block B. It has two small black circles. A big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a small yellow square. It also has one small black triangle and a medium blue circle. To the left of the medium blue circle is the small black triangle. Below the small yellow square there is the big yellow triangle. To the left of and below the small yellow square there is the small black triangle.. The medium blue circle is above small black circle number two. Which object is to the right of a small black circle? the medium black square or the big blue circle?
(a) the medium black square
(b) the big blue circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains a small black square, a big blue circle, and a medium black square. Block B, to the left of Block A, contains two small black circles. Since the question asks what is to the right of a small black circle, and the small black circles are in Block B, we look to Block A. The big blue circle and medium black square are both in Block A and are thus to the right of the small black circles in Block B.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the location of the small black circles (Block B) and checks the objects in Block A (which is to the right of Block B) against the question. The conclusion that both listed objects are to the right of the small black circles is supported by the spatial relationship established (Block B is to the left of Block A).
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #781
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is to the right of A. Block A has a big black circle. It also contains a small yellow triangle. The small yellow ...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is to the right of A. Block A has a big black circle. It also contains a small yellow triangle. The small yellow triangle is above and to the left of the big black circle. Block B has two big yellow triangles. It also contains a medium yellow circle. This block also has a big yellow circle. Big yellow triangle number one is touching the right edge of this block. Below a small black square there is big yellow triangle number two.. The medium yellow circle is to the right of and below the small black square. Far from and above the big yellow circle is big yellow triangle number one. It is to the right of big yellow triangle number two. And block C contains a medium blue triangle and a medium black circle. Below and to the left of the medium black circle there is the medium blue triangle. What is to the right of the small yellow triangle? a big yellow circle or a square?
(a) big yellow circle
(b) square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains the small yellow triangle, and Block B (to the right of A) contains a small black square, a big yellow circle, and two big yellow triangles. Since the big yellow circle is in Block B, and Block B is to the right of Block A (where the small yellow triangle is), the big yellow circle is to the right of the small yellow triangle. The small black square is also in Block B and to the right of the small yellow triangle.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies that the big yellow circle is to the right of the small yellow triangle because the circle is in B and B is to the right of A. However, it incorrectly asserts that the small black square is in Block B, which is not supported by the text, leading to an unsupported conclusion about the square's location relative to the triangle.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block B (to the right of A) contains a small black square, a big yellow circle, and two big yellow triangles.
Explanation
The reasoning chain claims Block B contains a small black square. The context only states that a small black square exists, and that it is below the big yellow triangle number two, and the medium yellow circle is to the right of and below it. It never states the small black square is *in* Block B.
Answer Span:
Block B (to the right of A) contains a small black square, a big yellow circle, and two big yellow triangles.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has two big yellow triangles. It also contains a medium yellow circle. This block also has a big yellow circle.
Question #404
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the right of B. Block B is above C. Block A contains a medium blue square. Block B contains a small yellow triangle. And block C contains one medium y...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the right of B. Block B is above C. Block A contains a medium blue square. Block B contains a small yellow triangle. And block C contains one medium yellow square, a big black triangle and a medium black triangle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and near to a small blue square is a medium blue square. This block also has a big blue triangle. The big black triangle is touching the right edge of this block. To the left of and below the medium black triangle is the medium yellow square. The medium blue square is touching the right edge of this block. To the left of the big black triangle is the medium yellow square. Which object is below a small yellow triangle? the medium blue square that is touching the right edge of a block or the medium blue square that is in block A?
(a) the medium blue square that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block B contains the small yellow triangle, and Block C (below B) contains the medium yellow square, big black triangle, and medium black triangle. Block A (to the right of B) contains a medium blue square. Since Block C is directly below Block B, and the medium yellow square is in Block C, only the objects in Block C are below the small yellow triangle in Block B. The medium blue square in Block A is to the right of, not below, the small yellow triangle. Neither of the medium blue squares are below the small yellow triangle.
Answer: {D}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies which blocks contain which objects but makes an unsupported assumption about Block C being *directly* below Block B and incorrectly limits the search space for the final answer based on this assumption. It fails to properly integrate all spatial clues to determine which object is below the small yellow triangle.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block C is directly below Block B, and the medium yellow square is in Block C, only the objects in Block C are below the small yellow triangle in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes Block C is *directly* below Block B, but the context only states 'Block B is above C'. It also incorrectly limits the scope of what is 'below' the small yellow triangle to only objects in Block C, ignoring the possibility of objects in other blocks being below it based on spatial relationships described later in the text.
Answer Span:
Since Block C is directly below Block B, and the medium yellow square is in Block C, only the objects in Block C are below the small yellow triangle in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is above C
Question #941
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the right of and C is to the left of A. Block A has three medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number three which is below a med...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the right of and C is to the left of A. Block A has three medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number three which is below a medium black square there is medium blue square number one. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium blue square number two and the medium black square. Block B has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below medium blue square number two. Block C contains one medium blue square. There is also one medium black square in this block. Below the medium black square is the medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium blue square? medium blue square number three or the medium blue square that is in block C?
(a) medium blue square number three
(b) the medium blue square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has three medium blue squares and a medium black square. Block C, to the left of Block A, has one medium blue square and one medium black square. Since Block C is directly to the left of Block A, and Block C contains a medium blue square, that medium blue square is to the left of the medium blue squares in Block A. Medium blue square number three is *in* Block A, so the medium blue square in Block C is to the left of it.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the components of Block C but makes an unsubstantiated assumption about the adjacency of Block C to Block A, which is not explicitly stated in the context.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C, to the left of Block A, has one medium blue square and one medium black square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes Block C is directly to the left of Block A, but the context only states 'C is to the left of A'. It does not specify the relative position of B, or the exact placement of C relative to A (e.g., immediately adjacent).
Answer Span:
Block C, to the left of Block A, has one medium blue square and one medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the right of and C is to the left of A.
Question #942
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the right of and C is to the left of A. Block A has three medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number three which is below a med...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the right of and C is to the left of A. Block A has three medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number three which is below a medium black square there is medium blue square number one. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium blue square number two and the medium black square. Block B has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below medium blue square number two. Block C contains one medium blue square. There is also one medium black square in this block. Below the medium black square is the medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium blue square? the medium blue square that is in block C or medium blue square number three?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block C
(b) medium blue square number three
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block C contains a medium blue square and Block A contains three medium blue squares, including medium blue square number three. Since Block C is to the left of Block A, the medium blue square in Block C is to the left of all the medium blue squares in Block A, including medium blue square number three.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly uses the positional information (C is to the left of A) to determine which blue square is to the left of the other, directly addressing the question.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1336
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Blocks B and C are below A. Block A contains a medium blue square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Blocks B and C are below A. Block A contains a medium blue square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below a medium black square. Block B contains two medium blue squares. It also contains a medium black square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium black square there is medium blue square number two. Below medium blue square number two and the medium black square there is medium blue square number one. And block C has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square. Below the medium yellow square is medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is below the medium black square number two. Which object is below a yellow shape? the medium black square that is in block A or medium black square number two?
(a) the medium black square that is in block A
(b) medium black square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium blue square below a medium black square. Block B has two medium blue squares and a medium black square. Block C has two medium black squares and a medium yellow square. The question asks what is below the yellow shape (the medium yellow square in block C). In block C, medium black square number two is below the medium yellow square, and medium black square number one is below number two. The medium black square in Block A is not below the yellow shape, as they are in different blocks.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies that medium black square number two is below the yellow shape based on the context. However, it incorrectly states that Block C contains a medium yellow square, which contradicts the context that only specifies Block C contains two medium black squares, with the yellow square being external to it (above one of its contents).
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextlow
Statement
Block A has a medium blue square below a medium black square.
Explanation
The context states that the medium blue square in Block A is *touching the bottom edge* and is *below a medium black square*. The reasoning chain implies a direct vertical stack within A that isn't fully specified, but more importantly, it omits the crucial detail that the object below the medium black square in A is the medium blue square, which is not the object being questioned (the question asks about the medium black square in A). However, the primary issue is the next hallucination regarding Block C's contents.
Answer Span:
Block A has a medium blue square below a medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains a medium blue square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below a medium black square.
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block C has two medium black squares and a medium yellow square.
Explanation
The context states Block C has two medium black squares, but it does not state it contains a medium yellow square. The medium yellow square is *above* medium black square number one in block C, but it is not stated to be *in* block C.
Answer Span:
Block C has two medium black squares and a medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
And block C has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square.
Question #1477
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. It also contains a medium black square. This object is below medium yellow square number two. Below medium ...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. It also contains a medium black square. This object is below medium yellow square number two. Below medium yellow square number two and the medium black square there is medium yellow square number one. To the left of block A we have block B which contains one medium blue square. Finally, we have block C which is below block A. It has two medium black squares. This block also contains one medium blue square. It is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. This shape is below medium black square number two. Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block A?
(a) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium black square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block B has a medium blue square, and Block A (to its right) has a medium black square. Block C, below Block A, also has medium black squares, but since Block A is directly to the right of Block B, the medium black square in Block A is the one to the right of the medium blue square in Block B.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of Block A and Block B and concludes that the medium black square in Block A is to the right of the medium blue square in Block B, which is supported by the context.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #83
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains one medium black square. To the right of block A is block B. It contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the b...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains one medium black square. To the right of block A is block B. It contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below a medium blue square. Below the medium blue square and medium yellow square number two is medium yellow square number one. To the right of block A there is block C. It has a medium black square and one medium yellow square. This block also contains one medium blue square. This shape is below the medium yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square. Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium yellow square number two?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium yellow square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium black square. Block B, to the right of A, has two medium yellow squares, with square one at the bottom and square two below a medium blue square. Block C, also to the right of A, has a medium black square, a medium yellow square, and a medium blue square at the bottom. The question asks what is to the right of the medium black square in Block A. Since both Block B and Block C are to the right of Block A, neither the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of Block B (medium yellow square number one) nor medium yellow square number two (also in Block B) can be individually identified as being directly to the right of the medium black square in Block A. However, Block B as a whole is to the right, and that block *contains* both yellow squares mentioned.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains a significant contradiction regarding the contents and placement of objects in Block C, and it incorrectly narrows the scope of the final question by assuming it only refers to the black square in Block A.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block C, also to the right of A, has a medium black square, a medium yellow square, and a medium blue square at the bottom.
Explanation
The context states the medium black square in Block C is touching the bottom edge, not that the blue square is at the bottom. It also states the medium black square is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square, which contradicts the placement described here.
Answer Span:
Block C, also to the right of A, has a medium black square, a medium yellow square, and a medium blue square at the bottom.
Reference/Question Span:
It has a medium black square and one medium yellow square. This block also contains one medium blue square. This shape is below the medium yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The question asks what is to the right of the medium black square in Block A.
Explanation
The question asks which object is to the right of *a* medium black square, not specifically the one in Block A. There is a medium black square in Block A and one in Block C. The reasoning chain incorrectly limits the scope to only the black square in Block A.
Answer Span:
The question asks what is to the right of the medium black square in Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium yellow square number two?
Question #298
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are a medium blue circle, one big yellow square and one medium black square in block A. Below the medium black square which is to the right of a bi...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are a medium blue circle, one big yellow square and one medium black square in block A. Below the medium black square which is to the right of a big blue square is the big yellow square. It is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is touching the left edge of this block.. The medium blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. It is above the big yellow square. It is below and to the right of the medium black square. Block B is below block A. It has a small black triangle and one small black square. To the right of the small black square there is the small black triangle. Finally, there is block C above block B. It has one small yellow square. It also has one medium blue triangle. The medium blue triangle is to the right of and below the small yellow square. What is to the right of the small yellow square? a medium blue triangle or a small black square?
(a) medium blue triangle
(b) small black square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block C contains the small yellow square and the medium blue triangle. The medium blue triangle is explicitly stated to be to the right of the small yellow square. The small black square is in Block B, which is below Block C and therefore not to the right of the small yellow square.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: excellent
The reasoning correctly identifies the relevant information from Block C to answer the question about what is to the right of the small yellow square.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1221
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A is above B. Block A contains a medium black square. A medium blue square is also in this block. The medium black square is touching the bottom edg...
2 issues
Full Question
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A is above B. Block A contains a medium black square. A medium blue square is also in this block. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square. Block B contains two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares. Below medium blue square number two is medium blue square number one. Below medium black square number two and medium blue square number two there is medium black square number one. Medium black square number two is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium black square number two. Which object is below a medium blue square? the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue square that is in block A?
(a) the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium blue square and a medium black square. Block B, below Block A, contains two medium blue squares (number one below number two) and two medium black squares (number one below number two). The question asks what is below *a* medium blue square. This could refer to either the medium blue square in Block A or the medium blue square number two in Block B.
The medium blue square in Block A has the medium black square below it. Medium blue square number two in Block B has medium black square number two below it. The prompt also says that medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. Therefore, both medium blue squares have something below them. The medium blue square touching the bottom edge of a block (medium blue square number one in Block B) is below medium blue square number two. The medium black square is below the medium blue square that is in Block A.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in each block and attempts to answer the question by checking which blue squares have objects below them. However, the description of what is below the blue square in Block A is slightly convoluted and misses the precise context structure, although the final conclusion about what is below the blue squares seems correct based on the overall context.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The medium blue square in Block A has the medium black square below it.
Explanation
The context states: 'The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block [A]. This shape is below the medium blue square.' This means the medium black square is below the medium blue square in Block A, but the reasoning chain incorrectly implies the medium black square is *below* the medium blue square without confirming the relationship based on the specific text structure.
Answer Span:
The medium blue square in Block A has the medium black square below it.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains a medium black square. A medium blue square is also in this block. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square.
missing_contextlow
Statement
The medium black square is below the medium blue square that is in Block A.
Explanation
The context states: 'The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block [A]. This shape is below the medium blue square.' This confirms the medium black square is below the medium blue square in Block A, but the reasoning chain presents this as a derived fact without explicitly linking it to the structure provided in the context for Block A.
Answer Span:
The medium black square is below the medium blue square that is in Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains a medium black square. A medium blue square is also in this block. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square.
Question #3041
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of C. Block C is to the left of A. Block A has three medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below medium ye...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of C. Block C is to the left of A. Block A has three medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two and a medium black square. Medium yellow square number two is below medium yellow square number three and the medium black square. The medium black square is below medium yellow square number three. Block B contains one medium blue square. And block C has a medium blue square and a medium black square. There is also one medium yellow square in this block. This shape is below the medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square and the medium black square. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is in block C or the medium black square that is in block A?
(a) the medium black square that is in block C
(b) the medium black square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block C contains a medium yellow square and a medium black square, with the yellow square below the black square. Block A contains three medium yellow squares and a medium black square. Since Block C is to the left of Block A, the medium black square in Block C is to the left of the medium yellow squares in Block A. The medium black square in Block A is not to the left of the medium yellow squares, it's within the same block and above some of them.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the blocks (C left of A) and uses this to compare the black square in C to the yellow squares in A. However, it incorrectly asserts that Block A contains a medium black square, which is not explicitly stated in the context.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block A contains three medium yellow squares and a medium black square.
Explanation
The context states Block A has three medium yellow squares, but it does not mention a medium black square in Block A. The description of the medium black square's location is only relative to the yellow squares within Block A, not stating it is *in* Block A.
Answer Span:
Block A contains three medium yellow squares and a medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has three medium yellow squares.
Question #3119
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. There are one big yellow triangle, one big black circle and one medium black triangle in block A. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of t...
3 issues
Full Question
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. There are one big yellow triangle, one big black circle and one medium black triangle in block A. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. A big black square is touching the right edge of this block. To the right of the big black circle and the medium black triangle there is the big yellow triangle. The big black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is far from, to the left of and below the big black square. Above block A there is block B. It contains one medium yellow circle and a small black circle. It also contains one big blue triangle. The big blue triangle is to the right of and below the medium yellow circle which is to the right of the small black circle. What is to the right of the small object? a medium black triangle or a big blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium black triangle
(b) big blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a small black circle, a medium black triangle, and a big black circle. Block B contains a small black circle and a big blue triangle. The small black circle in Block B is to the left of the medium yellow circle, and the big blue triangle is to the right of the small black circle and below the medium yellow circle. Since the question asks what is to the right of the small object (small black circle), and the big blue triangle is to the right of the small black circle in Block B, the answer is the big blue triangle. Note that the big blue triangle is not touching the bottom edge of a block.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains multiple factual errors regarding the contents of Block A and Block B, and makes an unsupported assertion about the location of the big blue triangle, directly impacting the evaluation of option (b).
Detected Issues (3)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block A contains a small black circle, a medium black triangle, and a big black circle.
Explanation
The context states Block A contains: one big yellow triangle, one big black circle and one medium black triangle. It does not mention a small black circle in Block A.
Answer Span:
Block A contains a small black circle, a medium black triangle, and a big black circle.
Reference/Question Span:
There are one big yellow triangle, one big black circle and one medium black triangle in block A.
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block B contains a small black circle and a big blue triangle.
Explanation
The context states Block B contains: one medium yellow circle and a small black circle. It also contains one big blue triangle. The reasoning incorrectly omits the medium yellow circle from Block B's contents.
Answer Span:
Block B contains a small black circle and a big blue triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
Above block A there is block B. It contains one medium yellow circle and a small black circle. It also contains one big blue triangle.
contradictionhigh
Statement
Note that the big blue triangle is not touching the bottom edge of a block.
Explanation
The question asks if the object to the right of the small object is 'a big blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block?'. The reasoning asserts the big blue triangle is *not* touching the bottom edge, which contradicts the possibility presented in option (b) and is an unsupported assertion, as the context only specifies the big yellow triangle touches the bottom edge of Block A, and provides no information about the big blue triangle's vertical placement relative to the bottom edge of Block B.
Answer Span:
Note that the big blue triangle is not touching the bottom edge of a block.
Reference/Question Span:
a big blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #1495
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are three medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are three medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below medium black square number three. Below medium black square number two and medium black square number three is medium black square number one. Above block A is block B. It contains one medium blue square and one medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium black square. Finally, there is block C. It is above block B. It has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium black square which is in block B or the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium black square which is in block B
(b) the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains three medium black squares, with square number one touching the bottom edge. Block B, above A, contains a medium blue square and a medium black square. Block C, above B, contains two medium yellow squares. Since Block B is directly below Block C (which contains the medium yellow squares), the medium black square in Block B is below the medium yellow squares. The medium black square touching the bottom edge of a block is in Block A, which is not directly below the yellow squares.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the blocks and squares and uses this information to determine which object is below a medium yellow square. It correctly concludes that the black square in Block B is below the yellow squares (in Block C), while the black square touching the bottom edge (in Block A) is not.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #920
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are one medium yellow circle and a big blue circle in block A. This block also contains one medium blue triangle. This shape is above, to the rig...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are one medium yellow circle and a big blue circle in block A. This block also contains one medium blue triangle. This shape is above, to the right of and far from the big blue circle. To the left of block A we have block B. It contains one small black square and one medium yellow square. Above the medium yellow square there is the small black square. Finally, there is block C to the left of block B. It has two small blue squares. It also has a medium black triangle. It is below small blue square number two. Small blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of and below small blue square number two. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? the triangle that is touching the right edge of a block or the square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the triangle that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block B contains a medium yellow square and a small black square. Block C, to the left of Block B, contains two small blue squares and a medium black triangle. Small blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of Block C. Since Block C is to the left of Block B, and small blue square number one (touching the bottom edge) is in Block C, it is to the left of the medium yellow square.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the location of the square touching the bottom edge (small blue square number one in Block C) and correctly deduces its position relative to the medium yellow square in Block B, leading to the correct choice (b).
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1280
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains one medium blue square and one medium yellow square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the med...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains one medium blue square and one medium yellow square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium yellow square. Block B is to the right of block A. It contains one medium blue square. A medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. Finally, there is block C. It is below block B. It has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium blue square number two and a medium black square there is medium blue square number one. The medium black square is below medium blue square number two. Which object is above a medium blue square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is in block A?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium yellow square above a medium blue square. Block B contains a medium blue square above a medium yellow square. Block C contains two medium blue squares and a medium black square. The question asks what is above *a* medium blue square. The medium yellow square in Block A is above a medium blue square, and the medium blue square in Block B is above a medium yellow square. Therefore, the medium yellow square in Block A is above a medium blue square.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that the medium yellow square in Block A is above a medium blue square, which is the key fact needed to answer the question correctly (Option B). However, it contains a factual error/misinterpretation regarding the relative positions in Block B, although this error did not derail the final selection based on Block A's contents.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block B contains a medium blue square above a medium yellow square.
Explanation
The context states that in Block B, the medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge and is *below* the medium blue square. This means the medium blue square is above the medium yellow square, which contradicts the reasoning's claim that the blue square is above the yellow square (which is true) but then incorrectly implies the yellow square is below the blue square in a way that contradicts the structure described for Block A.
Answer Span:
Block B contains a medium blue square above a medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the right of block A. It contains one medium blue square. A medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square.
contradictionlow
Statement
The medium yellow square in Block A is above a medium blue square
Explanation
The context explicitly states for Block A: 'The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium yellow square.' This means the medium blue square is below the medium yellow square, or the medium yellow square is above the medium blue square. The reasoning states this correctly, but the previous statement about Block B was flawed, and this statement is used to support the final conclusion.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow square in Block A is above a medium blue square
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains one medium blue square and one medium yellow square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium yellow square.
Question #278
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square. Above block A we have block B which contains two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square nu...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square. Above block A we have block B which contains two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. Below the square which is below medium blue square number two there is a medium black square. Below medium blue square number two is a medium yellow square.. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium blue square number two and the medium yellow square. Finally, we have block C below block B. It has one medium yellow square and one medium blue square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. Which object is above a medium blue square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is in block B?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium blue square. Block B (above A) has two medium blue squares, with number two above number one, a medium yellow square below blue square number two, and a medium black square below both the yellow square and blue square number one. Block C (below B) has a medium yellow square and a medium blue square, with the yellow square below the blue square. The question asks what is above *a* medium blue square. The medium yellow square in Block B is above a medium blue square (number one). The medium blue square in Block C is above the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of Block C.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains significant hallucinations regarding the contents and spatial relationships within Block B, incorrectly placing a yellow square in Block B and misstating which objects are above which blue squares in that block. This directly impacts the evaluation of option (b).
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
a medium yellow square below blue square number two, and a medium black square below both the yellow square and blue square number one.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly places the medium yellow square in Block B and misrepresents the relationship between the yellow square, black square, and blue square number two within Block B. The context states: 'Below medium blue square number two is a medium yellow square.' and 'Below the square which is below medium blue square number two there is a medium black square.' The reasoning implies the yellow square is below blue square number two, but then adds the black square is below *both* the yellow square and blue square number one, which is not supported or is an inaccurate synthesis of the complex layering described.
Answer Span:
a medium yellow square below blue square number two, and a medium black square below both the yellow square and blue square number one.
Reference/Question Span:
Below medium blue square number two is a medium yellow square.. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium blue square number two and the medium yellow square.
contradictionhigh
Statement
The medium yellow square in Block B is above a medium blue square (number one).
Explanation
The context states that Block B contains two medium blue squares, with number two above number one. It does not state that any yellow square is *in* Block B, nor does it state that a yellow square is above blue square number one. The yellow square mentioned in relation to Block B's contents is the one below blue square number two, which is then followed by the black square.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow square in Block B is above a medium blue square (number one).
Reference/Question Span:
Above block A we have block B which contains two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. Below the square which is below medium blue square number two there is a medium black square. Below medium blue square number two is a medium yellow square.
Question #1281
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A contains one medium black triangle. This block also has one small black triangle. Near to and above the small black triangle is the medium black t...
1 issue
Full Question
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A contains one medium black triangle. This block also has one small black triangle. Near to and above the small black triangle is the medium black triangle. Block B is below block A. It contains one small blue triangle, one big black square and a medium blue square. This block also has a medium black triangle. The medium blue square is touching the right edge of this block. It is below and to the right of the medium black triangle. The big black square is below the medium black triangle. It is to the left of the medium object which is below the medium black triangle. To the left of the medium blue square is the small blue triangle. The big black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Which object is below a small black triangle? the medium black triangle that is in block A or the medium black triangle that is in block B?
(a) the medium black triangle that is in block A
(b) the medium black triangle that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a small black triangle and a medium black triangle above it. Block B, below Block A, contains a medium black triangle as well. Since Block B is directly below Block A, the object below the small black triangle in Block A is the medium black triangle in Block B.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes the spatial relationship between objects in different blocks based only on the block positions, ignoring the specific relative positioning given for the objects within Block A. The context only states the medium black triangle is near to and above the small black triangle *within* Block A.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B is directly below Block A, the object below the small black triangle in Block A is the medium black triangle in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes that because Block B is below Block A, the object below the small black triangle (which is in Block A) must be an object in Block B. However, the question asks which object is below the small black triangle, and the context only specifies the relative position of the two triangles *within* Block A: 'Near to and above the small black triangle is the medium black triangle.' It does not state that the medium black triangle in Block B is below the small black triangle in Block A. The reasoning ignores the internal positioning within Block A and makes an unsupported leap based only on the block positions.
Answer Span:
the object below the small black triangle in Block A is the medium black triangle in Block B
Reference/Question Span:
Near to and above the small black triangle is the medium black triangle.
Question #1835
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the right of C. Block C is below B. Block A has a medium blue square. It also has one medium yellow square. Below the medium blue square there is the me...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the right of C. Block C is below B. Block A has a medium blue square. It also has one medium yellow square. Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square. Block B contains a medium yellow square. Block C contains two medium blue squares and two other medium yellow squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium blue square number two. Below medium yellow square number two is medium yellow square number one.. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two , medium yellow square number two and medium yellow square number one. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block C contains two medium yellow squares and two medium blue squares. Block A, which is to the right of Block C, contains a medium blue square and a medium yellow square. The medium blue square in Block A is above the medium yellow square. Since Block A is to the right of Block C, the medium blue square in Block A is to the right of the medium yellow squares in Block C. The medium blue square touching the bottom edge of Block C is not to the right of the medium yellow square in Block A.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains a direct contradiction regarding the relative positions of squares in Block A and makes an irrelevant comparison when evaluating the second option, failing to properly determine which object is to the right of a medium yellow square.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The medium blue square in Block A is above the medium yellow square.
Explanation
The context states: 'Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square' in Block A, meaning the yellow square is below the blue square, not the other way around.
Answer Span:
The medium blue square in Block A is above the medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The medium blue square touching the bottom edge of Block C is not to the right of the medium yellow square in Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning chain attempts to evaluate the second option ('the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block') but incorrectly assumes this square is in Block C and then compares it to a square in Block A. The question asks if the blue square touching the bottom edge (which is in C) is to the right of *a* medium yellow square. The reasoning chain fails to establish the relative positions needed to answer the question for the second option, instead making an irrelevant comparison.
Answer Span:
The medium blue square touching the bottom edge of Block C is not to the right of the medium yellow square in Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #3587
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is above C and block C is below B. Block A contains two small yellow triangles. Small yellow triangle number one is to the left of small yellow triangle numbe...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is above C and block C is below B. Block A contains two small yellow triangles. Small yellow triangle number one is to the left of small yellow triangle number two and a big black triangle. Above and near to small yellow triangle number two is the big black triangle. Block B contains a medium black square. And block C contains two small blue triangles. This block also contains a big black triangle. It is far from, below and to the right of small blue triangle number one. This block also has a small black square. A medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Small blue triangle number two is touching the left edge of this block. There is also one medium blue square in this block. The medium black triangle is to the left of the medium blue square. It is below small blue triangle number one. What is below the medium black square? a medium blue square or a small black square?
(a) medium blue square
(b) small black square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block B contains the medium black square, and Block C (below B) contains a small black square and a medium blue square. Since Block C is directly below Block B, the objects below the medium black square are the contents of Block C.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning correctly identifies where the medium black square (Block B) and the potential answers (Block C contents) are located. However, it makes an unsupported leap by assuming that the contents of Block C are automatically 'below' the medium black square in Block B simply because C is below B. The reasoning chain fails to use the specific spatial relationships given for the objects *within* Block C to answer the final question, which asks what is below the medium black square (which is in B). The question is ambiguous (is it asking what is physically below the square, or what objects are in the block below the block containing the square?), but the reasoning chain ignores the detailed spatial data provided for the objects in C, which is crucial context.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block C is directly below Block B, the objects below the medium black square are the contents of Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes that because C is below B, the contents of C are automatically below the contents of B. While C is below B, the question asks what is below the *medium black square* (which is in B). The reasoning ignores the spatial relationships described within Block C itself, which are necessary to determine what is below the medium black square if it is assumed to be resting on the contents of C, or if the question implies vertical stacking of objects within the blocks.
Answer Span:
Since Block C is directly below Block B, the objects below the medium black square are the contents of Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B contains a medium black square. And block C contains two small blue triangles. This block also contains a big black triangle. It is far from, below and to the right of small blue triangle number one. This block also has a small black square. A medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Small blue triangle number two is touching the left edge of this block. There is also one medium blue square in this block. The medium black triangle is to the left of the medium blue square. It is below small blue triangle number one.
Question #2014
We have three blocks, A, B and C. A big yellow square is in block A. Block B is to the left of block A. It has a small yellow square and a big black square. To the left of a medium black square there ...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. A big yellow square is in block A. Block B is to the left of block A. It has a small yellow square and a big black square. To the left of a medium black square there is the big black square. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black square is touching the right edge of this block. Above the big black square and the medium black square is the small yellow square. To the right of block B there is block C. It has one big blue circle, one small blue circle and a medium black circle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. To the right of the medium black circle there is the small blue circle.. To the right of and above the small blue circle there is the big blue circle. What is to the right of the small yellow square? a small blue circle or a big blue circle that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) small blue circle
(b) big blue circle that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block B contains the small yellow square, and Block C (to the right of Block B) contains the small blue circle and the big blue circle. Since the small blue circle is to the left of the big blue circle (which is touching the right edge of Block C), and both are in the block to the right of the small yellow square, both are to the right of the small yellow square.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an incorrect assertion about the location of the small yellow square and fails to establish the necessary spatial adjacency required to answer the question about what is immediately to the right of the small yellow square, relying instead on block adjacency.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block B contains the small yellow square
Explanation
The context states that Block A has the big yellow square, and Block B has a small yellow square and a big black square. The reasoning incorrectly implies the small yellow square is the only yellow square in B, or misrepresents the location of the yellow squares relative to the blocks.
Answer Span:
Block B contains the small yellow square
Reference/Question Span:
A big yellow square is in block A. Block B is to the left of block A. It has a small yellow square and a big black square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since the small blue circle is to the left of the big blue circle (which is touching the right edge of Block C), and both are in the block to the right of the small yellow square, both are to the right of the small yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes that because Block C is to the right of Block B (which contains the small yellow square), everything in Block C is immediately to the right of the small yellow square. The context only establishes relative block positions (B left of A, C right of B). It does not state that the small yellow square in B is immediately adjacent to Block C, nor does it establish the precise spatial relationship between the small yellow square (in B) and the contents of C relative to the question: 'What is to the right of the small yellow square?'. The reasoning skips the necessary step of determining what is immediately to the right of the small yellow square within Block B, or what is immediately adjacent to Block B.
Answer Span:
Since the small blue circle is to the left of the big blue circle (which is touching the right edge of Block C), and both are in the block to the right of the small yellow square, both are to the right of the small yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the right of the small yellow square? a small blue circle or a big blue circle that is touching the right edge of a block?
Question #1387
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are three medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square nu...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are three medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number two. A medium yellow square is also in this block. This object is below medium black square number three. It is below the black object which is below medium black square number three. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number one. It is below medium black square number two. Above block A there is block B which has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. To the right of block A there is block C which has one medium blue square. Which object is below a medium blue square? the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the yellow shape?
(a) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the yellow shape
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains three medium black squares and a medium yellow square. Medium black square number one touches the bottom edge. Block B, above A, contains two medium blue squares. Since the question asks what is below a medium blue square, and the medium blue squares are in Block B which is above Block A, both the medium black square touching the bottom edge (number one) and the medium yellow square (both in A) are below the medium blue squares.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly concludes that everything in Block A is below the blue squares in Block B simply because B is above A. It ignores the complex internal vertical relationships described within Block A and fails to establish any direct vertical relationship between the objects in A and the blue squares in B, which is necessary to answer the question.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since the question asks what is below a medium blue square, and the medium blue squares are in Block B which is above Block A, both the medium black square touching the bottom edge (number one) and the medium yellow square (both in A) are below the medium blue squares.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes that because Block B is above Block A, everything in Block A is below the blue squares in Block B. However, the context only states Block B is *above* Block A. It does not establish the vertical relationship between specific objects in A (like the yellow square or black square 1) and the blue squares in B, only that B is above A. Furthermore, the reasoning chain fails to check the specific vertical relationships given for the objects within Block A itself, which are crucial for determining what is below what.
Answer Span:
both the medium black square touching the bottom edge (number one) and the medium yellow square (both in A) are below the medium blue squares
Reference/Question Span:
Above block A there is block B which has two medium blue squares.
Question #1810
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are a medium black circle and a big black square in block A. To the right of the big black square is the medium black circle. This object is to the...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are a medium black circle and a big black square in block A. To the right of the big black square is the medium black circle. This object is to the left of a medium yellow triangle which is to the right of the big black square. Block B is to the left of block A. It contains a medium yellow circle, one big blue square and a small yellow triangle. There is also a small yellow square in this block. The medium yellow circle is near to the big blue square which is near to and to the right of the small yellow triangle.. The small yellow triangle is above and near to the small yellow square. To the right of block A there is block C. It has one medium blue circle and one big yellow triangle. The medium blue circle is to the left of, near to and below the big yellow triangle. Which object is to the left of a medium blue circle? the small yellow square or the medium black circle?
(a) the small yellow square
(b) the medium black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium black circle and a big black square. Block B, to the left of Block A, contains a small yellow square. Block C, to the right of Block A, contains a medium blue circle. The question asks what is to the left of the medium blue circle. Since Block A is to the left of Block C, and the medium black circle is in Block A, the medium black circle is to the left of the medium blue circle. The small yellow square is in Block B, which is to the left of Block A, so it is not directly to the left of the medium blue circle.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the location of the medium black circle (Block A) relative to the medium blue circle (Block C) and concludes it is to the left. However, it incorrectly dismisses the small yellow square (Block B) without properly assessing its position relative to Block C, leading to an incomplete evaluation of the options.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The small yellow square is in Block B, which is to the left of Block A, so it is not directly to the left of the medium blue circle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain fails to establish the relative position between the small yellow square (in Block B) and the medium blue circle (in Block C) based on the block arrangement (B is left of A, C is right of A). It incorrectly concludes it is 'not directly to the left' without checking if Block B is positioned to the left of Block C, which it must be.
Answer Span:
The small yellow square is in Block B, which is to the left of Block A, so it is not directly to the left of the medium blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the left of block A. . . To the right of block A there is block C.
Question #859
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. A medium yellow square is in block A. Then, there is block B. It contains two medium black squares and two other medium blue squares. Below medium bl...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. A medium yellow square is in block A. Then, there is block B. It contains two medium black squares and two other medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number one which is below medium blue square number two is medium black square number one. Below medium black square number two there is medium blue square number two. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and medium blue square number two. Finally, to the right of block B we have block C which is above block A. It contains one medium black square and a medium yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square. Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium black square number two?
(a) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium black square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block B contains two medium blue squares and two medium black squares. Block C, to the right of Block B, contains a medium black square touching the bottom edge and a medium yellow square above it. Since Block C is to the right of Block B (which contains the medium blue squares), the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block C is to the right of the medium blue squares in Block B. Medium black square number two is also in Block B, not to the right of the medium blue squares.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies that the black square in Block C is to the right of the blue squares in Block B. However, it incorrectly dismisses medium black square number two without analyzing its spatial relationship to the blue squares as defined in the context, relying only on the fact that it is in Block B.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Medium black square number two is also in Block B, not to the right of the medium blue squares.
Explanation
The reasoning chain fails to establish the relative positions of objects *within* Block B, specifically where medium black square number two is relative to the medium blue squares. The question provides specific vertical relationships for the objects in Block B (e.g., 'Below medium black square number one is medium black square number two and medium blue square number two'), but the reasoning ignores these internal spatial constraints when assessing if medium black square number two is to the right of a medium blue square. The reasoning only states it's 'in Block B', which is insufficient to rule it out based on the provided context.
Answer Span:
Medium black square number two is also in Block B, not to the right of the medium blue squares.
Reference/Question Span:
Below medium blue square number one which is below medium blue square number two is medium black square number one. Below medium black square number two there is medium blue square number two. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and medium blue square number two.
Question #1282
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A contains one medium black triangle. This block also has one small black triangle. Near to and above the small black triangle is the medium black t...
Clean
Full Question
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A contains one medium black triangle. This block also has one small black triangle. Near to and above the small black triangle is the medium black triangle. Block B is below block A. It contains one small blue triangle, one big black square and a medium blue square. This block also has a medium black triangle. The medium blue square is touching the right edge of this block. It is below and to the right of the medium black triangle. The big black square is below the medium black triangle. It is to the left of the medium object which is below the medium black triangle. To the left of the medium blue square is the small blue triangle. The big black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Which object is below a medium black triangle? the big black thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the small blue triangle?
(a) the big black thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the small blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium black triangle. Block B, below Block A, contains a big black square touching the bottom edge, a small blue triangle, a medium blue square, and a medium black triangle. The big black square is below the medium black triangle in Block B. The small blue triangle is also in Block B, but it's to the left of the medium blue square and not directly below the medium black triangle in Block B. The medium black triangle in Block A is above Block B, so the objects below it would be in Block B. The big black square is directly below the medium black triangle in Block B.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in Block B and uses the positional information provided in the context to determine which object is below the medium black triangle in Block B, which is the relevant location for objects below the medium black triangle in Block A.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #761
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one medium blue circle. One medium blue square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue circle is the medium blu...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one medium blue circle. One medium blue square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue circle is the medium blue square. Block B is below block A. It contains a small blue triangle, a medium yellow square and a medium blue circle. The small blue triangle is to the left of the medium yellow square and a big black square. The medium yellow square is to the left of the big black square. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. To the left of block B there is block C with two medium black circles in it. Medium black circle number one is below and touching a small yellow square. Medium black circle number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of and near to medium black circle number two is medium black circle number one. What is above the small blue thing? a small yellow square or a medium blue circle?
(a) small yellow square
(b) medium blue circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium blue circle and a medium blue square. Block B, which is below Block A, contains a small blue triangle. Since Block A is directly above Block B, and the medium blue circle is in Block A, the object above the small blue triangle is the medium blue circle. The small yellow square is in Block C, which is to the left of Block B, not above it.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the medium blue circle is above the small blue triangle (the 'small blue thing'). However, it fails to fully integrate the context regarding the small yellow square's location relative to the small blue triangle, leading to an incomplete evaluation of the options presented in the question.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The small yellow square is in Block C, which is to the left of Block B, not above it.
Explanation
The reasoning correctly identifies that the small yellow square is in Block C, but it fails to check if the small yellow square is *above* the 'small blue thing' (the small blue triangle in Block B), which is the core of the question. The question asks what is above the small blue thing (the small blue triangle). The reasoning correctly identifies the medium blue circle is above the small blue triangle, but it dismisses the small yellow square without checking its vertical relationship to the small blue triangle, which is necessary to answer the final question.
Answer Span:
The small yellow square is in Block C, which is to the left of Block B, not above it.
Reference/Question Span:
What is above the small blue thing? a small yellow square or a medium blue circle?
missing_contextlow
Statement
Since Block A is directly above Block B, and the medium blue circle is in Block A, the object above the small blue triangle is the medium blue circle.
Explanation
The reasoning correctly identifies that the medium blue circle is above the small blue triangle (which is the 'small blue thing' based on the context provided for Block B). However, the reasoning stops here and doesn't fully address the structure of the question which asks to compare the vertical relationship of *both* options (small yellow square and medium blue circle) relative to the 'small blue thing'. The reasoning implies the medium blue circle is the only relevant object above the small blue triangle, but it doesn't explicitly check the vertical relationship of the small yellow square to the small blue triangle, which is necessary to evaluate option (c) 'both of them'.
Answer Span:
Since Block A is directly above Block B, and the medium blue circle is in Block A, the object above the small blue triangle is the medium blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
What is above the small blue thing? a small yellow square or a medium blue circle?
Question #2503
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the right of block A and to the left of block C. Block A has one small blue circle. This block also has a medium yellow square. The med...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the right of block A and to the left of block C. Block A has one small blue circle. This block also has a medium yellow square. The medium yellow square is to the right of the small blue circle. Block B contains one small yellow triangle, a medium yellow square and a medium blue triangle. To the left of and above the medium yellow square is the small yellow triangle. Near to the medium blue triangle is a small black triangle. The medium blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. Above and to the right of the small yellow triangle is the small black triangle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. And block C contains a small blue circle. Which object is to the right of a medium blue triangle? the small blue circle which is in block C or the small blue circle which is in block A?
(a) the small blue circle which is in block C
(b) the small blue circle which is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A has a small blue circle and a medium yellow square. Block B has a small yellow triangle, a medium yellow square, and a medium blue triangle touching the right edge. Block C has a small blue circle. Since Block C is to the right of Block B, and the medium blue triangle is on the right edge of Block B, the small blue circle in Block C is to the right of the medium blue triangle.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the relevant objects and their locations based on the provided context to answer the question.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #531
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of B. Block C is to the left of A. Block A has one medium yellow triangle. Block B has a medium black circle. And block C has a...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of B. Block C is to the left of A. Block A has one medium yellow triangle. Block B has a medium black circle. And block C has a big yellow circle. One big blue triangle is also touching the bottom edge of this block. A medium black circle is to the right of a small blue circle. To the left of the big yellow circle there is the small blue circle. The big yellow circle is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue triangle is below the circle which is to the left of the big yellow circle. To the left of and below the big yellow circle is the medium black circle. To the right of the black shape which is to the right of the small blue circle is the big blue triangle. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow triangle? the small object or the big yellow circle that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the small object
(b) the big yellow circle that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium yellow triangle. Block B, to the left of A, has a medium black circle. Block C, to the left of A, has a big yellow circle touching the right edge. So, the big yellow circle in Block C is to the left of the medium yellow triangle in Block A. The small blue circle is also in Block C, to the left of the big yellow circle. Therefore, both the big yellow circle and the small blue circle are to the left of the medium yellow triangle. However, the question asks for "the small object or the big yellow circle". The "small object" refers to the small blue circle.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the blocks and objects based on the context, leading to a conclusion that addresses the final question structure.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2233
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains a medium blue square. To the right of block A we have block B with two medium blue squares in it. Medium blue square number one is touch...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains a medium blue square. To the right of block A we have block B with two medium blue squares in it. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below medium blue square number two. Finally, there is block C. It is above block A. It has two medium yellow squares. Below a medium blue square is medium yellow square number one. There is also one medium black square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two , medium yellow square number one and the medium blue square is the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Which object is above a medium blue square? the medium blue square that is in block C or the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block C
(b) the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium blue square. Block B, to the right of A, has two medium blue squares, with number one on the bottom and number two above it. Block C, above Block A, has medium yellow squares, a medium blue square, and a medium black square at the bottom. The question asks what is above *a* medium blue square. This is ambiguous, but since Block B is to the right of Block A and contains two medium blue squares, one above the other, then medium blue square number two is above medium blue square number one. Since block C is above Block A which has a medium blue square, then the medium blue square in block C is also above a medium blue square (namely, the one in block A).
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly asserts that Block C contains a medium blue square, which contradicts the provided context. This error leads to an incorrect justification for one of the potential answers.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block C, above Block A, has medium yellow squares, a medium blue square, and a medium black square at the bottom.
Explanation
The context states Block C has two medium yellow squares and one medium black square touching the bottom edge. It does not state Block C has a medium blue square.
Answer Span:
Block C, above Block A, has medium yellow squares, a medium blue square, and a medium black square at the bottom.
Reference/Question Span:
Finally, there is block C. It is above block A. It has two medium yellow squares. Below a medium blue square is medium yellow square number one. There is also one medium black square touching the bottom edge of this block.
contradictionhigh
Statement
Since block C is above Block A which has a medium blue square, then the medium blue square in block C is also above a medium blue square (namely, the one in block A).
Explanation
This statement relies on the false premise established in the previous hallucination that Block C contains a medium blue square. The context does not support that Block C has a medium blue square.
Answer Span:
then the medium blue square in block C is also above a medium blue square (namely, the one in block A).
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains a medium blue square. . . Finally, there is block C. It is above block A. It has two medium yellow squares.
Question #3118
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. There are one big yellow triangle, one big black circle and one medium black triangle in block A. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of t...
2 issues
Full Question
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. There are one big yellow triangle, one big black circle and one medium black triangle in block A. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. A big black square is touching the right edge of this block. To the right of the big black circle and the medium black triangle there is the big yellow triangle. The big black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is far from, to the left of and below the big black square. Above block A there is block B. It contains one medium yellow circle and a small black circle. It also contains one big blue triangle. The big blue triangle is to the right of and below the medium yellow circle which is to the right of the small black circle. What is above the big yellow triangle? a big black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a medium yellow circle?
(a) big black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium yellow circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains the big yellow triangle, and Block B (above Block A) contains the medium yellow circle. Since the big yellow triangle is in Block A and Block B is directly above Block A, the object above the big yellow triangle is the medium yellow circle. The big black circle is also in Block A, below the big black square and to the left of the big yellow triangle.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning correctly identifies that Block B is above Block A and that the medium yellow circle is in Block B. However, it incorrectly concludes that the medium yellow circle must be 'above' the big yellow triangle without any contextual support for vertical alignment between specific objects in different blocks. It also includes an irrelevant and potentially misleading statement about the location of the big black circle.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The big black circle is also in Block A, below the big black square and to the left of the big yellow triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly places the big black circle relative to the big black square and big yellow triangle in a way that implies a vertical relationship ('below') when the context only describes horizontal/positional relationships within Block A, and the question asks what is *above* the big yellow triangle (which implies vertical stacking between blocks). More importantly, the reasoning uses the location of the big black circle in Block A to dismiss it as an answer, but the question asks what is *above* the big yellow triangle, which requires checking Block B.
Answer Span:
The big black circle is also in Block A, below the big black square and to the left of the big yellow triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
What is above the big yellow triangle?
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since the big yellow triangle is in Block A and Block B is directly above Block A, the object above the big yellow triangle is the medium yellow circle.
Explanation
While Block B is above Block A, the reasoning chain incorrectly assumes that *any* object in Block B is directly above the big yellow triangle in Block A. The context does not specify the vertical alignment between the big yellow triangle in A and the medium yellow circle in B. The reasoning chain ignores the need to check for specific vertical alignment between the two objects.
Answer Span:
Since the big yellow triangle is in Block A and Block B is directly above Block A, the object above the big yellow triangle is the medium yellow circle.
Reference/Question Span:
What is above the big yellow triangle?
Question #3151
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Th...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Then, we have block B with two medium yellow squares in it. A medium black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black square is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Finally, to the right of block A we have block C. It is to the right of block B. It contains one medium blue square. There is also one medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the black thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue square?
(a) the black thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A has two medium yellow squares, with number one on the bottom. Block B also has two medium yellow squares and a medium black square touching the bottom edge. Block C has a medium blue square and a medium yellow square touching the bottom edge, with the blue square above the yellow one. The question asks what is below *a* medium yellow square. Since the prompt doesn't specify which medium yellow square, we need to consider all of them. In Block A, medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom, so nothing is below it. In Block B, the medium black square is below both medium yellow squares. In Block C, the medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge, so nothing is below it. However, the medium blue square is above *a* medium yellow square (the one in Block C). Thus, the medium blue square is below a medium yellow square (square number two in Block B).
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes incorrect assumptions about what is below objects touching the bottom edge and fabricates a relationship between the blue square in Block C and a yellow square in Block B, leading to an incorrect justification for the final answer choice.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
In Block A, medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom, so nothing is below it.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes that because square number one is touching the bottom edge of Block A, nothing is below it. This ignores the possibility that the question is asking about the relative positions *within* the block structure described, not just what is physically below the bottom edge of the block itself. More importantly, the context does not state that nothing is below it, it only states its position relative to square two.
Answer Span:
In Block A, medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom, so nothing is below it.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block.
contradictionhigh
Statement
Thus, the medium blue square is below a medium yellow square (square number two in Block B).
Explanation
The reasoning concludes that the medium blue square is below medium yellow square number two (from Block B). The context explicitly states that the medium blue square is in Block C, and the objects below it are the medium yellow square in Block C. It is never stated that the blue square in C is below any square in B.
Answer Span:
Thus, the medium blue square is below a medium yellow square (square number two in Block B).
Reference/Question Span:
Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square.
Question #3311
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is above block B and to the left of block C. Block A contains a small black square, one medium black circle and one medium blue square. The sma...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is above block B and to the left of block C. Block A contains a small black square, one medium black circle and one medium blue square. The small black square is above a small yellow circle and the medium blue square. Above and touching the medium blue square is the small yellow circle. It is touching the right edge of this block. To the right of the medium blue square there is the medium black circle. Block B contains a small blue square. Block C has two medium black triangles. To the left of medium black triangle number two there is medium black triangle number one. It also contains one small blue circle. Below and near to medium black triangle number one is the small blue circle. Which object is above a small blue square? the medium blue square or the small yellow circle which is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square
(b) the small yellow circle which is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A, which is above Block B, contains a small yellow circle, a medium blue square, and a small black square. The small blue square is in Block B. Since Block A is directly above Block B, the objects above the small blue square are the contents of Block A. The small yellow circle is above the medium blue square, and the small black square is above both of them. Since the question asks specifically about the small yellow circle touching the right edge, and this is indeed the object touching the right edge and above the small blue square, the answer is the small yellow circle which is touching the right edge of a block.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly lists the contents of Block A, leading to flawed logic about what objects are above Block B (where the small blue square is located). It also misinterprets the relationship between the small yellow circle and the medium blue square.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block A, which is above Block B, contains a small yellow circle, a medium blue square, and a small black square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly lists the contents of Block A. The context states Block A contains 'a small black square, one medium black circle and one medium blue square.' The reasoning chain incorrectly includes 'a small yellow circle' in Block A's contents and omits 'one medium black circle'.
Answer Span:
Block A, which is above Block B, contains a small yellow circle, a medium blue square, and a small black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains a small black square, one medium black circle and one medium blue square.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The small yellow circle is above the medium blue square, and the small black square is above both of them.
Explanation
The reasoning chain states the small yellow circle is above the medium blue square. The context states: 'The small black square is above a small yellow circle and the medium blue square. Above and touching the medium blue square is the small yellow circle.' This implies the small yellow circle is *not* above the medium blue square, but rather *above and touching* it, which is a spatial relationship, but the reasoning chain uses this to justify the vertical stacking which is not explicitly stated for the yellow circle relative to the blue square in the way implied.
Answer Span:
The small yellow circle is above the medium blue square
Reference/Question Span:
Above and touching the medium blue square is the small yellow circle.
Question #351
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. One medium yellow square is in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below a medium ...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. One medium yellow square is in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square and medium black square number two. This block also contains one medium blue square. The medium blue square is below medium black square number one and medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two is the medium yellow square. To the left of block B there is block C with two medium yellow squares in it. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. One medium blue square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two there is the medium blue square. It is below medium yellow square number one. Which object is below a medium yellow square? medium black square number two or medium black square number one?
(a) medium black square number two
(b) medium black square number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B, below A, has two medium black squares and a medium blue square. Medium black square number one is below the medium yellow square and medium black square number two. The medium blue square is below both medium black squares. Block C, to the left of Block B, has two medium yellow squares and a medium blue square. The medium yellow square number two is above both the medium yellow square number one and the medium blue square.
The question asks what is below *a* medium yellow square. There are three medium yellow squares. The one in Block A is above both medium black squares in Block B. So, medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the objects in each block but misinterprets or misstates the vertical relationship involving medium black square number one and the medium yellow square, leading to a potential contradiction regarding which object is below which. However, it correctly uses the information that the yellow square in Block A is above both black squares in Block B to reach the correct conclusion for the final question.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Medium black square number one is below the medium yellow square and medium black square number two.
Explanation
The context states that medium black square number one is below *a* medium yellow square AND medium black square number two. The reasoning chain implies it is below both simultaneously, but the structure in the context suggests it is below the yellow square AND below the other black square, which is a subtle but important distinction in spatial reasoning, but more critically, the context states: "Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square and medium black square number two." This phrasing is ambiguous, but the next sentence clarifies the yellow square's position relative to the black squares: "Below medium black square number two is the medium yellow square." This means the yellow square is below MBS2, not necessarily that MBS1 is below the yellow square mentioned in the same clause. However, the most direct contradiction is found in the next sentence of the context: 'Below medium black square number two is the medium yellow square.' The reasoning chain states MBS1 is below the medium yellow square, which contradicts the established hierarchy where the yellow square is below MBS2.
Answer Span:
Medium black square number one is below the medium yellow square and medium black square number two.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square and medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two is the medium yellow square.
Question #1430
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. A big yellow square and a small black triangle are in block A. The big yellow square is to the left of a small blue triangle which is below the small bla...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. A big yellow square and a small black triangle are in block A. The big yellow square is to the left of a small blue triangle which is below the small black triangle. This object is below and to the right of the small black triangle. Above block A we have block B which contains a small blue circle. A medium black square is below and to the right of the small blue circle. Finally, there is block C which is above block A. It contains a medium black square, one small yellow triangle and one big blue circle. To the left of and below the small yellow triangle is the medium black square. The small yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. It is to the right of the big blue circle. Which object is below a big blue circle? the small yellow triangle which is touching the right edge of a block or the big yellow square?
(a) the small yellow triangle which is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the big yellow square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block C contains the big blue circle, and Block A (below Block C) contains the big yellow square. Since Block A is directly below Block C, the big yellow square is below the big blue circle. The small yellow triangle is in Block C, to the right of the big blue circle, so it is not below it.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the location of the big yellow square (Block A) and the big blue circle (Block C). However, it makes an unsupported leap regarding the vertical relationship between the big blue circle (in C) and the big yellow square (in A) by stating A is 'directly below' C, which is not explicitly stated, although C is 'above' A. Crucially, it incorrectly dismisses the small yellow triangle based on a spatial relationship ('to the right of') that doesn't preclude it from also being below the circle, and it fails to use the explicit positional information given for the small yellow triangle relative to the medium black square, which is itself related to the big blue circle.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C contains the big blue circle
Explanation
The reasoning assumes the big blue circle is in Block C, but the context only states Block C contains 'one big blue circle'. It does not explicitly state that the big blue circle mentioned in the question ('Which object is below a big blue circle?') is the one in Block C, although it is the only one mentioned. More critically, the reasoning chain fails to establish the relative vertical positions of the objects within Block C or between Block C and Block A to support the conclusion that the big yellow square is below the big blue circle.
Answer Span:
Block C contains the big blue circle
Reference/Question Span:
Finally, there is block C which is above block A. It contains a medium black square, one small yellow triangle and one big blue circle.
Question #2748
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B. Block A is to the right of C. Block A has three medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bot...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B. Block A is to the right of C. Block A has three medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below a medium blue square there is medium black square number two. It is below medium black square number three. Medium black square number one is below the medium blue square , medium black square number three and medium black square number two. Block B has one medium black square. And block C has one medium blue square. This block also contains a medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square. Which object is to the left of a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A has three medium black squares and a medium blue square. Block B has one medium black square. Block C has a medium blue square touching the bottom edge and a medium black square above it. Since Block C is to the left of Block B (which contains a medium black square), the medium blue square in Block C is to the left of a medium black square. The medium blue square in Block A is not to the left of a medium black square, but rather above one.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly assigns a medium blue square to Block A and misrepresents the relative positions of the squares within Block C, leading to flawed intermediate conclusions about which blue square is to the left of a black square.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block A has three medium black squares and a medium blue square.
Explanation
The context states Block A has three medium black squares, but it does not state it has a medium blue square. The context specifies where the blue squares are located (Block C).
Answer Span:
Block A has three medium black squares and a medium blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has three medium black squares.
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block C has a medium blue square touching the bottom edge and a medium black square above it.
Explanation
The context states the medium blue square in Block C is touching the bottom edge and is *below* the medium black square, not that the black square is *above* it (which is true, but the context also specifies the relationship between the blue square and the black square in C: 'The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square.'). More critically, the context states the blue square is below the black square, which implies the black square is above the blue square. The reasoning chain states the black square is above the blue square, but the contradiction lies in the description of the blue square's location relative to the black square in C.
Answer Span:
Block C has a medium blue square touching the bottom edge and a medium black square above it.
Reference/Question Span:
And block C has one medium blue square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square.
Question #2773
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has one medium black circle and one medium black square. The medium black circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black square is touchi...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has one medium black circle and one medium black square. The medium black circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black circle is above the medium black square. To the right of block A is block B with one medium blue triangle in it. Finally, there is block C to the left of block A. It contains one medium black triangle, one small yellow circle and a small black square. To the right of the small black square there is the medium black triangle. This shape is touching the right edge of this block. It is to the right of the small yellow circle. To the right of and above the small black square is the small yellow circle. Which object is to the left of a medium triangle? the small black square or the medium shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small black square
(b) the medium shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium black circle and a medium black square. Block B has a medium blue triangle. Block C has a medium black triangle, a small yellow circle, and a small black square. The question asks what is to the left of a medium triangle. There are two medium triangles: one black in Block C and one blue in Block B. The small black square is in Block C, to the left of the medium black triangle. The medium black square is in Block A and is to the left of the medium blue triangle in Block B. Therefore, both are to the left of a medium triangle.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in each block and correctly evaluates the positional relationships required to answer the question based on the provided context.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #213
We have two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A has a medium black triangle, one medium blue circle and one big yellow circle. One small blue circle is also in this bl...
Clean
Full Question
We have two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A has a medium black triangle, one medium blue circle and one big yellow circle. One small blue circle is also in this block. The medium black triangle is touching the right edge of this block. Below, near to and to the right of the small blue circle there is the medium blue circle. Below and to the left of the small blue circle there is the big yellow circle.. Below the blue object which is below the small blue circle is the medium black triangle. Block B has one medium black triangle and a small black square. The small black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black triangle is to the left of the small black square. Which object is to the left of a medium black triangle? the medium black triangle which is touching the right edge of a block or the small blue circle?
(a) the medium black triangle which is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the small blue circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains a small blue circle, and Block B contains a medium black triangle. Block A is to the left of Block B, and the small blue circle is in Block A. The prompt asks what is to the left of *a* medium black triangle, not specifically the one touching the right edge of Block A. Since the small blue circle is in Block A, which is to the left of Block B (containing a medium black triangle), the small blue circle is to the left of a medium black triangle.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that Block A is left of Block B and that Block A contains a small blue circle while Block B contains a medium black triangle. It concludes that the small blue circle is to the left of a medium black triangle (the one in Block B). However, the reasoning chain fails to fully address the complexity of the question, which asks to compare the object to the left of *two specific* medium black triangles: one in A (which is touching the right edge) and one in B (which is not specified as touching the right edge, but the question implies we must check both possibilities mentioned in the options). The reasoning chain only checks the medium black triangle in Block B implicitly. Since the reasoning chain reaches a conclusion based on a partial analysis but doesn't contain explicit contradictions or ignore crucial constraints needed for the comparison, it is marked as having no hallucinations, though the analysis is incomplete.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #3335
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is to the right of A and block C is above B. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares. Me...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is to the right of A and block C is above B. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium blue square number two there is medium yellow square number two. Below medium blue square number two and medium yellow square number two is medium blue square number one. Below medium yellow square number two and medium blue square number two is medium yellow square number one. And block C contains a medium blue square. This block also contains a medium black square. Below the medium blue square is the medium black square. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium yellow square number two?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium yellow square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B, to the right of A, has two medium yellow squares (number one touching the bottom edge, number two above it) and two medium blue squares. Block C is above B. Since Block B is to the right of Block A, and both medium yellow squares (number one and number two) are in Block B, both are to the right of the medium yellow square in Block A.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the blocks (A, B, C) and correctly deduces that any object in B is to the right of the object in A. However, it makes an unsupported assumption about the relative vertical positions of the two medium yellow squares in Block B, which is not explicitly stated in the context, leading to a potential misinterpretation of which square is which, although the final conclusion about the relationship between the squares in A and B seems sound based on the block positions.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block B, to the right of A, has two medium yellow squares (number one touching the bottom edge, number two above it)
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly assigns the labels 'number one' and 'number two' to the medium yellow squares in Block B based on an assumed vertical stacking order ('number two above it'). The context only specifies that 'Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block' (Block B) and provides a complex set of positional relationships for the other squares relative to each other and the blue squares, but it does not explicitly state that medium yellow square number two is directly above number one.
Answer Span:
two medium yellow squares (number one touching the bottom edge, number two above it)
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium blue square number two there is medium yellow square number two.
Question #3150
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Th...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Then, we have block B with two medium yellow squares in it. A medium black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black square is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Finally, to the right of block A we have block C. It is to the right of block B. It contains one medium blue square. There is also one medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the blue thing or the black thing which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the blue thing
(b) the black thing which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Block A contains two medium yellow squares. Block B, which is not to the right of Block A, contains a medium black square touching the bottom edge. Block C, to the right of Block A, contains a medium blue square. Since Block C is to the right of Block A, and the medium blue square is in Block C, the blue thing (medium blue square) is to the right of the medium yellow squares in Block A. The black thing (medium black square) is in Block B, which is not to the right of Block A.
Answer: {A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains a factual contradiction regarding the relative positions of Block A and Block B, and it fails to correctly evaluate the second option ('the black thing') against the prompt's requirement ('Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square?'). The conclusion relies on the flawed premise about Block B's location relative to Block A.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block B, which is not to the right of Block A
Explanation
The context explicitly states that Block C is to the right of Block A, and Block C is to the right of Block B. This implies B is to the left of C, but it does not state B is *not* to the right of A. More critically, the context states: 'Finally, to the right of block A we have block C. It is to the right of block B.' This means A is to the left of C, and B is to the left of C. The relative position of A and B is not explicitly defined as 'B is not to the right of A'. However, the reasoning chain incorrectly assumes a relationship between A and B based on the description of C's position relative to both.
Answer Span:
Block B, which is not to the right of Block A
Reference/Question Span:
Finally, to the right of block A we have block C. It is to the right of block B.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The black thing (medium black square) is in Block B, which is not to the right of Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning chain uses the incorrect premise that Block B is not to the right of Block A to dismiss the black thing as an answer. The question asks which object is to the right of *a* medium yellow square. The black square is in Block B. The yellow squares are in A, B, and C. The black square is below YS1 and YS2 in Block B. The question asks if the black thing is to the right of *a* medium yellow square. Since the black thing is in Block B, and Block B contains YS3 (implied by the structure, though not explicitly numbered), or more simply, the black thing is in the same block as some yellow squares (YS in B), its position relative to *a* yellow square in B is ambiguous based on the text, but the reasoning chain incorrectly dismisses it based on the A/B relationship.
Answer Span:
The black thing (medium black square) is in Block B, which is not to the right of Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square?
Question #410
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is above B and block B is to the right of C. Block A contains one big blue square and a small yellow triangle. Above and to the right of the sm...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is above B and block B is to the right of C. Block A contains one big blue square and a small yellow triangle. Above and to the right of the small yellow triangle there is the big blue square. Block B contains a small yellow square and one small yellow triangle. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. This object is to the right of and above the small yellow triangle. This block also contains a medium blue square. The medium blue square is above the small yellow triangle. Block C contains one big blue square, one big black circle and one medium yellow square. The big blue square is to the right of the big black circle and the medium yellow square. Which object is to the right of a black thing? the small yellow square which is touching the right edge of a block or the medium blue square?
(a) the small yellow square which is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block C contains a big black circle. The big blue square and the medium yellow square are to the right of the big black circle. Block B, which is to the right of block C, contains the small yellow square (touching the right edge), the small yellow triangle, and the medium blue square. Since Block B is to the right of Block C (which contains the black circle), both the small yellow square and the medium blue square are to the right of the black thing (big black circle).
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the black object (big black circle in C) and correctly deduces that objects in Block B (which is to the right of C) are to the right of the black object. Both options (a) and (b) are in Block B, thus (c) is the correct choice based on the reasoning.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1626
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. There is also a medium blue square touching the bo...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two and medium yellow square number one is the medium blue square. Then, we have block B. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and a medium blue square. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square number two there is the medium blue square. To the right of both blocks A and B there is block C. It contains one medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium blue square? medium black square number two or the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium black square number two
(b) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains two medium yellow squares and a medium blue square. Block B contains two medium black squares and a medium blue square. Block C contains one medium blue square. Blocks A and B are to the left of Block C. The question asks what is to the left of *a* medium blue square. Since Block B, containing medium black squares number one and two (and a medium blue square) is to the left of Block C (which contains *a* medium blue square), both medium black squares are to the left of a medium blue square.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the contents of the blocks and uses the spatial relationship (A and B are to the left of C) to address the question about what is to the left of a medium blue square. It correctly notes that Block B contains two medium black squares and a medium blue square, and Block C contains a medium blue square, meaning the black squares in B are to the left of the blue square in C. The reasoning is sound based on the provided context.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #22
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are one big blue triangle and a medium yellow square in block A. Near to a medium blue triangle there is a big black circle. Near to and below th...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are one big blue triangle and a medium yellow square in block A. Near to a medium blue triangle there is a big black circle. Near to and below the black shape which is near to the medium blue triangle there is the big blue triangle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is near to and below the medium blue triangle. Block B is below block A. It has a big black square. To the left of block B there is block C which has a big blue triangle and one medium yellow circle. To the right of a big black square is the medium yellow circle.. The big blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. This shape is below and to the right of the big black square. Which object is to the right of a big black square? the blue thing that is touching the right edge of a block or the medium yellow circle?
(a) the blue thing that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium yellow square at the bottom, a big blue triangle near the bottom, and a medium blue triangle and a big black circle near each other. Block B, below A, has a big black square. Block C, to the left of B, has a big blue triangle touching its right edge and a medium yellow circle. The prompt states that the medium yellow circle is to the right of the big black square. The big blue triangle in Block C is also to the right of the big black square. Therefore, both the blue triangle touching the right edge of Block C and the medium yellow circle are to the right of the big black square in Block B.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the key objects and their relative positions needed to answer the final question, but it incorrectly includes the medium blue triangle as being in Block A, which is not supported by the text. It also slightly misrepresents how the location of the Block C triangle relative to the black square is established.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block A contains a medium yellow square at the bottom, a big blue triangle near the bottom, and a medium blue triangle and a big black circle near each other.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly states that Block A contains a medium blue triangle. The context states Block A has 'one big blue triangle and a medium yellow square'. The medium blue triangle is described as being near the big black circle, but its location relative to Block A is not explicitly stated, only that the big blue triangle and medium yellow square are in Block A.
Answer Span:
Block A contains a medium yellow square at the bottom, a big blue triangle near the bottom, and a medium blue triangle and a big black circle near each other.
Reference/Question Span:
There are one big blue triangle and a medium yellow square in block A.
missing_contextlow
Statement
The big blue triangle in Block C is also to the right of the big black square.
Explanation
The reasoning claims the big blue triangle in Block C is to the right of the big black square. The context states that the big blue triangle in Block C is 'touching the right edge of this block' and 'This shape is below and to the right of the big black square.' While the second part confirms it is to the right, the reasoning presents this as an independent deduction rather than relying on the explicit statement provided in the context regarding the relationship between the big blue triangle in Block C and the big black square.
Answer Span:
The big blue triangle in Block C is also to the right of the big black square.
Reference/Question Span:
This shape is below and to the right of the big black square.
Question #1439
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. A medium yellow square is in block A. To the right of block A there is block B with two medium yellow squares in it. Medium yellow square number one is...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. A medium yellow square is in block A. To the right of block A there is block B with two medium yellow squares in it. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. A medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two and medium yellow square number one there is a medium blue square. The medium black square is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Finally, there is block C to the left of block B. It contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below medium yellow square number two. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue square?
(a) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium yellow square. Block B, to the right of A, contains two medium yellow squares (number two above number one), a medium black square touching the bottom edge, and a medium blue square below the other yellow squares. Block C is to the left of Block B and contains two medium yellow squares. The question asks what is to the right of *a* medium yellow square, implying any medium yellow square. Since Block B is to the right of Block A (which has a medium yellow square), and Block B contains both the medium black square and the medium blue square, both are to the right of a medium yellow square.
Answer: {C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain fails to accurately map the spatial relationships described in the context, particularly regarding the black and blue squares. Crucially, it skips the necessary step of determining which object (black square or blue square) is actually positioned to the right of any medium yellow square, leading to an unsupported conclusion.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block B, to the right of A, contains two medium yellow squares (number two above number one), a medium black square touching the bottom edge, and a medium blue square below the other yellow squares.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly states the relationship between the medium black square and the medium blue square. The context specifies the black square is below YS1 and YS2, and the blue square is below YS1 and YS2. It does not state the blue square is below the black square, nor does it accurately capture the relative positions of the black and blue squares.
Answer Span:
a medium black square touching the bottom edge, and a medium blue square below the other yellow squares
Reference/Question Span:
A medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two and medium yellow square number one there is a medium blue square. The medium black square is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B is to the right of Block A (which has a medium yellow square), and Block B contains both the medium black square and the medium blue square, both are to the right of a medium yellow square.
Explanation
This reasoning ignores the specific constraints on the positions of the medium black square and the medium blue square relative to the yellow squares. The question asks which object is to the right of *a* medium yellow square. The reasoning assumes that because the black and blue squares are *in* Block B, and Block B is to the right of Block A (which has a yellow square), they must be to the right of *some* yellow square. This skips the necessary positional check required by the question.
Answer Span:
both are to the right of a medium yellow square
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue square?
Question #3555
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the left of B and block B is below C. Block A has two medium yellow squares. One medium black square is also in this block. Medium yell...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the left of B and block B is below C. Block A has two medium yellow squares. One medium black square is also in this block. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium black square.. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square and medium yellow square number two. Block B contains one medium blue square. And block C contains three medium black squares. Below medium black square number two and a medium yellow square is medium black square number one. Below the medium yellow square and medium black square number three is medium black square number two. Below the medium yellow square there is medium black square number three. Which object is to the left of a blue shape? medium black square number three or the medium black square which is in block A?
(a) medium black square number three
(b) the medium black square which is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Block A contains a medium black square and two medium yellow squares. Block B, to the right of Block A, contains a medium blue square. Block C, above Block B, contains three medium black squares and a medium yellow square. The question asks what is to the *left* of a blue shape. The blue shape is in Block B. Block A is to the left of Block B, and the medium black square is in Block A. Therefore, the medium black square in Block A is to the left of the blue shape. Medium black square number three is in Block C, which is above Block B, not to the left of it.
Answer: {B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the location of the blue shape (Block B) and correctly deduces that the object in Block A (which is left of B) is to the left of the blue shape. However, it introduces a hallucinated yellow square in Block C and makes an assumption about the horizontal relationship between A and B that, while consistent with 'A is left of B', is less precise than the explicit spatial relationships given (A left of B, B below C).
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block B, to the right of Block A, contains a medium blue square.
Explanation
The context states Block A is to the left of B, which implies B is to the right of A, but the context also states Block B is *below* C, not explicitly relating A and B horizontally other than A being left of B. More critically, the reasoning assumes Block B is to the right of A, which is consistent with A being left of B, but the reasoning then incorrectly states Block C is *above* Block B, which is true, but then it adds information about Block C's contents that is not fully supported or is an oversimplification.
Answer Span:
Block B, to the right of Block A
Reference/Question Span:
Block A is to the left of B
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block C, above Block B, contains three medium black squares and a medium yellow square.
Explanation
The context states Block C contains three medium black squares, but it never mentions Block C containing a medium yellow square. The reasoning chain invents this detail.
Answer Span:
Block C, above Block B, contains three medium black squares and a medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
And block C contains three medium black squares.
Questions Analyzed
200
With Issues
148
74.0% of questions
Total Issues Found
250
1.25 per question
Issue Type Distribution
missing_context: 154contradiction: 96
Question Analysis
Question #2791
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains one medium black square and a medium blue square. It also contains one big blue triangle and one small blue square. Below the small blue...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains one medium black square and a medium blue square. It also contains one big blue triangle and one small blue square. Below the small blue square there is the medium blue square. Above, to the left of and near to the medium black square which is to the right of and below the small blue square is the big blue triangle. Then, we have block B with a small yellow square, a big blue circle and a medium black triangle in it. This block also contains a small yellow triangle. To the right of the small yellow square which is above the big blue circle and the medium black triangle there is the small yellow triangle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the medium black triangle there is a medium black circle. Block C is to the right of block B and below block A. It has two small yellow circles and two other medium yellow circles. Small yellow circle number one is above small yellow circle number two. Medium yellow circle number one is to the left of, above and near to medium yellow circle number two. It is to the right of small yellow circle number two. Below and to the left of medium yellow circle number one is small yellow circle number one. What is to the right of the medium black circle? a small yellow circle number two or a small yellow circle number one?
(a) small yellow circle number two
(b) small yellow circle number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block A contains one medium black square and a medium blue square. It also contains one big blue triangle and one small blue square. Below the small blue square there is the medium blue square. Above, to the left of and near to the medium black square which is to the right of and below the small blue square is the big blue triangle. Then, we have block B with a small yellow square, a big blue circle and a medium black triangle in it. This block also contains a small yellow triangle. To the right of the small yellow square which is above the big blue circle and the medium black triangle there is the small yellow triangle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the medium black triangle there is a medium black circle. Block C is to the right of block B and below block A. It has two small yellow circles and two other medium yellow circles. Small yellow circle number one is above small yellow circle number two. Medium yellow circle number one is to the left of, above and near to medium yellow circle number two. It is to the right of small yellow circle number two. Below and to the left of medium yellow circle number one is small yellow circle number one. What is to the right of the medium black circle? a small yellow circle number two or a small yellow circle number one?
(a) small yellow circle number two
(b) small yellow circle number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B contains a medium black triangle touching the bottom edge. To the right of this triangle is a medium black circle. Block C is to the right of Block B and contains two small yellow circles (number two and number one) and two medium yellow circles. Since Block C is to the right of Block B, and the medium black circle is at the right edge of Block B, the objects to its right must be in Block C.The small yellow circles are in Block C, so they are to the right of the medium black circle. Specifically, small yellow circle number one is below and to the left of medium yellow circle number one, which is to the right of small yellow circle number two, thus putting small yellow circle number two to the right of the medium black circle. The answer is \boxed{A}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the relevant blocks (B and C) and the object in question (medium black circle). However, it makes an unsubstantiated assumption that the medium black circle is at the right edge of Block B, which is not stated in the context, leading to a missing context flag regarding the exact placement relative to the block boundary.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block C is to the right of Block B, and the medium black circle is at the right edge of Block B, the objects to its right must be in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes the medium black circle is at the right edge of Block B, but the context only states 'To the right of the medium black triangle there is a medium black circle.' It does not explicitly state the medium black circle is at the right edge of Block B, which is a crucial detail for determining what is to its right based on block boundaries.
Answer Span:
Since Block C is to the right of Block B, and the medium black circle is at the right edge of Block B, the objects to its right must be in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
To the right of the medium black triangle there is a medium black circle.
Question #2792
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains one medium black square and a medium blue square. It also contains one big blue triangle and one small blue square. Below the small blue...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains one medium black square and a medium blue square. It also contains one big blue triangle and one small blue square. Below the small blue square there is the medium blue square. Above, to the left of and near to the medium black square which is to the right of and below the small blue square is the big blue triangle. Then, we have block B with a small yellow square, a big blue circle and a medium black triangle in it. This block also contains a small yellow triangle. To the right of the small yellow square which is above the big blue circle and the medium black triangle there is the small yellow triangle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the medium black triangle there is a medium black circle. Block C is to the right of block B and below block A. It has two small yellow circles and two other medium yellow circles. Small yellow circle number one is above small yellow circle number two. Medium yellow circle number one is to the left of, above and near to medium yellow circle number two. It is to the right of small yellow circle number two. Below and to the left of medium yellow circle number one is small yellow circle number one. Which object is above a small yellow circle? the medium black circle or the big blue triangle?
(a) the medium black circle
(b) the big blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block A contains one medium black square and a medium blue square. It also contains one big blue triangle and one small blue square. Below the small blue square there is the medium blue square. Above, to the left of and near to the medium black square which is to the right of and below the small blue square is the big blue triangle. Then, we have block B with a small yellow square, a big blue circle and a medium black triangle in it. This block also contains a small yellow triangle. To the right of the small yellow square which is above the big blue circle and the medium black triangle there is the small yellow triangle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the medium black triangle there is a medium black circle. Block C is to the right of block B and below block A. It has two small yellow circles and two other medium yellow circles. Small yellow circle number one is above small yellow circle number two. Medium yellow circle number one is to the left of, above and near to medium yellow circle number two. It is to the right of small yellow circle number two. Below and to the left of medium yellow circle number one is small yellow circle number one. Which object is above a small yellow circle? the medium black circle or the big blue triangle?
(a) the medium black circle
(b) the big blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C is below Block A and to the right of Block B. Block A contains the big blue triangle, which is above and to the left of the medium black square. Block B contains a medium black circle, but it is not related to Block C, which has the small yellow circles. In Block A, the big blue triangle is above the medium black square, which is above and to the right of the medium blue square. Block C, which is below Block A, contains two small yellow circles, one above the other (small yellow circle number one above small yellow circle number two), and two medium yellow circles. The placement of the yellow circles in Block C makes the big blue triangle in Block Aabove them. The medium yellow circles are abovesmall yellow circle number two and small yellow circle number one is below and to the left of medium yellow circle number one. The medium black circle is in Block B and not related to the small yellow circles in Block C. Therefore, only the big blue triangle is above a small yellow circle.
Final Answer: \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the location of the big blue triangle relative to the small yellow circles in Block C. However, it incorrectly dismisses the medium black circle by assuming its location relative to Block B prevents it from being above a small yellow circle in Block C, ignoring the need to check the spatial relationship required by the final question.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block B contains a medium black circle, but it is not related to Block C, which has the small yellow circles.
Explanation
The reasoning claims the medium black circle is in Block B, but the context states the medium black circle is to the right of the medium black triangle, which is in Block B. The context does not explicitly state the medium black circle is *in* Block B, only that it is to the right of an object in Block B. More importantly, the reasoning fails to check if the medium black circle (which is spatially located relative to Block B) is above a small yellow circle (which are in Block C). The question asks if the medium black circle OR the big blue triangle is above a small yellow circle. The reasoning dismisses the medium black circle based on its location relative to Block B, ignoring the spatial relationship required by the question.
Answer Span:
Block B contains a medium black circle, but it is not related to Block C, which has the small yellow circles.
Reference/Question Span:
To the right of the medium black triangle there is a medium black circle. Block C is to the right of block B and below block A. It has two small yellow circles and two other medium yellow circles.
Question #3270
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of A and block A is to the left of B. Block A contains a big blue square, one big black circle and one big yellow circle. To t...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of A and block A is to the left of B. Block A contains a big blue square, one big black circle and one big yellow circle. To the left of, above and near to the big black circle which is far from and below a medium yellow circle is the big blue square. The big black circle is touching the right edge of this block. Block B contains two medium blue squares. Above medium blue square number two is medium blue square number one. Medium blue square number two is to the right of a small yellow square and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the left edge of this block. Medium blue square number two is touching the right edge of this block. This block also has a medium black square. And block C has a big blue triangle, one medium black square and one small black triangle. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of and below the small black triangle. The big blue triangle is to the right of the small black triangle. It is above the black shape which is to the right of the small black triangle. Which object is to the right of a small black triangle? the square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the triangle which is touching the left edge of a block?
(a) the square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the triangle which is touching the left edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block C is to the left of A and block A is to the left of B. Block A contains a big blue square, one big black circle, and one big yellow circle. To the left of, above, and near to the big black circle which is far from and below a medium yellow circle is the big blue square. The big black circle is touching the right edge of this block. Block B contains two medium blue squares. Above medium blue square number two is medium blue square number one. Medium blue square number two is to the right of a small yellow square and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the left edge of this block. Medium blue square number two is touching the right edge of this block. This block also has a medium black square. And block C has a big blue triangle, one medium black square, and one small black triangle. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of and below the small black triangle. The big blue triangle is to the right of the small black triangle. It is above the black shape which is to the right of the small black triangle. Which object is to the right of a small black triangle? the square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the triangle which is touching the left edge of a block? (a) the square which is touching the bottom edge of a block (b) the triangle which is touching the left edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block C contains a small black triangle, a medium black square, and a big blue triangle. The medium black square is to the right of and below the small black triangle, and the big blue triangle is also to the right of the small black triangle. Block B (which is to the right of Block A and Block C because of and ) contains a medium yellow triangle touching the left edge. Since Block C contains the small black triangle, and the medium black square is to the right of it within the same block, the medium black square is to the right of the small black triangle. The medium yellow triangle is in Block B, which is to the right of Block C, so the medium yellow triangle is also to the right of the small black triangle. Therefore, both the square and triangle are to the right of the small black triangle.
Final Answer: \boxed{C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains a major factual contradiction regarding the location of the medium black square, incorrectly placing it in Block C when the source states it is in Block B. This error significantly impacts the evaluation of option (a).
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block C contains a small black triangle, a medium black square, and a big blue triangle.
Explanation
The context states Block C has 'one medium black square and one small black triangle' and 'a big blue triangle'. The reasoning chain lists these three items, but the question context does not explicitly state that the medium black square is *in* Block C, only that it is touching the bottom edge of *this block* (Block C). However, the primary contradiction is that the reasoning chain claims Block C contains a medium black square, but the context states the medium black square is in Block B: 'This block [Block B] also has a medium black square.'
Answer Span:
Block C contains a small black triangle, a medium black square, and a big blue triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
This block [Block B] also has a medium black square.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The medium yellow triangle is in Block B, which is to the right of Block C, so the medium yellow triangle is also to the right of the small black triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly identifies the object 'the triangle which is touching the left edge of a block' as the 'medium yellow triangle' in Block B. The question asks about 'the triangle which is touching the left edge of a block'. The context states: 'Medium blue square number two is to the right of a small yellow square and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the left edge of this block [Block B].' This object is a medium yellow triangle, not a generic triangle. The reasoning chain correctly identifies the object's location relative to the small black triangle (which is in C), but it fails to check if the object described in option (b) matches the description of the object in option (a) or if the object described in option (b) is the one being asked about. The object in option (b) is 'the triangle which is touching the left edge of a block', which is the medium yellow triangle in Block B. The reasoning chain correctly identifies this object is to the right of the small black triangle, but it uses the description of the object in option (b) to support the conclusion, which is fine, but the previous contradiction about the medium black square's location is more severe.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow triangle is in Block B, which is to the right of Block C, so the medium yellow triangle is also to the right of the small black triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a small black triangle? the square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the triangle which is touching the left edge of a block?
Question #3269
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of A and block A is to the left of B. Block A contains a big blue square, one big black circle and one big yellow circle. To t...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of A and block A is to the left of B. Block A contains a big blue square, one big black circle and one big yellow circle. To the left of, above and near to the big black circle which is far from and below a medium yellow circle is the big blue square. The big black circle is touching the right edge of this block. Block B contains two medium blue squares. Above medium blue square number two is medium blue square number one. Medium blue square number two is to the right of a small yellow square and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the left edge of this block. Medium blue square number two is touching the right edge of this block. This block also has a medium black square. And block C has a big blue triangle, one medium black square and one small black triangle. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of and below the small black triangle. The big blue triangle is to the right of the small black triangle. It is above the black shape which is to the right of the small black triangle. What is to the right of the small black triangle? a object which is touching the bottom edge of a block or a triangle that is touching the left edge of a block?
(a) object which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) triangle that is touching the left edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block C is to the left of A and block A is to the left of B. Block A contains a big blue square, one big black circle and one big yellow circle. To the left of, above and near to the big black circle which is far from and below a medium yellow circle is the big blue square. The big black circle is touching the right edge of this block. Block B contains two medium blue squares. Above medium blue square number two is medium blue square number one. Medium blue square number two is to the right of a small yellow square and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the left edge of this block. Medium blue square number two is touching the right edge of this block. This block also has a medium black square. And block C has a big blue triangle, one medium black square and one small black triangle. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of and below the small black triangle. The big blue triangle is to the right of the small black triangle. It is above the black shape which is to the right of the small black triangle. What is to the right of the small black triangle? a object which is touching the bottom edge of a block or a triangle that is touching the left edge of a block?
(a) object which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) triangle that is touching the left edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C contains a small black triangle, a medium black square, and a big blue triangle. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of Block C and is to the right of the small black triangle. The big blue triangle is also to the right of the small black triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the left edge of Block B. Since the question asks what is to the right of the small black triangle (in Block C), and the medium black square touching the bottom edge satisfies this condition, option (a) is correct. The medium yellow triangle, while touching the left edge of Block B, is not relevant as it's not in Block C. Therefore, the answer is a.
\boxed{a}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains a major factual error regarding the contents of Block C, incorrectly placing an object from Block B into Block C. It also misinterprets the comparison required by the final question, leading to an incomplete evaluation of the options.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block C contains a small black triangle, a medium black square, and a big blue triangle.
Explanation
The context states Block C has 'a big blue triangle, one medium black square and one small black triangle.' The reasoning chain incorrectly lists the contents of Block C by including the medium black square which is stated to be in Block B in the context: 'This block [B] also has a medium black square.'
Answer Span:
Block C contains a small black triangle, a medium black square, and a big blue triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
And block C has a big blue triangle, one medium black square and one small black triangle.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The medium yellow triangle, while touching the left edge of Block B, is not relevant as it's not in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning chain dismisses option (b) based on the location of the triangle, but the question asks what is to the right of the small black triangle, comparing two general descriptions: (a) an object touching the bottom edge of *a block* or (b) a triangle touching the left edge of *a block*. The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes the comparison must only involve objects within Block C, ignoring that option (b) refers to *a* block, not necessarily Block C.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow triangle, while touching the left edge of Block B, is not relevant as it's not in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the right of the small black triangle? a object which is touching the bottom edge of a block or a triangle that is touching the left edge of a block?
Question #129
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block C is to the left of B. Block A has one small yellow circle, one small blue square and one big yellow circle. One small...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block C is to the left of B. Block A has one small yellow circle, one small blue square and one big yellow circle. One small black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. The big yellow circle is above and to the left of the small black square.. Below and near to the small blue square which is above the small black square there is the small yellow circle. It is to the right of the circle which is above the small black square. Block B has a medium yellow triangle and one small yellow circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of and below the small yellow circle. Block C has two big yellow triangles. One medium blue triangle is also in this block. There is also a big black square touching the right edge of this block. The medium blue triangle is to the left of, above and near to the big black square. Big yellow triangle number one is to the left of, far from and above the big black square. This block also has a small black square. Big yellow triangle number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. Which object is to the left of a big yellow triangle? the small yellow circle that is in block A or the small yellow circle that is in block B?
(a) the small yellow circle that is in block A
(b) the small yellow circle that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block C is to the left of B. Block A has one small yellow circle, one small blue square and one big yellow circle. One small black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. The big yellow circle is above and to the left of the small black square.. Below and near to the small blue square which is above the small black square there is the small yellow circle. It is to the right of the circle which is above the small black square. Block B has a medium yellow triangle and one small yellow circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of and below the small yellow circle. Block C has two big yellow triangles. One medium blue triangle is also in this block. There is also a big black square touching the right edge of this block. The medium blue triangle is to the left of, above and near to the big black square. Big yellow triangle number one is to the left of, far from and above the big black square. This block also has a small black square. Big yellow triangle number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. Which object is to the left of a big yellow triangle? the small yellow circle that is in block A or the small yellow circle that is in block B?
(a) the small yellow circle that is in block A
(b) the small yellow circle that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
We are given that Block A is to the left of Block C, and Block C is to the left of Block B. Block C contains two big yellow triangles (number one and number two). The question asks what is to the left of a big yellow triangle.
Since A is to the left of C, and A contains a small yellow circle (small yellow circle in A), this small yellow circle is to the left of the big yellow triangles in C. Since C is to the left of B, and B contains a small yellow circle (small yellow circle in B), this small yellow circle is to the right of the big yellow triangles in C.
Therefore, only the small yellow circle in Block A is to the left of a big yellow triangle.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{A}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the block order (A < C < B) and correctly identifies that the object in A is to the left of objects in C. However, it makes an unsupported leap regarding the object in B being to the right of objects in C based only on block order, ignoring the specific spatial constraints needed to definitively answer the question about which object is *to the left* of *a* big yellow triangle.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block C contains two big yellow triangles (number one and number two).
Explanation
The context states Block C has two big yellow triangles AND one medium blue triangle AND a big black square AND a small black square. It does not explicitly state that Block C contains both big yellow triangle number one AND number two. Big yellow triangle number one is stated to be in Block C, but Big yellow triangle number two is only stated to be touching the bottom edge of 'this block' (which refers to Block C based on the preceding sentence structure). However, the reasoning chain asserts both are in C, which is an assumption not fully supported by the text structure, but the main contradiction is the next point.
Answer Span:
Block C contains two big yellow triangles (number one and number two).
Reference/Question Span:
Block C has two big yellow triangles. One medium blue triangle is also in this block. There is also a big black square touching the right edge of this block. The medium blue triangle is to the left of, above and near to the big black square. Big yellow triangle number one is to the left of, far from and above the big black square. This block also has a small black square. Big yellow triangle number two is touching the bottom edge of this block.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since C is to the left of B, and B contains a small yellow circle (small yellow circle in B), this small yellow circle is to the right of the big yellow triangles in C.
Explanation
The reasoning concludes that the small yellow circle in B is to the right of the big yellow triangles in C because C is to the left of B. This ignores the fact that the question asks which object is to the left of *a* big yellow triangle. While the relative position of the blocks (A < C < B) suggests objects in B are to the right of objects in C, the reasoning fails to establish the spatial relationship between the specific objects (small yellow circle in B) and the specific objects being queried (big yellow triangles in C) based on the provided positional data, relying only on block order, which is insufficient to answer the specific spatial query about the objects themselves.
Answer Span:
Since C is to the left of B, and B contains a small yellow circle (small yellow circle in B), this small yellow circle is to the right of the big yellow triangles in C.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the left of a big yellow triangle? the small yellow circle that is in block A or the small yellow circle that is in block B?
Question #1505
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One small black square, a medium black circle and a small yellow circle are in block A. Above the medium black circle and the small yellow circle there is the small...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One small black square, a medium black circle and a small yellow circle are in block A. Above the medium black circle and the small yellow circle there is the small black square. The medium black circle is below the small yellow circle. The small yellow circle is touching the right edge of this block. Then, there is block B which contains one big blue square and one small blue square. A big yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big yellow square is to the right of and above the big blue square. Above the small blue square and the big blue square is a medium black square. It is to the left of the square which is to the right of the big blue square. Finally, to the left of block B we have block C. It is to the left of block A. It contains a medium black triangle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a big blue circle. A small blue circle is to the left of and above the medium black triangle. To the left of the big blue circle is the medium black triangle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. Which object is to the right of a big blue circle? the small blue circle or the medium black circle?
(a) the small blue circle
(b) the medium black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. One small black square, a medium black circle and a small yellow circle are in block A. Above the medium black circle and the small yellow circle there is the small black square. The medium black circle is below the small yellow circle. The small yellow circle is touching the right edge of this block. Then, there is block B which contains one big blue square and one small blue square. A big yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big yellow square is to the right of and above the big blue square. Above the small blue square and the big blue square is a medium black square. It is to the left of the square which is to the right of the big blue square. Finally, to the left of block B we have block C. It is to the left of block A. It contains a medium black triangle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a big blue circle. A small blue circle is to the left of and above the medium black triangle. To the left of the big blue circle is the medium black triangle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. Which object is to the right of a big blue circle? the small blue circle or the medium black circle?
(a) the small blue circle
(b) the medium black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C is to the left of Block B and also to the left of Block A. Block C contains a big blue circle and a small blue circle, with the big blue circle touching the right edge of Block C. Block B is to the right of Block C. Block A contains a medium black circle and has a small yellow circle touching its right edge. Since Block B is located between Block C and Block A, and the big blue circle touches the right edge of Block C, neither the small blue circle (which is to the left of the big blue circle in Block C) nor the medium black circle (which is in Block A) is directly to the right of the big blue circle. The objects in Block B would be to the right of the big blue circle in Block C.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{D}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains a factual contradiction regarding the contents of Block C (inventing a small blue circle) and ignores the spatial relationship required to answer the question, which involves checking objects in Block B (which is to the right of C) or objects in Block A (which is to the right of B).
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block C contains a big blue circle and a small blue circle
Explanation
The context states Block C contains a medium black triangle and a big blue circle, not a small blue circle.
Answer Span:
Block C contains a big blue circle and a small blue circle
Reference/Question Span:
It contains a medium black triangle. This block also has a big blue circle.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
neither the small blue circle (which is to the left of the big blue circle in Block C) nor the medium black circle (which is in Block A) is directly to the right of the big blue circle.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly assumes the small blue circle is in Block C and uses this incorrect assumption to dismiss it. The context states the small blue circle is to the left of and above the medium black triangle (which is in C), but it doesn't explicitly state the small blue circle is *in* C, nor does it state its position relative to the big blue circle in C. More importantly, the reasoning ignores the actual objects in Block A (medium black circle) and Block B, which are the candidates for being to the right of the big blue circle in C.
Answer Span:
neither the small blue circle (which is to the left of the big blue circle in Block C) nor the medium black circle (which is in Block A) is directly to the right of the big blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a big blue circle? the small blue circle or the medium black circle?
Question #1506
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One small black square, a medium black circle and a small yellow circle are in block A. Above the medium black circle and the small yellow circle there is the small...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One small black square, a medium black circle and a small yellow circle are in block A. Above the medium black circle and the small yellow circle there is the small black square. The medium black circle is below the small yellow circle. The small yellow circle is touching the right edge of this block. Then, there is block B which contains one big blue square and one small blue square. A big yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big yellow square is to the right of and above the big blue square. Above the small blue square and the big blue square is a medium black square. It is to the left of the square which is to the right of the big blue square. Finally, to the left of block B we have block C. It is to the left of block A. It contains a medium black triangle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a big blue circle. A small blue circle is to the left of and above the medium black triangle. To the left of the big blue circle is the medium black triangle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. What is to the right of the small blue circle? a small black square or a medium black circle?
(a) small black square
(b) medium black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. One small black square, a medium black circle and a small yellow circle are in block A. Above the medium black circle and the small yellow circle there is the small black square. The medium black circle is below the small yellow circle. The small yellow circle is touching the right edge of this block. Then, there is block B which contains one big blue square and one small blue square. A big yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big yellow square is to the right of and above the big blue square. Above the small blue square and the big blue square is a medium black square. It is to the left of the square which is to the right of the big blue square. Finally, to the left of block B we have block C. It is to the left of block A. It contains a medium black triangle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a big blue circle. A small blue circle is to the left of and above the medium black triangle. To the left of the big blue circle is the medium black triangle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. What is to the right of the small blue circle? a small black square or a medium black circle? (a) small black square (b) medium black circle (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block C is to the left of Block B and to the left of Block A. The small blue circle is in Block C. Block A is to the right of Block C, and it contains the small black square () and the medium black circle. Therefore, both the small black square and the medium black circle are to the right of the small blue circle.
Final Answer: \boxed{C}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the blocks (C left of B, C left of A) and correctly identifies that items in A are to the right of items in C. However, it makes an assumption that the small blue circle is *in* Block C, which is not explicitly stated, although strongly implied by its description relative to items in C.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The small blue circle is in Block C.
Explanation
The context states the location of the small blue circle relative to items in Block C ('A small blue circle is to the left of and above the medium black triangle'), but it never explicitly states that the small blue circle is *in* Block C. It is only implied by its relationship to items in C.
Answer Span:
The small blue circle is in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
A small blue circle is to the left of and above the medium black triangle.
Question #3097
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one big yellow triangle, one medium yellow square and a small blue circle. The big yellow triangle is above and to the right of a medium ye...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one big yellow triangle, one medium yellow square and a small blue circle. The big yellow triangle is above and to the right of a medium yellow triangle. Above the medium yellow triangle there is the small blue circle. The medium yellow square is touching the top edge of this block. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and above the medium yellow triangle is the medium yellow square. Above block A we have block B with two medium yellow squares in it. This block also has a medium yellow circle. The medium yellow circle is to the left of and above medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Finally, we have block C to the right of block B. It has two medium yellow triangles and two small yellow circles. Below small yellow circle number one and medium yellow triangle number two there is medium yellow triangle number one. Small yellow circle number one is above and to the left of small yellow circle number two. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow circle or the medium yellow square that is touching the top edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow circle
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the top edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block A has one big yellow triangle, one medium yellow square and a small blue circle. The big yellow triangle is above and to the right of a medium yellow triangle. Above the medium yellow triangle there is the small blue circle. The medium yellow square is touching the top edge of this block. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and above the medium yellow triangle is the medium yellow square. Above block A we have block B with two medium yellow squares in it. This block also has a medium yellow circle. The medium yellow circle is to the left of and above medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Finally, we have block C to the right of block B. It has two medium yellow triangles and two small yellow circles. Below small yellow circle number one and medium yellow triangle number two there is medium yellow triangle number one. Small yellow circle number one is above and to the left of small yellow circle number two. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow circle or the medium yellow square that is touching the top edge of a block? (a) the medium yellow circle (b) the medium yellow square that is touching the top edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is above Block A and contains two medium yellow squares and a medium yellow circle. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. The medium yellow circle is to the left of and above medium yellow square number two. In block A, the medium yellow square is touching the top edge. Since Block B is above Block A, the medium yellow circle and medium yellow squares are above any object in Block A, including the medium yellow square touching the top edge. Therefore, neither the medium yellow circle nor the medium yellow square that is touching the top edge of block A is below the other medium yellow squares. The object below the medium yellow squares in Block B is the objects in Block A.The object below the medium yellow square touching the top edge of Block A is the small blue circle. The answer is \boxed{D}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain fundamentally misunderstands the question, which asks to compare the relative positions of two specific objects (the medium yellow circle and the medium yellow square touching the top edge of a block) against *any* medium yellow square. Instead, the chain focuses on the vertical stacking of blocks A and B, leading to irrelevant conclusions about what is below objects in Block A.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B is above Block A, the medium yellow circle and medium yellow squares are above any object in Block A, including the medium yellow square touching the top edge.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes the question is asking which object is below the medium yellow squares in Block B, or which object is below the medium yellow square touching the top edge of Block A. The actual question asks: 'Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow circle or the medium yellow square that is touching the top edge of a block?' This requires checking the relative positions of the two specified objects against *any* medium yellow square, not just concluding they are above everything in Block A.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is above Block A, the medium yellow circle and medium yellow squares are above any object in Block A, including the medium yellow square touching the top edge.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow circle or the medium yellow square that is touching the top edge of a block?
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The object below the medium yellow square touching the top edge of Block A is the small blue circle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain introduces a new relationship ('The object below the medium yellow square touching the top edge of Block A is the small blue circle') which is not necessary to answer the specific question asked, and it misinterprets the core comparison required by the question. The question asks if the medium yellow circle OR the medium yellow square touching the top edge is below *a* medium yellow square. This statement attempts to answer a different question.
Answer Span:
The object below the medium yellow square touching the top edge of Block A is the small blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow circle or the medium yellow square that is touching the top edge of a block?
Question #1952
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are two medium blue squares in block A. This block also contains a small blue square. This block also contains a medium black triangle. One big...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are two medium blue squares in block A. This block also contains a small blue square. This block also contains a medium black triangle. One big black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium blue square number one is to the left of and above medium blue square number two. Below the medium black triangle there is the small blue square. A small yellow circle is far from and above the big black square. Block B is above block A. It has one big yellow circle, one small blue circle and one medium blue triangle. This block also contains one small yellow square. The big yellow circle is to the left of and above the medium blue triangle. This object is near to the small blue circle which is to the left of, above and near to the medium blue triangle. To the right of block B there is block C. It contains two small black circles. It also contains one medium black square. Small black circle number one is below small black circle number two. The medium black square is below and to the right of small black circle number two. What is to the right of the small yellow square? a small black circle or a big black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) small black circle
(b) big black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B and C. There are two medium blue squares in block A. This block also contains a small blue square. This block also contains a medium black triangle. One big black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium blue square number one is to the left of and above medium blue square number two. Below the medium black triangle there is the small blue square. A small yellow circle is far from and above the big black square. Block B is above block A. It has one big yellow circle, one small blue circle and one medium blue triangle. This block also contains one small yellow square. The big yellow circle is to the left of and above the medium blue triangle. This object is near to the small blue circle which is to the left of, above and near to the medium blue triangle. To the right of block B there is block C. It contains two small black circles. It also contains one medium black square. Small black circle number one is below small black circle number two. The medium black square is below and to the right of small black circle number two. What is to the right of the small yellow square? a small black circle or a big black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) small black circle
(b) big black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B contains the small yellow square. Block C is to the right of Block B and contains small black circles and a medium black square. Block A which contains the big black square is below block B. Therefore, the small black circles in Block C are to the right of the small yellow square in Block B. The big black square is in Block A, which is below Block B. So the big black square is not to the right of the small yellow square. Based on and , the final answer is $\boxed{A}$.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the locations of the relevant objects (small yellow square in B, small black circles in C, big black square in A). It correctly concludes that the small black circles in C are to the right of the small yellow square in B. However, it dismisses the second option (big black square touching the bottom edge of a block) too quickly without fully evaluating its spatial relationship relative to the small yellow square, which is necessary to compare options (a) and (b).
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The big black square is in Block A, which is below Block B . So the big black square is not to the right of the small yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning correctly identifies the location of the big black square (Block A) and the small yellow square (Block B), but it fails to consider the full description of option (b) in the question: 'a big black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block'. The context states that 'One big black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block [Block A]'. The reasoning concludes the big black square is not to the right without evaluating if the object described in option (b) is spatially to the right, which is a crucial part of answering the question.
Answer Span:
So the big black square is not to the right of the small yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the right of the small yellow square? a small black circle or a big black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #2215
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are one medium black square, one medium black triangle and one small yellow triangle in block A. To the left of a small yellow square is the medi...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are one medium black square, one medium black triangle and one small yellow triangle in block A. To the left of a small yellow square is the medium black square. The small yellow triangle is to the left of and below the small yellow square. The medium black triangle is to the right of and above the yellow object which is to the left of the small yellow square. Block B is below block A. It contains a big black square, a medium blue square and a small yellow square. Above a small black triangle there is the small yellow square. This block also has a small yellow triangle. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. The big black square is below the small yellow square and the small black triangle.. It is to the right of the small yellow triangle. Finally, there is block C which is to the right of block A. It has one small blue triangle and one medium yellow square. Near to and to the left of the medium yellow square there is the small blue triangle. What is below the medium black triangle? a small blue triangle or a small yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) small blue triangle
(b) small yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. There are one medium black square, one medium black triangle, and one small yellow triangle in block A. To the left of a small yellow square is the medium black square. The small yellow triangle is to the left of and below the small yellow square. The medium black triangle is to the right of and above the yellow object which is to the left of the small yellow square. Block B is below block A. It contains a big black square, a medium blue square, and a small yellow square. Above a small black triangle there is the small yellow square. This block also has a small yellow triangle. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. The big black square is below the small yellow square and the small black triangle. It is to the right of the small yellow triangle. Finally, there is block C which is to the right of block A. It has one small blue triangle and one medium yellow square. Near to and to the left of the medium yellow square there is the small blue triangle. What is below the medium black triangle? a small blue triangle or a small yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) small blue triangle
(b) small yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains the medium black triangle. Block B is directly below Block A. Block B contains a small yellow square touching the right edge. Therefore, the object below the medium black triangle is something in Block B. The small yellow square is in Block B, and it is touching the right edge. The small blue triangle is in Block C, which is to the right of Block A, not below it. Thus, the object directly below the medium black triangle is the small yellow square touching the right edge of Block B.
Final Answer: \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the small yellow square in Block B as being below the medium black triangle (which is in Block A, and B is below A). However, it incorrectly dismisses the small blue triangle option by focusing only on the block location rather than the required spatial relationship implied by the question structure, leading to an incomplete evaluation of the options.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The small blue triangle is in Block C, which is to the right of Block A, not below it.
Explanation
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that the small blue triangle is in Block C, but it fails to check if *any* object below the medium black triangle could be the small blue triangle, even if it's not directly below it in the same column. The question asks 'What is below the medium black triangle?', which implies checking the spatial relationship of objects relative to the medium black triangle's vertical position, not just what is directly underneath it in the same column. The reasoning prematurely dismisses the small blue triangle based on its block location (C) without establishing the vertical relationship between Block C and the medium black triangle's vertical position.
Answer Span:
The small blue triangle is in Block C, which is to the right of Block A, not below it.
Reference/Question Span:
What is below the medium black triangle? a small blue triangle or a small yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block?
Question #3098
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one big yellow triangle, one medium yellow square and a small blue circle. The big yellow triangle is above and to the right of a medium ye...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one big yellow triangle, one medium yellow square and a small blue circle. The big yellow triangle is above and to the right of a medium yellow triangle. Above the medium yellow triangle there is the small blue circle. The medium yellow square is touching the top edge of this block. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and above the medium yellow triangle is the medium yellow square. Above block A we have block B with two medium yellow squares in it. This block also has a medium yellow circle. The medium yellow circle is to the left of and above medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Finally, we have block C to the right of block B. It has two medium yellow triangles and two small yellow circles. Below small yellow circle number one and medium yellow triangle number two there is medium yellow triangle number one. Small yellow circle number one is above and to the left of small yellow circle number two. What is to the right of the object which is touching the bottom edge of a block? a big object or a medium thing which is touching the top edge of a block?
(a) big object
(b) medium thing which is touching the top edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:**
There are three blocks. We call them A, B, and C. Block A has one big yellow triangle, one medium yellow square, and a small blue circle. The big yellow triangle is above and to the right of a medium yellow triangle. Above the medium yellow triangle there is the small blue circle. The medium yellow square is touching the top edge of this block. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and above the medium yellow triangle is the medium yellow square. Above block A we have block B with two medium yellow squares in it. This block also has a medium yellow circle. The medium yellow circle is to the left of and above medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Finally, we have block C to the right of block B. It has two medium yellow triangles and two small yellow circles. Below small yellow circle number one and medium yellow triangle number two there is medium yellow triangle number one. Small yellow circle number one is above and to the left of small yellow circle number two. What is to the right of the object which is touching the bottom edge of a block? a big object or a medium thing which is touching the top edge of a block?
(a) big object
(b) medium thing which is touching the top edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
In Block A, the object touching the bottom edge is the medium yellow triangle. The objects in Block A to the right of the medium yellow triangle are the big yellow triangle and the small blue circle. Since Block B is above Block A and Block C is to the right of Block B, neither Block B's medium yellow squares nor Block C's objects are directly to the right of the medium yellow triangle in Block A. The question asks what is to the right of the object touching the bottom edge. The big yellow triangle is a big object and the medium yellow square is a medium thing touching the top edge of Block A. However, only the big yellow triangle is to the right of the medium yellow triangle.
Therefore, the answer is \boxed{A}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the object touching the bottom edge of Block A (medium yellow triangle) but then incorrectly restricts the search space for what is 'to the right' of it, failing to consider the spatial relationship between blocks A, B, and C as described in the context, which is crucial for answering the final question about objects in relation to the object touching the bottom edge of *a* block.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The objects in Block A to the right of the medium yellow triangle are the big yellow triangle and the small blue circle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain fails to correctly identify the object touching the bottom edge of *a* block, which is the premise for the final question. The question asks what is to the right of the object touching the bottom edge of *a* block. Block A has the medium yellow triangle touching the bottom edge. The reasoning then incorrectly limits the scope to objects *in Block A* to the right of this object, ignoring the possibility that the object to the right could be in Block B or C, or that the object touching the bottom edge could be in Block C.
Answer Span:
The objects in Block A to the right of the medium yellow triangle are the big yellow triangle and the small blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the right of the object which is touching the bottom edge of a block? a big object or a medium thing which is touching the top edge of a block?
Question #11
There are three blocks, A, B and C. A medium yellow triangle, one big black square and a big blue square are in block A. This block also contains one medium black circle. The medium black circle is to...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. A medium yellow triangle, one big black square and a big blue square are in block A. This block also contains one medium black circle. The medium black circle is to the right of the big black square and the big blue square. The medium yellow triangle is far from the big blue square. This block also has a big blue triangle. It is touching the right edge of this block. Near to the big blue triangle is the medium black circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the big black square there is the medium yellow triangle. To the left of block A we have block B with a medium yellow circle and a medium yellow triangle in it. It also has one big yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is above and to the left of the big yellow triangle. The medium yellow circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the big yellow triangle. Above block A there is block C which contains one small black square and one medium blue circle. To the left of the medium blue circle is the small black square. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow triangle? the big blue triangle or the medium yellow circle?
(a) the big blue triangle
(b) the medium yellow circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B and C. A medium yellow triangle, one big black square and a big blue square are in block A. This block also contains one medium black circle. The medium black circle is to the right of the big black square and the big blue square. The medium yellow triangle is far from the big blue square. This block also has a big blue triangle. It is touching the right edge of this block. Near to the big blue triangle is the medium black circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the big black square there is the medium yellow triangle. To the left of block A we have block B with a medium yellow circle and a medium yellow triangle in it. It also has one big yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is above and to the left of the big yellow triangle. The medium yellow circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the big yellow triangle. Above block A there is block C which contains one small black square and one medium blue circle. To the left of the medium blue circle is the small black square. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow triangle? the big blue triangle or the medium yellow circle?
(a) the big blue triangle
(b) the medium yellow circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a medium yellow triangle touching the right edge, a big blue triangle also touching the right edge, a big black square, a big blue square touching the bottom edge, and a medium black circle. Block B is to the left of Block A and contains a medium yellow circle and a medium yellow triangle. Block C is above Block A. The question asks what is to the right of a medium yellow triangle. Since both the medium yellow triangle and the big blue triangle are touching the right edge of Block A, nothing is to the right of the medium yellow triangle within Block A. The medium yellow circle is in Block B, which is to the left of Block A, so it's not to the right of the medium yellow triangle. Therefore, the answer is the big blue triangle, because they are both touching the right edge of block A.
Final Answer: \boxed{(a)}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly interprets the spatial constraints provided in the context, leading to a flawed deduction about the relative positions of objects touching the right edge of Block A. It ignores the need to check the explicit positional relationship between the medium yellow triangle and the big blue triangle.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since both the medium yellow triangle and the big blue triangle are touching the right edge of Block A, nothing is to the right of the medium yellow triangle within Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes that because both objects are touching the right edge, nothing can be to the right of the medium yellow triangle. The question asks which object *is* to the right of the medium yellow triangle, implying a relative position check between the two candidate objects (big blue triangle or medium yellow circle) and the medium yellow triangle, regardless of the block edge.
Answer Span:
Since both the medium yellow triangle and the big blue triangle are touching the right edge of Block A, nothing is to the right of the medium yellow triangle within Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium yellow triangle? the big blue triangle or the medium yellow circle?
contradictionhigh
Statement
Therefore, the answer is the big blue triangle, because they are both touching the right edge of block A.
Explanation
The conclusion that the big blue triangle is the answer is based on flawed reasoning (that they are both touching the right edge means nothing is to the right of the triangle). Furthermore, the context does not explicitly state the relative position between the medium yellow triangle and the big blue triangle *within* Block A, only that both touch the right edge. The reasoning chain jumps to a conclusion based on an incorrect interpretation of the edge constraint.
Answer Span:
Therefore, the answer is the big blue triangle, because they are both touching the right edge of block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium yellow triangle? the big blue triangle or the medium yellow circle?
Question #128
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block C is to the left of B. Block A has one small yellow circle, one small blue square and one big yellow circle. One small...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block C is to the left of B. Block A has one small yellow circle, one small blue square and one big yellow circle. One small black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. The big yellow circle is above and to the left of the small black square.. Below and near to the small blue square which is above the small black square there is the small yellow circle. It is to the right of the circle which is above the small black square. Block B has a medium yellow triangle and one small yellow circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of and below the small yellow circle. Block C has two big yellow triangles. One medium blue triangle is also in this block. There is also a big black square touching the right edge of this block. The medium blue triangle is to the left of, above and near to the big black square. Big yellow triangle number one is to the left of, far from and above the big black square. This block also has a small black square. Big yellow triangle number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow triangle? the big yellow circle or the small blue square?
(a) the big yellow circle
(b) the small blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block C is to the left of B. Block A has one small yellow circle, one small blue square and one big yellow circle. One small black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. The big yellow circle is above and to the left of the small black square.. Below and near to the small blue square which is above the small black square there is the small yellow circle. It is to the right of the circle which is above the small black square. Block B has a medium yellow triangle and one small yellow circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of and below the small yellow circle. Block C has two big yellow triangles. One medium blue triangle is also in this block. There is also a big black square touching the right edge of this block. The medium blue triangle is to the left of, above and near to the big black square. Big yellow triangle number one is to the left of, far from and above the big black square. This block also has a small black square. Big yellow triangle number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow triangle? the big yellow circle or the small blue square? (a) the big yellow circle (b) the small blue square (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
The question asks what is to the left of the medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is in Block B. Block C is to the left of Block B. Block A is to the left of Block C. Thus, the order of the blocks from left to right is A, C, B. The small blue square and the big yellow circle are both in Block A. Since Block A is to the left of Block B, both the small blue square and the big yellow circle are to the left of the medium yellow triangle. Therefore, the answer is {C}.
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the location of the medium yellow triangle (Block B) and uses the established block order (A, C, B) to determine that objects in Block A (where the big yellow circle and small blue square are located) are to the left of Block B. This aligns with the spatial constraints provided.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1559
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block C and it is below block A. Block A contains two medium blue circles. To the left of medium blue circle number two the...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block C and it is below block A. Block A contains two medium blue circles. To the left of medium blue circle number two there is medium blue circle number one. Block B contains one medium black square and one big blue triangle. The medium black square is above a medium blue circle. The medium blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below and to the left of the big blue triangle. Block C contains two medium yellow squares and two other big black circles. Medium yellow square number one is above big black circle number one. Medium yellow square number two is touching the right edge of this block. Big black circle number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is below big black circle number two. It is near to and to the left of medium yellow square number two. Which object is to the right of a big blue object? the medium blue circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block B is to the left of block C and it is below block A. Block A contains two medium blue circles. To the left of medium blue circle number two there is medium blue circle number one. Block B contains one medium black square and one big blue triangle. The medium black square is above a medium blue circle. The medium blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below and to the left of the big blue triangle. Block C contains two medium yellow squares and two other big black circles. Medium yellow square number one is above big black circle number one. Medium yellow square number two is touching the right edge of this block. Big black circle number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is below big black circle number two. It is near to and to the left of medium yellow square number two. Which object is to the right of a big blue object? the medium blue circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B contains a big blue triangle. Block B is to the left of Block C, and Block C contains medium yellow square number two, which is touching the right edge of Block C. The medium blue circle is touching the bottom edge of Block B and is below and to the left of the big blue triangle in Block B. Since Block C is to the right of Block B, the medium yellow square touching the right edge of Block C is to the right of the big blue triangle in Block B. Also, the medium blue circle is touching the bottom edge of Block B and is, therefore, not to the right of the big blue triangle in Block B but to its left and below. Thus, only the medium yellow square is to the right of a big blue object (triangle).
Final Answer: \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relevant objects (big blue triangle, medium blue circle, medium yellow square) and their relative positions based on the context to answer the final question.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1887
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C and block C is below B. Block A has one big blue circle, one big black square and one big yellow triangle. Above, to the right of and near...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C and block C is below B. Block A has one big blue circle, one big black square and one big yellow triangle. Above, to the right of and near to a medium black square which is to the left of and below the big yellow triangle there is the big blue circle. This block also has a big black circle. The big black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of the medium object which is to the left of the big yellow triangle. Block B contains one big yellow circle, a big blue square and one big yellow triangle. The big yellow circle is to the right of and above the big yellow triangle. This shape is touching the right edge of this block. Above the big yellow triangle is the big blue square. And block C has one small yellow circle, a small yellow square and a big yellow circle. To the left of the small yellow square and the big yellow circle there is the small yellow circle. The big yellow circle is touching the right edge of this block. The small yellow square is below the big yellow circle. What is to the right of the big blue circle? a big yellow circle which is in block B or a big yellow circle which is in block C?
(a) big yellow circle which is in block B
(b) big yellow circle which is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B, and C. Block A is to the left of C and block C is below B. Block A has one big blue circle, one big black square, and one big yellow triangle. Above, to the right of, and near to a medium black square which is to the left of and below the big yellow triangle there is the big blue circle. This block also has a big black circle. The big black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of the medium object which is to the left of the big yellow triangle. Block B contains one big yellow circle, a big blue square, and one big yellow triangle. The big yellow circle is to the right of and above the big yellow triangle. This shape is touching the right edge of this block. Above the big yellow triangle is the big blue square. And block C has one small yellow circle, a small yellow square, and a big yellow circle. To the left of the small yellow square and the big yellow circle there is the small yellow circle. The big yellow circle is touching the right edge of this block. The small yellow square is below the big yellow circle. What is to the right of the big blue circle? a big yellow circle which is in block B or a big yellow circle which is in block C?
(a) big yellow circle which is in block B
(b) big yellow circle which is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A is to the left of Block C, and Block B is above Block C. Block A contains a big blue circle. Block B contains a big yellow circle, and Block C contains a big yellow circle.
Since Block C is to the right of Block A, and Block C contains a big yellow circle, this big yellow circle is to the right of the big blue circle in Block A. This eliminates option (a).
Since Block B is above Block C, it's not directly to the right of Block A. Therefore, the big yellow circle in Block B is not directly to the right of the big blue circle in Block A. This eliminates option (b).
Only the big yellow circle in Block C is to the right of the big blue circle in Block A.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{B}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes that the relative positions of the blocks dictate the relative positions of the objects within them, leading to flawed deductions about what is to the right of the big blue circle. The text only provides one specific spatial relationship involving the big blue circle: 'Above, to the right of and near to a medium black square... there is the big blue circle.' It does not state what is to the right of the big blue circle in relation to objects in other blocks.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block A is to the left of Block C, and Block B is above Block C.
Explanation
The context states 'Block A is to the left of C and block C is below B'. The reasoning incorrectly states 'Block B is above Block C' instead of 'Block C is below B' (or B is above C, which is true, but the reasoning chain uses this spatial relationship to make an incorrect deduction later). More critically, the reasoning chain uses the relative positions of the blocks (A left of C, C below B) to determine the relative position of objects *between* blocks, which is not supported by the text. The text only describes the relative positions of the blocks themselves, not the relative positions of the objects *inside* them, except for one specific relationship.
Answer Span:
Block A is to the left of Block C, and Block B is above Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A is to the left of C and block C is below B.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block C is to the right of Block A, and Block C contains a big yellow circle, this big yellow circle is to the right of the big blue circle in Block A. This eliminates option (a).
Explanation
The reasoning assumes that because Block C is spatially to the right of Block A, the objects inside C are spatially to the right of objects inside A. The question asks what is *to the right of the big blue circle* (which is in A). The only explicit spatial relationship given between an object in A (the big blue circle) and an object in B or C is not provided. The reasoning chain invents a spatial relationship based only on block placement, which is not supported by the text.
Answer Span:
Since Block C is to the right of Block A, and Block C contains a big yellow circle, this big yellow circle is to the right of the big blue circle in Block A. This eliminates option (a).
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the right of the big blue circle?
Question #3493
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the right of A. Block B is above C. Block A contains one small yellow triangle, one small blue circle and a big black square. A big blue triangle is t...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the right of A. Block B is above C. Block A contains one small yellow triangle, one small blue circle and a big black square. A big blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. It is to the right of the small yellow triangle , the big black square and the small blue circle. The small yellow triangle is below the small blue circle. This block also has a big yellow triangle. Block B has a medium yellow circle, one small black square and a big black square. Above the big black square there is the small black square. The medium yellow circle is near to and above the big black square. Block C contains one big black circle, a medium black triangle and a medium blue triangle. To the left of a small yellow square which is to the right of and near to the medium blue triangle there is the big black circle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of the medium blue triangle. This shape is below the small yellow square. Which object is to the right of a big black square? the small yellow square or the medium black triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small yellow square
(b) the medium black triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block C is to the right of A. Block B is above C. Block A contains one small yellow triangle, one small blue circle and a big black square. A big blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. It is to the right of the small yellow triangle , the big black square and the small blue circle. The small yellow triangle is below the small blue circle. This block also has a big yellow triangle. Block B has a medium yellow circle, one small black square and a big black square. Above the big black square there is the small black square. The medium yellow circle is near to and above the big black square. Block C contains one big black circle, a medium black triangle and a medium blue triangle. To the left of a small yellow square which is to the right of and near to the medium blue triangle there is the big black circle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of the medium blue triangle. This shape is below the small yellow square. Which object is to the right of a big black square? the small yellow square or the medium black triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small yellow square
(b) the medium black triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
We are looking for what is to the right of a big black square.
Block A contains a big black square. Block C is to the right of Block A. Block C contains a medium black triangle which is touching the bottom edge. Since Block C is to the right of Block A, the medium black triangle is to the right of the big black square in Block A. So, the medium black triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block is to the right of a big black square.
The small yellow square is also in Block C, and thus to the right of the big black square in Block A. So, the small yellow square is to the right of a big black square.Therefore, since both the medium black triangle and small yellow square are to the right of the big black square, the answer is C.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{C}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that Block C is to the right of Block A, where one big black square is located. However, it fails to consider the big black square in Block B. Furthermore, the reasoning relies on block positioning (C is right of A) to establish object positioning relative to the big black square, rather than checking the explicit positional constraints given in the text for the objects in question (medium black triangle and small yellow square) relative to the big black square.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C contains a medium black triangle which is touching the bottom edge. Since Block C is to the right of Block A, the medium black triangle is to the right of the big black square in Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes the big black square mentioned is in Block A, which is true, but then concludes the medium black triangle in Block C is to the right of it based only on the block positions (C is right of A). It ignores the specific positional relationship between objects *within* the blocks or relative to the big black square itself, which is what the question asks for. More critically, it fails to check if the medium black triangle is *actually* to the right of the big black square based on the context provided for Block C's contents relative to Block A's contents.
Answer Span:
Block C contains a medium black triangle which is touching the bottom edge. Since Block C is to the right of Block A, the medium black triangle is to the right of the big black square in Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C contains one big black circle, a medium black triangle and a medium blue triangle. To the left of a small yellow square which is to the right of and near to the medium blue triangle there is the big black circle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of the medium blue triangle. This shape is below the small yellow square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The small yellow square is also in Block C, and thus to the right of the big black square in Block A. So, the small yellow square is to the right of a big black square.
Explanation
The reasoning correctly places the small yellow square in Block C (by inference from the description of Block C's contents), and Block C is to the right of Block A (where the big black square is). However, the question asks what is to the right of *a* big black square. Block B also contains a big black square. The reasoning only checks the relationship relative to the big black square in Block A, ignoring the big black square in Block B, which is crucial context for determining if the objects are to the right of *a* big black square.
Answer Span:
The small yellow square is also in Block C, and thus to the right of the big black square in Block A. So, the small yellow square is to the right of a big black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has a medium yellow circle, one small black square and a big black square.
Question #12
There are three blocks, A, B and C. A medium yellow triangle, one big black square and a big blue square are in block A. This block also contains one medium black circle. The medium black circle is to...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. A medium yellow triangle, one big black square and a big blue square are in block A. This block also contains one medium black circle. The medium black circle is to the right of the big black square and the big blue square. The medium yellow triangle is far from the big blue square. This block also has a big blue triangle. It is touching the right edge of this block. Near to the big blue triangle is the medium black circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the big black square there is the medium yellow triangle. To the left of block A we have block B with a medium yellow circle and a medium yellow triangle in it. It also has one big yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is above and to the left of the big yellow triangle. The medium yellow circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the big yellow triangle. Above block A there is block C which contains one small black square and one medium blue circle. To the left of the medium blue circle is the small black square. What is below the small shape? a medium black circle or a big blue square?
(a) medium black circle
(b) big blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. A medium yellow triangle, one big black square and a big blue square are in block A. This block also contains one medium black circle. The medium black circle is to the right of the big black square and the big blue square. The medium yellow triangle is far from the big blue square. This block also has a big blue triangle. It is touching the right edge of this block. Near to the big blue triangle is the medium black circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the big black square there is the medium yellow triangle. To the left of block A we have block B with a medium yellow circle and a medium yellow triangle in it. It also has one big yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is above and to the left of the big yellow triangle. The medium yellow circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the big yellow triangle. Above block A there is block C which contains one small black square and one medium blue circle. To the left of the medium blue circle is the small black square. What is below the small shape? a medium black circle or a big blue square?
(a) medium black circle
(b) big blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C is above Block A, and Block C contains a small black square and a medium blue circle. Block A (which is below Block C) contains a medium black circle and a big blue square. The big blue square is touching the bottom edge of Block A. Therefore, the object directly below the small black square (in Block C) is the big blue square in Block A.
The medium black circle is in Block A near the big blue square, but since it is to the right of the big blue square, it is not what is directly below the small black square.
Final Answer: \boxed{b}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the blocks and the objects within them to answer the question about what is below the small black square.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1953
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are two medium blue squares in block A. This block also contains a small blue square. This block also contains a medium black triangle. One big...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are two medium blue squares in block A. This block also contains a small blue square. This block also contains a medium black triangle. One big black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium blue square number one is to the left of and above medium blue square number two. Below the medium black triangle there is the small blue square. A small yellow circle is far from and above the big black square. Block B is above block A. It has one big yellow circle, one small blue circle and one medium blue triangle. This block also contains one small yellow square. The big yellow circle is to the left of and above the medium blue triangle. This object is near to the small blue circle which is to the left of, above and near to the medium blue triangle. To the right of block B there is block C. It contains two small black circles. It also contains one medium black square. Small black circle number one is below small black circle number two. The medium black square is below and to the right of small black circle number two. Which object is to the left of a small black circle? the small blue circle or the medium blue triangle?
(a) the small blue circle
(b) the medium blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. There are two medium blue squares in block A. This block also contains a small blue square. This block also contains a medium black triangle. One big black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium blue square number one is to the left of and above medium blue square number two. Below the medium black triangle there is the small blue square. A small yellow circle is far from and above the big black square. Block B is above block A. It has one big yellow circle, one small blue circle, and one medium blue triangle. This block also contains one small yellow square. The big yellow circle is to the left of and above the medium blue triangle. This object is near to the small blue circle which is to the left of, above, and near to the medium blue triangle. To the right of block B there is block C. It contains two small black circles. It also contains one medium black square. Small black circle number one is below small black circle number two. The medium black square is below and to the right of small black circle number two. Which object is to the left of a small black circle? the small blue circle or the medium blue triangle? (a) the small blue circle (b) the medium blue triangle (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block B contains the small blue circle and the medium blue triangle. Block C is to the right of Block B and contains the small black circles. Since Block B is to the left of Block C, both the small blue circle and the medium blue triangle (which are in Block B) are to the left of the small black circles (which are in Block C). Because the question asks for what object is to the left of *a* small black circle, which can refer to any of the two small black circles. Therefore, the answer is {C}. \boxed{C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the locations of the relevant objects (small blue circle and medium blue triangle in Block B; small black circles in Block C) and uses the positional relationship between Block B and Block C to answer the question about relative position to a small black circle.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #3314
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains one big yellow square, one small yellow circle and one medium black square. Below the medium black square is the big yellow square. ...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains one big yellow square, one small yellow circle and one medium black square. Below the medium black square is the big yellow square. The small yellow circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of the medium black square. The big yellow square is above the small yellow circle. Block B is to the left of block A. It contains two medium blue triangles. It also contains one small blue circle. Above a medium black triangle there is the small blue circle. Medium blue triangle number one is to the right of medium blue triangle number two. To the left of and touching medium blue triangle number two there is the medium black triangle. The small blue circle is above the triangle which is to the right of medium blue triangle number two. Medium blue triangle number one is touching the right edge of this block. Finally, we have block C. It is below block A. It has one big black square. A big blue square is to the right of the big black square. What is to the left of the big yellow square? a big blue square or a medium blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) big blue square
(b) medium blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block A contains one big yellow square, one small yellow circle, and one medium black square. Below the medium black square is the big yellow square. The small yellow circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of the medium black square. The big yellow square is above the small yellow circle. Block B is to the left of block A. It contains two medium blue triangles. It also contains one small blue circle. Above a medium black triangle there is the small blue circle. Medium blue triangle number one is to the right of medium blue triangle number two. To the left of and touching medium blue triangle number two there is the medium black triangle. The small blue circle is above the triangle which is to the right of medium blue triangle number two. Medium blue triangle number one is touching the right edge of this block. Finally, we have block C. It is below block A. It has one big black square. A big blue square is to the right of the big black square. What is to the left of the big yellow square? a big blue square or a medium blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) big blue square
(b) medium blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is to the left of Block A. Block B contains two medium blue triangles: medium blue triangle number one (touching the right edge) and medium blue triangle number two. Since Block B is directly left of Block A and the big yellow square is in Block A, medium blue triangle number one (which is touching the right edge of Block B) is directly to the left of the big yellow square. Block C is below Block A and contains a big black square and a big blue square (to the right of the big black square). Thus, the big blue square and big black square cannot be to the left of the big yellow square since Block C is below not to the left. The answer is therefore {B}. \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the relevant blocks (A and B) but makes an unsupported assumption about the adjacency of objects across the block boundary (B to A) to conclude that medium blue triangle number one is to the left of the big yellow square. It correctly dismisses Block C.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block B is directly left of Block A and the big yellow square is in Block A, medium blue triangle number one (which is touching the right edge of Block B) is directly to the left of the big yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes that because Block B is to the left of Block A, an object touching the right edge of B is immediately to the left of an object in A (the big yellow square). The context only establishes the relative position of the blocks (B is left of A), not the precise alignment or adjacency of the objects within them relative to the block boundary. The question asks what is to the left of the big yellow square, which is located in Block A. The reasoning jumps to the conclusion that an object in Block B must be immediately adjacent to the big yellow square based only on block placement.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is directly left of Block A and the big yellow square is in Block A, medium blue triangle number one (which is touching the right edge of Block B) is directly to the left of the big yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the left of block A.
Question #2085
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is above A. Block A contains one small black circle. It also contains a medium yellow square. It also contains one medium ye...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is above A. Block A contains one small black circle. It also contains a medium yellow square. It also contains one medium yellow circle. The small black circle is above the medium yellow square. To the left of and above the medium yellow square there is the medium yellow circle. Block B has a medium blue circle. There are also one small blue triangle and one small black circle in this block. To the left of the small black circle is the small blue triangle. To the right of and below the small black circle is the medium blue circle. And block C contains two small blue triangles. Small blue triangle number one is touching the top edge of this block. Small blue triangle number two is touching the right edge of this block. Near to and above a big yellow square there is small blue triangle number one. This object is to the left of small blue triangle number two. Which object is above a small black circle? the small blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block or the square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
3
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is above A. Block A contains one small black circle. It also contains a medium yellow square. It also contains one medium yellow circle. The small black circle is above the medium yellow square. To the left of and above the medium yellow square there is the medium yellow circle. Block B has a medium blue circle. There are also one small blue triangle and one small black circle in this block. To the left of the small black circle is the small blue triangle. To the right of and below the small black circle is the medium blue circle. And block C contains two small blue triangles. Small blue triangle number one is touching the top edge of this block. Small blue triangle number two is touching the right edge of this block. Near to and above a big yellow square there is small blue triangle number one. This object is to the left of small blue triangle number two. Which object is above a small black circle? the small blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block or the square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is above Block A and contains a small black circle, a small blue triangle, and a medium blue circle. Block C is to the left of Block B and contains two small blue triangles. Small blue triangle number two is touching the right edge of Block C. Since Block B is above Block A, and Block B contains the small black circle, the objects in Block B are above the objects in Block A. Since Block C is to the left of Block B, small blue triangle number two (touching the right edge of Block C) is not directly above the small black circle in Block B. Therefore, only the small blue triangle in Block B is above the small black circle. The small blue triangle touching the right edge of a block (Block C) is not above the small black circle. The square touching the bottom edge of a block (not mentioned in relation to Block B) is also not above the small black circle in Block B. Thus, the answer is {D}. \boxed{D}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes several logical leaps and ignores crucial positional information needed to answer the question correctly. It correctly establishes Block B is above A, but fails to use the positional constraints within Block A and Block B to determine what is directly above the small black circle in Block B. It also incorrectly concludes the answer is D based on flawed spatial reasoning regarding the options provided.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block B is above Block A and contains a small black circle, a small blue triangle, and a medium blue circle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that Block B is above A and lists some contents, but it omits that Block B also contains 'one small black circle' (which is listed twice in the context, once as 'one small black circle' and once as 'one small black circle' in the list of contents for B, but the reasoning only mentions one instance implicitly). More critically, it fails to mention the specific relationship given for the small black circle in B: 'To the right of and below the small black circle is the medium blue circle.' This relationship is crucial for determining what is above it.
Answer Span:
Block B is above Block A and contains a small black circle, a small blue triangle, and a medium blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has a medium blue circle. There are also one small blue triangle and one small black circle in this block.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The small blue triangle touching the right edge of a block (Block C) is not above the small black circle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that the small blue triangle touching the right edge is in Block C, which is to the left of Block B (where the small black circle is). However, it fails to explicitly check the location of the *other* small blue triangle mentioned in the question: 'the small blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block'. The question asks to compare two specific objects: (a) the small blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block OR (b) the square that is touching the bottom edge of a block. The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes the object in option (a) is the one in Block C and dismisses it, without checking if the object in option (a) could potentially be in Block B or if the object in option (b) could be in Block A.
Answer Span:
The small blue triangle touching the right edge of a block (Block C) is not above the small black circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is above a small black circle? the small blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block or the square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #2583
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is to the right of A and block C is above B. Block A contains a medium black circle. It also has a medium yellow triangle. This block also contains one medi...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is to the right of A and block C is above B. Block A contains a medium black circle. It also has a medium yellow triangle. This block also contains one medium black square. It is to the left of and above the medium black circle. The medium black circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium yellow triangle is below the medium black circle. It is to the right of the medium black square. Block B has one big yellow square and a small black square. There is also a big black square touching the right edge of this block. This shape is below and to the right of the small black square. The big yellow square is below the square which is below the small black square. And block C contains a big yellow triangle, one big blue square and one small black square. The big blue square is below and near to the small black square. The big yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. This shape is above the big blue square. It is to the right of the small black square. Which object is above a big black square? the circle which is touching the right edge of a block or the big blue square?
(a) the circle which is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the big blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block B is to the right of A and block C is above B. Block A contains a medium black circle. It also has a medium yellow triangle. This block also contains one medium black square. It is to the left of and above the medium black circle. The medium black circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium yellow triangle is below the medium black circle. It is to the right of the medium black square. Block B has one big yellow square and a small black square. There is also a big black square touching the right edge of this block. This shape is below and to the right of the small black square. The big yellow square is below the square which is below the small black square. And block C contains a big yellow triangle, one big blue square and one small black square. The big blue square is below and near to the small black square. The big yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. This shape is above the big blue square. It is to the right of the small black square. Which object is above a big black square? the circle which is touching the right edge of a block or the big blue square? (a) the circle which is touching the right edge of a block (b) the big blue square (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block B contains the big black square, and Block C is above Block B. Block C contains the big blue square. Thus, the big blue square is above the big black square. Block A, which is to the left of Block B, contains the circle touching the right edge. Since Block A is not above Block B, the circle is not above the big black square. Therefore, only the big blue square is above the big black square.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{B}$
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the locations of the big black square (Block B) and the big blue square (Block C, which is above B), and the circle (Block A, which is not above B), leading to the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1826
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Me...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below the medium blue square.. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and the medium blue square. Below block A there is block B with a medium blue square and one medium yellow square in it. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square and a medium black square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Below block B there is block C. It has two medium blue squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium blue square number two. It is below the yellow object which is below medium blue square number two. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block B?
(a) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium black square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below the medium blue square.. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and the medium blue square. Below block A there is block B with a medium blue square and one medium yellow square in it. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square and a medium black square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Below block B there is block C. It has two medium blue squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium blue square number two. It is below the yellow object which is below medium blue square number two. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block B?
(a) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium black square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has two medium black squares, a medium blue square, with medium black square number one touching the bottom edge. Below Block A is Block B, which contains a medium black square, a medium blue square, and a medium yellow square, where the medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Below Block B is Block C.
The question asks what is below a medium yellow square. In Block A, medium black square number one is below the medium blue square, not a medium yellow square. In Block B, a medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Therefore, the object below a medium yellow square is the medium black square in Block B.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{B}$
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that the medium black square in Block B is below the medium yellow square in Block B, leading to the correct final answer. However, it incorrectly summarizes the contents of Block B by stating it contains 'a medium black square' as one of its listed contents, which is not explicitly stated in the context for Block B's contents.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Below Block A is Block B, which contains a medium black square, a medium blue square, and a medium yellow square, where the medium black square is below the medium yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain states Block B contains 'a medium black square', but the context specifies Block B contains 'one medium yellow square' and 'a medium blue square' and the medium black square mentioned in Block B is only described in relation to Block A's contents (Block A has two medium black squares, Block B has one medium yellow square and one medium blue square). The context for Block B is: 'Below block A there is block B with a medium blue square and one medium yellow square in it. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square and a medium black square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square.' The reasoning chain incorrectly summarizes the contents of Block B by stating it contains 'a medium black square' when the context only mentions a medium blue square and a medium yellow square *in* Block B, and then describes a medium black square's position relative to them, implying the black square might be in Block B, but the reasoning chain asserts it is *in* Block B as a listed content item, which is not explicitly stated for Block B's contents list.
Answer Span:
Block B, which contains a medium black square, a medium blue square, and a medium yellow square
Reference/Question Span:
Below block A there is block B with a medium blue square and one medium yellow square in it.
Question #1888
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C and block C is below B. Block A has one big blue circle, one big black square and one big yellow triangle. Above, to the right of and near...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C and block C is below B. Block A has one big blue circle, one big black square and one big yellow triangle. Above, to the right of and near to a medium black square which is to the left of and below the big yellow triangle there is the big blue circle. This block also has a big black circle. The big black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of the medium object which is to the left of the big yellow triangle. Block B contains one big yellow circle, a big blue square and one big yellow triangle. The big yellow circle is to the right of and above the big yellow triangle. This shape is touching the right edge of this block. Above the big yellow triangle is the big blue square. And block C has one small yellow circle, a small yellow square and a big yellow circle. To the left of the small yellow square and the big yellow circle there is the small yellow circle. The big yellow circle is touching the right edge of this block. The small yellow square is below the big yellow circle. Which object is to the left of a big yellow circle? the small yellow circle or the big blue square?
(a) the small yellow circle
(b) the big blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C and block C is below B. Block A has one big blue circle, one big black square and one big yellow triangle. Above, to the right of and near to a medium black square which is to the left of and below the big yellow triangle there is the big blue circle. This block also has a big black circle. The big black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of the medium object which is to the left of the big yellow triangle. Block B contains one big yellow circle, a big blue square and one big yellow triangle. The big yellow circle is to the right of and above the big yellow triangle. This shape is touching the right edge of this block. Above the big yellow triangle is the big blue square. And block C has one small yellow circle, a small yellow square and a big yellow circle. To the left of the small yellow square and the big yellow circle there is the small yellow circle. The big yellow circle is touching the right edge of this block. The small yellow square is below the big yellow circle. Which object is to the left of a big yellow circle? the small yellow circle or the big blue square?
(a) the small yellow circle
(b) the big blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C has a small yellow circle, a small yellow square, and a big yellow circle. The small yellow circle is to the left of both the small yellow square and the big yellow circle. Therefore, the small yellow circle is to the left of the big yellow circle in Block C. Block B contains a big yellow circle, a big blue square, and a big yellow triangle. The big blue square is above the big yellow triangle, and the big yellow circle is to the right of and above the big yellow triangle. Since Block A is to the left of Block C () and Block C is below Block B (), the big blue square in Block B is not to the left of any big yellow circle. Therefore, only the small yellow circle is to the left of a big yellow circle.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning correctly identifies that the small yellow circle is to the left of the big yellow circle in Block C based on the context. However, it introduces irrelevant block positioning information (A left of C, C below B) to incorrectly dismiss the big blue square as a potential answer, ignoring the direct positional information provided for the objects within their respective blocks.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block A is to the left of Block C () and Block C is below Block B (), the big blue square in Block B is not to the left of any big yellow circle.
Explanation
The reasoning attempts to use the relative positions of the blocks (A left of C, C below B) to determine the spatial relationship between objects *within* different blocks (big blue square in B vs big yellow circle in C or B). The question asks which object (small yellow circle or big blue square) is to the left of *a* big yellow circle. The small yellow circle is explicitly stated to be to the left of the big yellow circle *in Block C*. The reasoning chain ignores this direct evidence by trying to use the block positioning, which is irrelevant for comparing objects within different blocks unless the question implied a unified coordinate system across all blocks, which it does not. Furthermore, the reasoning concludes the big blue square is not to the left of *any* big yellow circle, which is an unsupported leap based on the block positioning.
Answer Span:
Since Block A is to the left of Block C () and Block C is below Block B (), the big blue square in Block B is not to the left of any big yellow circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A is to the left of C and block C is below B. . . Which object is to the left of a big yellow circle? the small yellow circle or the big blue square?
Question #1825
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Me...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below the medium blue square.. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and the medium blue square. Below block A there is block B with a medium blue square and one medium yellow square in it. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square and a medium black square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Below block B there is block C. It has two medium blue squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium blue square number two. It is below the yellow object which is below medium blue square number two. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below the medium blue square.. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and the medium blue square. Below block A there is block B with a medium blue square and one medium yellow square in it. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square and a medium black square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Below block B there is block C. It has two medium blue squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium blue square number two. It is below the yellow object which is below medium blue square number two. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
In Block A, the medium blue square is above medium black square number two, which is above medium black square number one (touching the bottom edge). Block B is below Block A and contains a medium yellow square above a medium blue square. Block C is below Block B and contains two medium blue squares and a medium yellow square. This medium yellow square is below medium blue square number two, which is above medium blue square number one (touching the bottom edge).
The question asks what is above a medium yellow square.
In Block B, the medium yellow square is above the medium blue square.In Block C, the medium blue square number two is above the medium yellow square.The medium blue square touching the bottom edge of a block is in Block C, and it is not above a medium yellow square. The medium blue square in Block A is above the medium black squares. Therefore, only the medium blue square in Block B is above a medium yellow square.
Final Answer: The final answer is \boxed{D}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain fails to correctly evaluate the two candidate objects against the condition ('above a medium yellow square') across all relevant blocks (A, B, and C) and incorrectly concludes the final answer based on flawed intermediate steps. Specifically, it misinterprets which blue squares are relevant to the options and draws an unsupported conclusion about the blue square touching the bottom edge.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
In Block B, the medium yellow square is above the medium blue square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that the medium yellow square is in Block B, but it fails to check if the medium blue square *in Block A* or the medium blue square *touching the bottom edge of a block* is above *a* medium yellow square, as required by the question. It focuses on Block B's internal structure instead of answering the specific comparison requested.
Answer Span:
In Block B, the medium yellow square is above the medium blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
contradictionhigh
Statement
In Block C, the medium blue square number two is above the medium yellow square.
Explanation
The context states that the medium yellow square in Block C is *below* medium blue square number two, which means medium blue square number two is above the medium yellow square. However, the reasoning chain incorrectly states that the medium blue square touching the bottom edge of a block (which is in Block C, medium blue square number one) is *not* above a medium yellow square, and then concludes that only the medium blue square in Block B is above a medium yellow square, which is an incomplete analysis based on the options provided.
Answer Span:
In Block C, the medium blue square number two is above the medium yellow square. The medium blue square touching the bottom edge of a block is in Block C, and it is not above a medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
It is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium blue square number two. It is below the yellow object which is below medium blue square number two.
Question #2086
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is above A. Block A contains one small black circle. It also contains a medium yellow square. It also contains one medium ye...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is above A. Block A contains one small black circle. It also contains a medium yellow square. It also contains one medium yellow circle. The small black circle is above the medium yellow square. To the left of and above the medium yellow square there is the medium yellow circle. Block B has a medium blue circle. There are also one small blue triangle and one small black circle in this block. To the left of the small black circle is the small blue triangle. To the right of and below the small black circle is the medium blue circle. And block C contains two small blue triangles. Small blue triangle number one is touching the top edge of this block. Small blue triangle number two is touching the right edge of this block. Near to and above a big yellow square there is small blue triangle number one. This object is to the left of small blue triangle number two. Which object is to the right of a thing that is touching the right edge of a block? the small blue triangle which is in block B or the object that is touching the top edge of a block?
(a) the small blue triangle which is in block B
(b) the object that is touching the top edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is above A. Block A contains one small black circle. It also contains a medium yellow square. It also contains one medium yellow circle. The small black circle is above the medium yellow square. To the left of and above the medium yellow square there is the medium yellow circle. Block B has a medium blue circle. There are also one small blue triangle and one small black circle in this block. To the left of the small black circle is the small blue triangle. To the right of and below the small black circle is the medium blue circle. And block C contains two small blue triangles. Small blue triangle number one is touching the top edge of this block. Small blue triangle number two is touching the right edge of this block. Near to and above a big yellow square there is small blue triangle number one. This object is to the left of small blue triangle number two. Which object is to the right of a thing that is touching the right edge of a block? the small blue triangle which is in block B or the object that is touching the top edge of a block?
(a) the small blue triangle which is in block B
(b) the object that is touching the top edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block C is to the left of Block B, and small blue triangle number two is touching the right edge of Block C. Therefore, anything in Block B is to the right of small blue triangle number two.
The small blue triangle is in Block B, so it is to the right of small blue triangle number two. This confirms the first option.
Small blue triangle number one is touching the top edge of Block C. Since it is in Block C, it cannot be to the right of small blue triangle number two, which also touches the edge of Block C. This eliminates the second option.
Therefore, only the first option is correct.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that SBT #2 is touching the right edge of Block C. However, it incorrectly reasons about option (b) by ignoring the crucial context that SBT #1 is to the *left* of SBT #2, leading to a flawed elimination of option (b).
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Small blue triangle number one is touching the top edge of Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning claims SBT #1 is touching the top edge of Block C. The context states SBT #1 is touching the top edge of *this block* (referring to Block C, which is true), but then it incorrectly uses this fact to eliminate option (b) based on a false premise about its location relative to SBT #2.
Answer Span:
Small blue triangle number one is touching the top edge of Block C. Since it is in Block C, it cannot be to the right of small blue triangle number two, which also touches the edge of Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Small blue triangle number one is touching the top edge of this block.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Small blue triangle number one is touching the top edge of Block C. Since it is in Block C, it cannot be to the right of small blue triangle number two, which also touches the edge of Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly concludes that because SBT #1 is in Block C, it cannot be to the right of SBT #2. The question asks about the object touching the right edge of *a block* (which is SBT #2 in Block C), and whether SBT #1 (which is in Block C) is to the right of that object. The reasoning fails to establish the relative positions of SBT #1 and SBT #2 within Block C, which is necessary to answer the question about option (b). The context states: 'This object [SBT #1] is to the left of small blue triangle number two.' This crucial positional information is ignored when evaluating option (b).
Answer Span:
Small blue triangle number one is touching the top edge of Block C. Since it is in Block C, it cannot be to the right of small blue triangle number two, which also touches the edge of Block C. This eliminates the second option.
Reference/Question Span:
This object is to the left of small blue triangle number two.
Question #2216
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are one medium black square, one medium black triangle and one small yellow triangle in block A. To the left of a small yellow square is the medi...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are one medium black square, one medium black triangle and one small yellow triangle in block A. To the left of a small yellow square is the medium black square. The small yellow triangle is to the left of and below the small yellow square. The medium black triangle is to the right of and above the yellow object which is to the left of the small yellow square. Block B is below block A. It contains a big black square, a medium blue square and a small yellow square. Above a small black triangle there is the small yellow square. This block also has a small yellow triangle. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. The big black square is below the small yellow square and the small black triangle.. It is to the right of the small yellow triangle. Finally, there is block C which is to the right of block A. It has one small blue triangle and one medium yellow square. Near to and to the left of the medium yellow square there is the small blue triangle. What is above the big thing? a medium black square or a small yellow square?
(a) medium black square
(b) small yellow square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. There are one medium black square, one medium black triangle and one small yellow triangle in block A. To the left of a small yellow square is the medium black square. The small yellow triangle is to the left of and below the small yellow square. The medium black triangle is to the right of and above the yellow object which is to the left of the small yellow square. Block B is below block A. It contains a big black square, a medium blue square and a small yellow square. Above a small black triangle there is the small yellow square. This block also has a small yellow triangle. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. The big black square is below the small yellow square and the small black triangle.. It is to the right of the small yellow triangle. Finally, there is block C which is to the right of block A. It has one small blue triangle and one medium yellow square. Near to and to the left of the medium yellow square there is the small blue triangle. What is above the big thing? a medium black square or a small yellow square?
(a) medium black square
(b) small yellow square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is below Block A. Block B contains a big black square. Block A contains a medium black square and a small yellow square. Since the question asks what is above the big black square (the big thing) in Block B, and Block A is above Block B, we look at the contents of Block A. Block A has both a medium black square and a small yellow square, and the question specifies that the small yellow triangle is below this square. Since both objects are in Block A, which is above Block B, both the medium black square and small yellow square can be considered above the big black square. Therefore, the answer is {C}.
\boxed{C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly lists the contents of Block A by including a small yellow square, which is only mentioned in Block B. This error leads to an incorrect justification for why both options might be above the big black square.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block A contains a medium black square and a small yellow square.
Explanation
The context states Block A contains 'one medium black square, one medium black triangle and one small yellow triangle'. It does not mention a small yellow square in Block A.
Answer Span:
Block A contains a medium black square and a small yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
There are one medium black square, one medium black triangle and one small yellow triangle in block A.
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block A has both a medium black square and a small yellow square, and the question specifies that the small yellow triangle is below this square.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly claims Block A contains a small yellow square and then uses a relationship involving the small yellow triangle and 'this square' (implying the small yellow square) to justify the conclusion. The context states Block A has a small yellow triangle, but not a small yellow square.
Answer Span:
Block A has both a medium black square and a small yellow square, and the question specifies that the small yellow triangle is below this square.
Reference/Question Span:
There are one medium black square, one medium black triangle and one small yellow triangle in block A.
Question #1069
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of blocks C and B. Block A has one medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this bloc...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of blocks C and B. Block A has one medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. There is also one small blue triangle touching the right edge of this block. Near to and above the medium yellow triangle is the small blue triangle. Block B has one medium yellow square, a big yellow circle and a big blue circle. The medium yellow square is below a big blue triangle. To the right of the big blue circle is the big yellow circle. This object is near to and to the left of the big blue triangle. The medium yellow square is to the right of the big blue circle. The big blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. And block C has one medium blue triangle, one big yellow circle and a small blue triangle. To the right of and near to the big yellow circle which is to the right of and below the small blue triangle is the medium blue triangle. What is to the right of the medium blue triangle? a medium yellow triangle that is touching the right edge of a block or a small blue triangle?
(a) medium yellow triangle that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) small blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block A is to the right of blocks C and B. Block A has one medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. There is also one small blue triangle touching the right edge of this block. Near to and above the medium yellow triangle is the small blue triangle. Block B has one medium yellow square, a big yellow circle and a big blue circle. The medium yellow square is below a big blue triangle. To the right of the big blue circle is the big yellow circle. This object is near to and to the left of the big blue triangle. The medium yellow square is to the right of the big blue circle. The big blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. And block C has one medium blue triangle, one big yellow circle and a small blue triangle. To the right of and near to the big yellow circle which is to the right of and below the small blue triangle is the medium blue triangle. What is to the right of the medium blue triangle? a medium yellow triangle that is touching the right edge of a block or a small blue triangle?
(a) medium yellow triangle that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) small blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C contains a medium blue triangle, a big yellow circle, and a small blue triangle. The medium blue triangle is to the right of the big yellow circle, which is to the right of and below the small blue triangle. Block A is to the right of Block C. Block A contains a medium yellow triangle touching its right edge and a small blue triangle also touching its right edge. The small blue triangle is above the medium yellow triangle. Since Block A is to the right of Block C, both the medium yellow triangle and the small blue triangle (which are in Block A) are to the right of the medium blue triangle (which is in Block C). Thus, both are to the right of the medium blue triangle.
Final Answer: \boxed{C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in Block C and Block A and uses the positional information (Block A is to the right of C) to determine that the objects in A are to the right of the object in C, leading to the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2376
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One big black circle is in block A. There is also a big yellow square touching the right edge of this block. The big yellow square is far from and to the right of t...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One big black circle is in block A. There is also a big yellow square touching the right edge of this block. The big yellow square is far from and to the right of the big black circle. Then, there is block B. It contains one big yellow circle, one big black triangle and a big blue square. To the left of, below and near to the big blue square there is the big yellow circle. Below the big blue square there is the big black triangle. Finally, we have block C which is to the right of block A. Block B is to the right of it. It contains one small blue circle, one big blue triangle and a small black square. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It also has a small yellow square. This object is to the right of the small black square. The small blue circle is above the small black square and the big blue triangle. To the right of and below the small object which is to the right of the small black square is the big blue triangle. What is to the right of the small blue circle? a big blue square or a yellow thing that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) big blue square
(b) yellow thing that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block A contains one big black circle. There is also a big yellow square touching the right edge of this block. The big yellow square is far from and to the right of the big black circle. Then, there is block B. It contains one big yellow circle, one big black triangle and a big blue square. To the left of, below and near to the big blue square there is the big yellow circle. Below the big blue square there is the big black triangle. Finally, we have block C which is to the right of block A. Block B is to the right of it. It contains one small blue circle, one big blue triangle and a small black square. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It also has a small yellow square. This object is to the right of the small black square. The small blue circle is above the small black square and the big blue triangle. To the right of and below the small object which is to the right of the small black square is the big blue triangle. What is to the right of the small blue circle? a big blue square or a yellow thing that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) big blue square
(b) yellow thing that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
We are given that Block C is to the right of Block A, and Block B is to the right of Block C. Therefore, Block B is to the right of Block A. Block C contains the small blue circle. Since Block B is to the right of Block C, objects in Block B are to the right of objects in Block C. Block B contains the big blue square. Therefore, the big blue square is to the right of the small blue circle. Block A contains the big yellow square which touches the right edge of Block A. However, Block A is not to the right of Block C. Thus, the big yellow square is not to the right of the small blue circle.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{A}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains a direct contradiction regarding the relative positions of blocks B and C, which invalidates the subsequent spatial deduction about the big blue square being to the right of the small blue circle. It also fails to utilize the specific positional constraints within Block C necessary to answer the question.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
We are given that Block C is to the right of Block A, and Block B is to the right of Block C.
Explanation
The context states: 'Finally, we have block C which is to the right of block A. Block B is to the right of it.' 'It' refers to block A, meaning Block B is to the right of Block A, not Block C. The reasoning incorrectly states Block B is to the right of Block C.
Answer Span:
Block B is to the right of C
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the right of it
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C contains the small blue circle.
Explanation
The reasoning correctly identifies that Block C contains the small blue circle, but it fails to use the positional information given for the small blue circle within Block C to determine what is to its right. The question asks what is to the right of the small blue circle, which requires knowing its position relative to other objects *within* Block C, or relative to objects in Block B/A if they are spatially related in a way that matters for the final question.
Answer Span:
Block C contains the small blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Finally, we have block C which is to the right of block A. Block B is to the right of it. It contains one small blue circle, one big blue triangle and a small black square.
Question #784
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is above block A and below block C. Block A contains a medium yellow triangle, one medium black square and a medium black circle. The medium ...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is above block A and below block C. Block A contains a medium yellow triangle, one medium black square and a medium black circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium yellow triangle is below the medium black circle. This shape is below and to the right of the medium black square. Block B has a big blue triangle, one medium blue square and one small black square. One small yellow triangle is also touching the right edge of this block. It is touching and above the medium blue square. The big blue triangle is to the left of the triangle which is touching the medium blue square. It is far from and above the medium blue square. Block C contains a big blue square. To the right of a small black square there is a medium blue circle.. Near to and below the small black square there is the big blue square. This shape is above the circle which is to the right of the small black square. Which object is below a small black square? the medium blue square or the big blue square?
(a) the medium blue square
(b) the big blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block B is above block A and below block C. Block A contains a medium yellow triangle, one medium black square and a medium black circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium yellow triangle is below the medium black circle. This shape is below and to the right of the medium black square. Block B has a big blue triangle, one medium blue square and one small black square. One small yellow triangle is also touching the right edge of this block. It is touching and above the medium blue square. The big blue triangle is to the left of the triangle which is touching the medium blue square. It is far from and above the medium blue square. Block C contains a big blue square. To the right of a small black square there is a medium blue circle.. Near to and below the small black square there is the big blue square. This shape is above the circle which is to the right of the small black square. Which object is below a small black square? the medium blue square or the big blue square?
(a) the medium blue square
(b) the big blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B contains the small black square, a medium blue square, and a big blue triangle. Block C, which is above Block B, contains a big blue square. The question asks what is below the small black square. Since Block C is above Block B, the big blue square (in Block C) is below the small black square (in Block B). The medium blue square is in the same block as the small black square, so it cannot be below it. Therefore, the answer is {B}. \boxed{b}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the contents of Block B and C but makes a critical logical error regarding vertical positioning. It incorrectly concludes that an object in the upper block (C) is below an object in the lower block (B).
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block C, which is above Block B, contains a big blue square.
Explanation
The context states Block B is below Block C, meaning C is above B. However, the reasoning then incorrectly concludes that because C is above B, the big blue square (in C) is below the small black square (in B). This is a logical error based on the spatial relationship established, but the primary factual error is the subsequent deduction.
Answer Span:
Since Block C is above Block B, the big blue square (in Block C) is below the small black square (in Block B).
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is above block A and below block C.
contradictionhigh
Statement
Since Block C is above Block B, the big blue square (in Block C) is below the small black square (in Block B).
Explanation
If Block C is above Block B, objects in C cannot be below objects in B unless specified otherwise. The reasoning incorrectly uses the vertical stacking (C above B) to conclude that an object in C (big blue square) is below an object in B (small black square).
Answer Span:
Since Block C is above Block B, the big blue square (in Block C) is below the small black square (in Block B).
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is above block A and below block C.
Question #1747
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. A small yellow circle is in block A. Block B is to the right of block A. It has two medium yellow triangles. Above and near to a medium yellow square i...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. A small yellow circle is in block A. Block B is to the right of block A. It has two medium yellow triangles. Above and near to a medium yellow square is medium yellow triangle number two. There is also one medium black circle in this block. It also contains a small blue circle. The small blue circle is below and touching medium yellow triangle number two. Below and to the right of medium yellow triangle number two is the medium black circle. To the right of block A there is block C which has two medium yellow squares. It also contains one medium yellow triangle. It also contains a medium yellow circle. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of and below the medium yellow circle there is the medium yellow triangle. Near to, to the left of and below the medium yellow circle is medium yellow square number two. What is to the right of the small yellow circle? a medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a medium yellow square which is in block B?
(a) medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium yellow square which is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. A small yellow circle is in block A. Block B is to the right of block A. It has two medium yellow triangles. Above and near to a medium yellow square is medium yellow triangle number two. There is also one medium black circle in this block. It also contains a small blue circle. The small blue circle is below and touching medium yellow triangle number two. Below and to the right of medium yellow triangle number two is the medium black circle. To the right of block A there is block C which has two medium yellow squares. It also contains one medium yellow triangle. It also contains a medium yellow circle. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of and below the medium yellow circle there is the medium yellow triangle. Near to, to the left of and below the medium yellow circle is medium yellow square number two. What is to the right of the small yellow circle? a medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a medium yellow square which is in block B?
(a) medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium yellow square which is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
The small yellow circle is in Block A. Block B is to the right of Block A and contains medium yellow triangles, a medium yellow square, a medium black circle, and a small blue circle. Block C is also to the right of Block A and contains a medium yellow triangle, a medium yellow circle, and two medium yellow squares, one of which touches the bottom edge.
Since the question asks what is to the right of the small yellow circle (in Block A), and both Block B and Block C are to the right of Block A, the possible answers are objects within Block B or Block C.
Block B contains a medium yellow square. Block C contains a medium yellow square touching the bottom edge. Both of these meet the criteria of being to the right of the small yellow circle.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{C}$
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the location of the small yellow circle (Block A) and that the objects to its right must be in Block B or C. However, it incorrectly states that Block B contains a medium yellow square, which is not supported by the context, leading to an error in evaluating option (b).
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block B contains a medium yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain claims Block B contains a medium yellow square, but the context only lists the contents of Block B as: 'two medium yellow triangles' and 'one medium black circle' and 'a small blue circle'. It does not mention a medium yellow square in Block B.
Answer Span:
Block B contains a medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the right of block A. It has two medium yellow triangles. . . There is also one medium black circle in this block. It also contains a small blue circle.
Question #2592
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. This object is below medium black square number two. Medium bla...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. This object is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below medium black square number two. This shape is below the medium blue square. Then, we have block B. It contains two medium blue squares. It also has one medium black square. Below medium blue square number two there is the medium black square. Below medium blue square number two is medium blue square number one. Below medium blue square number one there is the medium black square. Block C is to the right of block A. Block B is to the left of it. It contains a medium blue square and a medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium black square. Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. This object is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below medium black square number two. This shape is below the medium blue square. Then, we have block B. It contains two medium blue squares. It also has one medium black square. Below medium blue square number two there is the medium black square. Below medium blue square number two is medium blue square number one. Below medium blue square number one there is the medium black square. Block C is to the right of block A. Block B is to the left of it. It contains a medium blue square and a medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium black square. Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has two medium black squares and a medium blue square. Block C is to the right of Block A and Block B is to the left of Block C. So Block A is to the left of Block C and thus Block A’s medium blue square can not be to the right of Block C. The answer is {B}. Block C contains a medium black square and a medium blue square below it and touching the bottom edge. Block C is to the right of Block A. So the medium blue square of Block C is to the right of Block A, which contains the black squares.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{B}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain fails to correctly address the question, which asks which object is to the right of *a medium black square*. It focuses too much on the relative positions of the blocks (A, B, C) and makes an irrelevant deduction about Block A's blue square relative to Block C, rather than analyzing the internal structure of the blocks as described in the context.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C is to the right of Block A and Block B is to the left of Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning chain correctly states the relative positions of A, B, and C, but it fails to use the crucial information about the contents of Block C when determining the final answer, instead relying on an incorrect deduction about Block A's contents relative to Block C.
Answer Span:
Block C is to the right of Block A and Block B is to the left of Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C is to the right of block A. Block B is to the left of it.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
So Block A’s medium blue square can not be to the right of Block C.
Explanation
This deduction is irrelevant and based on a flawed premise derived from ignoring the actual question: 'Which object is to the right of a medium black square?'. The reasoning chain jumps to conclusions about relative block positions instead of analyzing the internal structure relative to the black squares within each block.
Answer Span:
So Block A’s medium blue square can not be to the right of Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #3492
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the right of A. Block B is above C. Block A contains one small yellow triangle, one small blue circle and a big black square. A big blue triangle is t...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the right of A. Block B is above C. Block A contains one small yellow triangle, one small blue circle and a big black square. A big blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. It is to the right of the small yellow triangle , the big black square and the small blue circle. The small yellow triangle is below the small blue circle. This block also has a big yellow triangle. Block B has a medium yellow circle, one small black square and a big black square. Above the big black square there is the small black square. The medium yellow circle is near to and above the big black square. Block C contains one big black circle, a medium black triangle and a medium blue triangle. To the left of a small yellow square which is to the right of and near to the medium blue triangle there is the big black circle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of the medium blue triangle. This shape is below the small yellow square. What is above the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block? a big black square or a small yellow triangle?
(a) big black square
(b) small yellow triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the right of A. Block B is above C. Block A contains one small yellow triangle, one small blue circle and a big black square. A big blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. It is to the right of the small yellow triangle , the big black square and the small blue circle. The small yellow triangle is below the small blue circle. This block also has a big yellow triangle. Block B has a medium yellow circle, one small black square and a big black square. Above the big black square there is the small black square. The medium yellow circle is near to and above the big black square. Block C contains one big black circle, a medium black triangle and a medium blue triangle. To the left of a small yellow square which is to the right of and near to the medium blue triangle there is the big black circle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of the medium blue triangle. This shape is below the small yellow square. What is above the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block? a big black square or a small yellow triangle?
(a) big black square
(b) small yellow triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C contains the medium black triangle which is touching the bottom edge. Block B is above Block C. Block B contains a big black square. Since the medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of Block C and Block B (containing the big black square) is above Block C, then the big black square is above the shape that is touching the bottom edge of Block C (medium black triangle). The small yellow triangle is in Block A, which is not above Block C. Therefore, the answer is \boxed{A}.
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the shape touching the bottom edge (medium black triangle in C) and correctly determines what is above it (the contents of Block B, which includes a big black square). It correctly dismisses the small yellow triangle as being in Block A.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1073
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is above A and block A is to the right of C. Block A has a big yellow triangle. There is also a big blue square touching the right edge of this...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is above A and block A is to the right of C. Block A has a big yellow triangle. There is also a big blue square touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is above the big yellow triangle. Block B has one medium black square and one small yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of and below the small yellow square. Block C contains two big yellow circles. This block also has a big black circle. There is also a medium blue square in this block. It also has one small blue triangle. Big yellow circle number two is touching the top edge of this block. To the right of, near to and below big yellow circle number one there is a big black square. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of and near to the big black circle is the medium blue square. This object is below big yellow circle number two. Which object is to the left of a big blue square? the medium black square or the big black circle that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the medium black square
(b) the big black circle that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block B is above A and block A is to the right of C. Block A has a big yellow triangle. There is also a big blue square touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is above the big yellow triangle. Block B has one medium black square and one small yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of and below the small yellow square. Block C contains two big yellow circles. This block also has a big black circle. There is also a medium blue square in this block. It also has one small blue triangle. Big yellow circle number two is touching the top edge of this block. To the right of, near to and below big yellow circle number one there is a big black square. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of and near to the big black circle is the medium blue square. This object is below big yellow circle number two. Which object is to the left of a big blue square? the medium black square or the big black circle that is touching the right edge of a block? (a) the medium black square (b) the big black circle that is touching the right edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains the big blue square. Block A is to the right of Block C. Block B is above Block A. Block C contains the big black circle. Since Block C is to the left of Block A, the big black circle in Block C is to the left of the big blue square in Block A. The medium black square is in Block B which is above Block A, not to the left of it. Thus, only the big black circle is to the left of the big blue square. The big black circle is not touching the right edge of Block C; a big yellow circle is.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{B}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the location of the big blue square (Block A) and the big black circle (Block C) and correctly deduces the horizontal relationship between them (C is left of A). However, it fails to properly evaluate the medium black square's position relative to the big blue square, concluding it's not to the left based only on vertical stacking, which ignores the possibility of horizontal overlap. It also introduces an irrelevant and potentially contradictory statement about the right edge of Block C.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The medium black square is in Block B which is above Block A, not to the left of it.
Explanation
The reasoning chain fails to check if the medium black square is to the left of the big blue square, which is located in Block A. The context states the medium black square is in Block B. The reasoning concludes it's not to the left based on vertical positioning (Block B is above A), but it never checks the horizontal relationship between the object in B and the object in A, which is necessary to answer the question.
Answer Span:
The medium black square is in Block B which is above Block A, not to the left of it.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the left of a big blue square? the medium black square or the big black circle that is touching the right edge of a block?
contradictionlow
Statement
The big black circle is not touching the right edge of Block C; a big yellow circle is.
Explanation
The reasoning chain introduces a claim about what is touching the right edge of Block C, which is irrelevant to the question, and then contradicts itself by stating a fact about Block C's contents that is not directly relevant to the comparison being made in the question.
Answer Span:
The big black circle is not touching the right edge of Block C; a big yellow circle is.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C contains two big yellow circles. This block also has a big black circle.
Question #783
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is above block A and below block C. Block A contains a medium yellow triangle, one medium black square and a medium black circle. The medium ...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is above block A and below block C. Block A contains a medium yellow triangle, one medium black square and a medium black circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium yellow triangle is below the medium black circle. This shape is below and to the right of the medium black square. Block B has a big blue triangle, one medium blue square and one small black square. One small yellow triangle is also touching the right edge of this block. It is touching and above the medium blue square. The big blue triangle is to the left of the triangle which is touching the medium blue square. It is far from and above the medium blue square. Block C contains a big blue square. To the right of a small black square there is a medium blue circle.. Near to and below the small black square there is the big blue square. This shape is above the circle which is to the right of the small black square. What is above the medium yellow triangle? a big blue square or a medium blue circle?
(a) big blue square
(b) medium blue circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block B is above block A and below block C. Block A contains a medium yellow triangle, one medium black square and a medium black circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium yellow triangle is below the medium black circle. This shape is below and to the right of the medium black square. Block B has a big blue triangle, one medium blue square and one small black square. One small yellow triangle is also touching the right edge of this block. It is touching and above the medium blue square. The big blue triangle is to the left of the triangle which is touching the medium blue square. It is far from and above the medium blue square. Block C contains a big blue square. To the right of a small black square there is a medium blue circle.. Near to and below the small black square there is the big blue square. This shape is above the circle which is to the right of the small black square. What is above the medium yellow triangle? a big blue square or a medium blue circle?
(a) big blue square
(b) medium blue circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains the medium yellow triangle. Block B is above Block A. Block B contains a big blue triangle, a medium blue square, and a small black square. Block C is above Block B and contains a big blue square. Since Block B is directly above Block A, the shapes in Block B are above the medium yellow triangle in Block A. Therefore, the objects above the medium yellow triangle are the big blue triangle, the medium blue square, and the small black square (all in Block B). Neither the big blue square (in Block C) nor the medium blue circle (not mentioned in any block) are directly above the medium yellow triangle.
Thus, the answer is \boxed{(d) none of them}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the block hierarchy (A < B < C) and correctly identifies the contents of Block A. However, it makes an unsupported assumption about direct vertical alignment when concluding what is 'above' the object in A, and it incorrectly claims the medium blue circle is not mentioned in any block, ignoring context placing it in Block C.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C is above Block B and contains a big blue square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes Block C is *directly* above Block B, but the context only states the relative vertical stacking of the blocks (B is above A and below C), not that C is *directly* above B. More importantly, the reasoning chain incorrectly concludes that the objects in Block B are *directly* above the medium yellow triangle, which is a crucial step in answering the question, but the context only establishes the block hierarchy, not the direct vertical alignment of all objects within those blocks.
Answer Span:
Block C is above Block B and contains a big blue square. Since Block B is directly above Block A, the shapes in Block B are above the medium yellow triangle in Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is above block A and below block C.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Neither the big blue square (in Block C) nor the medium blue circle (not mentioned in any block) are directly above the medium yellow triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly states the medium blue circle is 'not mentioned in any block'. The context states: 'Block C contains a big blue square. To the right of a small black square there is a medium blue circle.' This places the medium blue circle in Block C, even if its exact vertical position relative to the triangle in A is unknown. Ignoring the presence of the medium blue circle in Block C is a failure to use context.
Answer Span:
Neither the big blue square (in Block C) nor the medium blue circle (not mentioned in any block) are directly above the medium yellow triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C contains a big blue square. To the right of a small black square there is a medium blue circle.
Question #2593
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. This object is below medium black square number two. Medium bla...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. This object is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below medium black square number two. This shape is below the medium blue square. Then, we have block B. It contains two medium blue squares. It also has one medium black square. Below medium blue square number two there is the medium black square. Below medium blue square number two is medium blue square number one. Below medium blue square number one there is the medium black square. Block C is to the right of block A. Block B is to the left of it. It contains a medium blue square and a medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium black square. Which object is below a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. This object is belowmedium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is belowmedium black square number two. This shape is below the medium blue square. Then, we have block B. It contains two medium blue squares. It also has one medium black square. Belowmedium blue square number two there is the medium black square. Belowmedium blue square number two is medium blue square number one. Belowmedium blue square number one there is the medium black square. Block C is to the right of block A. Block B is to the left of it. It contains a medium blue square and a medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium black square. Which object is below a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
In Block A, the medium blue square is below the two medium black squares (, , , ). So, the medium blue square is below a medium black square.
In Block B, the medium black square is below the two medium blue squares.
In Block C, the medium blue square is below the medium black square and touching the bottom edge (). So, the medium blue square is below a medium black square.The medium blue square in Block A andthe medium blue square in Block C are both below a medium black square.
\boxed{C}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that the medium blue square in Block A is below a medium black square (based on the context that it is below MBS #2). It also correctly identifies that the medium blue square in Block C is below a medium black square. However, the description of the relationship in Block A is an overgeneralization/contradiction of the specific positional data provided. The final conclusion (C) is correct based on the actual facts, despite the flawed intermediate step for Block A.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
In Block A, the medium blue square is below the two medium black squares (, , , ).
Explanation
The context states the medium blue square in Block A is below medium black square number two, but it does not state it is below *both* medium black squares. Furthermore, the context states the medium blue square is below the medium black square number one, but it doesn't specify the relationship to medium black square number one relative to medium black square number two.
Answer Span:
the medium blue square is below the two medium black squares
Reference/Question Span:
This object is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below medium black square number two. This shape is below the medium blue square.
contradictionlow
Statement
In Block C, the medium blue square is below the medium black square and touching the bottom edge().
Explanation
The context states the medium blue square in Block C is touching the bottom edge, and that *another object* (implied to be the medium black square based on the next sentence) is above it, but it does not explicitly state the medium blue square is *below* the medium black square in Block C. The context says: 'The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium black square.' The 'This object' refers to the medium blue square, meaning the medium black square is above the medium blue square, which means the medium blue square is below the medium black square. However, the reasoning chain incorrectly implies the medium blue square is below the medium black square *and* touching the bottom edge, which is true, but the reasoning chain then concludes it is below a medium black square based on this, which is correct, but the initial statement about Block A was flawed.
Answer Span:
In Block C, the medium blue square is below the medium black square and touching the bottom edge()
Reference/Question Span:
Block C is to the right of block A. Block B is to the left of it. It contains a medium blue square and a medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium black square.
Question #1546
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium blue squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. Th...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium blue squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. The medium yellow square is below the medium black square. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. The medium yellow square is below medium blue square number one which is below the medium black square. It is below medium blue square number two. Then, there is block B with one medium yellow square in it. There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square. Below block A and to the left of block B there is block C. It contains one medium black square and one medium blue square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is in block B?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium blue squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. The medium yellow square is below the medium black square. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. The medium yellow square is below medium blue square number one which is below the medium black square. It is below medium blue square number two. Then, there is block B with one medium yellow square in it. There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square. Below block A and to the left of block B there is block C. It contains one medium black square and one medium blue square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is in block B?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a medium black square, two medium blue squares, and a medium yellow square touching the bottom edge. Block B (which is to the right of Block C) contains a medium yellow square. Block C contains a medium black square. Since Block C is below Block A and to the left of Block B, only the medium yellow square in Block B is to the right of the medium black square in Block C. The medium yellow square in Block A is above Block C, not to its right. Therefore, the answer is {B}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the objects in each block but makes an assumption about the relative horizontal positioning of Block B to Block C that is not explicitly stated as a direct fact, although it is implied by the context. Crucially, the reasoning chain correctly identifies the relevant black square (in C) and the two yellow squares being compared (one touching A's bottom edge, one in B) and uses the spatial relationship (left/right) to eliminate one option, leading to the correct conclusion based on the implied layout.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block B (which is to the right of Block C) contains a medium yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain introduces the positional relationship between Block B and Block C ('to the right of Block C') without grounding it in the context, which only states 'Below block A and to the left of block B there is block C.' The relative horizontal position of B to C is not explicitly stated as 'B is to the right of C' in the context, although it is implied by C being 'to the left of block B'. However, the reasoning chain uses this relationship to justify the final answer, and the context only establishes C's position relative to A and B, not B's position relative to C.
Answer Span:
Block B (which is to the right of Block C) contains a medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Below block A and to the left of block B there is block C.
Question #2582
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is to the right of A and block C is above B. Block A contains a medium black circle. It also has a medium yellow triangle. This block also contains one medi...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is to the right of A and block C is above B. Block A contains a medium black circle. It also has a medium yellow triangle. This block also contains one medium black square. It is to the left of and above the medium black circle. The medium black circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium yellow triangle is below the medium black circle. It is to the right of the medium black square. Block B has one big yellow square and a small black square. There is also a big black square touching the right edge of this block. This shape is below and to the right of the small black square. The big yellow square is below the square which is below the small black square. And block C contains a big yellow triangle, one big blue square and one small black square. The big blue square is below and near to the small black square. The big yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. This shape is above the big blue square. It is to the right of the small black square. What is to the right of the medium black square? a medium yellow triangle or a big black square?
(a) medium yellow triangle
(b) big black square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block B is to the right of A and block C is above B. Block A contains a medium black circle. It also has a medium yellow triangle. This block also contains one medium black square. It is to the left of and above the medium black circle. The medium black circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium yellow triangle is below the medium black circle. It is to the right of the medium black square. Block B has one big yellow square and a small black square. There is also a big black square touching the right edge of this block. This shape is below and to the right of the small black square. The big yellow square is below the square which is below the small black square. And block C contains a big yellow triangle, one big blue square and one small black square. The big blue square is below and near to the small black square. The big yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. This shape is above the big blue square. It is to the right of the small black square. What is to the right of the medium black square? a medium yellow triangle or a big black square? (a) medium yellow triangle (b) big black square (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a medium black square, a medium black circle, and a medium yellow triangle. The medium black square is to the left of and above the medium black circle, and the medium yellow triangle is below the medium black circle and to the right of the medium black square. Block B is to the right of Block A, and contains a big black square. Since the medium yellow triangle is explicitly stated as being to the right of the medium black square (within Block A), the answer is medium yellow triangle. The big black square is in Block B, which is to the right of Block A as a whole, not specifically to the right of the medium black square.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relationship between the medium black square and the medium yellow triangle within Block A based on the context and uses this to answer the question.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #3047
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is above and C is to the right of A. Block A has a small black square and one medium black triangle. To the left of and near to the medium bl...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is above and C is to the right of A. Block A has a small black square and one medium black triangle. To the left of and near to the medium black triangle there is the small black square. Block B has one medium yellow circle and one big yellow triangle. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of, above and near to the big yellow triangle is the medium yellow circle. Block C contains one small blue square and one small yellow triangle. There is also a small yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also contains a small yellow circle. To the right of the small blue square which is near to and to the right of the small yellow triangle is the small yellow circle. Below the small yellow triangle there is the small yellow square. The small yellow circle is to the right of and below the small yellow triangle. Which object is above a small black square? the small yellow square or the big yellow triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small yellow square
(b) the big yellow triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B and C. Block B is above A and C is to the right of A. Block A has a small black square and one medium black triangle. To the left of and near to the medium black triangle there is the small black square. Block B has one medium yellow circle and one big yellow triangle. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of, above and near to the big yellow triangle is the medium yellow circle. Block C contains one small blue square and one small yellow triangle. There is also a small yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also contains a small yellow circle. To the right of the small blue square which is near to and to the right of the small yellow triangle is the small yellow circle. Below the small yellow triangle there is the small yellow square. The small yellow circle is to the right of and below the small yellow triangle. Which object is above a small black square? the small yellow square or the big yellow triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small yellow square
(b) the big yellow triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains the small black square. Block B is above Block A. Block B contains the big yellow triangle and medium yellow circle. Since Block B is directly above Block A, the object directly above the small black square is something from Block B. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of Block B, so the big yellow triangle is above the small black square. The small yellow square is in Block C, which is to the right of Block A, not above it. Therefore, the answer is {B}. \boxed{b}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the location of the objects and uses the positional information (B is above A) to determine which objects are above the small black square (which is in A). The conclusion that the big yellow triangle is above the small black square is supported by the chain.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1074
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is above A and block A is to the right of C. Block A has a big yellow triangle. There is also a big blue square touching the right edge of this...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is above A and block A is to the right of C. Block A has a big yellow triangle. There is also a big blue square touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is above the big yellow triangle. Block B has one medium black square and one small yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of and below the small yellow square. Block C contains two big yellow circles. This block also has a big black circle. There is also a medium blue square in this block. It also has one small blue triangle. Big yellow circle number two is touching the top edge of this block. To the right of, near to and below big yellow circle number one there is a big black square. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of and near to the big black circle is the medium blue square. This object is below big yellow circle number two. What is above the big yellow triangle? a medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a medium blue square?
(a) medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block B is above A and block A is to the right of C. Block A has a big yellow triangle. There is also a big blue square touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is above the big yellow triangle. Block B has one medium black square and one small yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of and below the small yellow square. Block C contains two big yellow circles. This block also has a big black circle. There is also a medium blue square in this block. It also has one small blue triangle. Big yellow circle number two is touching the top edge of this block. To the right of, near to and below big yellow circle number one there is a big black square. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of and near to the big black circle is the medium blue square. This object is below big yellow circle number two. What is above the big yellow triangle? a medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a medium blue square?
(a) medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a big yellow triangle. Above the big yellow triangle is a big blue square. Block B is above Block A, and Block B contains a medium black square and a small yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of Block B. Since Block B is directly above Block A, the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block B is directly above the big yellow triangle in Block A. The medium blue square is in Block C, and Block C is to the left of Block A, not above it. Therefore, the object above the big yellow triangle is the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block B.
The answer is $\boxed{A}$.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies that the big blue square is above the big yellow triangle, but it incorrectly concludes that the medium black square in Block B is above the triangle based on block positioning, ignoring the explicit statement that the big blue square is above the triangle. The reasoning chain fails to use the most direct piece of information regarding what is above the triangle.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B is directly above Block A, the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block B is directly above the big yellow triangle in Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes that because Block B is above Block A, the objects *within* Block B are directly above the objects *within* Block A based on their relative positions within their respective blocks. The context only states the relationship between the blocks ('Block B is above A') and the relationship between the triangle and the square ('The big blue square is above the big yellow triangle'). It does not establish that the medium black square in B is above the big yellow triangle in A.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is directly above Block A, the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block B is directly above the big yellow triangle in Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is above A
Question #1560
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block C and it is below block A. Block A contains two medium blue circles. To the left of medium blue circle number two the...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block C and it is below block A. Block A contains two medium blue circles. To the left of medium blue circle number two there is medium blue circle number one. Block B contains one medium black square and one big blue triangle. The medium black square is above a medium blue circle. The medium blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below and to the left of the big blue triangle. Block C contains two medium yellow squares and two other big black circles. Medium yellow square number one is above big black circle number one. Medium yellow square number two is touching the right edge of this block. Big black circle number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is below big black circle number two. It is near to and to the left of medium yellow square number two. What is above the triangle? a medium blue circle or a medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) medium blue circle
(b) medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:**
There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block B is to the left of block C and it is below block A. Block A contains two medium blue circles. To the left of medium blue circle number two there is medium blue circle number one. Block B contains one medium black square and one big blue triangle. The medium black square is above a medium blue circle. The medium blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below and to the left of the big blue triangle. Block C contains two medium yellow squares and two other big black circles. Medium yellow square number one is above big black circle number one. Medium yellow square number two is touching the right edge of this block. Big black circle number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is below big black circle number two. It is near to and to the left of medium yellow square number two. What is above the triangle? a medium blue circle or a medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) medium blue circle
(b) medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block B contains the big blue triangle. Block A is above Block B and contains two medium blue circles. Since Block B is below Block A, the objects in Block A (the medium blue circles) are above the big blue triangle in Block B. Block C is to the right of Block B, so the medium yellow square touching the right edge of Block C is not above the triangle in Block B. The medium yellow squares are in block C which is not above the triangle in question. Therefore, the object above the triangle is a medium blue circle.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: excellent
The reasoning correctly identifies the location of the triangle (Block B) and the objects above it (Block A contains medium blue circles). It correctly dismisses the objects in Block C as not being above the triangle in Block B. The reasoning chain accurately reflects the spatial relationships provided in the context.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #187
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block B is to the right of A. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black squa...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block B is to the right of A. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue square is medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two and the medium blue square is medium black square number one. Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two is a medium black square. Below the medium black square is medium yellow square number one. It is below medium yellow square number two. Block C has one medium yellow square and one medium blue square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is in block B or the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium black square that is in block B
(b) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block B is to the right of A. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue square is medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two and the medium blue square is medium black square number one. Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two is a medium black square. Below the medium black square is medium yellow square number one. It is below medium yellow square number two. Block C has one medium yellow square and one medium blue square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is in block B or the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block? (a) the medium black square that is in block B (b) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
From the question, we know that Block B is to the right of Block A, and Block A is to the left of Block C. Therefore, the blocks are arranged A, B, C.
Block A has two medium black squares and a medium blue square. Medium black square number oneis at the bottom edge of Block A.
Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is at the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square is below medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium black square.
Block C has a medium yellow square and a medium blue square, with the medium yellow square at the bottom.
The question asks what is below a medium yellow square. In Block B, the medium black square is below medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number oneis at the bottom of Block B. The medium black square is in Block B.
In Block A, the medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge. Since we are looking for what is below a medium yellow square, and the medium black square in Block B fits this description, the answer is the medium black square that is in block B.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{A}$
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the relevant information in Block B to answer the question. However, it includes irrelevant details about Block A's structure, which slightly muddies the focus, although it doesn't lead to an incorrect final conclusion based on the provided options.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextlow
Statement
Medium black square number one is at the bottom edge of Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning states this fact about Block A, but the question asks what is below a medium yellow square. The structure of Block A is irrelevant to answering the final question, which focuses on objects below medium yellow squares (which are present in B and C).
Answer Span:
Medium black square number one is at the bottom edge of Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is in block B or the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
missing_contextlow
Statement
In Block A, the medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge.
Explanation
The reasoning brings up Block A's structure again when evaluating the options, even though the options relate to Block B or a square touching the bottom edge of *a* block (which could be A, B, or C). Focusing on Block A's structure here is irrelevant to determining which option (a or b) is correct based on the constraints provided for B and C.
Answer Span:
In Block A, the medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is in block B or the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #3313
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains one big yellow square, one small yellow circle and one medium black square. Below the medium black square is the big yellow square. ...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains one big yellow square, one small yellow circle and one medium black square. Below the medium black square is the big yellow square. The small yellow circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of the medium black square. The big yellow square is above the small yellow circle. Block B is to the left of block A. It contains two medium blue triangles. It also contains one small blue circle. Above a medium black triangle there is the small blue circle. Medium blue triangle number one is to the right of medium blue triangle number two. To the left of and touching medium blue triangle number two there is the medium black triangle. The small blue circle is above the triangle which is to the right of medium blue triangle number two. Medium blue triangle number one is touching the right edge of this block. Finally, we have block C. It is below block A. It has one big black square. A big blue square is to the right of the big black square. What is above the big blue square? a medium black square or a big black square?
(a) medium black square
(b) big black square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B and C. Block A contains one big yellow square, one small yellow circle and one medium black square. Below the medium black square is the big yellow square. The small yellow circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of the medium black square. The big yellow square is above the small yellow circle. Block B is to the left of block A. It contains two medium blue triangles. It also contains one small blue circle. Above a medium black triangle there is the small blue circle. Medium blue triangle number one is to the right of medium blue triangle number two. To the left of and touching medium blue triangle number two there is the medium black triangle. The small blue circle is above the triangle which is to the right of medium blue triangle number two. Medium blue triangle number one is touching the right edge of this block. Finally, we have block C. It is below block A. It has one big black square. A big blue square is to the right of the big black square. What is above the big blue square? a medium black square or a big black square?
(a) medium black square
(b) big black square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a medium black square, a big yellow square below it, and a small yellow circle at the bottom. Block B is to the left of Block A, and Block C is below Block A. Block C contains a big black square and a big blue square to its right. Since Block C is below Block A, and Block A contains the medium black square, the medium black square is above the big blue square in Block C. Therefore, the answer is {A}. \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsupported leap in spatial logic by assuming that the vertical arrangement of objects within Block A dictates the vertical arrangement relative to objects in Block C, which is located below A. The context does not provide information about what is above the big blue square in Block C.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block C is below Block A, and Block A contains the medium black square, the medium black square is above the big blue square in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes a direct vertical relationship between objects in Block A and objects in Block C simply because Block C is below Block A. The context only describes the relative positions of objects *within* their respective blocks (A, B, or C) or the relative positions *between* blocks (A relative to B, A relative to C). It does not state that the medium black square in A is directly above the big blue square in C.
Answer Span:
the medium black square is above the big blue square in Block C
Reference/Question Span:
Block C. It is below block A.
Question #3226
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains one big blue triangle and a big blue square. The big blue triangle is to the right of the big blue square. Block B is below block A. It has one big y...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains one big blue triangle and a big blue square. The big blue triangle is to the right of the big blue square. Block B is below block A. It has one big yellow circle. To the right of block A there is block C with a medium yellow circle, a small yellow circle and one medium yellow square in it. The medium yellow circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a small black square. Above the medium yellow square is the small yellow circle. The medium yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. A big yellow square is touching the left edge of this block. Far from and to the right of the big yellow square there is the medium yellow square.. The small yellow circle is to the right of the big yellow square. Below the big yellow square there is the medium yellow circle. Which object is below a big yellow square? the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block or the circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains one big blue triangle and a big blue square. The big blue triangle is to the right of the big blue square. Block B is below block A. It has one big yellow circle. To the right of block A there is block C with a medium yellow circle, a small yellow circle and one medium yellow square in it. The medium yellow circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a small black square. Above the medium yellow square is the small yellow circle. The medium yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. A big yellow square is touching the left edge of this block. Far from and to the right of the big yellow square there is the medium yellow square.. The small yellow circle is to the right of the big yellow square. Below the big yellow square there is the medium yellow circle. Which object is below a big yellow square? the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block or the circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block? (a) the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block (b) the circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block C is to the right of Block A. Block C has a big yellow square touching its left edge (), a medium yellow square touching its right edge (), and a medium yellow circle touching its bottom edge (). The medium yellow circle is below the big yellow square. Block B is below Block A and contains a big yellow circle. Since the question asks what is below the big yellow square in Block C, and the medium yellow circle is below the big yellow square in that block, the answer is the circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block. The medium yellow square is to the right of, not below, the big yellow square.
Final Answer: \boxed{b}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the object below the big yellow square based on the context ('Below the big yellow square there is the medium yellow circle'). However, it makes an unsupported assertion about the medium yellow square touching the right edge of Block C, which is a minor hallucination/misinterpretation of the list of contents. The final conclusion based on the correct piece of evidence is sound.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C has a big yellow square touching its left edge (), a medium yellow square touching its right edge (), and a medium yellow circle touching its bottom edge ().
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly states that Block C has a medium yellow square touching its right edge. The context states: 'To the right of block A there is block C with a medium yellow circle, a small yellow circle and one medium yellow square in it. ... A big yellow square is touching the left edge of this block.' It does not explicitly state the medium yellow square is touching the right edge; it only lists the contents.
Answer Span:
a medium yellow square touching its right edge
Reference/Question Span:
To the right of block A there is block C with a medium yellow circle, a small yellow circle and one medium yellow square in it. ... A big yellow square is touching the left edge of this block.
contradictionlow
Statement
The medium yellow circle is below the big yellow square.
Explanation
The context explicitly states the relationship between the big yellow square and the medium yellow circle: 'Below the big yellow square there is the medium yellow circle.' The reasoning chain states this fact correctly, but then uses it to support the conclusion that the circle touching the bottom edge is the answer. However, the question asks which object is below the big yellow square: 'the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block or the circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?'. The context states the medium yellow circle is touching the bottom edge of the block. The reasoning chain correctly identifies that the medium yellow circle is below the big yellow square, but the structure of the reasoning implies this is the only object below it, which is not explicitly contradicted, but the subsequent claim about the medium yellow square is.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow circle is below the big yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Below the big yellow square there is the medium yellow circle.
Question #708
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains one big black circle and a medium blue triangle. To the right of, far from and above the medium blue triangle there is the big black...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains one big black circle and a medium blue triangle. To the right of, far from and above the medium blue triangle there is the big black circle. The medium blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of block A we have block B with one medium blue square and a medium black circle in it. Above a big black triangle there is the medium blue square. It is near to, below and to the right of the medium black circle. To the right of block A there is block C. It contains one medium yellow square and one medium yellow circle. This block also has a big yellow triangle. Above and to the right of a small black square there is the medium yellow square. Above a big yellow square is the medium yellow circle. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Near to and to the right of the medium yellow circle is the medium yellow square. The small black square is to the left of the medium yellow circle. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow circle? the medium yellow square or the small thing?
(a) the medium yellow square
(b) the small thing
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block A contains one big black circle and a medium blue triangle. To the right of, far from and above the medium blue triangle there is the big black circle. The medium blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of block A we have block B with one medium blue square and a medium black circle in it. Above a big black triangle there is the medium blue square. It is near to, below and to the right of the medium black circle. To the right of block A there is block C. It contains one medium yellow square and one medium yellow circle. This block also has a big yellow triangle. Above and to the right of a small black square there is the medium yellow square. Above a big yellow square is the medium yellow circle. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Near to and to the right of the medium yellow circle is the medium yellow square. The small black square is to the left of the medium yellow circle. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow circle? the medium yellow square or the small thing?
(a) the medium yellow square
(b) the small thing
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C contains a medium yellow circle, a medium yellow square, and a small black square. The medium yellow square is near and to the right of the medium yellow circle. The small black square is to the left of the medium yellow circle. Since the question asks what is to the left of the medium yellow circle, and the small black square fulfills this condition, the answer is the small thing.
Final Answer: \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relevant spatial relationship from the context to answer the question.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #300
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. It also has one medium blue square. This shape is below medium black square number two. Medium black square numbe...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. It also has one medium blue square. This shape is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square and medium black square number two. Below block A is block B which has two medium yellow squares. There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium blue square is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. Finally, we have block C. It is to the left of block B. It contains a medium yellow square. This block also has a medium black square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue square that is in block A?
(a) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. It also has one medium blue square. This shape is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square and medium black square number two. Below block A is block B which has two medium yellow squares. There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium blue square is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. Finally, we have block C. It is to the left of block B. It contains a medium yellow square. This block also has a medium black square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue square that is in block A? (a) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block (b) the medium blue square that is in block A (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has a medium blue square and two medium black squares. Block B is below block A and has two medium yellow squares and a medium blue square. Block C is to the left of Block B and contains a medium yellow square and a medium black square.
The question asks what is below a medium yellow square. Specifically, we are looking at the medium yellow square in Block C, since the question does not mention the medium yellow squares in Block B. The medium yellow square in block C is touching the bottom edge of Block C, meaning there is nothing below it within that block. Therefore, the answer is the medium blue square touching the bottom edge of block B.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{A}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly summarizes the contents of the blocks but fails to correctly interpret the scope of the question. It arbitrarily focuses only on the yellow square in Block C and ignores the yellow squares in Block B, which are necessary to evaluate option (a) correctly based on the context provided.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The medium yellow square in block C is touching the bottom edge of Block C, meaning there is nothing below it within that block. Therefore, the answer is the medium blue square touching the bottom edge of block B.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly assumes the question is only asking about the medium yellow square in Block C. The question asks generally 'Which object is below a medium yellow square?' and presents two options involving blue squares. The reasoning ignores the existence and location of the yellow squares in Block B, which are crucial for evaluating option (a).
Answer Span:
The medium yellow square in block C is touching the bottom edge of Block C, meaning there is nothing below it within that block. Therefore, the answer is the medium blue square touching the bottom edge of block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Below block A is block B which has two medium yellow squares. There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium blue square is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two.
Question #709
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains one big black circle and a medium blue triangle. To the right of, far from and above the medium blue triangle there is the big black...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains one big black circle and a medium blue triangle. To the right of, far from and above the medium blue triangle there is the big black circle. The medium blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of block A we have block B with one medium blue square and a medium black circle in it. Above a big black triangle there is the medium blue square. It is near to, below and to the right of the medium black circle. To the right of block A there is block C. It contains one medium yellow square and one medium yellow circle. This block also has a big yellow triangle. Above and to the right of a small black square there is the medium yellow square. Above a big yellow square is the medium yellow circle. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Near to and to the right of the medium yellow circle is the medium yellow square. The small black square is to the left of the medium yellow circle. Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium yellow square or the small thing?
(a) the medium yellow square
(b) the small thing
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block A contains one big black circle and a medium blue triangle. To the right of, far from, and above the medium blue triangle there is the big black circle. The medium blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of block A we have block B with one medium blue square and a medium black circle in it. Above a big black triangle there is the medium blue square. It is near to, below, and to the right of the medium black circle. To the right of block A there is block C. It contains one medium yellow square and one medium yellow circle. This block also has a big yellow triangle. Above and to the right of a small black square there is the medium yellow square. Above a big yellow square is the medium yellow circle. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Near to and to the right of the medium yellow circle is the medium yellow square. The small black square is to the left of the medium yellow circle. Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium yellow square or the small thing?
(a) the medium yellow square
(b) the small thing
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block B is to the left of Block A, and Block C is to the right of Block A. The medium blue square is in Block B. Since Block C is to the right of Block A, and Block A is to the right of Block B, then Block C is also to the right of Block B. The objects in Block C, including the small black square and the medium yellow square, are therefore to the right of the medium blue square in Block B. Therefore, the medium yellow square is to the right of the medium blue square, and the small black square is also to the right of the medium blue square.
Final Answer: \boxed{C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes a critical, unsupported leap in logic by assuming that because Block C is generally to the right of Block B, every object in C is to the right of the medium blue square in B. The context does not provide sufficient relational data to confirm the position of the small black square relative to the medium blue square, making the conclusion that both options are correct unsupported by the source text.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The objects in Block C, including the small black square and the medium yellow square, are therefore to the right of the medium blue square in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes that because Block C is to the right of Block A, and Block A is to the right of Block B, all objects in Block C are to the right of all objects in Block B. The context only describes relative positions *between* specific objects or edges, not the relative position of every object in Block C to every object in Block B. The question asks which object is to the right of the medium blue square, and the context only establishes the relative position of the medium yellow square to the medium yellow circle, and the small black square to the medium yellow circle, not their relation to the medium blue square.
Answer Span:
The objects in Block C, including the small black square and the medium yellow square, are therefore to the right of the medium blue square in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
To the left of block A we have block B with one medium blue square and a medium black circle in it. To the right of block A there is block C. It contains one medium yellow square and one medium yellow circle. This block also has a big yellow triangle.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Therefore, the medium yellow square is to the right of the medium blue square, and the small black square is also to the right of the medium blue square.
Explanation
This conclusion is based on the flawed assumption in the previous step. The context does not explicitly state the position of the small black square relative to the medium blue square. The context only states the small black square is to the left of the medium yellow circle.
Answer Span:
Therefore, the medium yellow square is to the right of the medium blue square, and the small black square is also to the right of the medium blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium yellow square or the small thing?
Question #3126
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is below B. Block C is to the right of A. Block A has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the right edge of this block. M...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is below B. Block C is to the right of A. Block A has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the right edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. Above medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. Block B has one big black square and a big black circle. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. This block also has a small black circle. The big black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big black square is to the right of the big black circle and the small black circle. And block C has one big black triangle. There is also a small yellow circle in this block. Near to and to the left of the big black triangle is the small yellow circle. The big black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the big black triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the small black circle?
(a) the big black triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the small black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is below B. Block C is to the right of A. Block A has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the right edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. Above medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. Block B has one big black square and a big black circle. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. This block also has a small black circle. The big black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big black square is to the right of the big black circle and the small black circle. And block C has one big black triangle. There is also a small yellow circle in this block. Near to and to the left of the big black triangle is the small yellow circle. The big black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the big black triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the small black circle?
(a) the big black triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the small black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains medium yellow squares. Block C is to the right of Block A and contains a big black triangle. Block B, which is above Block A, contains a small black circle. Since Block C is directly to the right of Block A, the big black triangle is to the right of the medium yellow squares. The small black circle is in Block B, which is above Block A, so it is not to the right of the medium yellow squares. Therefore, only the big black triangle is to the right of a medium yellow square.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{A}$
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies that Block C is to the right of A, which contains the medium yellow squares, and correctly links the big black triangle (in C) to being to the right of the medium yellow squares. However, it makes an assumption about the horizontal placement of Block B (containing the small black circle) relative to A, or incorrectly dismisses the small black circle based only on its vertical placement in Block B, ignoring the possibility that Block B might also extend horizontally to the right of A.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block B, which is above Block A, contains a small black circle.
Explanation
The context states Block A is below B, meaning B is above A. However, the reasoning chain incorrectly implies that the small black circle's location relative to the medium yellow squares (in A) is determined by B being *above* A, which is irrelevant to the question asking what is to the *right* of a medium yellow square. More critically, the reasoning chain uses the relative vertical position (B is above A) to dismiss the small black circle, but the crucial missing piece is that the small black circle is in Block B, and we don't know the horizontal relationship between Block B and Block A, only that C is to the right of A.
Answer Span:
The small black circle is in Block B, which is above Block A, so it is not to the right of the medium yellow squares.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A is below B.
Question #2375
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One big black circle is in block A. There is also a big yellow square touching the right edge of this block. The big yellow square is far from and to the right of t...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One big black circle is in block A. There is also a big yellow square touching the right edge of this block. The big yellow square is far from and to the right of the big black circle. Then, there is block B. It contains one big yellow circle, one big black triangle and a big blue square. To the left of, below and near to the big blue square there is the big yellow circle. Below the big blue square there is the big black triangle. Finally, we have block C which is to the right of block A. Block B is to the right of it. It contains one small blue circle, one big blue triangle and a small black square. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It also has a small yellow square. This object is to the right of the small black square. The small blue circle is above the small black square and the big blue triangle. To the right of and below the small object which is to the right of the small black square is the big blue triangle. Which object is to the left of a small blue circle? the big black circle or the big black triangle?
(a) the big black circle
(b) the big black triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B and C. One big black circle is in block A. There is also a big yellow square touching the right edge of this block. The big yellow square is far from and to the right of the big black circle. Then, there is block B. It contains one big yellow circle, one big black triangle and a big blue square. To the left of, below and near to the big blue square there is the big yellow circle. Below the big blue square there is the big black triangle. Finally, we have block C which is to the right of block A. Block B is to the right of it. It contains one small blue circle, one big blue triangle and a small black square. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It also has a small yellow square. This object is to the right of the small black square. The small blue circle is above the small black square and the big blue triangle. To the right of and below the small object which is to the right of the small black square is the big blue triangle. Which object is to the left of a small blue circle? the big black circle or the big black triangle? (a) the big black circle (b) the big black triangle (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
We have three blocks: A, B, and C. Block A contains a big black circle. Block C is to the right of Block A and Block B is to the right of Block C. Therefore, the order of blocks from left to right is A, C, B. Block C contains a small blue circle. We want to know what is to the left of the small blue circle. Since Block C contains the small blue circle and Block A is to the left of Block C, the big black circle is to the left of the small blue circle. Since the big black triangle is in Block B and Block B is to the right of Block C, the big black triangle is to the right and not to the left of the small blue circle. Therefore, only the big black circle is to the left of the small blue circle.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the block order (A, C, B) and the location of the small blue circle (Block C) and the big black circle (Block A). However, it makes an unsubstantiated leap regarding the big black triangle's position relative to the small blue circle based only on block membership and block order, ignoring the specific positional constraints needed to answer the question definitively. The question asks which object is *to the left of* the small blue circle, requiring specific spatial relationships, not just block adjacency.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionlow
Statement
Block C is to the right of Block A and Block B is to the right of Block C.
Explanation
The context states: 'Block C which is to the right of block A. Block B is to the right of it.' This means the order is A, C, B. The reasoning chain correctly deduces A, C, B, but the statement implies the reasoning used this specific sequence as a premise, which is slightly different from the context's phrasing, but the main issue is the next contradiction.
Answer Span:
Block C is to the right of Block A and Block B is to the right of Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C which is to the right of block A. Block B is to the right of it.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since the big black triangle is in Block B and Block B is to the right of Block C, the big black triangle is to the right and not to the left of the small blue circle.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes the big black triangle is in Block B, but the question only states Block B contains the big black triangle. The question asks about the relative position of objects *within* the blocks or *between* blocks based on proximity/directionality clues, not just block membership. Crucially, the reasoning fails to check the specific positional relationship between the big black triangle (in B) and the small blue circle (in C) based on the provided spatial constraints, relying only on block order, which is insufficient for determining 'left of' between objects in different blocks unless explicitly stated or derivable from the block arrangement relative to the objects.
Answer Span:
Since the big black triangle is in Block B and Block B is to the right of Block C, the big black triangle is to the right and not to the left of the small blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the left of a small blue circle? the big black circle or the big black triangle?
Question #2544
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There is a medium yellow square in block A. Above block A there is block B which contains one medium blue triangle and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow t...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There is a medium yellow square in block A. Above block A there is block B which contains one medium blue triangle and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium blue triangle is near to a medium yellow circle. It is above the medium yellow triangle. Below the medium yellow circle is the medium yellow triangle. To the right of block A there is block C with one medium yellow square and a big yellow square in it. A small blue triangle is above the medium yellow square. The medium yellow square is above the big yellow square. The big yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. This object is near to and far from a big blue square. The small blue triangle is to the right of the big blue square. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium yellow triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the big yellow square which is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the big yellow square which is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B and C. There is a medium yellow square in block A. Above block A there is block B which contains one medium blue triangle and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium blue triangle is near to a medium yellow circle. It is above the medium yellow triangle. Below the medium yellow circle is the medium yellow triangle. To the right of block A there is block C with one medium yellow square and a big yellow square in it. A small blue triangle is above the medium yellow square. The medium yellow square is above the big yellow square. The big yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. This object is near to and far from a big blue square. The small blue triangle is to the right of the big blue square. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium yellow triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the big yellow square which is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the big yellow square which is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a medium yellow square. Block B is above Block A and contains a medium yellow triangle (touching the bottom edge) and a medium blue triangle above it. Block C is to the right of Block A and contains a medium yellow square and a big yellow square (touching the right edge) with the medium yellow squareabove the big yellow square. The question asks what is above a medium yellow square. In Block C, the medium yellow square is above the big yellow square. In Block B (above Block A), the medium yellow triangle is present, but it is not abovethe medium yellow square in Block A. Therefore, only the big yellow square is above a medium yellow square.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{B}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly concludes that only the big yellow square is above a medium yellow square by failing to properly evaluate the first option (the medium yellow triangle) against the question's requirement ('Which object is above *a* medium yellow square?'). It incorrectly dismisses the medium yellow triangle based on its location relative to the medium yellow square in Block A, ignoring that the question asks about *any* medium yellow square.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
In Block B (above Block A), the medium yellow triangle is present, but it is not above the medium yellow square in Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning chain fails to check if the medium yellow triangle (which is an option) is above *any* medium yellow square, instead focusing only on the one in Block A and incorrectly concluding the medium yellow triangle is not above it, which is irrelevant to the question asking which object is above *a* medium yellow square.
Answer Span:
In Block B (above Block A), the medium yellow triangle is present, but it is not above the medium yellow square in Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium yellow triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the big yellow square which is touching the right edge of a block?
Question #3048
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is above and C is to the right of A. Block A has a small black square and one medium black triangle. To the left of and near to the medium bl...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is above and C is to the right of A. Block A has a small black square and one medium black triangle. To the left of and near to the medium black triangle there is the small black square. Block B has one medium yellow circle and one big yellow triangle. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of, above and near to the big yellow triangle is the medium yellow circle. Block C contains one small blue square and one small yellow triangle. There is also a small yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also contains a small yellow circle. To the right of the small blue square which is near to and to the right of the small yellow triangle is the small yellow circle. Below the small yellow triangle there is the small yellow square. The small yellow circle is to the right of and below the small yellow triangle. What is to the left of the small yellow circle? a small blue square or a big object that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) small blue square
(b) big object that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block B is above A and C is to the right of A. Block A has a small black square and one medium black triangle. To the left of and near to the medium black triangle there is the small black square. Block B has one medium yellow circle and one big yellow triangle. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of, above and near to the big yellow triangle is the medium yellow circle. Block C contains one small blue square and one small yellow triangle. There is also a small yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also contains a small yellow circle. To the right of the small blue square which is near to and to the right of the small yellow triangle is the small yellow circle. Below the small yellow triangle there is the small yellow square. The small yellow circle is to the right of and below the small yellow triangle. What is to the left of the small yellow circle? a small blue square or a big object that is touching the bottom edge of a block? (a) small blue square (b) big object that is touching the bottom edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block C contains a small blue square, a small yellow triangle, and a small yellow circle. The small yellow circle is to the right of the small blue square, which is to the right of the small yellow triangle. Therefore, the small blue square is directly to the left of the small yellow circle. This eliminates option (b).
Block B has a big yellow triangle touching its bottom edge. However, Block C (containing the small yellow circle) is to the right of Block A, and Block B is above Block A. Thus, neither Block B nor its contents are to the left of the small yellow circle. This eliminates option (b) and (c).
Since the small blue square is directly to the left of the small yellow circle (both in Block C), the answer is the small blue square.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the relevant objects in Block C and uses the positional information provided in the context to determine what is to the left of the small yellow circle. It correctly eliminates the 'big object' option based on location.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #301
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. It also has one medium blue square. This shape is below medium black square number two. Medium black square numbe...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. It also has one medium blue square. This shape is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square and medium black square number two. Below block A is block B which has two medium yellow squares. There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium blue square is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. Finally, we have block C. It is to the left of block B. It contains a medium yellow square. This block also has a medium black square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square. Which object is below a medium black square? the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium yellow square number one?
(a) the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium yellow square number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has two medium black squares. It also has one medium blue square. This shape is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square and medium black square number two. Below block A is block B which has two medium yellow squares. There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium blue square is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. Finally, we have block C. It is to the left of block B. It contains a medium yellow square. This block also has a medium black square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square. Which object is below a medium black square? the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium yellow square number one?
(a) the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium yellow square number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C contains a medium black square, below which is a medium yellow square touching the bottom edge. Block B (below Block A) has two medium yellow squares, one on top of the other, medium yellow square number one being below medium yellow square number two. Since Block C is to the left of Block B, the bottom yellow square in Block C is not directly under any squares in Block B. The question asks what is below a medium black square. The medium black square is in Block C, and the object directly below it is the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of Block C. Therefore, the answer is {A}.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{A}$
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the relevant block (C) for one of the candidates but includes irrelevant details about Block B's internal structure, which doesn't directly help answer the comparison required by the question. However, it correctly identifies the object below the black square in Block C.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block B (below Block A) has two medium yellow squares, one on top of the other, medium yellow square number one being below medium yellow square number two.
Explanation
The reasoning chain describes the arrangement of yellow squares in Block B, but it ignores the crucial context that the question asks about objects below a medium black square, and the arrangement described here (Block B's yellow squares) is irrelevant to the specific comparison required by the question, which focuses on Block C's yellow square and medium yellow square number one.
Answer Span:
Block B (below Block A) has two medium yellow squares, one on top of the other, medium yellow square number one being below medium yellow square number two.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is below a medium black square? the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium yellow square number one?
Question #1154
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium black squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. T...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium black squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium yellow square and medium black square number two. Below the medium yellow square there is medium black square number two. Then, we have block B. It has one medium black square and one medium blue square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. Finally, we have block C which is above block A. Block B is to the right of it. It contains a medium yellow square. This block also has one medium black square. This block also contains a medium blue square. Below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square there is the medium black square. Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square. Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block C or the medium blue square which is in block B?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block C
(b) the medium blue square which is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Two medium black squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium yellow square and medium black square number two. Below the medium yellow square there is medium black square number two. Then, we have block B. It has one medium black square and one medium blue square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. Finally, we have block C which is above block A. Block B is to the right of it. It contains a medium yellow square. This block also has one medium black square. This block also contains a medium blue square. Below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square there is the medium black square. Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square. Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block C or the medium blue square which is in block B?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block C
(b) the medium blue square which is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block B is to the right of Block C. Block C has a medium black square. Block B contains a medium blue square. Therefore, the medium blue square in Block B is to the right of the medium black square in Block C.Block C also has a medium blue square. This medium blue square (in C) is not to the right of the medium black square (also in C); rather, it is above the medium black square.Thus, only the medium blue square in Block B is to the right of a medium black square (the one in Block C).
Final Answer: \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the spatial relationship between the blocks and uses the information about the contents of Block B and Block C to answer the question about which blue square is to the right of a black square.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1545
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium blue squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. Th...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium blue squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. The medium yellow square is below the medium black square. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. The medium yellow square is below medium blue square number one which is below the medium black square. It is below medium blue square number two. Then, there is block B with one medium yellow square in it. There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square. Below block A and to the left of block B there is block C. It contains one medium black square and one medium blue square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. Which object is above a medium blue square? medium blue square number one or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium blue square number one
(b) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium blue squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. The medium yellow square is below the medium black square. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. The medium yellow square is below medium blue square number one which is below the medium black square. It is below medium blue square number two. Then, there is block B with one medium yellow square in it. There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square. Below block A and to the left of block B there is block C. It contains one medium black square and one medium blue square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. Which object is above a medium blue square? medium blue square number one or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium blue square number one
(b) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
In Block A, the arrangement from top to bottom is: medium black square, medium blue square number two, medium blue square number one, and medium yellow square (touching the bottom). This order is determined by combining , , , and . In Block B, the medium yellow square is above the medium blue square (which touches the bottom edge). Finally, in Block C the medium blue square is above the medium black square (which touches the bottom edge). The question asks what is above "a" medium blue square, not specifically which medium blue square. Since medium blue square number one has medium blue square number two above it and the medium blue square in Block B has a medium yellow square above it, the answer is {C}.
\boxed{c}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain attempts to establish a vertical order for Block A which is complex and not fully derived correctly or clearly from the context. More critically, it fails to systematically check both candidate blue squares against the question's requirement. It correctly identifies that B1 has something above it (B2) and the B square in Block B has something above it (Yellow square), but it jumps to conclusion (C) without explicitly confirming that the *other* blue square mentioned in the question (the one touching the bottom edge of a block) is also above *some* medium blue square, which is what option (c) implies.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
In Block A, the arrangement from top to bottom is: medium black square, medium blue square number two, medium blue square number one, and medium yellow square (touching the bottom).
Explanation
The reasoning chain establishes a specific vertical order for Block A that is not fully supported or derived correctly from the context. The context states: 'Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. The medium yellow square is below medium blue square number one which is below the medium black square. It is below medium blue square number two.' This implies the order is Black > B2 > B1 > Yellow, but the reasoning chain presents this as a definitive, established fact without showing the derivation, and the derivation itself seems to misinterpret the complex relative positioning given.
Answer Span:
In Block A, the arrangement from top to bottom is: medium black square, medium blue square number two, medium blue square number one, and medium yellow square (touching the bottom).
Reference/Question Span:
Two medium blue squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. The medium yellow square is below the medium black square. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. The medium yellow square is below medium blue square number one which is below the medium black square. It is below medium blue square number two.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since medium blue square number one has medium blue square number two above it and the medium blue square in Block B has a medium yellow square above it, the answer is {C}.
Explanation
The reasoning claims that medium blue square number one has medium blue square number two above it. The context states: 'Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. The medium yellow square is below medium blue square number one which is below the medium black square. It [medium yellow square] is below medium blue square number two.' This implies B2 is above B1, which supports the claim, but the reasoning chain fails to check the other required object: 'the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block'. The context states for Block B: 'The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square.' This means the medium yellow square is above it. The reasoning correctly identifies that something is above B1 (B2) and something is above the B square in Block B (Yellow square), but it ignores the requirement to check if *both* options satisfy the condition 'Which object is above *a* medium blue square?' and then incorrectly concludes (C) based on an incomplete check of the options provided in the question.
Answer Span:
Since medium blue square number one has medium blue square number two above it and the medium blue square in Block B has a medium yellow square above it, the answer is {C}.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is above a medium blue square? medium blue square number one or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #1153
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium black squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. T...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium black squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium yellow square and medium black square number two. Below the medium yellow square there is medium black square number two. Then, we have block B. It has one medium black square and one medium blue square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. Finally, we have block C which is above block A. Block B is to the right of it. It contains a medium yellow square. This block also has one medium black square. This block also contains a medium blue square. Below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square there is the medium black square. Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square. Which object is above a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is in block A or the medium yellow square which is in block C?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(b) the medium yellow square which is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Two medium black squares are in block A. One medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium yellow square and medium black square number two. Below the medium yellow square there is medium black square number two. Then, we have block B. It has one medium black square and one medium blue square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. Finally, we have block C which is above block A. Block B is to the right of it. It contains a medium yellow square. This block also has one medium black square. This block also contains a medium blue square. Below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square there is the medium black square. Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square. Which object is above a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is in block A or the medium yellow square which is in block C?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(b) the medium yellow square which is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains two medium black squares and one medium yellow square. Medium black square number one is at the bottom, below medium black square number two, which is in turn below the medium yellow square. Block C is above Block A, and it contains a medium yellow square and a medium black square. The question asks which yellow square is above a medium black square.
Since Block C is above Block A, and Block C has a medium yellow square above a medium black square, the medium yellow square in Block C is above a medium black square. The medium yellow square in Block A is above medium black square number two, but since we are looking for objects above medium black squares, and C is above A, the answer is the medium yellow square in Block C.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{B}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain misinterprets the vertical relationships within Block A and fails to correctly evaluate the condition for the yellow square in Block A against the question's requirement ('Which object is above a medium black square?'). It incorrectly concludes based on the relative position of Block C above Block A rather than evaluating the objects within Block A against the criteria.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Medium black square number one is at the bottom, below medium black square number two, which is in turn below the medium yellow square.
Explanation
The context states that Medium black square number one is below the medium yellow square AND medium black square number two. It does not state that medium black square number two is below the medium yellow square, nor does it establish a direct vertical relationship between medium black square number one and medium black square number two in the way described (i.e., one being directly below the other in a chain like that). Specifically, the context says: 'Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium yellow square and medium black square number two.' This implies both the yellow square and MBS #2 are above MBS #1. The reasoning chain incorrectly structures the relationship between MBS #1 and MBS #2.
Answer Span:
Medium black square number one is at the bottom, below medium black square number two, which is in turn below the medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium yellow square and medium black square number two.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The medium yellow square in Block A is above medium black square number two
Explanation
The context states that the medium yellow square is above medium black square number two, but it also states that below the medium yellow square there is medium black square number two. The reasoning chain fails to check if the yellow square in Block A is above *any* medium black square, which is the core question, by only focusing on the relationship with MBS #2 and then dismissing it based on Block C's position.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow square in Block A is above medium black square number two
Reference/Question Span:
Below the medium yellow square there is medium black square number two.
Question #2513
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of C and block C is below A. Block A has one big yellow triangle and one small yellow square. The big yellow triangle is far fro...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of C and block C is below A. Block A has one big yellow triangle and one small yellow square. The big yellow triangle is far from and to the right of a big blue triangle which is to the right of and above the small yellow square. Block B has two big blue squares. This block also contains one big blue circle. This block also has a small yellow triangle. It also has one small black circle. Big blue square number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big blue circle is to the right of big blue square number two and big blue square number one. And block C has two big black squares. Big black square number one is touching the right edge of this block. This object is to the right of a big yellow triangle and big black square number two. Which object is to the right of a small yellow triangle? the big blue circle that is touching the right edge of a block or the object that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the big blue circle that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the object that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
3
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block B is to the left of C and block C is below A. Block A has one big yellow triangle and one small yellow square. The big yellow triangle is far from and to the right of a big blue triangle which is to the right of and above the small yellow square. Block B has two big blue squares. This block also contains one big blue circle. This block also has a small yellow triangle. It also has one small black circle. Big blue square number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big blue circle is to the right of big blue square number two and big blue square number one. And block C has two big black squares. Big black square number one is touching the right edge of this block. This object is to the right of a big yellow triangle and big black square number two. Which object is to the right of a small yellow triangle? the big blue circle that is touching the right edge of a block or the object that is touching the bottom edge of a block? (a) the big blue circle that is touching the right edge of a block (b) the object that is touching the bottom edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block B contains a small yellow triangle, two big blue squares, and a big blue circle. Big blue square number two is touching the bottom edge of Block B, and the big blue circle is to the right of both blue squares. Block C contains two big black squares, with big black square number one touching the right edge. Since we're looking for what is to the right of the small yellow triangle in Block B, and the big blue circle is to the right of the other shapes within Block B, the big blue circle is to the right of the small yellow triangle. The question states that the big blue circle is to the right of big blue square number two.Big blue square number two is the object touching the bottom edge of block B. Therefore, both the big blue circle and the object touching the bottom edge (big blue square number two) are to the right of the small yellow triangle. Even though big black square number one is touching the right edge of Block C, it is not in Block B, and Block B is to the left of Block C. So, the answer is {C}.
\boxed{C}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the contents of Block B and attempts to answer the question. However, it makes an unsupported leap regarding the relationship between the small yellow triangle and the other objects in Block B, and incorrectly frames a statement from the context as the justification for its conclusion about the small yellow triangle. Crucially, the reasoning chain fails to establish *why* the big blue circle is to the right of the small yellow triangle, which is the core requirement for answering the question, instead relying on an assumption based on the relative positions of the blue squares and the circle within Block B.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The question states that the big blue circle is to the right of big blue square number two.
Explanation
The reasoning chain claims the question states the big blue circle is to the right of big blue square number two, but the question only states: "The big blue circle is to the right of big blue square number two and big blue square number one." The reasoning chain incorrectly implies this statement is the basis for concluding the circle is to the right of the small yellow triangle, when the actual relationship between the circle and the small yellow triangle needs to be established based on the context provided, which is not explicitly stated for the small yellow triangle.
Answer Span:
The question states that the big blue circle is to the right of big blue square number two.
Reference/Question Span:
The big blue circle is to the right of big blue square number two and big blue square number one.
Question #1294
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A is below B. Block A contains one small black circle, one medium black triangle and one small blue triangle. The small black circle is touching the...
Clean
Full Question
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A is below B. Block A contains one small black circle, one medium black triangle and one small blue triangle. The small black circle is touching the right edge of this block. Below and to the right of a medium black square is the small blue triangle. A medium yellow square is also in this block. Above and to the right of the small blue triangle is the small black circle. The small blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and below the medium black triangle is the small black circle. Block B has two medium black circles. Medium black circle number one is below medium black circle number two. Medium black circle number one is touching the right edge of this block. A small blue square is to the left of and above medium black circle number two. Medium black circle number two is touching the right edge of this block. What is below the small blue square? a small black circle which is touching the right edge of a block or a medium yellow object?
(a) small black circle which is touching the right edge of a block
(b) medium yellow object
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are two blocks. Let's call them A and B. Block A is below B. Block A contains one small black circle, one medium black triangle and one small blue triangle. The small black circle is touching the right edge of this block. Below and to the right of a medium black square is the small blue triangle. A medium yellow square is also in this block. Above and to the right of the small blue triangle is the small black circle. The small blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and below the medium black triangle is the small black circle. Block B has two medium black circles. Medium black circle number one is below medium black circle number two. Medium black circle number one is touching the right edge of this block. A small blue square is to the left of and above medium black circle number two. Medium black circle number two is touching the right edge of this block. What is below the small blue square? a small black circle which is touching the right edge of a block or a medium yellow object?
(a) small black circle which is touching the right edge of a block
(b) medium yellow object
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B has a small blue square above medium black circle number two. Below medium black circle number two is medium black circle number one. Below block B is Block A, containing a small black circle touching the right edge, a small blue triangle touching the bottom edge, and a medium yellow square. Because Block A is below Block B, the objects in Block A are below the objects in Block B. The small blue square is in Block B, and the small black circle touching the right edge is in Block A. Thus, the small black circle is below the small blue square. Also, the medium yellow square is below the small blue square. So the answer is small black circle which is touching the right edge of block A and medium yellow square in block A. The question mentions the two options independently. Since it is specified as the small black circle *which is touching the right edge*, the answer is {A}.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{A}$
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the objects based on the block structure and determines that both options (a) and (b) are below the small blue square. However, the final selection of (A) based on the phrasing of the options is a conclusion, not a factual error against the context.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #3112
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and below block C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge o...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and below block C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium black square number two. Block B contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below a medium black square and medium yellow square number two. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black square is below medium yellow square number two. Block C contains two medium black squares. Below medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. This block also has one medium yellow square. Below the medium object which is below medium black square number two there is the medium yellow square. It is below medium black square number two. Which object is to the left of a medium black square? the medium black square that is in block B or the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium black square that is in block B
(b) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. Let's call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and below block C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium black square number two. Block B contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below a medium black square and medium yellow square number two. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black square is below medium yellow square number two. Block C contains two medium black squares. Below medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. This block also has one medium yellow square. Below the medium object which is below medium black square number two there is the medium yellow square. It is below medium black square number two. Which object is to the left of a medium black square? the medium black square that is in block B or the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium black square that is in block B
(b) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is to the left of Block A. Block A has two medium black squares, with medium black square number one touching the bottom edge. Block B contains two medium yellow squares and one medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of Block B.
The question asks what is to the left of a medium black square. The options are the medium black square in Block B or the medium black square touching the bottom edge of a block (which is in Block A). Since Block B is to the left of Block A, the medium black square in Block B is to the left of both of the medium black squares in Block A, including the one touching the bottom edge (medium black square number one). However, the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block A cannot be to the left of a medium black square in Block A. So, only the medium black square that is in Block B is to the left of a medium black square.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains a direct contradiction regarding the contents of Block B (inventing a black square there) and makes an unverified assumption about the location of the black square touching the bottom edge, which is crucial for answering the question based on the provided options.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block B contains two medium yellow squares and one medium black square.
Explanation
The context explicitly states Block B contains two medium yellow squares, but it does not mention any medium black squares in Block B. The reasoning incorrectly asserts Block B contains one medium black square.
Answer Span:
Block B contains two medium yellow squares and one medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B contains two medium yellow squares.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The question asks what is to the left of a medium black square. The options are the medium black square in Block B or the medium black square touching the bottom edge of a block (which is in Block A).
Explanation
The reasoning assumes the medium black square touching the bottom edge of a block is in Block A. While the context states Block A has two medium black squares and one of them (number one) is touching the bottom edge, the reasoning fails to check if Block C also contains a medium black square that could be the one touching the bottom edge, or if the question is asking about the relative position of the *objects* mentioned in the options, not just the blocks they reside in.
Answer Span:
The options are the medium black square in Block B or the medium black square touching the bottom edge of a block (which is in Block A).
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block.
Question #97
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. There are a small black circle, one medium black square and a big yellow square in block A. It also contains a medium black triangle. The big yellow square ...
Clean
Full Question
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. There are a small black circle, one medium black square and a big yellow square in block A. It also contains a medium black triangle. The big yellow square is to the left of the medium black triangle. The small black circle is to the left of the medium black triangle. Above the big yellow square is the medium black square. It is touching the right edge of this block. It is above the medium black triangle. To the right of the square which is to the left of the medium black triangle is the small black circle. Below block A we have block B which contains one big blue triangle, a big yellow square and one small yellow triangle. The big blue triangle is above and to the left of the small yellow triangle. It is above the big yellow square. To the left of the small yellow triangle is the big yellow square. Which object is to the left of a shape which is touching the bottom edge of a block? the big yellow square that is in block A or the big yellow square that is in block B?
(a) the big yellow square that is in block A
(b) the big yellow square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are two blocks. We call them A and B. There are a small black circle, one medium black square and a big yellow square in block A. It also contains a medium black triangle. The big yellow square is to the left of the medium black triangle. The small black circle is to the left of the medium black triangle. Above the big yellow square is the medium black square. It is touching the right edge of this block. It is above the medium black triangle. To the right of the square which is to the left of the medium black triangle is the small black circle. Below block A we have block B which contains one big blue triangle, a big yellow square and one small yellow triangle. The big blue triangle is above and to the left of the small yellow triangle. It is above the big yellow square. To the left of the small yellow triangle is the big yellow square. Which object is to the left of a shape which is touching the bottom edge of a block? the big yellow square that is in block A or the big yellow square that is in block B?
(a) the big yellow square that is in block A
(b) the big yellow square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a big yellow square, a medium black square (touching the right edge), a medium black triangle, and a small black circle. Block B is below Block A and contains a big yellow square, a big blue triangle, and a small yellow triangle. The question asks which big yellow square (in A or in B) is to the left of a shape touching the bottom edge of a block. Since Block B is below Block A, any shape touching the bottom edge of a block must be in Block B. The big yellow square in Block B is to the left of the small yellow triangle. This small yellow triangle could be touching the bottom edge of Block B. Therefore, the big yellow square in Block B is to the left of a shape potentially touching the bottom edge of a block. The big yellow square in Block A cannot be to the left of anything in Block B, since Block A is above Block B. Therefore, the answer is {b}. \boxed{b}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in each block and logically deduces which block's contents are relevant to the final question based on the spatial relationship described ('Below block A we have block B'). The conclusion that the object must be in Block B is sound based on the context provided.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1070
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of blocks C and B. Block A has one medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this bloc...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of blocks C and B. Block A has one medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. There is also one small blue triangle touching the right edge of this block. Near to and above the medium yellow triangle is the small blue triangle. Block B has one medium yellow square, a big yellow circle and a big blue circle. The medium yellow square is below a big blue triangle. To the right of the big blue circle is the big yellow circle. This object is near to and to the left of the big blue triangle. The medium yellow square is to the right of the big blue circle. The big blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. And block C has one medium blue triangle, one big yellow circle and a small blue triangle. To the right of and near to the big yellow circle which is to the right of and below the small blue triangle is the medium blue triangle. What is near to the big blue triangle? a big yellow circle or a medium yellow triangle?
(a) big yellow circle
(b) medium yellow triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of blocks C and B. Block A has one medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. There is also one small blue triangle touching the right edge of this block. Near to and above the medium yellow triangle is the small blue triangle. Block B has one medium yellow square, a big yellow circle and a big blue circle. The medium yellow square is below a big blue triangle. To the right of the big blue circle is the big yellow circle. This object is near to and to the left of the big blue triangle. The medium yellow square is to the right of the big blue circle. The big blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. And block C has one medium blue triangle, one big yellow circle and a small blue triangle. To the right of and near to the big yellow circle which is to the right of and below the small blue triangle is the medium blue triangle. What is near to the big blue triangle? a big yellow circle or a medium yellow triangle? (a) big yellow circle (b) medium yellow triangle (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block B contains a big blue triangle, a big yellow circle, and a medium yellow square. The big yellow circle is near to and to the left of the big blue triangle. Block A, which is to the right of Block B, has a medium yellow triangle. Since the big yellow circle is in the same block (Block B) as the big blue triangle, and the medium yellow triangle is in a different block (Block A), only the big yellow circle is near the big blue triangle.
Final Answer: \boxed{a}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains a factual contradiction by stating Block B contains a big blue triangle when the context does not list it. It also uses flawed logic by assuming proximity is only determined by being in the same block, ignoring explicit positional clues provided in the context, although it correctly identifies the relationship between the big yellow circle and the big blue triangle.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block B contains a big blue triangle
Explanation
The reasoning chain claims Block B contains a big blue triangle, but the context only lists objects for Block B as: 'Block B has one medium yellow square, a big yellow circle and a big blue circle.'
Answer Span:
Block B contains a big blue triangle
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has one medium yellow square, a big yellow circle and a big blue circle.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since the big yellow circle is in the same block (Block B) as the big blue triangle, and the medium yellow triangle is in a different block (Block A), only the big yellow circle is near the big blue triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning concludes that only the big yellow circle is near the big blue triangle based on block location, but it ignores the explicit positional information given in the context: 'To the right of the big blue circle is the big yellow circle. This object is near to and to the left of the big blue triangle.' This statement confirms the proximity of the big yellow circle to the big blue triangle, but the reasoning chain should also check if the medium yellow triangle is near the big blue triangle, which is located in Block A. The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes that proximity is only established by being in the same block, ignoring the explicit 'near to' relationship stated for the big yellow circle, and failing to check the medium yellow triangle's proximity relative to Block A's contents.
Answer Span:
Since the big yellow circle is in the same block (Block B) as the big blue triangle, and the medium yellow triangle is in a different block (Block A), only the big yellow circle is near the big blue triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
What is near to the big blue triangle? a big yellow circle or a medium yellow triangle?
Question #3419
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of B and block B is above C. Block A has one small yellow triangle, a small blue circle and a big blue circle. To the left of...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of B and block B is above C. Block A has one small yellow triangle, a small blue circle and a big blue circle. To the left of the small blue circle which is to the right of the big blue circle is the small yellow triangle. The big blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Above the big blue circle there is the small yellow triangle. Block B has a big yellow circle. And block C contains one small black square, a big yellow triangle and a big yellow circle. The big yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. This block also has a small black triangle. The small black square is to the left of and above the big yellow triangle which is to the right of the big yellow circle.. One small blue square is also in this block. It is near to and above the big yellow circle. Which object is below a big yellow circle? the big blue circle which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the small black triangle?
(a) the big blue circle which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the small black triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of B and block B is above C. Block A has one small yellow triangle, a small blue circle and a big blue circle. To the left of the small blue circle which is to the right of the big blue circle is the small yellow triangle. The big blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Above the big blue circle there is the small yellow triangle. Block B has a big yellow circle. And block C contains one small black square, a big yellow triangle and a big yellow circle. The big yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. This block also has a small black triangle. The small black square is to the left of and above the big yellow triangle which is to the right of the big yellow circle. One small blue square is also in this block. It is near to and above the big yellow circle. Which object is below a big yellow circle? the big blue circle which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the small black triangle?
(a) the big blue circle which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the small black triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B contains a big yellow circle, and is above Block C. Block C contains a small black triangle. Block C also contains a big yellow circle. Block A contains a big blue circle that is touching the bottom edge. Since we're looking for what is below a big yellow circle, and Block B (with the big yellow circle) is directly above Block C, there are no objects directly below the big yellow circle in Block B. In Block C, there is no mention of any object being below the big yellow circle. Therefore, neither the small black triangle nor the big blue circle touching the bottom edge of Block A is below the big yellow circle in Block B. Because Block B is above Block C, and the big yellow circle is in Block B, and the question mentions another big yellow circle and a small black triangle in Block C. The small black triangle in Block C would be what's below the big yellow circle in Block B IF the big yellow circle in Block C were stated to be below the big yellow circle in Block B, but it's not stated as below so that logic cannot be applied. This is not an issue of 'not enough information'. It's stated to be 'to the right' so can't be below.
Final Answer: \boxed{D}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly asserts that Block C contains a big yellow circle, which contradicts the context that specifies the big yellow circle is in Block B. This error leads to flawed logic regarding the relative positions of objects in Block C.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block B contains a big yellow circle, and is above Block C. Block C contains a small black triangle. Block C also contains a big yellow circle.
Explanation
The reasoning correctly identifies that Block B has a big yellow circle and Block C has a small black triangle. However, it incorrectly states that Block C contains a big yellow circle. The context states Block C contains 'a big yellow triangle' and 'a big yellow circle' (singular) is in Block B. The context states Block C contains 'a big yellow triangle' and 'a big yellow circle' is in Block B.
Answer Span:
Block C also contains a big yellow circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has a big yellow circle. And block C contains one small black square, a big yellow triangle and a big yellow circle.
contradictionmedium
Statement
Because Block B is above Block C, and the big yellow circle is in Block B, and the question mentions another big yellow circle and a small black triangle in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning claims Block C has a big yellow circle, which contradicts the context that only specifies one big yellow circle, located in Block B. The context states Block C has a 'big yellow triangle', not a 'big yellow circle'.
Answer Span:
the question mentions another big yellow circle and a small black triangle in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has a big yellow circle. And block C contains one small black square, a big yellow triangle and a big yellow circle.
Question #968
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is above block C and it is to the left of block A. Block A contains two small yellow circles. There is also one big black circle in this block. Small yellow c...
3 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is above block C and it is to the left of block A. Block A contains two small yellow circles. There is also one big black circle in this block. Small yellow circle number one is above the big black circle and small yellow circle number two. Block B has two big yellow circles. It also contains one medium yellow triangle. Below big yellow circle number two is big yellow circle number one. It is to the left of and near to the medium yellow triangle. Block C contains a small black square, a big yellow triangle and a small yellow circle. A medium blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a big black square. Above the big black square and the small yellow circle there is the small black square. To the right of and touching the big black square is the medium blue triangle. This object is below the big yellow triangle. What is above the big black square? a blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block or a big yellow circle?
(a) blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) big yellow circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is above block C and it is to the left of block A. Block A contains two small yellow circles. There is also one big black circle in this block. Small yellow circle number one is above the big black circle and small yellow circle number two. Block B has two big yellow circles. It also contains one medium yellow triangle. Below big yellow circle number two is big yellow circle number one. It is to the left of and near to the medium yellow triangle. Block C contains a small black square, a big yellow triangle and a small yellow circle. A medium blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a big black square. Above the big black square and the small yellow circle there is the small black square. To the right of and touching the big black square is the medium blue triangle. This object is below the big yellow triangle. What is above the big black square? a blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block or a big yellow circle?
(a) blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) big yellow circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C contains a big black square, a small black square (above the big black square), a small yellow circle, a big yellow triangle (above the medium blue triangle) and a medium blue triangle touching the bottom edge. Block B (above Block C) contains big yellow circles and a medium yellow triangle. The small black square is above the big black square in block C. Since Block B is above block C, the big yellow circles in Block B are above the big black square in Block C. The blue triangle is touching the big black square and also touching the bottom edge. The question asks what is above the big black square. The answer is the small black square. So the correct answer is {d} \boxed{none of them}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that the small black square is above the big black square in Block C. However, it fails to address the actual multiple-choice options provided in the question, instead concluding the answer is the small black square, which is not an option. It also fabricates a detail about the blue triangle touching the big black square.
Detected Issues (3)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The blue triangle is touching the big black square and also touching the bottom edge.
Explanation
The context states the medium blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of Block C, and that the small black square is above the big black square. It also states the medium blue triangle is to the right of and touching the big black square, and below the big yellow triangle. It does not state the blue triangle is touching the big black square AND touching the bottom edge.
Answer Span:
The blue triangle is touching the big black square and also touching the bottom edge.
Reference/Question Span:
A medium blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. . . To the right of and touching the big black square is the medium blue triangle.
contradictionhigh
Statement
The answer is the small black square.
Explanation
The reasoning concludes the answer is the small black square, but the question asks to choose between option (a) 'a blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block' or option (b) 'a big yellow circle'. The small black square is not one of the choices provided in the question.
Answer Span:
The answer is the small black square.
Reference/Question Span:
What is above the big black square? a blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block or a big yellow circle?
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The small black square is above the big black square in block C.
Explanation
While the context states the small black square is above the big black square, the reasoning uses this fact to conclude the answer is the small black square, ignoring the actual options provided in the question which are (a) blue triangle touching bottom edge or (b) big yellow circle.
Answer Span:
The small black square is above the big black square in block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Above the big black square and the small yellow circle there is the small black square.
Question #1188
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is above A and block B is above C. Block A contains a medium black triangle. Block B contains a big blue triangle and one medium blue circle. The...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is above A and block B is above C. Block A contains a medium black triangle. Block B contains a big blue triangle and one medium blue circle. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has one medium black triangle. To the left of the big blue triangle is the medium black triangle. It is touching and below the medium blue circle. And block C contains one small yellow square, a medium yellow circle and one medium blue triangle. It also contains a medium black square. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. Near to and to the left of the medium black square is the medium blue triangle. The small yellow square is below the medium black square and the medium yellow circle. To the left of the medium black square is the medium yellow circle. Which object is above a medium black triangle? the medium blue triangle or the big blue triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue triangle
(b) the big blue triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is above A and block B is above C. Block A contains a medium black triangle. Block B contains a big blue triangle and one medium blue circle. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has one medium black triangle. To the left of the big blue triangle is the medium black triangle. It is touching and below the medium blue circle. And block C contains one small yellow square, a medium yellow circle and one medium blue triangle. It also contains a medium black square. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. Near to and to the left of the medium black square is the medium blue triangle. The small yellow square is below the medium black square and the medium yellow circle. To the left of the medium black square is the medium yellow circle. Which object is above a medium black triangle? the medium blue triangle or the big blue triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block? (a) the medium blue triangle (b) the big blue triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is above Block C, and Block C is above Block A. Block B contains a big blue triangle touching the bottom edge and a medium black triangle to the left of the big blue triangle. Block C, which is above Block A, contains a medium blue triangle. Since Block B is above Block C and Block B contains the medium black triangle, the big blue triangle is in Block B which is above the medium black triangle in Block B, and the medium blue triangle is in Block C which is above Block A. Since the medium black triangle mentioned in the question is in Block B, and Block B contains the big blue triangle below which is the medium black triangle, the answer is the big blue triangle in Block B. The object above the medium black triangle in Block B is the medium blue circle but the question asks about the medium blue triangle and the big blue triangle. Thus, the answer is {b}. \boxed{b}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly locates the medium black triangle in Block B when the context states it is in Block A. This fundamental error leads to incorrect subsequent reasoning about what is above it.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Since Block B is above Block C and Block B contains the medium black triangle, the big blue triangle is in Block B which is above the medium black triangle in Block B
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly states that Block B contains the medium black triangle. The context states Block A contains the medium black triangle, and Block B contains a big blue triangle and one medium blue circle, and also a medium black triangle is mentioned in relation to Block B's contents, but the context explicitly states: 'Block A contains a medium black triangle.'
Answer Span:
Block B contains the medium black triangle
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains a medium black triangle
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The object above the medium black triangle in Block B is the medium blue circle but the question asks about the medium blue triangle and the big blue triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning correctly identifies that the medium blue circle is above the medium black triangle in Block B, but it ignores the crucial context that the medium black triangle is in Block A, not Block B, which invalidates the premise of checking what is above it in Block B.
Answer Span:
The object above the medium black triangle in Block B is the medium blue circle
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains a medium black triangle
Question #3113
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and below block C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge o...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and below block C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium black square number two. Block B contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below a medium black square and medium yellow square number two. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black square is below medium yellow square number two. Block C contains two medium black squares. Below medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. This block also has one medium yellow square. Below the medium object which is below medium black square number two there is the medium yellow square. It is below medium black square number two. Which object is to the left of a medium black square? medium yellow square number two or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium yellow square number two
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block B is to the left of block A and below block C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium black square number two. Block B contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below a medium black square and medium yellow square number two. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black square is below medium yellow square number two. Block C contains two medium black squares. Below medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. This block also has one medium yellow square. Below the medium object which is below medium black square number two there is the medium yellow square. It is below medium black square number two. Which object is to the left of a medium black square? medium yellow square number two or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block? (a) medium yellow square number two (b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains two medium black squares. Block B, which is to the left of Block A, contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of Block B, while medium yellow square number two is above it. Since Block B is to the left of Block A, both medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two are to the left of the medium black squares in Block A. Therefore, both medium yellow squares are to the left of a medium black square.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{C}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an assumption about the relative positions of the yellow squares in Block B and then incorrectly concludes that because Block B is left of Block A, both yellow squares in B satisfy the condition. It completely ignores the contents and relative positions of Block C, which contains a medium yellow square that must be evaluated against the question.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of Block B, while medium yellow square number two is above it.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes the relative positions of medium yellow square number one and number two within Block B based on the description of Block A. The context for Block B states: 'Medium yellow square number one is below a medium black square and medium yellow square number two. It is touching the bottom edge of this block.' This implies medium yellow square number one is at the bottom, and medium yellow square number two is above it, but the reasoning chain derives this relationship incorrectly or incompletely by mixing information about Block A's squares.
Answer Span:
Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of Block B, while medium yellow square number two is above it.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below a medium black square and medium yellow square number two. It is touching the bottom edge of this block.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B is to the left of Block A, both medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two are to the left of the medium black squares in Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning chain concludes that both yellow squares in B are to the left of the black squares in A. However, the question asks which object is to the left of *a* medium black square. The reasoning chain fails to check if the yellow squares in Block B are to the left of *any* black square, specifically the ones in Block A, or if the yellow square in Block C is to the left of any black square. Crucially, it ignores the existence and location of the black squares in Block C, which is necessary to fully evaluate option (a) and (b) against the question.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is to the left of Block A, both medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two are to the left of the medium black squares in Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the left of a medium black square? medium yellow square number two or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #188
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block B is to the right of A. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black squa...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block B is to the right of A. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue square is medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two and the medium blue square is medium black square number one. Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two is a medium black square. Below the medium black square is medium yellow square number one. It is below medium yellow square number two. Block C has one medium yellow square and one medium blue square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? medium black square number two or the medium black square which is in block B?
(a) medium black square number two
(b) the medium black square which is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of C. Block B is to the right of A. Block A has two medium black squares. There is also one medium blue square in this block. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue square is medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two and the medium blue square is medium black square number one. Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two is a medium black square. Below the medium black square is medium yellow square number one. It is below medium yellow square number two. Block C has one medium yellow square and one medium blue square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? medium black square number two or the medium black square which is in block B?
(a) medium black square number two
(b) the medium black square which is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A is to the left of Block C and Block B is to the right of Block A. This means the order is A, B, C. Block A contains medium black square number two and Block B contains a medium black square. Block C contains a medium yellow square. Since we are looking for objects to the left of the medium yellow square in Block C, both medium black square number two (in Block A) and the medium black square (in Block B) are to its left. Therefore, both objects are to the left of the medium yellow square.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{C}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes assumptions about the location of the specific squares mentioned in the question and completely ignores the detailed positional constraints within Block B, which are necessary to answer the final question about relative positions.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block A contains medium black square number two and Block B contains a medium black square.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly assumes the location of 'medium black square number two' (which is in Block A) and the location of 'the medium black square' mentioned in the question (which is in Block B). The question states Block A has two medium black squares, one of which is number one, and Block B has two medium yellow squares and *a* medium black square. The reasoning chain incorrectly assigns 'medium black square number two' to Block A without verifying its location relative to the other squares in A, and incorrectly assumes the medium black square in B is the one being referenced without checking if it's the one relevant to the final comparison.
Answer Span:
Block A contains medium black square number two and Block B contains a medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has two medium black squares. . . Block B has two medium yellow squares. . . Below medium yellow square number two is a medium black square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since we are looking for objects to the left of the medium yellow square in Block C, both medium black square number two (in Block A) and the medium black square (in Block B) are to its left.
Explanation
The reasoning correctly identifies the target (medium yellow square in Block C) but fails to use the positional information given for the squares in Block B to determine if the medium black square in Block B is actually to the left of the medium yellow square in Block C. The positional information about Block B (Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two is a medium black square. Below the medium black square is medium yellow square number one. It is below medium yellow square number two.) is crucial for determining the relative position of the medium black square in B to Block C, but this information is ignored.
Answer Span:
Since we are looking for objects to the left of the medium yellow square in Block C, both medium black square number two (in Block A) and the medium black square (in Block B) are to its left.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A is to the left of C. Block B is to the right of A. . . Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two is a medium black square. Below the medium black square is medium yellow square number one. It is below medium yellow square number two. Block C has one medium yellow square and one medium blue square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square.
Question #1869
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has one medium black triangle, a big black square and one medium yellow square. There is also one big blue circle touching the right edge of th...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has one medium black triangle, a big black square and one medium yellow square. There is also one big blue circle touching the right edge of this block. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of, near to and below the big blue circle. The medium black triangle is touching the top edge of this block. This shape is to the right of, far from and above the big black square. Then, there is block B with a small yellow circle and a big yellow triangle in it. Touching, to the left of and above the big yellow triangle there is the small yellow circle. Block C is above block A and to the left of block B. It contains one medium yellow circle. Which object is to the left of a big circle? the object which is touching the bottom edge of a block that is in block A or the object that is touching the bottom edge of a block that is in block A?
(a) the object which is touching the bottom edge of a block that is in block A
(b) the object that is touching the bottom edge of a block that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block A has one medium black triangle, a big black square, and one medium yellow square. There is also one big blue circle touching the right edge of this block. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the left of, near to, and below the big blue circle. The medium black triangle is touching the top edge of this block. This shape is to the right of, far from, and above the big black square. Then, there is block B with a small yellow circle and a big yellow triangle in it. Touching, to the left of, and above the big yellow triangle there is the small yellow circle. Block C is above block A and to the left of block B. It contains one medium yellow circle. Which object is to the left of a big circle? the object which is touching the bottom edge of a block that is in block A or the object that is touching the bottom edge of a block that is in block A?
(a) the object which is touching the bottom edge of a block that is in block A
(b) the object that is touching the bottom edge of a block that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a medium black triangle, a big black square, a medium yellow square, and a big blue circle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of Block A and is to the left of the big blue circle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of Block A. The medium black triangle is at the top of Block A, and the big black square is to its left. Since the question asks what is to the left of the big circle and the question provides identical options related to the medium yellow square, the answer is the object touching the bottom edge of Block A, which is the medium yellow square.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{A}$
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the medium yellow square as being to the left of the big blue circle, but it incorrectly states that the big blue circle is *in* Block A, contradicting the source text which says it is *touching the right edge* of Block A.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block A contains a medium black triangle, a big black square, a medium yellow square, and a big blue circle.
Explanation
The context states the big blue circle is *touching the right edge of this block* (Block A), not *contained within* Block A like the other listed objects.
Answer Span:
Block A contains a medium black triangle, a big black square, a medium yellow square, and a big blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has one medium black triangle, a big black square and one medium yellow square. There is also one big blue circle touching the right edge of this block.
Question #3586
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is above C and block C is below B. Block A contains two small yellow triangles. Small yellow triangle number one is to the left of small yellow triangle numbe...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is above C and block C is below B. Block A contains two small yellow triangles. Small yellow triangle number one is to the left of small yellow triangle number two and a big black triangle. Above and near to small yellow triangle number two is the big black triangle. Block B contains a medium black square. And block C contains two small blue triangles. This block also contains a big black triangle. It is far from, below and to the right of small blue triangle number one. This block also has a small black square. A medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Small blue triangle number two is touching the left edge of this block. There is also one medium blue square in this block. The medium black triangle is to the left of the medium blue square. It is below small blue triangle number one. Which object is below a medium black square? the small black square or the small blue triangle that is touching the left edge of a block?
(a) the small black square
(b) the small blue triangle that is touching the left edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is above C and block C is below B. Block A contains two small yellow triangles. Small yellow triangle number one is to the left of small yellow triangle number two and a big black triangle. Above and near to small yellow triangle number two is the big black triangle. Block B contains a medium black square. And block C contains two small blue triangles. This block also contains a big black triangle. It is far from, below and to the right of small blue triangle number one. This block also has a small black square. A medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Small blue triangle number two is touching the left edge of this block. There is also one medium blue square in this block. The medium black triangle is to the left of the medium blue square. It is below small blue triangle number one. Which object is below a medium black square? the small black square or the small blue triangle that is touching the left edge of a block?
(a) the small black square
(b) the small blue triangle that is touching the left edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B contains the medium black square. Block C is below Block B. Block C contains a small blue triangle touching its left edge and a small black square. Since Block C is directly below Block B, both the small blue triangle and the small black square are below the medium black square. Therefore, both objects are below the medium black square.
Final Answer: \boxed{C}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies where the medium black square is (Block B) and where the candidate objects are (Block C). However, it makes an unsupported assumption that because C is below B, everything in C is below the medium black square in B. While this is likely true in a physical stacking scenario, the reasoning chain should rely only on explicit facts. The key error is the leap in logic regarding the spatial relationship used to justify the conclusion, although the final answer (C) is correct based on the facts that the square is in B and the candidates are in C.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block C is below Block B.
Explanation
The context states 'block C is below B', which is true, but the reasoning implies a direct vertical relationship that isn't explicitly stated as 'directly below' in a way that guarantees everything in C is below everything in B, especially when the question asks about objects below the medium black square which is *in* B. More critically, the reasoning uses this relationship to justify that *both* objects in C are below the object in B, which is a logical leap based on an incomplete understanding of the spatial relationships provided.
Answer Span:
Block C is below Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
block C is below B
Question #856
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the right of block B and above block A. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the right of block B and above block A. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium blue square number one which is below medium blue square number two. This object is below medium blue square number two. Below medium yellow square number two and medium blue square number one is medium yellow square number one. And block C contains two medium yellow squares. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one.. A medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium blue square number one?
(a) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium blue square number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B, and C. Block C is to the right of block B and above block A. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium blue square number one which is below medium blue square number two. This object is below medium blue square number two. Below medium yellow square number two and medium blue square number one is medium yellow square number one. And block C contains two medium yellow squares. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one.. A medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium blue square number one?
(a) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium blue square number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B has two medium blue squares, which we can call number one and number two. Block C has a medium blue square touching the bottom edge, and Block C is to the right of Block B. Therefore, the medium blue square touching the bottom edge of Block C is to the right of both medium blue squares in Block B, including medium blue square number one. The medium blue square touching the bottom edge of Block C is to the right of medium blue square number one in Block B. The question asks which object is to the right of a medium blue square (referring to those in Block B). Since the medium blue square touching the bottom edge of Block C is to the right of medium blue square number one in Block B, the answer is {B}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain fabricates the existence of a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of Block C, which contradicts the explicit description of Block C's contents (two medium yellow squares). It also misinterprets the scope of the final question.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block C has a medium blue square touching the bottom edge
Explanation
The context specifies the location of the blue squares relative to Block B, but it never states that Block C has a medium blue square touching the bottom edge. The context only states Block C contains two medium yellow squares.
Answer Span:
Block C has a medium blue square touching the bottom edge
Reference/Question Span:
Block C contains two medium yellow squares.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The question asks which object is to the right of a medium blue square (referring to those in Block B).
Explanation
The question asks which object is to the right of *a* medium blue square, offering two specific candidates: 'the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block' OR 'medium blue square number one'. The reasoning incorrectly narrows the scope of the question to only refer to blue squares in Block B.
Answer Span:
The question asks which object is to the right of a medium blue square (referring to those in Block B).
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium blue square number one?
Question #2502
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the right of block A and to the left of block C. Block A has one small blue circle. This block also has a medium yellow square. The med...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the right of block A and to the left of block C. Block A has one small blue circle. This block also has a medium yellow square. The medium yellow square is to the right of the small blue circle. Block B contains one small yellow triangle, a medium yellow square and a medium blue triangle. To the left of and above the medium yellow square is the small yellow triangle. Near to the medium blue triangle is a small black triangle. The medium blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. Above and to the right of the small yellow triangle is the small black triangle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. And block C contains a small blue circle. Which object is to the right of a small blue circle? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B and C. Block B is to the right of block A and to the left of block C. Block A has one small blue circle. This block also has a medium yellow square. The medium yellow square is to the right of the small blue circle. Block B contains one small yellow triangle, a medium yellow square and a medium blue triangle. To the left of and above the medium yellow square is the small yellow triangle. Near to the medium blue triangle is a small black triangle. The medium blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. Above and to the right of the small yellow triangle is the small black triangle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. And block C contains a small blue circle. Which object is to the right of a small blue circle? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has a small blue circle and a medium yellow square. The medium yellow square is to the right of the small blue circle in Block A. Block B contains a medium yellow square touching the bottom edge and a medium blue triangle touching the right edge. Block B is to the right of Block A. So, the objects in Block B are to the right of the objects in Block A. Specifically, the medium yellow square in Block B is to the right of the small blue circle in Block A. Block C contains a small blue circle but is to the right of Block B. The question asks which object is to the right of a small blue circle. There is no medium yellow square touching the right edge of a block. The medium yellow square in Block B is touching the bottom edge.
Therefore, the answer is \boxed{A}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the location of objects in Block A and Block B relative to each other. However, it introduces a factual claim that contradicts the premise of the comparison required by the question by stating that a medium yellow square touching the right edge of a block does not exist, which is not supported by the context.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
There is no medium yellow square touching the right edge of a block.
Explanation
The reasoning claims there is no medium yellow square touching the right edge of a block, but the context only specifies where the medium yellow square in Block B is located (touching the bottom edge). It does not state that no medium yellow square exists touching the right edge of *any* block. Furthermore, the question asks to compare two *hypothetical* objects based on their location relative to a small blue circle, one of which is defined as 'the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block'. The reasoning incorrectly asserts this object does not exist based on the provided context.
Answer Span:
There is no medium yellow square touching the right edge of a block.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a small blue circle? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is touching the right edge of a block?
Question #1189
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is above A and block B is above C. Block A contains a medium black triangle. Block B contains a big blue triangle and one medium blue circle. The...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is above A and block B is above C. Block A contains a medium black triangle. Block B contains a big blue triangle and one medium blue circle. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has one medium black triangle. To the left of the big blue triangle is the medium black triangle. It is touching and below the medium blue circle. And block C contains one small yellow square, a medium yellow circle and one medium blue triangle. It also contains a medium black square. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. Near to and to the left of the medium black square is the medium blue triangle. The small yellow square is below the medium black square and the medium yellow circle. To the left of the medium black square is the medium yellow circle. Which object is above a medium black triangle? the big object that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow circle?
(a) the big object that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is above A and block B is above C. Block A contains a medium black triangle. Block B contains a big blue triangle and one medium blue circle. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has one medium black triangle. To the left of the big blue triangle is the medium black triangle. It is touching and below the medium blue circle. And block C contains one small yellow square, a medium yellow circle and one medium blue triangle. It also contains a medium black square. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. Near to and to the left of the medium black square is the medium blue triangle. The small yellow square is below the medium black square and the medium yellow circle. To the left of the medium black square is the medium yellow circle. Which object is above a medium black triangle? the big object that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow circle? (a) the big object that is touching the bottom edge of a block (b) the medium yellow circle (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is above Block C, and Block C is above Block A. Block A contains a medium black triangle. Block B contains a big blue triangle(touching the bottom edge), a medium blue circle, and a medium black triangle. Block C contains a small yellow square, a medium yellow circle, a medium blue triangle, and a medium black square. We're looking for what's above the medium black triangle. Since the medium black triangle is in Block B, and Block B is above Block C, we need to look in Block B. Inside Block B, the medium black triangle is below the medium blue circle and to the left of the big blue triangle(which is touching the bottom edge). Therefore, the medium blue circle is directly above the medium black triangle. Since we're asked if it's the big blue triangle(touching the bottom edge) or the medium yellow circle, the medium yellow circle is in Block C, not Block B, so it cannot be directly above the medium black triangle in Block B. The big blue triangle is in Block B, but is not directly above the medium black triangle. So, neither of the suggested options is correct. The big blue triangle is not directly above the medium black triangle. The medium yellow circle is not directly above the medium black triangle.
\boxed{D}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly interprets the vertical stacking implied by the question. It correctly identifies the location of the medium black triangle (in Block B) but then makes flawed assumptions about what 'above' means relative to block structure and object placement within the block. It fails to correctly evaluate the options against the known facts, especially regarding the object in Block C (medium yellow circle) being potentially 'above' the object in Block B (medium black triangle) due to the overall block stacking (C is above A, B is above C, so B is above A, but C is below B). The question asks which object is above a medium black triangle. The medium black triangle is in Block B. Block C is below Block B. Therefore, the medium yellow circle (in Block C) cannot be above the medium black triangle (in Block B). The big blue triangle is in Block B, but the reasoning incorrectly dismisses it as not being directly above.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since the medium black triangle is in Block B, and Block B is above Block C, we need to look in Block B.
Explanation
The question asks which object is *above* a medium black triangle, which implies vertical stacking relationship, not just which block the object is in relative to other blocks. The reasoning incorrectly assumes that because the medium black triangle is in Block B, the answer must be an object *in* Block B, ignoring the possibility that an object in Block C or A could be below the medium black triangle, or that the question is asking about the object *directly* above it, which requires checking relative positions within the stack or within the block if the context implies that.
Answer Span:
Since the medium black triangle is in Block B, and Block B is above Block C, we need to look in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C is above A and block B is above C.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Therefore, the medium blue circle is directly above the medium black triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning concludes the medium blue circle is *directly* above the medium black triangle based on context within Block B, but the question asks which object is *above* a medium black triangle, which could mean any object in a higher block or any object vertically above it. More critically, the reasoning uses information about the medium black triangle's location *within* Block B ('The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has one medium black triangle. To the left of the big blue triangle is the medium black triangle. It is touching and below the medium blue circle.') to infer vertical stacking, but the context only describes horizontal/relative positions within the block, not vertical stacking *between* objects inside the block, except for the circle being above the triangle ('It is touching and below the medium blue circle'). However, the reasoning then dismisses the options based on block location, which is flawed reasoning based on the initial premise.
Answer Span:
Therefore, the medium blue circle is directly above the medium black triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C is above A and block B is above C. Block A contains a medium black triangle. Block B contains a big blue triangle and one medium blue circle. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has one medium black triangle. To the left of the big blue triangle is the medium black triangle. It is touching and below the medium blue circle.
Question #305
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has one big yellow circle. To the left of a medium yellow triangle is the big yellow circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom ...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has one big yellow circle. To the left of a medium yellow triangle is the big yellow circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Block B is above block A. It contains a big black circle. Finally, we have block C. It is to the right of block A. It has one big black circle, one small black circle and one small blue square. It also has a big black square. Near to the big black square is the big black circle. Above the big black square there is the small black circle. The small blue square is to the left of the big black square. This shape is touching the left edge of this block. Far from the blue shape which is to the left of the big black square is the small black circle.. The big black circle is below the black shape which is far from the small blue square. Which object is to the right of a medium thing? the big yellow circle or the small blue square that is touching the left edge of a block?
(a) the big yellow circle
(b) the small blue square that is touching the left edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. Let's call them A, B and C. Block A has one big yellow circle. To the left of a medium yellow triangle is the big yellow circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Block B is above block A. It contains a big black circle. Finally, we have block C. It is to the right of block A. It has one big black circle, one small black circle and one small blue square. It also has a big black square. Near to the big black square is the big black circle. Above the big black square there is the small black circle. The small blue square is to the left of the big black square. This shape is touching the left edge of this block. Far from the blue shape which is to the left of the big black square is the small black circle.. The big black circle is below the black shape which is far from the small blue square. Which object is to the right of a medium thing? the big yellow circle or the small blue square that is touching the left edge of a block? (a) the big yellow circle (b) the small blue square that is touching the left edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a big yellow circle and a medium yellow triangle with the circle to the left of the triangle. Block C is to the right of Block A () and contains a small blue square touching the left edge (). The "medium thing" referred to in the question is the medium yellow triangle in Block A. Since Block C is to the right of Block A (), the objects in Block C, including the small blue square, are to the right of the medium yellow triangle. Also, since the big yellow circle is to the left of the medium yellow triangle, it is not to its right. Therefore, the object to the right of the medium yellow triangle is the small blue square.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{B}$
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the 'medium thing' as the medium yellow triangle and uses the spatial relationship between Block A and Block C to determine which object is to its right, leading to the correct conclusion.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #855
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the right of block B and above block A. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the right of block B and above block A. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium blue square number one which is below medium blue square number two. This object is below medium blue square number two. Below medium yellow square number two and medium blue square number one is medium yellow square number one. And block C contains two medium yellow squares. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one.. A medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium blue square number two?
(a) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium blue square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the right of block B and above block A. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium blue square number one which is below medium blue square number two. This object is below medium blue square number two. Below medium yellow square number two and medium blue square number one is medium yellow square number one. And block C contains two medium yellow squares. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one.. A medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium blue square number two?
(a) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium blue square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C is to the right of Block B and above Block A. Block B has two medium yellow squares and two medium blue squares. In Block B, medium blue square number two is above medium yellow square number one. Block C has two medium yellow squares, and a medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of Block C, below the two yellow squares. Medium blue square number two (in Block B) is above a medium yellow square, specifically medium yellow square number one. The medium blue square touching the bottom edge of Block C is not above a medium yellow square; it's below them. Thus only medium blue square number two is above a medium yellow square.
Final Answer: \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes unsupported assumptions about the contents and arrangement of squares in Block B and incorrectly assigns the description of a blue square to Block C, leading to flawed logic regarding which blue square is above a yellow square.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
In Block B, medium blue square number two is above medium yellow square number one.
Explanation
The context describes the arrangement of squares *within* Block B, but it never explicitly states that medium blue square number two is above medium yellow square number one. The context describes the relative positions of the squares in Block B as: 'Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium blue square number one which is below medium blue square number two.' This implies MB2 > MB1 > MY2 > MY1 (from top to bottom, assuming 'below' means lower position), but the reasoning chain asserts a specific relationship (MB2 above MY1) that isn't directly stated as a single fact, and it ignores the full sequence provided.
Answer Span:
In Block B, medium blue square number two is above medium yellow square number one.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium blue square number one which is below medium blue square number two.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block C has two medium yellow squares, and a medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of Block C, below the two yellow squares.
Explanation
The context states Block C has two medium yellow squares. It then describes a medium blue square elsewhere: 'A medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two.' The reasoning chain incorrectly attributes this description to Block C, implying Block C contains this specific blue square below its yellow squares. The context does not specify the contents or arrangement of squares in Block C beyond having two medium yellow squares.
Answer Span:
Block C has two medium yellow squares, and a medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of Block C, below the two yellow squares.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C contains two medium yellow squares.
Question #2092
There are three blocks, A, B and C. A big black square, a medium black circle and one medium yellow triangle are in block A. Below the medium yellow triangle and the medium black circle is the big bla...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. A big black square, a medium black circle and one medium yellow triangle are in block A. Below the medium yellow triangle and the medium black circle is the big black square. It is touching the right edge of this block. Near to the medium yellow triangle is the medium black circle. Then, there is block B which has one big black triangle. This block also contains a small yellow triangle. Above a medium black circle which is touching and below the big black triangle there is the small yellow triangle. Above blocks A and B there is block C. It contains one medium yellow square, one small yellow square and one small blue triangle. This block also has a medium blue circle. Below the small blue triangle which is to the right of and above the medium blue circle there is the small yellow square. It is to the right of the medium blue circle. The medium yellow square is to the left of the small yellow square. What is below the medium blue circle? a medium yellow triangle or a small blue triangle?
(a) medium yellow triangle
(b) small blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B and C. A big black square, a medium black circle and one medium yellow triangle are in block A. Below the medium yellow triangle and the medium black circle is the big black square. It is touching the right edge of this block. Near to the medium yellow triangle is the medium black circle. Then, there is block B which has one big black triangle. This block also contains a small yellow triangle. Above a medium black circle which is touching and below the big black triangle there is the small yellow triangle. Above blocks A and B there is block C. It contains one medium yellow square, one small yellow square and one small blue triangle. This block also has a medium blue circle. Below the small blue triangle which is to the right of and above the medium blue circle there is the small yellow square. It is to the right of the medium blue circle. The medium yellow square is to the left of the small yellow square. What is below the medium blue circle? a medium yellow triangle or a small blue triangle? (a) medium yellow triangle (b) small blue triangle (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block C is above Blocks A and B. Block C contains a medium blue circle, a small blue triangle, a small yellow square, and a medium yellow square. The small yellow square is below the small blue triangle and to the right of the medium blue circle. Block B is below Block C, which contains the medium blue circle. Since Block B is directly below Block C and contains a big black triangle, nothing in Block B is directly below the medium blue circle.
In Block B, the small yellow triangle is above the medium black circle and below the big black triangle.
Block A contains a medium yellow triangle. Since Block C (containing the medium blue circle) is above both Block A and Block B, neither the medium yellow triangle (in Block A) nor the small blue triangle (in Block C) can be directly below the medium blue circle. The answer is \boxed{D}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes critical errors by assuming direct adjacency between blocks (C above B) and by incorrectly interpreting the question 'What is below the medium blue circle?' as excluding objects in the same block (C) or objects in the block below (A). This leads to ignoring the actual spatial relationships provided for the objects in question.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B is directly below Block C and contains a big black triangle, nothing in Block B is directly below the medium blue circle.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes Block B is *directly* below Block C, which is not stated. The context only says 'Above blocks A and B there is block C.' This ignores the possibility that Block A or Block B could be below the medium blue circle, which is in Block C.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is directly below Block C and contains a big black triangle, nothing in Block B is directly below the medium blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Above blocks A and B there is block C.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block C (containing the medium blue circle) is above both Block A and Block B, neither the medium yellow triangle (in Block A) nor the small blue triangle (in Block C) can be directly below the medium blue circle.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly concludes that because Block C is above A and B, nothing *in* C or *in* A can be below the medium blue circle (which is in C). The question asks what is *below* the medium blue circle, which could be an object in the same block (C) or an object in a block below C (A or B). The reasoning ignores the spatial relationships within Block C itself.
Answer Span:
neither the medium yellow triangle (in Block A) nor the small blue triangle (in Block C) can be directly below the medium blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
What is below the medium blue circle? a medium yellow triangle or a small blue triangle?
Question #2091
There are three blocks, A, B and C. A big black square, a medium black circle and one medium yellow triangle are in block A. Below the medium yellow triangle and the medium black circle is the big bla...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. A big black square, a medium black circle and one medium yellow triangle are in block A. Below the medium yellow triangle and the medium black circle is the big black square. It is touching the right edge of this block. Near to the medium yellow triangle is the medium black circle. Then, there is block B which has one big black triangle. This block also contains a small yellow triangle. Above a medium black circle which is touching and below the big black triangle there is the small yellow triangle. Above blocks A and B there is block C. It contains one medium yellow square, one small yellow square and one small blue triangle. This block also has a medium blue circle. Below the small blue triangle which is to the right of and above the medium blue circle there is the small yellow square. It is to the right of the medium blue circle. The medium yellow square is to the left of the small yellow square. What is below the big black triangle? a medium black circle or a medium yellow square?
(a) medium black circle
(b) medium yellow square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B and C. A big black square, a medium black circle and one medium yellow triangle are in block A. Below the medium yellow triangle and the medium black circle is the big black square. It is touching the right edge of this block. Near to the medium yellow triangle is the medium black circle. Then, there is block B which has one big black triangle. This block also contains a small yellow triangle. Above a medium black circle which is touching and below the big black triangle there is the small yellow triangle. Above blocks A and B there is block C. It contains one medium yellow square, one small yellow square and one small blue triangle. This block also has a medium blue circle. Below the small blue triangle which is to the right of and above the medium blue circle there is the small yellow square. It is to the right of the medium blue circle. The medium yellow square is to the left of the small yellow square. What is below the big black triangle? a medium black circle or a medium yellow square?
(a) medium black circle
(b) medium yellow square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B contains the big black triangle and a medium black circle below it, with a small yellow triangle abovethe medium black circle (above a medium black circle which is below the big black triangle there is the small yellow triangle). Block C is above blocks A and B, meaning that the medium yellow square (and the other shapes in Block C) are above both Block B and Block A. Since the medium black circle is positioned directly below the big black triangle in Block B, and the medium yellow square is in Block C (above Block B), the object below the big black triangle is the medium black circle.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly places a medium black circle in Block B, which contradicts the context that only lists a big black triangle and a small yellow triangle for Block B. This error fundamentally misrepresents the contents of Block B, leading to a flawed deduction about what is below the big black triangle.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block B contains the big black triangle and a medium black circle below it
Explanation
The context states Block B has 'one big black triangle' and 'a small yellow triangle'. It does not mention a medium black circle in Block B. The medium black circle is mentioned in Block A.
Answer Span:
Block B contains the big black triangle and a medium black circle below it
Reference/Question Span:
Block B which has one big black triangle. This block also contains a small yellow triangle.
Question #2256
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this b...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. Below medium blue square number one , medium blue square number two and medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. Block B is to the right of block A. It has a medium black square. A medium yellow square is below the medium black square. Finally, there is block C. It is to the right of block B. It has a medium black square and a medium yellow square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Which object is to the left of a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block C
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. Below medium blue square number one , medium blue square number two and medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. Block B is to the right of block A. It has a medium black square. A medium yellow square is below the medium black square. Finally, there is block C. It is to the right of block B. It has a medium black square and a medium yellow square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Which object is to the left of a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block C
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains two medium yellow squares, one of which (medium yellow square number one) is touching the bottom edge. Block B is to the right of Block A and contains a medium black square. Block C is to the right of Block B and contains a medium black square and a medium yellow square.
The question asks what is to the left of a medium black square. Since there are two medium black squares, one in Block B and one in Block C, we need to consider both.
The medium black square in Block B has Block A to its left. Block A contains medium yellow square number one, which is touching the bottom edge. Thus, medium yellow square number one is to the left of the medium black square in Block B.
The medium black square in Block C has Block B to its left. Block B does not contain the medium yellow square from Block C.
Therefore, only the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block (medium yellow square number one in Block A) is to the left of a medium black square (the one in Block B).
\boxed{B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in each block and uses the spatial relationships (left/right) to determine which object is to the left of a medium black square. It correctly evaluates both black squares present.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2897
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of C and block C is above B. Block A contains three medium yellow squares. It also contains a medium black square. It is below me...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of C and block C is above B. Block A contains three medium yellow squares. It also contains a medium black square. It is below medium yellow square number three. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium yellow square number three and the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium black square and medium yellow square number three. Block B contains two medium yellow squares. One medium blue square is also in this block. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium blue square and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square. Block C contains one medium yellow square. Which object is to the left of a medium square? medium yellow square number three or the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium yellow square number three
(b) the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
3
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of C and block C is above B. Block A contains three medium yellow squares. It also contains a medium black square. It is below medium yellow square number three. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium yellow square number three and the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium black square and medium yellow square number three. Block B contains two medium yellow squares. One medium blue square is also in this block. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium blue square and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square. Block C contains one medium yellow square. Which object is to the left of a medium square? medium yellow square number three or the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium yellow square number three
(b) the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A is to the right of Block C, and Block C is above Block B. Block A contains three medium yellow squares: number one (touching the bottom edge), number two (below number three and the black square), and number three. Block C contains one medium yellow square. The question asks which object is to the left of a medium square in Block A. Since Block C is to the left of Block A and Block C contains a medium yellow square, that medium yellow square in Block C must be to the left of all the medium squares in Block A. This includes both medium yellow square number three and the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge (number one). Therefore, the answer is {C}. \boxed{c}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsupported assumption that Block A contains yellow squares numbered one, two, and three, and incorrectly restricts the scope of the final question to objects to the left of squares *in Block A*, ignoring the actual phrasing of the question.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block A contains three medium yellow squares: number one (touching the bottom edge), number two (below number three and the black square), and number three.
Explanation
The context states Block A contains *three* medium yellow squares and *one* medium black square. It then describes the location of medium yellow square number one, number two, and number three relative to other objects, but it never explicitly states that A contains yellow squares numbered one, two, and three. It only states A contains three medium yellow squares, one medium black square, and that medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of A, and medium yellow square number three is above A.
Answer Span:
Block A contains three medium yellow squares: number one (touching the bottom edge), number two (below number three and the black square), and number three.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains three medium yellow squares. It also contains a medium black square. It is below medium yellow square number three. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The question asks which object is to the left of a medium square in Block A.
Explanation
The actual question asks which object is to the left of *a* medium square, not specifically one *in Block A*. The objects being tested are 'medium yellow square number three' or 'the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block'. The reasoning incorrectly restricts the scope of the final comparison to Block A squares.
Answer Span:
The question asks which object is to the left of a medium square in Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the left of a medium square? medium yellow square number three or the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #2907
We have two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A has a big black circle, one small black triangle and a small black square. This block also has a small yellow triangle. This block also has a big bl...
1 issue
Full Question
We have two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A has a big black circle, one small black triangle and a small black square. This block also has a small yellow triangle. This block also has a big black square. The big black circle is above the small black triangle which is below and to the right of the small black square. The small black square is below the big black square. To the right of the big black square is the big black circle. Block B is to the right of block A. It has a medium black triangle, one small black circle and one small blue triangle. To the right of the small blue triangle is the medium black triangle. This object is below the small black circle. This block also has one big black triangle. This block also has a big yellow triangle. It is near to and below the big black triangle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the big black triangle there is the small blue triangle. What is to the right of the big black circle? a small black circle or a big yellow triangle?
(a) small black circle
(b) big yellow triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are two blocks. Let's call them A and B. Block A has a big black circle, one small black triangle and a small black square. This block also has a small yellow triangle. This block also has a big black square. The big black circle is above the small black triangle which is below and to the right of the small black square. The small black square is below the big black square. To the right of the big black square is the big black circle. Block B is to the right of block A. It has a medium black triangle, one small black circle and one small blue triangle. To the right of the small blue triangle is the medium black triangle. This object is below the small black circle. This block also has one big black triangle. This block also has a big yellow triangle. It is near to and below the big black triangle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the big black triangle there is the small blue triangle. What is to the right of the big black circle? a small black circle or a big yellow triangle? (a) small black circle (b) big yellow triangle (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a big black circle. Block B is to the right of Block A. Block B contains a small black circle and a big yellow triangle. Since Block B is to the right of Block A, the objects within Block B are to the right of the objects in Block A. Therefore, both the small black circle and the big yellow triangle are to the right of the big black circle in Block A. So, both objects are to the right of the big black circle.
Final Answer: \boxed{C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsupported leap in logic. It correctly identifies that Block B is to the right of Block A and that Block B contains the candidate objects. However, it incorrectly concludes that this means the objects in Block B are necessarily to the right of a specific object (the big black circle) located in Block A, ignoring the specific spatial relationships defined within Block A itself, which are necessary to answer the question definitively.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Therefore, both the small black circle and the big yellow triangle are to the right of the big black circle.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes that because Block B is to the right of Block A, everything in Block B is to the right of everything in Block A. However, the question asks specifically what is to the right of the *big black circle* (which is in Block A). The context only establishes the relative position of the blocks (B is right of A), not the relative position of every object within A compared to every object within B, especially when the object in question (big black circle) has specific positional constraints within Block A.
Answer Span:
Therefore, both the small black circle and the big yellow triangle are to the right of the big black circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the right of block A.
Question #2906
We have two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A has a big black circle, one small black triangle and a small black square. This block also has a small yellow triangle. This block also has a big bl...
Clean
Full Question
We have two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A has a big black circle, one small black triangle and a small black square. This block also has a small yellow triangle. This block also has a big black square. The big black circle is above the small black triangle which is below and to the right of the small black square. The small black square is below the big black square. To the right of the big black square is the big black circle. Block B is to the right of block A. It has a medium black triangle, one small black circle and one small blue triangle. To the right of the small blue triangle is the medium black triangle. This object is below the small black circle. This block also has one big black triangle. This block also has a big yellow triangle. It is near to and below the big black triangle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the big black triangle there is the small blue triangle. What is to the right of the big black circle? a big black triangle or a small black circle?
(a) big black triangle
(b) small black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have two blocks. Let's call them A and B. Block A has a big black circle, one small black triangle and a small black square. This block also has a small yellow triangle. This block also has a big black square. The big black circle is above the small black triangle which is below and to the right of the small black square. The small black square is below the big black square. To the right of the big black square is the big black circle. Block B is to the right of block A. It has a medium black triangle, one small black circle and one small blue triangle. To the right of the small blue triangle is the medium black triangle. This object is below the small black circle. This block also has one big black triangle. This block also has a big yellow triangle. It is near to and below the big black triangle. The medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the big black triangle there is the small blue triangle. What is to the right of the big black circle? a big black triangle or a small black circle?
(a) big black triangle
(b) small black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a big black circle. Block B is to the right of Block A, and it contains a small black circle. Because Block B is to the right of Block A, the objects within Block B are to the right of those in Block A. Therefore, the small black circle (in Block B) is to the right of the big black circle (in Block A). The big black triangle is also in Block B, so it is also to the right of the big black circle. Thus, both the big black triangle and the small black circle are to the right of the big black circle.
\boxed{C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies that Block B is to the right of Block A, and since both the big black triangle and the small black circle are in Block B, they must both be to the right of the big black circle in Block A. The conclusion aligns with the derived facts.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2390
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is below blocks A and C. Block A has two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of ...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is below blocks A and C. Block A has two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium blue square number two is below medium black square number two and medium black square number one. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two. Below medium black square number one and medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Block B has a medium yellow square. And block C contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. A medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. This object is below medium yellow square number one. Which object is above a medium blue square? the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium black square number one?
(a) the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium black square number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is below blocks A and C. Block A has two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium blue square number two is below medium black square number two and medium black square number one. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two. Below medium black square number one and medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Block B has a medium yellow square. And block C contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. A medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. This object is below medium yellow square number one. Which object is above a medium blue square? the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium black square number one?
(a) the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium black square number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has two medium blue squares (number one and number two) and two medium black squares (number two and number one). In Block A, black square number one is below black square number two, and blue square number two is also below both black square number two and black square number one. Blue square number one is at the bottom edge of Block A and below both black square number one and blue square number two. This arrangement implies that black square number one is directly above blue square number one. Block C has a medium black square touching its bottom edge. Since Block B is below both Blocks A and C, the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block C is not above a medium blue square (which are in Block A). Thus, only medium black square number one is above a medium blue square.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{B}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes several factual errors regarding the numbering and positioning of squares within Block A, leading to an incorrect intermediate conclusion about which black square is above a blue square. Specifically, it incorrectly assumes the location of the black square touching the bottom edge of Block C is relevant to the question, when the question asks about the two specified options: the black square touching the bottom edge of *a* block (which could be C) or black square number one (which is in A).
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionlow
Statement
Block A has two medium blue squares (number one and number two) and two medium black squares (number two and number one).
Explanation
The context states Block A has two medium blue squares and two *other* medium black squares. It does not assign numbers 'number one' and 'number two' to the black squares in the initial enumeration, only to the blue squares. The reasoning chain assigns numbers to the black squares based on later context, but the initial summary incorrectly implies the black squares are numbered 'number two and number one' in the same way the blue squares are.
Answer Span:
Block A has two medium blue squares (number one and number two) and two medium black squares (number two and number one)
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares.
contradictionmedium
Statement
Blue square number one is at the bottom edge of Block A and below both black square number one and blue square number two.
Explanation
The context states that Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of *this block* (Block A). It does not state it is below black square number one or blue square number two. The context states: 'Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block.' and 'Below medium black square number one and medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one.' This means blue square number one is below them, not that it is *at the bottom edge* AND below them, which is a slight misrepresentation of the structure, but the main contradiction is the claim that it is *below* black square number one, which is true, but the reasoning chain incorrectly implies the bottom edge location is derived from being below the others, or conflates the location description.
Answer Span:
Blue square number one is at the bottom edge of Block A and below both black square number one and blue square number two.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. . . Below medium black square number one and medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one.
Question #304
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has one big yellow circle. To the left of a medium yellow triangle is the big yellow circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom ...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A has one big yellow circle. To the left of a medium yellow triangle is the big yellow circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Block B is above block A. It contains a big black circle. Finally, we have block C. It is to the right of block A. It has one big black circle, one small black circle and one small blue square. It also has a big black square. Near to the big black square is the big black circle. Above the big black square there is the small black circle. The small blue square is to the left of the big black square. This shape is touching the left edge of this block. Far from the blue shape which is to the left of the big black square is the small black circle.. The big black circle is below the black shape which is far from the small blue square. What is to the left of the big black square? a small black circle or a small blue square that is touching the left edge of a block?
(a) small black circle
(b) small blue square that is touching the left edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block A has one big yellow circle. To the left of a medium yellow triangle is the big yellow circle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Block B is above block A. It contains a big black circle. Finally, we have block C. It is to the right of block A. It has one big black circle, one small black circle, and one small blue square. It also has a big black square. Near to the big black square is the big black circle. Above the big black square there is the small black circle. The small blue square is to the left of the big black square. This shape is touching the left edge of this block. Far from the blue shape which is to the left of the big black square is the small black circle.. The big black circle is below the black shape which is far from the small blue square. What is to the left of the big black square? a small black circle or a small blue square that is touching the left edge of a block?
(a) small black circle
(b) small blue square that is touching the left edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C contains a big black square, a small black circle, and a small blue square. The small blue square is to the left of the big black square and touching the left edge of Block C. The small black circle is above the big black square. The question asks what is to the left of the big black square. Since the small blue square is explicitly stated to be to the left of the big black square, the answer is the small blue square that is touching the left edge of a block. \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relevant facts about the objects in Block C and uses them to answer the question based on the provided context.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #722
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of and C is below A. Block A contains a big blue circle. Block B has one medium blue circle and a big blue triangle. This block ...
3 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of and C is below A. Block A contains a big blue circle. Block B has one medium blue circle and a big blue triangle. This block also contains one small black square. To the left of the big blue triangle and the medium blue circle there is the small black square. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. And block C has one medium black square, a medium blue circle and one small black square. There is also a small black triangle in this block. Above the small black square and the small black triangle there is the medium black square. The medium blue circle is touching the top edge of this block. The small black square is to the left of the small black triangle. The medium blue circle is to the right of and above the small black square. Which object is to the left of a small black triangle? the big blue circle or the medium blue circle which is touching the top edge of a block?
(a) the big blue circle
(b) the medium blue circle which is touching the top edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
3
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of and C is below A. Block A contains a big blue circle. Block B has one medium blue circle and a big blue triangle. This block also contains one small black square. To the left of the big blue triangle and the medium blue circle there is the small black square. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. And block C has one medium black square, a medium blue circle and one small black square. There is also a small black triangle in this block. Above the small black square and the small black triangle there is the medium black square. The medium blue circle is touching the top edge of this block. The small black square is to the left of the small black triangle. The medium blue circle is to the right of and above the small black square. Which object is to the left of a small black triangle? the big blue circle or the medium blue circle which is touching the top edge of a block?
(a) the big blue circle
(b) the medium blue circle which is touching the top edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C contains a medium blue circle touching the top edge, a small black square, and a small black triangle. The small black square is to the left of the small black triangle. Block B, which is to the left of Block A (), contains a medium blue circle, a big blue triangle, and a small black square. The small black square is to the left of both the medium blue circle and the big blue triangle. Since Block B is to the left of Block A, the objects in Block B (medium blue circle, small black square) are to the left of objects in Block A. The big blue circle is in Block A, and Block C is below Block A. Thus the medium blue circle in Block C is not to the left of the small black triangle, but rather above and to the right of it. The small black square in Block B is to the left of the small black triangle since Block B is to the left of Block C and Block C contains the small black triangle. The correct answer is the small black square, which is in Block B to the left of Block C, the small black triangle being located in Block C.
However, the question asks about the big blue circle (in Block A) and the medium blue circle (in Block C) being to the left of the small black triangle (in Block C). As reasoned above, only the objects in Block B are to the left of the small black triangle and therefore, neither the big blue circle nor the medium blue circle meet this condition.
Final Answer: \boxed{D}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes several inaccurate statements about the contents of Block B and Block C, and draws conclusions about relative positioning that are not explicitly stated or necessary. Crucially, it fails to correctly evaluate the two options provided in the question against the constraints given in the context.
Detected Issues (3)
contradictionlow
Statement
Block C contains a medium blue circle touching the top edge
Explanation
The context states that the medium blue circle in Block C is touching the top edge, but it also states that the medium blue circle in Block B is touching the top edge (implicitly, as the context says 'The medium blue circle is to the right of and above the small black square' and 'The medium blue circle is touching the top edge of this block' immediately after describing Block C's contents, but the description of Block B's contents is separate). Re-reading the context: Block C has one medium black square, a medium blue circle and one small black square. There is also a small black triangle in this block. ... The medium blue circle is touching the top edge of this block. This refers to Block C. However, the reasoning chain later claims the medium blue circle in Block C is not to the left of the small black triangle, but rather above and to the right of it, which is a statement about relative position, not the object's location in the block description.
Answer Span:
Block C contains a medium blue circle touching the top edge
Reference/Question Span:
And block C has one medium black square, a medium blue circle and one small black square. ... The medium blue circle is touching the top edge of this block.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block B, which is to the left of Block A (), contains a medium blue circle, a big blue triangle, and a small black square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain omits the fact that Block B contains a big blue triangle and a small black square, but it incorrectly states that Block B contains a medium blue circle. The context states Block B has 'one medium blue circle and a big blue triangle. This block also contains one small black square.' The reasoning chain seems to conflate the contents of B and C or misstate the contents of B.
Answer Span:
Block B, which is to the left of Block A (), contains a medium blue circle, a big blue triangle, and a small black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has one medium blue circle and a big blue triangle. This block also contains one small black square.
contradictionlow
Statement
Thus the medium blue circle in Block C is not to the left of the small black triangle, but rather above and to the right of it.
Explanation
The context states: 'The medium blue circle is to the right of and above the small black square.' It does not explicitly state the relationship between the medium blue circle in C and the small black triangle in C, only that the small black square is to the left of the small black triangle. The reasoning chain asserts a specific spatial relationship ('above and to the right') for the medium blue circle relative to the small black triangle which is not directly supported or contradicted by the text, but it is an inference about relative position that isn't necessary to answer the question about which object is *to the left* of the small black triangle.
Answer Span:
Thus the medium blue circle in Block C is not to the left of the small black triangle, but rather above and to the right of it.
Reference/Question Span:
The small black square is to the left of the small black triangle. The medium blue circle is to the right of and above the small black square.
Question #762
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one medium blue circle. One medium blue square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue circle is the medium blu...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one medium blue circle. One medium blue square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue circle is the medium blue square. Block B is below block A. It contains a small blue triangle, a medium yellow square and a medium blue circle. The small blue triangle is to the left of the medium yellow square and a big black square. The medium yellow square is to the left of the big black square. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. To the left of block B there is block C with two medium black circles in it. Medium black circle number one is below and touching a small yellow square. Medium black circle number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of and near to medium black circle number two is medium black circle number one. Which object is below a medium blue circle? the medium blue square or the big shape which is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square
(b) the big shape which is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has one medium blue circle. One medium blue square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue circle is the medium blue square. Block B is below block A. It contains a small blue triangle, a medium yellow square and a medium blue circle. The small blue triangle is to the left of the medium yellow square and a big black square. The medium yellow square is to the left of the big black square. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. To the left of block B there is block C with two medium black circles in it. Medium black circle number one is below and touching a small yellow square. Medium black circle number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of and near to medium black circle number two is medium black circle number one. Which object is below a medium blue circle? the medium blue square or the big shape which is touching the right edge of a block? (a) the medium blue square (b) the big shape which is touching the right edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
In Block A, the medium blue circle is above the medium blue square, which is touching the bottom edge (stated explicitly). Block B is below Block A, and contains the big black square touching its right edge, the medium yellow square, and the small blue triangle. Since the question asks what is below the medium blue circle (in Block A), and Block B is below Block A, the objects directly below the medium blue circle are those in Block B. Of the options, only the big black square is in Block B, so it is below the medium blue circle. The medium blue square is in Block A, and it is below the medium blue circle within Block A, but not directly below it in the arrangement of blocks.
The question asks which object from the given options is directly below a medium blue circle. Since Block B is directly below Block A (containing the medium blue circle), the answer is the big black square that is touching the right edge of Block B.
Final Answer: \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly interprets the spatial relationship within Block A, stating the circle is above the square when the context says the square is below the circle. More critically, it ignores the possibility that the medium blue square (which is explicitly stated to be below the medium blue circle) is the correct answer, by incorrectly concluding that 'below' must mean in the next block down (Block B).
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
In Block A, the medium blue circle is above the medium blue square, which is touching the bottom edge (stated explicitly).
Explanation
The context states the medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of Block A, but it does not state that the medium blue circle is *above* it. It states the square is *below* the circle.
Answer Span:
In Block A, the medium blue circle is above the medium blue square, which is touching the bottom edge (stated explicitly).
Reference/Question Span:
Below the medium blue circle is the medium blue square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since the question asks what is below the medium blue circle (in Block A), and Block B is below Block A, the objects directly below the medium blue circle are those in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning ignores the fact that the medium blue square is *also* described as being below the medium blue circle within Block A itself, which is one of the options being tested. The reasoning incorrectly assumes that 'below' must mean in the next block down (Block B).
Answer Span:
Since the question asks what is below the medium blue circle (in Block A), and Block B is below Block A, the objects directly below the medium blue circle are those in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Below the medium blue circle is the medium blue square.
Question #3225
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains one big blue triangle and a big blue square. The big blue triangle is to the right of the big blue square. Block B is below block A. It has one big y...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains one big blue triangle and a big blue square. The big blue triangle is to the right of the big blue square. Block B is below block A. It has one big yellow circle. To the right of block A there is block C with a medium yellow circle, a small yellow circle and one medium yellow square in it. The medium yellow circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a small black square. Above the medium yellow square is the small yellow circle. The medium yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. A big yellow square is touching the left edge of this block. Far from and to the right of the big yellow square there is the medium yellow square.. The small yellow circle is to the right of the big yellow square. Below the big yellow square there is the medium yellow circle. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? the square that is touching the left edge of a block or the small yellow circle?
(a) the square that is touching the left edge of a block
(b) the small yellow circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains one big blue triangle and a big blue square. The big blue triangle is to the right of the big blue square. Block B is below block A. It has one big yellow circle. To the right of block A there is block C with a medium yellow circle, a small yellow circle and one medium yellow square in it. The medium yellow circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a small black square. Above the medium yellow square is the small yellow circle. The medium yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. A big yellow square is touching the left edge of this block. Far from and to the right of the big yellow square there is the medium yellow square.. The small yellow circle is to the right of the big yellow square. Below the big yellow square there is the medium yellow circle. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? the square that is touching the left edge of a block or the small yellow circle?
(a) the square that is touching the left edge of a block
(b) the small yellow circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C contains the medium yellow square, which is touching the right edge. It also contains a big yellow square touching the left edge and a small yellow circle above the medium yellow square and to the right of the big yellow square. Because the small yellow circle is above and to the right of the big yellow square, it cannot be to the left of the medium yellow square. However, the big yellow square is on the left edge and the medium yellow square is on the right edge. The small yellow circle is located to the right of the big yellow square and above the medium yellow square. Therefore, the big yellow square is to the left of the medium yellow square. So, the answer is $\boxed{A}$.
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in Block C and uses their relative positions to determine which object is to the left of the medium yellow square, concluding correctly based on the provided context.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2389
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is below blocks A and C. Block A has two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of ...
3 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is below blocks A and C. Block A has two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium blue square number two is below medium black square number two and medium black square number one. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two. Below medium black square number one and medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Block B has a medium yellow square. And block C contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. A medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. This object is below medium yellow square number one. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium blue square number two?
(a) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium blue square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is below blocks A and C. Block A has two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium blue square number two is below medium black square number two and medium black square number one. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two. Below medium black square number one and medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Block B has a medium yellow square. And block C contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. A medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. This object is below medium yellow square number one. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium blue square number two?
(a) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium blue square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is below Blocks A and C. Block A has two medium blue squares and two medium black squares. In Block A, black square number one is below black square number two. Blue square number two is below both black squares. And blue square number one is at the bottom edge of Block A, below everything else in that block. Thus, the medium yellow square in Block B is directly below Block A, making it below blue square number one. Block C has two medium yellow squares, with yellow square number one below yellow square number two. A medium black square is at the bottom edge of Block C. Since Block B is also below Block C, neither of the blue squares in Block A is directly above the yellow square in Block B. The blue squares in Block A *are* abovethe yellow square in Block B, but not directly above it. Instead, Block C's yellow squares are abovethe yellow square in Block B. The answer is medium blue square number one.
Block B is below Block A and has a medium yellow square. Thus, the only thing above a medium yellow square in Block B would be in Block A. Medium blue square number one is at the bottom edge of Block A, and hence directly above the yellow square in Block B. Medium blue square number two is not at the bottom of Block A hence not directly above the yellow square in Block B.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain significantly misinterprets the spatial relationships within Block A as described in the context, leading to incorrect assumptions about which blue square is above the yellow square in Block B. It incorrectly places blue square number one at the bottom edge relative to all other squares in Block A.
Detected Issues (3)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
In Block A, black square number one is below black square number two. Blue square number two is below both black squares. And blue square number one is at the bottom edge of Block A, below everything else in that block.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly summarizes the relative positions of the squares within Block A. The context states: 'Medium blue square number two is below medium black square number two and medium black square number one. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two. Below medium black square number one and medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one.' The chain incorrectly states that blue square number one is at the bottom edge of Block A, below everything else, and misrepresents the relationship between blue square number one and the other squares.
Answer Span:
In Block A, black square number one is below black square number two. Blue square number two is below both black squares. And blue square number one is at the bottom edge of Block A, below everything else in that block.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium blue square number two is below medium black square number two and medium black square number one. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two. Below medium black square number one and medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Thus, the medium yellow square in Block B is directly below Block A, making it below blue square number one.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes a direct vertical stacking relationship between the blocks (A above B) and then incorrectly deduces the position of blue square number one relative to the yellow square in B, based on the flawed premise established in the previous step about blue square number one's position within Block A.
Answer Span:
Thus, the medium yellow square in Block B is directly below Block A, making it below blue square number one.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is below blocks A and C.
contradictionhigh
Statement
Medium blue square number one is at the bottom edge of Block A, and hence directly above the yellow square in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning claims blue square number one is at the bottom edge of Block A, which contradicts the context that states 'Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block' (referring to Block A), but the context also states that *below* medium black square number one and medium blue square number two is medium blue square number one. This implies blue square number one is the lowest of the four squares mentioned in Block A, but the reasoning chain uses this flawed premise to conclude it is 'directly above' the yellow square in B, which is an inference based on the previous hallucinated structure of Block A.
Answer Span:
Medium blue square number one is at the bottom edge of Block A, and hence directly above the yellow square in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block.
Question #2694
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the left of A. Block A is above B. Block A has two medium black squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium black squ...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the left of A. Block A is above B. Block A has two medium black squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square. It is below medium black square number two. Block B has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium black square number two. Block C has two medium yellow squares. A medium blue square is below medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block A or the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(b) the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B, and C. Block C is to the left of A. Block A is above B. Block A has two medium black squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square. It is below medium black square number two. Block B has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium black square number two. Block C has two medium yellow squares. A medium blue square is below medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block A or the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(b) the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C contains two medium yellow squares, with medium yellow square number one touching the bottom edge. Block A (which is above Block B and to the right of Block C) also contains a medium yellow square. Since Block C is to the left of Block A, the medium yellow square in Block A is to the right of both medium yellow squares in Block C, including the one touching the bottom edge. Therefore, both the medium yellow square in Block A and the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of Block C are to the right of a medium yellow square (specifically, the other medium yellow square in Block C). The answer is $\boxed{C}$.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain misinterprets the final question, leading to an incorrect logical path. It concludes that both options (a) and (b) are correct because they are to the right of *another* yellow square, rather than determining if the objects themselves (MY in A, or MY touching bottom edge) are located to the right of *any* yellow square based on the spatial layout (C is left of A).
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block C is to the left of Block A, the medium yellow square in Block A is to the right of both medium yellow squares in Block C, including the one touching the bottom edge.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes that the question is asking which object is to the right of *another* medium yellow square. The question asks: 'Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block A or the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?' This requires determining the relative horizontal positions of Block A and Block C, and then checking if the specified objects (MY in A, or MY touching bottom edge) are to the right of *any* medium yellow square.
Answer Span:
Since Block C is to the left of Block A, the medium yellow square in Block A is to the right of both medium yellow squares in Block C, including the one touching the bottom edge.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block A or the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #98
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. There are a small black circle, one medium black square and a big yellow square in block A. It also contains a medium black triangle. The big yellow square ...
Clean
Full Question
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. There are a small black circle, one medium black square and a big yellow square in block A. It also contains a medium black triangle. The big yellow square is to the left of the medium black triangle. The small black circle is to the left of the medium black triangle. Above the big yellow square is the medium black square. It is touching the right edge of this block. It is above the medium black triangle. To the right of the square which is to the left of the medium black triangle is the small black circle. Below block A we have block B which contains one big blue triangle, a big yellow square and one small yellow triangle. The big blue triangle is above and to the left of the small yellow triangle. It is above the big yellow square. To the left of the small yellow triangle is the big yellow square. What is to the left of the small yellow triangle? a big yellow square or a medium shape that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) big yellow square
(b) medium shape that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are two blocks. We call them A and B. There are a small black circle, one medium black square and a big yellow square in block A. It also contains a medium black triangle. The big yellow square is to the left of the medium black triangle. The small black circle is to the left of the medium black triangle. Above the big yellow square is the medium black square. It is touching the right edge of this block. It is above the medium black triangle. To the right of the square which is to the left of the medium black triangle is the small black circle. Below block A we have block B which contains one big blue triangle, a big yellow square and one small yellow triangle. The big blue triangle is above and to the left of the small yellow triangle. It is above the big yellow square. To the left of the small yellow triangle is the big yellow square. What is to the left of the small yellow triangle? a big yellow square or a medium shape that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) big yellow square
(b) medium shape that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a big yellow square, a medium black square (touching the right edge), a small black circle, and a medium black triangle. Block B (below Block A) contains a big blue triangle, a big yellow square, and a small yellow triangle. The big yellow square in Block B is to the left of the small yellow triangle. The question asks what is to the left of the small yellow triangle. Since the big yellow square in Block B is stated to be to the left of the small yellow triangle, the answer is big yellow square. The medium black square is in Block A, not Block B, and is therefore not to the left of the small yellow triangle.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relevant objects and their locations based on the context to answer the final question about what is to the left of the small yellow triangle in Block B.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2620
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the left of B and block B is to the left of C. Block A contains two medium yellow squares. One medium blue square is also touching the bo...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the left of B and block B is to the left of C. Block A contains two medium yellow squares. One medium blue square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two is medium yellow square number one. Below the square which is below medium yellow square number two there is the medium blue square. It is below medium yellow square number two. Block B contains one medium blue square. Block C has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below a medium black square is medium blue square number two. It also contains one medium yellow square. It is below the medium black square. It is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is below the medium yellow square and the medium black square. What is to the left of the black shape? a medium yellow square number one or a medium yellow square that is in block C?
(a) medium yellow square number one
(b) medium yellow square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block A is to the left of B and block B is to the left of C. Block A contains two medium yellow squares. One medium blue square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two is medium yellow square number one. Below the square which is below medium yellow square number two there is the medium blue square. It is below medium yellow square number two. Block B contains one medium blue square. Block C has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below a medium black square is medium blue square number two. It also contains one medium yellow square. It is below the medium black square. It is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is below the medium yellow square and the medium black square. What is to the left of the black shape? a medium yellow square number one or a medium yellow square that is in block C?
(a) medium yellow square number one
(b) medium yellow square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
We are given that Block A is to the left of Block B, and Block B is to the left of Block C. Block A contains two medium yellow squares (number one and two) and a medium blue square at the bottom. Block B contains a medium blue square. Block C contains two medium blue squares, a medium black square, and a medium yellow square. We want to find what is to the left of the medium black square (in Block C).
Since Block B is to the left of Block C, and Block B contains a medium blue square, the medium blue square in Block B is to the left of the medium black square in Block C. Block A is to the left of Block B and it contains medium yellow square number one, so medium yellow square number one is also to the left of the medium black square. The medium yellow square in Block C cannot be to the left of the medium black square because they are both in Block C. Therefore, the object to the left of the black shape is medium yellow square number one.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{A}$
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the relative positions of the blocks (A left of B left of C) and correctly identifies the target question (what is left of the black shape). However, it makes assumptions about the numbering of yellow squares in Block A and incorrectly asserts the presence and location of a yellow square in Block C based on complex positional descriptions, leading to potential inaccuracies in identifying the options provided in the question.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block A contains two medium yellow squares (number one and two) and a medium blue square at the bottom.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes the two medium yellow squares in Block A are numbered one and two. The context only states Block A has two medium yellow squares and one medium blue square touching the bottom edge. The numbering (one and two) is introduced later in relation to squares below another square, not explicitly assigned to the two squares in Block A.
Answer Span:
Block A contains two medium yellow squares (number one and two) and a medium blue square at the bottom.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains two medium yellow squares.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C contains two medium blue squares, a medium black square, and a medium yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain states Block C contains a medium yellow square. The context states Block C has two medium blue squares. It also states 'It also contains one medium yellow square. It is below the medium black square. It is below medium blue square number two.' This yellow square is associated with the description involving medium blue square number two, which is described in relation to Block C's contents, but the reasoning chain incorrectly asserts Block C *has* a medium yellow square without confirming its location relative to the block structure, or it misinterprets the complex description of the yellow square's location.
Answer Span:
Block C contains two medium blue squares, a medium black square, and a medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C has two medium blue squares.
Question #1748
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. A small yellow circle is in block A. Block B is to the right of block A. It has two medium yellow triangles. Above and near to a medium yellow square i...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. A small yellow circle is in block A. Block B is to the right of block A. It has two medium yellow triangles. Above and near to a medium yellow square is medium yellow triangle number two. There is also one medium black circle in this block. It also contains a small blue circle. The small blue circle is below and touching medium yellow triangle number two. Below and to the right of medium yellow triangle number two is the medium black circle. To the right of block A there is block C which has two medium yellow squares. It also contains one medium yellow triangle. It also contains a medium yellow circle. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of and below the medium yellow circle there is the medium yellow triangle. Near to, to the left of and below the medium yellow circle is medium yellow square number two. What is to the right of the small yellow circle? a medium black circle or a medium yellow triangle?
(a) medium black circle
(b) medium yellow triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. A small yellow circle is in block A. Block B is to the right of block A. It has two medium yellow triangles. Above and near to a medium yellow square is medium yellow triangle number two. There is also one medium black circle in this block. It also contains a small blue circle. The small blue circle is below and touching medium yellow triangle number two. Below and to the right of medium yellow triangle number two is the medium black circle. To the right of block A there is block C which has two medium yellow squares. It also contains one medium yellow triangle. It also contains a medium yellow circle. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of and below the medium yellow circle there is the medium yellow triangle. Near to, to the left of and below the medium yellow circle is medium yellow square number two. What is to the right of the small yellow circle? a medium black circle or a medium yellow triangle?
(a) medium black circle
(b) medium yellow triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
The small yellow circle is in Block A. Block B is to the right of Block A, and Block C is also to the right of Block A. Block B contains two medium yellow triangles and a medium black circle, while Block C contains one medium yellow triangle. Because both Block B and Block C are to the right of Block A, both the medium yellow triangle (in Block B) and the medium black circle (also in Block B) are to the right of the small yellow circle. Block C also has a medium yellow triangle to the right of the small yellow circle. Thus, both a medium black circle and a medium yellow triangle are to the right of the small yellow circle. Therefore, the answer is \boxed{C}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies that Block B and C are to the right of Block A (where the small yellow circle is). However, it makes an unsupported assumption that all objects in B and C are necessarily 'to the right of the small yellow circle' without confirming their specific spatial relationship to the circle, which is crucial for answering the question. It correctly identifies the presence of the required objects in blocks to the right, but the justification for their relative position is weak/missing context.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block B contains two medium yellow triangles and a medium black circle, while Block C contains one medium yellow triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly implies that the medium black circle is in Block B, but the context only states that Block B has two medium yellow triangles and one medium black circle. The reasoning then incorrectly attributes the medium yellow triangle in Block C to being to the right of the small yellow circle, without establishing its relative position to the small yellow circle, only that it is in Block C which is to the right of A. More critically, the reasoning claims 'both the medium yellow triangle (in Block B) and the medium black circle (also in Block B) are to the right of the small yellow circle.' This is an assumption based on Block B being to the right of A, but the specific location of the medium black circle relative to the small yellow circle is not established, only that the small yellow circle is in A and the black circle is in B.
Answer Span:
Block B contains two medium yellow triangles and a medium black circle, while Block C contains one medium yellow triangle. Because both Block B and Block C are to the right of Block A, both the medium yellow triangle (in Block B) and the medium black circle (also in Block B) are to the right of the small yellow circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the right of block A. It has two medium yellow triangles. . . There is also one medium black circle in this block.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C also has a medium yellow triangle to the right of the small yellow circle.
Explanation
The reasoning states that Block C has a medium yellow triangle to the right of the small yellow circle simply because Block C is to the right of Block A. However, the question asks what is *to the right of the small yellow circle*. While Block C is to the right of A (where the circle is), the specific location of the medium yellow triangle *within* C relative to the small yellow circle is not established, only that it is *in* C. The reasoning uses the block location as sufficient proof for the object's location relative to the circle, which is an unsupported leap.
Answer Span:
Block C also has a medium yellow triangle to the right of the small yellow circle.
Reference/Question Span:
To the right of block A there is block C which has two medium yellow squares. It also contains one medium yellow triangle.
Question #2543
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There is a medium yellow square in block A. Above block A there is block B which contains one medium blue triangle and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow t...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There is a medium yellow square in block A. Above block A there is block B which contains one medium blue triangle and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium blue triangle is near to a medium yellow circle. It is above the medium yellow triangle. Below the medium yellow circle is the medium yellow triangle. To the right of block A there is block C with one medium yellow square and a big yellow square in it. A small blue triangle is above the medium yellow square. The medium yellow square is above the big yellow square. The big yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. This object is near to and far from a big blue square. The small blue triangle is to the right of the big blue square. Which object is near to a medium yellow object? the medium yellow triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue triangle?
(a) the medium yellow triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. There is a medium yellow square in block A. Above block A there is block B which contains one medium blue triangle and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium blue triangle is near to a medium yellow circle. It is above the medium yellow triangle. Below the medium yellow circle is the medium yellow triangle. To the right of block A there is block C with one medium yellow square and a big yellow square in it. A small blue triangle is above the medium yellow square. The medium yellow square is above the big yellow square. The big yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. This object is near to and far from a big blue square. The small blue triangle is to the right of the big blue square. Which object is near to a medium yellow object? the medium yellow triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue triangle?
(a) the medium yellow triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B contains a medium blue triangle and a medium yellow triangle. The medium yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of Block B. The medium blue triangle is near a medium yellow circle and is above the medium yellow triangle.
Since the medium blue triangle is above and near to the medium yellow triangle (which is a medium yellow object), the medium blue triangle is near to a medium yellow object. Also, because the medium yellow triangle is a medium yellow object, it is near to itself.
Therefore, both the medium blue triangle and the medium yellow triangle are near to a medium yellow object.
Final Answer: \boxed{C}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in Block B. However, it incorrectly assumes proximity between the medium blue triangle and the medium yellow triangle based on the context, which only states the blue triangle is near a medium yellow circle. It also incorrectly concludes the medium yellow triangle is near itself, which is not supported by the context regarding proximity relationships.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since the medium blue triangle is above and near to the medium yellow triangle (which is a medium yellow object), the medium blue triangle is near to a medium yellow object.
Explanation
The reasoning claims the medium blue triangle is near to the medium yellow triangle. The context states the medium blue triangle is near to a medium yellow circle, not the medium yellow triangle. The question asks which object is near to *a* medium yellow object, and while the medium yellow triangle *is* a medium yellow object, the reasoning uses the proximity relationship established in the context (near to a medium yellow circle) to justify the conclusion about the medium blue triangle, but incorrectly substitutes the medium yellow triangle for the medium yellow circle in the proximity statement.
Answer Span:
The medium blue triangle is near a medium yellow circle and is above the medium yellow triangle. Since the medium blue triangle is above and near to the medium yellow triangle (which is a medium yellow object), the medium blue triangle is near to a medium yellow object.
Reference/Question Span:
The medium blue triangle is near to a medium yellow circle.
Question #1610
We have two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A has a small yellow triangle, one small blue circle and a small black circle. There is also one big blue circle touching the bottom edge of this bloc...
1 issue
Full Question
We have two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A has a small yellow triangle, one small blue circle and a small black circle. There is also one big blue circle touching the bottom edge of this block. The small black circle is to the left of the big blue circle. The small yellow triangle is above the big blue circle. It is to the left of the small blue circle which is to the right of the small black circle. Above the big blue circle is the small blue circle. Block B is above block A. It has one big yellow circle, one small black square and one small yellow triangle. A big blue circle is to the left of the big yellow circle , the small yellow triangle and the small black square. The big yellow circle is above the small yellow triangle. The small black square is touching the right edge of this block. What is to the left of the big yellow circle? a big blue circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a big blue circle that is in block B?
(a) big blue circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) big blue circle that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have two blocks. Let's call them A and B. Block A has a small yellow triangle, one small blue circle and a small black circle. There is also one big blue circle touching the bottom edge of this block. The small black circle is to the left of the big blue circle. The small yellow triangle is above the big blue circle. It is to the left of the small blue circle which is to the right of the small black circle. Above the big blue circle is the small blue circle. Block B is above block A. It has one big yellow circle, one small black square and one small yellow triangle. A big blue circle is to the left of the big yellow circle , the small yellow triangle and the small black square. The big yellow circle is above the small yellow triangle. The small black square is touching the right edge of this block. What is to the left of the big yellow circle? a big blue circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a big blue circle that is in block B?
(a) big blue circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) big blue circle that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is above Block A. Block B contains a big yellow circle, a small black square, a small yellow triangle, and a big blue circle. The question asks what is to the left of the big yellow circle. According to the question, the big blue circle in Block B is to the left of the big yellow circle, the small yellow triangle, and the small black square. The big blue circle in Block A is touching the bottom edge of Block A, and since Block B is above Block A, this big blue circle is not to the left of the big yellow circle in Block B. Therefore, only the big blue circle in Block B is to the left of the big yellow circle.
Final Answer: \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the relevant information about the big yellow circle and the object to its left in Block B. However, it incorrectly asserts that Block B contains a big blue circle, which contradicts the explicit listing of Block B's contents in the source text.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block B contains a big yellow circle, a small black square, a small yellow triangle, and a big blue circle.
Explanation
The context states Block B has one big yellow circle, one small black square and one small yellow triangle. It does not state Block B contains a big blue circle. The big blue circle mentioned in relation to Block B is described as being to the left of the big yellow circle, but its location (inside Block B) is not explicitly confirmed, only implied by the subsequent sentence structure. However, the explicit list of contents for Block B does not include a big blue circle.
Answer Span:
Block B contains a big yellow circle, a small black square, a small yellow triangle, and a big blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is above block A. It has one big yellow circle, one small black square and one small yellow triangle.
Question #516
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There is one big yellow square in block A. It also contains one medium black square. The medium black square is near to, above and to the right of the big yellow sq...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There is one big yellow square in block A. It also contains one medium black square. The medium black square is near to, above and to the right of the big yellow square. The big yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below block A is block B. It contains a big blue circle and a small black circle. The small black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is near to and to the right of the small black circle. Above block A there is block C which has a big blue triangle and one big yellow triangle. The big blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. This object is above and to the right of the big yellow triangle. What is below the big yellow square? a big blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block or a small black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) big blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) small black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** There are three blocks, A, B and C. There is one big yellow square in block A. It also contains one medium black square. The medium black square is near to, above and to the right of the big yellow square. The big yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below block A is block B. It contains a big blue circle and a small black circle. The small black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is near to and to the right of the small black circle. Above block A there is block C which has a big blue triangle and one big yellow triangle. The big blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. This object is above and to the right of the big yellow triangle. What is below the big yellow square? a big blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block or a small black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) big blue triangle that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) small black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block A contains a big yellow square and a medium black square. The big yellow square is touching the bottom edge of Block A. Block B is below Block A and contains a big blue circle and a small black circle. The small black circle is touching the bottom edge of Block B. Block C is above Block A and contains a big blue triangle touching the right edge.
Since we are looking for what is below the big yellow square in Block A and Block B is directly below Block A, we are looking for what is in Block B at the bottom edge. The small black circle is touching the bottom edge of Block B. Therefore, the small black circle is below the big yellow square. The big blue triangle is in Block C (above Block A), so it cannot be below the big yellow square.
Final Answer: \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the blocks and the objects within them to answer the question about what is below the big yellow square.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2693
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the left of A. Block A is above B. Block A has two medium black squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium black squ...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block C is to the left of A. Block A is above B. Block A has two medium black squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square. It is below medium black square number two. Block B has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium black square number two. Block C has two medium yellow squares. A medium blue square is below medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block A or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block C is to the left of A. Block A is above B. Block A has two medium black squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square. It is below medium black square number two. Block B has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium black square number two. Block C has two medium yellow squares. A medium blue square is below medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block A or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a medium yellow square, which is below medium black square number two and above medium black square number one. Block B, which is below Block A, contains two medium black squares with medium black square number one touching the bottom edge. Block C has two medium yellow squares, with medium yellow square number one touching the bottom edge.
The question asks what is below a medium yellow square.
The medium yellow square in Block A has a medium black square (number one)below it. This is a medium black square, not a medium yellow square.
The medium yellow squaretouching the bottom edge of Block Chas nothing below it, as it's at the bottom edge. Therefore, it doesn't have another medium yellow square below it.
Therefore, the answer is \boxed{(d) none of them}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects below the two specified yellow squares (a black square for A, and nothing for C's bottom yellow square). However, it misses the crucial step of checking if the object below is *also* a medium yellow square, which is what the final question asks for when evaluating options (a) and (b). The reasoning correctly concludes (d) based on its findings, but the evaluation of option (a) is incomplete regarding the required object type.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionlow
Statement
Block A contains a medium yellow square, which is below medium black square number two and above medium black square number one.
Explanation
The context states that the medium yellow square in Block A is below medium black square number two, but it does not state it is *above* medium black square number one. The context states medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of Block A, and the medium yellow square is above it, but the reasoning chain presents this as a direct fact about the yellow square's relation to black square one, which is slightly misstated/incomplete compared to the context's structure.
Answer Span:
Block A contains a medium yellow square, which is below medium black square number two and above medium black square number one.
Reference/Question Span:
This block also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The medium yellow square in Block A has a medium black square (number one) below it.
Explanation
The question asks which object is below a medium yellow square. The reasoning concludes that the medium yellow square in Block A has medium black square number one below it. This is true, but the question asks if the object below it is *a medium yellow square*. The reasoning fails to check if the object below it (medium black square number one) is a medium yellow square, which is the core requirement for answering option (a).
Answer Span:
The medium yellow square in Block A has a medium black square (number one) below it. This is a medium black square, not a medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block A or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #1345
We have two blocks, A and B. Block A contains one small yellow circle, a big blue circle and a small black circle. The small yellow circle is below the big blue circle. The big blue circle is to the l...
Clean
Full Question
We have two blocks, A and B. Block A contains one small yellow circle, a big blue circle and a small black circle. The small yellow circle is below the big blue circle. The big blue circle is to the left of and above the small black circle. The small black circle is touching the right edge of this block. To the right of block A we have block B. It contains a medium yellow square, one big blue triangle and one small black triangle. This block also has a medium yellow circle. Above the small black triangle and the big blue triangle is a medium black triangle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The small black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the medium yellow circle and the small black triangle is the big blue triangle. Which object is to the right of a object that is touching the right edge of a block? the big blue circle or the medium square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the big blue circle
(b) the medium square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** We have two blocks, A and B. Block A contains one small yellow circle, a big blue circle and a small black circle. The small yellow circle is below the big blue circle. The big blue circle is to the left of and above the small black circle. The small black circle is touching the right edge of this block. To the right of block A we have block B. It contains a medium yellow square, one big blue triangle and one small black triangle. This block also has a medium yellow circle. Above the small black triangle and the big blue triangle is a medium black triangle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The small black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the medium yellow circle and the small black triangle is the big blue triangle. Which object is to the right of a object that is touching the right edge of a block? the big blue circle or the medium square that is touching the bottom edge of a block? (a) the big blue circle (b) the medium square that is touching the bottom edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block A contains a small black circle touching its right edge (). Block B is to the right of Block A. Block B contains a medium yellow square touching the bottom edge () and a small black triangle also touching the bottom edge. Since Block B is to the right of Block A, and the small black circle is touching the right edge of Block A (), then both the medium yellow square and small black triangle in Block B are to the right of the small black circle. Thus, the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of Block B is to the right of the small black circle. The big blue circle is in Block A, so it cannot be to the right of the small black circle which is also in Block A and touching its right edge. Therefore, the answer is \boxed{b}.
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the object touching the right edge of a block (small black circle in Block A) and then checks which of the listed objects are to its right (which means they must be in Block B, or further right, but the context only defines Block B relative to A). It correctly concludes that the medium yellow square in Block B is to the right of the small black circle, while the big blue circle in Block A is not. The reasoning is sound based on the provided context.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1295
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A is below B. Block A contains one small black circle, one medium black triangle and one small blue triangle. The small black circle is touching the...
1 issue
Full Question
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A is below B. Block A contains one small black circle, one medium black triangle and one small blue triangle. The small black circle is touching the right edge of this block. Below and to the right of a medium black square is the small blue triangle. A medium yellow square is also in this block. Above and to the right of the small blue triangle is the small black circle. The small blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and below the medium black triangle is the small black circle. Block B has two medium black circles. Medium black circle number one is below medium black circle number two. Medium black circle number one is touching the right edge of this block. A small blue square is to the left of and above medium black circle number two. Medium black circle number two is touching the right edge of this block. Which object is below a medium black circle? the small blue square or the medium black square?
(a) the small blue square
(b) the medium black square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are two blocks. Let's call them A and B. Block A is below B. Block A contains one small black circle, one medium black triangle and one small blue triangle. The small black circle is touching the right edge of this block. Below and to the right of a medium black square is the small blue triangle. A medium yellow square is also in this block. Above and to the right of the small blue triangle is the small black circle. The small blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and below the medium black triangle is the small black circle. Block B has two medium black circles. Medium black circle number one is below medium black circle number two. Medium black circle number one is touching the right edge of this block. A small blue square is to the left of and above medium black circle number two. Medium black circle number two is touching the right edge of this block. Which object is below a medium black circle? the small blue square or the medium black square?
(a) the small blue square
(b) the medium black square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B contains two medium black circles. Medium black circle number one is below medium black circle number two. Block A is below Block B. Block A contains a small black circle, a medium black triangle, and a small blue triangle. It also contains a medium black square and a medium yellow square. Since Block A is below Block B, and Block B contains the medium black circles, any objects in Block A are below the medium black circles in Block B. Block A contains the medium black square (below medium black circle number two). The small blue square is above medium black circle number two and is therefore not below any medium black circles. Thus, only the medium black square is below a medium black circle.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{b}$
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that objects in Block A are below the medium black circles in Block B. It correctly deduces that the medium black square (in Block A) is below a medium black circle. It correctly uses the relative positioning of the small blue square (in Block B, above MBC2, and thus above MBC1) to conclude it is not below any medium black circle. The logic is sound and supported by the context.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionlow
Statement
The small blue square is above medium black circle number two and is therefore not below any medium black circles.
Explanation
The reasoning chain claims the small blue square is above medium black circle number two. The context states: 'A small blue square is to the left of and above medium black circle number two.' This part is consistent. However, the reasoning then concludes it is *not* below any medium black circles based on this position relative to MBC2. The question asks which object (small blue square or medium black square) is below *a* medium black circle. The medium black square is in Block A, which is below Block B (where the medium black circles are). The small blue square is in Block B, positioned above MBC2. The reasoning incorrectly uses the relative position of the small blue square to MBC2 to definitively state it is not below *any* medium black circle, when the context only places it relative to MBC2, not relative to MBC1 or the overall block structure in a way that excludes it from being below *a* medium black circle (though in this specific case, it is above MBC2, and MBC1 is below MBC2, so it is above both). The critical error is the conclusion drawn from the relative position, but the most direct contradiction is the assertion about its location relative to MBC2 being the final determinant, ignoring the possibility of being below MBC1 if it were positioned differently, or misinterpreting the overall structure. More critically, the reasoning chain seems to assume that because the small blue square is in Block B, and it is above MBC2, it cannot be below any medium black circle. The context states MBC1 is below MBC2. If the small blue square is above MBC2, it must also be above MBC1. The reasoning chain correctly identifies the relative position but then draws a conclusion that is not fully supported or is based on an incomplete assessment of the structure, leading to a potentially flawed step in the logic chain, although the final conclusion about the small blue square being above MBC2 is factually derived from the text. The primary issue is the leap in logic that being 'above MBC2' means it is 'not below any medium black circles' without explicitly checking its relation to MBC1, which is below MBC2. However, since MBC1 is below MBC2, and the square is above MBC2, it must be above MBC1. The reasoning chain's conclusion that it is 'therefore not below any medium black circles' is logically sound *if* the premise (above MBC2) is true, which it is. Let's re-examine the contradiction based on the structure: MBC1 is below MBC2. SBS is above MBC2. Therefore SBS is above MBC1. So SBS is not below any medium black circle. The reasoning chain seems logically sound based on the facts provided, even if it skips checking MBC1 explicitly. Let's look for a clearer contradiction or missing context. The reasoning chain states: 'Block A contains the medium black square (below medium black circle number two).' This is an inference, not explicitly stated. The context says Block A is below Block B. Block B contains the medium black circles. Therefore, everything in Block A is below the medium black circles in Block B. The reasoning chain correctly deduces this general principle: 'Since Block A is below Block B, and Block B contains the medium black circles, any objects in Block A are below the medium black circles in Block B.' Then it applies this: 'Block A contains the medium black square (below medium black circle number two).' This parenthetical statement is an inference based on the general principle just stated, not a direct contradiction. Let's re-evaluate the small blue square statement: 'The small blue square is above medium black circle number two and is therefore not below any medium black circles.' The context says: 'A small blue square is to the left of and above medium black circle number two.' This is consistent. Since MBC1 is below MBC2, if SBS is above MBC2, it is above MBC1. Thus, it is not below any medium black circle. The reasoning chain appears factually correct based on the context provided, even if slightly verbose in its justification for the SBS. I will mark the reasoning as having no hallucinations based on a strict interpretation of contradiction/missing context relative to the source text.
Answer Span:
The small blue square is above medium black circle number two and is therefore not below any medium black circles.
Reference/Question Span:
A small blue square is to the left of and above medium black circle number two.
Question #464
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Blocks B and A are below C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium bl...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Blocks B and A are below C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square. A medium blue square is also in this block. It is below medium black square number two. Below the medium blue square , the medium yellow square and medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. Block B has one medium blue square and one medium yellow square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It also contains one medium black square. This object is below the medium yellow square. Below the medium black square and the medium yellow square is the medium blue square. Block C contains one medium black square. Which object is below a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is in block B or the medium yellow square that is in block A?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block B
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B and C. Blocks B and A are below C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square. A medium blue square is also in this block. It is below medium black square number two. Below the medium blue square , the medium yellow square and medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. Block B has one medium blue square and one medium yellow square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It also contains one medium black square. This object is below the medium yellow square. Below the medium black square and the medium yellow square is the medium blue square. Block C contains one medium black square. Which object is below a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is in block B or the medium yellow square that is in block A?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block B
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C contains a medium black square. Blocks A and B are below Block C. Block A contains a medium yellow square and Block B contains a medium yellow square. In Block A, the medium yellow square is above medium black square number two, which means medium black square number two is below the medium yellow square. In Block B, the medium yellow square is above the medium black square, which means the medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Since both Block A and Block B are below Block C, which contains a medium black square, both the medium yellow square in Block A and the medium yellow square in Block B are below a medium black square (the one in Block C). Therefore, the answer is {C}. \boxed{c}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes unsupported inferences about the relative positions of squares within Block A and incorrectly uses the black square in Block C to justify the answer, ignoring the specific relationships described within Blocks A and B that directly address the question.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
In Block A, the medium yellow square is above medium black square number two, which means medium black square number two is below the medium yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning claims the medium yellow square is above medium black square number two in Block A, but the context only states: 'Medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square.' This implies the yellow square is above the black square, but the reasoning chain incorrectly assumes the relative positions of the other objects in Block A (like the blue square and black square #1) to support this claim, leading to an unsupported inference about the yellow square's position relative to black square #2.
Answer Span:
In Block A, the medium yellow square is above medium black square number two, which means medium black square number two is below the medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since both Block A and Block B are below Block C, which contains a medium black square, both the medium yellow square in Block A and the medium yellow square in Block B are below a medium black square (the one in Block C).
Explanation
The reasoning concludes that the yellow squares in A and B are below the black square in C. While A and B are below C, the question asks which yellow square is below *a* medium black square (implying a black square within the same block or immediately adjacent/related structure, or simply any black square). The reasoning chain fails to establish that the yellow square in A is below the black square in A, or the yellow square in B is below the black square in B, which are the primary relationships to check. Instead, it jumps to the black square in C, which is an irrelevant comparison based on the structure described for A and B.
Answer Span:
Since both Block A and Block B are below Block C, which contains a medium black square, both the medium yellow square in Block A and the medium yellow square in Block B are below a medium black square (the one in Block C).
Reference/Question Span:
Blocks B and A are below C.
Question #782
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is to the right of A. Block A has a big black circle. It also contains a small yellow triangle. The small yellow ...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is to the right of A. Block A has a big black circle. It also contains a small yellow triangle. The small yellow triangle is above and to the left of the big black circle. Block B has two big yellow triangles. It also contains a medium yellow circle. This block also has a big yellow circle. Big yellow triangle number one is touching the right edge of this block. Below a small black square there is big yellow triangle number two.. The medium yellow circle is to the right of and below the small black square. Far from and above the big yellow circle is big yellow triangle number one. It is to the right of big yellow triangle number two. And block C contains a medium blue triangle and a medium black circle. Below and to the left of the medium black circle there is the medium blue triangle. What is to the left of the thing which is touching the right edge of a block? a small yellow triangle or a big black circle?
(a) small yellow triangle
(b) big black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:**
There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is to the right of A. Block A has a big black circle. It also contains a small yellow triangle. The small yellow triangle is above and to the left of the big black circle. Block B has two big yellow triangles. It also contains a medium yellow circle. This block also has a big yellow circle. Big yellow triangle number one is touching the right edge of this block. Below a small black square there is big yellow triangle number two. The medium yellow circle is to the right of and below the small black square. Far from and above the big yellow circle is big yellow triangle number one. It is to the right of big yellow triangle number two. And block C contains a medium blue triangle and a medium black circle. Below and to the left of the medium black circle there is the medium blue triangle. What is to the left of the thing which is touching the right edge of a block? a small yellow triangle or a big black circle?
(a) small yellow triangle
(b) big black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block C is to the left of Block B, and Block B is to the right of Block A. This means the order is A, B, C from right to left. Block B contains big yellow triangle number one, which is touching the right edge. We want to know what is to the left of this. Since Block B is to the right of Block A, and Block A contains both the small yellow triangle and the big black circle, neither object is to the left of the big yellow triangle touching the right edge of Block B. Thus, the answer is none of them and the circled answer is (D).
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{D}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly deduces the spatial arrangement of the blocks (A, B, C) based on the provided constraints, leading to a flawed subsequent step in identifying the object to the left of the target location.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block C is to the left of Block B, and Block B is to the right of Block A. This means the order is A, B, C from right to left.
Explanation
The context states: 'Block C is to the left of B and block B is to the right of A.' This establishes the order from left to right as C, B, A or A, B, C depending on how 'left of' and 'right of' relate across all three. If C is left of B, and B is right of A (meaning A is left of B), the order from left to right must be C, A, B or A, C, B or C, A, B. The statement 'Block C is to the left of B' and 'block B is to the right of A' implies A is to the left of B. If C is to the left of B, the relative order of A and C is not fully determined by these two statements alone, but the conclusion that the order is A, B, C from right to left (meaning C, B, A from left to right) contradicts the explicit statement that C is to the left of B, and B is to the right of A (A is left of B). If the order is C, B, A from left to right, then C is left of B, but B is to the left of A, which contradicts 'block B is to the right of A'. If the order is A, B, C from left to right, then C is to the right of B, which contradicts 'Block C is to the left of B'. The only consistent order from left to right is C, A, B or A, C, B or A, B, C. Let's re-evaluate the explicit constraints: C < B and A < B. The reasoning concludes A, B, C from right to left, which is C, B, A from left to right. In C, B, A: C is left of B (True). B is right of A (False, B is left of A). Therefore, the derived order is factually incorrect based on the premises.
Answer Span:
Block C is to the left of Block B, and Block B is to the right of Block A. This means the order is A, B, C from right to left.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C is to the left of B and block B is to the right of A.
Question #1601
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There are one small black square, one small black circle and one big black square in block A. The small black square is below and near to the small black circle. Th...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There are one small black square, one small black circle and one big black square in block A. The small black square is below and near to the small black circle. This object is to the left of the big black square. Below block A we have block B with one big blue circle, one small blue circle and a medium blue triangle in it. The big blue circle is above the medium blue triangle which is near to a big yellow triangle. The small blue circle is above the big yellow triangle. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Near to and to the left of the medium blue triangle there is the small blue circle. To the left of block A there is block C. It contains one small yellow circle and a big black square. To the right of the big black square there is the small yellow circle. What is below the small black circle? a small black square or a big yellow triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) small black square
(b) big yellow triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** There are three blocks, A, B and C. There are one small black square, one small black circle and one big black square in block A. The small black square is below and near to the small black circle. This object is to the left of the big black square. Below block A we have block B with one big blue circle, one small blue circle and a medium blue triangle in it. The big blue circle is above the medium blue triangle which is near to a big yellow triangle. The small blue circle is above the big yellow triangle. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Near to and to the left of the medium blue triangle there is the small blue circle. To the left of block A there is block C. It contains one small yellow circle and a big black square. To the right of the big black square there is the small yellow circle. What is below the small black circle? a small black square or a big yellow triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) small black square
(b) big yellow triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block A contains a small black square, a small black circle, and a big black square. The small black square is below the small black circle. Block B is below Block A, and it contains a big yellow triangle touching the bottom edge. Since Block B is directly below Block A, the object directly below the small black circle in Block A is the small black square. The big yellow triangle touching the bottom edge is in Block B, so it cannot be directly below anything in Block A. Therefore, the answer is {a}. \boxed{a}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in Block A but makes a critical logical leap by assuming the answer must be within Block A, ignoring the possibility of objects in Block B being below the small black circle, which is one of the options provided in the question.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B is directly below Block A, the object directly below the small black circle in Block A is the small black square.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes that because Block B is below Block A, the object directly below the small black circle (which is in Block A) must be the small black square (which is also in Block A). The question asks what is below the small black circle, which could be an object in Block A or an object in Block B. The reasoning incorrectly concludes the answer based only on the relative positions within Block A, ignoring the possibility of objects in Block B being below it.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is directly below Block A, the object directly below the small black circle in Block A is the small black square.
Reference/Question Span:
What is below the small black circle? a small black square or a big yellow triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #3127
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is below B. Block C is to the right of A. Block A has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the right edge of this block. M...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is below B. Block C is to the right of A. Block A has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the right edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. Above medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. Block B has one big black square and a big black circle. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. This block also has a small black circle. The big black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big black square is to the right of the big black circle and the small black circle. And block C has one big black triangle. There is also a small yellow circle in this block. Near to and to the left of the big black triangle is the small yellow circle. The big black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the small yellow circle or the small black circle?
(a) the small yellow circle
(b) the small black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:**
There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block A is below B. Block C is to the right of A. Block A has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the right edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. Above medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. Block B has one big black square and a big black circle. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. This block also has a small black circle. The big black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big black square is to the right of the big black circle and the small black circle. And block C has one big black triangle. There is also a small yellow circle in this block. Near to and to the left of the big black triangle is the small yellow circle. The big black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the small yellow circle or the small black circle?
(a) the small yellow circle
(b) the small black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block A has two medium yellow squares. Block B is above Block A, and contains a big black square, a big black circle, and a small black circle. Block C is to the right of Block A and contains a big black triangle and a small yellow circle.
Since the question asks what is above the medium yellow squares, and Block B is above Block A (which contains the medium yellow squares), we consider the objects in Block B. Block B contains a small black circle. The small yellow circle is in Block C, which is not above Block A. Therefore, the object above a medium yellow square is the small black circle.
Final Answer: \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies that Block B is above Block A (where the medium yellow squares are located) and concludes that the small black circle (located in Block B) is above a medium yellow square, while correctly dismissing the small yellow circle (located in Block C).
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #463
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Blocks B and A are below C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium bl...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Blocks B and A are below C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square. A medium blue square is also in this block. It is below medium black square number two. Below the medium blue square , the medium yellow square and medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. Block B has one medium blue square and one medium yellow square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It also contains one medium black square. This object is below the medium yellow square. Below the medium black square and the medium yellow square is the medium blue square. Block C contains one medium black square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is in block B or the medium black square which is in block C?
(a) the medium black square that is in block B
(b) the medium black square which is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B and C. Blocks B and A are below C. Block A has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square. A medium blue square is also in this block. It is below medium black square number two. Below the medium blue square , the medium yellow square and medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. Block B has one medium blue square and one medium yellow square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It also contains one medium black square. This object is below the medium yellow square. Below the medium black square and the medium yellow square is the medium blue square. Block C contains one medium black square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is in block B or the medium black square which is in block C?
(a) the medium black square that is in block B
(b) the medium black square which is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Blocks A and B are below block C. In Block A, the medium yellow square is above medium black square number two, which is above a medium blue square, and finally above medium black square number one (touching the bottom edge). In Block B, the medium yellow square is above a medium black square, which is above a medium blue square (touching the bottom edge). Block C contains a medium black square.
The question asks what is below a medium yellow square. In Block B, the medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Since Block B is below Block C, the medium black square in Block C cannot be below the medium yellow square in Block B. Therefore, only the medium black square in Block B is below a medium yellow square.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains a major contradiction regarding the vertical arrangement of squares within Block A and introduces an irrelevant constraint based on block hierarchy to dismiss one of the options.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
In Block A, the medium yellow square is above medium black square number two, which is above a medium blue square, and finally above medium black square number one (touching the bottom edge).
Explanation
The context states that medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square, and the medium blue square is below medium black square number two. It does not state the yellow square is above black square two. Furthermore, the context states that below the medium blue square, the medium yellow square and medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. The reasoning chain reverses the order described for Block A.
Answer Span:
In Block A, the medium yellow square is above medium black square number two, which is above a medium blue square, and finally above medium black square number one (touching the bottom edge)
Reference/Question Span:
Medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square. A medium blue square is also in this block. It is below medium black square number two. Below the medium blue square , the medium yellow square and medium black square number two there is medium black square number one.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block B is below Block C, the medium black square in Block C cannot be below the medium yellow square in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes that for one object to be below another, they must be in the same block, or that the relative vertical position of blocks (B below C) prevents an object in C from being below an object in B. The question asks which object is below a medium yellow square, referring to the objects described in the context, which are organized vertically within blocks. The relationship 'Blocks B and A are below C' describes the block positions relative to each other, but the question is about the internal structure described for the squares. The reasoning incorrectly uses the block hierarchy to dismiss the possibility of the black square in C being below the yellow square in B, which is irrelevant to the internal structure described for the squares.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is below Block C, the medium black square in Block C cannot be below the medium yellow square in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Blocks B and A are below C.
Question #730
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. One medium yellow triangle, one medium blue triangle and one small blue square are in block A. Below a small black triangle is the medium yellow triang...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. One medium yellow triangle, one medium blue triangle and one small blue square are in block A. Below a small black triangle is the medium yellow triangle. Below the small black triangle is a big yellow square. This object is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of the medium blue triangle which is near to the small blue square is the medium yellow triangle. Above and to the right of the small black triangle is the small blue square. Then, we have block B. It has a small yellow square and a medium yellow square. A medium blue circle is to the right of the medium yellow square and the small yellow square. Below the medium yellow square there is the small yellow square. Below both blocks A and B there is block C which contains one small black circle. Which object is above a small black circle? the small blue square or the big yellow object that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small blue square
(b) the big yellow object that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. One medium yellow triangle, one medium blue triangle and one small blue square are in block A. Below a small black triangle is the medium yellow triangle. Below the small black triangle is a big yellow square. This object is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of the medium blue triangle which is near to the small blue square is the medium yellow triangle. Above and to the right of the small black triangle is the small blue square. Then, we have block B. It has a small yellow square and a medium yellow square. A medium blue circle is to the right of the medium yellow square and the small yellow square. Below the medium yellow square there is the small yellow square. Below both blocks A and B there is block C which contains one small black circle. Which object is above a small black circle? the small blue square or the big yellow object that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small blue square
(b) the big yellow object that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a medium yellow triangle, a medium blue triangle, and a small blue square. A big yellow square is at the bottom of Block A. Block B contains a small yellow square and a medium yellow square. Block C, below both Block A and Block B, contains a small black circle. Since the big yellow square is at the bottom of Block A, and Block C (with the small black circle) is directly below Block A, the big yellow square is directly above the small black circle. The small blue square, however, is not directly above the small black circle, but rather higher up in Block A. Therefore, the object directly above the small black circle is the big yellow object that is touching the bottom edge of a block (Block A).
Final Answer: \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the location of the small black circle in Block C and correctly deduces which object in Block A is positioned above it based on the provided spatial relationships, leading to the correct choice.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2973
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square and one medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium ...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square and one medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square. Block B is to the left of block A. It has a medium black square. Below block B there is block C with two medium black squares and two other medium yellow squares in it. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two is medium black square number two. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. It is below medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two and medium yellow square number one is medium black square number one. Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block A?
(a) the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium black square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. We call them A, B, and C. Block A has a medium blue square and one medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square. Block B is to the left of block A. It has a medium black square. Below block B there is block C with two medium black squares and two other medium yellow squares in it. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two is medium black square number two. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. It is below medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two and medium yellow square number one is medium black square number one. Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block A?
(a) the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium black square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is to the left of Block A, and it contains a medium black square. Block A contains a medium black square and a medium blue square. Block C is below Block B and contains two medium black squares and two medium yellow squares.
The question asks what is to the right of a medium black square. Since Block B is to the left of Block A and contains a medium black square, the objects in Block A are to the right of the medium black square in Block B. Therefore, the medium black square in Block A is to the right of the medium black square in Block B. Block C is below Block B, so the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block C is not to the right of the medium black square in Block B. Thus, only the medium black square in Block A is to the right of a medium black square, specifically the one in Block B.
Final Answer: \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of Blocks A and B, but it fails to fully utilize the detailed positional information provided for the squares in Block C, which is necessary to evaluate option (a) correctly. It concludes that the black square touching the bottom edge of C is not to the right of the black square in B, but this conclusion is based on an incomplete analysis of the context regarding that specific square.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C is below Block B and contains two medium black squares and two medium yellow squares.
Explanation
The reasoning chain states Block C is below Block B, which is true, but it fails to incorporate the specific positional information given for the squares within Block C, which is crucial for determining which black square is touching the bottom edge.
Answer Span:
Block C is below Block B and contains two medium black squares and two medium yellow squares.
Reference/Question Span:
Below block B there is block C with two medium black squares and two other medium yellow squares in it. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block.
Question #2206
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is below A. Block C is to the right of B. Block A has one medium black square and one medium yellow square. The medium black square is below th...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is below A. Block C is to the right of B. Block A has one medium black square and one medium yellow square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Block B contains two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below a medium yellow square. A medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium blue square number two there is the medium yellow square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square , medium blue square number one and medium blue square number two. And block C contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block B or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block B
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block B is below A. Block C is to the right of B. Block A has one medium black square and one medium yellow square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Block B contains two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below a medium yellow square. A medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium blue square number two there is the medium yellow square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square , medium blue square number one and medium blue square number two. And block C contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block B or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block B
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block B contains two medium blue squares and a medium yellow square. Block C contains two medium yellow squares, one of which (medium yellow square number one) is touching the bottom edge. Since Block C is to the right of Block B, and the question asks what is to the left of a medium yellow square, we can infer the medium yellow square in question is the one in Block B. Therefore, since Block C is to the right of Block B, the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of Block C would be to the right of the medium yellow square in Block B, not to the left. The answer is the medium yellow square that is in block B.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly states the contents of Block B, claiming it contains a medium yellow square when the context assigns yellow squares to A and C. It also fails to correctly analyze the spatial relationships required to answer the final question, relying on an unsupported inference about what is to the left of what.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block B contains two medium blue squares and a medium yellow square.
Explanation
The context states Block A has the medium yellow squares, not Block B. Block B contains two medium blue squares.
Answer Span:
Block B contains two medium blue squares and a medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has one medium black square and one medium yellow square. . . Block B contains two medium blue squares.
contradictionmedium
Statement
The answer is the medium yellow square that is in block B.
Explanation
The reasoning concludes that the medium yellow square in Block B is the answer, but the context does not support that this object is to the left of *any* medium yellow square mentioned in the question's final query. The reasoning chain fails to establish the spatial relationship required by the question.
Answer Span:
The answer is the medium yellow square that is in block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block B or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #565
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One big black circle is in block A. Below block A there is block B with a big blue triangle, a big black triangle and one big blue square in it. Above and to the ri...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. One big black circle is in block A. Below block A there is block B with a big blue triangle, a big black triangle and one big blue square in it. Above and to the right of a medium black triangle there is the big blue triangle. The big black triangle is above the medium black triangle. It is to the left of and below the big blue square. Above block A there is block C with one small yellow square and a small black square in it. A big blue square is below the small yellow square. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. A big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and near to the small black square is the big blue square. The small black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and below the small yellow square is the big blue triangle. What is below the circle? a big blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a medium black triangle?
(a) big blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium black triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B and C. One big black circle is in block A. Below block A there is block B with a big blue triangle, a big black triangle and one big blue square in it. Above and to the right of a medium black triangle there is the big blue triangle. The big black triangle is above the medium black triangle. It is to the left of and below the big blue square. Above block A there is block C with one small yellow square and a small black square in it. A big blue square is below the small yellow square. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. A big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and near to the small black square is the big blue square. The small black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and below the small yellow square is the big blue triangle. What is below the circle? a big blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a medium black triangle?
(a) big blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium black triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a big black circle. Block B is below Block A and contains a big blue triangle, a big black triangle, a big blue square, and a medium black triangle. Block C is above Block A. Since we're looking for what's below the circle in Block A, and Block B is below Block A, we need to consider the contents of Block B. Block B contains a big black triangle which is above a medium black triangle. Therefore, the object directly below the big black circle is the big black triangle which itself is above a medium black triangle. The answer is {B}. \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes the contents of Block B and makes an unsupported leap about which object is directly below the circle in Block A, ignoring the ambiguity in the question itself.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block B contains a big blue triangle, a big black triangle, a big blue square, and a medium black triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain claims Block B contains a medium black triangle, but the context only states Block B contains 'a big blue triangle, a big black triangle and one big blue square in it.' The medium black triangle's location is described relative to other objects, not explicitly listed as being *in* Block B.
Answer Span:
Block B contains a big blue triangle, a big black triangle, a big blue square, and a medium black triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
Below block A there is block B with a big blue triangle, a big black triangle and one big blue square in it.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Therefore, the object directly below the big black circle is the big black triangle which itself is above a medium black triangle.
Explanation
The question asks what is below the circle (which is in Block A). The reasoning chain jumps to concluding the big black triangle is directly below the circle, but the context only establishes that Block B is below Block A. It does not specify the vertical relationship between the circle in A and any specific object in B, nor does it confirm the big black triangle is *directly* below the circle.
Answer Span:
Therefore, the object directly below the big black circle is the big black triangle which itself is above a medium black triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
What is below the circle? a big blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a medium black triangle?
Question #1602
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There are one small black square, one small black circle and one big black square in block A. The small black square is below and near to the small black circle. Th...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. There are one small black square, one small black circle and one big black square in block A. The small black square is below and near to the small black circle. This object is to the left of the big black square. Below block A we have block B with one big blue circle, one small blue circle and a medium blue triangle in it. The big blue circle is above the medium blue triangle which is near to a big yellow triangle. The small blue circle is above the big yellow triangle. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Near to and to the left of the medium blue triangle there is the small blue circle. To the left of block A there is block C. It contains one small yellow circle and a big black square. To the right of the big black square there is the small yellow circle. Which object is below a big black square? the small black square or the big shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small black square
(b) the big shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** There are three blocks, A, B and C. There are one small black square, one small black circle and one big black square in block A. The small black square is below and near to the small black circle. This object is to the left of the big black square. Below block A we have block B with one big blue circle, one small blue circle and a medium blue triangle in it. The big blue circle is above the medium blue triangle which is near to a big yellow triangle. The small blue circle is above the big yellow triangle. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Near to and to the left of the medium blue triangle there is the small blue circle. To the left of block A there is block C. It contains one small yellow circle and a big black square. To the right of the big black square there is the small yellow circle. Which object is below a big black square? the small black square or the big shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small black square
(b) the big shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
In Block A, the big black square is located with the small black circle and the small black square, such that the small black square is below the small black circle. Block B is positioned below Block A. Block B contains a big yellow triangle touching the bottom edge. Since we are looking for what is below the big black square in Block A, and Block B is directly below Block A, the object below the big black square is the big yellow triangle which is touching the bottom edge of Block B. The small black square is below the small black circle within Block A, not below the big black square itself. Therefore, the answer is {b}.
\boxed{b}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain fails to correctly evaluate the two candidates presented in the question against the condition 'below a big black square'. It incorrectly assumes the object below the big black square in Block A must be in Block B, and it incorrectly dismisses the first candidate ('the small black square') based on its relationship with another object in Block A, rather than checking the required condition.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
the big yellow triangle which is touching the bottom edge of Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning chain identifies the 'big yellow triangle' as the object below the big black square, but the question asks which of two specific objects is below *a* big black square: 'the small black square or the big shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block?'. The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes the object below the big black square in Block A must be in Block B, and then selects one of the options provided in the question based on an incorrect premise about what is below the big black square.
Answer Span:
the big yellow triangle which is touching the bottom edge of Block B
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is below a big black square? the small black square or the big shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The small black square is below the small black circle within Block A, not below the big black square itself.
Explanation
The reasoning chain correctly notes the relationship between the small black square and the small black circle, but then incorrectly dismisses the first option ('the small black square') based on its internal relationship within Block A, rather than checking if the small black square is below *a* big black square (which is in Block A). The question asks to evaluate two specific candidates against the condition 'below a big black square'. The reasoning ignores checking the first candidate against the condition.
Answer Span:
The small black square is below the small black circle within Block A, not below the big black square itself.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is below a big black square? the small black square or the big shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #2095
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and a medium black square. This shape ...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and a medium black square. This shape is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black square is below medium blue square number two. Above block A there is block B which has three medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium yellow square number three. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number three and medium yellow square number two. To the right of block B there is block C. It has two medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Which object is above a medium blue square? medium yellow square number two or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium yellow square number two
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block A contains two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and a medium black square. This shape is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black square is below medium blue square number two. Above block A there is block B which has three medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium yellow square number three. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number three and medium yellow square number two. To the right of block B there is block C. It has two medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Which object is above a medium blue square? medium yellow square number two or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium yellow square number two
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains two medium blue squares (number one and number two) and a medium black square at the bottom. Block B is above Block A and contains three medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is at the bottom of Block B, with number two and number three above it. Since Block B is directly above Block A, the objects above the medium blue squares in Block A are the medium yellow squares in Block B. Specifically, medium yellow square number one (the one touching the bottom edge of Block B) is directly above the medium blue squares. Medium yellow square number two is also above the medium blue squares, as it's in Block B above Block A. Therefore, both medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two are above a medium blue square. So the answer is {C}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the blocks but makes unsupported assumptions about the vertical alignment of individual squares between the blocks (claiming 'directly above'). It also slightly misrepresents the description of the contents of Block A.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block A contains two medium blue squares (number one and number two) and a medium black square at the bottom.
Explanation
The context states that medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two AND a medium black square. It does not explicitly number the blue squares in A as 1 and 2, nor does it state that the black square is *at the bottom* of the group described, only that the shape containing MB1, MB2, and the black square touches the bottom edge of the block.
Answer Span:
Block A contains two medium blue squares (number one and number two) and a medium black square at the bottom.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and a medium black square. This shape is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black square is below medium blue square number two.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Specifically, medium yellow square number one (the one touching the bottom edge of Block B) is directly above the medium blue squares.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes that because Block B is above Block A, the objects in B are 'directly above' the objects in A. The question only establishes the relative vertical position of the blocks (B is above A). It does not specify the vertical alignment of individual squares between the blocks, making the claim of 'directly above' an unsupported assumption.
Answer Span:
Specifically, medium yellow square number one (the one touching the bottom edge of Block B) is directly above the medium blue squares.
Reference/Question Span:
Above block A there is block B which has three medium yellow squares.
Question #2514
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of C and block C is below A. Block A has one big yellow triangle and one small yellow square. The big yellow triangle is far fro...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of C and block C is below A. Block A has one big yellow triangle and one small yellow square. The big yellow triangle is far from and to the right of a big blue triangle which is to the right of and above the small yellow square. Block B has two big blue squares. This block also contains one big blue circle. This block also has a small yellow triangle. It also has one small black circle. Big blue square number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big blue circle is to the right of big blue square number two and big blue square number one. And block C has two big black squares. Big black square number one is touching the right edge of this block. This object is to the right of a big yellow triangle and big black square number two. Which object is to the right of a small yellow triangle? the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the small black circle?
(a) the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the small black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
3
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block B is to the left of C and block C is below A. Block A has one big yellow triangle and one small yellow square. The big yellow triangle is far from and to the right of a big blue triangle which is to the right of and above the small yellow square. Block B has two big blue squares. This block also contains one big blue circle. This block also has a small yellow triangle. It also has one small black circle. Big blue square number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. The big blue circle is to the right of big blue square number two and big blue square number one. And block C has two big black squares. Big black square number one is touching the right edge of this block. This object is to the right of a big yellow triangle and big black square number two. Which object is to the right of a small yellow triangle? the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the small black circle?
(a) the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the small black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B contains two big blue squares, a big blue circle, a small yellow triangle, and a small black circle. Big blue square number two is touching the bottom edge of Block B, and the big blue circle is to the right of both big blue squares. Therefore, both the small black circle and the big blue square touching the bottom edge (big blue square number two) are in Block B. Since the question asks what is to the right of the small yellow triangle (also in Block B), we know that the big blue circle is to the right of both big blue square number two and big blue square number one. We also know that the small black circle is in Block B. The spatial relationships of these shapes within Block B aren't fully defined, but it's stated that the big blue circle is to the right of big blue square number two. Since the prompt specifically asks about the shape touching the bottom edge and the small black circle, and both are in the same block as the small yellow triangle, it's possible that either or both could be to its right depending on their exact arrangement. Because the big blue circle is explicitly stated to be to the right of big blue square number two, and the question doesn't clarify the position of the small black circle relative to the small yellow triangle, we can't definitively say it's to the right. However, it is entirely possible based on the available information. Therefore, the answer is (C).
\boxed{C}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning attempts to deduce the answer based on the location of the objects within Block B, but it struggles to find a definitive relationship between the small yellow triangle and the two candidate objects (the shape touching the bottom edge and the small black circle). The conclusion (C) is reached despite the reasoning noting that the relative positions are not fully defined, which is an accurate reflection of the ambiguity in the source text regarding the small yellow triangle's position relative to the other two items in Block B.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #775
We have three blocks, A, B and C. There are a big yellow square, a big blue circle and one medium black circle in block A. The big yellow square is near to a small yellow square. Near to the medium bl...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. There are a big yellow square, a big blue circle and one medium black circle in block A. The big yellow square is near to a small yellow square. Near to the medium black circle there is the big blue circle. The small yellow square is above the medium black circle. The medium black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the medium black circle is the big yellow square.. The big blue circle is to the left of the small yellow square. Above block A we have block B which contains one medium yellow triangle. Below block A there is block C with a small blue square and one big blue triangle in it. One big blue circle is also in this block. To the right of and below the big blue triangle there is the small blue square. It is near to the big blue circle. Which object is below a medium yellow triangle? the small yellow square or the black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small yellow square
(b) the black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains a big yellow square, a big blue circle and one medium black circle. The big yellow square is near to a small yellow square. Near to the medium black circle there is the big blue circle. The small yellow square is above the medium black circle. The medium black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the medium black circle is the big yellow square.. The big blue circle is to the left of the small yellow square. Above block A we have block B which contains one medium yellow triangle. Below block A there is block C with a small blue square and one big blue triangle in it. One big blue circle is also in this block. To the right of and below the big blue triangle there is the small blue square. It is near to the big blue circle. Which object is below a medium yellow triangle? the small yellow square or the black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small yellow square
(b) the black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is above Block A and contains a medium yellow triangle. Block A contains the small yellow square and the medium black circle that is touching the bottom edge. Since Block B is directly above Block A, the objects directly below the medium yellow triangle are the objects in Block A. Both the small yellow square and the black circle touching the bottom edge are in Block A, which is below the medium yellow triangle in Block B. Therefore, both are below the medium yellow triangle.
The question asks what is below the medium yellow triangle, we know that the medium yellow triangle is in block B and block A is below block B, so the objects in block A are below the medium yellow triangle. The question asks about the small yellow square and the black circle, and we know that they are both in block A. Therefore, both are below the medium yellow triangle.
Final Answer: \boxed{C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies that the medium yellow triangle is in Block B, and Block A is below Block B. It then correctly identifies that both the small yellow square and the medium black circle are in Block A, thus both are below the medium yellow triangle.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2844
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square. To the left of block A is block B which contains a medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also contains a medium...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square. To the left of block A is block B which contains a medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also contains a medium yellow square. It is below the medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square. To the right of block A there is block C. It has two medium yellow squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. It is below the medium blue square. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square and the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square. Which object is above a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block C or the medium blue square which is in block B?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block C
(b) the medium blue square which is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block A has a medium blue square. To the left of block A is block B which contains a medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also contains a medium yellow square. It is below the medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square. To the right of block A there is block C. It has two medium yellow squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. It is below the medium blue square. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square and the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square. Which object is above a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block C or the medium blue square which is in block B? (a) the medium blue square that is in block C (b) the medium blue square which is in block B (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block B (left of A) contains a medium blue square, a medium yellow square, and a medium black square. The arrangement in Block B is blue on top, then yellow, then black at the bottom. So, the blue square in Block B is above the black square.Block C (right of A) contains a medium blue square, a medium black square, and two medium yellow squares. The arrangement in Block C has blue on top, then black, then yellow. So, the blue square in Block C is also above the black square.
Therefore, since the blue square in Block B is above a black square and the blue square in Block C is above a black square, the answer is {C}.
\boxed{c}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the necessary relationships for Block B (Blue is above Black). However, it invents a specific vertical ordering for Block C that is not fully supported by the context, although the conclusion that the blue square in C is above the black square in C is supported by the fact that the black square is below the blue square in C.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionlow
Statement
The arrangement in Block B is blue on top, then yellow, then black at the bottom.
Explanation
The context specifies the relative vertical positions within Block B: 'It [medium yellow square] is below the medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square.' This implies the order is Blue (top), Yellow (middle), Black (bottom). The reasoning chain states this order correctly, but the initial statement about the contents of B is slightly misleading as it doesn't explicitly state the vertical order, which is crucial for the conclusion.
Answer Span:
The arrangement in Block B is blue on top, then yellow, then black at the bottom.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B which contains a medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also contains a medium yellow square. It is below the medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square.
contradictionhigh
Statement
The arrangement in Block C has blue on top, then black, then yellow.
Explanation
The context for Block C only specifies the relationship between the black square and the blue square: 'It [medium black square] is below the medium blue square.' It does not specify the relative position of the yellow squares to the blue or black squares, only that 'Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square.' and 'Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square and the medium black square.' The reasoning chain invents a specific vertical order (blue on top, then black, then yellow) which is not fully supported or derivable as stated.
Answer Span:
The arrangement in Block C has blue on top, then black, then yellow.
Reference/Question Span:
It has two medium yellow squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. It is below the medium blue square. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square and the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square.
Question #1657
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains one medium yellow square. A medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square. Then, t...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains one medium yellow square. A medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square. Then, there is block B. It has one medium black square. Finally, we have block C. It is to the left of block A and to the right of block B. It contains two medium blue squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. This block also has a medium black square. This shape is below the medium yellow square and medium blue square number two.. Below the medium yellow square there is medium blue square number one. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium blue square number two which is below the medium yellow square. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block C?
(a) the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium black square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. We call them A, B, and C. Block A contains one medium yellow square. A medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square. Then, there is block B. It has one medium black square. Finally, we have block C. It is to the left of block A and to the right of block B. It contains two medium blue squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. This block also has a medium black square. This shape is below the medium yellow square and medium blue square number two.. Below the medium yellow square there is medium blue square number one. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium blue square number two which is below the medium yellow square. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block C?
(a) the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium black square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has a medium yellow square and a medium black square below it, touching the bottom edge. Block B has a medium black square. Block C is to the left of Block A and contains a medium yellow square, two medium blue squares, and a medium black square. We're looking for what is to the right of a medium yellow square. Since Block C is to the left of Block A, the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block A is to the right of the medium yellow square in Block C. Therefore, the medium black square touching the bottom edge of a block is to the right of a medium yellow square (in Block C). Also, Block C is to the left of Block A, so the black square at the bottom of Block A is to the right of the black square in Block C, but the black square in Block C is not to the right ofthe yellow square in Block A. The question asks what is to the right of a medium yellow square, so considering the yellow square in Block A, the answer is the medium black square touching the bottom edge. Therefore the answer is $\boxed{A}$.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects and their locations relative to the blocks. However, it makes assumptions about the horizontal positioning of objects *between* blocks (e.g., comparing the black square below A to the yellow square in C) that are not explicitly supported by the context, leading to speculative steps in the chain.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block C is to the left of Block A, the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block A is to the right of the medium yellow square in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning correctly establishes the relative positions of C and A, but it fails to specify *which* medium yellow square it is referring to when checking the 'to the right of' condition. The question asks which object is to the right of *a* medium yellow square. The reasoning jumps to comparing the black square below A with the yellow square in C without establishing the spatial relationship between them, which is not explicitly defined in the context.
Answer Span:
the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block A is to the right of the medium yellow square in Block C
Reference/Question Span:
It is to the left of block A and to the right of block B. It contains two medium blue squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Also, Block C is to the left of Block A, so the black square at the bottom of Block A is to the right of the black square in Block C, but the black square in Block C is not to the right of the yellow square in Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning introduces a comparison between the black square in Block C and the yellow square in Block A, but the context does not provide enough information to definitively state the relative horizontal positions of the contents *within* Block A versus the contents *within* Block C, only the relative positions of the blocks themselves. This comparison is speculative based on the provided text.
Answer Span:
the black square in Block C is not to the right of the yellow square in Block A
Reference/Question Span:
It is to the left of block A and to the right of block B. It contains two medium blue squares. This block also contains one medium yellow square. This block also has a medium black square.
Question #2578
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A contains a small black square, one big blue circle and one medium black square. The small black square is above and near to the medium black square ...
1 issue
Full Question
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A contains a small black square, one big blue circle and one medium black square. The small black square is above and near to the medium black square which is above, to the left of and near to a medium yellow square. The big blue circle is to the left of the medium yellow square. To the left of block A is block B. It has two small black circles. A big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a small yellow square. It also has one small black triangle and a medium blue circle. To the left of the medium blue circle is the small black triangle. Below the small yellow square there is the big yellow triangle. To the left of and below the small yellow square there is the small black triangle.. The medium blue circle is above small black circle number two. What is to the right of the small yellow square? a big blue circle or a thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) big blue circle
(b) thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A contains a small black square, one big blue circle and one medium black square. The small black square is above and near to the medium black square which is above, to the left of and near to a medium yellow square. The big blue circle is to the left of the medium yellow square. To the left of block A is block B. It has two small black circles. A big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a small yellow square. It also has one small black triangle and a medium blue circle. To the left of the medium blue circle is the small black triangle. Below the small yellow square there is the big yellow triangle. To the left of and below the small yellow square there is the small black triangle. The medium blue circle is above small black circle number two. What is to the right of the small yellow square? a big blue circle or a thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) big blue circle
(b) thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a big blue circle, a medium black square, and a small black square. Block B is to the left of Block A and contains a small yellow square, a big yellow triangle touching the bottom edge, a small black triangle, and a medium blue circle. The big yellow triangle is below the small yellow square. The question asks what is to the right of the small yellow square. Since Block A is to the right of Block B, the objects in Block A, which are to the right of the small yellow square in Block B, include the big blue circle. The thing touching the bottom edge of Block B is the big yellow triangle, which is not to the right of the small yellow square, but below it. Therefore, only the big blue circle is to the right of the small yellow square.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in each block and the relative positions of the blocks. However, it incorrectly states the spatial relationship between the big yellow triangle and the small yellow square, contradicting the source text. Despite this error, the final conclusion about what is to the right of the small yellow square seems to follow the correct logic based on the block positions, but the internal reasoning step is flawed.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The big yellow triangle is below the small yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning states the big yellow triangle is below the small yellow square, but the context states: 'Below the small yellow square there is the big yellow triangle.' This is a direct contradiction of the spatial relationship described in the context.
Answer Span:
The big yellow triangle is below the small yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Below the small yellow square there is the big yellow triangle.
Question #3576
We have three blocks, A, B and C. There are three medium yellow squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below m...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. There are three medium yellow squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below medium yellow square number three. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number three. Above block A is block B with a medium black square in it. To the left of block A there is block C with a medium black square, one medium blue square and a medium yellow square in it. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square is the medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square. Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is in block C?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains three medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below medium yellow square number three. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number three. Above block A is block B with a medium black square in it. To the left of block A there is block C with a medium black square, one medium blue square and a medium yellow square in it. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square is the medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square. Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is in block C? (a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block (b) the medium yellow square that is in block C (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block C is to the left of Block A. Block C contains a medium black square and a medium yellow square. Block A contains medium yellow squares, with number one touching the bottom edge. Since Block A is to the right of Block C, the medium yellow square (number one) at the bottom edge of Block A is to the right of the medium black square in Block C. Also, the medium yellow square in Block C cannot be to the right of the medium black square since they are both within Block C. Therefore, only the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of Block A is to the right of the medium black square.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes a definitive claim about the relative horizontal positions of objects within Block C that is not supported by the context, leading to a contradiction. It also fails to fully analyze the spatial relationships required to answer the question, particularly regarding the black square in Block B or the precise horizontal alignment of objects.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block A is to the right of Block C, the medium yellow square (number one) at the bottom edge of Block A is to the right of the medium black square in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning correctly identifies that Block A is to the right of Block C (implied by 'To the left of block A there is block C'), but it fails to consider the relative vertical positions of the objects. The question asks which object is *to the right* of a medium black square. The medium black square in Block C is at the bottom edge. The medium yellow square #1 in Block A is touching the bottom edge of Block A. While Block A is generally to the right of Block C, the reasoning doesn't establish the horizontal relationship between the specific objects mentioned in the question's options relative to the specific black square mentioned in the question ('Which object is to the right of *a* medium black square?'). Crucially, the reasoning ignores the existence of the medium black square in Block B, which is *above* Block A, and the medium black square in Block C.
Answer Span:
Since Block A is to the right of Block C, the medium yellow square (number one) at the bottom edge of Block A is to the right of the medium black square in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium black square?
contradictionhigh
Statement
Also, the medium yellow square in Block C cannot be to the right of the medium black square since they are both within Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning claims the medium yellow square in Block C cannot be to the right of the medium black square because they are both in Block C. However, the context only specifies their vertical relationship within Block C: 'The medium black square is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square.' It does not state they share the same horizontal position, nor does it forbid the yellow square from being to the right of the black square within the block.
Answer Span:
Also, the medium yellow square in Block C cannot be to the right of the medium black square since they are both within Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
To the left of block A there is block C with a medium black square, one medium blue square and a medium yellow square in it. . . The medium black square is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square.
Question #2099
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block C and below block A. Block A contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below a medium blue square and med...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block C and below block A. Block A contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below a medium blue square and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square. Block B has two medium blue squares. This block also contains a medium black square. Below the medium black square there is medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the square which is below the medium black square. This shape is below the medium black square. And block C has one medium black square. It also has one medium yellow square. Below the medium black square is the medium yellow square. Which object is above a medium blue square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue square that is in block A?
(a) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block C and below block A. Block A contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below a medium blue square and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square. Block B has two medium blue squares. This block also contains a medium black square. Below the medium black square there is medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the square which is below the medium black square. This shape is below the medium black square. And block C has one medium black square. It also has one medium yellow square. Below the medium black square is the medium yellow square. Which object is above a medium blue square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue square that is in block A? (a) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block (b) the medium blue square that is in block A (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has two medium yellow squares and one medium blue square, with yellow square one and yellow square two both below the blue square. Block B has two medium blue squares and a medium black square. Blue square two is below the black square, and blue square one is touching the bottom edge.
The question asks what is above a medium blue square.
In Block B, the medium black square is above medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is at the bottom, so nothing is above it.
In Block A, the medium blue square is above both medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two.
The question specifically asks about the medium blue square touching the bottom edge of a block (medium blue square number one in Block B) and the medium blue square in Block A. Since nothing is above the blue square in Block B that is touching the bottom edge, and something is above the blue square in Block A. Thus, only the medium blue square that is in block A has an object above it.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{B}$
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the components of Block B and correctly deduces that nothing is above the blue square touching the bottom edge. However, it makes two factual assertions about the contents and relationships within Block A that are not explicitly supported or contradict the precise wording of the source context regarding the blue square's position relative to YS1.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block A has two medium yellow squares and one medium blue square, with yellow square one and yellow square two both below the blue square.
Explanation
The context states Block A contains two medium yellow squares. It does not state how many medium blue squares are in Block A, only that medium yellow square number one is below a medium blue square and medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square. The reasoning incorrectly asserts Block A has 'one medium blue square' and that both yellow squares are below *the* blue square, which is an assumption not fully supported by the text regarding the count.
Answer Span:
Block A has two medium yellow squares and one medium blue square, with yellow square one and yellow square two both below the blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains two medium yellow squares.
contradictionmedium
Statement
In Block A, the medium blue square is above both medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two.
Explanation
The context states: 'Medium yellow square number one is below a medium blue square and medium yellow square number two.' This implies the blue square is above YS2, but it does not explicitly state the blue square is above YS1. The reasoning asserts the blue square is above *both*, which is an inference that contradicts the precise wording regarding YS1.
Answer Span:
In Block A, the medium blue square is above both medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium yellow square number one is below a medium blue square and medium yellow square number two.
Question #2974
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square and one medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium ...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square and one medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square. Block B is to the left of block A. It has a medium black square. Below block B there is block C with two medium black squares and two other medium yellow squares in it. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two is medium black square number two. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. It is below medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two and medium yellow square number one is medium black square number one. Which object is below a medium black square? the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block A?
(a) the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium black square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block A has a medium blue square and one medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square. Block B is to the left of block A. It has a medium black square. Below block B there is block C with two medium black squares and two other medium yellow squares in it. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two is medium black square number two. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. It is below medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two and medium yellow square number one is medium black square number one. Which object is below a medium black square? the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block A?
(a) the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium black square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has a medium black square above a medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of Block A (It is below the medium black square). Block B is to the left of Block A and contains a medium black square. Block C is below Block B and contains two medium black squares and two medium yellow squares. Medium black square number one in Block C touches the bottom edge.
The question asks what is below a medium black square. We are given two options: the medium black square touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square in Block A.
The medium black square in Block A is above the medium blue square, which touches the bottom edge of Block A.Therefore, the medium black square in Block A is not below another medium black square.Block B's medium black square is above Block C, which contains medium black square number one touching the bottom edge.Thus, medium black square number one, which touches the bottom edge of Block C, is below the medium black square in Block B.
The question asks which object is below *a* medium black square (implying any medium black square). Since medium black square number one in Block C is below the medium black square in Block B, medium black square number one (touching the bottom edge) is a valid answer.
Final Answer: The final answer is \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain misinterprets the final question structure, leading to an incorrect analysis of option (b). It incorrectly assumes the question asks if the object *itself* is below another black square, rather than checking if the object described in option (b) is below *any* black square based on the context.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The medium black square in Block A is above the medium blue square, which touches the bottom edge of Block A. Therefore, the medium black square in Block A is not below another medium black square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes the question is asking which object is below *another* medium black square, but the question asks which object is below *a* medium black square, and then presents two specific candidates for that object: 'the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block' or 'the medium black square that is in block A'. The reasoning chain incorrectly analyzes the relationship of the medium black square in Block A relative to other squares instead of checking if the object described in option (b) meets the condition of being below *a* medium black square.
Answer Span:
The medium black square in Block A is above the medium blue square, which touches the bottom edge of Block A. Therefore, the medium black square in Block A is not below another medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is below a medium black square? the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block A?
Question #969
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is above block C and it is to the left of block A. Block A contains two small yellow circles. There is also one big black circle in this block. Small yellow c...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is above block C and it is to the left of block A. Block A contains two small yellow circles. There is also one big black circle in this block. Small yellow circle number one is above the big black circle and small yellow circle number two. Block B has two big yellow circles. It also contains one medium yellow triangle. Below big yellow circle number two is big yellow circle number one. It is to the left of and near to the medium yellow triangle. Block C contains a small black square, a big yellow triangle and a small yellow circle. A medium blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a big black square. Above the big black square and the small yellow circle there is the small black square. To the right of and touching the big black square is the medium blue triangle. This object is below the big yellow triangle. Which object is below a big yellow circle? the small black square or the big black circle?
(a) the small black square
(b) the big black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B, and C. Block B is above block C and it is to the left of block A. Block A contains two small yellow circles. There is also one big black circle in this block. Small yellow circle number one is above the big black circle and small yellow circle number two. Block B has two big yellow circles. It also contains one medium yellow triangle. Below big yellow circle number two is big yellow circle number one. It is to the left of and near to the medium yellow triangle. Block C contains a small black square, a big yellow triangle and a small yellow circle. A medium blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a big black square. Above the big black square and the small yellow circle there is the small black square. To the right of and touching the big black square is the medium blue triangle. This object is below the big yellow triangle. Which object is below a big yellow circle? the small black square or the big black circle?
(a) the small black square
(b) the big black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is above Block C and to the left of Block A. Block B contains two big yellow circles, with big yellow circle number two above big yellow circle number one. Block A contains a big black circle and two small yellow circles, with small yellow circle number one above both the big black circle and small yellow circle number two. Block C is below Block B and contains a small black square, a big yellow triangle, a small yellow circle, a medium blue triangle touching the bottom edge, and a big black square.
Since Block C is directly below Block B (which contains the big yellow circles), the objects directly below the big yellow circles are the ones in Block C. Block C contains the small black square and the big black square. The question asks which of the options is below the big yellow circles. Thus, the small black square is below a big yellow circle, and the big black circle is in Block A, which is not below Block B. Therefore, the answer is the small black square.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the objects in each block but contains a direct contradiction regarding the vertical relationship between the two big yellow circles in Block B. It also makes a slightly inaccurate restatement of the vertical relationship within Block A's contents. However, the final conclusion about the location of the objects relative to the question seems to follow from the correct block assignments.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block B contains two big yellow circles, with big yellow circle number two above big yellow circle number one.
Explanation
The context states: 'Below big yellow circle number two is big yellow circle number one.' This means big yellow circle number one is below big yellow circle number two, not the other way around.
Answer Span:
big yellow circle number two above big yellow circle number one
Reference/Question Span:
Below big yellow circle number two is big yellow circle number one
contradictionlow
Statement
Block A contains a big black circle and two small yellow circles, with small yellow circle number one above both the big black circle and small yellow circle number two.
Explanation
The context states: 'Small yellow circle number one is above the big black circle and small yellow circle number two.' The reasoning incorrectly states that small yellow circle number one is above the big black circle AND small yellow circle number two, implying a vertical stack where SYC1 is above both, which is true, but the reasoning chain implies a specific relationship that is slightly misstated compared to the source, although the core facts are present. More critically, the reasoning chain implies that the big black circle is *in* Block A, which is true, but the relationship described for SYC1 is slightly ambiguous in the reasoning compared to the source.
Answer Span:
Block A contains a big black circle and two small yellow circles, with small yellow circle number one above both the big black circle and small yellow circle number two.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains two small yellow circles. There is also one big black circle in this block. Small yellow circle number one is above the big black circle and small yellow circle number two.
Question #1254
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains a big black circle and one small blue circle. The big black circle is below a medium black triangle. Below the medium black triangle t...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains a big black circle and one small blue circle. The big black circle is below a medium black triangle. Below the medium black triangle there is the small blue circle. The big black circle is above and near to the small blue circle. Then, there is block B with one medium yellow circle, a big black square and one small blue square in it. A medium black circle is to the right of the medium yellow circle and the small blue square. Above the big black square and the small blue square is the medium yellow circle. The medium black circle is above the big black square. To the right of block A and to the left of block B there is block C. It has one medium blue circle and a small blue circle. The medium blue circle is near to and to the left of a medium black square which is to the right of and below the small blue circle. Which object is to the right of a big black circle? the medium blue circle or the small blue square?
(a) the medium blue circle
(b) the small blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block A contains a big black circle and one small blue circle. The big black circle is below a medium black triangle. Below the medium black triangle there is the small blue circle. The big black circle is above and near to the small blue circle. Then, there is block B with one medium yellow circle, a big black square and one small blue square in it. A medium black circle is to the right of the medium yellow circle and the small blue square. Above the big black square and the small blue square is the medium yellow circle. The medium black circle is above the big black square. To the right of block A and to the left of block B there is block C. It has one medium blue circle and a small blue circle. The medium blue circle is near to and to the left of a medium black square which is to the right of and below the small blue circle. Which object is to the right of a big black circle? the medium blue circle or the small blue square? (a) the medium blue circle (b) the small blue square (c) both of them (d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block A contains a big black circle and a small blue circle. Block B contains a small blue square, a medium yellow circle and a big black square. Block C is located between Block A and Block B, and contains a medium blue circle. Since we want to determine what is to the right of the big black circle in Block A, and Block C is directly to the right of Block A, the object to the right of the big black circle is the medium blue circle in Block C. The small blue square is in Block B, which is to the right of Block C, hence not directly to the right of the big black circle. Therefore, only the medium blue circle is directly to the right of the big black circle.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsupported leap by assuming that because Block C is to the right of Block A, an object in Block C must be to the right of an object in Block A, without verifying the specific positional relationship between the big black circle and the medium blue circle. It ignores the fact that the positional information given relates to objects *within* blocks or relative positions of the blocks themselves, not the specific relative position between an object in A and an object in C.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block C is located between Block A and Block B
Explanation
The context states Block C is to the right of Block A and to the left of Block B, which implies it is between them, but the reasoning chain uses this as a definitive statement without checking if the relative positions of objects *within* the blocks support this conclusion for the specific object requested.
Answer Span:
Block C is located between Block A and Block B
Reference/Question Span:
To the right of block A and to the left of block B there is block C.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since we want to determine what is to the right of the big black circle in Block A, and Block C is directly to the right of Block A, the object to the right of the big black circle is the medium blue circle in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes that because Block C is to the right of Block A, the object in Block C (medium blue circle) is automatically to the right of the big black circle (which is *inside* Block A). The context does not establish the relative positions of objects *between* blocks, only the relative positions of the blocks themselves. The reasoning ignores the need to check if the medium blue circle is actually positioned to the right of the big black circle based on the positional descriptions provided.
Answer Span:
the object to the right of the big black circle is the medium blue circle in Block C
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a big black circle? the medium blue circle or the small blue square?
Question #1453
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There is one medium yellow square in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium blue squares. It also contains a medium yellow square. M...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There is one medium yellow square in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium blue squares. It also contains a medium yellow square. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and the medium yellow square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square is medium blue square number two. Above block A there is block C which contains two medium yellow squares. This block also contains one medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium black square and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium black square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium black square or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium black square
(b) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There is one medium yellow square in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium blue squares. It also contains a medium yellow square. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and the medium yellow square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square is medium blue square number two. Above block A there is block C which contains two medium yellow squares. This block also contains one medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium black square and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium black square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium black square or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium black square
(b) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is below Block A, and Block B contains two medium blue squares and a medium yellow square. In Block B, medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge, and it's located below medium blue square number two and the medium yellow square. Block C is above Block A and contains a medium black square and two medium yellow squares. We're looking for what is below a medium yellow square. Since the medium yellow square is in Block B (which is under Block A), and medium blue square number one is below the medium yellow square in Block B, the medium blue square touching the bottom edge of a block is indeed below a medium yellow square. The answer is {B}. The medium black square is below a different medium yellow square (in Block C), not the one referred to in the question which is in Block B.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{B}$
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies that the medium blue square touching the bottom edge (in Block B) is below a medium yellow square (the one in Block B). However, it introduces a factual error by misplacing the medium black square relative to a yellow square in Block B, which is not supported by the text, and incorrectly dismisses the possibility of the black square being below *a* yellow square (the ones in Block C).
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The medium black square is below a different medium yellow square (in Block B), not the one referred to in the question which is in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly claims the medium black square is below a medium yellow square in Block B. Block B contains blue and yellow squares, but the black square is explicitly stated to be in Block C, above Block A. Furthermore, the question asks which object is below *a* medium yellow square, implying we check all possibilities.
Answer Span:
The medium black square is below a different medium yellow square (in Block B), not the one referred to in the question which is in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Above block A there is block C which contains two medium yellow squares. This block also contains one medium black square.
Question #1454
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There is one medium yellow square in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium blue squares. It also contains a medium yellow square. M...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There is one medium yellow square in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium blue squares. It also contains a medium yellow square. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and the medium yellow square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square is medium blue square number two. Above block A there is block C which contains two medium yellow squares. This block also contains one medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium black square and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium black square. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square?
(a) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium black square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There is one medium yellow square in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium blue squares. It also contains a medium yellow square. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and the medium yellow square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square is medium blue square number two. Above block A there is block C which contains two medium yellow squares. This block also contains one medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium black square and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium black square. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square? (a) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block (b) the medium black square (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B, which is below Block A, has a medium yellow square and two medium blue squares. Block C, which is above Block A, has two medium yellow squares and a medium black square.
In Block B, the medium yellow square is above medium blue square number two, and medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge. In Block C, the medium black square is above medium yellow square number two, which is above medium yellow square number one (touching the bottom edge).
The question asks what is above a medium yellow square. In Block A, the medium yellow square has Block C above it, which contains the medium black square. Therefore, the medium black square is above a medium yellow square. In Block B, the medium yellow square is above medium blue square number two, and medium blue square number one is at the bottom. Therefore, the medium blue square touching the bottom edge is not above the medium yellow square, but below it. So, only the medium black square is above a medium yellow square.
Final Answer: \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning chain accurately interprets the spatial relationships described in the context to answer the question about what objects are above a medium yellow square.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #806
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and above block C. Block A contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below medium black sq...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and above block C. Block A contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. There is also a medium blue square in this block. It is below medium black square number two. Below the blue shape which is below medium black square number two is medium black square number one. Block B has a medium black square and a medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium blue square. It also contains one medium yellow square.. Below the medium blue square and the medium black square is the medium yellow square. And block C contains one medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium blue square? the thing which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block B?
(a) the thing which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium black square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and above block C. Block A contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. There is also a medium blue square in this block. It is below medium black square number two. Below the blue shape which is below medium black square number two is medium black square number one. Block B has a medium black square and a medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium blue square. It also contains one medium yellow square.. Below the medium blue square and the medium black square is the medium yellow square. And block C contains one medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium blue square? the thing which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block B?
(a) the thing which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium black square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a medium blue square, which is below medium black square number two and above medium black square number one (touching the bottom edge). Block B (which is to the left of Block A) contains a medium black square and a medium blue square. Since Block B is to the left of Block A, the objects in Block B are to the left of the objects in Block A. Therefore, the medium black square in Block B is to the left of the medium blue square in Block A. The object touching the bottom edge of Block A, which is medium black square number one, cannot be to the left of the medium blue square in Block A because it's in the same block and below it. So, only the medium black square in Block B is to the left of the medium blue square in Block A.
\boxed{B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the objects based on the block locations and then evaluates the two options provided in the question against the target object (a medium blue square). The reasoning implicitly focuses on the medium blue square in Block A as the reference point, which is necessary to evaluate the options provided in the multiple-choice question.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #999
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and it is below block C. Block A has one small blue circle. Above and to the left of a medium black square there is t...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and it is below block C. Block A has one small blue circle. Above and to the left of a medium black square there is the small blue circle. The medium black square is touching the right edge of this block. Block B has a small yellow triangle, one big blue circle and a big black circle. The small yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. The small yellow triangle is above the big blue circle. It is below and to the right of the big black circle. And block C contains two medium yellow circles. Medium yellow circle number one is above, to the left of and near to medium yellow circle number two. This block also has a small yellow circle. What is to the left of the small blue circle? a medium yellow circle or a small yellow triangle which is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) medium yellow circle
(b) small yellow triangle which is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. Let's call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and it is below block C. Block A has one small blue circle. Above and to the left of a medium black square there is the small blue circle. The medium black square is touching the right edge of this block. Block B has a small yellow triangle, one big blue circle and a big black circle. The small yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. The small yellow triangle is above the big blue circle. It is below and to the right of the big black circle. And block C contains two medium yellow circles. Medium yellow circle number one is above, to the left of and near to medium yellow circle number two. This block also has a small yellow circle. What is to the left of the small blue circle? a medium yellow circle or a small yellow triangle which is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) medium yellow circle
(b) small yellow triangle which is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is to the left of Block A. Block A contains a small blue circle. Block B contains a small yellow triangle, a big blue circle, and a big black circle. The small yellow triangle is touching the right edge of Block B. Block C, which is above Block B, contains two medium yellow circles. Medium yellow circle number two is below and to the right of medium yellow circle number one. Since Block B is to the left of Block A, and the small yellow triangle is touching the right edge of Block B, the small yellow triangle is to the left of the small blue circle (which is in Block A). Although Block C contains medium yellow circles, Block C is above Block B, not to its left, therefore, a medium yellow circle isn't to the left of the small blue circle. The small yellow triangle is the only object to the left of the small blue circle.
Final Answer: \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the location of the small yellow triangle relative to the small blue circle (by linking B to A) but fails to properly evaluate the possibility of the medium yellow circle being to the left. It incorrectly dismisses the medium yellow circle based only on the relative positions of Block C and Block B, ignoring the complex spatial relationships described in the context that determine the final answer (a).
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C, which is above Block B, contains two medium yellow circles.
Explanation
The reasoning chain correctly states Block C is above Block B, but it fails to incorporate the crucial positional information about the small blue circle relative to the objects in Block C or Block A that would determine if a medium yellow circle is to its left.
Answer Span:
Block C, which is above Block B, contains two medium yellow circles.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the left of block A and it is below block C.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Although Block C contains medium yellow circles, Block C is above Block B, not to its left, therefore, a medium yellow circle isn't to the left of the small blue circle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly dismisses the possibility of a medium yellow circle being to the left of the small blue circle based only on the relationship between Block C and Block B. The question asks what is to the left of the *small blue circle*, which is located in Block A. The reasoning ignores the positional information given for the medium yellow circles within Block C relative to each other, and crucially, ignores the positional information linking the small blue circle to the medium black square, and the medium black square to the block containing the small blue circle (Block A). The reasoning concludes a medium yellow circle cannot be to the left without checking the actual spatial relationship required by the question.
Answer Span:
Although Block C contains medium yellow circles, Block C is above Block B, not to its left, therefore, a medium yellow circle isn't to the left of the small blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the left of the small blue circle? a medium yellow circle or a small yellow triangle which is touching the right edge of a block?
Question #3501
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block C is above block A and to the right of block B. Block A has a big black circle. One medium yellow circle is also in this block. The medium yellow...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block C is above block A and to the right of block B. Block A has a big black circle. One medium yellow circle is also in this block. The medium yellow circle is above and to the right of the big black circle. Block B contains a big black circle. A medium yellow triangle and one small black square are also in this block. The medium yellow triangle is to the left of, above and near to the small black square. The big black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Block C contains one small yellow triangle, a medium blue triangle and one medium black triangle. Below and to the left of the medium blue triangle which is near to the medium black triangle there is the small yellow triangle. This shape is below the medium black triangle. Which object is near to a medium black triangle? the medium blue triangle or the big black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue triangle
(b) the big black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block C is above block A and to the right of block B. Block A has a big black circle. One medium yellow circle is also in this block. The medium yellow circle is above and to the right of the big black circle. Block B contains a big black circle. A medium yellow triangle and one small black square are also in this block. The medium yellow triangle is to the left of, above, and near to the small black square. The big black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Block C contains one small yellow triangle, a medium blue triangle, and one medium black triangle. Below and to the left of the medium blue triangle which is near to the medium black triangle there is the small yellow triangle. This shape is below the medium black triangle. Which object is near to a medium black triangle? the medium blue triangle or the big black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue triangle
(b) the big black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C contains a medium black triangle, a medium blue triangle, and a small yellow triangle. The small yellow triangle is below and to the left of the medium blue triangle, which is near to the medium black triangle. The small yellow triangle is also below the medium black triangle. Block B contains a big black circle touching the bottom edge. Since Block C is above Block A and to the right of Block B, the big black circle in Block B is not near the medium black triangle in Block C. However, the medium blue triangle is near the medium black triangle, both being in Block C. Therefore, the object near to the medium black triangle is the medium blue triangle.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relevant spatial relationships described in the context to answer the question about which object is near the medium black triangle.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2843
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square. To the left of block A is block B which contains a medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also contains a medium...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square. To the left of block A is block B which contains a medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also contains a medium yellow square. It is below the medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square. To the right of block A there is block C. It has two medium yellow squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. It is below the medium blue square. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square and the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square. Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium yellow square that is in block B or medium yellow square number two?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block B
(b) medium yellow square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block A has a medium blue square. To the left of block A is block B which contains a medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also contains a medium yellow square. It is below the medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square. To the right of block A there is block C. It has two medium yellow squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. There is also a medium black square in this block. It is below the medium blue square. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square and the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square. Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium yellow square that is in block B or medium yellow square number two?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block B
(b) medium yellow square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has a medium blue square. Block B is to the left of Block A and contains a medium yellow square. Block C is to the right of Block A and contains medium yellow square number two. Since the question asks what is to the right of the medium blue square in Block A, and Block C is to the right of Block A, only objects in Block C can be to the right of the medium blue square. Medium yellow square number two is in Block C, so it is to the right of the medium blue square in Block A. The medium yellow square in Block B is to the left of Block A, so it cannot be to the right of the medium blue square. Therefore, the answer is \boxed{B}.
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the blocks and uses this to determine which object is to the right of the medium blue square in Block A. No contradictions or missing context were found.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #3577
We have three blocks, A, B and C. There are three medium yellow squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below m...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. There are three medium yellow squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below medium yellow square number three. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number three. Above block A is block B with a medium black square in it. To the left of block A there is block C with a medium black square, one medium blue square and a medium yellow square in it. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square is the medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square which is in block C or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square which is in block C
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains three medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below medium yellow square number three. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number three. Above block A is block B with a medium black square in it. To the left of block A there is block C with a medium black square, one medium blue square and a medium yellow square in it. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square is the medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square which is in block C or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square which is in block C
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains three medium yellow squares, stacked with square number one at the bottom, square number two in the middle, and square number three on top. Block C (to the left of A) contains a medium blue square and a medium yellow square with the medium blue square below the yellow one.
The question asks what is below a medium yellow square. We need to consider both the squares in Block A and Block C. In Block A, medium yellow square number one touches the bottom edge, meaning nothing is below it. In Block C, the medium blue square is below the medium yellow square. Therefore, only the medium blue square is below a medium yellow square. Since medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom, nothing is below it. Thus, the only correct option is (a) because the medium blue square is below the medium yellow square which is in block C.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{A}$
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies that the medium blue square is below the medium yellow square in Block C. However, it contains a minor misstatement regarding the stacking order in Block A (though the final conclusion derived from that fact is correct) and incorrectly frames the analysis of Block A's bottom square as a reason to dismiss it, rather than evaluating the options provided in the question.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionlow
Statement
Block A contains three medium yellow squares, stacked with square number one at the bottom, square number two in the middle, and square number three on top.
Explanation
The context states square 1 is below square 2, and square 2 is below square 3. This implies the order is 1 (bottom), 2 (middle), 3 (top). However, the reasoning chain incorrectly states square 1 is at the bottom, square 2 in the middle, and square 3 on top, which is consistent with the description, but then it contradicts itself later by saying square 1 is touching the bottom edge, meaning nothing is below it, which is true, but the initial description of the stack order in the reasoning is slightly misleading compared to the explicit description of the relationships.
Answer Span:
Block A contains three medium yellow squares, stacked with square number one at the bottom, square number two in the middle, and square number three on top.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below medium yellow square number three.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
In Block A, medium yellow square number one touches the bottom edge, meaning nothing is below it.
Explanation
The question asks which *object* is below a medium yellow square, and the options refer to specific yellow squares (the one in C or the one touching the bottom edge). Stating that nothing is below square 1 in Block A is true, but it ignores the fact that the question is asking to identify which *yellow square* (from the options) has something below it, not whether *every* yellow square has something below it. The reasoning concludes based on this observation that option (a) is correct because the blue square is below the yellow square in C, but it doesn't fully address the structure of the question which asks to identify the yellow square that *has* something below it.
Answer Span:
In Block A, medium yellow square number one touches the bottom edge, meaning nothing is below it.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square which is in block C or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #3067
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks A and B. Block A contains one small yellow square. Block B contains a big blue triangle, one medium black circle and one medium y...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks A and B. Block A contains one small yellow square. Block B contains a big blue triangle, one medium black circle and one medium yellow square. The medium black circle is to the right of a small black square and the medium yellow square. It is touching the right edge of this block. The small black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below and to the left of the medium yellow square. And block C contains one medium yellow triangle, a medium black circle and a small yellow square. To the left of and above the small yellow square is the medium black circle. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. Below the medium black circle is the medium yellow triangle. Which object is above a medium black circle? the medium yellow triangle or the small black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow triangle
(b) the small black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:**
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks A and B. Block A contains one small yellow square. Block B contains a big blue triangle, one medium black circle and one medium yellow square. The medium black circle is to the right of a small black square and the medium yellow square. It is touching the right edge of this block. The small black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below and to the left of the medium yellow square. And block C contains one medium yellow triangle, a medium black circle and a small yellow square. To the left of and above the small yellow square is the medium black circle. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. Below the medium black circle is the medium yellow triangle. Which object is above a medium black circle? the medium yellow triangle or the small black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow triangle
(b) the small black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block B contains a medium black circle, a small black square touching the bottom edge, and a medium yellow square. Block C contains a medium black circle, a medium yellow triangle, and a small yellow square touching the right edge. Block C is below Blocks A and B.
We're looking for what's above a medium black circle. Since the question specifies blocks A, B, and C, and since C is below A and B, when the question asks what is above a medium black circle, we're referring to the medium black circle in Block C, not the one in Block B. In Block C, the medium yellow triangle is below the medium black circle. So the medium yellow triangle is not above the medium black circle. The small black square touching the bottom edge is in Block B, which is not above Block C, so it's not above the medium black circle in Block C. Since neither object is in a block above Block C, neither is above the medium black circle in Block C.
Therefore, the answer is \boxed{D}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes a critical, unsupported assumption that the question must refer only to the medium black circle in Block C because C is below A and B. This ignores the medium black circle in Block B. Furthermore, the reasoning fails to check the relative positions of the objects *within* Block B or Block C as described, leading to an incorrect conclusion based on the flawed premise.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
We're looking for what's above a medium black circle. Since the question specifies blocks A, B, and C, and since C is below A and B, when the question asks what is above a medium black circle, we're referring to the medium black circle in Block C, not the one in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning arbitrarily decides to only consider the medium black circle in Block C, ignoring the possibility that the question refers to the medium black circle in Block B, or that the question is asking about the relative vertical positions of the objects listed in the options *within their respective blocks* or relative to *any* medium black circle mentioned.
Answer Span:
we're referring to the medium black circle in Block C, not the one in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is above a medium black circle? the medium yellow triangle or the small black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
contradictionlow
Statement
In Block C, the medium yellow triangle is below the medium black circle.
Explanation
The context states: 'Below the medium black circle is the medium yellow triangle.' This means the medium yellow triangle is *below* the medium black circle in Block C, not above it. The reasoning correctly identifies this relationship but uses it to support the conclusion that (a) is false, which is fine, but the statement itself is a correct deduction from the context, however, the subsequent reasoning about the small black square is flawed based on the initial assumption.
Answer Span:
In Block C, the medium yellow triangle is below the medium black circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Below the medium black circle is the medium yellow triangle.
Question #3096
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A contains one medium blue triangle and a small yellow square. There is also a small black circle in this block. Above an...
3 issues
Full Question
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A contains one medium blue triangle and a small yellow square. There is also a small black circle in this block. Above and to the left of the small yellow square is the medium blue triangle. A medium black circle is far from, above and to the left of the small yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is to the left of and below medium yellow square number two. It also has one medium black circle. This object is below medium yellow square number two. It also contains a big blue square. Below and near to the big blue square is the medium black circle. To the left of the black object which is below the big blue square there is medium yellow square number one. Which object is below a big object? the medium black circle which is in block A or the thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium black circle which is in block A
(b) the thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A contains one medium blue triangle and a small yellow square. There is also a small black circle in this block. Above and to the left of the small yellow square is the medium blue triangle. A medium black circle is far from, above and to the left of the small yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is to the left of and below medium yellow square number two. It also has one medium black circle. This object is below medium yellow square number two. It also contains a big blue square. Below and near to the big blue square is the medium black circle. To the left of the black object which is below the big blue square there is medium yellow square number one. Which object is below a big object? the medium black circle which is in block A or the thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium black circle which is in block A
(b) the thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A is to the left of Block B. In Block A, the medium black circle is above and to the left of the small yellow square. In Block B, the big blue square has the medium black circledirectly below it, and medium yellow square number one is to the left of the medium black circle. Nothing is specified as touching the bottom edge of either block. Since the question asks what is below a big object (the big blue square), the answer is the medium black circle in Block B. The medium black circle in Block A is not below anything big, and there is no object described as touching the bottom edge. Thus, the answer is {D}. The medium black circle in Block B is directly below the big blue square, making it below a big object. The other listed objects are not described as below anything big. \boxed{D}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains several factual errors (contradictions) regarding the placement of the medium black circle in Block A and the relationship between the medium black circle and the big blue square in Block B. It also dismisses one of the comparison options based on an assumption about missing information.
Detected Issues (3)
contradictionhigh
Statement
In Block A, the medium black circle is above and to the left of the small yellow square.
Explanation
The context states that the medium blue triangle is above and to the left of the small yellow square, and that there is *also* a small black circle in this block. It does not state the medium black circle's position relative to the small yellow square in Block A.
Answer Span:
In Block A, the medium black circle is above and to the left of the small yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains one medium blue triangle and a small yellow square. There is also a small black circle in this block. Above and to the left of the small yellow square is the medium blue triangle.
contradictionmedium
Statement
In Block B, the big blue square has the medium black circle directly below it
Explanation
The context states the medium black circle in Block B is *below* medium yellow square number two, and that the medium black circle is *below and near to* the big blue square. 'Directly below' is a stronger claim than what is stated.
Answer Span:
In Block B, the big blue square has the medium black circle directly below it
Reference/Question Span:
It also contains a big blue square. Below and near to the big blue square is the medium black circle.
missing_contextlow
Statement
Nothing is specified as touching the bottom edge of either block.
Explanation
The question asks about 'the thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block' as an option, implying this object might exist or be relevant to the comparison, even if its specific identity isn't fully detailed. Ignoring this possibility entirely when evaluating the options is missing context relevant to the final choice.
Answer Span:
Nothing is specified as touching the bottom edge of either block.
Reference/Question Span:
the thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #3420
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of B and block B is above C. Block A has one small yellow triangle, a small blue circle and a big blue circle. To the left of...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of B and block B is above C. Block A has one small yellow triangle, a small blue circle and a big blue circle. To the left of the small blue circle which is to the right of the big blue circle is the small yellow triangle. The big blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Above the big blue circle there is the small yellow triangle. Block B has a big yellow circle. And block C contains one small black square, a big yellow triangle and a big yellow circle. The big yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. This block also has a small black triangle. The small black square is to the left of and above the big yellow triangle which is to the right of the big yellow circle.. One small blue square is also in this block. It is near to and above the big yellow circle. Which object is to the left of a big blue circle? the small yellow triangle or the small blue square?
(a) the small yellow triangle
(b) the small blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
3
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block A is to the right of B and block B is above C. Block A has one small yellow triangle, a small blue circle and a big blue circle. To the left of the small blue circle which is to the right of the big blue circle is the small yellow triangle. The big blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Above the big blue circle there is the small yellow triangle. Block B has a big yellow circle. And block C contains one small black square, a big yellow triangle and a big yellow circle. The big yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. This block also has a small black triangle. The small black square is to the left of and above the big yellow triangle which is to the right of the big yellow circle. One small blue square is also in this block. It is near to and above the big yellow circle. Which object is to the left of a big blue circle? the small yellow triangle or the small blue square?
(a) the small yellow triangle
(b) the small blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a small yellow triangle, a small blue circle, and a big blue circle. The small yellow triangle is to the left of the small blue circle, which is to the right of the big blue circle. This means the order from left to right in Block A is: small yellow triangle, big blue circle, small blue circle.
Block C contains a small blue square. Since Block A is to the right of Block B and Block B is above Block C, Block C is not directly to the left of Block A. The small yellow triangle is to the left of the big blue circle within Block A. Therefore, the small yellow triangle is to the left of the big blue circle. Since the small blue square is in Block C and Block C is not to the left of Block A, the small blue square cannot be to the left of the big blue circle.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{A}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsupported assumption about the left-to-right ordering of objects within Block A and incorrectly dismisses the small blue square based on the irrelevant spatial relationship between blocks A, B, and C, failing to check if the small blue square is described as being spatially to the left of the big blue circle.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
The small yellow triangle is to the left of the small blue circle, which is to the right of the big blue circle. This means the order from left to right in Block A is: small yellow triangle, big blue circle, small blue circle.
Explanation
The context states: 'To the left of the small blue circle which is to the right of the big blue circle is the small yellow triangle.' This implies the order is (Big Blue Circle) -> (Small Blue Circle) and (Small Yellow Triangle) is to the left of (Small Blue Circle). The context does not explicitly state the relative position of the small yellow triangle and the big blue circle, only that the small yellow triangle is to the left of the small blue circle, and the small blue circle is to the right of the big blue circle. The reasoning incorrectly deduces the order is 'small yellow triangle, big blue circle, small blue circle'. The context only guarantees that the small yellow triangle is to the left of the small blue circle, and the big blue circle is to the left of the small blue circle. The relative order of the small yellow triangle and the big blue circle is ambiguous based on the provided text, but the reasoning asserts a specific order that is not directly supported.
Answer Span:
This means the order from left to right in Block A is: small yellow triangle, big blue circle, small blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
To the left of the small blue circle which is to the right of the big blue circle is the small yellow triangle.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block A is to the right of Block B and Block B is above Block C, Block C is not directly to the left of Block A.
Explanation
The question asks which object is to the left of the big blue circle. The big blue circle is in Block A. The reasoning correctly identifies that the small yellow triangle is in Block A. However, it then dismisses the small blue square (which is in Block C) by reasoning about the relative positions of the blocks (A is right of B, B is above C). This spatial relationship between blocks (A, B, C) is irrelevant to the question, which asks about relative positions *within* the context of the objects described, specifically asking which object is to the left of the big blue circle (which is in Block A). The reasoning ignores the possibility that the small blue square might be described as being spatially to the left of the big blue circle, regardless of which block it is in, or it incorrectly assumes that objects in different blocks cannot satisfy the positional query.
Answer Span:
Since Block A is to the right of Block B and Block B is above Block C, Block C is not directly to the left of Block A. The small yellow triangle is to the left of the big blue circle within Block A. Therefore, the small yellow triangle is to the left of the big blue circle. Since the small blue square is in Block C and Block C is not to the left of Block A, the small blue square cannot be to the left of the big blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the left of a big blue circle? the small yellow triangle or the small blue square?
Question #1335
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Blocks B and C are below A. Block A contains a medium blue square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below...
3 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Blocks B and C are below A. Block A contains a medium blue square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below a medium black square. Block B contains two medium blue squares. It also contains a medium black square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium black square there is medium blue square number two. Below medium blue square number two and the medium black square there is medium blue square number one. And block C has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square. Below the medium yellow square is medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is below the medium black square number two. Which object is above a medium black square? the medium black square that is in block A or the medium black square that is in block B?
(a) the medium black square that is in block A
(b) the medium black square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Blocks B and C are below A. Block A contains a medium blue square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below a medium black square. Block B contains two medium blue squares. It also contains a medium black square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium black square there is medium blue square number two. Below medium blue square number two and the medium black square there is medium blue square number one. And block C has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square. Below the medium yellow square is medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is below the medium black square number two. Which object is above a medium black square? the medium black square that is in block A or the medium black square that is in block B?
(a) the medium black square that is in block A
(b) the medium black square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has a medium black square above the medium blue square. Block B also has a medium black square, which is above medium blue square number two and above medium blue square number one (which is touching the bottom). Since the question asks what is above a medium black square, and both Block A's black square and Block B's black square have objects above them, both fulfill the criteria. Block A's black square is above the blue square, which is above nothing. Since B and C are below A, then both A's black square and B's black square have items above them. The answer is {C}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains multiple direct contradictions regarding the spatial relationship between the black square and the blue square in Block A. It also misuses the context about the relative positions of blocks A, B, and C to justify its claims about what is above the black squares.
Detected Issues (3)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block A has a medium black square above the medium blue square.
Explanation
The context states that Block A contains a medium blue square, and this blue square is below a medium black square. The reasoning reverses this relationship.
Answer Span:
Block A has a medium black square above the medium blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains a medium blue square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below a medium black square.
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block A's black square is above the blue square, which is above nothing.
Explanation
This contradicts the established facts for Block A. The blue square is below the black square, and the blue square is touching the bottom edge of Block A, implying nothing is below it *within the block structure described for A* (though the block itself is below A). More critically, the relationship between the black square and blue square is stated incorrectly.
Answer Span:
Block A's black square is above the blue square, which is above nothing.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains a medium blue square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below a medium black square.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since B and C are below A, then both A's black square and B's black square have items above them.
Explanation
The fact that B and C are below A is irrelevant to determining what is *above* the black squares *within* their respective blocks (A and B). The reasoning uses this positional information incorrectly to support the conclusion about what is above the black squares.
Answer Span:
Since B and C are below A, then both A's black square and B's black square have items above them.
Reference/Question Span:
Blocks B and C are below A.
Question #1386
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are three medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square nu...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are three medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number two. A medium yellow square is also in this block. This object is below medium black square number three. It is below the black object which is below medium black square number three. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number one. It is below medium black square number two. Above block A there is block B which has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. To the right of block A there is block C which has one medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium blue square? medium black square number two or the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium black square number two
(b) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:**
We have three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. There are three medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number two. A medium yellow square is also in this block. This object is below medium black square number three. It is below the black object which is below medium black square number three. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number one. It is below medium black square number two. Above block A there is block B which has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. To the right of block A there is block C which has one medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium blue square? medium black square number two or the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium black square number two
(b) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block A contains three medium black squares and one medium yellow square. Medium black square number one touches the bottom edge. Block B is above Block A and has two medium blue squares. Block C is to the right of Block A and has one medium blue square. Since Block A is to the left of Block C, the objects in Block A are to the left of the medium blue square in Block C. Both medium black square number two and medium black square number one (touching the bottom edge) are in Block A. Therefore, both are to the left of the medium blue square in Block C.
Final Answer: \boxed{C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relevant spatial relationships (Block A is to the left of Block C) and uses this to answer the question about which objects in Block A are to the left of the blue square in Block C. No contradictions or missing context were found.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #627
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium blue squares are in block A. There is also one medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium yellow square is below medium blue s...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium blue squares are in block A. There is also one medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium yellow square is below medium blue square number two. It is below medium blue square number one which is below medium blue square number two. Block B is below block A. It has one medium yellow square. Finally, we have block C which is above block A. It has a medium blue square and a medium black square. There is also one medium yellow square in this block. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. Below the medium black square is the medium blue square. It is below the medium yellow square. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block C
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium blue squares are in block A. There is also one medium yellow squaretouching the bottom edge of this block. The medium yellow square is below medium blue square number two. It is below medium blue square number one which is below medium blue square number two. Block B is below block A. It has one medium yellow square. Finally, we have block C which is above block A. It has a medium blue square and a medium black square. There is also one medium yellow square in this block. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. Below the medium black square is the medium blue square. It is below the medium yellow square. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block C
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains two medium blue squares (number one and number two) and a medium yellow squareat the bottom edge. Block B is below Block A, and Block C is above Block A. Block C contains a medium yellow square, a medium black square, and a medium blue squareat its bottom edge. The question asks what is above a medium yellow square. In Block A, the blue squares are above the medium yellow square. In Block C, the medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Thus, only the medium yellow square at the bottom edge of Block A has something above it. The answer is {B}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning correctly identifies the contents of the blocks but misinterprets or ignores the positional constraints within Block C necessary to answer the final comparative question. It incorrectly concludes that only the yellow square in Block A has something above it, failing to properly assess the yellow square in Block C based on the provided relative positions.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
In Block C, the medium black square is below the medium yellow square.
Explanation
The context states the relative positions within Block C: 'Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. Below the medium black square is the medium blue square. It is below the medium yellow square.' This implies the order is Yellow -> Black -> Blue (from top to bottom). The reasoning states the black square is *below* the yellow square, which is consistent with the first part of the description, but then it ignores the subsequent crucial information about what is *above* the yellow square in Block C, which is necessary to answer the question about what is *above* a yellow square.
Answer Span:
In Block C, the medium black square is below the medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. Below the medium black square is the medium blue square. It is below the medium yellow square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Thus, only the medium yellow square at the bottom edge of Block A has something above it.
Explanation
The reasoning concludes that only the yellow square in Block A has something above it. This ignores the yellow square in Block C. The context states for Block C: 'Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square.' This means the medium yellow square in Block C has nothing explicitly stated to be above it *within the block's description*, but the question asks which object is above *a* medium yellow square, referring to the two specific yellow squares mentioned in the final question: 'the medium yellow square that is in block C or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?'. The reasoning fails to properly evaluate the yellow square in Block C against the question's requirement.
Answer Span:
Thus, only the medium yellow square at the bottom edge of Block A has something above it.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #1344
We have two blocks, A and B. Block A contains one small yellow circle, a big blue circle and a small black circle. The small yellow circle is below the big blue circle. The big blue circle is to the l...
1 issue
Full Question
We have two blocks, A and B. Block A contains one small yellow circle, a big blue circle and a small black circle. The small yellow circle is below the big blue circle. The big blue circle is to the left of and above the small black circle. The small black circle is touching the right edge of this block. To the right of block A we have block B. It contains a medium yellow square, one big blue triangle and one small black triangle. This block also has a medium yellow circle. Above the small black triangle and the big blue triangle is a medium black triangle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The small black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the medium yellow circle and the small black triangle is the big blue triangle. What is to the right of the small yellow circle? a small black triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a big blue triangle?
(a) small black triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) big blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have two blocks, A and B. Block A contains one small yellow circle, a big blue circle and a small black circle. The small yellow circle is below the big blue circle. The big blue circle is to the left of and above the small black circle. The small black circle is touching the right edge of this block. To the right of block A we have block B. It contains a medium yellow square, one big blue triangle and one small black triangle. This block also has a medium yellow circle. Above the small black triangle and the big blue triangle is a medium black triangle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The small black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of the medium yellow circle and the small black triangle is the big blue triangle. What is to the right of the small yellow circle? a small black triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a big blue triangle? (a) small black triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block (b) big blue triangle (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains the small yellow circle, the big blue circle, and the small black circle. Block B, which is to the right of Block A, contains a small black triangle touching the bottom edge and a big blue triangle. Since Block B is to the right of Block A, both the big blue triangle and the small black triangle (which is touching the bottom edge of Block B) are to the right of the small yellow circle (which is in Block A). Therefore, the answer is {C}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly concludes that both options must be to the right of the small yellow circle simply because they are in a block to the right of the block containing the circle. It fails to use the specific positional information given for the small yellow circle relative to other objects in Block A, which is necessary to determine what is immediately to its right.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B is to the right of Block A, both the big blue triangle and the small black triangle (which is touching the bottom edge of Block B) are to the right of the small yellow circle (which is in Block A).
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes that because Block B is to the right of Block A, everything in Block B is to the right of everything in Block A. This ignores the specific spatial relationships *within* Block A and Block B, and the relative positions needed to answer the question about what is *immediately* to the right of the small yellow circle.
Answer Span:
both the big blue triangle and the small black triangle (which is touching the bottom edge of Block B) are to the right of the small yellow circle (which is in Block A)
Reference/Question Span:
The small yellow circle is below the big blue circle. The big blue circle is to the left of and above the small black circle.
Question #316
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of A. Block A is below C. Block A has one medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also has one medium yellow sq...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of A. Block A is below C. Block A has one medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also has one medium yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square and the medium yellow square. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square. Block B has two medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Block C has two medium yellow squares. Below a medium blue square there is medium yellow square number one. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square number two. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? medium blue square number one or the medium blue square which is in block C?
(a) medium blue square number one
(b) the medium blue square which is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block B is to the left of A. Block A is below C. Block A has one medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also has one medium yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square and the medium yellow square. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square. Block B has two medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Block C has two medium yellow squares. Below a medium blue square there is medium yellow square number one. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square number two. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? medium blue square number one or the medium blue square which is in block C?
(a) medium blue square number one
(b) the medium blue square which is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is to the left of Block A. Block B contains two medium blue squares, with medium blue square number one below medium blue square number two. Block C contains two medium yellow squares and one medium blue square, with medium yellow square number two below the blue square and medium yellow square number one below square number two, touching the bottom edge. Block A is below Block C and contains a medium yellow square.
Since B is to the left of A, the blue squares in B are to the left of the yellow square in A. This means medium blue square number one is to the left of a medium yellow square (the one in Block A). Since Block A is below Block C, the blue square in Block C cannot be to the left of the yellow squares also in Block C. It is above them. So, the blue square in Block C is not to the left of a yellow square. Therefore, only medium blue square number one is to the left of a medium yellow square.
Final Answer: \boxed{a}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsupported assumption about the number of blue squares in Block C and incorrectly dismisses the possibility of the blue square in Block C being to the left of a yellow square based only on vertical positioning information provided for objects within Block C.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block C contains two medium yellow squares and one medium blue square
Explanation
The context states Block C has two medium yellow squares, but it does not specify the number of medium blue squares in Block C. The reasoning assumes there is only one.
Answer Span:
Block C contains two medium yellow squares and one medium blue square
Reference/Question Span:
Block C has two medium yellow squares.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block A is below Block C, the blue square in Block C cannot be to the left of the yellow squares also in Block C. It is above them.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly assumes the relative horizontal positions (left/right) of objects within Block C based only on vertical positioning ('Below a medium blue square there is medium yellow square number one. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square.'). The question asks which object is to the *left* of a medium yellow square. The relative horizontal positions of objects *within* Block C are not defined, only their vertical relationships.
Answer Span:
Since Block A is below Block C, the blue square in Block C cannot be to the left of the yellow squares also in Block C. It is above them.
Reference/Question Span:
Below a medium blue square there is medium yellow square number one. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square.
Question #2495
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains one medium yellow square. To the right of block A we have block B. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one ...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains one medium yellow square. To the right of block A we have block B. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a medium blue square. Medium black square number two is below the medium blue square. Below the medium blue square and medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. Finally, there is block C which is below block A. It has three medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and medium blue square number three. Medium blue square number two is below medium blue square number three. A medium yellow square is below medium blue square number two and medium blue square number one. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium blue square which is in block B or medium blue square number one?
(a) the medium blue square which is in block B
(b) medium blue square number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** We have three blocks, A, B, and C. Block A contains one medium yellow square. To the right of block A we have block B. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a medium blue square. Medium black square number two is below the medium blue square. Below the medium blue square and medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. Finally, there is block C which is below block A. It has three medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and medium blue square number three. Medium blue square number two is below medium blue square number three. A medium yellow square is below medium blue square number two and medium blue square number three. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium blue square which is in block B or medium blue square number one?
(a) the medium blue square which is in block B
(b) medium blue square number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block A contains a medium yellow square. Block B is to the right of Block A and contains a medium blue square. Block C is below Block A and contains medium blue square number one.
Since the question asks what is to the right of a medium yellow square, and Block A contains the medium yellow square, we need to find the object in the block to the right of Block A, which is Block B.
Block B contains a medium blue square. Thus, the medium blue square which is in block B, is to the right of the medium yellow square. Medium blue square number one, located in Block C (below Block A), is not to the right of the medium yellow square.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{A}$
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the location of the medium yellow square (Block A) and deduces that the object to its right must be in Block B, which is explicitly stated to be to the right of Block A. It correctly evaluates the options based on the context.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #349
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the right of A. Block B is to the left of C. Block A contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bo...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the right of A. Block B is to the left of C. Block A contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Block B has three medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square number three is medium black square number two. Below medium black square number three is medium black square number one. It is below the medium black square number two. And block C contains a medium yellow square and one medium blue square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square. Which object is below a medium black square? medium black square number three or the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium black square number three
(b) the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the right of A. Block B is to the left of C. Block A contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Block B has three medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square number three is medium black square number two. Below medium black square number three is medium black square number one. It is below the medium black square number two. And block C contains a medium yellow square and one medium blue square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square. Which object is below a medium black square? medium black square number three or the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium black square number three
(b) the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is to the left of C and Block C is to the right of Block A. Thus, the order of blocks from left to right is B, A, C. Block B contains three medium black squares: number one, two, and three. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge. Medium black square number two is below number three and number one is below number two, thus the order from top to bottom is three, two, and one. The question asks what is below a medium black square. Since medium black square number two is below medium black square number three and medium black square number one (which is touching the bottom edge) is below medium black square number two, both medium black square number three and the medium black square touching the bottom edge have a medium black square below them. Therefore, the answer is {C}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the block order but misinterprets or misrepresents the vertical stacking order of the black squares in Block B, leading to a flawed justification for the final conclusion, although the final conclusion itself might coincidentally align with the correct interpretation of the question asked.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Medium black square number two is below number three and number one is below number two, thus the order from top to bottom is three, two, one.
Explanation
The source states: 'Below medium black square number three is medium black square number two. Below medium black square number three is medium black square number one. It is below the medium black square number two.' This means 3 is above 2, and 1 is below 2 (so 2 is above 1). The order top to bottom is 3, 2, 1. The reasoning chain correctly states the order is three, two, one, but the description of the relationship between 1 and 2 contradicts the source's description of 1 being below 2, and 2 being below 3.
Answer Span:
Medium black square number two is below number three and number one is below number two, thus the order from top to bottom is three, two, one.
Reference/Question Span:
Below medium black square number three is medium black square number two. Below medium black square number three is medium black square number one. It is below the medium black square number two.
Question #1845
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are two medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are two medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square. Medium black square number one is below the medium yellow square. This object is below medium black square number two. Above block A we have block B with two medium blue squares in it. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium blue square number two. It also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is below the yellow object which is below medium blue square number two. Below block A there is block C with one medium yellow square in it. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or the medium yellow square that is in block A?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block C
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. There are two medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square. Medium black square number one is below the medium yellow square. This object is below medium black square number two. Above block A we have block B with two medium blue squares in it. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium blue square number two. It also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is below the yellow object which is below medium blue square number two. Below block A there is block C with one medium yellow square in it. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or the medium yellow square that is in block A?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block C
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer: Block A contains two medium black squares and a medium yellow square. Medium black square number one is at the bottom edge of Block A, with the medium yellow square above it, and medium black square number two above that. Block B is above Block A, and Block C is below Block A. Block C contains a medium yellow square. Since the question asks what is below the medium yellow square (in Block A), the answer is the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block A. This medium black square is in Block A, not Block C. The medium yellow square in Block C is below Block A as a whole, not specifically below the medium yellow square within Block A. Therefore, the answer is {B}. \boxed{b}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain contains a factual contradiction regarding the vertical stacking order of squares in Block A and fundamentally misinterprets the final question by ignoring the required comparison between the objects below the yellow squares in Block A and Block C.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Medium black square number one is at the bottom edge of Block A, with the medium yellow square above it, and medium black square number two above that.
Explanation
The context states that Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge, and Medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square. It does not state the order is Black 1 -> Yellow -> Black 2. The context states: 'Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square. Medium black square number one is below the medium yellow square.' This implies Yellow is above Black 1, and Black 2 is also below Yellow, but the exact vertical stacking order of Black 1, Black 2, and Yellow is not explicitly stated as Black 1 -> Yellow -> Black 2.
Answer Span:
Medium black square number one is at the bottom edge of Block A, with the medium yellow square above it, and medium black square number two above that.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square. Medium black square number one is below the medium yellow square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since the question asks what is below the medium yellow square (in Block A), the answer is the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes the question is only asking about the yellow square in Block A, but the question explicitly asks to compare the object below the yellow square in Block C versus the object below the yellow square in Block A: 'Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or the medium yellow square that is in block A?' The reasoning ignores the comparison aspect.
Answer Span:
Since the question asks what is below the medium yellow square (in Block A), the answer is the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or the medium yellow square that is in block A?
Question #1846
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are two medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are two medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square. Medium black square number one is below the medium yellow square. This object is below medium black square number two. Above block A we have block B with two medium blue squares in it. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium blue square number two. It also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is below the yellow object which is below medium blue square number two. Below block A there is block C with one medium yellow square in it. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block B or the medium yellow square that is in block A?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block B
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. Let's call them A, B and C. There are two medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below a medium yellow square. Medium black square number one is below the medium yellow square. This object is below medium black square number two. Above block A we have block B with two medium blue squares in it. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium blue square number two. It also contains one medium yellow square. It is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is below the yellow object which is below medium blue square number two. Below block A there is block C with one medium yellow square in it. Which object is above a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is in block B or the medium yellow square that is in block A? (a) the medium yellow square that is in block B (b) the medium yellow square that is in block A (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has two medium black squares and a medium yellow square. Block B is above Block A and contains two medium blue squares and a medium yellow square. Block C is below Block A and contains a medium yellow square. The question asks what is above a medium yellow square. Since Block B is above Block A, the medium yellow square in Block A is below the medium yellow square in Block B. The medium yellow square in Block B has a medium blue square number two above it. The medium yellow square in Block A has medium black square number two above it. Thus, only medium blue square number two, which is in Block B, is above a medium yellow square.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{B}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly summarizes the contents of Block A and makes an unsupported assumption about the relative vertical positioning of the two yellow squares based only on the block positions, leading to an incorrect final conclusion based on flawed intermediate steps.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block A has two medium black squares and a medium yellow square.
Explanation
The context states Block A has two medium black squares, but it does not explicitly state it has a medium yellow square. It only describes relationships involving a medium yellow square relative to the black squares within Block A.
Answer Span:
Block A has two medium black squares and a medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
There are two medium black squares in block A.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B is above Block A, the medium yellow square in Block A is below the medium yellow square in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes a direct vertical relationship between the two yellow squares based only on the blocks' relative positions (B above A). The context does not establish that the yellow square in A is directly below the yellow square in B, only that B is above A.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is above Block A, the medium yellow square in Block A is below the medium yellow square in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Above block A we have block B with two medium blue squares in it. . . Below block A there is block C with one medium yellow square in it.
Question #317
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of A. Block A is below C. Block A has one medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also has one medium yellow sq...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of A. Block A is below C. Block A has one medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also has one medium yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square and the medium yellow square. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square. Block B has two medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Block C has two medium yellow squares. Below a medium blue square there is medium yellow square number one. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square number two. Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium blue square that is in block A or medium blue square number one?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) medium blue square number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block B is to the left of A. Block A is below C. Block A has one medium black square and a medium blue square. This block also has one medium yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square and the medium yellow square. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square. Block B has two medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Block C has two medium yellow squares. Below a medium blue square there is medium yellow square number one. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square number two. Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium blue square that is in block A or medium blue square number one?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) medium blue square number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is to the left of Block A. Block B contains two medium blue squares, with medium blue square number one below medium blue square number two. Block A contains a medium blue square. Since Block A is to the right of Block B, the medium blue square in Block A is to the right of both medium blue squares in Block B. Medium blue square number one is in Block B. Therefore, the medium blue square in Block A is to the right of medium blue square number one in Block B. The medium blue square in Block A is to the right of a medium blue square (specifically, the top medium blue square) in Block B.Block A also contains a medium black square and medium yellow square. Block C has two medium yellow squares, and it is located above Block A. This information doesn't impact the position of the medium blue squares.
Final Answer: The final answer is \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the blocks (B left of A) and uses this to determine the relative horizontal positions of the specified blue squares. It correctly concludes that the blue square in A is to the right of the blue square in B (which contains medium blue square number one).
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1789
We have two blocks, A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A contains one small blue triangle, a big blue circle and one medium blue triangle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of th...
2 issues
Full Question
We have two blocks, A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A contains one small blue triangle, a big blue circle and one medium blue triangle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. This object is near to, above and to the right of the medium blue triangle. Block B contains two medium blue triangles. Medium blue triangle number one is touching the right edge of this block. A big yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of medium blue triangle number two is a small yellow circle. Below medium blue triangle number two is a big blue triangle.. To the left of medium blue triangle number one and the big blue triangle there is the big yellow square. It is to the right of the yellow shape which is to the left of medium blue triangle number two. What is to the right of the small blue triangle? a big blue triangle or a yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) big blue triangle
(b) yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** We have two blocks, A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A contains one small blue triangle, a big blue circle and one medium blue triangle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. This object is near to, above and to the right of the medium blue triangle. Block B contains two medium blue triangles. Medium blue triangle number one is touching the right edge of this block. A big yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of medium blue triangle number two is a small yellow circle. Below medium blue triangle number two is a big blue triangle. To the left of medium blue triangle number one and the big blue triangle there is the big yellow square. It is to the right of the yellow shape which is to the left of medium blue triangle number two. What is to the right of the small blue triangle? a big blue triangle or a yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) big blue triangle
(b) yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
The small blue triangle is in Block A. Block B is to the right of Block A. Block B contains two medium blue triangles, a big blue triangle, and a big yellow square touching the bottom edge. Since Block B is to the right of Block A, both the big blue triangle and the big yellow square are to the right of the small blue triangle in Block A. Thus, the answer is {C}.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{C}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes several unsupported assumptions about the contents of Block B and incorrectly concludes the answer based on general block positioning rather than checking the specific positional constraints required by the question (what is to the right of the small blue triangle).
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block B contains two medium blue triangles, a big blue triangle, and a big yellow square touching the bottom edge.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly states that Block B contains a big blue triangle. The context states Block B contains 'two medium blue triangles' and 'A big yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block.' The big blue triangle is mentioned in relation to Block B, but its location is specified relative to other objects *within* Block B, not explicitly stated as being *contained* in Block B in the same way the medium triangles are.
Answer Span:
Block B contains two medium blue triangles, a big blue triangle, and a big yellow square touching the bottom edge.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B contains two medium blue triangles. Medium blue triangle number one is touching the right edge of this block. A big yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block B is to the right of Block A, both the big blue triangle and the big yellow square are to the right of the small blue triangle in Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes that because Block B is to the right of Block A, everything mentioned in Block B is to the right of everything in Block A. However, the question asks what is to the right of the *small blue triangle* specifically. The small blue triangle is in Block A. While Block B is to the right of Block A, the reasoning fails to check the specific positional constraints given for the objects mentioned in the options relative to the small blue triangle, relying only on block location, and it incorrectly assumes the big blue triangle is in Block B.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is to the right of Block A, both the big blue triangle and the big yellow square are to the right of the small blue triangle in Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the right of the small blue triangle? a big blue triangle or a yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #3160
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of and C is to the right of B. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B contains two medium blue squares. This block also has a medium black...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of and C is to the right of B. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B contains two medium blue squares. This block also has a medium black square. This block also contains one medium yellow square. This object is below medium blue square number two. It is below the medium black square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium blue square number two , the medium yellow square and the medium black square. Block C has two medium yellow squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square is medium yellow square number one. Which object is below a black shape? the medium blue square that is in block C or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block C
(b) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the left of and C is to the right of B. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B contains two medium blue squares. This block also has a medium black square. This block also contains one medium yellow square. This object is below medium blue square number two. It is below the medium black square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium blue square number two , the medium yellow square and the medium black square. Block C has two medium yellow squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square is medium yellow square number one. Which object is below a black shape? the medium blue square that is in block C or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block? (a) the medium blue square that is in block C (b) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is between Block A and Block C. Block B contains two medium blue squares, a medium black square, and a medium yellow square. The arrangement within Block B is such that the medium black square is on top, followed by medium blue square number two, then the medium yellow square, and finally, medium blue square number one touching the bottom edge (This order is confirmed by the fact that the yellow square is below both blue square two and the black square, and blue square one is below all three). Since we are looking for what is below the black shape in Block B, and medium blue square one is at the bottom edge of Block B, the answer is {B}. \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain focuses exclusively on Block B and fails to analyze the contents or location of Block C, which is necessary to evaluate the first option in the multiple-choice question. It also makes an assumption about the relative positions of A, B, and C. Crucially, it ignores the context needed to determine if the blue square in C is below a black shape.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block B is between Block A and Block C.
Explanation
The context states the relative positions (A left of B, C right of B), which implies B is between A and C, but the reasoning chain presents this as an established fact derived from the context, when the context only gives directional relationships, not explicitly stating B is *between* A and C, although this is a reasonable inference. More critically, the reasoning chain focuses entirely on Block B and ignores Block C's contents entirely, which is necessary to answer the question.
Answer Span:
Block B is between Block A and Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A is to the left of and C is to the right of B.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The arrangement within Block B is such that the medium black square is on top, followed by medium blue square number two, then the medium yellow square, and finally, medium blue square number one touching the bottom edge (This order is confirmed by the fact that the yellow square is below both blue square two and the black square, and blue square one is below all three).
Explanation
The reasoning chain constructs a specific vertical order for the shapes within Block B based on partial information provided, but it completely ignores the information about Block C, which is essential for answering the question which asks to compare an object in C with an object in B.
Answer Span:
The arrangement within Block B is such that the medium black square is on top, followed by medium blue square number two, then the medium yellow square, and finally, medium blue square number one touching the bottom edge (This order is confirmed by the fact that the yellow square is below both blue square two and the black square, and blue square one is below all three).
Reference/Question Span:
Block C has two medium yellow squares. There is also a medium blue square in this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Below medium yellow square number two and the medium blue square is medium yellow square number one. Which object is below a black shape? the medium blue square that is in block C or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #2896
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of C and block C is above B. Block A contains three medium yellow squares. It also contains a medium black square. It is below me...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of C and block C is above B. Block A contains three medium yellow squares. It also contains a medium black square. It is below medium yellow square number three. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium yellow square number three and the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium black square and medium yellow square number three. Block B contains two medium yellow squares. One medium blue square is also in this block. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium blue square and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square. Block C contains one medium yellow square. Which object is below a medium square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or medium yellow square number three?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block C
(b) medium yellow square number three
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
3
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of C and block C is above B. Block A contains three medium yellow squares. It also contains a medium black square. It is below medium yellow square number three. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium yellow square number three and the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium black square and medium yellow square number three. Block B contains two medium yellow squares. One medium blue square is also in this block. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium blue square and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium blue square. Block C contains one medium yellow square. Which object is below a medium square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or medium yellow square number three?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block C
(b) medium yellow square number three
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C is above Block B. Block C contains one medium yellow square. Block A is to the right of Block C. Block A contains three medium yellow squares and a medium black square. Medium yellow square number three is above medium yellow square number two and the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one (in Block A) is touching the bottom edge. The question asks what is below a medium square (in Block C). Since Block B is below Block C, and Block A is to the right of, not below, Block C, only Block B can be below Block C. Therefore, the object below the medium yellow square in Block C is something in Block B. Since medium yellow square number three is in Block A and Block A is not below Block C, medium yellow square number three cannot be below the medium yellow square in Block C. The medium yellow square in Block C has objects in Block B below it. The answer is \boxed{A}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain fundamentally misinterprets the final question, leading to an irrelevant line of deduction about what is below the square in Block C, rather than evaluating the two options provided in the question against the condition 'is below a medium square'.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block C is above Block B.
Explanation
The context states 'block C is above B', which is consistent. However, the reasoning then pivots to assume the question is asking what is below the square in C, which is not the question asked.
Answer Span:
Block C is above Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
block C is above B
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The question asks what is below a medium square (in Block C).
Explanation
The actual question is: 'Which object is below a medium square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or medium yellow square number three?' This is a choice between two specific objects being below *some* medium square, not asking what is below the square in Block C.
Answer Span:
The question asks what is below a medium square (in Block C).
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is below a medium square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or medium yellow square number three?
Question #2032
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one medium blue square. Block B is above block A. It contains one medium blue triangle, one big yellow square and one small yellow square. ...
1 issue
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one medium blue square. Block B is above block A. It contains one medium blue triangle, one big yellow square and one small yellow square. A big blue circle is also in this block. The small yellow square is above the big blue circle. The medium blue triangle is below the small yellow square. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is near to the big blue circle. The big yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. It is below the small shape which is above the big blue circle. It is above the big blue circle. To the left of block B there is block C which has one big black circle. There is also one medium black circle in this block. The big black circle is to the left of and near to the medium black circle. Which object is below a medium blue object? the medium black circle or the square that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the medium black circle
(b) the square that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
3
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block A has one medium blue square. Block B is above block A. It contains one medium blue triangle, one big yellow square and one small yellow square. A big blue circle is also in this block. The small yellow square is above the big blue circle. The medium blue triangle is below the small yellow square. It is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is near to the big blue circle. The big yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. It is below the small shape which is above the big blue circle. It is above the big blue circle. To the left of block B there is block C which has one big black circle. There is also one medium black circle in this block. The big black circle is to the left of and near to the medium black circle. Which object is below a medium blue object? the medium black circle or the square that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the medium black circle
(b) the square that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is above Block A, and Block B contains a medium blue triangle. Since Block B is above Block A, and Block A contains a medium blue square, the medium blue triangle is above the medium blue square. Therefore, the medium blue square is below the medium blue triangle. This blue square is in Block A. The big yellow square is in Block B and is touching the right edge of Block B. The medium black circle is in Block C, which is to the left of Block B. Therefore, the medium black circle cannot be below a medium blue object in Block B or A. The big yellow square, however, is in Block B and is, therefore, below the medium blue triangle.
Final Answer: The final answer is \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies one potential answer (the square touching the right edge, which is the big yellow square in B, below the medium blue triangle in B) but incorrectly dismisses the other option (the medium black circle) based on an unwarranted assumption about location relative to the medium blue objects.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Therefore, the medium black circle cannot be below a medium blue object in Block B or A.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly assumes the medium black circle must be in Block B or A to be below a medium blue object. The question asks which object *is* below a medium blue object, regardless of which block they are in, as long as the spatial relationship holds. The medium black circle is in Block C, and the medium blue objects are in A and B. The reasoning fails to check if any medium blue object (in A or B) is above the medium black circle (in C).
Answer Span:
Therefore, the medium black circle cannot be below a medium blue object in Block B or A.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is below a medium blue object? the medium black circle or the square that is touching the right edge of a block?
Question #1516
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of C and block C is to the right of A. Block A contains a medium blue square, one big blue circle and a big black circle. This...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of C and block C is to the right of A. Block A contains a medium blue square, one big blue circle and a big black circle. This block also has a small black square. There is also one small blue square in this block. The big blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the small blue square. The medium blue square is below and to the right of the small black square. This shape is above and to the left of the big black circle. Block B contains a medium black square. Block C contains one small black square, one small yellow triangle and one small blue triangle. Below the small blue triangle and the small yellow triangle there is the small black square. The small yellow triangle is near to the small blue triangle. What is to the right of the small blue square? a object that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a small black square?
(a) object that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) small black square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block B is to the left of C and block C is to the right of A. Block A contains a medium blue square, one big blue circle, and a big black circle. This block also has a small black square. There is also one small blue square in this block. The big blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the small blue square. The medium blue square is below and to the right of the small black square. This shape is above and to the left of the big black circle. Block B contains a medium black square. Block C contains one small black square, one small yellow triangle, and one small blue triangle. Below the small blue triangle and the small yellow triangle there is the small black square. The small yellow triangle is near to the small blue triangle. What is to the right of the small blue square? a object that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a small black square?
(a) object that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) small black square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
We know that Block A contains a small blue square, a small black square, and a big blue circle. The small blue square is above the big blue circle, which is touching the bottom edge of Block A. The small black square is above and to the left of the medium blue square. Since we want to know what is to the right of the small blue square, and we know that the small black square is to the left of the medium blue square, while the big blue circle is below the small blue square, the correct answer is the small black square.
The medium blue square is to the right and below the small black square. The big blue circle is below the small blue square. Thus, to the right of the small blue square is the small black square.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{B}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain fails to correctly deduce the answer from the provided spatial relationships. It makes an unsupported leap by concluding the small black square is to the right of the small blue square based on relationships involving the medium blue square and the big blue circle, without establishing the necessary direct spatial link between the small blue square and the small black square. The context only states the medium blue square is below/right of the small black square, and the big blue circle is below the small blue square.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionlow
Statement
The small black square is above and to the left of the medium blue square.
Explanation
The context states the medium blue square is below and to the right of the small black square, which means the small black square is above and to the left of the medium blue square. However, the context states: 'The medium blue square is below and to the right of the small black square.' This is a direct restatement of the relationship, but the reasoning chain uses this to establish a relationship that is not directly used to answer the final question about what is to the right of the small blue square, and it misrepresents the relative positions in the subsequent step.
Answer Span:
The small black square is above and to the left of the medium blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
The medium blue square is below and to the right of the small black square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Thus, to the right of the small blue square is the small black square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain concludes that the small black square is to the right of the small blue square based on the relative positions of the small black square and the medium blue square, and the position of the big blue circle relative to the small blue square. However, the question asks what is to the right of the small blue square, and the context only specifies the relationship between the medium blue square and the small black square relative to *each other*, and the big blue circle relative to the small blue square. It never explicitly states the position of the small black square relative to the small blue square, which is crucial for answering the question. The reasoning chain invents a direct relationship to support the conclusion.
Answer Span:
Thus, to the right of the small blue square is the small black square.
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the right of the small blue square? a object that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a small black square?
Question #2821
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. One medium blue square, a medium black square and a medium yellow square are in block A. Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. The me...
2 issues
Full Question
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. One medium blue square, a medium black square and a medium yellow square are in block A. Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square and the medium black square. Below block A is block B. It has three medium black squares. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number one. Below medium black square number three is medium black square number two. There is also one medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium black square number one is the medium yellow square. This object is below medium black square number two and medium black square number three. Which object is below a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is in block A or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are two blocks. Let's call them A and B. One medium blue square, a medium black square and a medium yellow square are in block A. Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square and the medium black square. Below block A is block B. It has three medium black squares. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number one. Below medium black square number three is medium black square number two. There is also one medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium black square number one is the medium yellow square. This object is below medium black square number two and medium black square number three. Which object is below a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is in block A or the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(b) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
In Block A, the medium black square is below the medium yellow square, and the medium blue square is below both of those. Block B is below Block A, and contains three medium black squares. Since Block B is below Block A, some of the medium black squares in Block B are below the medium black square in Block A. The medium yellow square in Block B is below the medium black squares in Block B. Therefore, the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of Block B is below a medium black square (specifically, those in Block B). The medium yellow square in Block A is above the medium black square in Block A and is not below any medium black square. Therefore, the answer is {b}. \boxed{b}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies that the yellow square in Block B is below black squares in Block B based on the context. However, it introduces an unsupported spatial inference about the relationship between the squares in Block A and Block B, which is not explicitly stated in the context, leading to a potentially flawed intermediate step, even though the final conclusion aligns with the explicit facts about Block B.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block B is below Block A, some of the medium black squares in Block B are below the medium black square in Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes a spatial relationship between the black squares in Block A and Block B based only on the blocks' relative positions, but the context only describes the internal arrangement of squares within each block and the position of Block B relative to Block A. It does not state that any square in B is directly below any square in A.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is below Block A, some of the medium black squares in Block B are below the medium black square in Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Below block A is block B.
missing_contextlow
Statement
The medium yellow square in Block B is below the medium black squares in Block B.
Explanation
The context describes the arrangement in Block B: 'Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number one. Below medium black square number three is medium black square number two. There is also one medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium black square number one is the medium yellow square. This object is below medium black square number two and medium black square number three.' This explicitly states the yellow square in B is below black squares 1, 2, and 3. The reasoning summarizes this correctly but the previous step's assumption about B being below A is flawed contextually.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow square in Block B is below the medium black squares in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Below medium black square number one is the medium yellow square. This object is below medium black square number two and medium black square number three.
Question #1425
There are two blocks, A and B. Block A has a big black square, a small black square and one medium black square. The small black square is above the medium black square. Near to and to the right of th...
1 issue
Full Question
There are two blocks, A and B. Block A has a big black square, a small black square and one medium black square. The small black square is above the medium black square. Near to and to the right of the small black square there is the big black square. Block B is to the right of block A. It contains one medium black triangle, one small black square and one big yellow square. A medium yellow triangle is also in this block. The big yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. Near to the big yellow square and the small black square there is the medium black triangle. The small black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black triangle is to the right of the medium yellow triangle. Which object is to the left of a medium black triangle? the thing that is touching the right edge of a block or the black thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the thing that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the black thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
3
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are two blocks, A and B. Block A has a big black square, a small black square and one medium black square. The small black square is above the medium black square. Near to and to the right of the small black square there is the big black square. Block B is to the right of block A. It contains one medium black triangle, one small black square and one big yellow square. A medium yellow triangle is also in this block. The big yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. Near to the big yellow square and the small black square there is the medium black triangle. The small black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black triangle is to the right of the medium yellow triangle. Which object is to the left of a medium black triangle? the thing that is touching the right edge of a block or the black thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block? (a) the thing that is touching the right edge of a block (b) the black thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer: Block B is to the right of Block A. Block B contains the medium black triangle, the big yellow square touching the right edge, and the small black square touching the bottom edge. Since both the big yellow square and the small black square are in Block B along with the medium black triangle, and are described as being near it, they are both to its left. Therefore, both the big yellow square (touching the right edge) and the small black square (touching the bottom edge) are to the left of the medium black triangle. The answer is \boxed{C}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in Block B and their properties relevant to the options. However, it makes an unsubstantiated assumption about the relative positioning (left/right) of the small black square relative to the medium black triangle based only on the proximity statement, which is a missing context error regarding spatial reasoning.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since both the big yellow square and the small black square are in Block B along with the medium black triangle, and are described as being near it, they are both to its left.
Explanation
The reasoning claims the small black square is touching the bottom edge of Block B, but the context states the small black square is in Block B, and the small black square is touching the bottom edge of *this block* (referring to Block B, which is correct), but the question asks about the object touching the bottom edge of a block, which is the small black square. The reasoning incorrectly assumes that because the small black square is near the medium black triangle, it must be to its left. The context only states the small black square is near the medium black triangle, not its relative position (left/right).
Answer Span:
they are both to its left
Reference/Question Span:
Near to the big yellow square and the small black square there is the medium black triangle.
Question #2635
We have two blocks. We call them A and B. There are one small yellow triangle, a big black square and a medium black triangle in block A. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block....
1 issue
Full Question
We have two blocks. We call them A and B. There are one small yellow triangle, a big black square and a medium black triangle in block A. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. It is above the medium black triangle. The small yellow triangle is touching the top edge of this block. The medium black triangle is touching the right edge of this block. The small yellow triangle is above and to the left of the big black square. Block B is above block A. It contains one small black square, one medium yellow circle and one big black triangle. This block also has a small blue square. Above the big black triangle is the medium yellow circle. A small blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Above the small blue circle and the big black triangle there is the small black square. What is below the small blue square? a big black square or a small object that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) big black square
(b) small object that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have two blocks. We call them A and B. There are one small yellow triangle, a big black square and a medium black triangle in block A. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. It is above the medium black triangle. The small yellow triangle is touching the top edge of this block. The medium black triangle is touching the right edge of this block. The small yellow triangle is above and to the left of the big black square. Block B is above block A. It contains one small black square, one medium yellow circle and one big black triangle. This block also has a small blue square. Above the big black triangle is the medium yellow circle. A small blue circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Above the small blue circle and the big black triangle there is the small black square. What is below the small blue square? a big black square or a small object that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) big black square
(b) small object that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a small yellow triangle at the top, a big black square on the right edge above a medium black triangle, which is also on the right edge. Block B, which is above Block A, contains a small blue square, a small blue circle touching the bottom edge, a big black triangle, a small black square, and a medium yellow circle. The small black square is above the small blue circle and the big black triangle. The medium yellow circle is above the big black triangle. Since Block B is above Block A and the small blue square is in Block B, the object directly below the small blue square would be in Block A. The big black square is in Block A. Therefore, the big black square is below the small blue square. The small blue circle is touching the bottom edge of Block B, not Block A, so it cannot be below the small blue square. The answer is \boxed{A}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the location of the big black square in Block A. However, it incorrectly dismisses option (b) by assuming the object below the small blue square must be in Block A, ignoring that both objects could be in Block B, and the small blue circle fits the description in option (b) and is below the small blue square within Block B.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The small blue circle is touching the bottom edge of Block B, not Block A, so it cannot be below the small blue square.
Explanation
The reasoning correctly identifies that the small blue circle is in Block B and touches the bottom edge of Block B. However, the question asks if the object below the small blue square is 'a big black square or a small object that is touching the bottom edge of a block?'. The small object touching the bottom edge of a block *could* be the small blue circle (which touches the bottom edge of Block B). By concluding it 'cannot be below the small blue square' based on it being in Block B, the reasoning ignores the possibility that the small blue circle *is* the 'small object that is touching the bottom edge of a block' mentioned in option (b), and since Block B is above Block A, the small blue circle is indeed below the small blue square (as they are both in Block B, and the small blue circle is at the bottom edge of B, while the small blue square is somewhere above it in B). The reasoning incorrectly dismisses option (b) based on spatial separation between blocks when the question is phrased generally about the objects.
Answer Span:
The small blue circle is touching the bottom edge of Block B, not Block A, so it cannot be below the small blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
What is below the small blue square? a big black square or a small object that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #3095
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A contains one medium blue triangle and a small yellow square. There is also a small black circle in this block. Above an...
2 issues
Full Question
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A contains one medium blue triangle and a small yellow square. There is also a small black circle in this block. Above and to the left of the small yellow square is the medium blue triangle. A medium black circle is far from, above and to the left of the small yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is to the left of and below medium yellow square number two. It also has one medium black circle. This object is below medium yellow square number two. It also contains a big blue square. Below and near to the big blue square is the medium black circle. To the left of the black object which is below the big blue square there is medium yellow square number one. What is to the left of the blue square? a medium blue triangle or a medium black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium blue triangle
(b) medium black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A contains one medium blue triangle and a small yellow square. There is also a small black circle in this block. Above and to the left of the small yellow square is the medium blue triangle. A medium black circle is far from, above and to the left of the small yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is to the left of and below medium yellow square number two. It also has one medium black circle. This object is below medium yellow square number two. It also contains a big blue square. Below and near to the big blue square is the medium black circle. To the left of the black object which is below the big blue square there is medium yellow square number one. What is to the left of the blue square? a medium blue triangle or a medium black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium blue triangle
(b) medium black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block A is to the left of Block B. Block A contains a medium blue triangle. Block B contains two medium yellow squares, a medium black circle, and a big blue square. Medium yellow square number one is to the left of the medium black circle (which is below the big blue square). Since the question asks what is to the left of the big blue square, and medium yellow square number one is to its left, the answer is not a medium black circle touching the bottom edge. Because Block A is to the left of Block B and Block A contains the medium blue triangle, the medium blue triangle is to the left of the big blue square. Therefore, the answer is {A}.
\boxed{A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain fundamentally misinterprets the target object for the final question, substituting 'blue square' with 'big blue square' and then using derived (and partially flawed) spatial relationships to eliminate option (b) before correctly identifying that the medium blue triangle is in Block A, which is to the left of Block B (where the blue square is located).
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Medium yellow square number one is to the left of the medium black circle (which is below the big blue square).
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes the question is asking what is to the left of the *big blue square*. The actual question asks what is to the left of the *blue square* (which is only mentioned as being in Block B, but the specific object being referenced for the 'left of' query is not explicitly defined as the big blue square in the question itself, although the options suggest a comparison to an object in Block B). More critically, the reasoning chain uses the relationship between medium yellow square number one and the medium black circle to conclude something about the big blue square, when the context only states: "To the left of the black object which is below the big blue square there is medium yellow square number one."
Answer Span:
Medium yellow square number one is to the left of the medium black circle (which is below the big blue square).
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the left of the blue square? a medium blue triangle or a medium black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since the question asks what is to the left of the big blue square, and medium yellow square number one is to its left, the answer is not a medium black circle touching the bottom edge.
Explanation
This step incorrectly assumes the question is about the big blue square, ignoring the actual question which asks what is to the left of the 'blue square'. Furthermore, it uses the relationship derived in the previous hallucinated step to eliminate option (b), which is based on the actual options provided in the question.
Answer Span:
Since the question asks what is to the left of the big blue square, and medium yellow square number one is to its left, the answer is not a medium black circle touching the bottom edge.
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the left of the blue square? a medium blue triangle or a medium black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #1253
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains a big black circle and one small blue circle. The big black circle is below a medium black triangle. Below the medium black triangle t...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A contains a big black circle and one small blue circle. The big black circle is below a medium black triangle. Below the medium black triangle there is the small blue circle. The big black circle is above and near to the small blue circle. Then, there is block B with one medium yellow circle, a big black square and one small blue square in it. A medium black circle is to the right of the medium yellow circle and the small blue square. Above the big black square and the small blue square is the medium yellow circle. The medium black circle is above the big black square. To the right of block A and to the left of block B there is block C. It has one medium blue circle and a small blue circle. The medium blue circle is near to and to the left of a medium black square which is to the right of and below the small blue circle. What is to the left of the big black square? a medium blue circle or a yellow object?
(a) medium blue circle
(b) yellow object
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B and C. Block A contains a big black circle and one small blue circle. The big black circle is below a medium black triangle. Below the medium black triangle there is the small blue circle. The big black circle is above and near to the small blue circle. Then, there is block B with one medium yellow circle, a big black square and one small blue square in it. A medium black circle is to the right of the medium yellow circle and the small blue square. Above the big black square and the small blue square is the medium yellow circle. The medium black circle is above the big black square. To the right of block A and to the left of block B there is block C. It has one medium blue circle and a small blue circle. The medium blue circle is near to and to the left of a medium black square which is to the right of and below the small blue circle. What is to the left of the big black square? a medium blue circle or a yellow object? (a) medium blue circle (b) yellow object (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block B contains the big black square, a medium yellow circle, and a small blue square. Block C is to the left of Block B and to the right of Block A. Block C contains a medium blue circle and a small blue circle. Since Block C is directly to the left of Block B, the object directly to the left of the big black square (which is in Block B) is the medium blue circle (in Block C). The yellow object (medium yellow circle) is above the big black square (within the same Block B). Therefore, the answer is {A}. \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the contents of the blocks but makes an unsupported assumption about the spatial relationship between objects in Block C and the big black square in Block B, leading to a potentially flawed step, although the final conclusion based on this flawed step happens to align with the correct answer derived from other facts (the yellow object is in B, the blue circle is in C, and C is to the left of B).
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block C is directly to the left of Block B, the object directly to the left of the big black square (which is in Block B) is the medium blue circle (in Block C).
Explanation
The reasoning assumes Block C is *directly* to the left of Block B, and that the object immediately to the left of the big black square must be in Block C. The context only states Block C is 'To the right of block A and to the left of block B'. It does not specify the internal alignment or adjacency between objects in C and objects in B, especially not that the medium blue circle is *directly* to the left of the big black square.
Answer Span:
Since Block C is directly to the left of Block B, the object directly to the left of the big black square (which is in Block B) is the medium blue circle (in Block C)
Reference/Question Span:
To the right of block A and to the left of block B there is block C.
Question #1296
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is above blocks C and A. Block A has a small yellow square and one big yellow triangle. The small yellow square is below the big yellow triangle. Block B ha...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is above blocks C and A. Block A has a small yellow square and one big yellow triangle. The small yellow square is below the big yellow triangle. Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the right edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is above a big blue triangle. It also contains a big blue square. It is above and to the right of the big blue triangle. Above and to the right of the big blue triangle there is medium yellow square number one. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. And block C has one medium yellow square and a big yellow circle. This block also has a medium black triangle. The medium yellow square is near to, to the right of and below the big yellow circle. Which object is above a yellow square? the triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the big blue square?
(a) the triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the big blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block B is above blocks C and A. Block A has a small yellow square and one big yellow triangle. The small yellow square is below the big yellow triangle. Block B has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the right edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is above a big blue triangle. It also contains a big blue square. It is above and to the right of the big blue triangle. Above and to the right of the big blue triangle there is medium yellow square number one. The big blue triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. And block C has one medium yellow square and a big yellow circle. This block also has a medium black triangle. The medium yellow square is near to, to the right of and below the big yellow circle. Which object is above a yellow square? the triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the big blue square? (a) the triangle that is touching the bottom edge of a block (b) the big blue square (c) both of them (d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block B is above Block A. Block B contains medium yellow square number two above a big blue triangle, and a big blue square which is above and to the right of the big blue triangle. The big blue triangle touches the bottom edge of Block B. Since we are looking for what is above a yellow square, we focus on medium yellow square number two in Block B. The object directly above the big blue triangle (and therefore above medium yellow square number two)is the big blue square. The answer is \boxed{B}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsupported assumption about the vertical relationship between the big blue square and medium yellow square number two, leading to a conclusion based on flawed intermediate steps. It also slightly misrepresents the positional information given for Block B.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block B is above Block A.
Explanation
The context states Block B is above blocks C and A, but the reasoning chain implies a specific relationship between B and A that isn't the full context, and more importantly, it misses the crucial detail that B is above *both* A and C.
Answer Span:
Block B is above Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is above blocks C and A.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The object directly above the big blue triangle (and therefore above medium yellow square number two) is the big blue square.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes that because medium yellow square number two is above the big blue triangle, and the big blue square is also above and to the right of the big blue triangle, the big blue square must be directly above medium yellow square number two. The context only states that medium yellow square number two is above the big blue triangle, and the big blue square is above and to the right of the big blue triangle. It does not establish the vertical relationship between the big blue square and medium yellow square number two.
Answer Span:
The object directly above the big blue triangle (and therefore above medium yellow square number two) is the big blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium yellow square number two is above a big blue triangle. It also contains a big blue square. It is above and to the right of the big blue triangle.
Question #350
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. One medium yellow square is in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below a medium ...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. One medium yellow square is in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square and medium black square number two. This block also contains one medium blue square. The medium blue square is below medium black square number one and medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two is the medium yellow square. To the left of block B there is block C with two medium yellow squares in it. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. One medium blue square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two there is the medium blue square. It is below medium yellow square number one. Which object is above a medium blue square? medium yellow square number one or the medium yellow square which is in block A?
(a) medium yellow square number one
(b) the medium yellow square which is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. One medium yellow square is in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square and medium black square number two. This block also contains one medium blue square. The medium blue square is below medium black square number one and medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two is the medium yellow square. To the left of block B there is block C with two medium yellow squares in it. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. One medium blue square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two there is the medium blue square. It is below medium yellow square number one. Which object is above a medium blue square? medium yellow square number one or the medium yellow square which is in block A?
(a) medium yellow square number one
(b) the medium yellow square which is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is below Block A. Block A contains a medium yellow square. Block B contains two medium black squares and a medium blue square. The arrangement in Block B is: medium yellow square, medium black square number two, medium black square number one, and then the medium blue square. Block C is to the left of Block B. Block C contains two medium yellow squares (number two above number one) and a medium blue square at the bottom. The arrangement in Block C is: medium yellow square number two, medium yellow square number one, and then the medium blue square. We are asked which square is above a medium blue square: medium yellow square number one (in Block C) or the medium yellow square (in Block A). Medium yellow square number one is above the medium blue square in Block C. The question asks what is above *a* medium blue square, not a specific one. Since medium yellow square number one is above a medium blue square (the one in Block C) and the medium yellow square in Block A is also above a medium blue square (the one in Block B), the answer is both.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{C}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain invents a specific vertical stacking order for the objects within Block B, which contradicts the fragmented and relative positional information provided in the source text. This invented structure leads to an incorrect intermediate conclusion about what is above the blue square in Block B.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The arrangement in Block B is: medium yellow square, medium black square number two, medium black square number one, and then the medium blue square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain invents a specific vertical arrangement for Block B that is not supported by the text. The text only specifies relative positions for some items in Block B, not a complete stack including all items mentioned in this sentence.
Answer Span:
The arrangement in Block B is: medium yellow square, medium black square number two, medium black square number one, and then the medium blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is below block A. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square and medium black square number two. This block also contains one medium blue square. The medium blue square is below medium black square number one and medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two is the medium yellow square.
Question #2115
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is below block B and it is above block C. Block A has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and a medi...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is below block B and it is above block C. Block A has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and a medium black square. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. Block B contains two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium blue square number two is below medium black square number two and medium black square number one. Below medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. Medium blue square number one is below the black object which is below medium black square number two. It is below the medium blue square number two. Block C contains one medium black square. Which object is below a medium black square? medium black square number one or the medium black square that is in block C?
(a) medium black square number one
(b) the medium black square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is below block B and it is above block C. Block A has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and a medium black square. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. Block B contains two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium blue square number two is below medium black square number two and medium black square number one. Below medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. Medium blue square number one is below the black object which is below medium black square number two. It is below the medium blue square number two. Block C contains one medium black square. Which object is below a medium black square? medium black square number one or the medium black square that is in block C?
(a) medium black square number one
(b) the medium black square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A is below Block B and above Block C. In Block A, the medium blue square number two is below the medium black square, and medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. Block B has medium blue square number one touching the bottom edge. Since Block C is below Block A and Block A has a medium black square, the object below the medium black square (in Block A) is the medium black square in Block C. Medium black square number one (in Block B) is below a medium black square (medium black square number two in Block B). Therefore, both medium black square number one and the medium black square in Block C are each below a medium black square. Thus, the answer is {C}.
\boxed{c}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes two significant factual errors regarding the contents and location of the black squares, leading to an unsupported conclusion about the relationship between medium black square number one and the black square in Block C.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since Block C is below Block A and Block A has a medium black square, the object below the medium black square (in Block A) is the medium black square in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly assumes Block A contains a medium black square. The context states Block A has two medium blue squares. Block C contains one medium black square, but the reasoning links it to a non-existent black square in Block A.
Answer Span:
Since Block C is below Block A and Block A has a medium black square, the object below the medium black square (in Block A) is the medium black square in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has two medium blue squares.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Medium black square number one (in Block B) is below a medium black square (medium black square number two in Block B).
Explanation
The reasoning claims medium black square number one is in Block B. The context states Block B contains two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares, but it does not specify where medium black square number one is located. The context only specifies the location of medium blue square number one (in Block B).
Answer Span:
Medium black square number one (in Block B) is below a medium black square (medium black square number two in Block B).
Reference/Question Span:
Block B contains two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares.
Question #2822
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. One medium blue square, a medium black square and a medium yellow square are in block A. Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. The me...
1 issue
Full Question
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. One medium blue square, a medium black square and a medium yellow square are in block A. Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square and the medium black square. Below block A is block B. It has three medium black squares. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number one. Below medium black square number three is medium black square number two. There is also one medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium black square number one is the medium yellow square. This object is below medium black square number two and medium black square number three. Which object is below a blue object? the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is in block A?
(a) the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are two blocks. Let's call them A and B. One medium blue square, a medium black square and a medium yellow square are in block A. Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square and the medium black square. Below block A is block B. It has three medium black squares. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number one. Below medium black square number three is medium black square number two. There is also one medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium black square number one is the medium yellow square. This object is below medium black square number two and medium black square number three. Which object is below a blue object? the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is in block A?
(a) the medium yellow square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer: In block A, we have a medium yellow square, a medium black square, and a medium blue square. According to and , the order from top to bottom is: medium yellow square, then medium black square, and finally medium blue square. Below block A is block B, which contains three medium black squares and a medium yellow square touching the bottom edge. Since the question asks what is below the blue object (medium blue square), and the blue square is in Block A, while Block B is below Block A, the object below the blue object must be in Block B. The only yellow square below the blue square in the entire setting is the one touching the bottom of Block B, which is the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of a block. Therefore, the answer is {a}. \boxed{a}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly determines the vertical stacking order within Block A, leading to a flawed justification for selecting the final answer, even though the final selection might coincidentally align with the correct answer based on other constraints.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
According to and , the order from top to bottom is: medium yellow square, then medium black square, and finally medium blue square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly establishes the vertical order within Block A. The context states: 'Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square and the medium black square.' This implies Yellow is on top, and both Black and Blue are below Yellow. The context does not explicitly state the order between the medium black square and the medium blue square, nor does it state the order is Yellow -> Black -> Blue.
Answer Span:
According to and , the order from top to bottom is: medium yellow square, then medium black square, and finally medium blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
One medium blue square, a medium black square and a medium yellow square are in block A. Below the medium yellow square is the medium black square. The medium blue square is below the medium yellow square and the medium black square.
Question #2116
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is below block B and it is above block C. Block A has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and a medi...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is below block B and it is above block C. Block A has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and a medium black square. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. Block B contains two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium blue square number two is below medium black square number two and medium black square number one. Below medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. Medium blue square number one is below the black object which is below medium black square number two. It is below the medium blue square number two. Block C contains one medium black square. Which object is below a medium blue square? medium black square number one or the medium black square that is in block C?
(a) medium black square number one
(b) the medium black square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is below block B and it is above block C. Block A has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and a medium black square. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. Block B contains two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium blue square number two is below medium black square number two and medium black square number one. Below medium black square number two there is medium black square number one. Medium blue square number one is below the black object which is below medium black square number two. It is below the medium blue square number two. Block C contains one medium black square. Which object is below a medium blue square? medium black square number one or the medium black square that is in block C?
(a) medium black square number one
(b) the medium black square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has two medium blue squares, with number two below a medium black square, and number one below square two. Block B (above A) has two medium blue squares and two medium black squares. Medium blue square number one in Block B is touching the bottom edge and is below black square number one, which is in turn below black square number two. Block C, below A, has one medium black square. Since we want what is below the medium blue squares, focusing on Block B, black square number one is below blue square number two. Block C and its black square are below Block A, which is below Block B. Therefore, the medium black square in Block C is not directly below a medium blue square. So only medium black square number one is directly below a blue square.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain misattributes and incorrectly summarizes the positional relationships of the blue squares in Block A and Block B, leading to an unsupported conclusion about which object is below a medium blue square.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block A has two medium blue squares, with number two below a medium black square, and number one below square two.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly attributes the description of the blue squares (number one below number two, and number two below a black square) to Block A. The context states these relationships apply to the two medium blue squares *in Block A* (which are described separately from the block contents description), but the reasoning chain mixes this description with the contents of Block B later on, and misrepresents the initial description of Block A's contents.
Answer Span:
Block A has two medium blue squares, with number two below a medium black square, and number one below square two.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two and a medium black square. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square.
contradictionhigh
Statement
Medium blue square number one in Block B is below black square number one, which is in turn below black square number two.
Explanation
The context states that in Block B, 'Medium blue square number one is below the black object which is below medium black square number two. It is below the medium blue square number two.' The reasoning chain incorrectly states that blue square number one is below black square number one, and that black square number one is below black square number two, which contradicts the complex positional information given for Block B's contents.
Answer Span:
Medium blue square number one in Block B is below black square number one, which is in turn below black square number two.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium blue square number one is below the black object which is below medium black square number two. It is below the medium blue square number two.
Question #631
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks B and A. Block A has two medium blue squares. A medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium blue square number one is touc...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks B and A. Block A has two medium blue squares. A medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square there is medium blue square number two. Below the medium yellow square and medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Block B contains two medium blue squares. It also has a medium black square. This object is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the square which is below medium blue square number two. This shape is below medium blue square number two. Block C has one medium black square. Which object is below a medium blue square? the medium black square which is in block B or the medium black square that is in block C?
(a) the medium black square which is in block B
(b) the medium black square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks B and A. Block A has two medium blue squares. A medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square there is medium blue square number two. Below the medium yellow square and medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Block B contains two medium blue squares. It also has a medium black square. This object is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the square which is below medium blue square number two. This shape is below medium blue square number two. Block C has one medium black square. Which object is below a medium blue square? the medium black square which is in block B or the medium black square that is in block C?
(a) the medium black square which is in block B
(b) the medium black square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has two medium blue squares and medium blue square number one touches the bottom edge. Block B also has two medium blue squares, with a medium black square below medium blue square number two and medium blue square number one touching the bottom edge. Block C is below both Block A and B and contains a medium black square. Because Block C is below Block B, the medium black square in C is below medium blue square number one in Block B. Also, since the medium black square in B is below medium blue square number two, both medium black squares are below a medium blue square. Therefore, the answer is {C}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the contents of the blocks but makes an unsupported logical leap regarding the spatial relationship between the black square in Block C and the contents of Block B. It also includes a fragmented quote from the context without proper integration into the argument flow.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Because Block C is below Block B, the medium black square in C is below medium blue square number one in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes a spatial relationship between the contents of Block C and Block B based only on the fact that Block C is physically below Block B. The context only states what is *in* Block C (one medium black square) and what is *in* Block B (two medium blue squares and one medium black square), but it does not establish that the black square in C is directly below any specific square in B.
Answer Span:
Because Block C is below Block B, the medium black square in C is below medium blue square number one in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C is below blocks B and A.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
This object is below medium blue square number two.
Explanation
The reasoning chain references 'This object is below medium blue square number two' which is a statement found in the context describing Block B, but it is not explicitly stated *which* object the reasoning chain is referring to here, leading to ambiguity and potential misapplication of the constraint. More critically, the context states: 'This object is below medium blue square number two. This shape is below the square which is below medium blue square number two. This shape is below medium blue square number two.' The reasoning chain seems to be trying to piece together these fragmented descriptions without clearly linking them to the black square in B.
Answer Span:
This object is below medium blue square number two.
Reference/Question Span:
This object is below medium blue square number two.
Question #2255
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this b...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. Below medium blue square number one , medium blue square number two and medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. Block B is to the right of block A. It has a medium black square. A medium yellow square is below the medium black square. Finally, there is block C. It is to the right of block B. It has a medium black square and a medium yellow square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Which object is to the left of a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or medium yellow square number two?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block C
(b) medium yellow square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. Below medium blue square number one , medium blue square number two and medium yellow square number two there is medium yellow square number one. Block B is to the right of block A. It has a medium black square. A medium yellow square is below the medium black square. Finally, there is block C. It is to the right of block B. It has a medium black square and a medium yellow square. The medium black square is below the medium yellow square. Which object is to the left of a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or medium yellow square number two?
(a) the medium yellow square that is in block C
(b) medium yellow square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block A contains two medium yellow squares (number one and number two) and two medium blue squares (number two above number one). Block B is to the right of Block A and contains a medium black square. Block C is to the right of Block B and contains a medium yellow square above a medium black square. We are looking for which object is to the left of a medium black square. Since Block A is to the left of Block B (which contains a medium black square), medium yellow square number two (which is in Block A) is to the left of the medium black square in Block B. The medium yellow square in Block C is not to the left of the medium black square; rather, it is in a block to the right of the medium black square. Therefore, only medium yellow square number two is to the left of the medium black square.
Final Answer: \boxed{b}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies that medium yellow square number two (in Block A) is to the left of the black square in Block B. However, it fails to fully analyze the spatial relationship concerning the black square *in Block C* when evaluating option (a), leading to an incomplete analysis, although the final conclusion matches the correct answer based on the black square in Block B.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionlow
Statement
Block A contains two medium yellow squares (number one and number two) and two medium blue squares (number two above number one).
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly states the vertical relationship between the blue squares. The context states: 'Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two.' This implies number two is above number one, but the reasoning states 'number two above number one' which is a correct inference, but it misses the crucial detail about the yellow squares' relative positions which is complex and necessary for full spatial reasoning.
Answer Span:
two medium blue squares (number two above number one)
Reference/Question Span:
Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two.
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block C is to the right of Block B and contains a medium yellow square above a medium black square.
Explanation
The context states for Block C: 'The medium black square is below the medium yellow square.' This means the yellow square is above the black square, which the reasoning correctly states. However, the reasoning then uses this structure to conclude the yellow square in C is NOT to the left of the black square in B, which is irrelevant to the question asked, which is 'Which object is to the left of *a* medium black square?' (implying any black square). The reasoning ignores the black square in C itself.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow square in Block C is not to the left of the medium black square; rather, it is in a block to the right of the medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the left of a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is in block C or medium yellow square number two?
Question #630
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks B and A. Block A has two medium blue squares. A medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium blue square number one is touc...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks B and A. Block A has two medium blue squares. A medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square there is medium blue square number two. Below the medium yellow square and medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Block B contains two medium blue squares. It also has a medium black square. This object is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the square which is below medium blue square number two. This shape is below medium blue square number two. Block C has one medium black square. Which object is below a medium blue square? the medium black square that is in block B or the medium black square that is in block C?
(a) the medium black square that is in block B
(b) the medium black square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks B and A. Block A has two medium blue squares. A medium yellow square is also in this block. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium yellow square there is medium blue square number two. Below the medium yellow square and medium blue square number two there is medium blue square number one. Block B contains two medium blue squares. It also has a medium black square. This object is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the square which is below medium blue square number two. This shape is below medium blue square number two. Block C has one medium black square. Which object is below a medium blue square? the medium black square that is in block B or the medium black square that is in block C? (a) the medium black square that is in block B (b) the medium black square that is in block C (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has medium blue squares and a medium yellow square. Medium blue square number one is at the bottom edge of Block A. Block B has two medium blue squares and a medium black square. The black square is below medium blue square number two in Block B. Medium blue square number one is at the bottom edge of Block B. Block C, which is below Blocks A and B, contains a medium black square.
We want to know which black square is below a medium blue square.
Since the medium black square in Block B is below medium blue square number two, and Block C (containing the other black square) is below Block B, the answer is the medium black square in Block B.
Because Block C is beneath Block B, the black square in C is below the blue squares in Block B, but not directly below any of them. The black square in Block B, however, is directly beneath a blue square in Block B.
\boxed{(a)}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the components but misinterprets the exact positional relationship of the black square in Block B relative to the blue squares, leading to a factual inaccuracy in the reasoning chain, although the final conclusion might still align with the intended answer based on the available facts.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionmedium
Statement
The black square is below medium blue square number two in Block B.
Explanation
The context states that the medium black square in Block B is below medium blue square number two, but it also states that 'This shape is below the square which is below medium blue square number two.' and 'This shape is below medium blue square number two.' The reasoning chain simplifies this to a direct 'below' relationship which is contradicted by the complex positional information given for the black square in B.
Answer Span:
The black square is below medium blue square number two in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
This object is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the square which is below medium blue square number two. This shape is below medium blue square number two.
Question #1490
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are two medium yellow squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two which is below a medium blue squ...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are two medium yellow squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two which is below a medium blue square. It also contains one medium black square. Below the medium blue square and medium yellow square number one there is the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium blue square. Then, there is block B with one medium yellow square in it. Finally, we have block C to the right of block A and to the left of block B. It contains a medium yellow square and a medium black square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is in block C or the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium black square that is in block C
(b) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are two medium yellow squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two which is below a medium blue square. It also contains one medium black square. Below the medium blue square and medium yellow square number one there is the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below the medium blue square. Then, there is block B with one medium yellow square in it. Finally, we have block Cto the right of block A and to the left of block B. It contains a medium yellow square and a medium black square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is in block C or the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block? (a) the medium black square that is in block C (b) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains two medium yellow squares (number one and number two), a medium blue square, and a medium black square. Block B contains a medium yellow square. Block C, which is to the right of Block A and to the left of Block B, contains a medium yellow square and a medium black square.
The question asks what is to the right of a medium yellow square. Since Block C is to the right of Block A, and Block C contains a medium black square, the medium black square in Block C is to the right of the medium yellow squares in Block A. The medium black square in Block A is not to the right of any medium yellow square. Therefore, the answer is {A}. \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the contents of the blocks and uses the spatial relationship between Block A and Block C to partially answer the question. However, it fails to analyze the internal structure of Block A, leading to an unsupported conclusion about the black square in Block A, which is necessary to fully evaluate option (b).
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The medium black square in Block A is not to the right of any medium yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning chain fails to establish the relative positions of the objects *within* Block A, which is crucial for determining if the medium black square in Block A is to the right of any medium yellow square. The context describes the vertical stacking in A (Y1 below Y2, Y2 below Blue, Black below Blue and Y1), but the reasoning ignores this internal structure when concluding the black square in A is not to the right of any yellow square.
Answer Span:
The medium black square in Block A is not to the right of any medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
There are two medium yellow squares in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two which is below a medium blue square. It also contains one medium black square. Below the medium blue square and medium yellow square number one there is the medium black square.
Question #3068
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks A and B. Block A contains one small yellow square. Block B contains a big blue triangle, one medium black circle and one medium y...
3 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks A and B. Block A contains one small yellow square. Block B contains a big blue triangle, one medium black circle and one medium yellow square. The medium black circle is to the right of a small black square and the medium yellow square. It is touching the right edge of this block. The small black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below and to the left of the medium yellow square. And block C contains one medium yellow triangle, a medium black circle and a small yellow square. To the left of and above the small yellow square is the medium black circle. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. Below the medium black circle is the medium yellow triangle. Which object is above a medium black circle? the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow triangle?
(a) the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is below blocks A and B. Block A contains one small yellow square. Block B contains a big blue triangle, one medium black circle and one medium yellow square. The medium black circle is to the right of a small black square and the medium yellow square. It is touching the right edge of this block. The small black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below and to the left of the medium yellow square. And block C contains one medium yellow triangle, a medium black circle and a small yellow square. To the left of and above the small yellow square is the medium black circle. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. Below the medium black circle is the medium yellow triangle. Which object is above a medium black circle? the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow triangle?
(a) the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C contains a medium yellow triangle, a medium black circle, and a small yellow square touching the right edge. The medium yellow triangle is below the medium black circle, and the small yellow square is also below and to the right of the medium black circle. Block B contains a medium black circle as well, and it sits above Block C. The small black square in Block B is touching the bottom edge, and it's to the left of the medium black circle. Since we're asked what's above the medium black circle in Block C, and Block B is above Block C, the shape above the medium black circle is the small black square. Since the small black square is the shape touching the bottom edge of Block B, the answer is {A}. The medium yellow triangle is below, not above, the medium black circle in Block C.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{A}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly tries to determine the answer by analyzing the spatial relationship between Block B and Block C, which is not required by the question structure. It misinterprets the question, which asks which of the two provided options (a shape touching the bottom edge OR the medium yellow triangle) is above *a* medium black circle (implying the one in Block C, as the options relate to Block C's contents or general properties). The reasoning incorrectly concludes the answer based on an object in Block B being above Block C.
Detected Issues (3)
contradictionlow
Statement
Block C contains a medium yellow triangle, a medium black circle, and a small yellow square touching the right edge.
Explanation
The context states the small yellow square in Block C is touching the right edge, but it incorrectly implies the medium yellow triangle and medium black circle are also part of this description, which is not explicitly stated as touching the edge.
Answer Span:
Block C contains a medium yellow triangle, a medium black circle, and a small yellow square touching the right edge.
Reference/Question Span:
And block C contains one medium yellow triangle, a medium black circle and a small yellow square. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block B contains a medium black circle as well, and it sits above Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning introduces a medium black circle in Block B, but the question only specifies Block B contains 'one big blue triangle, one medium black circle and one medium yellow square.' The reasoning then uses this assumed object location to determine what is above the medium black circle in Block C, which is irrelevant to the question asking about what is above the medium black circle *in general* (implied by the options referring to objects touching edges or the medium yellow triangle). Crucially, the reasoning jumps to concluding what is above the medium black circle in Block C based on Block B being above Block C, which is not the structure of the question's options.
Answer Span:
Block B contains a medium black circle as well, and it sits above Block C. The small black square in Block B is touching the bottom edge, and it's to the left of the medium black circle. Since we're asked what's above the medium black circle in Block C, and Block B is above Block C, the shape above the medium black circle is the small black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C contains one medium yellow triangle, a medium black circle and a small yellow square.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The small black square in Block B is touching the bottom edge, and it's to the left of the medium black circle.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly attributes the description of the small black square touching the bottom edge to Block B. The context states: 'The small black square is touching the bottom edge of this block' where 'this block' refers to the block containing the medium black circle and medium yellow square that the small black square is to the left of. This description is associated with Block B, but the reasoning uses this fact to justify the final answer based on option (a) 'the shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block', without confirming if this specific object is the one above the medium black circle in Block C (which it isn't, as Block B is above C). More importantly, the context states the small black square is *below and to the left* of the medium yellow square in Block B, and the medium black circle is *to the right* of the small black square in Block B. The reasoning uses the 'touching the bottom edge' fact to select option (a) without properly linking it to the question's required relationship (above a medium black circle).
Answer Span:
The small black square in Block B is touching the bottom edge, and it's to the left of the medium black circle. Since we're asked what's above the medium black circle in Block C, and Block B is above Block C, the shape above the medium black circle is the small black square. Since the small black square is the shape touching the bottom edge of Block B, the answer is {A}.
Reference/Question Span:
The small black square is touching the bottom edge of this block.
Question #299
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are a medium blue circle, one big yellow square and one medium black square in block A. Below the medium black square which is to the right of a bi...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are a medium blue circle, one big yellow square and one medium black square in block A. Below the medium black square which is to the right of a big blue square is the big yellow square. It is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is touching the left edge of this block.. The medium blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. It is above the big yellow square. It is below and to the right of the medium black square. Block B is below block A. It has a small black triangle and one small black square. To the right of the small black square there is the small black triangle. Finally, there is block C above block B. It has one small yellow square. It also has one medium blue triangle. The medium blue triangle is to the right of and below the small yellow square. Which object is below a small yellow square? the small black square or the medium blue triangle?
(a) the small black square
(b) the medium blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are a medium blue circle, one big yellow square and one medium black square in block A. Below the medium black square which is to the right of a big blue square is the big yellow square. It is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is touching the left edge of this block.. The medium blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. It is above the big yellow square. It is below and to the right of the medium black square. Block B is below block A. It has a small black triangle and one small black square. To the right of the small black square there is the small black triangle. Finally, there is block C above block B. It has one small yellow square. It also has one medium blue triangle. The medium blue triangle is to the right of and below the small yellow square. Which object is below a small yellow square? the small black square or the medium blue triangle?
(a) the small black square
(b) the medium blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a medium blue circle, a big yellow square, and a medium black square. Block B (below Block A) has a small black triangle and a small black square. Block C (above Block B) has a small yellow square and a medium blue triangle. The question asks what is below the small yellow square. Since Block C is above Block B, and the small yellow square is in Block C, anything below it must be in Block B. Block B contains the small black square and small black triangle. Thus, the small black square is below the small yellow square, while the medium blue triangle is in the same block (Block C) as the small yellow square but to its right and below. The medium blue triangle cannot be below the small yellow square.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the contents of the blocks and correctly deduces that anything below the small yellow square (in Block C) must be in Block B. However, it incorrectly dismisses the medium blue triangle as being below the small yellow square, contradicting the explicit positional information given in the context for those two objects within Block C.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The medium blue triangle cannot be below the small yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning concludes the medium blue triangle cannot be below the small yellow square based on its location relative to the small yellow square within Block C, but the question asks which object is below the small yellow square, implying a vertical relationship that might span blocks. The context states the medium blue triangle is to the right of and below the small yellow square, which means it is physically below it, even if in the same block.
Answer Span:
The medium blue triangle cannot be below the small yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
The medium blue triangle is to the right of and below the small yellow square.
Question #807
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and above block C. Block A contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below medium black sq...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and above block C. Block A contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. There is also a medium blue square in this block. It is below medium black square number two. Below the blue shape which is below medium black square number two is medium black square number one. Block B has a medium black square and a medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium blue square. It also contains one medium yellow square.. Below the medium blue square and the medium black square is the medium yellow square. And block C contains one medium blue square. Which object is below a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square that is in block C?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) the medium blue square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of block A and above block C. Block A contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. There is also a medium blue square in this block. It is below medium black square number two. Below the blue shape which is below medium black square number two is medium black square number one. Block B has a medium black square and a medium blue square. The medium black square is below the medium blue square. It also contains one medium yellow square.. Below the medium blue square and the medium black square is the medium yellow square. And block C contains one medium blue square. Which object is below a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square that is in block C?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) the medium blue square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B contains a medium black square, which is located below a medium blue square and above a medium yellow square. Block A also contains medium black squares. The question asks what is below a medium black square.
In Block A, the medium blue square is below medium black square number two. Block C's medium blue square is below Block B's medium black square since Block C is below Block B.
Therefore, the medium blue square in Block A and the medium blue square in Block C are both below a medium black square (in their respective blocks). The question is ambiguous about *which* black square, simply asking about what is below "a" black square.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{C}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsupported assumption about the vertical relationship between Block C and Block B, leading to an incorrect deduction about the location of Block C's blue square relative to Block B's black square. It also simplifies the positional information within Block A.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block C's medium blue square is below Block B's medium black square since Block C is below Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes Block C is below Block B, but the context only states Block B is to the left of A and above C. The relationship between Block C and Block B's contents is not established by stating C is below B.
Answer Span:
Block C's medium blue square is below Block B's medium black square since Block C is below Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the left of block A and above block C.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
In Block A, the medium blue square is below medium black square number two.
Explanation
The context states the blue square is below medium black square number two, but it also states that medium black square number one is below the blue square. The reasoning ignores the full positional relationship within Block A.
Answer Span:
In Block A, the medium blue square is below medium black square number two.
Reference/Question Span:
It is below medium black square number two. Below the blue shape which is below medium black square number two is medium black square number one.
Question #1627
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. There is also a medium blue square touching the bo...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two and medium yellow square number one is the medium blue square. Then, we have block B. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and a medium blue square. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square number two there is the medium blue square. To the right of both blocks A and B there is block C. It contains one medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium blue square? the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue square that is in block B?
(a) the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two and medium yellow square number one is the medium blue square. Then, we have block B. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and a medium blue square. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square number two there is the medium blue square. To the right of both blocks A and B there is block C. It contains one medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium blue square? the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue square that is in block B?
(a) the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains two medium yellow squares and a medium blue square touching the bottom edge. Block B contains two medium black squares and a medium blue square. Block C is to the right of both Block A and Block B and contains a medium blue square. Since Block C is to the right of Block B and Block A, the objects in Block A and Block B are to the left of the medium blue square in Block C. Therefore, both the medium blue square touching the bottom edge of Block A and the medium blue square in Block B are to the left of the medium blue square in Block C. Both and meet the condition.
Final Answer: \boxed{C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in each block and uses the spatial relationship (Block C being to the right of A and B) to deduce that objects in A and B are to the left of the blue square in C. The reasoning correctly addresses the question about which blue square has something to its left.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2579
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A contains a small black square, one big blue circle and one medium black square. The small black square is above and near to the medium black square ...
Clean
Full Question
There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A contains a small black square, one big blue circle and one medium black square. The small black square is above and near to the medium black square which is above, to the left of and near to a medium yellow square. The big blue circle is to the left of the medium yellow square. To the left of block A is block B. It has two small black circles. A big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a small yellow square. It also has one small black triangle and a medium blue circle. To the left of the medium blue circle is the small black triangle. Below the small yellow square there is the big yellow triangle. To the left of and below the small yellow square there is the small black triangle.. The medium blue circle is above small black circle number two. Which object is to the right of a small black circle? the medium black square or the big blue circle?
(a) the medium black square
(b) the big blue circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are two blocks. We call them A and B. Block A contains a small black square, one big blue circle and one medium black square. The small black square is above and near to the medium black square which is above, to the left of and near to a medium yellow square. The big blue circle is to the left of the medium yellow square. To the left of block A is block B. It has two small black circles. A big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This block also has a small yellow square. It also has one small black triangle and a medium blue circle. To the left of the medium blue circle is the small black triangle. Below the small yellow square there is the big yellow triangle. To the left of and below the small yellow square there is the small black triangle.. The medium blue circle is above small black circle number two. Which object is to the right of a small black circle? the medium black square or the big blue circle? (a) the medium black square (b) the big blue circle (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a small black square, a big blue circle, and a medium black square. Block B (to the left of Block A) contains two small black circles, a small black triangle, and a medium blue circle. The question asks what is to the right of a small black circle. Since Block A is to the right of Block B, and Block B contains small black circles, the objects in Block A are to the right of the small black circles. Block A contains both the big blue circle and the medium black square. Therefore, to the right of the small black circles are both the big blue circle and the medium black square.
Final Answer: \boxed{C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in Block A and Block B based on the context and logically deduces that objects in Block A are to the right of objects in Block B, which contains the small black circles. The conclusion that both listed objects are to the right is supported by the context.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #781
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is to the right of A. Block A has a big black circle. It also contains a small yellow triangle. The small yellow ...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is to the right of A. Block A has a big black circle. It also contains a small yellow triangle. The small yellow triangle is above and to the left of the big black circle. Block B has two big yellow triangles. It also contains a medium yellow circle. This block also has a big yellow circle. Big yellow triangle number one is touching the right edge of this block. Below a small black square there is big yellow triangle number two.. The medium yellow circle is to the right of and below the small black square. Far from and above the big yellow circle is big yellow triangle number one. It is to the right of big yellow triangle number two. And block C contains a medium blue triangle and a medium black circle. Below and to the left of the medium black circle there is the medium blue triangle. What is to the right of the small yellow triangle? a big yellow circle or a square?
(a) big yellow circle
(b) square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B and block B is to the right of A. Block A has a big black circle. It also contains a small yellow triangle. The small yellow triangle is above and to the left of the big black circle. Block B has two big yellow triangles. It also contains a medium yellow circle. This block also has a big yellow circle. Big yellow triangle number one is touching the right edge of this block. Below a small black square there is big yellow triangle number two. The medium yellow circle is to the right of and below the small black square. Far from and above the big yellow circle is big yellow triangle number one. It is to the right of big yellow triangle number two. And Block C contains a medium blue triangle and a medium black circle. Below and to the left of the medium black circle there is the medium blue triangle. What is to the right of the small yellow triangle? a big yellow circle or a square?
(a) big yellow circle
(b) square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block B is to the right of Block A. Block A contains the small yellow triangle. Block B contains the big yellow circle and a square (implied by the question). Since Block B is to the right of Block A, the objects in Block B are to the right of the small yellow triangle in Block A. Therefore, both the big yellow circle and the square are to the right of the small yellow triangle.
Final Answer: \boxed{C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsubstantiated claim that Block B contains a square, which is not supported by the context. It also relies on an oversimplification of block spatial relationships rather than using the specific positional data provided for the objects.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Block B contains the big yellow circle and a square (implied by the question).
Explanation
The reasoning chain claims Block B contains a square, but the context only lists the contents of Block B as: 'two big yellow triangles', 'a medium yellow circle', and 'a big yellow circle'. The square mentioned later ('Below a small black square there is big yellow triangle number two') is not explicitly stated to be *in* Block B, and the reasoning assumes its presence in B.
Answer Span:
Block B contains the big yellow circle and a square (implied by the question).
Reference/Question Span:
Block B has two big yellow triangles. It also contains a medium yellow circle. This block also has a big yellow circle.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Since Block B is to the right of Block A, the objects in Block B are to the right of the small yellow triangle in Block A.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes that because Block B is spatially to the right of Block A, *all* objects in B are to the right of *all* objects in A. The question asks about the relative position of the small yellow triangle (in A) to the big yellow circle (in B) or a square. The spatial relationship between blocks (C left of B, B right of A) only establishes the block order (A, B, C or C, A, B, etc., depending on the full arrangement), but it does not guarantee that every object in the right block is to the right of every object in the left block, especially since the triangle's specific location relative to the circle/square is not defined by block position alone. Crucially, the reasoning ignores the specific positional information given about the small yellow triangle.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is to the right of Block A, the objects in Block B are to the right of the small yellow triangle in Block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C is to the left of B and block B is to the right of A.
Question #404
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the right of B. Block B is above C. Block A contains a medium blue square. Block B contains a small yellow triangle. And block C contains one medium y...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the right of B. Block B is above C. Block A contains a medium blue square. Block B contains a small yellow triangle. And block C contains one medium yellow square, a big black triangle and a medium black triangle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and near to a small blue square is a medium blue square. This block also has a big blue triangle. The big black triangle is touching the right edge of this block. To the left of and below the medium black triangle is the medium yellow square. The medium blue square is touching the right edge of this block. To the left of the big black triangle is the medium yellow square. Which object is below a small yellow triangle? the medium blue square that is touching the right edge of a block or the medium blue square that is in block A?
(a) the medium blue square that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block A is to the right of B. Block B is above C. Block A contains a medium blue square. Block B contains a small yellow triangle. And block C contains one medium yellow square, a big black triangle and a medium black triangle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the right of and near to a small blue square is a medium blue square. This block also has a big blue triangle. The big black triangle is touching the right edge of this block. To the left of and below the medium black triangle is the medium yellow square. The medium blue square is touching the right edge of this block. To the left of the big black triangle is the medium yellow square. Which object is below a small yellow triangle? the medium blue square that is touching the right edge of a block or the medium blue square that is in block A?
(a) the medium blue square that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B contains a small yellow triangle. Block B is above Block C. Block C contains a medium yellow square, a big black triangle, and a medium black triangle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of Block C. The medium blue square is touching the right edge of a block (C). Block A is to the right of Block B, and contains a medium blue square.
Since we are looking for what is below the small yellow triangle in Block B, and Block C is below Block B, we are looking at objects in Block C. The objects below the small yellow triangle are the medium yellow square, the big black triangle, and the medium black triangle. The medium yellow square is the object directly beneath, but the other two are also beneath. The medium blue square is also in Block C, but it's to the right of the other objects, therefore partially under the small yellow triangle in Block B. Therefore, the medium blue square touching the right edge of Block C is also below the small yellow triangle. The medium blue square in Block A is not below the small yellow triangle because Block A is to the right of, not below, Block B.
The question asks what is below the small yellow triangle, the medium blue square touching the right edge of a block or the medium blue square in Block A. The correct answer is {A}.
\boxed{A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes multiple contradictory claims about the location of the medium blue square, incorrectly placing one in Block C when the context explicitly states it is in Block A. This fundamental error in locating the objects leads to flawed reasoning about what is below the small yellow triangle.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The medium blue square is touching the right edge of a block (C).
Explanation
The text states that the medium blue square is in Block A. It also states that 'The medium blue square is touching the right edge of this block' where 'this block' refers to the block containing the small blue square, which is not explicitly identified as C. Furthermore, the reasoning later assumes the medium blue square touching the right edge is in Block C, which contradicts the initial statement that the medium blue square is in Block A.
Answer Span:
The medium blue square is touching the right edge of a block (C).
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains a medium blue square.
contradictionhigh
Statement
The medium blue square is also in Block C, but it's to the right of the other objects, therefore partially under the small yellow triangle in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly places a medium blue square in Block C. The context states Block A contains the medium blue square, and Block B contains the small yellow triangle. The reasoning incorrectly assumes a medium blue square is in Block C.
Answer Span:
The medium blue square is also in Block C, but it's to the right of the other objects, therefore partially under the small yellow triangle in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains a medium blue square.
Question #941
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the right of and C is to the left of A. Block A has three medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number three which is below a med...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the right of and C is to the left of A. Block A has three medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number three which is below a medium black square there is medium blue square number one. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium blue square number two and the medium black square. Block B has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below medium blue square number two. Block C contains one medium blue square. There is also one medium black square in this block. Below the medium black square is the medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium blue square? medium blue square number three or the medium blue square that is in block C?
(a) medium blue square number three
(b) the medium blue square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block B is to the right of and C is to the left of A. Block A has three medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number three which is below a medium black square there is medium blue square number one. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium blue square number two and the medium black square. Block B has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below medium blue square number two. Block C contains one medium blue square. There is also one medium black square in this block. Below the medium black square is the medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium blue square? medium blue square number three or the medium blue square that is in block C?
(a) medium blue square number three
(b) the medium blue square that is in block C
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C is to the left of Block A, and Block B is to the right of Block A. Block A has three medium blue squares, with medium blue square number three at the top, and medium blue square number one at the bottom. Block B has two medium blue squares, and Block C has one medium blue square.
The question asks which object is to the left of a medium blue square. Specifically, it asks whether medium blue square number three (in Block A) or the medium blue square in Block C is to the left of a medium blue square.
Since Block C is to the left of Block A, any object in Block C (including the medium blue square) will be to the left of any object in Block A (including the medium blue squares). Thus, the medium blue square in Block C is to the left of the medium blue squares in Block A.
Medium blue square number three, which is inside Block A, cannot be to the left of any other medium blue square in Block A.
Therefore, only the medium blue square that is in Block C satisfies the condition.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{B}$
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative horizontal positions of the blocks (C left of A, B right of A) and uses this to answer the question about which object is to the left of another. However, it introduces an unsubstantiated vertical ordering for the blue squares within Block A, which is a minor hallucination regarding the internal structure of Block A.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block A has three medium blue squares, with medium blue square number three at the top, and medium blue square number one at the bottom.
Explanation
The reasoning chain makes an assumption about the vertical arrangement of the blue squares in Block A ('number three at the top, and number one at the bottom') which is not explicitly stated. The context only describes the relative vertical positions of squares 1, 2, and 3 based on what they are below, not their absolute top/bottom order relative to each other.
Answer Span:
Block A has three medium blue squares, with medium blue square number three at the top, and medium blue square number one at the bottom.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A has three medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number three which is below a medium black square there is medium blue square number one. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square.
Question #942
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the right of and C is to the left of A. Block A has three medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number three which is below a med...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the right of and C is to the left of A. Block A has three medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number three which is below a medium black square there is medium blue square number one. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium blue square number two and the medium black square. Block B has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below medium blue square number two. Block C contains one medium blue square. There is also one medium black square in this block. Below the medium black square is the medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium blue square? the medium blue square that is in block C or medium blue square number three?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block C
(b) medium blue square number three
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block B is to the right of and C is to the left of A. Block A has three medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number three which is below a medium black square there is medium blue square number one. Medium blue square number two is below the medium black square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below medium blue square number two and the medium black square. Block B has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below medium blue square number two. Block C contains one medium blue square. There is also one medium black square in this block. Below the medium black square is the medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium blue square? the medium blue square that is in block C or medium blue square number three?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block C
(b) medium blue square number three
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C is to the left of Block A, and Block B is to the right of Block A. Block C contains a medium blue square, and Block A contains three medium blue squares, including medium blue square number three. Since Block C is to the left of Block A, the medium blue square in Block C is to the left of all the medium blue squares in Block A, including medium blue square number three. Therefore, the medium blue square in Block C is to the left of a medium blue square (specifically, any of the ones in Block A). Medium blue square number three is in Block A, so it cannot be to the left of a medium blue square in Block A. Thus, only the medium blue square that is in Block C meets the criteria.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly establishes the relative positions of the blocks (C left of A, B right of A) and uses this to answer the question about which blue square is to the left of another blue square. No contradictions or missing context were found.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1336
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Blocks B and C are below A. Block A contains a medium blue square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Blocks B and C are below A. Block A contains a medium blue square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below a medium black square. Block B contains two medium blue squares. It also contains a medium black square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium black square there is medium blue square number two. Below medium blue square number two and the medium black square there is medium blue square number one. And block C has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square. Below the medium yellow square is medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is below the medium black square number two. Which object is below a yellow shape? the medium black square that is in block A or medium black square number two?
(a) the medium black square that is in block A
(b) medium black square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B, and C. Blocks B and C are below A. Block A contains a medium blue square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below a medium black square. Block B contains two medium blue squares. It also contains a medium black square. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium black square there is medium blue square number two. Below medium blue square number two and the medium black square there is medium blue square number one. And block C has two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square. Below the medium yellow square is medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is below the medium black square number two. Which object is below a yellow shape? the medium black square that is in block A or medium black square number two?
(a) the medium black square that is in block A
(b) medium black square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C contains a medium yellow square and two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below the medium yellow square, and medium black square number two is also below the medium yellow square (fact11 and fact13 contradict, so focusing on fact 13 which relates to the question). The question asks what is below a yellow shape. In Block C, medium black square number two is below the medium yellow square. The medium black square in Block A is not below any yellow shape. Therefore, the answer is medium black square number two.
Final Answer: \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly states that Block C contains a medium yellow square, which contradicts the context that only lists two medium black squares for Block C. This initial error leads to flawed reasoning about the location of the yellow shape relative to the blocks.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block C contains a medium yellow square and two medium black squares.
Explanation
The context states Block C has two medium black squares, but it does not state it contains a medium yellow square. The yellow square is stated to be *above* medium black square number one.
Answer Span:
Block C contains a medium yellow square and two medium black squares.
Reference/Question Span:
And block C has two medium black squares.
contradictionmedium
Statement
Medium black square number one is below the medium yellow square, and medium black square number two is also below the medium yellow square
Explanation
The context states: 'Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square. Below the medium yellow square is medium black square number two.' This implies both are below the yellow square, but the reasoning chain incorrectly implies the yellow square is *in* Block C, and the statement about medium black square number two being below the yellow square is a restatement/interpretation, but the initial premise about Block C contents is false.
Answer Span:
Medium black square number one is below the medium yellow square, and medium black square number two is also below the medium yellow square
Reference/Question Span:
Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square. Below the medium yellow square is medium black square number two.
Question #1477
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. It also contains a medium black square. This object is below medium yellow square number two. Below medium ...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. It also contains a medium black square. This object is below medium yellow square number two. Below medium yellow square number two and the medium black square there is medium yellow square number one. To the left of block A we have block B which contains one medium blue square. Finally, we have block C which is below block A. It has two medium black squares. This block also contains one medium blue square. It is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. This shape is below medium black square number two. Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block A?
(a) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium black square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. It also contains a medium black square. This object is below medium yellow square number two. Below medium yellow square number two and the medium black square there is medium yellow square number one. To the left of block A we have block B which contains one medium blue square. Finally, we have block C which is below block A. It has two medium black squares. This block also contains one medium blue square. It is below medium black square number two. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. This shape is below medium black square number two. Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium black square that is in block A? (a) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block (b) the medium black square that is in block A (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block B is to the left of Block A and contains a medium blue square. Block A contains a medium black square. Block C, which is below Block A, contains a medium blue square and two medium black squares, with one touching the bottom edge.
Since Block A is to the right of Block B (which contains a medium blue square), the medium black square in Block A is to the right of the medium blue square in Block B. Block C is below Block A, so the medium black squares in Block C are not to the right of the medium blue square in Block B.
Therefore, only the medium black square in Block A is to the right of the medium blue square in Block B.
Final Answer: \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions based on the context to answer the question about which object is to the right of a medium blue square.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #83
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains one medium black square. To the right of block A is block B. It contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the b...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains one medium black square. To the right of block A is block B. It contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below a medium blue square. Below the medium blue square and medium yellow square number two is medium yellow square number one. To the right of block A there is block C. It has a medium black square and one medium yellow square. This block also contains one medium blue square. This shape is below the medium yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square. Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium yellow square number two?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium yellow square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains one medium black square. To the right of block A is block B. It contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium yellow square number two is below a medium blue square. Below the medium blue square and medium yellow square number two is medium yellow square number one. To the right of block A there is block C. It has a medium black square and one medium yellow square. This block also contains one medium blue square. This shape is below the medium yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium yellow square and the medium blue square. Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium yellow square number two?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium yellow square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block A contains a medium black square. Block B is to the right of Block A and contains two medium yellow squares: medium yellow square number one (touching the bottom edge) and medium yellow square number two (below a medium blue square). Block C is also to the right of Block A and contains a medium black square, a medium yellow square, and a medium blue square. Since the question asks what is to the right of a medium black square, and Block A contains a medium black square, we are looking at the contents of blocks to the right of Block A. This includes Block B (stated as being to the right of A) and Block C (also stated to be to the right of A).
Medium yellow square number one is in Block B and is touching the bottom edge. Medium yellow square number two is also in Block B. Since both Block B and Block C are to the right of Block A (which contains a medium black square), both medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two are to the right of a medium black square.
Final Answer: \boxed{C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the contents of the blocks but fails to correctly analyze the spatial relationship required by the question. It incorrectly concludes that both options must be correct based only on their location relative to Block A's black square, ignoring the specific constraints and the presence of another black square in Block C, which is crucial for determining the correct answer among the choices provided.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since both Block B and Block C are to the right of Block A (which contains a medium black square), both medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two are to the right of a medium black square.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly assumes that because Block B and Block C are to the right of Block A (which has a black square), *all* contents of B and C are to the right of *a* black square. It fails to check the location relative to the black square in Block C, or if the question implies the black square in A is the reference point for all subsequent checks. More critically, it ignores the specific contents and locations within Block C, which also contains a medium black square, and the question asks which object is to the right of *a* medium black square (implying we must check the context around *any* black square mentioned). The reasoning only focuses on the black square in A.
Answer Span:
both medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two are to the right of a medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium black square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium yellow square number two?
Question #298
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are a medium blue circle, one big yellow square and one medium black square in block A. Below the medium black square which is to the right of a bi...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are a medium blue circle, one big yellow square and one medium black square in block A. Below the medium black square which is to the right of a big blue square is the big yellow square. It is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is touching the left edge of this block.. The medium blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. It is above the big yellow square. It is below and to the right of the medium black square. Block B is below block A. It has a small black triangle and one small black square. To the right of the small black square there is the small black triangle. Finally, there is block C above block B. It has one small yellow square. It also has one medium blue triangle. The medium blue triangle is to the right of and below the small yellow square. What is to the right of the small yellow square? a medium blue triangle or a small black square?
(a) medium blue triangle
(b) small black square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are a medium blue circle, one big yellow square and one medium black square in block A. Below the medium black square which is to the right of a big blue square is the big yellow square. It is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue square is touching the left edge of this block.. The medium blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. It is above the big yellow square. It is below and to the right of the medium black square. Block B is below block A. It has a small black triangle and one small black square. To the right of the small black square there is the small black triangle. Finally, there is block C above block B. It has one small yellow square. It also has one medium blue triangle. The medium blue triangle is to the right of and below the small yellow square. What is to the right of the small yellow square? a medium blue triangle or a small black square?
(a) medium blue triangle
(b) small black square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C is above Block B, and Block B is below Block A. Block C contains a small yellow square and a medium blue triangle. Block B contains a small black square and a small black triangle. The medium blue triangle is to the right of the small yellow square in Block C. The small black triangle is to the right of the small black square in Block B. Since the question asks what is to the right of the small yellow square (which is in Block C), and we know the medium blue triangle is to its right, the answer is medium blue triangle. The small black square is in Block B, a different block.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the relevant information from Block C to answer the question. It correctly states that the medium blue triangle is to the right of the small yellow square. The final boxed answer uses 'A' which is not explicitly defined in the options (a, b, c, d), but it aligns with option (a). No factual contradictions or missing context regarding the spatial relationships were found in the derivation steps.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionlow
Statement
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Explanation
The reasoning correctly identifies that the medium blue triangle is to the right of the small yellow square. The options provided in the question are (a) medium blue triangle, (b) small black square, (c) both of them, (d) none of them. The final answer box 'A' corresponds to option (a), which is correct based on the reasoning, but the reasoning chain itself concludes the answer is 'medium blue triangle', which corresponds to option (a). However, the final boxed answer 'A' is not one of the options listed in the question text (a, b, c, d). Since the reasoning chain correctly identifies the object, but the final boxed answer uses an external label 'A' instead of the provided option labels, this is flagged as a contradiction against the expected format/options, although the reasoning points to the correct choice (a). Given the strict instruction not to flag final answers/conclusions, I will re-evaluate. The reasoning chain *concludes* the answer is 'medium blue triangle'. The final boxed answer is '\boxed{A}'. Since the question lists options (a), (b), (c), (d), and the reasoning supports (a), boxing 'A' is an external label, but it's the conclusion. I will check if the reasoning chain itself contains a factual error relative to the context.
Answer Span:
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Reference/Question Span:
(a) medium blue triangle
(b) small black square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Question #1221
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A is above B. Block A contains a medium black square. A medium blue square is also in this block. The medium black square is touching the bottom edg...
2 issues
Full Question
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A is above B. Block A contains a medium black square. A medium blue square is also in this block. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square. Block B contains two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares. Below medium blue square number two is medium blue square number one. Below medium black square number two and medium blue square number two there is medium black square number one. Medium black square number two is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium black square number two. Which object is below a medium blue square? the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue square that is in block A?
(a) the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are two blocks. Let's call them A and B. Block A is above B. Block A contains a medium black square. A medium blue square is also in this block. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square. Block B contains two medium blue squares and two other medium black squares. Below medium blue square number two is medium blue square number one. Below medium black square number two and medium blue square number two there is medium black square number one. Medium black square number two is below medium blue square number two. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium black square number two. Which object is below a medium blue square? the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue square that is in block A? (a) the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block (b) the medium blue square that is in block A (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a medium blue square and a medium black square, with the black square below the blue square and touching the bottom edge. Block B (below Block A) has two medium blue squares (number one and number two) and two medium black squares. Medium blue square number one is at the bottom of Block B.
The question asks what is below a medium blue square.
In Block A, the medium black square is below the medium blue square. This corresponds to option (b).
In Block B, medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. This corresponds to option (a).
Since both scenarios are represented, the answer is {C}.
\boxed{C}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies that both options (a) and (b) are satisfied by objects in the blocks, leading to the correct final conclusion (C). However, the intermediate steps contain factual inaccuracies regarding the specific relationships and constraints described in the context, particularly concerning Block A's contents and the justification for option (a) based on Block B's contents.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block A contains a medium blue square and a medium black square, with the black square below the blue square and touching the bottom edge.
Explanation
The context states that Block A contains a medium black square and a medium blue square. It specifies that the medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block, and that 'This shape [the black square] is below the medium blue square.' The reasoning incorrectly states the black square is touching the bottom edge AND is below the blue square, but it misses the crucial detail about which shape is touching the bottom edge and the exact relationship.
Answer Span:
Block A contains a medium blue square and a medium black square, with the black square below the blue square and touching the bottom edge.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains a medium black square. A medium blue square is also in this block. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is below the medium blue square.
contradictionhigh
Statement
In Block B, medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two.
Explanation
The context states: 'Below medium blue square number two is medium blue square number one.' The reasoning reverses this relationship, stating number one is below number two, which is correct, but then it incorrectly links this to option (a) based on the description of option (a). Option (a) refers to 'the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block'. The context states 'Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block [Block B].' The reasoning incorrectly implies that the fact that MB1 is below MB2 satisfies the condition for option (a), which is about touching the bottom edge.
Answer Span:
In Block B, medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. This corresponds to option (a).
Reference/Question Span:
Below medium blue square number two is medium blue square number one. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block.
Question #3041
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of C. Block C is to the left of A. Block A has three medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below medium ye...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of C. Block C is to the left of A. Block A has three medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two and a medium black square. Medium yellow square number two is below medium yellow square number three and the medium black square. The medium black square is below medium yellow square number three. Block B contains one medium blue square. And block C has a medium blue square and a medium black square. There is also one medium yellow square in this block. This shape is below the medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square and the medium black square. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is in block C or the medium black square that is in block A?
(a) the medium black square that is in block C
(b) the medium black square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B and C. Block B is to the left of C. Block C is to the left of A. Block A has three medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two and a medium black square. Medium yellow square number two is below medium yellow square number three and the medium black square. The medium black square is below medium yellow square number three. Block B contains one medium blue square. And block C has a medium blue square and a medium black square. There is also one medium yellow square in this block. This shape is below the medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square and the medium black square. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is in block C or the medium black square that is in block A? (a) the medium black square that is in block C (b) the medium black square that is in block A (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
We have three blocks, B, C, and A arranged from left to right (B left of C, and C left of A). Block C contains a medium yellow square, a medium black square above it, and a medium blue square at the bottom. Since the medium black square is in the same block C as the medium yellow square, and the medium black square is above the medium yellow square, it cannot be to the left of the medium yellow square. The medium black square in Block A is also not to the left of the medium yellow square in block C. The answer is \boxed{D}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes unsupported assumptions about the contents and arrangement within Block C and incorrectly uses vertical positioning to dismiss the possibility of horizontal adjacency, failing to properly analyze the horizontal layout (B-C-A) relative to the objects mentioned in the question.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block C contains a medium yellow square, a medium black square above it, and a medium blue square at the bottom.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly assumes the relative vertical positions of the squares within Block C based on the general description of Block C's contents, ignoring the specific positional information given for the yellow square in C.
Answer Span:
Block C contains a medium yellow square, a medium black square above it, and a medium blue square at the bottom.
Reference/Question Span:
And block C has a medium blue square and a medium black square. There is also one medium yellow square in this block. This shape is below the medium black square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since the medium black square is in the same block C as the medium yellow square, and the medium black square is above the medium yellow square, it cannot be to the left of the medium yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly concludes the spatial relationship (left/right) based on the vertical relationship (above/below) within Block C, and it ignores the actual question which asks about the horizontal relationship between the *objects* (the black squares in A or C) and *a* medium yellow square (which could be the one in C or the three in A). The reasoning focuses only on the black square in C relative to the yellow square in C, which is not sufficient to answer the question.
Answer Span:
Since the medium black square is in the same block C as the medium yellow square, and the medium black square is above the medium yellow square, it cannot be to the left of the medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is in block C or the medium black square that is in block A?
Question #3119
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. There are one big yellow triangle, one big black circle and one medium black triangle in block A. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of t...
1 issue
Full Question
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. There are one big yellow triangle, one big black circle and one medium black triangle in block A. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. A big black square is touching the right edge of this block. To the right of the big black circle and the medium black triangle there is the big yellow triangle. The big black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is far from, to the left of and below the big black square. Above block A there is block B. It contains one medium yellow circle and a small black circle. It also contains one big blue triangle. The big blue triangle is to the right of and below the medium yellow circle which is to the right of the small black circle. What is to the right of the small object? a medium black triangle or a big blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium black triangle
(b) big blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are two blocks. Let's call them A and B. There are one big yellow triangle, one big black circle and one medium black triangle in block A. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. A big black square is touching the right edge of this block. To the right of the big black circle and the medium black triangle there is the big yellow triangle. The big black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is far from, to the left of and below the big black square. Above block A there is block B. It contains one medium yellow circle and a small black circle. It also contains one big blue triangle. The big blue triangle is to the right of and below the medium yellow circle which is to the right of the small black circle. What is to the right of the small object? a medium black triangle or a big blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium black triangle
(b) big blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a big yellow triangle, a big black circle, and a medium black triangle. Block B, which is above Block A, contains a small black circle, a medium yellow circle, and a big blue triangle. The big blue triangle is to the right of the small black circle. Since we are looking for what is to the right of the small black circle (the small object), and the big blue triangle is to its right, the answer is the big blue triangle. The medium black triangle is in Block A, not Block B, so it's not to the right of the small black circle.
The question mentions "big blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block", but there's no information stating the big blue triangle touches the bottom edge. The big yellow triangle in Block A touches the bottom edge, and the big black circle touches the bottom edge of Block A.
Therefore, the answer is a big blue triangle.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{B}$
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the contents of the blocks. It correctly identifies that the big blue triangle is to the right of the small black circle. However, it makes an assumption about what 'the small object' refers to in the final question and fails to properly evaluate option (b) against the context (specifically, whether the big blue triangle touches the bottom edge of a block, which is part of option (b) but not stated in the context for the big blue triangle).
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The big blue triangle is to the right of the small black circle. Since we are looking for what is to the right of the small black circle (the small object), and the big blue triangle is to its right, the answer is the big blue triangle.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes 'the small object' refers to the 'small black circle' without checking if any other object fits the description 'small object'. The question asks what is to the right of 'the small object', and option (b) refers to a 'big blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block'. The reasoning chain fails to check if the 'small black circle' is the only 'small object' or if the question implies the object being asked about is the one described in option (b). More critically, the reasoning chain incorrectly assumes the question is asking what is to the right of the small black circle, when the question asks what is to the right of 'the small object'. The reasoning chain then uses the relationship between the big blue triangle and the small black circle to conclude the answer, ignoring the structure of the final question.
Answer Span:
Since we are looking for what is to the right of the small black circle (the small object), and the big blue triangle is to its right, the answer is the big blue triangle.
Reference/Question Span:
What is to the right of the small object? a medium black triangle or a big blue triangle which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #1495
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are three medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are three medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below medium black square number three. Below medium black square number two and medium black square number three is medium black square number one. Above block A is block B. It contains one medium blue square and one medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium black square. Finally, there is block C. It is above block B. It has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium black square which is in block B or the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium black square which is in block B
(b) the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are three medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Medium black square number two is below medium black square number three. Below medium black square number two and medium black square number three is medium black square number one. Above block A is block B. It contains one medium blue square and one medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium black square. Finally, there is block C. It is above block B. It has two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the medium black square which is in block B or the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium black square which is in block B
(b) the medium black square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C is above Block B, and Block B is above Block A. Block B contains a medium black square and a medium blue square. Block A contains three medium black squares, with medium black square number one touching the bottom edge. Since Block C (containing medium yellow squares) is above Block B, the object directly below the medium yellow squares is the medium black square in Block B. Therefore, the medium black square in Block B is below the yellow square. The medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block A is not directly below a yellow square.
The answer is \boxed{A}.
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the blocks and determines which object is below the medium yellow squares based on the provided context.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #920
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are one medium yellow circle and a big blue circle in block A. This block also contains one medium blue triangle. This shape is above, to the rig...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are one medium yellow circle and a big blue circle in block A. This block also contains one medium blue triangle. This shape is above, to the right of and far from the big blue circle. To the left of block A we have block B. It contains one small black square and one medium yellow square. Above the medium yellow square there is the small black square. Finally, there is block C to the left of block B. It has two small blue squares. It also has a medium black triangle. It is below small blue square number two. Small blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of and below small blue square number two. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? the triangle that is touching the right edge of a block or the square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the triangle that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are one medium yellow circle and a big blue circle in block A. This block also contains one medium blue triangle. This shape is above, to the right of and far from the big blue circle. To the left of block A we have block B. It contains one small black square and one medium yellow square. Above the medium yellow square there is the small black square. Finally, there is block Cto the left of block B. It has two small blue squares. It also has a medium black triangle. It is below small blue square number two. Small blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is to the right of and below small blue square number two. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow square? the triangle that is touching the right edge of a block or the square that is touching the bottom edge of a block? (a) the triangle that is touching the right edge of a block (b) the square that is touching the bottom edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a medium yellow circle, a big blue circle, and a medium blue triangle. Block B (which is to the left of Block A) contains a medium yellow square and a small black square. Block C (to the left of Block B) contains two small blue squares and a medium black triangle. Small blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of Block C. Since Block C is to the left of Block B, and small blue square number one is in Block C, small blue square number one is to the left of the medium yellow square in Block B. The medium blue triangle is in Block A, which is not to the left of Block B. Therefore, only the square touching the bottom edge is to the left of the medium yellow square.
Final Answer: \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the contents and relative positions of the blocks and uses this information to evaluate the two options provided in the question. No contradictions or missing context were found.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1280
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains one medium blue square and one medium yellow square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the med...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains one medium blue square and one medium yellow square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium yellow square. Block B is to the right of block A. It contains one medium blue square. A medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. Finally, there is block C. It is below block B. It has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium blue square number two and a medium black square there is medium blue square number one. The medium black square is below medium blue square number two. Which object is above a medium blue square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is in block A?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block A contains one medium blue square and one medium yellow square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below the medium yellow square. Block B is to the right of block A. It contains one medium blue square. A medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. Finally, there is block C. It is below block B. It has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium blue square number two and a medium black square there is medium blue square number one. The medium black square is below medium blue square number two. Which object is above a medium blue square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is in block A?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
In Block A, the medium yellow square is above the medium blue square. So, the medium yellow square in Block A is above a medium blue square.
In Block B (to the right of Block A), the medium blue square has a medium yellow squarebelow it, not above it. So, the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of Block B is not above a medium blue square.
In Block C, which is below Block B, the medium blue squares have a medium black square below them. There's no mention of a yellow square above a blue square in Block C.
The question asks which medium yellow square is above a medium blue square: the one in Block A or the one in Block B. The medium yellow square in Block A is indeed above a medium blue square.The medium yellow square in Block B, however, is below a medium blue square.
Therefore, the answer is \boxed{B}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the relationship in Block A but completely misinterprets or ignores the description of Block B's contents and spatial arrangement, leading to an incorrect elimination of one of the options and the final answer.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
In Block B (to the right of Block A), the medium blue square has a medium yellow square below it, not above it. So, the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of Block B is not above a medium blue square.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly assumes Block B contains a medium yellow square. The context only states Block B contains one medium blue square and a medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block, which is below the medium blue square. The reasoning ignores the specific description of Block B's contents and spatial relationship.
Answer Span:
In Block B (to the right of Block A), the medium blue square has a medium yellow square below it, not above it. So, the medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of Block B is not above a medium blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the right of block A. It contains one medium blue square. A medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The medium yellow square in Block A is indeed above a medium blue square. The medium yellow square in Block B, however, is below a medium blue square.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly concludes that the medium yellow square in Block B is below a medium blue square, which contradicts the context that Block B only has one medium blue square and the yellow square is below that blue square. The reasoning then uses this flawed premise to eliminate option (a) in the final step, leading to the wrong conclusion.
Answer Span:
The medium yellow square in Block A is indeed above a medium blue square. The medium yellow square in Block B, however, is below a medium blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the right of block A. It contains one medium blue square. A medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square.
Question #278
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square. Above block A we have block B which contains two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square nu...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has a medium blue square. Above block A we have block B which contains two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. Below the square which is below medium blue square number two there is a medium black square. Below medium blue square number two is a medium yellow square.. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium blue square number two and the medium yellow square. Finally, we have block C below block B. It has one medium yellow square and one medium blue square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. Which object is above a medium blue square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is in block B?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Block A has a medium blue square. Above block A we have block B which contains two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. Below the square which is below medium blue square number two there is a medium black square. Below medium blue square number two is a medium yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium blue square number two and the medium yellow square. Finally, we have block C below block B. It has one medium yellow square and one medium blue square. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium blue square. Which object is above a medium blue square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium yellow square that is in block B?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow square that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has a medium blue square. Block B is above Block A and contains two medium blue squares, with number two above number one. A medium yellow square is below medium blue square number two in Block B. Block C is below Block B and has a medium yellow square and a medium blue square, with the medium yellow square below the medium blue square. We are looking for an object that is above a medium blue square. In Block C, the medium yellow square is below the medium blue square, so it cannot be above it. In Block B, the medium yellow square is below medium blue square number two, so it also cannot be above it. Therefore, neither of the given options is above a medium blue square.
Final Answer: \boxed{D}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsupported assumption that a medium yellow square exists within Block B, which contradicts the explicit description of Block B's contents (only two medium blue squares). This leads to an incorrect evaluation of option (b).
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
A medium yellow square is below medium blue square number two in Block B.
Explanation
The text states that below medium blue square number two is a medium yellow square, but it does not explicitly state this yellow square is *in Block B*. The reasoning chain assumes this location, which is not confirmed.
Answer Span:
A medium yellow square is below medium blue square number two in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Below medium blue square number two is a medium yellow square..
missing_contexthigh
Statement
In Block B, the medium yellow square is below medium blue square number two, so it also cannot be above it.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly assumes there is a medium yellow square *in Block B* that is below medium blue square number two. The context only mentions two medium blue squares in Block B, and a medium yellow square below medium blue square number two, but it never places that yellow square *in Block B*. Furthermore, the question asks about 'the medium yellow square that is in block B' as an option, but the context does not confirm the existence or location of a yellow square *in Block B*.
Answer Span:
In Block B, the medium yellow square is below medium blue square number two, so it also cannot be above it.
Reference/Question Span:
Above block A we have block B which contains two medium blue squares.
Question #1281
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A contains one medium black triangle. This block also has one small black triangle. Near to and above the small black triangle is the medium black t...
Clean
Full Question
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A contains one medium black triangle. This block also has one small black triangle. Near to and above the small black triangle is the medium black triangle. Block B is below block A. It contains one small blue triangle, one big black square and a medium blue square. This block also has a medium black triangle. The medium blue square is touching the right edge of this block. It is below and to the right of the medium black triangle. The big black square is below the medium black triangle. It is to the left of the medium object which is below the medium black triangle. To the left of the medium blue square is the small blue triangle. The big black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Which object is below a small black triangle? the medium black triangle that is in block A or the medium black triangle that is in block B?
(a) the medium black triangle that is in block A
(b) the medium black triangle that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are two blocks. Let's call them A and B. Block A contains one medium black triangle. This block also has one small black triangle. Near to and above the small black triangle is the medium black triangle. Block B is below block A. It contains one small blue triangle, one big black square and a medium blue square. This block also has a medium black triangle. The medium blue square is touching the right edge of this block. It is below and to the right of the medium black triangle. The big black square is below the medium black triangle. It is to the left of the medium object which is below the medium black triangle. To the left of the medium blue square is the small blue triangle. The big black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Which object is below a small black triangle? the medium black triangle that is in block A or the medium black triangle that is in block B?
(a) the medium black triangle that is in block A
(b) the medium black triangle that is in block B
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a medium black triangle which is above a small black triangle. Block B is below Block A. Block B contains a medium black triangle, a small blue triangle, a big black square, and a medium blue square. Since Block B is below Block A, the objects in Block B are below the objects in Block A. Thus, the medium black triangle in Block B is below the small black triangle in Block A. The medium black triangle in Block A is above the small black triangle, not below it. Therefore, the answer is {B}. \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions based on the block structure and the specific spatial relationship given for the objects within Block A.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1835
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the right of C. Block C is below B. Block A has a medium blue square. It also has one medium yellow square. Below the medium blue square there is the me...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the right of C. Block C is below B. Block A has a medium blue square. It also has one medium yellow square. Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square. Block B contains a medium yellow square. Block C contains two medium blue squares and two other medium yellow squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium blue square number two. Below medium yellow square number two is medium yellow square number one.. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two , medium yellow square number two and medium yellow square number one. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is to the right of C. Block C is below B. Block A has a medium blue square. It also has one medium yellow square. Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square. Block B contains a medium yellow square. Block C contains two medium blue squares and two other medium yellow squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two there is medium blue square number two. Below medium yellow square number two is medium yellow square number one.. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two , medium yellow square number two and medium yellow square number one. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block? (a) the medium blue square that is in block A (b) the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has a medium blue square and a medium yellow square. The yellow square is below the blue square. Block C has two medium blue squares and two medium yellow squares. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of Block C. Block A is to the right of Block C. So the medium blue square in Block A is to the right of the medium yellow squares in Block C. The answer is {A}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies some facts about the blocks but makes an unsupported leap in establishing the horizontal relationship required to answer the question, leading to a high-severity missing context error regarding the relative positioning needed for the final conclusion.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
So the medium blue square in Block A is to the right of the medium yellow squares in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning concludes that the medium blue square in Block A is to the right of the medium yellow squares in Block C based only on the fact that Block A is to the right of Block C. The question asks which object is to the right of *a* medium yellow square. The reasoning fails to establish the relative horizontal position between the medium blue square in A and *any* specific medium yellow square, especially those in C, which are only known to be below other elements within C, not necessarily horizontally aligned with A's contents in a way that satisfies the question.
Answer Span:
So the medium blue square in Block A is to the right of the medium yellow squares in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square?
Question #3587
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is above C and block C is below B. Block A contains two small yellow triangles. Small yellow triangle number one is to the left of small yellow triangle numbe...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is above C and block C is below B. Block A contains two small yellow triangles. Small yellow triangle number one is to the left of small yellow triangle number two and a big black triangle. Above and near to small yellow triangle number two is the big black triangle. Block B contains a medium black square. And block C contains two small blue triangles. This block also contains a big black triangle. It is far from, below and to the right of small blue triangle number one. This block also has a small black square. A medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Small blue triangle number two is touching the left edge of this block. There is also one medium blue square in this block. The medium black triangle is to the left of the medium blue square. It is below small blue triangle number one. What is below the medium black square? a medium blue square or a small black square?
(a) medium blue square
(b) small black square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A is above C and block C is below B. Block A contains two small yellow triangles. Small yellow triangle number one is to the left of small yellow triangle number two and a big black triangle. Above and near to small yellow triangle number two is the big black triangle. Block B contains a medium black square. And block C contains two small blue triangles. This block also contains a big black triangle. It is far from, below and to the right of small blue triangle number one. This block also has a small black square. A medium black triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. Small blue triangle number two is touching the left edge of this block. There is also one medium blue square in this block. The medium black triangle is to the left of the medium blue square. It is below small blue triangle number one. What is below the medium black square? a medium blue square or a small black square? (a) medium blue square (b) small black square (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
We are told that Block B contains a medium black square. We are also told that Block C is below B. The question is what is below the medium black square in Block B. Since Block C is below B, the objects in Block C are below the objects in Block B. Block C containsa small black square and a medium blue square. Therefore, the objects below the medium black square in Block B are the small black square and the medium blue square. So both are below the medium black square.
Final Answer: \boxed{C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies that since Block C is below Block B, the contents of C are below the contents of B, including the medium black square in B. It correctly lists the relevant items in C as the potential answers.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #2014
We have three blocks, A, B and C. A big yellow square is in block A. Block B is to the left of block A. It has a small yellow square and a big black square. To the left of a medium black square there ...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. A big yellow square is in block A. Block B is to the left of block A. It has a small yellow square and a big black square. To the left of a medium black square there is the big black square. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black square is touching the right edge of this block. Above the big black square and the medium black square is the small yellow square. To the right of block B there is block C. It has one big blue circle, one small blue circle and a medium black circle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. To the right of the medium black circle there is the small blue circle.. To the right of and above the small blue circle there is the big blue circle. What is to the right of the small yellow square? a small blue circle or a big blue circle that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) small blue circle
(b) big blue circle that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:**
We have three blocks, A, B, and C. A big yellow square is in block A. Block B is to the left of block A. It has a small yellow square and a big black square. To the left of a medium black square there is the big black square. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black square is touching the right edge of this block. Above the big black square and the medium black square is the small yellow square. To the right of block B there is block C. It has one big blue circle, one small blue circle and a medium black circle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. To the right of the medium black circle there is the small blue circle.. To the right of and above the small blue circle there is the big blue circle. What is to the right of the small yellow square? a small blue circle or a big blue circle that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) small blue circle
(b) big blue circle that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block B is to the left of Block A and contains a small yellow square touching the right edge. Block C is to the right of Block B and contains a small blue circle and a big blue circle touching the right edge. Because of the position of the small blue circle relative to the medium black circle and the big blue circle relative to the small blue circle within Block C, and since Block C is to the right of Block B, the small blue circle would be positioned to the right of the small yellow square which is at the right edge of Block B. Additionally, the big blue circle is at the right edge of Block C, therefore is also to the right of the small yellow square. Thus, both the small blue circle and the big blue circle are to the right of the small yellow square.
Final Answer: \boxed{C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the components and block locations but makes unsupported spatial assumptions about the relationship between the contents of Block B (where the small yellow square is) and the contents of Block C (the blue circles) to conclude that both options (a) and (b) are to the right of the small yellow square. The context only defines relative positions within blocks and relative block positions, not the horizontal alignment between objects in different blocks.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Because of the position of the small blue circle relative to the medium black circle and the big blue circle relative to the small blue circle within Block C, and since Block C is to the right of Block B, the small blue circle would be positioned to the right of the small yellow square which is at the right edge of Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes a spatial relationship between objects *within* Block C (small blue circle relative to medium black circle, etc.) and then uses this to determine the position relative to the small yellow square in Block B. The question only establishes the relative positions of objects *within* Block C (e.g., 'To the right of the medium black circle there is the small blue circle.') and the relative positions of the blocks (B is left of A, C is right of B). It never establishes the absolute or relative horizontal position of the contents of Block C with respect to the contents of Block B, other than Block C being to the right of Block B.
Answer Span:
Because of the position of the small blue circle relative to the medium black circle and the big blue circle relative to the small blue circle within Block C, and since Block C is to the right of Block B, the small blue circle would be positioned to the right of the small yellow square which is at the right edge of Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
To the right of block B there is block C. It has one big blue circle, one small blue circle and a medium black circle. The big blue circle is touching the right edge of this block. To the right of the medium black circle there is the small blue circle.. To the right of and above the small blue circle there is the big blue circle.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Additionally, the big blue circle is at the right edge of Block C, therefore is also to the right of the small yellow square.
Explanation
While the big blue circle is at the right edge of Block C, and Block C is to the right of Block B (where the small yellow square is), the reasoning chain fails to account for the fact that the objects within Block C might not span the entire horizontal space to the right of the small yellow square, or that the small yellow square might be positioned such that the right edge of Block C is not necessarily 'to the right' of it in a way that guarantees the object is visible or positioned relative to it without more specific spatial data linking the contents of B and C.
Answer Span:
Additionally, the big blue circle is at the right edge of Block C, therefore is also to the right of the small yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the left of block A. . . To the right of block B there is block C.
Question #1387
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are three medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square nu...
3 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. There are three medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number two. A medium yellow square is also in this block. This object is below medium black square number three. It is below the black object which is below medium black square number three. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number one. It is below medium black square number two. Above block A there is block B which has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. To the right of block A there is block C which has one medium blue square. Which object is below a medium blue square? the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the yellow shape?
(a) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the yellow shape
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. There are three medium black squares in block A. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number two. A medium yellow square is also in this block. This object is below medium black square number three. It is below the black object which is below medium black square number three. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number one. It is below medium black square number two. Above block A there is block B which has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two. To the right of block A there is block C which has one medium blue square. Which object is below a medium blue square? the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the yellow shape?
(a) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the yellow shape
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block A contains three medium black squares and a medium yellow square. The arrangement in Block A (from top to bottom) is: medium black square number three, medium black square number two, medium yellow square, and medium black square number one (touching the bottom edge). Block B (above A) has two medium blue squares, with medium blue square number two above medium blue square number one. Block C (to the right of A) also has a medium blue square. Since Block B is above Block A, the objects directly below the medium blue squares are medium black square number three (below medium blue square number two) and medium black square number two (below medium blue square number one). So, both the yellow shape (below medium black square number two in A) and the medium black square touching the bottom edge are below something, but they are not directly below the medium blue squares of Block B. Thus, below a medium blue square, specifically medium blue square number one is medium black square number two. Also, below medium blue square number two is medium black square number three. Therefore, neither of the specified options are directly below a medium blue square. The answer is \boxed{D}.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain fails to correctly interpret the relative positioning constraints within Block A, leading to a completely fabricated internal structure for Block A. This incorrect structure then leads to flawed conclusions about what is below the blue squares in Block B.
Detected Issues (3)
contradictionhigh
Statement
The arrangement in Block A (from top to bottom) is: medium black square number three, medium black square number two, medium yellow square, and medium black square number one (touching the bottom edge).
Explanation
The reasoning chain establishes a specific vertical order for objects in Block A that contradicts the explicit positional statements given in the context.
Answer Span:
The arrangement in Block A (from top to bottom) is: medium black square number three, medium black square number two, medium yellow square, and medium black square number one (touching the bottom edge).
Reference/Question Span:
Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number two. A medium yellow square is also in this block. This object is below medium black square number three. It is below the black object which is below medium black square number three. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number one. It is below medium black square number two.
contradictionhigh
Statement
Since Block B is above Block A, the objects directly below the medium blue squares are medium black square number three (below medium blue square number two) and medium black square number two (below medium blue square number one).
Explanation
This statement assumes a direct vertical stacking relationship between objects in Block B and objects in Block A based on the derived (and incorrect) internal ordering of Block A. The context only states Block B is *above* Block A, implying the objects in B are above the objects in A, but it does not specify which object in B is above which object in A, nor does it specify the internal ordering of A correctly.
Answer Span:
Since Block B is above Block A, the objects directly below the medium blue squares are medium black square number three (below medium blue square number two) and medium black square number two (below medium blue square number one).
Reference/Question Span:
Above block A there is block B which has two medium blue squares. Medium blue square number one is below medium blue square number two.
missing_contextmedium
Statement
So, both the yellow shape (below medium black square number two in A) and the medium black square touching the bottom edge are below something, but they are not directly below the medium blue squares of Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning ignores the crucial information that the yellow shape is below medium black square number three, and that medium black square number one is below medium black square number two, which are necessary to determine if the yellow shape or the bottom-touching black square is below a blue square.
Answer Span:
So, both the yellow shape (below medium black square number two in A) and the medium black square touching the bottom edge are below something, but they are not directly below the medium blue squares of Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number two. A medium yellow square is also in this block. This object is below medium black square number three. It is below the black object which is below medium black square number three. Below medium black square number three there is medium black square number one. It is below medium black square number two.
Question #1810
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are a medium black circle and a big black square in block A. To the right of the big black square is the medium black circle. This object is to the...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are a medium black circle and a big black square in block A. To the right of the big black square is the medium black circle. This object is to the left of a medium yellow triangle which is to the right of the big black square. Block B is to the left of block A. It contains a medium yellow circle, one big blue square and a small yellow triangle. There is also a small yellow square in this block. The medium yellow circle is near to the big blue square which is near to and to the right of the small yellow triangle.. The small yellow triangle is above and near to the small yellow square. To the right of block A there is block C. It has one medium blue circle and one big yellow triangle. The medium blue circle is to the left of, near to and below the big yellow triangle. Which object is to the left of a medium blue circle? the small yellow square or the medium black circle?
(a) the small yellow square
(b) the medium black circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are a medium black circle and a big black square in block A. To the right of the big black square is the medium black circle. This object is to the left of a medium yellow triangle which is to the right of the big black square. Block B is to the left of block A. It contains a medium yellow circle, one big blue square and a small yellow triangle. There is also a small yellow square in this block. The medium yellow circle is near to the big blue square which is near to and to the right of the small yellow triangle.. The small yellow triangle is above and near to the small yellow square. To the right of block A there is block C. It has one medium blue circle and one big yellow triangle. The medium blue circle is to the left of, near to and below the big yellow triangle. Which object is to the left of a medium blue circle? the small yellow square or the medium black circle? (a) the small yellow square (b) the medium black circle (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a medium black circle and a big black square. Block B is to the left of Block A and contains a small yellow square. Block C is to the right of Block A and contains a medium blue circle. Since the question asks what is to the left of the medium blue circle, and Block A (containing the medium black circle) is to the left of Block C, the medium black circle is to the left of the medium blue circle. The small yellow square is in Block B, which is to the left of both Block A and Block C. Thus, the small yellow square is not to the left of the medium blue circle. Therefore, only the medium black circle is to the left of the medium blue circle.
Final Answer: \boxed{B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the location of the medium black circle (Block A) relative to the medium blue circle (Block C) and concludes it is to the left. However, it incorrectly concludes that the small yellow square (Block B) is *not* to the left of the medium blue circle (Block C), ignoring the established block order (B < A < C), which means B is to the left of C.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Thus, the small yellow square is not to the left of the medium blue circle.
Explanation
The reasoning concludes the small yellow square is not to the left of the medium blue circle based on block positions, but it ignores the explicit spatial relationship given in the context: 'The medium blue circle is to the left of, near to and below the big yellow triangle.' and the relative positions of the blocks (B is left of A, C is right of A). Since B is to the left of A, and C is to the right of A, B is to the left of C. The small yellow square is in B, and the medium blue circle is in C. Therefore, the small yellow square *is* to the left of the medium blue circle. The reasoning incorrectly dismisses the small yellow square.
Answer Span:
Thus, the small yellow square is not to the left of the medium blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is to the left of block A. . . To the right of block A there is block C. It has one medium blue circle and one big yellow triangle.
Question #859
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. A medium yellow square is in block A. Then, there is block B. It contains two medium black squares and two other medium blue squares. Below medium bl...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. A medium yellow square is in block A. Then, there is block B. It contains two medium black squares and two other medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number one which is below medium blue square number two is medium black square number one. Below medium black square number two there is medium blue square number two. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and medium blue square number two. Finally, to the right of block B we have block C which is above block A. It contains one medium black square and a medium yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square. Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium black square number two?
(a) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium black square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B and C. A medium yellow square is in block A. Then, there is block B. It contains two medium black squares and two other medium blue squares. Below medium blue square number one which is below medium blue square number two is medium black square number one. Below medium black square number two there is medium blue square number two. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and medium blue square number two. Finally, to the right of block B we have block C which is above block A. It contains one medium black square and a medium yellow square. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium yellow square. Which object is to the right of a medium blue square? the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium black square number two?
(a) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium black square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block B contains medium blue squares and medium black squares. Block C is to the right of Block B and contains a medium black squaretouching the bottom edge. Since Block C is to the right of Block B, the medium black square in Block C, which is touching the bottom edge, is to the right of the medium blue squares in Block B. Medium black square number two is within Block B, and thus not to the right of the medium blue squares. Therefore, the answer is {A}. \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the blocks and the objects within them to answer the question about which object is to the right of a medium blue square.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1282
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A contains one medium black triangle. This block also has one small black triangle. Near to and above the small black triangle is the medium black t...
Clean
Full Question
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A contains one medium black triangle. This block also has one small black triangle. Near to and above the small black triangle is the medium black triangle. Block B is below block A. It contains one small blue triangle, one big black square and a medium blue square. This block also has a medium black triangle. The medium blue square is touching the right edge of this block. It is below and to the right of the medium black triangle. The big black square is below the medium black triangle. It is to the left of the medium object which is below the medium black triangle. To the left of the medium blue square is the small blue triangle. The big black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Which object is below a medium black triangle? the big black thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the small blue triangle?
(a) the big black thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the small blue triangle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are two blocks. Let's call them A and B. Block A contains one medium black triangle. This block also has one small black triangle. Near to and above the small black triangle is the medium black triangle. Block B is below block A. It contains one small blue triangle, one big black square and a medium blue square. This block also has a medium black triangle. The medium blue square is touching the right edge of this block. It is below and to the right of the medium black triangle. The big black square is below the medium black triangle. It is to the left of the medium object which is below the medium black triangle. To the left of the medium blue square is the small blue triangle. The big black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Which object is below a medium black triangle? the big black thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the small blue triangle? (a) the big black thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block (b) the small blue triangle (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block A is above Block B. Block B has a medium black triangle, a small blue triangle, and a big black square touching the bottom edge. The big black square is below the medium black triangle. Since the big black square is touching the bottom edge and is below the medium black triangle, the answer is {A}. \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies that the big black square is below the medium black triangle in Block B and uses this fact to select option (a). No contradictions or missing context were found.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #761
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one medium blue circle. One medium blue square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue circle is the medium blu...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A has one medium blue circle. One medium blue square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue circle is the medium blue square. Block B is below block A. It contains a small blue triangle, a medium yellow square and a medium blue circle. The small blue triangle is to the left of the medium yellow square and a big black square. The medium yellow square is to the left of the big black square. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. To the left of block B there is block C with two medium black circles in it. Medium black circle number one is below and touching a small yellow square. Medium black circle number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of and near to medium black circle number two is medium black circle number one. What is above the small blue thing? a small yellow square or a medium blue circle?
(a) small yellow square
(b) medium blue circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** We have three blocks. We call them A, B, and C. Block A has one medium blue circle. One medium blue square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue circle is the medium blue square. Block B is below block A. It contains a small blue triangle, a medium yellow square and a medium blue circle. The small blue triangle is to the left of the medium yellow square and a big black square. The medium yellow square is to the left of the big black square. The big black square is touching the right edge of this block. To the left of block B there is block C with two medium black circles in it. Medium black circle number one is below and touching a small yellow square. Medium black circle number two is touching the bottom edge of this block. To the left of and near to medium black circle number two is medium black circle number one. What is above the small blue thing (small blue triangle)? a small yellow square or a medium blue circle?
(a) small yellow square
(b) medium blue circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block A has a medium blue circle and a medium blue square with the circle above the square. Block B is below Block A. Block B contains a small blue triangle, a medium yellow square, and a medium blue circle. Because Block B is directly below Block A, the objects in Block A are directly above the objects in Block B. Therefore, the medium blue circle (from Block A) is above the small blue triangle (from Block B). The small yellow square is in Block C, which is to the left of Block B, not above it. So the answer is {medium blue circle}
\boxed{B}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsupported assumption about the vertical alignment of objects between Block A and Block B, leading to an incorrect intermediate step regarding what is above the small blue thing.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Because Block B is directly below Block A, the objects in Block A are directly above the objects in Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning assumes a direct vertical alignment between objects in Block A and Block B, which is not specified. The context only states Block B is below Block A, not how the objects align vertically.
Answer Span:
Because Block B is directly below Block A, the objects in Block A are directly above the objects in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Block B is below block A.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Therefore, the medium blue circle (from Block A) is above the small blue triangle (from Block B).
Explanation
This conclusion relies on the unstated assumption of direct vertical alignment between the medium blue circle in A and the small blue triangle in B. The question asks what is above the *small blue thing* (which is the small blue triangle in B), and the reasoning incorrectly assumes the medium blue circle from A is directly above it without justification from the text.
Answer Span:
Therefore, the medium blue circle (from Block A) is above the small blue triangle (from Block B).
Reference/Question Span:
What is above the small blue thing? a small yellow square or a medium blue circle?
Question #2503
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the right of block A and to the left of block C. Block A has one small blue circle. This block also has a medium yellow square. The med...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block B is to the right of block A and to the left of block C. Block A has one small blue circle. This block also has a medium yellow square. The medium yellow square is to the right of the small blue circle. Block B contains one small yellow triangle, a medium yellow square and a medium blue triangle. To the left of and above the medium yellow square is the small yellow triangle. Near to the medium blue triangle is a small black triangle. The medium blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. Above and to the right of the small yellow triangle is the small black triangle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. And block C contains a small blue circle. Which object is to the right of a medium blue triangle? the small blue circle which is in block C or the small blue circle which is in block A?
(a) the small blue circle which is in block C
(b) the small blue circle which is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block B is to the right of block A and to the left of block C. Block A has one small blue circle. This block also has a medium yellow square. The medium yellow square is to the right of the small blue circle. Block B contains one small yellow triangle, a medium yellow square and a medium blue triangle. To the left of and above the medium yellow square is the small yellow triangle. Near to the medium blue triangle is a small black triangle. The medium blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. Above and to the right of the small yellow triangle is the small black triangle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. And block C contains a small blue circle. Which object is to the right of a medium blue triangle? the small blue circle which is in block C or the small blue circle which is in block A?
(a) the small blue circle which is in block C
(b) the small blue circle which is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block B is to the right of Block A and to the left of Block C. The medium blue triangle is in Block B and is touching the right edge. Since Block C is to the right of Block B, and Block C contains a small blue circle, this small blue circle must be to the right of the medium blue triangle. The small blue circle in Block A is to the left of Block B, so it cannot be to the right of the medium blue triangle. Therefore, the answer is {the small blue circle in Block C}.
\boxed{A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly uses the positional information (B is right of A, C is right of B) and the location of the medium blue triangle (in B) and the small blue circle in C to deduce the correct relative position.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #531
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of B. Block C is to the left of A. Block A has one medium yellow triangle. Block B has a medium black circle. And block C has a...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the right of B. Block C is to the left of A. Block A has one medium yellow triangle. Block B has a medium black circle. And block C has a big yellow circle. One big blue triangle is also touching the bottom edge of this block. A medium black circle is to the right of a small blue circle. To the left of the big yellow circle there is the small blue circle. The big yellow circle is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue triangle is below the circle which is to the left of the big yellow circle. To the left of and below the big yellow circle is the medium black circle. To the right of the black shape which is to the right of the small blue circle is the big blue triangle. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow triangle? the small object or the big yellow circle that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the small object
(b) the big yellow circle that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:**
We have three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block A is to the right of B. Block C is to the left of A. Block A has one medium yellow triangle. Block B has a medium black circle. And Block C has a big yellow circle. One big blue triangle is also touching the bottom edge of this block. A medium black circle is to the right of a small blue circle. To the left of the big yellow circle there is the small blue circle. The big yellow circle is touching the right edge of this block. The big blue triangle is below the circle which is to the left of the big yellow circle. To the left of and below the big yellow circle is the medium black circle. To the right of the black shape which is to the right of the small blue circle is the big blue triangle. Which object is to the left of a medium yellow triangle? the small object or the big yellow circle that is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the small object
(b) the big yellow circle that is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
We have three blocks: A, B, and C. Block A is to the right of Block B and Block C is to the left of Block A. Block A contains a medium yellow triangle. Block B contains a medium black circle, and Block C contains a big yellow circle and a big blue triangle touching the bottom edge. The small blue circle is to the left of the big yellow circle in Block C. The question asks what is to the left of the medium yellow triangle (in Block A): the small blue circle or the big yellow circle (touching the right edge of Block C). Since Block C is to the left of Block A and the small blue circle is in Block C (along with the big yellow circle), both are to the left of the medium yellow triangle in Block A. Therefore, both the small blue circle and the big yellow circle are to the left of the medium yellow triangle.
\boxed{C}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the relative positions of the blocks (C is left of A) and correctly identifies the objects in question. However, it makes an unsubstantiated assumption that the small blue circle is located within Block C, which is not explicitly stated in the source context, leading to a potential reasoning error regarding location.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
The small blue circle is to the left of the big yellow circle in Block C.
Explanation
The reasoning chain assumes the small blue circle is in Block C, but the context only states that Block C has a big yellow circle and a big blue triangle touching its bottom edge. The location of the small blue circle is not explicitly tied to Block C in the context, only its relation to the big yellow circle ('To the left of the big yellow circle there is the small blue circle').
Answer Span:
The small blue circle is to the left of the big yellow circle in Block C.
Reference/Question Span:
Block C has a big yellow circle. . . To the left of the big yellow circle there is the small blue circle.
Question #2233
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains a medium blue square. To the right of block A we have block B with two medium blue squares in it. Medium blue square number one is touch...
3 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. Block A contains a medium blue square. To the right of block A we have block B with two medium blue squares in it. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below medium blue square number two. Finally, there is block C. It is above block A. It has two medium yellow squares. Below a medium blue square is medium yellow square number one. There is also one medium black square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two , medium yellow square number one and the medium blue square is the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Which object is above a medium blue square? the medium blue square that is in block C or the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block C
(b) the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B, and C. Block A contains a medium blue square. To the right of block A we have block B with two medium blue squares in it. Medium blue square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below medium blue square number two. Finally, there is block C. It is above block A. It has two medium yellow squares. Below a medium blue square is medium yellow square number one. There is also one medium black square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two , medium yellow square number one and the medium blue square is the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Which object is above a medium blue square? the medium blue square that is in block C or the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block? (a) the medium blue square that is in block C (b) the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has a medium blue square. Block B (to the right of A) has two medium blue squares: number two above number one (touching the bottom edge). Block C (above A) has two medium yellow squares and a medium black square (touching the bottom edge). The question asks what is above a medium blue square. Since we are looking for what is above a medium blue square, we look at the blocks above where medium blue squares exist. The medium blue squares are in block B. Block C is above block A, so the object above the blue square in Block A would be something in Block C. Block C does not contain any medium blue squares, only medium yellow squares and a medium black square. In Block B, medium blue square number two is above medium blue square number one. Since the question mentions a medium blue square generally, it refers to the medium blue square in block A. Because Block C is above Block A, the object above this medium blue square is one of the medium yellow squares in Block C. Thus, a medium blue square in Block C does not exist, while medium blue square number two exists in Block B and is above medium blue square number one. The answer is medium blue square number two.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{B}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes several errors by ignoring the existence of a blue square in Block A and incorrectly concluding which blue square the general question refers to, leading to flawed logic about what is above it. It also misinterprets the location/touching status of the black square.
Detected Issues (3)
contradictionlow
Statement
Block C (above A) has two medium yellow squares and a medium black square (touching the bottom edge).
Explanation
The context states Block C has two medium yellow squares and one medium black square. The reasoning incorrectly states the black square is touching the bottom edge of Block C. The context states the black square is touching the bottom edge of 'this block' (referring to Block C, which is above A), but then later states: 'Below a medium blue square is medium yellow square number one. There is also one medium black square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two , medium yellow square number one and the medium blue square is the medium black square.' The structure implies the black square is below the objects mentioned, not necessarily touching the bottom edge of C, and the context is ambiguous about which block the black square touches the bottom edge of, but the reasoning asserts it touches the bottom edge of C.
Answer Span:
Block C (above A) has two medium yellow squares and a medium black square (touching the bottom edge).
Reference/Question Span:
It has two medium yellow squares. Below a medium blue square is medium yellow square number one. There is also one medium black square touching the bottom edge of this block.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The medium blue squares are in block B.
Explanation
This ignores the fact that Block A also contains a medium blue square, which is crucial for answering the question about what is above *a* medium blue square.
Answer Span:
The medium blue squares are in block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains a medium blue square.
contradictionhigh
Statement
Since the question mentions a medium blue square generally, it refers to the medium blue square in block A.
Explanation
The question asks which object is above *a* medium blue square, presenting two specific candidates in the options: 'the medium blue square that is in block C' or 'the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block'. The reasoning incorrectly assumes the general reference defaults to the one in Block A, ignoring the specific options provided in the question structure.
Answer Span:
Since the question mentions a medium blue square generally, it refers to the medium blue square in block A.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is above a medium blue square? the medium blue square that is in block C or the medium blue square which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #3118
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. There are one big yellow triangle, one big black circle and one medium black triangle in block A. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of t...
Clean
Full Question
There are two blocks. Lets call them A and B. There are one big yellow triangle, one big black circle and one medium black triangle in block A. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. A big black square is touching the right edge of this block. To the right of the big black circle and the medium black triangle there is the big yellow triangle. The big black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is far from, to the left of and below the big black square. Above block A there is block B. It contains one medium yellow circle and a small black circle. It also contains one big blue triangle. The big blue triangle is to the right of and below the medium yellow circle which is to the right of the small black circle. What is above the big yellow triangle? a big black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a medium yellow circle?
(a) big black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium yellow circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are two blocks. Let's call them A and B. There are one big yellow triangle, one big black circle and one medium black triangle in block A. The big yellow triangle is touching the bottom edge of this block. A big black square is touching the right edge of this block. To the right of the big black circle and the medium black triangle there is the big yellow triangle. The big black circle is touching the bottom edge of this block. This shape is far from, to the left of and below the big black square. Above block A there is block B. It contains one medium yellow circle and a small black circle. It also contains one big blue triangle. The big blue triangle is to the right of and below the medium yellow circle which is to the right of the small black circle. What is above the big yellow triangle? a big black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block or a medium yellow circle?
(a) big black circle that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium yellow circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a big yellow triangle touching the bottom edge, a big black circle also touching the bottom edge, and a medium black triangle. Block B, which is above Block A, contains a medium yellow circle, a small black circle, and a big blue triangle. Since Block B is above Block A, the objects in Block B are above the objects in Block A. Therefore, the medium yellow circle (in Block B) is above the big yellow triangle (in Block A). The big black circle is in Block A and is next to the big yellow triangle, but not above it. The answer is \boxed{B}.
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the locations of the objects and deduces that the medium yellow circle in Block B is above the big yellow triangle in Block A, while the big black circle is in Block A and thus not above the triangle.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #3151
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Th...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Then, we have block B with two medium yellow squares in it. A medium black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black square is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Finally, to the right of block A we have block C. It is to the right of block B. It contains one medium blue square. There is also one medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the black thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue square?
(a) the black thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Then, we have block B with two medium yellow squares in it. A medium black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black square is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Finally, to the right of block A we have block C. It is to the right of block B. It contains one medium blue square. There is also one medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square. Which object is below a medium yellow square? the black thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue square?
(a) the black thing that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
In Block A, medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two and touching the bottom edge. In Block B, a medium black square is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two and touching the bottom edge. In Block C, a medium yellow square is below the medium blue square and touching the bottom edge. The question asks what is below a medium yellow square.
In Block B, the medium black square is below medium yellow squares.In Block C, the medium yellow square is below the medium blue square.
Thus, both the black thing (medium black square) and the medium blue square are below a medium yellow square.
Final Answer: \boxed{C}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning correctly identifies that the black square is below medium yellow squares in Block B. However, it incorrectly concludes that the medium blue square is below a medium yellow square in Block C, contradicting the source text which states the yellow square is below the blue square. It also adds an unsupported detail about the yellow square in C touching the bottom edge.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
In Block C, a medium yellow square is below the medium blue square and touching the bottom edge.
Explanation
The context states that in Block C, the medium yellow square is below the medium blue square, but it does not state that the medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of Block C. It only states that *one* medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of Block C.
Answer Span:
In Block C, a medium yellow square is below the medium blue square and touching the bottom edge.
Reference/Question Span:
There is also one medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Thus, both the black thing (medium black square) and the medium blue square are below a medium yellow square.
Explanation
The reasoning concludes that the medium blue square is below a medium yellow square, but the context states the opposite: 'Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square.' This means the medium blue square is *above* the medium yellow square, not below it.
Answer Span:
Thus, both the black thing (medium black square) and the medium blue square are below a medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square.
Question #3311
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is above block B and to the left of block C. Block A contains a small black square, one medium black circle and one medium blue square. The sma...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is above block B and to the left of block C. Block A contains a small black square, one medium black circle and one medium blue square. The small black square is above a small yellow circle and the medium blue square. Above and touching the medium blue square is the small yellow circle. It is touching the right edge of this block. To the right of the medium blue square there is the medium black circle. Block B contains a small blue square. Block C has two medium black triangles. To the left of medium black triangle number two there is medium black triangle number one. It also contains one small blue circle. Below and near to medium black triangle number one is the small blue circle. Which object is above a small blue square? the medium blue square or the small yellow circle which is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square
(b) the small yellow circle which is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block A is above block B and to the left of block C. Block A contains a small black square, one medium black circle and one medium blue square. The small black square is above a small yellow circle and the medium blue square. Above and touching the medium blue square is the small yellow circle. It is touching the right edge of this block. To the right of the medium blue square there is the medium black circle. Block B contains a small blue square. Block C has two medium black triangles. To the left of medium black triangle number two there is medium black triangle number one. It also contains one small blue circle. Below and near to medium black triangle number one is the small blue circle. Which object is above a small blue square? the medium blue square or the small yellow circle which is touching the right edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square
(b) the small yellow circle which is touching the right edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a medium blue square, a small black square, and a small yellow circle. The small yellow circle is above the medium blue square. The medium black circle is to the right of the medium blue square. Block B, which is below Block A, contains a small blue square. Since Block A is above Block B, the objects in Block A are above the small blue square in Block B. The small yellow circle and the medium blue square are both in Block A. Therefore, the medium blue square is directly above the small blue square. The answer is $\boxed{A}$.
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain incorrectly lists the contents of Block A and misinterprets the spatial relationship between the small yellow circle and the medium blue square, leading to an incorrect final conclusion based on flawed premises.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Block A contains a medium blue square, a small black square, and a small yellow circle.
Explanation
The context states Block A contains 'one medium black circle and one medium blue square' along with 'a small black square'. The reasoning incorrectly lists a 'small yellow circle' as being *in* Block A, when the context only states the small yellow circle is *above* the medium blue square (which is in A).
Answer Span:
Block A contains a medium blue square, a small black square, and a small yellow circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Block A contains a small black square, one medium black circle and one medium blue square.
contradictionmedium
Statement
The small yellow circle is above the medium blue square.
Explanation
The context states the small yellow circle is *above* the medium blue square, but then immediately clarifies: 'Above and touching the medium blue square is the small yellow circle.' This implies direct adjacency or immediate proximity, but the reasoning chain later implies the medium blue square is *directly* above the small blue square, which is a separate deduction. More critically, the context states: 'The small black square is above a small yellow circle and the medium blue square.' This means the small black square is above both, not that the small yellow circle is above the medium blue square.
Answer Span:
The small yellow circle is above the medium blue square.
Reference/Question Span:
The small black square is above a small yellow circle and the medium blue square.
Question #351
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. One medium yellow square is in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below a medium ...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. One medium yellow square is in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square and medium black square number two. This block also contains one medium blue square. The medium blue square is below medium black square number one and medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two is the medium yellow square. To the left of block B there is block C with two medium yellow squares in it. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. One medium blue square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two there is the medium blue square. It is below medium yellow square number one. Which object is below a medium yellow square? medium black square number two or medium black square number one?
(a) medium black square number two
(b) medium black square number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. One medium yellow square is in block A. Block B is below block A. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square and medium black square number two. This block also contains one medium blue square. The medium blue square is below medium black square number one and medium black square number two. Below medium black square number two is the medium yellow square. To the left of block B there is block C with two medium yellow squares in it. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. One medium blue square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two there is the medium blue square. It is below medium yellow square number one. Which object is below a medium yellow square? medium black square number two or medium black square number one?
(a) medium black square number two
(b) medium black square number one
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B is below Block A, and contains two medium black squares and one medium blue square. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and the medium yellow square. The medium blue square is below both medium black squares. According to medium black square number two is also below the medium yellow square. Block C is to the left of Block B and has two medium yellow squares and a medium blue square touching the bottom edge. Since the question asks what is below *a* medium yellow square, and Block B's arrangement places medium black square number one below a medium yellow square *and* medium black square number two, while also placing medium black square number two below a medium yellow square, both medium black squares are below *a* medium yellow square. Thus, the answer is {C}.
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain correctly identifies the relevant blocks and objects but contains a factual error in describing the positional relationship between medium black square number one, medium black square number two, and the medium yellow square within Block B, leading to a contradiction with the source text.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionhigh
Statement
Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and the medium yellow square.
Explanation
The context states that medium black square number one is below *a* medium yellow square and medium black square number two, not that it is below medium black square number two AND the medium yellow square. The context specifies the relationship between MBS1, MBS2, and *a* medium yellow square, but the reasoning chain incorrectly states MBS1 is below MBS2 AND the medium yellow square, which is a misrepresentation of the structure described.
Answer Span:
Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and the medium yellow square.
Reference/Question Span:
Medium black square number one is below a medium yellow square and medium black square number two.
Question #1430
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. A big yellow square and a small black triangle are in block A. The big yellow square is to the left of a small blue triangle which is below the small bla...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. We call them A, B and C. A big yellow square and a small black triangle are in block A. The big yellow square is to the left of a small blue triangle which is below the small black triangle. This object is below and to the right of the small black triangle. Above block A we have block B which contains a small blue circle. A medium black square is below and to the right of the small blue circle. Finally, there is block C which is above block A. It contains a medium black square, one small yellow triangle and one big blue circle. To the left of and below the small yellow triangle is the medium black square. The small yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. It is to the right of the big blue circle. Which object is below a big blue circle? the small yellow triangle which is touching the right edge of a block or the big yellow square?
(a) the small yellow triangle which is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the big yellow square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. A big yellow square and a small black triangle are in block A. The big yellow square is to the left of a small blue triangle which is below the small black triangle. This object is below and to the right of the small black triangle. Above block A we have block B which contains a small blue circle. A medium black square is below and to the right of the small blue circle. Finally, there is block C which is above block A. It contains a medium black square, one small yellow triangle and one big blue circle. To the left of and below the small yellow triangle is the medium black square. The small yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. It is to the right of the big blue circle. Which object is below a big blue circle? the small yellow triangle which is touching the right edge of a block or the big yellow square?
(a) the small yellow triangle which is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the big yellow square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block C is above Block A and contains a big blue circle, a small yellow triangle, and a medium black square. Block A (which is below Block C) contains a big yellow square, a small black triangle, and a small blue triangle. Since Block C is directly above Block A, anything in Block A is below the objects in Block C. Thus, the big yellow square (in Block A) is below the big blue circle (in Block C). The small yellow triangle is in the same block (Block C) as the big blue circle and is not below it. Therefore, the answer is {B}. \boxed{b}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an incorrect assumption about the contents of Block C (though the listed items are present, the phrasing is slightly off) and critically ignores the explicit positional relationship between the small yellow triangle and the big blue circle within Block C, relying only on co-location to determine the answer.
Detected Issues (2)
contradictionmedium
Statement
Block C is above Block A and contains a big blue circle, a small yellow triangle, and a medium black square.
Explanation
The context states Block C contains 'one small yellow triangle and one big blue circle' and 'a medium black square'. The reasoning chain incorrectly states Block C contains 'a big blue circle' when the context specifies 'one big blue circle'. More critically, the reasoning chain implies the medium black square is in Block C, which is true, but it omits the fact that the medium black square in Block C is *not* the same object as the medium black square mentioned earlier (which is in Block B). However, the most direct contradiction is the listing of contents.
Answer Span:
Block C is above Block A and contains a big blue circle, a small yellow triangle, and a medium black square.
Reference/Question Span:
Finally, there is block C which is above block A. It contains a medium black square, one small yellow triangle and one big blue circle.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The small yellow triangle is in the same block (Block C) as the big blue circle and is not below it.
Explanation
The reasoning chain correctly identifies that the small yellow triangle and big blue circle are in Block C. However, it ignores the positional relationship given in the context: 'To the left of and below the small yellow triangle is the medium black square. The small yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. It is to the right of the big blue circle.' This context is crucial for determining if the small yellow triangle is below the big blue circle, but the reasoning chain dismisses it based only on co-location in Block C.
Answer Span:
The small yellow triangle is in the same block (Block C) as the big blue circle and is not below it.
Reference/Question Span:
To the left of and below the small yellow triangle is the medium black square. The small yellow triangle is touching the right edge of this block. It is to the right of the big blue circle.
Question #2748
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B. Block A is to the right of C. Block A has three medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bot...
2 issues
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B. Block A is to the right of C. Block A has three medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below a medium blue square there is medium black square number two. It is below medium black square number three. Medium black square number one is below the medium blue square , medium black square number three and medium black square number two. Block B has one medium black square. And block C has one medium blue square. This block also contains a medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square. Which object is to the left of a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B and C. Block C is to the left of B. Block A is to the right of C. Block A has three medium black squares. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below a medium blue square there is medium black square number two. It is below medium black square number three. Medium black square number one is below the medium blue square , medium black square number three and medium black square number two. Block B has one medium black square. And block C has one medium blue square. This block also contains a medium black square. The medium blue square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square. Which object is to the left of a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the medium blue square that is in block A
(b) the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
We are given that Block C is to the left of Block B and Block A is to the right of Block C. This means the order is C, A, B. Block C contains a medium blue square and a medium black square. Block B contains a medium black square. The question asks what is to the left of the medium black square in Block B. Since Block A is to the left of Block B, Block C is also to the left of Block B. Block C contains a medium blue square and a medium black square. So the medium blue square in Block C is to the left of the medium black square in Block B. Therefore, the answer is {B}. The medium blue square in Block A is not relevant since we are looking for something to the left of Block B.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{B}$
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain fundamentally misunderstands the question by focusing only on the black square in Block B, ignoring the two specific blue squares presented as options in the final query.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The question asks what is to the left of the medium black square in Block B.
Explanation
The question asks which object is to the left of *a* medium black square, presenting two specific candidates: 'the medium blue square that is in block A' or 'the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block'. The reasoning chain incorrectly narrows the focus to only the black square in Block B.
Answer Span:
The question asks what is to the left of the medium black square in Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the left of a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
missing_contexthigh
Statement
The medium blue square in Block A is not relevant since we are looking for something to the left of Block B.
Explanation
The reasoning incorrectly dismisses the blue square in Block A based on an assumption about Block B, ignoring that the question asks about *a* medium black square, and the blue square in A is one of the two options presented in the question to check against the condition.
Answer Span:
The medium blue square in Block A is not relevant since we are looking for something to the left of Block B.
Reference/Question Span:
Which object is to the left of a medium black square? the medium blue square that is in block A or the medium blue square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
Question #2773
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has one medium black circle and one medium black square. The medium black circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black square is touchi...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has one medium black circle and one medium black square. The medium black circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black circle is above the medium black square. To the right of block A is block B with one medium blue triangle in it. Finally, there is block C to the left of block A. It contains one medium black triangle, one small yellow circle and a small black square. To the right of the small black square there is the medium black triangle. This shape is touching the right edge of this block. It is to the right of the small yellow circle. To the right of and above the small black square is the small yellow circle. Which object is to the left of a medium triangle? the small black square or the medium shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the small black square
(b) the medium shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block A has one medium black circle and one medium black square. The medium black circle is touching the right edge of this block. The medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black circle is above the medium black square. To the right of block A is block B with one medium blue triangle in it. Finally, there is block C to the left of block A. It contains one medium black triangle, one small yellow circle and a small black square. To the right of the small black square there is the medium black triangle. This shape is touching the right edge of this block. It is to the right of the small yellow circle. To the right of and above the small black square is the small yellow circle. Which object is to the left of a medium triangle? the small black square or the medium shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block? (a) the small black square (b) the medium shape that is touching the bottom edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block C is to the left of Block A. Block C contains a medium black triangle, a small yellow circle, and a small black square. The medium black triangle is to the right of the small black square and to the right of the small yellow circle. Block A contains a medium black square touching the bottom edge. Since Block C is to the left of Block A, the medium black square touching the bottom edge of Block A cannot be to the left of the medium triangle in Block C. However, the small black square in Block C is to the left of the medium black triangle, also in Block C. Therefore, the small black square is to the left of a medium triangle(the medium black triangle).
The question asks what is to the left of a medium triangle. In this case, the medium triangle is in Block C. The small black square is to the left of the medium black triangle within Block C. The medium black square is in Block A. Since Block B is to the right of Block A and Block C is to the left of Block A, the medium black square in Block A is not to the left of anything in Block C.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in Block C and their relative positions, leading to the correct conclusion based on the provided context.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #213
We have two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A has a medium black triangle, one medium blue circle and one big yellow circle. One small blue circle is also in this bl...
1 issue
Full Question
We have two blocks. Lets call them A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A has a medium black triangle, one medium blue circle and one big yellow circle. One small blue circle is also in this block. The medium black triangle is touching the right edge of this block. Below, near to and to the right of the small blue circle there is the medium blue circle. Below and to the left of the small blue circle there is the big yellow circle.. Below the blue object which is below the small blue circle is the medium black triangle. Block B has one medium black triangle and a small black square. The small black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black triangle is to the left of the small black square. Which object is to the left of a medium black triangle? the medium black triangle which is touching the right edge of a block or the small blue circle?
(a) the medium black triangle which is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the small blue circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have two blocks. Let's call them A and B. Block A is to the left of B. Block A has a medium black triangle, one medium blue circle and one big yellow circle. One small blue circle is also in this block. The medium black triangle is touching the right edge of this block. Below, near to and to the right of the small blue circle there is the medium blue circle. Below and to the left of the small blue circle there is the big yellow circle. Below the blue object which is below the small blue circle is the medium black triangle. Block B has one medium black triangle and a small black square. The small black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black triangle is to the left of the small black square. Which object is to the left of a medium black triangle? the medium black triangle which is touching the right edge of a block or the small blue circle?
(a) the medium black triangle which is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the small blue circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A contains a medium black triangle touching its right edge, a medium blue circle, a big yellow circle, and a small blue circle. Block B is to the right of Block A and contains a medium black triangle. We are looking for what is to the left of the medium black triangle in Block B. Since Block A is to the left of Block B, the objects in Block A are to the left of the medium black triangle in Block B. The medium blue circle is below and to the right of the small blue circle and the big yellow circle is below and to the left of the small blue circle. The medium black triangle in Block A is below the medium blue circle and thus also below the small blue circle. Therefore, the small blue circle is located to the left of the medium black triangle in Block B. The medium black triangle which is touching the right edge of Block A cannot be to the left of anything in Block B because Block A is entirely to the left of Block B. The answer is {b}. \boxed{b}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning correctly identifies the core question (what is left of the medium black triangle in Block B) and uses the block separation correctly. However, it misinterprets one specific positional relationship within Block A, although this error does not ultimately change the final selection between options (a) and (b) because the logic relies more heavily on the block separation.
Detected Issues (1)
contradictionmedium
Statement
The medium black triangle in Block A is below the medium blue circle and thus also below the small blue circle.
Explanation
The context states: "Below the blue object which is below the small blue circle is the medium black triangle." This implies the medium black triangle is below the medium blue circle (which is below the small blue circle), but the reasoning chain asserts the medium black triangle is below the medium blue circle AND thus below the small blue circle, which is a misinterpretation/simplification of the complex positional relationship given.
Answer Span:
The medium black triangle in Block A is below the medium blue circle and thus also below the small blue circle.
Reference/Question Span:
Below the blue object which is below the small blue circle is the medium black triangle.
Question #3335
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is to the right of A and block C is above B. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares. Me...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is to the right of A and block C is above B. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium blue square number two there is medium yellow square number two. Below medium blue square number two and medium yellow square number two is medium blue square number one. Below medium yellow square number two and medium blue square number two is medium yellow square number one. And block C contains a medium blue square. This block also contains a medium black square. Below the medium blue square is the medium black square. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium yellow square number two?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium yellow square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks, A, B and C. Block B is to the right of A and block C is above B. Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B has two medium yellow squares and two other medium blue squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium blue square number two there is medium yellow square number two. Below medium blue square number two and medium yellow square number two is medium blue square number one. Below medium yellow square number two and medium blue square number two is medium yellow square number one. And block C contains a medium blue square. This block also contains a medium black square. Below the medium blue square is the medium black square. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or medium yellow square number two?
(a) the medium yellow square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) medium yellow square number two
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B, which is to the right of Block A, contains medium yellow square number two and medium yellow square number one (touching the bottom edge). Since Block B is to the right of Block A, both medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two are to the right of the medium yellow square in Block A. Therefore, the answer is {c}.
\boxed{c}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the blocks and deduces that the yellow squares in Block B are to the right of the yellow square in Block A, leading to the correct conclusion based on the question's structure.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #3150
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Th...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Then, we have block B with two medium yellow squares in it. A medium black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black square is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Finally, to the right of block A we have block C. It is to the right of block B. It contains one medium blue square. There is also one medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the blue thing or the black thing which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the blue thing
(b) the black thing which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
0
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:** There are three blocks, A, B, and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below medium yellow square number two. Then, we have block B with two medium yellow squares in it. A medium black square is also touching the bottom edge of this block. The medium black square is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. Finally, to the right of block A we have block C. It is to the right of block B. It contains one medium blue square. There is also one medium yellow square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below the medium blue square there is the medium yellow square. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the blue thing or the black thing which is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) the blue thing
(b) the black thing which is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block A contains two medium yellow squares. Block B also contains two medium yellow squares. Block C is to the right of Block A and to the right of Block B, and it contains a medium blue square. Because Block C is to the right of Block A (which has medium yellow squares), the blue square is to the right of a medium yellow square. So the blue thing is to the right of a medium yellow square. Similarly, since Block C is also to the right of Block B (which also contains medium yellow squares), the blue square is also to the right of medium yellow squares in Block B. Block B contains a black square touching the bottom edge, but it is not to the right of any medium yellow square in Block B, but below it. So the black thing is not to the right of a medium yellow square.
Final Answer: \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the relative positions of the blocks and the objects within them to answer the question about which object is to the right of a medium yellow square. It correctly concludes that the blue thing is to the right of a medium yellow square (in Block C relative to Block A/B), and the black thing is not to the right of a medium yellow square.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #410
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is above B and block B is to the right of C. Block A contains one big blue square and a small yellow triangle. Above and to the right of the sm...
Clean
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is above B and block B is to the right of C. Block A contains one big blue square and a small yellow triangle. Above and to the right of the small yellow triangle there is the big blue square. Block B contains a small yellow square and one small yellow triangle. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. This object is to the right of and above the small yellow triangle. This block also contains a medium blue square. The medium blue square is above the small yellow triangle. Block C contains one big blue square, one big black circle and one medium yellow square. The big blue square is to the right of the big black circle and the medium yellow square. Which object is to the right of a black thing? the small yellow square which is touching the right edge of a block or the medium blue square?
(a) the small yellow square which is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
**Reformatted Question:**
We have three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block A is above B and block B is to the right of C. Block A contains one big blue square and a small yellow triangle. Above and to the right of the small yellow triangle there is the big blue square. Block B contains a small yellow square and one small yellow triangle. The small yellow square is touching the right edge of this block. This object is to the right of and above the small yellow triangle. This block also contains a medium blue square. The medium blue square is above the small yellow triangle. Block C contains one big blue square, one big black circle and one medium yellow square. The big blue square is to the right of the big black circle and the medium yellow square. Which object is to the right of a black thing? the small yellow square which is touching the right edge of a block or the medium blue square?
(a) the small yellow square which is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
**Answer:**
Block C contains the big black circle. Block B is to the right of Block C. Block B contains the small yellow square (touching the right edge) and the medium blue square. Because Block B is to the right of Block C, both the small yellow square and the medium blue square are to the right of the big black circle in Block C. Therefore, both the small yellow square and the medium blue square are to the right of the black thing.
Final Answer: \boxed{C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the black object (big black circle in C) and uses the spatial relationship (B is to the right of C) to conclude that objects in B (small yellow square and medium blue square) are to the right of the black object. This aligns with the context provided.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1626
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. There is also a medium blue square touching the bo...
1 issue
Full Question
We have three blocks, A, B and C. Two medium yellow squares are in block A. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two and medium yellow square number one is the medium blue square. Then, we have block B. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and a medium blue square. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square number two there is the medium blue square. To the right of both blocks A and B there is block C. It contains one medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium blue square? medium black square number two or the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block?
(a) medium black square number two
(b) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks, A, B and C. Block A contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. There is also a medium blue square touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two and medium yellow square number one is the medium blue square. Then, we have block B. It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and a medium blue square. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square number two there is the medium blue square. To the right of both blocks A and B there is block C. It contains one medium blue square. Which object is to the left of a medium blue square? medium black square number two or the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block? (a) medium black square number two (b) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block (c) both of them (d) none of them
Answer:
Block B has two medium black squares: number two and number one (touching the bottom edge), as well as a medium blue square. Medium black square number two is above the medium blue square, and medium black square number one is below both of them. Block C is to the right of Block B. Since medium black square number two is to the left of the blue square in block B, the answer is {A}. Medium black square number two is to the left of the blue square in block B and is to the left of the medium blue square in block C. Medium black square number one is also to the left of the medium blue square in block C, but isn't to the left of a medium blue square in block B. The answer is medium black square number two. \boxed{A}
Overall Quality: poor
The reasoning chain makes an unsupported assertion about the horizontal placement of medium black square number two relative to the blue square in block B, which is crucial for determining the correct answer based on the provided spatial constraints. It ignores the lack of explicit horizontal positioning for the objects within block B.
Detected Issues (1)
missing_contexthigh
Statement
Since medium black square number two is to the left of the blue square in block B, the answer is {A}.
Explanation
The reasoning claims that medium black square number two is to the left of the blue square in block B. The context only states that medium black square number one is below the medium blue square in block B, and medium black square number two is above medium black square number one. It does not specify the horizontal relationship between medium black square number two and the medium blue square in block B, which is necessary to answer the question about what is to the left of *a* medium blue square.
Answer Span:
Since medium black square number two is to the left of the blue square in block B
Reference/Question Span:
It contains two medium black squares. Medium black square number one is below medium black square number two and a medium blue square. Medium black square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium black square number two there is the medium blue square.
Question #22
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are one big blue triangle and a medium yellow square in block A. Near to a medium blue triangle there is a big black circle. Near to and below th...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are one big blue triangle and a medium yellow square in block A. Near to a medium blue triangle there is a big black circle. Near to and below the black shape which is near to the medium blue triangle there is the big blue triangle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is near to and below the medium blue triangle. Block B is below block A. It has a big black square. To the left of block B there is block C which has a big blue triangle and one medium yellow circle. To the right of a big black square is the medium yellow circle.. The big blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. This shape is below and to the right of the big black square. Which object is to the right of a big black square? the blue thing that is touching the right edge of a block or the medium yellow circle?
(a) the blue thing that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. We call them A, B and C. There are one big blue triangle and a medium yellow square in block A. Near to a medium blue triangle there is a big black circle. Near to and below the black shape which is near to the medium blue triangle there is the big blue triangle. The medium yellow square is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is near to and below the medium blue triangle. Block B is below block A. It has a big black square. To the left of block B there is block C which has a big blue triangle and one medium yellow circle. To the right of a big black square is the medium yellow circle.. The big blue triangle is touching the right edge of this block. This shape is below and to the right of the big black square. Which object is to the right of a big black square? the blue thing that is touching the right edge of a block or the medium yellow circle?
(a) the blue thing that is touching the right edge of a block
(b) the medium yellow circle
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A is above Block B, and Block C is to the left of Block B. Block B contains a big black square. Block C contains a big blue triangle touching the right edge and a medium yellow circle. The question states that the medium yellow circle is to the right of the big black square. Additionally, since Block C is to the left of Block B, and the big blue triangle is touching the right edge of Block C, this blue triangle is also to the right of the big black square. Therefore, both the medium yellow circle and the blue triangle touching the right edge of a block are to the right of the big black square.
Final Answer: \boxed{C}
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the objects in Block C and uses the provided spatial relationships to determine which objects are to the right of the big black square in Block B. The conclusion aligns with the context.
✓ No hallucinations detected
Question #1439
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. A medium yellow square is in block A. To the right of block A there is block B with two medium yellow squares in it. Medium yellow square number one is...
2 issues
Full Question
We have three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. A medium yellow square is in block A. To the right of block A there is block B with two medium yellow squares in it. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. A medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two and medium yellow square number one there is a medium blue square. The medium black square is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Finally, there is block C to the left of block B. It contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below medium yellow square number two. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue square?
(a) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
2
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: We have three blocks. Let's call them A, B and C. A medium yellow square is in block A. To the right of block A there is block B with two medium yellow squares in it. Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. A medium black square is touching the bottom edge of this block. Below medium yellow square number two and medium yellow square number one there is a medium blue square. The medium black square is below medium yellow square number one and medium yellow square number two. Finally, there is block C to the left of block B. It contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. This object is below medium yellow square number two. Which object is to the right of a medium yellow square? the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block or the medium blue square?
(a) the medium black square that is touching the bottom edge of a block
(b) the medium blue square
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A has a medium yellow square. Block B is to the right of Block A and contains two medium yellow squares, a medium black square touching the bottom edge, and a medium blue square below the yellow squares. Block C is to the left of Block B. We want to know what's to the right of a medium yellow square (the one in Block A). Since Block B is to the right of Block A, everything in Block B is to the right of the yellow square in Block A. This includes both the medium black square touching the bottom edge and the medium blue square. Therefore, both are to the right of the medium yellow square in Block A.
\boxed{C}
Overall Quality: fair
The reasoning chain makes an assumption about the contents of Block B and arbitrarily limits the scope of 'a medium yellow square' to only the one in Block A, which ignores crucial positional information needed to fully answer the question based on all constraints.
Detected Issues (2)
missing_contextmedium
Statement
Block B is to the right of Block A and contains two medium yellow squares, a medium black square touching the bottom edge, and a medium blue square below the yellow squares.
Explanation
The reasoning chain incorrectly summarizes the contents of Block B. The context states Block B has two medium yellow squares, but it does not explicitly state the medium black square and medium blue square are *in* Block B. The context describes their relative positions to the yellow squares, which are in Block A and B.
Answer Span:
Block B is to the right of Block A and contains two medium yellow squares, a medium black square touching the bottom edge, and a medium blue square below the yellow squares.
Reference/Question Span:
To the right of block A there is block B with two medium yellow squares in it.
missing_contexthigh
Statement
We want to know what's to the right of a medium yellow square (the one in Block A).
Explanation
The question asks which object is to the right of *a* medium yellow square, but the reasoning chain arbitrarily focuses only on the yellow square in Block A, ignoring the other yellow squares mentioned (two in B, two in C, and the numbered ones). This omission affects the completeness of the reasoning.
Answer Span:
We want to know what's to the right of a medium yellow square (the one in Block A).
Reference/Question Span:
Medium yellow square number one is below medium yellow square number two. . . It contains two medium yellow squares. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block.
Question #3555
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the left of B and block B is below C. Block A has two medium yellow squares. One medium black square is also in this block. Medium yell...
Clean
Full Question
There are three blocks. Lets call them A, B and C. Block A is to the left of B and block B is below C. Block A has two medium yellow squares. One medium black square is also in this block. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium black square.. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square and medium yellow square number two. Block B contains one medium blue square. And block C contains three medium black squares. Below medium black square number two and a medium yellow square is medium black square number one. Below the medium yellow square and medium black square number three is medium black square number two. Below the medium yellow square there is medium black square number three. Which object is to the left of a blue shape? medium black square number three or the medium black square which is in block A?
(a) medium black square number three
(b) the medium black square which is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Ground Truth Answer
1
Generated Answer
Reformatted Question: There are three blocks. Let's call them A, B, and C. Block A is to the left of B and block B is below C. Block A has two medium yellow squares. One medium black square is also in this block. Medium yellow square number two is below the medium black square. Medium yellow square number one is touching the bottom edge of this block. It is below the medium black square and medium yellow square number two. Block B contains one medium blue square. And block C contains three medium black squares. Below medium black square number two and a medium yellow square is medium black square number one. Below the medium yellow square and medium black square number three is medium black square number two. Below the medium yellow square there is medium black square number three. Which object is to the left of a blue shape? medium black square number three or the medium black square which is in block A?
(a) medium black square number three
(b) the medium black square which is in block A
(c) both of them
(d) none of them
Answer:
Block A is to the left of Block B. Block B contains a medium blue square. Block A contains two medium yellow squares and one medium black square. Block C contains three medium black squares. We want to know what is to the left of the medium blue square in Block B. Since Block A is to the left of Block B, the medium black square in Block A is to the left of the medium blue square. The three medium black squares in Block C are arranged vertically and Block B is below Block C, so the medium black squares in Block C are not to the left of the medium blue square. Therefore, only the medium black square in Block A is to the left of the medium blue square.
Final Answer: The final answer is $\boxed{B}$
Overall Quality: good
The reasoning correctly identifies the spatial relationships provided in the context (A is left of B, B is below C) and uses this to answer the question about what is to the left of the blue shape (in B). It correctly concludes that the object in A is to the left of the object in B, and objects in C are not relevant to being 'to the left' of B based on the given constraints.